Critical Appraisal of Development Plan
Critical Appraisal of Development Plan
Critical Appraisal of Development Plan
Town Profile
Introduction
1847
1847 - foundation stone of famous Lawrence School
1850 -Establishment of British Cantonment
1873
Kasauli brewery set up near Kasauli Village By General Dyer
Pasteur Institute of India was set up
1947 onwards
Kasauli became Indian Airforce Base
Imperatives
Rich eco-system and cultural heritage.
Low level of urbanization in the State,
Legal Framework
Extension Of Himachal Pradesh Town and Country Planning
Act, 1977 to Kasauli Planning Area in the year 1991.
Area upto 1.00 Kilometre on both sides of road from Kasauli to
Dharampur, Kasauli to Kuthar via Jagjitnagar and Kasauli to Parwanoo via
Jangeshu
Jurisdictions
The planning area is Y-shaped, as it extends in a linear fashion along three
major roads, emanating from Kasauli town.The area is spread along 12
Kilometre Kasauli-Dharampur road, 10 Kilometre Kasauli-Jagjitnagar road,
12 Kilometre Kasauli-Jangeshu-Parwanoo road and 5 Kilometre
Kimmughat-Kutahaghat road.
- Critical Appraisal
Vision
Regulate and guide growth in
desired directions in view of
Kasauli being an eco fragile
,eco sensitive
zone , to
regulate
unprecedented
invasion on the peaceful
environs of the hill.
Haphazard Growth
There are several pockets in Kasauli Planning Area,
which have developed in a haphazard manner and have
thick development. These pockets are eyesores amidst
the natural landscape around them.
Physical Infrastructure
Provision of Adequate physical
infrastructure for the population in
Kasauli Planning area specially
provision of adequate water supply.
Physical Growth:
linear/ribbon growth along
major corridors and is not
conducive for ensuring holistic
and sustainable development of
the area
Concept
Phasing
With a perspective period of 15 years
Implementation of Development Plan is
divided into three phases, coinciding with five
year plans namely:
(i) 2009 -2012
(ii) 2012-2017
(iii) 2017-2021
Norms , standards and assumptions:
Norms for various physical
and social
infrastructure have been mentioned but not
very clearly.
The rate of growth of population has been
assumed to be the current rate .
Sno
Name
Kasauli Gaon
Nahari
Chhatiyan
Mashobra
Shalaura Kalan
Shalaura Khurd
Jangeshu
Upmohal Tipra
Nadho
10
Dochi
11
Kaphal Ka Hara
12
Gosan
13
Garkhal
14
Khadoli
15
Chabal
16
Sadiyana
`17
Banjni
18
Chamian
19
Khajret
20
Nichli Gaongari
21
Uparli Gaongari
22
Tipra
23
Shili Kalan
24
Shili Khurd
25
Thare Ka
Thakurdawara
26
Dharampur
27
Sanawar
28
Mando Matkanda
29
Mangoti
30
Sanawar
31
Sanwara
THEME
INDICATOR
BRIEF DESCRIPTION
QUERIES
SPATIAL SCALE
PLAN PREPARATION
Vision
SWOT analysis
taking into
account
need
demands
aspirations
Region
City
Ward
Region
City
Ward
Approach/concept
Region
City
Planning methodology
Region
City
Ward
Perspective period
Region
City
Ward
Phasing
Number of phases
Time span
Region
City
Ward
THEME
Assessmen
t of future
Requirements
INDICATOR
BRIEF
DESCRIPTION
Land suitability based
on development
constraints / natural
resources / vulnerable/
sensitive areas
Land
QUERIES
Existing land
Utilization /land Use
Densities
Components Of Plan
Settlement Pattern
Shelter
Housing
Other Shelter
Options
Infrastruct
ure
Water Supply
Provision of other
shelter options like night
shelters.
Sources of water
Proportion of
households having
access to safe water
supply.
SPATIAL SCALE
Region
City
Ward
THEME
INDICATOR
Sanitation
Infrastructure
Drainage
BRIEF DESCRIPTION
QUERIES
SPATIAL
SCALE
Region
City
Ward
Proportion of Households
having access to sanitation
facilities.
Natural Drainage
(water shed areas)
Region
City
Ward
Drainage network
Power
Supply
Alternative / Renewable
sources for Power Supply
Region
City
Region
City
Ward
Solid waste
Management
Disposal Sites
Integration Of informal
Sector
Hierarchy , Number and
Distribution
THEME
INDICATOR
BRIEF DESCRIPTION
QUERIES
Infrastruc
ture
Education
SPATIAL
SCALE
Region
City
Ward
Health
Recreational facilities
Urban
Form
Transit oriented
corridors /Special areas
Built
Heritage
Monuments
Natural
Resources
Precincts
City
Ward
Region
City
Ward
Region
City
Ward
THEME
INDICATOR
BRIEF DESCRIPTION
QUERIES
Climate
Change
Compact City
Structure/Carbon Neutral City
concept considering like Green
Building codes Renewable
energy sources, etc.
Energy efficiency
measures
Provision of Sustainable
Transport options
Urban
Environ
mental
Quality
Disaster
Manage
ment
Water Pollution
Air Pollution
Noise Pollution
Safety of vulnerable
communities
Adaptive capacity
Adaptive capacity of
Population Institutions ,
Information System and
Resources
SPATIAL
SCALE
Ward
Region
City
Ward
Region
City
Ward
Region
City
Ward
THEME
INDICATOR
BRIEF
DESCRIPTION
QUERIES
Marginalized Groups
Slums
Urban Poor
Informal Sector
Inclusion of Marginalized
Groups /Population with
special needs in planning &
design Decision making and
implementation
Inclusivity
Population with
special needs
Children, Youth,
Women , Single
Parents, Senior
citizens, Disabled
Population
Equity
Distribution of
housing supply
Provision of access to
infrastructure &
services
Region
City
Ward
Equitable distribution of
housing & infrastructure
between various social and
economic classes?
City
Ward
implementation.
Capacity
building &
community
empowerme
nt
Social well
being
Personal development
Security (Crime
Terrorism
SPATIAL SCALE
Ward
City
Ward
THEME
INDICATOR
BRIEF
DESCRIPTION
QUERIES
GDP
Provision of economic
sustainability in the plan
by ways of employment
and economic
opportunities which would
contribute to the state
GDP & experts .
Employment rate
in local enterprise /
SHGs/CBOs/NGOs
Local economic
development
Investment plan
Mobilization of finance /
Economic
Development
Financial
development
investment Projects.
SPATIAL
SCALE
Region
City
Ward
Region
City
Ward
Governance
Implementatio
n and
enforcement
Phasing
Plan approvals
Responsibility /Accountability
Stakeholder
Participation
enforcement?
Region
City
Ward
THEME
INDICATOR
BRIEF
DESCRIPTION
QUERIES
Plan Evaluation
Monitoring Mechanism
Review Mechanism
Responsibility/ Accountability
Stakeholder
participation
Monitoring
and Review
Public grievance
System
Ward community,
women, youth
academia, NGOs,
CBOs, SHGs Pvt
Sector etc
SPATIAL
SCALE
Region
City
Ward
Infrastructure Requirements
Water Supply
Storm Water generation
Solid waste generation
Land
2500
2000
1500
1000
500
Population Size
Within the planning area ,
Kasauli Gaon has the highest population with 2131 persons.
Shilli Khurd - has the lowest population with merely 8 persons.
Total Population of Kasauli Planning Area is 14315
Kasauli development plan gives the population village wise also projects the population
for the year 2021
2011
850.00
2001
800.00
India
Himachal Kasauli
Male
Female
Rural population:male-female
distribution
45%
55%
Male
Female
Male
Female
Inferences
The cumulative rural vs. urban
population shows a little deviation in
balance of male to female ratio. Sex
ratio in rural area is higher as
compared to urban area .
The urban as well as rural female
sex ratio is much below the state as
well as national sex ratios of 974
and
940
per
1000
males
respectively.
However, the distinctly lesser
female population in the urban areas
as compared to the rural area
demarcates the
in-migration of
majorly male population in pursuit
of economic opportunities and job
prospects.
villages
Dharampur
Sanawar
Mando Matkanda
Mangoti
Sanawar
Sanwara
Kasauli Gaon
Nahari
Chhatiyan
Mashobra
Shalaura Kalan
Shalaura Khurd
Jangeshu
Upmohal Tipra
Nadho
Dochi
Kaphal Ka Hara
Gosan
Garkhal
Khadoli
Chabal
Sadiyana
Banjni
Chamian
Khajret
Nichli Gaongari
Uparli Gaongari
Tipra
Shili Kalan
Shili Khurd
population
2500
2000
1500
1000
500
0
TOT_Population
P_SC
F_06
3577
Urban
M_06
4026
Rural
Kasauli
P_06
7603
0
2000
4000
6000
8000
District Code
State/District
2
Himachal Pradesh
01
02
03
04
05
06
07
08
09
10
11
12
Chamba
Kangra
Lahul & Spiti
Kullu
Mandi
Hamirpur
Una
Bilaspur
Solan
Sirmaur
Shimla
Kinnaur
2011
4
906
950
873
1,013
962
913
881
870
893
899
931
922
953
The decreasing sex ratio in this age group has a cascading effect
on population over a period of time leading to diminishing sex
ratio in the country
This reflects a grim picture of the status of the girl child in the
country and majority of the states. The magnitude of the decline
can be seen by the fact that 31 States / Uts have registered a
decline in Child Sex Ratio during 2001.Alarming trends are
discerned
in
some
of
the
major
states
like Punjab, Haryana, Himachal Pradesh, Gujrat, and Delhi.
Comparative child sex-ratio
920
900
880
860
886
Kasauli
906
914
Himachal
India
(Source:
Solan, 2011
data)
Inferences
While the child sex ratio for Himachal Pradesh is below
the national figure ,that of kasauli is even far more lower.
The decreasing sex ratio in this age group has a
cascading effect on population over a period of time
leading to diminishing sex ratio in the country.
Literacy Rate
95
90
85
M_ Lit rate
80
F_lit Rate
75
70
Total
Rural
Urban
Source : DP Kasauli
120
100
80
60
40
20
Observations
Dharampur
Sanawar
Mando Matkanda
Mangoti
Sanawar
Sanwara
Kasauli Gaon
Nahari
Chhatiyan
Mashobra
Shalaura Kalan
Shalaura Khurd
Jangeshu
Upmohal Tipra
Nadho
Dochi
Kaphal Ka Hara
Gosan
Garkhal
Khadoli
Chabal
Sadiyana
Banjni
Chamian
Khajret
Nichli Gaongari
Uparli Gaongari
Tipra
Shili Kalan
Shili Khurd
Literacy rate is highest in Khajret followed by Nahari, with both male and female literacy being highest
here.
Male Literacy rate is lowest in Shilli Kalan, while female lieracy rate is lowest in Shilli Khurd.
39%
Workers
Non-workers
61%
6%
Main
Marginal
94%
22%
Male
Female
78%
Infrastructure Requirements
Water Supply
Kasauli Cantonment is being supplied drinking water supply by Military Engineering Service.
The sources of water are springs near Manaun and Gambhar river.
The military as well as civil population in Kasauli town are served water by these schemes.
The total supply is 80,000 to 90,000 gallons per day. There are gaps in the actual supply of
water and the overall demand of water supply.
Water Supply Schemes for Kasauli Villages
Currently the population in the planning area is getting its supply of
water from Irrigation and Public Health Department .
Other schemes which are serving the villages of Planning Area are
Perreinal Sources
of Water for
Kasauli
Manuan
Springs
Gambhar
The plan states that it is being augmented to the water supply level of 70
litre per capita per day, by connecting it to the Water Supply
Scheme, Solan from Giri River.
it was predicted in the development plan that Kasauli was likely to
witness continuing shortage of water supply
Observations
Improvements in the water supply system depend upon
public financing, for existing tariffs generate insufficient
revenues to cover the operational and maintenance costs.
Enhancement of tariff is linked to economic structure of the
consumer population and to the improvement in service
delivery.
Present schemes are supplying water at 45 LPCD which is by
any far below the benchmark
Source :Development
Plan
Consumer
Drinking
Bathing
Cooking
Washing of Utensils
Water
requirement
(l/c/d)
5
55
5
10
10
Washing of clothes
20
Flushing of toilets
30
Total
135
Water requirement
(l/c/d)
25 35
20 25
5 15
10 15
15 25
Design Parameters
The following simple formula may be
applied to arrive at the quantity of
rainwater collected:
Quantity of water = Cat c h m e n t area
x Run-off x Rainfall
For example :(a)
If a roof area is 10 m long and
8 m wide and rainfall is equal to 102 cm
per annum.
Quantity of Rainfall =10 x 8 x 102 x
1000
100
=
81,600 litres per annum
For the rural household with average
number of livestock assumed above this
is just is enough.
Challenges:
Small plots and due to hilly terrain
the RWHT of higher plot often start
seeping ,this seepage travels to the
adjacent structures on lower slope.
It weakens the structures as the
seepage often travels through
the retaining walls thereby
causing danger of them yielding in
during rainy season.
Suggestions:
Thorough monitoring concerned TCP providing guidelines for proper construction of
RWHT .
PVC tanks could be used instead of in-situ construction.
Location of RWHT on the site plan should check to avoid close proximity to any
structural elements.
Observations
The region is entirely mountainous covered with green vegetation.
Villages are mostly located on hilltops. It receives a rainfall of
about 1050 mm annually.
Run-off is rapid carrying with it top soil. People have tendency to
dispose off solid waste near drains leading to pollution of
streams.
Suggestions
Clean up animal waste, grass clippings and fallen leaves
from your property regularly.
Source :Development
Plan
Observations
Land
Land Use
Density
9 persons per hectare for the revised Kasauli
Planning Area.
The proposed gross density of urbanisable area
is envisaged as 27 persons per hectare and the net
residential density for urbanisable area as
49 persons per hectare.
Land
Land suitability based on development
constraints / natural resources / vulnerable/
sensitive areas
Density
9 persons per hectare for the revised
Kasauli Planning Area.
The proposed net residential density for
urbanisable area as 49 persons per hectare.
Transportation
Roads and streets are not capable to cater for the traffic volume, which has
increased manifold during the last few years..
Lack of adequate parking facilities forther creates a problem. National Highway-22
passes through the South-Eastern periphery of the Planning Area.
There is major congestion and traffic jam in Garkhal Bazar .
Two major accesses to Kasauli emanate from it from Parwanoo and Dharampur.
In between Chandigarh and Kasauli, there are two major bottlenecks at Kalka and
Pinjore which adversely affect the tourist flow.
Lack of parking facilities in Kasauli town during peak tourist season .
There are nine other important roads of widths ranging from5.0 Metre to 10.67
Metre running through the Planning Area.
Components of Plan
- Indicators
Social Infrastructure
Education
Health
Work Recreation Facilities
Police Station
Post offices
Religious Facilities
Urban Form
Place making and Imagability
Built Heritage
Monuments
Colonial heritage
Natural Resources
Water bodies
Ground water aquifers
Natural drainage
Hills /Ridges
Biodiversity including
areas
forest/green
Social Infrastructure
EDUCATIONAL FACILITIES
Education and healthcare available have
direct bearing on the quality of life of a
town or city. Present situation is
discussed with relevance to the aims as
defined in the development plan. There is
insufficient discussion in the development
plan Kasaulii about the status of
education .It may be prudent to mention
the
recommended
standards
for
educational institutions and analyse the
current situation
Standards for educational provision by population threshold
Population
threshold
Student
strength
Nursery school
Primary school
Senior secondary school
College
2500
5000
7500
125000
500
500
1000
1000-1500
(Source: UDPFI
There are were 11 Primary Schools ,One Middle School is at Jagjitnagar,3 Senior Secondary in Kasauli
Planning Area during plan formulation period. Presently there are about 12 primary schools in KPA, 6 Middle
schools, 4 senior secondary schools here.
In hill towns due to lower densities Standards of UDPFI for number of schools on the basis of population is
inadequate parameter , therefore safe walking distance should be considered.
Social Infrastructure
Standards for educational provision by walking distances
Type of education
Nursery
Primary
Middle school
Secondary
College
University
Suggested walking
distance in kms
Population
threshold
0.4
0.4 0.6
0.54 1.61
0.54 1.61
-
(metro cities)
750 -1000
3500 - 5000
6000 - 8000
12000 - 15000
> 150000
>500000
Population threshold
Sl
1
2
3
4
Observations
There are sufficient number of government
schools in KPA.
Enrolment in primary and middle schools
is far below their carrying capacity.
Improvement in quality of education and
image building of government schools is
required to be done.
People shy away from sending their kids to
government schools.
Children have to walk on average 2.5 Km to
reach school, which is because of not getting
sufficient threshold population in hill towns
for providing facilities.
Source: K.V.Sundaram Urban and Regional planning in India, Delhi Vikas, 1977
List of some Middle -Schools
Sl.No.
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
Name Of School
GPS Sanawar
GPS Garkhal
GPS Kasauli
GPS Dharampur
GPS Chamian
GPS Banjini
GPS Shadyana
GPS Sanawar Gaon
GPS Kasauli
GPS Jagjitnagar
GPS Gaunguri
GPS Sanwara
Total
Enrolment
33
60
39
191
50
26
5
29
28
86
31
40
647
Sl.No.
1
2
3
4
6
Name Of School
GMS Jagjit nagar
GMS Kasauli Gaon
GMS Sanawar
GMS Kasauli
GMS Chamian
Enrolment
86
33
139
74
143
Total
475
School Name
Lawrence School,
Pinegrove School,
Saraswati Niketan School,
St. Mary's Convent School,
Name Of School
Number of Boys
1
2
3
GSSS Chamian
GSSS Kasauli
GSSS Sanawar
159
126
50
Number of
Girls
178
119
73
Number of
Students
337
245
123
Social Infrastructure
Health Facilities
There are adequate number of Primary Health
Centres, Community Health Centre, Health
Sub-Centres and Ayurvedic Dispensary in
KPA. The Military Hospital in Cantonment
Area is also serving the local residents.
Planning Area also has a few specialized
medical institutions namely a Leprosy Hospital
and a Sanatorium, which serve the regional
population.
Few suggestions
Local residents find inadequate facilities in
case of some big ailments.
Inadequate public transport available and long
time taken for such health check ups hampers
day to day activities of the residents.
Upgradation of existing facilities .
Fire Station
One fire station, owned by Military
Engineering Service,
There are occurence of fire usually
during summers in the forest area .
Components of Plan
Inclusivity
- Indicators
Marginalized Groups
Slums
Urban Poor
Informal Sector
Population with special needs
Children, Youth, Women , Single
Parents, Senior citizens, Disabled
Population
Equity
Distribution of housing supply
Provision of access to infrastructure &
services
Inclusivity
Equity
Reservation for Economic Weaker Section
Built Heritage
Heritage has been taken as a separate chapter .The
plan talks about colonial heritage as a memoir of past
and its present day Value .It reiterates Importance of
heritage for present day calm quiet environs that
attract tourists.
Natural Resources
The town as well as the planning area boasts of rich flora and fauna.
Kasauli Hills are covered with conifers and many varieties of coniferous or
deciduous trees. A variety of this species Pine White Leafed Oak ,Silver Oak fir
,Deodar,etc
Governance -
Indicators
Phasing
Plan Approvals
Responsibility/ Accountability
Stakeholders Participation
Financial Development
Investment Plan
PHASING
Implementation of Development Plan is divided into three phases, coinciding with five year plans namely:
(i) 2009 -2012
(ii) 2012-2017
(iii) 2017-2021
IMPLEMENTATION
Execution of the Development Plan has to be ensured
by Land Pooling and Reconstitution Mechanism by
coordinated
efforts
of
the
landowners,
Development Authority, Revenue Department,
Panchayats and
Infrastructural Departments.
Overall control and monitoring of implementation of
proposals of development in terms of land use zoning
and regulatory mechanism shall be vested with the
Town and Country Planning Department.
Financial development
Costing
The plan further says that the cost of infrastructure
will be borne by the land owners through mechanism
of land pooling and plot reconstitution.
Conclusion
The Development Plan needs to elaborate on various issues.
Economy and Housing have not been dealt with, in it .
Estimates for arriving at proposed land use are based on
UDPFI and Delhi Master plan.
Public participation
would lend a better
accountability and
transparency to plan
document. Not only
this it will sensitize
the masses about the
future
challenges
that urban areas are
to face and will lead
to their effective
participation.
References
1. Development Plan Kasauli
2. Alternative Approach to Master Plan......MOUD
3. Action Plan for implementation of
management......Government t of Himachal Pradesh
4.Total sanitation Campaign In Himachal Pradesh
5. Census CD TCP Solan
6.GIS Kasauli
solid
and
liquid
waste