The Terminal Spy by Alan S. Cowell - Excerpt
The Terminal Spy by Alan S. Cowell - Excerpt
The Terminal Spy by Alan S. Cowell - Excerpt
The
TERMINAL
SPY
ALAN S. COWELL
Broadway Books
NEW YORK
PDF
Cowe_9780767928168_3p_all_r1.qxp 7/17/09 1:37 PM Page vi
For Sue
ISBN 978-0-7679-2816-8
10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1
www.BroadwayBooks.com
PDF
To purchase a copy of
The Terminal Spy
visit one of these online retailers:
Also available as an Audiobook
Read by Simon Vance
Cowe_9780767928168_1p_all_r1.qxp 4/30/09 2:04 PM Page vii
CONTENTS
AUTHOR’S NOTE ix
DRAMATIS PERSONAE xi
PROLOGUE 1
3. A C O LY T E S 66
4. RENEGADE 81
5. WAR STORIES 96
6. F R O M R U S S I A W I T H S T E A LT H 122
7. SILOVIKI 146
www.BroadwayBooks.com
PDF
Cowe_9780767928168_1p_all_r1.qxp 4/30/09 2:04 PM Page viii
viii | CONTENTS
EPILOGUE 422
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS 425
NOTES AND SOURCES 427
SELECT BIBLIOGRAPHY 431
www.BroadwayBooks.com
PDF
Cowe_9780767928168_1p_all_r1.qxp 4/30/09 2:04 PM Page ix
AUTHOR’S NOTE
The reporting for this book began when, as head of the New York Times
bureau in London, I covered the breaking news of the Litvinenko case
in the days before and after his death. Over the subsequent weeks and
months, my research expanded to include interviews and conversations
with contacts and the key players in Austria, Britain, France, Germany,
Israel, Italy, Russia, and the United States. Throughout the book I have
tried to identify by name the people I spoke to. But there were other
sources who could not be so easily identified because of the nature of
their work. In the case of informants able to speak only in return for
anonymity, I have honored their desire for confidentiality.
Alan S. Cowell
Paris, May 2008
www.BroadwayBooks.com
PDF
Cowe_9780767928168_1p_all_r1.qxp 4/30/09 2:04 PM Page xi
D R A M AT I S P E R S O N A E
The Victims
Litvinenko, Alexander: former officer in the KGB and FSB
Politkovskaya, Anna: Russian journalist, murdered in Moscow,
October 2006
Londongrad
Abramovich, Roman: wealthy Russian tycoon, owner of London’s
Chelsea soccer club, former business associate of Boris Berezovsky
Berezovsky, Boris: wealthy Russian tycoon in self-exile in Britain,
bitter opponent of Vladimir Putin, onetime employer of Andrei
Lugovoi and Alexander Litvinenko
www.BroadwayBooks.com
PDF
Cowe_9780767928168_1p_all_r1.qxp 4/30/09 2:04 PM Page xii
xii | D R A M AT I S P E R S O N A E
The Kremlin
Medvedev, Dmitri: president of Russia nominated by Vladimir
Putin
Putin, Vladimir: former KGB officer, ex-president, now prime
minister, of Russia
Yeltsin, Boris: former president of Russia
The Family
Belyavskaya, Nina: mother of Alexander Litvinenko
Litvinenko, Marina : second wife of Alexander Litvinenko
Litvinenko, Maxim: half brother of Alexander Litvinenko, living
in Italy
Litvinenko, Natalia: first wife of Alexander Litvinenko
Litvinenko, Walter: father of Alexander and Maxim Litvinenko
www.BroadwayBooks.com
PDF
Cowe_9780767928168_1p_all_r1.qxp 4/30/09 2:04 PM Page xiii
D R A M AT I S P E R S O N A E | xiii
Business Connections
Glushkov, Nikolai: Berezovsky associate jailed in connection with
Aeroflot embezzlement case
Khodorkovsky, Mikhail: former head of Yukos oil company,
imprisoned on embezzlement and fraud charges
www.BroadwayBooks.com
PDF
Cowe_9780767928168_1p_all_r1.qxp 4/30/09 2:04 PM Page xiv
xiv | D R A M AT I S P E R S O N A E
Ivanov, Viktor: former KGB officer and senior aide to Vladimir Putin,
chairman of Aeroflot
Khokhlov, Nikolai: KGB defector, poisoned in Frankfurt, 1957
Sudoplatov, Pavel: former officer of Stalin’s secret police
The History
Curie, Marie and Pierre : discoverers of polonium
www.BroadwayBooks.com
PDF
Cowe_9780767928168_1p_all_r1.qxp 4/30/09 2:04 PM Page 1
PROLOGUE
www.BroadwayBooks.com
PDF
Cowe_9780767928168_1p_all_r1.qxp 4/30/09 2:04 PM Page 2
2 | ALAN S. COWELL
child prisoners from Chechnya, and to chase down the Russian mafia in
Moscow. But Litvinenko had turned his back on all that, on everything
he had been taught to do, as the Soviet Union dissolved into the new
Russia. Brazenly, he defied his masters in Moscow, betraying what he in-
sisted were their innermost secrets.
Now it was payback time, although, as so often in matters of deceit,
the victim was the last to know.
On this day in late 2006—the last when his life might pass for nor-
mal within the somewhat abnormal émigré circles he inhabited—Litvi-
nenko bade farewell to his elegantly coiffed wife, Marina, and his gifted
twelve-year-old son, Anatoly, of whom he was exceptionally proud. He
headed for the city center—the capital of his own adoptive land. Just
weeks earlier, on October 13, Litvinenko and his family had been granted
citizenship, and he boasted happily to friends that he was British. He
brandished his pristine plum-colored passport, proclaiming with an al-
most childish delight that it was his protector, the freshly burnished
shield of this crusader against evil, this champion of the free (this tilter at
windmills, some thought, this swashbuckling D’Artagnan).
To mark the family’s new status, his son hung their new banner—
the red-on-white cross of St. George, the English emblem—from the
first-floor balcony of the Litvinenkos’ pale brick town house a mile
north of the center of Muswell Hill at 140 Osier Crescent.
The three-story house was one more unassuming home in a new-
looking development in the commuter belt on a quiet street that filled
with young children when the school day ended and with parked cars
when the workday was over. But for Litvinenko it was his castle. Out-
lawed and outcast by the Kremlin, given refuge in London, he told his
wife with tragic naïveté that they were safe now.
In many ways the journey from his semi-gentrified suburb to May-
fair—London’s swankiest square mile—offered a metaphor for his own
life, caught between dream and reality, between modest circumstance
and grand vision.
www.BroadwayBooks.com
PDF
Cowe_9780767928168_1p_all_r1.qxp 4/30/09 2:04 PM Page 3
If, as Litvinenko had often done, you walk south from Osier Cres-
cent and take the bus—the 134—from the parade of shoe shops and
liquor stores and pubs on Muswell Hill Broadway, if you sit on the up-
per deck and peer out at the level of the lesser treetops, you will see a
London the tourists never see, displaying its confused and conflicted
soul—tawdry, vain, self-congratulatory, decaying.
After St. James’s Church, with its bright billboards and blunt en-
treaties to worship, the bus lurches and grumbles its way past the ivy-
choked, ghostly trees of Highgate Wood, turning left onto the Archway
Road, a north-south artery rushing with commuter cars and white-
flanked delivery vans. If you want to spy, you peer into the first-floor
bed-sitting-rooms of the houses along the route, but there is little to see
beyond the graying net curtains and the weak glow of low-wattage
lightbulbs. If you want imagined drama, you wait for the point where
the road runs below the wrought-iron curve of the Hornsey Lane
bridge, nicknamed Suicide Bridge to honor those who leaped in despair
and plunged a hundred feet into the traffic below.
But on this day, there is no despair for Litvinenko. He is spry of foot,
nimble in his early forties. His thoughts are in a different London, in the
London of five-star hotels and wealthy shopping streets, of discreet,
whispering offices and plump consultancies, of contact with his erst-
while peers in the KGB, with people who, like him, inhabit an opaque
world between illusion and reality, between conspiracy and riches.
In retrospect, it was easy to ask the question: Why was this day, this
Wednesday, November 1—not one day earlier, nor one day later—cho-
sen to be his last in good health, and by whom? But then, on that day,
there seemed to be nothing exceptional. There was no premonition of
catastrophe.
“Sasha was absolutely normal,” his wife, Marina, recalled, using the
affectionate form of her husband’s first name by which his friends and
associates knew him. “Sasha was absolutely looking forward to life.”
Just a day earlier, he had bought expensive new boots—“very high
www.BroadwayBooks.com
PDF
Cowe_9780767928168_1p_all_r1.qxp 4/30/09 2:04 PM Page 4
4 | ALAN S. COWELL
The 134 bus route burrowed through the palimpsest of bleak and cos-
mopolitan modernity that time has spread over the Gothic frame of
www.BroadwayBooks.com
PDF
Cowe_9780767928168_1p_all_r1.qxp 4/30/09 2:04 PM Page 5
www.BroadwayBooks.com
PDF
Cowe_9780767928168_1p_all_r1.qxp 4/30/09 2:04 PM Page 6
6 | ALAN S. COWELL
www.BroadwayBooks.com
PDF
Cowe_9780767928168_1p_all_r1.qxp 4/30/09 2:04 PM Page 7
After his death, the Kremlin went to great lengths to belittle Litvi-
nenko as a thug, a lowlife, a former guard on military convoys, a man of
no substance. But why, then, did someone spend so much money and
time and flawed ingenuity to ensure that he would be launched unwit-
tingly onto the trajectory of the most macabre and gruesome assassina-
tion of modern times? If he was a nobody, why snuff out the last flicker
of his nonentity with such lurid drama? But if he was more than the
Kremlin depicted him to be, what had he done to deserve a death that
depended on such ingenuity and cruelty?
www.BroadwayBooks.com
PDF
Cowe_9780767928168_1p_all_r1.qxp 4/30/09 2:04 PM Page 8
8 | ALAN S. COWELL
www.BroadwayBooks.com
PDF
Cowe_9780767928168_1p_all_r1.qxp 4/30/09 2:04 PM Page 9
www.BroadwayBooks.com
PDF
Cowe_9780767928168_1p_all_r1.qxp 4/30/09 2:04 PM Page 10
10 | ALAN S. COWELL
took its final turn, on his adoptive home turf, on territory he knew well
and reconnoitered often.
From the Millennium it was a two-minute walk to the offices of a
private security company, Erinys, at 25 Grosvenor Street, where Litvi-
nenko had, in the recent past, sought to learn the inside story of Russia’s
booming oil and gas business, to trade information on such corporate
giants as the former Yukos and Gazprom—entities laden with secrets
worth far more than one man’s life. Grosvenor Square indeed provided
a kind of center of gravity for this downtown double life that Litvi-
nenko led, away from his suburban home. At the end, Litvinenko’s
stock-in-trade had become what private security contractors call due
diligence—the scuttlebutt and pay dirt on companies and individuals in
Russia being sought out as business partners by Western entrepreneurs.
It was a thriving business.
It may have cost Litvinenko his life.
From his hasty meeting at the Pine Bar he went on—not too far away—
to the offices of his mentor, Boris Berezovsky, an exiled Russian oligarch
with a reputation for ruthless and devious business dealings.* Bere-
zovsky had made his money as an entrepreneur-cum-politician in
Moscow’s freewheeling 1990s. In that era, his power was such that he
was known as the gray cardinal of the Kremlin. (He sued Forbes maga-
zine for calling him a godfather rather than a cleric.) In those days, like
a snug inner layer of a Russian Matryoshka nesting doll, Berezovsky en-
*The use of the word “oligarch” became widespread in Russia in the 1990s, initially to
denote those people whose political influence in the inner circles of the Kremlin both
derived from and yielded great wealth, acquired in the sell-off of state assets that
marked the end of the Soviet Union. Later, it came to mean any wealthy tycoon. Bere-
zovsky was one of the earliest examples of the term’s original meaning.
www.BroadwayBooks.com
PDF
Cowe_9780767928168_1p_all_r1.qxp 4/30/09 2:04 PM Page 11
www.BroadwayBooks.com
PDF
Cowe_9780767928168_1p_all_r1.qxp 4/30/09 2:04 PM Page 12
12 | ALAN S. COWELL
At around 7:00 p.m., Zakayev dropped off his friend at the town
house in Muswell Hill, then worth around $1.5 million, which Bere-
zovsky had bought through a front company in the British Virgin Is-
lands for around $500,000 in 2002 and placed at the Litvinenko family’s
disposal. (Berezovsky also paid Litvinenko around $9,500 a month to
act as his agent and emissary—a stipend that had recently been severely
reduced as the two men drifted apart.)
Litvinenko promised to call at Zakayev’s nearby home later. But he
never did. Instead, he stayed home with Marina and Anatoly and ate the
chicken dinner—a favorite—that his wife had prepared for him, relish-
ing, as she said often, the homemaker’s role she had assumed in Britain.
The recipe came from her mother, who had visited a week earlier:
chicken diced small, mixed with herbs and sour cream, turned in a skil-
let. Litvinenko liked it and asked for it again on the anniversary of their
arrival in London, so it was being prepared when he arrived home.
There was no sign, at that precise moment when he entered 140 Osier
Crescent, passing his homemade gymnasium on the way to the kitchen
at the rear, that he had begun to die.
In Russia, Marina Litvinenko had studied the oil and gas industry
at Moscow’s Gubkin Institute. She had been on the professional ball-
room dancing circuit and maintained a dancer’s poise and power. She
had taught aerobics and fitness classes. But now, with a smart new
house and a son at school—as well as a husband prone to obsessions
and crusades beyond the imagination of most Don Quixotes—she had
adopted what she thought to be the ways of an English wife.
“I do everything for our son,” she told me. “I am involved in every-
thing he does, his activities, his trips.” She had tried to persuade her hus-
band to be less of a serial conspirator, more of a father, and felt she was
succeeding: Alexander Litvinenko had even started taking his son for
swimming lessons. But Marina kept a close and not always approving
eye on her husband’s increasingly inflammatory writing in the articles
he wrote for Zakayev’s ChechenPress Web site.
www.BroadwayBooks.com
PDF
Cowe_9780767928168_1p_all_r1.qxp 4/30/09 2:04 PM Page 13
“I was a strong critic. I was very hard on him,” she said. But he was
a different man from the man she had married in Moscow, more mel-
low perhaps, with fewer hard edges. “I could see how he changed when
he arrived,” she said. “He was an officer of the FSB in England—but he
changed into a different person.”
This small, tight-knit family seemed to find England to its liking, at
least in Marina’s account. “I never had any second thoughts that I would
like to leave England. We were very happy here. He was very proud of
our boy. He said he was like a real English boy, and we had a lot of
friends who supported us.”
But even on this special anniversary night, Litvinenko could not
quite tear himself away from the parallel world of conspiracy. The fol-
lowing morning he had scheduled a meeting at a security company
called RISC Management along with the men he had met at the Pine
Bar, Lugovoi and Kovtun. He had e-mails to send, one of them to
Vladimir Bukovsky, a Soviet-era dissident living in the English univer-
sity town of Cambridge, sixty miles northeast of London, and one of
the leading lights in the émigré circle that had embraced the Litvinenko
family.
Nothing in his behavior suggested that he was in any way aware of
the death sentence that had just been executed. He was a man prepar-
ing for life, not death. The family dinner in their unassuming suburban
home was to mark the distance they had traveled together and the
routes they planned for the future, certainly not the end of the road.
“On November 1, Sasha and I decided to have a family dinner in
honor of the anniversary of our move to London,” Marina Litvinenko
said. “Sasha came home and didn’t even stop by to see Akhmed Zakayev
the way he usually does. He went upstairs, checked some information
on the Internet, and then we had dinner together.”
At 9:33 p.m., Litvinenko sent an e-mail to Bukovsky, attaching a
photograph of himself twenty years earlier in camouflage uniform at
the KGB’s counterintelligence school, lying in a field of leaves in a for-
www.BroadwayBooks.com
PDF
Cowe_9780767928168_1p_all_r1.qxp 4/30/09 2:04 PM Page 14
14 | ALAN S. COWELL
www.BroadwayBooks.com
PDF
Cowe_9780767928168_1p_all_r1.qxp 4/30/09 2:04 PM Page 15
If you talk to people now and ask them what kind of man Alexander
Litvinenko was, they will tell you—with varying degrees of forbearance
or scorn—that he talked too much. He seized on ideas. He was undis-
cerning of the truth. He relished campaigns, reached wild conclusions.
He was a zealot. He was flaky. He saw connections where no one else
did. He was obsessive. But they will also say he was professional, an in-
vestigator, well practiced in the dark arts of his business. He could get
to the bottom of things, gather information, distill mysteries into ac-
tionable quantities. He had a great memory, phenomenal recall of dates,
places, people, times. He loved his wife, his son, never smoked, never
drank, never strayed.
Did that mean his hands were clean? Very unlikely: he had been
trained in the counterintelligence branch of the KGB, where they did
not breed gentleman spies. Were there stains on his record? Why not?
He had interrogated Chechen prisoners for the FSB—the domestic suc-
cessor to the KGB—and had worked for a secretive FSB unit in Moscow
that he boasted openly was licensed to kill. So how could he be an inno-
cent? Why would he not have used the terrible powers vested in him by
his rank and calling, first in the KGB then in the FSB?
If you ask, people will reach for literary caricatures, not just
D’Artagnan and Don Quixote, but also Jekyll and Hyde—a dual person,
sunny and open, naive, cruel, insecure; indifferent to money, desperate
for riches; loyal, devious. “Inside, Sasha always remained a child,” his fa-
ther, Walter Litvinenko, a government physician who had worked in the
Soviet penal colonies, said later. Perhaps, like a child, he fed an inner life
with dreams and was uneasy with reality. Perhaps, his father meant to
say, he was easily convinced of a righteous cause, undiscerning, lacking
in judgment, too ready to trust those who meant him harm.
Yet people will also say that he made enemies, within his family,
with his colleagues. He inspired violent reaction. He infuriated the
Kremlin by publicly insulting Vladimir Putin, labeling him, among
www.BroadwayBooks.com
PDF
Cowe_9780767928168_1p_all_r1.qxp 4/30/09 2:04 PM Page 16
16 | ALAN S. COWELL
other things, a pedophile—a far cruder taunt than simply calling him a
dictator, which might even bring some approval in his native land.
Some of Litvinenko’s former associates called him a “scumbag,” a Judas.
He exasperated people, including his sponsor, Boris Berezovsky, and he
used people as his sounding board for crazy ideas. He pestered them
and attached himself to them, seeking benefit for himself and his
causes. He tried to please, to help, to arrange other people’s lives. But he
quested for opportunity, advantage. If you ask those who met him, they
will say he was physically fit, a model of abstemiousness. He could
run—not jog—ten miles at a stretch. He pumped iron. He had a sense
of humor that did not appeal to everyone: after his death the Observer
newspaper in Britain got hold of a photograph showing him wearing a
Scottish tam-o’-shanter cap and KGB-issue gauntlets, waving a double-
handed Chechen sword. The eyes were cold, the face unshaven, the
mouth tight, unsmiling, cruel. The portrait was taken by Pavel Stroilov,
a friend of Vladimir Bukovsky’s, to celebrate the family’s naturalization
as British citizens. The backdrop was a Union flag, and perhaps it
showed just how many conflicting influences had coalesced in the man
who began to die on November 1, 2006.
www.BroadwayBooks.com
PDF
Cowe_9780767928168_1p_all_r1.qxp 4/30/09 2:04 PM Page 17
1
BROKEN HOMES, BROKEN EMPIRE
www.BroadwayBooks.com
PDF
Cowe_9780767928168_1p_all_r1.qxp 4/30/09 2:04 PM Page 18
18 | ALAN S. COWELL
was not shy about confronting American power. Litvinenko was born in
the year of the Cuban missile crisis that pushed the United States and
the Soviet Union to the brink of nuclear war. True, Khrushchev had of-
fered a kind of liberalization after the death of Joseph Stalin, permitting
the publication of the works of Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn and famously
decrying the Stalinist “cult of personality.” But Khrushchev also led a
muscular drive to cement Soviet influence. He approved the crushing of
the Hungarian revolt in 1956, the building of the Berlin Wall in 1961.
And at home, the state’s writ ran unchallenged, its power exercised
through the taut sinews of the KGB and other internal forces created to
forestall dissent. Soviet troops occupied garrisons across Eastern Eu-
rope. Soviet spies tunneled into the Western political establishment.
When Alexander Litvinenko was born, the Cold War was decades away
from any thaw, and the Soviet Union was years from collapse. None of
that brought direct comfort to ordinary citizens struggling to make
ends meet, find an apartment, a telephone line, a car, a television set.
The economy ran to order, according to the principles of scientific so-
cialism. Save for the elite, and those with scarce American dollars or
British pounds to finance themselves, there was no abundance. The out-
put from the collectivized farms failed to keep pace with the growing
population. The harvests were often poor. The shelves in the rubles-
only food stores were never full, usually empty. Lines formed. In grim
concrete apartment houses, ordered up by Khrushchev himself to ease
a dire shortage of dwellings in postwar Russia, communal heating failed
and sputtered. The Russian winter had no mercy.
Litvinenko’s life spanned his land’s liberation and emasculation—
from oppressive superpower to something far less than that, yet some-
thing far more than an ordinary nation: a diminished land that
dreamed of glory revived. He was a child of history.
“We lived in a small room in a hostel in Voronezh,” Nina
Belyavskaya, Litvinenko’s mother, recalled in an interview, sitting in the
same two-bedroom apartment outside Moscow where her son spent
www.BroadwayBooks.com
PDF
Cowe_9780767928168_1p_all_r1.qxp 4/30/09 2:04 PM Page 19
some of his early years while his father moved on to the northern Cau-
casus and Russia’s far east.
“We went hungry and cold because there was no food in the shops,
no meat in Russia at the time. We used to buy bones.”
When she spoke in the summer of 2007, Nina Belyavskaya was
sixty-seven years old, a frazzled, faded blonde living on the margins of
Russian life, remote from the glitzy ostentation of downtown Moscow
with its high-end imported cars and smart eateries. She tended a
makeshift shrine to her lost son with a photograph and flowers and
lived on a pension worth about $150 a month.
The early years were not so easy, either. Imagine a young woman in
her early twenties, boiling bones for soup, prizing open cans of cheap
meat, suckling a child from reluctant breasts. “There was no milk in the
shops and I had very little milk. In the factory next to where I worked,
they used to give workers special milk rations. I’d go there at 4:00 p.m.
as people were leaving with their milk and would ask them to sell me a
couple of bottles to feed my baby,” she said. “Life was very hard.”
In the Soviet way, with the Russian Orthodox Church suppressed,
his mother took the infant Litvinenko secretly to a priest for clandestine
baptism—a common enough occurrence in those days.*
Through the rose glow of maternal retrospect, Nina Belyavskaya re-
called the early years of motherhood as a valiant, single-parent struggle
to make ends meet while tending an ailing but virtuous child.
“Sasha was a very good boy,” she said. He would come home from
kindergarten—the kind of child care the Soviet system offered to all so
that all could work in their designated slots in the command econ-
omy—and balance on a stool at the kitchen sink to start washing the
dishes she had left unwashed and tell her not to worry, he would “do
*In the very last days of his life, Litvinenko’s adherence to his baptismal faith became
something of an issue, but his family disputed the extent of its importance to him. His
mother insisted that the young Sasha had no interest in religion at all.
www.BroadwayBooks.com
PDF
Cowe_9780767928168_1p_all_r1.qxp 4/30/09 2:04 PM Page 20
20 | ALAN S. COWELL
everything for you.” She gave him scarce kopecks to buy ice cream when
he went for a day at the VDNK exhibition complex in northern
Moscow. He returned with a cigarette lighter. “I decided to buy you a
lighter because you are always saying that by using matchsticks you are
poisoning yourself,” he told her.
During his early school years, he made for her a wood burning—a
pyrograph—depicting Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs, and she kept
it throughout her life. He was a skinny, spindle-shanked boy, too eager
to please, begging recognition, offering favors as a coded way of seeking
love or at least attention. An early photograph of mother and son
showed a wistful-looking woman with peroxide blond hair, wearing a
polka-dot dress, with the young Sasha in a white shirt and combed fair
hair, peering at the camera with a look that could be interpreted as re-
proachful or sulky. Neither of them smiled. For the young Sasha, there
was an uncanny resemblance in the set of the mouth and the directness
of the gaze to an iconic photograph of the dying Alexander Litvinenko
that the world came to know in 2006. Then, as earlier, he sought at-
tention.
“He was gentle and attentive and loving,” his mother said, but “we
didn’t always have much time to spend together.
“Sometimes I’d come home and would do some work at home.
‘Mum, stop working,’ he’d say. ‘Let’s spend some time together.’ ” The
loneliness of the latchkey kid would one day create a yearning for com-
pany, for a team, for a mentor. Sasha was never destined to be a loner.
“He was very sociable,” his mother said. When he was a young man and
living away from her, “I bought a lovely suit from Finland, and when he
got back, I asked him where it was. He said he gave it to a friend who
was going to Germany. He was one of those who would give anything
to a friend.”
www.BroadwayBooks.com
PDF
Cowe_9780767928168_1p_all_r1.qxp 4/30/09 2:04 PM Page 21
www.BroadwayBooks.com
PDF
Cowe_9780767928168_1p_all_r1.qxp 4/30/09 2:04 PM Page 22
22 | ALAN S. COWELL
www.BroadwayBooks.com
PDF
Cowe_9780767928168_1p_all_r1.qxp 4/30/09 2:04 PM Page 23
www.BroadwayBooks.com
PDF
Cowe_9780767928168_1p_all_r1.qxp 4/30/09 2:04 PM Page 24
24 | ALAN S. COWELL
Sasha would often come to visit. We’d spend the days running around
the fields, swimming in lakes, and so on.”
How remote those memories seem from Litvinenko’s destiny—the
sunlit, endless summer days, the chill frisson of fresh, clean water on
sunburned skin, the pollen in the air and the games of hide-and-seek
and desultory, childish chatter in the heat of the day. It was a time when
Soviet military and diplomatic power toward the United States was at
its height, the time of Leonid Brezhnev’s thaw in the Cold War that be-
came known as détente between East and West. It must have seemed as
if the world would never change.
“For both, it was our first love,” Natalia said. “Once, we sat next to
each other during a theater performance, and for the first time we
sensed this very strong feeling between us, a platonic love between two
children which grew with every passing year.”
But, in those days as much as later, a dark shadow crossed the sun.
“Vadim, one of my cousins, even then told me that Sasha was not a
good friend,” she recalled. “He said he was tricky. He could betray you,
he told me. I didn’t ask why.”
One thing everyone seemed to agree on is that this young man, this fu-
ture KGB operative whose death would unfold on a global stage, was no
great achiever in class. His Russian grammar was poor. He liked math
and geography, but his grades were middling. He did better at sports.
Walter, his father, said he cut classes to go shooting at tin cans, to nuz-
zle horses and ride them, to run. “He was a bit like Forrest Gump,” his
father said. He liked to play chess and to swim. He gravitated toward the
modern pentathlon, which demands skills in pistol shooting, épée fenc-
ing, swimming, horseback riding, and cross-country running. But he
was never going to make it on to college without a bribe, a back-
www.BroadwayBooks.com
PDF
Cowe_9780767928168_1p_all_r1.qxp 4/30/09 2:04 PM Page 25
www.BroadwayBooks.com
PDF
Cowe_9780767928168_1p_all_r1.qxp 4/30/09 2:04 PM Page 26
26 | ALAN S. COWELL
stepfather, forever competing for attention with the children of his par-
ents’ other liaisons. When he was conscripted into the army at the age
of eighteen, he was glad enough to go.
“In Fryazino his mother had a second husband and a daughter, and
in Nalchik his father had a big family with many kids,” Natalia Litvi-
nenko said during a long conversation in the summer of 2007 in the
kitchen of her small wooden dacha outside Moscow—a modest place
with no running water and an outhouse for a toilet.
“No one needed him,” she said. He “didn’t really have a proper
family.”
www.BroadwayBooks.com
PDF
Cowe_9780767928168_1p_all_r1.qxp 4/30/09 2:04 PM Page 27
apart with his bare hands and eat it.” The father told the story with ap-
propriate gestures mimicking the actions of a starving man. He leaped
up to show how his son had grabbed the chicken. But his anger sud-
denly dissolved into a welling of tears, and he ceased his narrative, sit-
ting down abruptly in his chair.
In his son’s early days in the military, Walter Litvinenko recalled, the
Communist system worked on individual networks of influence and
contacts—people with debts to repay, obligations to redeem. And so,
through various channels, Litvinenko secured a place at the Internal
Forces military academy in what is now called Vladikavkaz, the capital
of North Ossetia, a city of some 300,000 people only eighty miles from
Nalchik. For much of the Soviet era, the city had been known as Or-
dzhonikidze, and in that period the military school had been named for
S. M. Kirov, an associate of Joseph Stalin’s assassinated in 1934. Some
scholars perceive Kirov’s murder as a pretext for unleashing a reign of
terror that culminated in the murder of millions. Years later, Litvi-
nenko’s friends raised similar questions about the Kremlin’s pursuit and
abuse of power. Would Russia’s modern rulers resort to the same tactics
of murder to cement their supremacy? Certainly Alexander Litvinenko
believed so.
The academy—now called the North Caucasian Military Institute
of Internal Forces of the Ministry of Interior of the Russian Federa-
tion—offered Litvinenko his first experience of life outside his extended
family. He was an eighteen-year-old at the beginning of a four-year
course that would mark him out as an officer—a career his parents wel-
comed. But he was also a young cadet in the throes of early manhood,
casting about for love, for attachment, for passion. Adrift from his com-
plicated family, he may well have been plain lonesome, too.
Out of the blue, and after a silence of four years since his move to
Nalchik, Natalia Litvinenko recalled, Alexander began writing her to
rekindle their childhood romance, although under different circum-
stances: she was on the rebound from a broken relationship with a boy-
www.BroadwayBooks.com
PDF
Cowe_9780767928168_1p_all_r1.qxp 4/30/09 2:04 PM Page 28
28 | ALAN S. COWELL
friend who left her; he was pining. Neither of them were children any-
more.
Alexander “wrote many very affectionate letters. He was in the
academy, felt lonely. I fell in love later. At first it was a way of getting
over my boyfriend.” As an aside she also noted that his epistles were
grammatically challenged. “He couldn’t write without making grammar
mistakes. Later, when he used to write to me, I used to always correct his
Russian and send him back his letter, covered in red marks.”
Whatever their literary flaws, the letters led to encounters, to trysts
during the summer vacation in Moscow, to breathless phone calls, and
to yet more letters promising fidelity and undying love when the two
were apart. The relationship blossomed. (Litvinenko’s mother had al-
ways taught him to behave honorably with women: “I used to say:
‘Don’t run around after women, be sensitive and clear with them,’ ” she
said.) But in the harsh light of jilted hindsight, Natalia recalled a
stranger, darker side to him.
“At the academy, they had the equipment to listen in on phone
calls,” she said. “I was once chatting to a male friend of mine when sud-
denly Sasha’s voice interrupted us, jokingly asking me who I was talking
to. From Ordzhonikidze he had linked up and hooked into our phone
call. It was a joke, but he was always checking on me. It was in his
blood.”
In later life, Natalia recalled such moments to build a crescendo of
enduring bitterness toward Litvinenko.
www.BroadwayBooks.com
PDF
Cowe_9780767928168_1p_all_r1.qxp 4/30/09 2:04 PM Page 29
Alexander Litvinenko can no longer shape the debate about the na-
ture of his childhood, this reconstruction of his growth to manhood.
There are snippets and versions, captured on videotape, in notebooks,
in memories. But ultimately, the picture that emerges is colored by the
judgments of those he left behind and their assessment of his nature,
colored as much by political as by personal considerations. There are
flashes of insight, of tenderness, of treachery.
Consider, for instance, Natalia’s memory of the birth of their first
son, Alexander, on January 5, 1985, while the father was close to the end
of his studies in Vladikavkaz and his young wife lived with her parents
in northeastern Moscow, in the same apartment that Natalia lives in to
this day. “He was here on holiday at the birth, but then had to go back
to finish his exams,” she recalled. When their son was just twenty-nine
days old, he returned to Moscow. Natalia was still in the hospital after a
difficult birth. This soldier from the Caucasus, this putative KGB oper-
ative accused later of so much cruelty and deceit, “blushed at the sight
of his son. He didn’t know how to behave, was shy. His reunion with our
son was a very beautiful and emotional moment.”
If he was uncertain around infants, he was less so in his career. Just
as he had won a place at the military academy through family connec-
tions, Alexander Litvinenko pulled strings, courted the right people,
networked. A friend’s uncle had connections with the elite unit of the
Interior Ministry troops—the Dzerzhinsky Division, named for Felix
Dzerzhinsky, the head of the Cheka secret police, the wellspring of So-
viet and Russian internal espionage. And that was the unit he joined af-
ter his four years in training school.
Its training manuals dwelled on crowd control, protection of the
party leadership, keeping watch on sensitive cargoes—some of them
human in the prison trains that rumbled across Russia’s icy time zones.
The Dzerzhinsky Division had fought outlaws in the 1930s and joined
in the Battle of Finland in 1939. Its regiments guarded strategic loca-
tions such as the vaults holding the national gold and currency reserves
www.BroadwayBooks.com
PDF
Cowe_9780767928168_1p_all_r1.qxp 4/30/09 2:04 PM Page 30
30 | ALAN S. COWELL
and the perimeters of nuclear facilities. In the old days of the May Day
military parade on Red Square before the assembled bosses of the So-
viet Communist Party, soldiers from the division’s Third Regiment
would dress in police uniform, deployed in the huge, ornate GUM store
across the way from the Kremlin, ready to put down any displays of dis-
satisfaction with the Central Committee.
The Dzerzhinsky Division was also known as ODON, the Separate
Special Purpose Division, and it was garrisoned near Moscow. To be as-
signed to it was not just a smart career move, it was the kind of move
an ambitious military wife like Natalia Litvinenko would approve—far
more than being dispatched to some remote provincial garrison. But for
Alexander Litvinenko it meant something else that would change his
life: while still in the Dzerzhinsky Division, he joined the KGB, and
from that point on his destiny was sealed, one way or another.
For, as countless former agents have testified, the KGB was a lifelong
commitment: you might think you can quit, but you can never escape
its long reach.
www.BroadwayBooks.com
PDF
Cowe_9780767928168_1p_all_r1.qxp 4/30/09 2:04 PM Page 31
www.BroadwayBooks.com
PDF
Cowe_9780767928168_1p_all_r1.qxp 4/30/09 2:04 PM Page 32
32 | ALAN S. COWELL
Dzerzhinsky Division, his day job was barely spectacular. As his enemies
in the Kremlin recounted with scorn after his death, he was no James
Bond. Along with others, he guarded trains carrying diamonds, gold
bullion, currency printed in Russia for use in Cuba and Mongolia. The
trains carried prisoners, sometimes women. (“They’d jump on a man,
like animals, if they had a chance,” he told his wife.)
But within his unit Alexander Litvinenko was working toward a
new goal—the cherished invitation to join the KGB, at that time con-
sidered a matter not just of patriotic pride but of advancement and
benefit. Of all the military units, Litvinenko told Seymour, the Dzer-
zhinsky Division had the highest per capita proportion of KGB inform-
ers enlisted to snoop and report on their fellow soldiers.
Three officers from the KGB, or its successor, the FSB, were attached
to every regiment, and each officer was required to recruit a minimum
of twenty-five sources. “Some would be the wives of officers or troops,
some would be locals living close to the barracks. In addition, each of-
ficer must recruit a further thirty ‘confidential sources’—agents who are
less important and do not have files maintained on them,” Litvinenko
explained. “Out of the 1,000 officers and men in the regiment there
could be 170 sources and confidential sources.”
Russia at that time was moving, finally, toward liberalization. In
1985—the year Alexander Litvinenko joined the Dzerzhinsky Divi-
sion—Mikhail Gorbachev became general secretary of the Communist
Party and, later, the executive president until the coup of 1991 that de-
posed him and brought Boris Yeltsin to power.
Gorbachev’s rallying cries were “glasnost” and “perestroika”—
“openness” and “restructuring.” But the break with the old Soviet ways
did not seem to extend to the KGB. By the account relayed to Gerald
Seymour, Litvinenko first was recruited as a “source, then is invited to
join the KGB after two and a half years with the division. He becomes a
cadre officer of the KGB, a first-year candidate. He has been a source for
www.BroadwayBooks.com
PDF
Cowe_9780767928168_1p_all_r1.qxp 4/30/09 2:04 PM Page 33
one year at that time. In his probation period he writes reports on many
fellow officers that are scrutinized by the KGB for reliability.”
There was no hint here of opposition to the KGB or its function.
Litvinenko emerged from this conversation with Seymour as an ardent
agent in the making. When people protested much later at the use of the
word “spy” to describe him, they chose a narrow definition of the word
relating to overseas espionage.
True, Alexander Litvinenko was not a KGB First Directorate agent
sent to the West, or even a lesser spy like Vladimir Putin dispatched to
East Germany, then a vassal state of the Soviet Union. But he was an of-
ficer in the Third Directorate—counterintelligence, which meant spy-
ing on his comrades to vet their loyalty and to seek out enemy agents.
And his family was proud of him.
“Joining the KGB was an honor then,” Natalia, his first wife, said.
“There’s a big difference between the Ministry of the Interior and the
KGB. A different level. Much better people.
“This opened up all sorts of opportunities, a far cry from guarding
prisoners all your life,” she said. His father, Walter, said the popular im-
age of the KGB was built on propaganda television programs depicting
valiant Soviet agents infiltrating Hitler’s armies during the Second
World War. “I was very pleased when Sasha was asked to join the KGB,”
he told me. “It was very honorable.”
KGB agents interviewed both Alexander and Natalia to assess their
loyalty and suitability. Natalia hoped her husband would one day be-
come a general. But there were many delicate steps along the way for a
young couple starting on what had all the makings of a good career.
With their infant son, they set up home for two years at the KGB
Military Counterintelligence School in Novosibirsk in Siberia. The early
days were not all free from difficulty, from challenges to be met, in part
by pulling strings, calling in connections. As a newly commissioned
KGB officer, Alexander Litvinenko was assigned to a dismal outpost in
www.BroadwayBooks.com
PDF
Cowe_9780767928168_1p_all_r1.qxp 4/30/09 2:04 PM Page 34
34 | ALAN S. COWELL
www.BroadwayBooks.com
PDF
Cowe_9780767928168_1p_all_r1.qxp 4/30/09 2:04 PM Page 35
“I always used to tell him that we didn’t need much money,” Natalia
said. “As long as he was in the KGB-FSB, he had power, and that counts
more than money. I used to tell him that money solves nothing unless
you have power, and if you leave the Lubyanka, you’ll have no power.
Now you have power and a gun, we don’t need much money. You’ll be-
come a general, a KGB general; you won’t need anything else.”
Through her family, she said, the couple had access to high-level
people who influenced his career and his deployments. That was not
peculiar to the old Soviet Union or the modern Russia: many societies
operate on hidden channels of influence and patronage. But Litvi-
nenko’s reliance on a patron, a mentor, seemed to be a recurring pattern
of behavior: a Russian saying had it that everyone needs a krisha, a
“roof,” for protection.
“After a while, thanks to recommendations people in the KGB gave,
he was transferred to Moscow. We had a good family, I had good par-
ents, a good education. I always pushed him because I wanted him to
become a general,” Natalia said.
At times he took the networking too far.
“He came home from work, and instead of spending time with his
son, he’d get on the phone and start making calls. First one KGB gen-
eral, then another, to wind them up against one another. I worried and
told him to stop lying to these people, to stop plotting. He wouldn’t lis-
ten. He loved intrigue, muckraking. He did it to further his career. It was
his hobby.”
And there was one incident later, close to a turning point in Litvi-
nenko’s life, that showed his first wife how he defined his loyalties, and
the extremes to which he was prepared to go to pursue them. It hap-
pened soon after Litvinenko moved on from the Dzherzinsky Division
in 1991 to join the KGB at its Moscow headquarters, just as Russia was
teetering on the cusp of the chaotic era dominated by Boris Yeltsin. Na-
talia explained:
www.BroadwayBooks.com
PDF
Cowe_9780767928168_1p_all_r1.qxp 4/30/09 2:04 PM Page 36
36 | ALAN S. COWELL
www.BroadwayBooks.com
PDF
Cowe_9780767928168_1p_all_r1.qxp 4/30/09 2:04 PM Page 37
When you asked people after his death what kind of person Litvinenko
was, there was no uniform answer. As with most families—broken or
whole—the Litvinenkos built their own memory, their own narratives.
Litvinenko was different things to different people, and their percep-
tions of him canceled out each other to the end—hero and villain, Ju-
das and martyr, man of courage and coward.
In the months after his death, there was a snatch of poetry that, as
much as anything, revealed something of Litvinenko’s questioning
about his identity. The poem surfaced in a state-sponsored and very
negative television documentary about him in which mother and ex-
wife both referred to lines he was said to have penned in London, his
only poem, perhaps concocted—who knows?—as he mulled life from
the grimy window of the 134 bus. The documentary evoked the an-
guished musings of a man wondering whether, after death, his soul
would migrate to become “the soul of a scumbag, and an executioner.”
Each version of this same personality provided a point of departure
to see the man who began to die on November 1, 2006. At the simplest
level, Litvinenko was a symbol, a cardboard cutout, a pawn in a bigger
game played by people who did not seek his consent. But the accounts
provided by his family and parents and colleagues suggested a much
more complex figure.
Asking that question—who was Alexander Litvinenko?—I was
tempted to ponder whether opposites could be contained within the
*I offer the anecdote with a note of caution since it may be colored by the harsh judg-
ments of a former spouse, or it may in a perverse way show the extent to which he
sought to protect her in the complex political shoals of his calling.
www.BroadwayBooks.com
PDF
Cowe_9780767928168_1p_all_r1.qxp 4/30/09 2:04 PM Page 38
38 | ALAN S. COWELL
same entity without one dominating the other, whether conflicting per-
sonalities could coexist in the same person.
In Litvinenko’s case it might be more accurate to say that he re-
vealed himself to different people in different guises depending on his
requirement of them—hardly an exclusive characteristic. For such peo-
ple, good and evil, light and shade fight in a perpetual battle for domi-
nance. But some of those Litvinenko left in his wake had much less
sympathetic words to describe him.
With the cruelty of the abandoned, his first wife ascribed his behav-
ior to clinical schizophrenia: “I think that Sasha was ill . . . I think that
even when he was still with me, he behaved strangely at times.”
Toward the end of the conversation at her dacha, the condemnation
moved into strident high gear. “I think he was a traitor because he be-
trayed his family, the FSB, his country, his religion. By nature he was
very slippery. He was not transparent. He loved intrigue and plotting
and all that. You’d look him in the eyes, and I’d feel sorry for him and
think he’s honest and open and so on, when in fact behind his eyes was
a mess. He was messed up. He was a terrible person, a traitor, someone
who could do anything.”
From her point of view, the biggest betrayals began when two new
people entered the life of Alexander Litvinenko, setting him on a course
that would wrench him far from his provincial roots and loyalties.
One was a ballroom dancer of modest means called Marina Shtoda.
The other was a very rich man called Boris Berezovsky.
www.BroadwayBooks.com
PDF
Cowe_9780767928168_1p_all_r1.qxp 4/30/09 2:04 PM Page 433
Alan S. Cowell was the London bureau chief of the New York
Times when the events narrated in this book reached their cli-
max. Previously, Cowell served as a correspondent for Reuters
and the New York Times in Europe, the Middle East, and Africa.
He has been based in twelve capitals and has reported the news
from around ninety countries and territories. Cowell is married
and has three children. He is now based in Paris.
www.BroadwayBooks.com
PDF
To purchase a copy of
The Terminal Spy
visit one of these online retailers:
Also available as an Audiobook
Read by Simon Vance