Figure 1 Commodities are in a bear market. Figure 1 proves that the Feds feverish quantitative easing (QE)i.e. record at-money inatingis not driving overall prices of goods higher. The bear market in commodities began two months before the Feds massive asset-buying program began. Despite the Feds inating at a 33% rate annually for ve straight years, commodities are still slipping lower. This is yet another example of the non-existence of external causality on nancial market prices. Such events are results, not causes. The Fed is not pro-acting but reacting. Going into the 2008 peak, sentiment was a key indicator showing that belief in higher prices was rampant. When speaking at a conference in the fall of 2007, I saw hundreds of attendees lined up for the equivalent of half a city block to have an investment guru sign his new commodity-investing book for them. While the author himself had bought commodities early, these fans were getting on board only in the nal months. Few of them would even have read a book on commodity investing in 1999. P.O. Box 1618 Gainesville, GA 30503 USA 770-536-0309 800-336-1618 FAX 770-536-2514 November 2013 Issue November 15, 2013 Figure 1 The Elliott Wave TheoristNovember 15, 2013 Learn how you can get Robert Prechters unique insight and analysis each month in The Elliott Wave Theorist. Visit http://www.elliottwave.com/wave/EWT-CLUBEWIA Figure 2 The September 2013 issue of EWT called for another peak in gasoline prices, and it happened. Gas prices have been falling despite the slightly expanding economy and despite record QE. The peak price in July was the fth in a series of lower peaks since 2008. Figure 2 is the same chart shown then but with prices updated. Gas now sells for the lowest price in nearly three years. In an unusual development, todays paper sports the headline, Fuel Costs Might Have Hit Bottom. At the short term lows in gas prices over the past two years, articles reported experts predictions of still-lower prices. Todays willingness to call a bottom suggests that gas prices are going much lower. Figure 2 Figures 3 and 4 Figure 3, published ten days after gold hit its all-time high, is from the September 2011 EWT. Since the Fed was created in 1913, gold at that time had risen 93 times in value while the Consumer Price Index had risen only 23 times. In other words, having climbed four times as much as the CPI, gold was expensive. Figure 4 updates these charts. The CPI has barely budged since then, but gold has fallen so that its 100-year gain is only about three times that of the CPI. The gap is closing, but there is still a lot of room on the downside for gold. The Elliott Wave TheoristNovember 15, 2013 Learn how you can get Robert Prechters unique insight and analysis each month in The Elliott Wave Theorist. Visit http://www.elliottwave.com/wave/EWT-CLUBEWIA Figure 4 Figure 3 The Elliott Wave TheoristNovember 15, 2013 Learn how you can get Robert Prechters unique insight and analysis each month in The Elliott Wave Theorist. Visit http://www.elliottwave.com/wave/EWT-CLUBEWIA Figure 5 The Elliott Wave Financial Forecast showed Figure 5 two years ago, in October 2011. The Elliott wave labeling shown that month on this chart and in Figure 3 indicated the end of the bull market at both Cycle and Supercycle degree. As you can see, the last chance to sell (not buy) coincided with the Feds launching of its trillion-dollar-a- year bond and mortgage-buying program. Figure 5 Figure 6 Figure 6, also shown in EWFF two years ago, cited a dozen indications of extreme optimism in the gold market during its nal year of rise. Some of these citations are amazing: Societe Generale announced that golds fair value was $10,000/oz. People polled by Gallup cited gold as the single best long-term investment. (In 1999, investors didnt know gold existed.) Ninety-eight percent of futures traders polled for the Daily Sentiment Index (trade-futures.com) were bullish on gold. And the kicker: Central banks, after selling gold a decade earlier near the lows, were buying it. Many speakers on the circuit cited this as a reason gold would soar, but it was a top signal. With gold now down by 1/3, optimism has waned substantially. But investors have not reached the level of pessimism toward gold that existed on February 12, 2001, when a major article was sub-headed, Nobody expects gold prices to turn up soon, and one of the typical comments recorded was, There doesnt seem to be anything on the horizon that will make gold prices go up. Gold at the time was days from its low at $253/oz. When gold reaches its next major bottom, well see articles with similar comments and quotes. The Elliott Wave TheoristNovember 15, 2013 Learn how you can get Robert Prechters unique insight and analysis each month in The Elliott Wave Theorist. Visit http://www.elliottwave.com/wave/EWT-CLUBEWIA Figure 7 The stock market top has eluded us. Prices have repeatedly passed what we thought were terminal junctures. But the charts just keep getting more bearish. The top graph in Figure 7 shows the S&P that everyone is watching. New bull market, right? Wrong. The middle graph shows the real S&P, which has been in a bear market since the rst quarter of 2000. The Feds liquidity has re-fattened the banks, and bankers in turn are lending the new money to wealthy institutional speculators, who use it as collateral to buy stocks on ten to thirty times leverage. This is not a bull market but a hyped-up bear market rally. As Elliott Wave Principle (p.81) said 35 years ago, If the analyst can easily say to himself, There is something wrong with this market, chances are its a B wave [a bear market rally]. There is something not just wrong but sick about a market that is making new all-time highs for seven months on the subterfuge of a purposely debased measuring unit and the central banks nancing of speculators with values stolen from savers. Figure 7 Figure 6 The Elliott Wave TheoristNovember 15, 2013 Learn how you can get Robert Prechters unique insight and analysis each month in The Elliott Wave Theorist. Visit http://www.elliottwave.com/wave/EWT-CLUBEWIA The huge difference between the top two lines on Figure 7 highlights how remarkable it is that nominal prices for gold, silver and commodities are down 30%-60% from their highs. In real terms, they have fallen even further. The lower graph on the chart conrms our interpretation that the post-2000 rallies are bear-market rallies. Main Street knows that the recovery is phony, and its assessments of the economy are in lock-step with the real S&P, not the phony one. The depression is ongoing, and counterfeiting money cant stop it. Figure 8 Big-cap institutional issues are pushing up the popular averages, but the NYSE indexa broad measure comprising 1860 stockshasnt even passed its 2007 high in nominal terms, much less in real terms. Per Figure 8, the broad list of stocks is still in a bear market no matter how you look at it. Figure 9 This year, EWT and EWFF have showed two dozen charts of sentiment indicators at or near all-time expressions of optimism, and here are two more. Figure 9 shows that in the second-to-last week of October, the public poured more money into various U.S. stock funds than at any time in at least seven years, which includes the 2007 stock market top. Figure 8 Figure 9 The Elliott Wave TheoristNovember 15, 2013 Learn how you can get Robert Prechters unique insight and analysis each month in The Elliott Wave Theorist. Visit http://www.elliottwave.com/wave/EWT-CLUBEWIA Figure 10 All this stock buying has created a lopsided investment ratio among fund sectors. As shown in Figure 10, the percentage of money in Rydexs conservative money-market funds as opposed to speculative stock market funds is the lowest since 2001, which is just after the all-time high in the real value for stocks (shown in the middle graph of Figure 7). Figure 10 Figure 11 So much for the public. What about professional advisors? Figure 11 shows that newsletter advisors polled by Investors Intelligence have just reached the lowest percentage of bears since 1987, over a quarter century ago! Under the Elliott wave model, that optimism made sense, because the market was in the third Primary wave of the bull market, the healthiest part of the rise. Still, those peak readings led to the second-biggest stock market crash of the 20 th century. The reading today, while not quite as extreme, is lower than that at the stock market peak of 2007, lower than at the peak of 2000, and just one-quarter of the percentage of bears recorded near major lows. In addition, the latest Daily Sentiment Index shows 90% bulls among S&P futures traders. Now observe on the upper graph that the S&P 500 index is right at the upper line of a trend channel dating back to the 2009 low. Overall, then, we have near-record optimism at an all-time high, right at a point of trendline resistance. Figure 12 Per Figure 12, the NASDAQ Composite and NASDAQ 100 indexes are likewise at the upper ends of channels. They are also touching resistance lines that go back a decade. The S&P and NASDAQ, then, are simultaneously reaching major resistance in an environment of peak optimism. The Elliott Wave TheoristNovember 15, 2013 Learn how you can get Robert Prechters unique insight and analysis each month in The Elliott Wave Theorist. Visit http://www.elliottwave.com/wave/EWT-CLUBEWIA F i g u r e
1 1 The Elliott Wave TheoristNovember 15, 2013 Learn how you can get Robert Prechters unique insight and analysis each month in The Elliott Wave Theorist. Visit http://www.elliottwave.com/wave/EWT-CLUBEWIA Figure 13 Hedge funds arent the only entities using leverage in record amounts. Individuals are using it, too. Figure 13 shows that margin debt at brokerage rms has now reached an all-time high. Leveraged buying by institutions and margin buying by individuals explains how the averages shown in all the previous charts got to where they are. Its just another big debt-nanced bubble, like the one in housing that ended in 2006. Figure 14 The Dow-Jones Utility Average sported ve waves down from April to June, indicating that its bear market is already Figure 12 Figure 13 The Elliott Wave TheoristNovember 15, 2013 Learn how you can get Robert Prechters unique insight and analysis each month in The Elliott Wave Theorist. Visit http://www.elliottwave.com/wave/EWT-CLUBEWIA underway (see Figure 14). The recovery is taking an A-B-C shape, so its counter-trend rally is nearly over. Investors tend to buy utilities for dividend yield. With the bond market having turned from major bull to major bear in the summer of 2012, utilities are going to face stiff competition from rising bond yields. Figure 15 The short term chart of the Dow published on November 7 showed ve waves up from the October 9 low. But wave 9 stretched into a triangle, from which prices have thrust. The thrust is weak, with the past three up days averaging less than a 2:1 ratio of advances to declines. The combination of wave counts in Figures 11 and 15 indicates the imminent end of the entire rise from 2009. The stock market has been the only major nancial sector holding up. Its been frustrating, but it wont last. When wave c in the Dow gets going, the rush to the exits across all markets will be both frightening and exhilarating. Figure 14 Figure 15 Boldly independent and refreshingly contrary, Prechters Elliott Wave Theorist is dedicated to bringing you a tomorrows news today perspective on upcoming market activity and social trends. It exposes commonly held market myths and replaces them with a more accurate depiction of how markets behave and why. Each issue delivers unparalleled insight into the marketplace. The scope is wide, the content profound and the relevance universal. Each Elliott Wave Theorist pushes the envelope of wave research. Preview the topics covered in Bobs Theorist and fnd out how you can get the three latest issues for just $20 >> Or visit http://www.elliottwave.com/wave/EWT-CLUBEWIA ROBERT PRECHTERS ELLIOTT WAVE THEORIST DELIVERS UNIQUE INSIGHT AND ANALYSIS EACH MONTH THAT WILL HELP YOU INVEST INDEPENDENTLY The Elliott Wave Theorist is published by Elliott Wave International, Inc. Mail: P.O. Box 1618, Gainesville, Georgia, 30503, U.S.A. Phone: 770-536-0309. All contents copyright 2013 Elliott Wave International, Inc. Reproduction, retransmission or redistribution in any form is illegal and strictly forbidden, as is continuous and regular dissemination of specic forecasts or strategies. Otherwise, feel free to quote, cite or review if full credit is given. Typos and minor errors are corrected in the online version, which is the ofcial nal version of each issue. Subscribers will be notied by email if substantive changes are made.