Nebosh Shnakar Project
Nebosh Shnakar Project
Nebosh Shnakar Project
CERTIFICATE
(2011 specification)
Candidates observation
sheet
Student number:
Date of inspection
Observations
Hazards and consequences
1. Location: Parking area
Hazard:
People are working in open
area (Hot environment) to
construct parking lot.
Control Measures
Immediate and Long Term
Actions
Immediate measure:
People should be provided
with sunglasses to avoid
harmful effects on eyes.
Timescales
Immediate
1 day
Immediate
Hazard:
Dust is generating during
excavation to construct
parking lot.
Consequence:
Risk of Inhalation of dust
leading to ill health
3. Location : Parking area
Immediate measure:
People should be provided
with correct type of dusts
masks/ respirators.
Long term measure:
Competent person should
supervise the task.
1 day
Immediate measure:
1 day
People should maintain the
Hazard:
distance from the Excavator
Excessive noise is generated and provided with personal
with back hoe which is in
protective equipment such as
improper maintenance during ear muffs or ear plugs.
excavation to construct
Long term measure:
parking lot.
Proper maintenance should
Consequence:
be done and tool box talks to
of
be conducted on hazards of
noise exposure.
Within 1 week
Immediate measure:
Operator should be provided
with Anti vibration gloves and
proper respirators.
Immediate
Hazard:
Operator observed not
wearing Anti vibration gloves
during drilling the earth
surface with Jack hammer.
Consequence:
Risk of Neurological
problems.
Hazard:
No barricades are found near
Long term measure:
the excavation.
Excavation hazards to be
Consequence:
controlled by the valid work
permit.
People may fall into
excavation leading to severe
injuries and fatalities.
6. Location: Ground floor
Hazard: Damaged slings are
found in use while lifting
objects.
Immediate measure:
Damaged slings should be
replaced by new ones.
Within 1 week
Immediate
1 day
Immediate
Consequence:
Leads to severe injuries and
fatality.
Inspection by a competent
person is needed before
starting the work.
Immediate measure:
Hazard:
Welding performed in wet
conditions to fix the entry
gate.
Consequence:
Risk of electric shock.
8. Location: Main entry
(Ground floor)
Immediate
Within 1 day
Immediate measure:
Welders should be provided
Immediate
Hazard:
Welders are found without
PPE during welding.
Consequence:
Risk of burns for welders due
to the burning slags and
sparks evolved.
1 day
Immediate
Consequence:
Leads to musculoskeletal
disorders (Joint and Muscle
pains).
10. Location: First floor
1 day
Immediate measure:
Suitable respirators must be
provided to the people.
Immediate
1 day
Immediate measure:
Immediate
Hazard:
Observed accidental start up
of grinders while replacing
the discs during floor
smoothening activity.
Consequence:
Leads to electrocution,
laceration and abrasion.
Immediate measure:
Hazard:
Sparks are flying while
performing grinding
Hazard:
Observed release of toxic
vapours during painting
activity on the worksite.
Consequence:
Risk of asphyxiation and
health problems.
Consequence:
Leads to eye injury and skin
burns.
1 day
Immediate
1 day
Immediate measure:
Hazard:
Incompetent and
unauthorised workers are
working on electrical
systems.
Immediate
1 day
Immediate
Consequence:
Risk of eye injury and skin
disorders.
Consequence:
Risk of Electrocution and
Fatality.
Within 1 week
Immediate measure:
Carrying of heavy loads
(welding machines, materials
and etc) at a time and
allowing excessive personnel
on scaffold to be prohibited.
1 day
Within week
Immediate measure:
Screens should be placed on
the guardrail system and
area under scaffold should
be barricaded.
1 day
Within 1 week
Consequence:
Leads to serious head
injuries.
Immediate measure:
Personal fall arrest system
should be provided to the
people on scaffold.
Immediate
Consequence:
Falling from height may
cause severe head injury or
fatality.
1 day
Immediate measure:
1 day
Explosion proof motor pumps
should be provided in the
store room to transfer liquids.
Hazard:
Risk of workers falling from
the scaffolds.
Consequence:
Spillage of chemicals leads
to inhalation of toxic
substances.
19. Location: Store room
Hazard: Damaged insulation
on electrical wires
Consequence:
Leads to short circuit.
20. Location: Store room
Hazard: Chemicals are
stored in bulk quantities with
Poor ventilation.
Consequences
Risk of Fire and explosion.
Within 1 week
Immediate measure:
Electrical wire should be
replaced.
Immediate
1 week
Immediate measure:
Cylinders should be stored in
upright positions in the racks
and securely tie with chains.
Immediate
Consequence:
Explosion may occur due to
fall of gas cylinders.
INTERNATIONAL GENERAL
CERTIFICATE
(2011 specification)
Within a week
Date of review:
The work being carried out is construction of retaining walls in the ground floors, constructing
parking lot, welding activity, electrical wiring installations and painting of constructed floors.
Executive Summary
This report identifies the important areas which need modifications as listed below. These
are listed in the order of importance.
Fire safety
Fire risk arises from damaged electrical wiring and storage of flammable substances like
welding gas (oxy acetylene) cylinders, paints, wooden materials, solvents, wooden materials
are stored with inadequate protection. Proper segregation of these materials is needed with
adequate labelling and safe storage.
Machinery safety
Machines like cranes and excavators are not used and maintained according to the
manufactures recommendations. Injuries can be controlled by removing damaged slings
from the workplace and proper procedures should be adopted while using machinery.
Working practices
Appropriate PPE is not used while painting and welding; allowing excessive personnel on
the scaffolds; Barricades are not installed after excavation, etc, are some of the unsafe
practices found during the inspection. Proper inspection, training and supervision are
needed.
Welding hazards
Risk of electrocution and burns founded from welding activity which is performed wet
conditions and workers not wearing proper PPE. The welding hazards are controlled by
adopting work permit system and providing training and required PPE to the welders.
Fall hazards
Several fall hazards are identified in the work site. Workers are found on the heights
(scaffolds) without personal fall arrest systems. Equipment and tools are placed on the
scaffold under which no barricades are provided.
Sufficient protective equipment and guarding systems should be provided which reduces the
risk of accidents in the work site.
Improvisation of job activities by adopting the safe work practices will reduce the risk of
accidents in the work site. This in turn improves the efficiency and productivity. A lot of time
and investment is saved in connection with staff training, accident investigation, and
compensation claims.
The suggestions made in this report can be exercised directly by the staff only and at
relatively little cost.
Failure to implement the suggestions made will cause damage to reputation and negative
publicity. This in turn will make a difference to the financial success. Management should
also view the issues in terms of humanity and moral dimension.
Main findings of the inspection
This report identifies the important areas which need modifications as listed below.
Fire hazards (observations 19, 20, 21)
A number of fire hazards were present on the worksite specially inspecting store room:
Damaged electric wiring and components, chemicals are stored in bulk quantities without
proper ventilation and welding gas cylinders are stored under poor condition without security.
These conditions may lead to major fire explosion and also to huge property damage, severe
injuries or death.
These conditions are violation of rules stated in Article 16 of ILO Convention C155 and more
specifically the obligations mentioned in ILO Recommendation R164 for the employer are
breached.
Electric wirings and components to be replaced by authorized persons and welding gas
cylinders should be separately stored in blocks in upright position and secured with chains.
Store employees should be trained in segregation and proper storage of materials, regular
inspections should be conducted by a competent person.
Machinery and equipment (observations 3, 4, 6)
Several items of machinery and equipment are identified to be in dangerous state due to the
poor use and maintenance:
Excessive noise was generated by backhoe during excavation to construct parking lot in
open area of the worksite.
Damaged slings of Cranes are found in use for lifting heavy objects (gas pipes) to be fitted in
the second floor.
Jack hammer which is been used to drill the concrete for pipe laying in the ground floor is
found physically damaged.
These conditions may result in severe injuries or deaths leading to significant fines or
prosecutions and also to large compensation pay outs.
These conditions are violation of rules by the employer mentioned in ILO Article 10 (a) of
R164.
Jack hammer should be repaired; Backhoe should be under regular maintenance, damaged
slings should be immediately replaced.
Proper training should be provided for the operators of carne, backhoe and staff and regular
inspection should be conducted by a competent person.
Workers are identified without fall protection on scaffolds while carrying out the roofing
activity. This may cause their fall from height leading to severe head and body injuries and
sometimes even fatality.
This condition may result in severe injuries or deaths and give out compensation apart from
possible sanctions from authorities.
This indicates the breach of rules mentioned in Article 16 of ILO Convention C155.
Management should provide screens for placing on the guardrail system and area under
scaffold should be barricaded.
Management should allocate a full time supervisor to monitor the task and to restrict the
entry.
Proper fall protective equipment should be provided to the people working on scaffolds.
Training in fall protection should be provided by a competent person to the staff.
Conclusions
Little attention towards safety issues are found to be paid in implementation. Due to poor
maintenance and lack of safety knowledge employees are working under hazardous
conditions. Lot of energy is found to be put in for carrying out easy tasks. Stress and strain
are the immediate consequences. Property damage, loss of reputation and bad publicity are
the issues that rise later.
The five areas mentioned in the report need immediate attention. Appropriate suggestions
have been made for some observations. Implementing these practices assumes very little
cost and can be actioned by in house staff only. It is certain that costs required for facing the
consequences of the hazards resulting due to these mentioned will be more tham their
implementation cost.
Recommendations
Recommendation
Damaged Electric
wirings and
components in the
store room should be
replaced by the
electrician.
Likely resource
implications
25 meters of double
insulated electrical
wire and 2 switch
boards which includes
the cost of 2000 INR.
Priority
Target date
High priority
1 week
2 nos of storage
blocks and 10 meters
of steel chain which
includes the cost of
3500 INR.
1 week
Classroom and
practical training to
store room staff
Immediate
storage of materials.
(approx. 2 hours)
should be conducted
by Safety officer.
Regular inspections
should be conducted
by the competent
person in the store
room to prevent
hazards.
Excavation work
should be stopped
immediately and
backhoe should be
sent for maintenance.
1 week
High priority
Immediately
1 day
1 week
Training to the
operators and staff to
be provided by a
competent person on
regular maintenance
and inspection of
equipments and
machinery.
Classroom and
practical training to
operators and staff
(approx. 3 hours)
should be conducted
by Safety officer.
1 week
1. Procuring 10 nos of
UV protected
sunglasses includes
the cost of 4000 INR.
Classroom and
practical training to
supervisor (approx. 2
hours) should be
conducted by Safety
officer.
1 day
Classroom and
practical training to
operator and
supervisor (approx. 2
hours) should be
conducted by Safety
officer.
1 day
Immediate
2. Procuring 10 nos of
particulate cartridge
respirators include the
cost of 8000 INR.
Activity supervisor to
control the task
according to work
permit checklist.
Grounding the
machinery and use of
GFCI cost implication
5000 INR.
High priority
High priority
1 day
1 day
1 day
Management should
allocate a full time
supervisor to monitor
the task and to restrict
the entry with
barricades.
Procuring 10 meters
of Guardrail screen
includes the cost of
15000 INR.
Screens should be
placed on the guardrail
system of scaffold.
Placing of 25 feet of
barricade procure cost
8000 INR.
Training in fall
protection should be
provided by a
competent person to
the staff.
Classroom and
practical training to the
staff on potential fall
hazard (approx. 2
hours) should be
conducted by Safety
officer.
High priority
1 day
Immediate
Immediate
1 week