SPE Method Development
SPE Method Development
SPE is Chromatography
Keep in mind that solid-phase extraction has the same fundamental basis as HPLC. Any knowledge
of the chromatographic behavior of the analytes of interest, and of other matrix components, can
help in choosing the proper sorbent and eluents. If, for example, you know that certain
chromatographic conditions provide excellent separation of your analyte from interferences, then
you may choose a similar SPE sorbent and solvent combination. Similarly, if you are trying to
remove an interference that coelutes in HPLC, then you know a priori that similar SPE conditions
will not be successful.
unretained.
adsorb components of interest while matrix interferences pass through the cartridge
unretained.
The first strategy is usually chosen when the desired sample component is present in high
concentration. When components of interest are present at low levels, or multiple components of
widely differing polarities need to be isolated, then the second strategy is generally employed.
Trace enrichment of compounds present at extremely low levels and concentration of dilute
samples are also achieved by the second strategy.
2.
3.
4.
1.
Condition the cartridge with six to ten hold-up volumes of non-polar solvent, usually the
same solvent in which the sample is dissolved.
2.
3.
4.
5.
Elute remaining components of interest with progressively more polar [stronger] solvents.
6.
When you recover all of your components, discard the used cartridge in a safe and
appropriate manner.
This procedure is illustrated in the figure below for a sample containing a mixture of three neutral,
relatively non-polar organic dyes [yellow, red, and blue] that appears black when initially loaded
onto the cartridge bed.
Illustration of a General Elution Protocol for Normal-Phase Chromatography on SPE Cartridges
(Silica, Florisil, Alumina, Diol, CN, NH2)
Reversed-Phase Chromatography
Because of the multiplicity of aqueous samples spanning a breadth of applications from
environmental water to fruits and vegetables, from beverages to biological fluids, reversed-phase
chromatography has become the predominant mode of SPE.
To perform reversed-phase chromatography with SPE cartridges, use a gradient of strongly to
weakly polar solvents [from weak to strong solvent elution strength] with a non-polar packing
material.
1.
Solvate the silica-bonded phase or polymer packing with six to ten hold-up volumes of
methanol or acetonitrile. Flush the cartridge with six to ten hold-up volumes of water or buffer. Do
not allow the cartridge to dry out [unless using HLB].
2.
Load the sample dissolved in a strongly polar [weak] solvent [typically water].
3.
4.
5.
Elute more tightly bound components with progressively more non-polar [stronger]
solvents.
6.
When you recover all the components of interest, discard the used cartridge in a safe and
appropriate manner.
This procedure is illustrated in the figure below for a sample of an aqueous grape drink containing
two polar food dyes [red and blue], as well as sugar and artificial flavor [but no real grape juice!].
As prepared, this drink appears light purple in a glass, since the dye concentration is dilute. When
a portion is loaded onto a prepared SPE cartridge, the strongly retained dyes become concentrated
near the inlet in a dark purple band.
Illustration of a General Elution Protocol for Reversed-Phase Chromatography on SPE Cartridges
(C18, tC18, C8, CN, Diol, HLB, Porapak RDX, NH2)
Ion-Exchange Chromatography
Compounds that are ionic or ionizable are often best isolated using some form of ion-exchange
chromatography. This separation mode is orthogonal to the more widely used normal-phase and
reversed-phase modes and provides a powerful, selective second dimension to sample preparation
protocols.
Illustration of the Two Major Types of PhasesAnion and Cation Exchange
and How They Selectively Attract and Retain Molecules of Opposite Charge
Condition the cartridge with six to ten hold-up volumes of deionized water or weak buffer.
2.
3.
4.
Elute the first component of interest with a stronger buffer (change the pH or ionic
strength).
5.
6.
When you recover all of your components, discard the used cartridge in an appropriate
manner.
This procedure is illustrated in the figure below for a sample of an aqueous mixture of two ionic
dyes with different pKa values. When loaded onto the cartridge, both are strongly retained, and the
combination of blue and yellow components appears as a green band near the inlet.
Illustration of General Elution Protocol for Ion-Exchange Chromatography on SPE Cartridges
(NH2, Accell Plus QMA, Accell Plus CM, SCX, SAX, WCX, WAX)
Cation and anion exchangers are further categorized as either weak or strong exchangers,
depending upon the type of ionic group on their surface. Strong cation exchangers possess an
acidic surface moiety such as a sulfonic acid that is always ionized [negatively charged] over the
whole pH range. Weak cation exchangers possess an acidic surface moiety such as a carboxylic
acid that is negatively charged at high pH but neutral at low pH. Similarly, strong anion exchangers
typically bear quaternary ammonium groups that are always positively charged, while weak anion
exchangers possess primary, secondary, or tertiary amine groups that may be positively charged
at low pH but neutral at high pH.
Use the following table as a guideline to choose the appropriate SPE ion-exchange cartridge type
for your particular analyte.
Mixed-mode ion exchange chromatography combines the use of reversed-phase and ion-exchange
modes into a single protocol on a single SPE cartridge. It can be used to isolate and separate
neutral, acidic, and basic compounds from a single complex matrix. An ideal mixed-mode SPE
sorbent substrate remains water-wettable while exhibiting strong reversed-phase retention of
hydrophobic compounds. On its surface are ion-exchange functionalities of one of the four general
types just described above. Intermediate washes with organic solvent mixtures of appropriate
elution strength may be used to isolate neutral compounds [including ionizable analytes in their
neutral state]. Selective elution of ionically bound analytes may be attained by manipulating the
charge of either the analyte [when bound to strong ion exchangers] or of the sorbent [for analytes
bound to weak ion exchangers].
Analyte
Reversed Phase
Normal Phase
Ion Exchange
Moderate to low
Low to high
Charged or Ionizable
polarity
polarity/neutral
Separation
Separation based
Separation based on
Mechanism
on hydrophobicity
polarity
Sample Matrix
Aqueous
Non-polar organic
solvent
Condition/
Equilibrate SPE
Sorbent
Preliminary Wash
1. Solvate with
Non-polar organic
Aqueous/buffer
Non-polar organic
Increase polar
Increase eluotropic
organic content
strength of organic
polar organic
2. Water
Step
Elution Steps
solvent mixture
Sorbent
Functionality
CX
[Cation
Exchange]
Exchange]
Silica, Alumina,
WAX
Rxn CX
RDX, Rxn RP
Sorbent Surface
AX
[Anion
Low to Medium
High to Medium
High
High
High to Medium
Low to Medium
High
High
Hexane, chloroform,
Water, low
Water, low
Polarity
Typical Solvent
Polarity Range
Typical Sample
Loading Solvent
buffer
methylene chloride
strength buffer
strength buffer
Typical Elution
CH3OH/water,
Ethyl acetate,
Buffers, salts
Buffers, salts
Solvent
CH3CN/water
acetone, CH3CN
strength,
strength,
increase pH
decrease pH
Most weakly
Most weakly
Sample Elution
Order
components first
components first
Mobile Phase
Solvent Change
ionized sample
ionized sample
component first
component first
Decrease solvent
Increase solvent
Increase ionic
Increase ionic
polarity
polarity
strength or
strength, or
increase pH
lower pH
Required to Elute
Compounds
This has been a brief introduction to sample enrichment and purification using solid-phase
extraction [SPE]. The best way to start using SPE is to first learn what others have done with
analytes and/or matrices similar to those of interest to you. You will find > 7,700 references to the
use of SPE in the Resource Library on waters.com. Fill in the blank with a partial compound or
matrix name in the following search phrase:
Sep-Pak OR Oasis AND ______*
NOTE: Rather than risk a spelling error, use an asterisk [*] with a root name for best results. Using
this same search string, even more references [> 60,000] may be found on GOOGLE Scholar.
Further reading:
J.C. Arsenault and P.D. McDonald, Beginners Guide to Liquid Chromatography, Waters [2007];
Order P/N 715001531 on waters.com
P.D. McDonald and E.S.P. Bouvier, A Sample Preparation Primer and Guide to Solid-Phase
Extraction Methods Development, Waters [2001] Search for WA20300 on waters.com
Waters, Purity by SPE [2008]; Search for 720001692en on waters.com
U.D. Neue, P.D. McDonald, Topics in Solid-Phase Extraction. Part 1. Ion Suppression in LC/MS
Analysis: A Review. Strategies for its elimination by well-designed, multidimensional solid-phase
extraction [SPE] protocols and methods for its quantitative assessment [2005]; Search for
720001273en on waters.com
The chromatographic bed can be used to separate the different compounds in a sample, to make
subsequent analytical testing more successful. For example, SPE is often used for the selective
removal of interferences.
The technically correct name for this technology is Liquid-Solid Phase Extraction, since the
chromatographic particles are solid and the sample is in the liquid state. The same basic
chromatographic principles of liquid chromatography that are used in HPLC are also used here, but
in a different format and for a different reason. Here, chromatography is used to better prepare a
sample before it is submitted for analytical testing.
In sample preparation, samples can come from a wide range of sources. They can be biological
fluids such as plasma, saliva, or urine; environmental samples such as water, air, or soil; food
products such as grains, meat, and seafood; pharmaceuticals; nutraceuticals; beverages; or
industrial products. Even mosquito heads can be the sample! When a scientist needed to analyze
neuropeptides extracted from the brains of mosquitoes, SPE was the sample preparation method
of choice [Waters Applications Database, 1983].
One of the most difficult problems for an analytical chemist is when compounds of interest are
contained in a complex sample matrix, such as mycotoxins in grains, antibiotic residues in shrimp,
or drug metabolites in plasma, serum, or urine. T he large number of interfering constituents or
substances in the sample matrix along with the compounds of interest makes analysis extremely
difficult.
The first problem to solve is the resulting complexity of the analysis itself due to the presence of
so many entities which must be separated in order to identify and quantitate the compound[s] of
interest. See Figure 2.
could be analyzed with a simpler, more robust method. This can be seen in Figure 3, which
compares the original sample on top to the new SPE-prepared sample on the bottom.
base line] due to proper sample preparation with SPE. Notice a much cleaner baseline improves
the accuracy of the analytical results. Also, a much purer extract can be obtained if the sample
requires isolation and purification of that compound.
In some instances, interferences from the sample matrix can artificially increase the signal
reported for a compound. This is called ion enhancement, resulting in an inaccurately high
reported value. A proper SPE method will minimize this effect by cleaning away the interferences
from the compound, resulting in a more accurate reported value.
3. Capability to Fractionate Sample Matrix to Analyze Compounds by Class
An analyst may be faced with a sample that contains many compounds, with a need to separate
them by class so that further analysis can be carried out much more efficiently. For example, a soft
drink beverage contains a wide range of compounds in its formulation. An SPE method could be
developed to separate the different classes of compounds, for example by their polarity. The polar
compounds could be collected, as a separated fraction, from the more non-polar compounds.
These two fractions could then be separately analyzed in a much more efficient way because their
compounds would be more similar.
An example of the power of fractionation by SPE is shown in Figure 8. Here, a complex sample of a
dry powder [purple grape drink mix] is easily separated into four fractions: a fraction of just the
polar compounds, a purified red compound, a purified blue compound, and a fraction containing all
the remaining very non-polar compounds. You will see elsewhere in this book how very powerful
this capability can be.
Analysts today often need to report on compounds at far lower concentration levels than ever
before, as little as parts per trillion [ppt] and even lower. Typically these levels are lower in the
neat sample than the sensitivity capability of the analytical instruments.
A good example of this is the analysis for trace contaminants in environmental samples or
metabolite development over time in biological fluids. The upper trace in Figure 9 shows the poor
response of the original neat sample for the compound of interest. Using the same analytical
conditions but with the sample prepared with SPE used in a trace concentration strategy, the lower
trace shows a dramatic increase in signal strength for this compound. With this result, an accurate
calculation of the original compound concentration in the neat sample can be made.
Summary
As weve seen, an SPE device with a chromatographic bed can perform four critical functions to
make the analysis of the sample more successful. See Figure 10.
2. You need to increase the concentration of the analyte of interest in the original sample so that it
can be more readily detected and more accurately quantitated by your analytical technique. A
large sample volume may be loaded onto an SPE column if the analyte of interest is strongly
retained. Then the analyte may be eluted in a very small volume, thereby increasing its
concentration in the sample aliquot presented to your chosen analytical tool.
3. You need to remove interferences in your sample that, though invisible, suppress the signal for
the analyte of interest as detected by mass spectrometry. In the example shown here, protein
precipitation failed to remove the phospholipids from a plasma extract, causing severe ion
suppression. An optimized mixed-mode SPE protocol provides the cleanest extract and minimizes
ion suppression.
Typical SPE cartridges are low-pressure devices-constructed of solvent-resistant plastic or glassfilled with particles 30 m in diameter. Suitable flow rates may be achieved by gravity or with the
assistance of vacuum or low positive pressure. [The latter requires putting a cap on the open inlet
of a column or using a sealed device with inlet and outlet fittings.]
in solution
to reduce the scale as much as practicable [gaining economies of time, labor, and cost];
When compared to other sample preparation processes, solid-phase extraction using SPE
cartridges offers:
Lower Cost
Greater Recoveries
Faster Protocol
fewer steps
Greater Safety
Greater Accuracy
no cross contamination
No Emulsion Problems
minimal evaporation
adsorbed:
use solid-phase extraction with sorbent surface chemistry that is the same as that
use solid-phase extraction with sorbent surface chemistry and/or separation mode
will be unnecessary.
To desalt samples:
first, adsorb analytes on reversed-phase sorbent while salt breaks through
unretained.
then, after using water to wash away residual salt, desorb analytes using watermiscible organic solvent.
To exchange solvents:
adsorb the sample completely onto a strongly retentive sorbent and flush away the
original solvent with a weaker eluent.