Maylasian Airline MH370: Investor
Maylasian Airline MH370: Investor
Maylasian Airline MH370: Investor
4. Missile Guidance
5. Electronic Warfare
6. Identification, friend or foe (IFF)
Freescales shareholders include the Carlyle Group of private equity investors
whose past advisers have included ex-US president George Bush Sr and former
British Prime Minister John Major.
Carlyles previous heavyweight clients include the Saudi Binladin Group, the
construction firm owned by the family of Osama bin Laden.
The fact that Freescale had so many highly qualified staff on board the Boeing 777
had already prompted wild conspiracy theories about what might have happened.
The company says they were flying to China to improve its consumer products
operations, but Freescales fresh links to electronic warfare technology is likely to
trigger more speculation and deepen the mystery.
Experts have been baffled how a large passenger jet seems to have flown
undetected and possibly beaten military radar systems for up to six hours.
Avoiding radar via cloaking technology has long been one of the objectives of
the defense industry and Freescale has been active developing chips for military
radar.
On its website, the company says its radio frequency products meet the
requirements for applications in avionics, radar, communications, missile
guidance, electronic warfare and identification friend or foe.
Last June it announced it was creating a team of specialists dedicated to
producing radio frequency power products for the defense industry.
And on March 3, it announced it was releasing 11 of these new gadgets for use in
high frequency, VHF and low-band UHF radar and radio communications.
The company did not respond to questions from Express Online, including whether
any of its missing employees had been working on the defense products.
It neither provided any responses to the latest bizarre conspiracy theory being
widely published on the comments sections of newspaper websites and other
internet forums.
The comment reads: It reads: Have you pieced together the puzzle of missing
flight 370 to Beijing China? If not, here are your missing pieces.
Four days after the flight MH370 disappear, semiconductor patent was approved
by the U.S. patent office patent is divided in parts of 20% between five starters.
One of the owners is the company itself, Freescale Semiconductor, Austin, Texas
(USA), and the other four Chinese employees of the company: Peidong Wang,
Zhijun Chen, Cheng and Li Ying Zhijong, all the Suzhou City. And they all
passengers of Malaysia Airlines plane disappeared on March 8, according Eternity.
It adds: Here is your motive for the missing Beijing plane. As all four Chinese
members of the Patent were passengers on the missing plane.
Patent holders can alter the proceeds legally by passing wealth to their heirs.
However, they cannot do so until the Patent is approved. So when the plane went
missing, the patent had not been approved.
However, the theory does not add up.
Although a Freescale patent does exist under number US8650327, none of the
names listed actually appear on the passenger manifest released by the
Malaysian authorities. ( But maybe the names have been removed from the flight
manifest)
If the patent holder dies, the other owners share equally in dividends from the
deceased. If four of the five patentees die, then the patentee left alive gets 100%
of the patent. That remaining patent holder is the company Freescale
Semiconductor. Who owns Freescale Semiconductor?
The answer is: Jacob Rothschild
(You can read the complete history of the House of Rothschild HERE).
British billionaire owns the company Blackstone, which in turn owns the company
20FreescaleSemiconductorEmployeesWhatweretheydoing?Whobenefits?Updated
15Apr201404:42
WrittenbyKerryCassidy
Iwassittingaroundchattingwithafriendanddiscussingtheunlikelyeventthatisthedisappearanceof
Flight370.Whenwedecidedtofollowthetrailofthevariousclueswherenooneappearstobe
looking.
Forexample,if20employeesofthesamecompanyallwentaboardthesameplane,assumingatleast
severalmayhavebeenashasbeenreported,possiblypatentholders.Thenwhenexactlydidtheybuy
theirtickets?Onemightaskwhenall20employeesboughtticketstoflydirecttoChina?Andif,the
illuminati(specificallyRothschild)whoownsFreescaleSemiconductor,didnothavethenecessary
timetoadequatelycreateanalibiforlet'ssay,aplanneddisappearanceandredirectingoftheplaneto
DiegoGarcia...Itwouldbeinterestingtowonderif:
1.The20employeesallboughtticketsaroundthesametime...evenlastminute.
2.The20employees(orevensaysomeofthem)mighthavebeenplanningsomething..saya'walk
out"orpossiblybandingtogethertodelivertopsecretplanstotheChinesefortherecentcontroller
chip(KLO2)thattheyjustreleased.
3.Orwereall20employees,mindcontrolledanddirectedtoallboardthesameplane,contraryto
prudenceofatopchipmanufacturerputtingtheirbestandbrightestallononeplane.Notawisemove.
Unlessthoseemployeeswerebeing"directed"todoso...
Itseemsclearafterevaluatingtheclueswehavesofarthatthisoperationwasnotwellplannedand
perhapshadtobepulledtogetheratthelastminute.
Iwouldbewillingforexample,tobetthatthetwosocalledsupposedterroristswhoboardedwithfake
passports,boughtlastminutetickets.Theyseemedtobepartofaverylastminutepoorlyconstructed
alibiforthedisappearanceofaplanethatcouldnot,wouldnot,mustnotatallcosts,reachits
destination...China.
Itseemsnooneislookingatthisscenariocloselyenoughtobeabletoseethatthissocalledfalseflag
doesnotseemtohavebeenplannedinadvance.Instead,itseemsthattheplanewastakenoffcourse
becausenewsofeitherwhatitcarried,whattheemployeeswerecarryingorwhatwasonboard,could
notbeallowedtoreachitsdestination.
Weneedtodeterminewhatitwasthatthe20Freescaleemployeeswerecarryingthatwhoever
engineeredthisstealthkidnapping,didnotwanttoreachtheChinese.Thismuchseemsclear.
ItseemsthattheVERYPUBLICDISAPPEARANCEofacommercialjetwith239peoplewouldhave
toeitherbe:
1.Apurposefulshowof"strength"andtechniquedisplayedasamessagegovernmenttogovernment,
whetherAmericanstoChineseorRussiansorIsraeli...setoutattheexpenseofthoseonboard.
2.OritwastheresultofanunexpectedlastminuterevealtothoseinchargeofFreescalethat
somethingwasgoingonboardalongwiththose20employees.
Theseeminglycoincidentalnatureofthefactthatyouhaveacompany(Freescale)thatdealswith:
1.Stealthtechnology
2.Hasjustamonthbeforereleasedtheirlatestcontrollerchip"thesizeofadimpleonagolfball"
cannotbesimply"acoincidence".Asidefromthefactthattherearenocoincidences..Everything
playsaparthoweverinsignificant...leadsonetowanttoinvestigatefurtherintoexactlywhatthis
"controllerchip"iscapableof...andwhether,revealingthetechnologybehindsuchachipisenoughto
riskthepublicdisfavorandagrandstandingmanueverofsuchapparentdisdainforthelivesofthe
innocentsonboard.ItwouldseemthatatleastsomeoftheFreescaleemployeesonboardwerenotso
innocent.
IsthischipasortofminiSKYNETcommandandcontrolcentralizerforrunningwhoknowswhat
amountofsoftware/hardwareatwhatdistance.Thisisanexampleofaquestionthatmightbeasked.
InarecentRenseradioshow,TimRifat,occultmagicianandresearcher,mentionedthepossibilitythat
thehijackingwasinordertogetholdofsay,the12ChineseFreescaleemployeeswhomightbewhatis
calledSUPERUSERS...inordertohookthemuptoanAIundercommandandmindcontrolandget
themtocontrolsay,Putin,inordertochangethetrajectoryoftheUkrainesituation.Butthisseems
while,verytantalizinglyscifi(andquitealongthelinesoftheupcomingJohnnyDeppmovie
TRANSCENDENCE)...lessthanaccurate.Theverypublicdisplayofdisappearingawholecommercial
jetof239peopleintheprocessseemslikeoverkill.Rather,ifalltheywantedtodowaskidnapand
controlahighleveltechie,orseveralofthem...thentheycouldquiteeasilydothatanytime.They
wouldn'thavetodoitpubliclyandwithall20fromthesamecompanyinplaindaylightontheworld
stage.
Whatismuchmorelikelyisthatthisplanecontaining20employeesofthesamecompanywasheaded
directlytoChinawithsomethingonboardthattheyweregoingtoDELIVER.Onemustask,whenthe
dustsettlesandwhatyouhaveisquestionssuchas:
1.Whythisparticularplane?
2.Doeswhereitwasheadedhaveanythingtodowithwhyitwastaken?
3.Whywere20employeesofacompanyspecializinginstealthtechnologythathadjustreleaseda
worldclasschiponthescenedisappeared?
4.IsitpossibletheemployeesofFreescalehadbandedtogetherandfiguredoutsomethingkeyabout
whattheyweredealingwith?OrweretheymadeanoffertheycouldnotrefusebytheChinese?
5.AsreferencedbymyinterviewwithFieldMcConnellandDavidHawkins,wasitacoincidencethat
MichelleObamawasinahotelinthesamecitywheretheplanewassupposedtobeheaded?Could
shehavebeenthereto"brokeradeal"?Didshefail?
Thesearejustsomeoftheimportantquestionspeopleandespeciallyrealjournalistsshouldbeasking.
ItisalsoimportanttonotethatmyinterviewwithMikeHarris,radiotalkshowhostandformer
contractortotopexecutivesatMotorolawhenFreescaleSemiconductorwaspartofit,wastoldtoshut
up,justafterhisinterviewwithme.Thatinterviewhasbeenverywidelyviewed.WhatisitMike
knowsrelatedtothehistoryofFreescalethatwouldbesoimportantthattheCIAwouldwanttosilence
him,nodoubt,intheinterestof"nationalsecurity"?
ADDENDUMTOARTICLE:
AccordingtoasourcetheIsraelistooktheplaneinordertostealthecontrollerchipbecausethey
needitinawaragainstIran.Paraphrasing,imagineamissilethatdeliversdromesassmallasinsects
thatflyorcrawl,andhavedeadlycapabilities,theycanclimbintotheventilationsystemandkill
everyoneattheIraniannukefacilities.
Perhaps,anIsraelifantasy(warwithIran)however,isthistherealreasonbehindtheabductionofthe
aircraftanditspassengers?
Itisalsosignificantthatthenewchip(amicrocontroller)alsocalledtheKLO2releasedintothepublic
domaininFebruarybyFreescalecanturnahumanintoacomputerWhichsoundsremarkablyuseful
forcontrollingandmanipulatingandroids(ahumanlookingrobot)
http://www.wired.com/2013/02/freescalestinyarmchip/
TheSKYNET,terminatoraspectsofthisstoryseemtobeexpanding.
ItwouldseemactuallythatIsraelisalreadydeeplyinvolvedinFreescaleandwouldhavenoneedto
abductajetwiththeirownemployees.FreescalehasanIsraelioffice.
ItwouldalsobesuicideforIsraeltoattackIranevenwithU.S.help.BecauseultimatelytheIsraeli
peoplewouldbetheonestosufferThecountryissotinythatitwouldtakeverylittletowipeitoff
themap.SowhyblamethedisappearanceofthejetonIsrael?Thissoundslikeaconvenient
misdirect.
WhatismorelikelyisthattheU.S.andIsrael(andtheUK)conductedajointoperationredirectingthe
flightusingtheBoeingnoninterruptibleautopilottoDiegoGarcia.TheemployeesofFreescaleare
likelytohavebeenputbacktowork(albeitasprisoners)inanundergroundbase(underDiegoGarcia)
orperhapsatanotherlocation.
Itseemsunavoidabletoconcludethatthetechnology(whetherpatentholdersornot)asabraintrust
viatheemployeesonthatplaneoractualspecsorothersignificantcomponentsmusthavebeenonthat
plane.
ThefalseflaguseofFlight370doesnotholdupsimplybecausetheycanuseANYplaneforthe
purposeofafalseflagandwouldnthavetogotoallthetroubletoabduct239peopleonacommercial
jetintheprocess.
Onehastoask,whythatjet,whyonthatparticulardateandwhyonethathasthatnumberof
employeesallfromthesamecompanyThisisthedirectionthatalegitimateinquiryshouldgo.
Indeed,themostobviousmotivewouldappeartobesomethingthattheU.S./IsraelandtheUKdidnot
wanttogetintothehandsoftheChinese.
http://projectcamelotportal.com/blog/31-kerrys-blog/2084-20-freescalesemiconductor-employees-what-were-they-doing
DrugsandWar
Whyaren'tweputtingUSagenciesontrialforfinancingElChapo'sdrugwar?
FromCaponetoMexico'scapturedcocaineking,thevillainswelovetohateobscurethetruthabout
America'ssecretsupport
o
GabrielMatthewSchivone
theguardian.com,Thursday10April201415.14BST
"ThisAmericansystemofours,"shoutedthefamedgangsterAlCaponeina1930interview."Callit
Capitalism,callitwhatyoulikegivestoeachandeveryoneofusagreatopportunityifweonlyseize
itwithbothhandsandmakethemostofit."
Sincethoseuntouchabledays,Chicagoofficialshaveawarded"PublicEnemyNo1"statustoonlyone
otherperson:cartelbillionaireJoaqunGuzmnLoera,betterknownnowtotheworldoveras"El
Chapo".
Nearlysevenweeksago,ofcourse,ElChapowascapturedbyUSandMexicanauthoritiesafter13
yearsonthelam.HavingachievedaculturalstatureakintothatofaBondvillain,hiscapturenaturally
gotallthelimelightwhilehisUSbackerswentmoreorlessunmentioned.
Butnearlysevenweeksbeforeanovernightcaptureatabeachresort,theMexicannewspaperEl
UniversalreportedhowUSagencieshadarmedandfinancedElChapo'sSinaloacriminalempireforat
least12years.ThatlinkhasbeensubstantiatedbyDEAandJusticeDepartmentcourttestimonies,and
evenUSagentsconfirmedthefinancinghadbeenapprovedbyhighrankingofficialsandfederal
prosecutors.ButtheAmericanmediabarelyreportedhowentrenchedtheAmericangovernmenthas
becomeintheMexicandrugtrade.
Instead,wegotphotosofagentsleadingashackledGuzman,hisheadbowedbyoneofthemarines'
glovedhandsgrippinghisneck,towardaUSBlackhawkhelicopterthatwouldshuttlehimofftoa
highsecurityprison.
"Thechoiceofnewsorganizationstonotmaketheconnectionreflectsachoice[of]whatmediawould
likeforustorememberandwouldlikeforustoforget,"saidCrystalVanceGuerra,aLatinAmerican
studiesscholarattheNationalAutonomousUniversityofMexico.Sheasked:Whydon'tweholdthese
agentsandagenciestothesamejudgmentasorganizedcrime?
Aswewaitforthebiggestgangstertrialinyears,why,indeed,aren'tweputtingAmericanintelligence
anddrugagenciesontrialforfinancingadrugwar?
Thelatestinstalmentofthe"warondrugs"haskilled100,000peoplesinceitsofficialdeclarationby
MexicanPresidentFilipeCalderonandUSPresidentGeorgeWBushin2006.Duringthisperiod,the
USElChapopartnershipwasreportedlynevercloser:underthedeal,WashingtonallowedElChapo's
SinaloacarteltocarryonbusinessasusualwhiletopSinaolamembers,fortheirpart,provided
informationontheirrivals.DEAagentsmetwiththeirinformantsmorethan50times,ElUniversal
reported,astheagentsofferedtheirwhisperersimmunity.
AmericanpatronagegoeswellbeyondstokingthelargestandmostpowerfuloftheMexicancartels
(Sinaloa),aswellasthemostheinous(GolfoandLosZetas).TheUSalsoopenlyarmedandfinanced
evenbiggerplayersinthisgameMexico'sstateandsecurityforces.JustastheUSElChapo
relationshipwasatitsclosest,theBushadministrationsignedintolawtheMeridaInitiative,ahuge
militarizationpackagetoMexicounderthe"warondrugs"Between2008and2012,PresidentObama
increasedsecurityaidundertheplanforhelicopters,armoredvehicles,surveillanceequipmentand
policetrainingprogramstotalling$1.9bn.
AsUSauthoritiessurelyknewbythistime,appearancesweredeceivingonMexico'scounternarcotics
battlefield,awashwithstockpilesofAmericangunsandmoney.Drugarrestsofcartelassociates
amountedtolessthan2%ofover50,000arrestsmadeinthefirstfouryearsoftheBushCalderon
partnership.AsunflaggingMexicanjournalistAnabelHernandezshowedinher2013book,
Narcoland,Mexico'sgovernmentwasn'tfightingtostopadrugtradeindustryitwerefightingfor
whattheindustryhadtooffer.Shatteringpopularmisconceptionsaboutthedrugwars,Hernandez
concluded:
[T]hebiggestdangerisnotinfactthedrugcartels,butratherthegovernmentandbusinessofficialsthat
workforthemandfearexposure.
TheUSplayedaleadingroleincreatingthecartelundergroundinthefirstplace.JointUSMexican
militaryforcescarriedoutbrutalscorchedearthincursionsinMexicoasearlyas1976,ostensibly
targetingsmall,ruralpoppyandmarijuanafarmersbutactuallydestroyingmostlypoorcommunities
caughtinthemiddle.Thisenforcementbasedapproachhardenedfarmersintoreactionaryelements
thatrelocatedtomajorcitiesandeventuallyformedthefederatedSinaloaledcartels.
TheAmericanmademonstermodeleditselfoffitscreator.Today,moreandmoredrugcarteltycoons
areinvestingin"legitimate"businessenterprisesexpandedbyUSbasedfreetrade.InMexicoalone,
freetradeagreementsmandatedafloodofUSagribusinessimportsthatdisplaced2.3mjobsinthe
agriculturalsector;theaveragewagedroppedseverelywhilethecommercialsectorandtheinformal
economygrewexponentially.
Whileactorsbothsmalltime(cartel)andbigtime(governmentandcorporate)claimto"makethe
most"oftheAmericandream,thosewhoendupsufferingthemostarethepoor,womenand
undocumentedmigrantsinMexico,CentralAmericaandtheUS.Theamalgamationofthecriminal
ringthatenrichedElChapowithUSbusinessintereststhereforeshowscapitalismatitsworst:arace
forwealthfreeofmoralorethicalconsiderations.
Officially,ElChapo'sjudgmentsarecurrentlyunderwayinChicago,becausetheauthoritiesthere
believetheyhavethestrongestcasetoextraditetheformerpublicenemyfortrial.Thegovernmentof
Mexico,however,willnotconsiderextraditiontotheUSwithoutfirsttryingElChapoinMexican
courts.
Butwhenthetimecomes,shouldn'tElChapo'sUSbackersthehighrankingUSofficialsresponsible
forincitinganddirectingcartelviolencefaceprosecution,too?
Wehavelongglamorizedthelivesofhighprofilecriminals,ineverythingfromcivilralliestopopular
TVshowstoentiremusicalgenres.Cartelsarethepublicdemonsomanyofuslovetohate.Buta
publicfocusonthemessentiallydeflectsattentionfromthewayinwhichotherplayersliketheUS
governmentarenotonlycomplicit,butevenruntheshow.
AsthefilmmakerGuillermoDelToroGmezonceobserved,"Youcanhaveamaincharacterbethe
hero,butalmostinvariablythestarisgoingtobethevillain."Hecouldeasilyhavebeentalkingabout
thelargerthanlifemediadepictionsofAlCaponeinthe1930s.OrthemediafrenzyaroundElChapo
Guzman.
http://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2014/apr/10/usagenciesfinancingelchapodrugwar#
UScomplicitinSouthAmericadrugtrade
ByDr.DylanMurphy
ThisfailureonthebehalfoftheUSgovernmenttoreallycrackdownonthefinancesofthedrugcartels
extendstoBritishbanksaswell.InJuly2012theUSSenateCommitteeonHomelandSecurityand
GovernmentalAffairsissueda339pagereportdetailinganamazingcatalogueof''criminal''behavior
byLondonbasedHSBC.
Mexicoisinthegripofamurderousdrugwarthathaskilledover150,000peoplesince2006.Itisone
ofthemostviolentcountriesonearth.Thisdrugwarisaproductofthetransnationaldrugtradewhich
isworthuptoUSD400billionayearandaccountsforabout8%ofallinternationaltrade.
TheAmericangovernmentmaintainsthatthereisnoalternativebuttovigorouslyprosecutetheirzero
tolerancepolicyofarrestingdrugusersandtheirdealers.Thishasledtotheincarcerationofover
500,000Americans.MeanwhilethefloodofillegaldrugsintoAmericacontinuesunabated.
OnethingtheAmericangovernmenthasnotdoneistoprosecutethelargestbanksintheworldfor
supportingthedrugcartelsbywashingbillionsofdollarsoftheirbloodstainedmoney.AsNarco
spherejournalistBillConroyhasobservedbanksare''wherethemoneyis''intheglobaldrugwar.
HSBC,WesternUnion,BankofAmerica,JPMorganChase&Co,Citigroup,Wachoviaamongstmany
othershaveallegedlyfailedtocomplywithAmericanantimoneylaundering(AML)laws.
TheMexicandrugcartelshavecaughttheheadlinesagainandagainduetotheirmurderousactivities.
Thewarbetweenthedifferentdrugcartelsandthewarbetweenthecartelsandgovernmentsecurity
forceshasspilledthebloodoftensofthousandsofinnocentpeople.Thedrugcartelswouldfindit
muchhardertoprofitfromtheirmurderousactivityiftheydidn'thavetoobigtofailbankswillingto
washtheirdirtymoney.
InMarch2010WachoviacutadealwiththeUSgovernmentwhichinvolvedthebankbeinggiven
finesofUSD160millionundera''deferredprosecution''agreement.ThiswasduetoWachovia'sheavy
involvementinmoneylaunderingmovinguptoUSD378.4billionoverseveralyears.Notonebanker
wasprosecutedforillegalinvolvementinthedrugstrade.Meanwhilesmalltimedrugdealersandusers
gotoprison.
Ifanymemberofthepubliciscaughtinpossessionofafewgramsofcokeorheroinyoucanbetyour
bottomdollartheywillbegoingdowntoservesomehardtime.However,ifyouareabankstercaught
launderingbillionsofdollarsforsomeofthemostmurderouspeopleontheplanetyougetoffwitha
slaponthewristintheformofsomepunyfineandadeferredprosecutiondeal.
CharlesA.Intriago,presidentoftheMiamibasedAssociationofCertifiedFinancialCrimeSpecialists
hasobserved,Ifyoureanindividual,andgetcaught,yougethammered.
Butifyoureabigbank,andyourecaughtmovingmoneyforaterroristordrugdealer,youdont
havetoworry.Youjustforkoveramonetarypenalty,andthenraiseyourfeestomakeupforit.
Untilweseebankerswalkingoffinhandcuffstofacechargesinthesecases,nothingisgoingto
change,Intriagoadds.Thesemonetarypenaltiesarejustacostofdoingbusinesstothem,likepaying
foranewcorporatejet.
ThisfailureonthebehalfoftheUSgovernmenttoreallycrackdownonthefinancesofthedrugcartels
extendstoBritishbanksaswell.InJuly2012theUSSenateCommitteeonHomelandSecurityand
GovernmentalAffairsissueda339pagereportdetailinganamazingcatalogueof''criminal''behavior
byLondonbasedHSBC.
ThisincludeswashingoverUSD881fortheMexicanSinaloaCartelandfortheNortedelValleCartel
inColombia.Besidesthis,HSBCaffiliatedbankssuchasHBUSrepeatedlybrokeAmericanAML
lawsbytheirlongstandingandsevereAMLdeficiencieswhichallowedSaudibankssuchasAlRajhi
tofinanceterroristgroupsthatincludedAlQaeda.HBUStheAmericanaffiliateofHSBCsuppliedAl
RajhibankwithnearlyUSD1billion.
JackBlumanattorneyandformerSenateinvestigatorhascommented,Theyviolatedeverygoddamn
lawinthebook.Theytookeveryimaginableformofillegalandillicitbusiness.
HSBCaffiliateHBUSwasrepeatedlyinstructedtoimproveitsantimoneylaunderingprogram.In
2003theFederalReserveBankofNewYorktookenforcementactionthatcalleduponHBUSto
improveitsantimoneylaunderingprogram.
InSeptember2010theOfficeofComptrolleroftheCurrency(OCC)senta''blisteringsupervisory
letter''toHBUSlistingnumerousAMLproblemsatthebank.InOctober2010thiswasfollowedup
withtheOCCissuingaceaseanddesistorderrequiringHBUStoimproveitsAMLprogramasecond
time.
SenatorCarlLevinchairmanoftheSenateinvestigationintoHSBChascommentedthat''HSBCs
ChiefComplianceOfficerandotherseniorexecutivesinLondonknewwhatwasgoingon,butallowed
thedeceptiveconducttocontinue.''
LetuslookatjustacoupleofthedevastatingfindingsintheSenatereport.Themainfocusofthe
reportisthemultiplefailuresofHSBCtocomplywithAMLlawsandregulations:
''Theidentifiedproblemsincludedaoncemassivebacklogofover17,000alertsidentifyingpossible
suspiciousactivitythathadyettobereviewed;ineffectivemethodsforidentifyingsuspiciousactivity;
afailuretofiletimelySuspiciousActivityReportswithUSlawenforcement;...a3yearfailureby
HBUS[aHSBCaffiliate],frommid2006tomid2009,toconductanyAMLmonitoringofUSD15
billioninbulkcashtransactions...afailuretomonitorUSD60trillioninannualwiretransferactivity
bycustomers...inadequateandunqualifiedAMLstaffing;inadequateAMLresources;andAML
leadershipproblems.
ThereportcataloguesingreatdetailthefailingsofHSBCaffiliatesHBUSinAmericaandHMEXin
Mexico:
''From2007through2008,HBMXwasthesinglelargestexporterofUSdollarstoHBUS,shipping
USD7billionincashtoHBUSovertwoyears,outstrippinglargerMexicanbanksandotherHSBC
affiliates.MexicanandUSauthoritiesexpressedrepeatedconcernthatHBMXsbulkcashshipments
couldreachthatvolumeonlyiftheyincludedillegaldrugproceeds.Theconcernwasthatdrug
traffickersunabletodepositlargeamountsofcashinUSbanksduetoAMLcontrolsweretransporting
USdollarstoMexico,arrangingforbulkdepositsthere,andthenusingMexicanfinancialinstitutions
toinsertthecashbackintotheUSfinancialsystem....highprofileclientsinvolvedindrugtrafficking;
millionsofdollarsinsuspiciousbulktravelerschequetransactions;inadequatestaffingandresources;
andahugebacklogofaccountsmarkedforclosureduetosuspiciousactivity,butwhoseclosureswere
delayed.''
IntheSenatehearingonJuly17,2012CarlLevinChairmanoftheCommitteeonHomelandSecurity
andGovernmentalAffairsexplainedhowHMEXhelpedtheMexicandrugcartels:
''BecauseourtoughAMLlawsintheUnitedStateshavemadeithardfordrugcartelstofindaUSbank
willingtoaccepthugeunexplaineddepositsofcash,theynowsmuggleUSdollarsacrosstheborder
intoMexicoandlookforaMexicanbankorcasadecambiowillingtotakethecash.Someofthose
casasdecambioshadaccountsatHBMX.HBMX,inturn,tookallthephysicaldollarsitgotand
transportedthembyarmoredcaroraircraftbackacrossthebordertoHBUSfordepositintoitsUS
banknotesaccount,completingthelaunderingcycle.''
SenatorLevinwentontonotehow:''Overtwoyears,from2007to2008,HBMXshipped7billionin
physicalUSdollarstoHBUS.Thatwasmorethananyother
Mexicanbank,evenonetwiceHBMXssize.WhenlawenforcementandbankregulatorsinMexico
andtheUnitedStatesgotwindofthebanknotestransactions,theywarnedHBMXandHBUSthatsuch
largedollarvolumeswereredflagsfordrugproceedsmovingthroughtheHSBCnetwork.''
InDecember2012theDepartmentofJusticecutadealwithHSBCwhichimposedarecordUSD1.9
billiondollarfine.Itmaysoundalottoordinaryfolksbutitisatinyfractionofitsannualprofitswhich
in2011totaledUSD22billion.AssistantAttorneyGeneralLannyBauerannouncedthesettlementata
pressconferenceon11December2012.
HiscommentsrevealwhytheUSgovernmentdecidedtogosoftonsuchcriminalbehaviorandshow
quiteclearlyhowthereisonelawfortherichest1%andonelawfortherestofus.LennyBauersaid:
''HadtheUSauthoritiesdecidedtopresscriminalcharges,HSBCwouldalmostcertainlyhavelostits
bankinglicenseintheUS,thefutureoftheinstitutionwouldhavebeenunderthreatandtheentire
bankingsystemwouldhavebeendestabilized.''
Thinkaboutthatstatementforamoment.Abankthathasquiteclearlybeencaughtouthelping
murderousdrugcriminals,terroristgroups,thirdworlddictatorshipsandallsortsofcriminalcharacters
istobeletoffwithaslaponthewrist.
Nocriminalprosecutionsorevenamentionofcriminalbehaviorduetothefearsthattodosowould
puttheworldeconomyinjeopardy.Sothereyouhaveit.Banksterswhoengageinsuchbehaviorthat
isregardedascriminalbythevastmajorityofpeopleontheplanetarenotonlytoobigtofailtheyare
alsotoobigtojail.
AftertheDepartmentofJusticeannouncementofthedeferredprosecutionHSBCChiefExecutive
StuartGulliversaid,"Weacceptresponsibilityforourpastmistakes.Wehavesaidweareprofoundly
sorryforthem,andwedosoagain.''
Suchstatementswillprovidelittlesolacetothefamiliesofthe150,000peopleestimatedbyUS
SecretaryofDefenseLeonPanettatohavebeenkilledinMexico'sdrugwar.Norwillithelpthe
hundredsofthousandsofMexicancitizenswhohavebeenforcedtofleetheirhomesandescapethe
violencebygoingtotheUnitedSatesormovingtootherpartsofMexico.
SenatorElizabethWarrenappearingatameetingoftheSenateBankingCommitteeinFebruary
expressedfrustrationwithofficialsfromtheUSTreasuryDepartmentandUSFederalReserveoverthe
issueofwhycriminalchargeswerenotpressedonHSBCoranyofitsofficials.Theofficialswere
evasivewhenshetriedtodrawthemontheissueofwhatittakesforabanktohaveitslicense
withdrawn:
''HSBCpaidafine,butnooneindividualwenttotrial,noindividualwasbannedfrombanking,and
therewasnohearingtoconsidershuttingdownHSBCsactivitieshereintheUnitedStates.So,what
Idlikeis,youretheexpertsonmoneylaundering.Idlikeanopinion:Whatdoesittakehowmany
billionsdoyouhavetolaunderfordruglordsandhowmanyeconomicsanctionsdoyouhaveto
violatebeforesomeonewillconsidershuttingdownafinancialinstitutionlikethis?''
SenatorWarrenfinishedthesessionbycommentingontheglaringdoublestandardswithintheUS
justicesystem:
Youknow,ifyourecaughtwithanounceofcocaine,thechancesaregoodyouregoingtogotojail.
Ifithappensrepeatedly,youmaygotojailfortherestofyourlife.Butevidently,ifyoulaundernearly
abilliondollarsfordrugcartelsandviolateourinternationalsanctions,yourcompanypaysafineand
yougohomeandsleepinyourownbedatnight,everysingleindividualassociatedwiththis.Ithink
thatsfundamentallywrong.
On4March2013HSBCannouncedprofitsofUSD20.6billionin2012whileitpaidoutaUSD3
millionbonustoitsCEO.ThisoutrageousstateofaffairsbeggarsbeliefafterHSBChasbeenclearly
caughtoutengaginginactivityonbehalfofmurderousdruglords,terroristfinancingbanksandbrutal
thirdworlddictatorships.
WhereistheBritishGovernment'scondemnationofHSBC?Youmaybewaitingalongtimeforthat
consideringthefactthatChancellorGeorgeOsborneandhisfellowministersareintimatelyconnected
totheBritishbankingelite.
Thisgovernmentoftherichrulingonbehalfoftherichwillnevertakeactionofanykindagainstthe
criminalactivityofBritishbanksters.Norwillthecravenmainstreammediaexposetheblatant
hypocrisyofagovernmentwhichwageswaragainstthepoorestsectionsofsocietywhilecompletely
ignoringcriminalactivitybyBritishbanksterswhetheritbeLiborfraudorlaunderingmoneyforsome
ofthemostmurderouspeopleontheplanet.
LongtimeobserveroftheMexicandrugwarBillConroycommentsthatthedealcutwithHSBCby
theDepartmentofJustice,''shouldilluminateforallthegreatpretenseofthedrugwarnomatterhow
hardUSprosecutors,viathemainstreammedia,attempttoconvinceusotherwise....Anditshouldlead
ustoconclude,ifwearehonestwithourselves,thatthesocalleddrugwarislittlemorethanone
immense"drugdeal.''
http://www.presstv.com/detail/2013/06/12/308588/uscomplicitinsamericadrugtrade/
WesterncomplicityinAfghanistanherointradeisoldnews
Coolio
14092010,23:19
U.K.militarypoliceareinvestigatingclaimsthatBritishandCanadiantroopshavebeensmuggling
heroinoutofKandaharaccordingtotheBBConSunday.Well,it'sabouttimebecauseoneoftheworst
keptsecretsinAfghanhistoryisthatWesternershavetheirhandintheCentralAsiandrugtrade,most
notablytheUnitedStatesviatheC.I.A.
Today,Afghanistanisthesourceof90%oftheworld'sopium,amultibilliondollarindustrywhich
fuelstheinsurgencyandisdestabilizingtheregion.Thedrugtradeallowsmilitantstopurchase
weaponswithwhichtheythenattacktheAfghangovernmentandinternationalforces.Whichmakes
Westernculpabilityevenmoremaddening.
YettheC.I.A.hasbeenaccusedofenablingtheexplosionofthedrugtradeintheAfPakregion,
stretchingbacktothe1980swhentheyfundedtheAfghanmujahideenviaPakistan'sspyagencyto
wageaholywaragainstRussia.
Before1979Pakistanwasnotamajorexporterofheroin.In198480%ofallheroinconsumedin
Britainand30%ofU.S.importscamefromPakistanthankstothecollaborationbetweentheC.I.A.
andPakistaniintelligence.AccordingtoAlfredW.McCoyinThePoliticsofHeroin:CIAComplicity
intheGlobalDrugTrade:
"CIAassetsagaincontrolledthisherointrade.AstheMujahideenguerrillasseizedterritoryinside
Afghanistan,theyorderedpeasantstoplantopiumasarevolutionarytax.Acrosstheborderin
Pakistan,AfghanleadersandlocalsyndicatesundertheprotectionofPakistanIntelligenceoperated
hundredsofheroinlaboratories.Duringthisdecadeofwideopendrugdealing,theU.S.Drug
EnforcementAgencyinIslamabadfailedtoinstigatemajorseizuresorarrests."
AccordingtoElizabethGouldandPaulFitzgeraldinInvisibleHistory:AfghanistansUntoldStory,the
drugtradewasfinancedthroughtheBankofCreditandCommerceInternational(BCCI)whichacted
asagobetweenforD.C.,HongKong,PeshawarandSwitzerlandlaunderingdrugmoneyand
facilitatingarmssalestoNicaraguanContrasandAfghanmujahideen.
JackBlum,formerspecialcounseltothe1987KerrySenateForeignRelationsSubcommitteeon
Terrorism,NarcoticsandInternationalRelations,claimedthattheC.I.A.,Mossad,Arabintelligence,
theRussiansandtheBritishalsousedBCCItofinancearmsdealsanddrugsmugglingoperations.
Blumsaid:
Theamountsofheroinwerestaggering,theamountsofmoneyinvolvedwerestaggering.Therewasa
seizureofashipoffthecoastofTurkeythathadcomefromtheMakrancoastofPakistanthathad
twelvetonsmetrictonsofheroinandheroinderivativesonit.Thatissuchastartlinglylarge
number,itssortofliketheworldssupplyforayear.
Duringthe1980stheCIApartneredwiththeSafariClub,whichwasanetworkofforeignintelligence
agenciesformedtohelptheCIAfundoperationsnotauthorizedbyCongress,totransformCentralAsia
fromaselfcontainedopiumzoneintoamajorsupplierofheroinfortheworldmarket.Congressknew
aboutmujahideendrugdealingasearlyas1984butturnedablindeyebecausetheopiumprofitswere
financingtheaforementionedU.S.jihadagainsttheSovietUnion.
By2003,AfghanistansheroinproblemhadgrowntwentytimesworsethanitwasunderTalibanrule
accordingtoareportbyHyRothstein,aSpecialForcesveteranandteacherattheNavalPostgraduate
SchoolinMonterreyCalifornia,whohadbeencommissionedbytheofficeofSpecialOperationsand
LowIntensityConflicttoconductamilitarystudyofwhytheU.S.wasnotmakingprogressin
Afghanistan.AsofyesterdaysBBCreport,sincetheU.S.invasiononOct.7,2001,Afghanistan's
opiumoutputhasincreased33fold.
Ina2007DailyMailpiece,BritainsformerambassadortoUzbekistan,CraigMurray,reportedthat
WesternintelligenceagenicesdirectandindirectlyhelpedAfghanistangofromsimplyfarmingpoppies
toconvertingopiumintoheroinonanindustrialscale.Murraywrote:
Howcanthishavehappened,andonthisscale?Theanswerissimple.Thefourlargestplayersinthe
heroinbusinessareallseniormembersoftheAfghangovernment.Thegovernmentthatoursoldiers
arefightinganddyingtoprotect.
MurrayalsoassertedthatvastamountsofheroincamefromthefiefdomofGeneralAbdulRashid
Dostum,theheadofAfghan'sarmedforces,innorthandeastAfghanistan:
DostumisanUzbek,andtheheroinpassesovertheFriendshipBridgefromAfghanistanto
Uzbekistan,whereitistakenoverbyPresidentIslamKarimov'speople.Itisthenshippedupthe
railwayline,inbalesofcotton,toStPetersburgandRiga.
MurraysappealshavefallenondeafearsbecauseGeneralDostumisvitaltoAfghanPresidentHamid
Karzai'scoalitionandtoWesternpretenseofastable,democraticgovernment.
TheC.I.A.hasprotectedanumberofKarzaicroniesandrelativesinvolvedwiththedrugtrade,
includingSherMohammedAkhunzada,Karzai'sformergovernorinHelmandProvincewhowas
caughtwith9tonsofopiumandheroininhisbasementin2005.Karzaiactuallytriedtoreinstate
Akhunzadain2008tonoavail.ThePresidentsbrother,AhmedWaliKarzai,hasbeenaccusedof
beingoneofthebiggestdruglordsinAfghanistan,buthetooisontheC.I.A.spayroll.
FormerRussianmilitaryCommander,MahmutGareev,claimedtheU.S.wasnotgoingtostopthe
productionofdrugsinAfghanistanbecauseitcoveredthecostsoftheirmilitarypresencethere.
"Actually,they(theUSandNATOtroops)themselvesadmitthatifdrugsweresmuggledpastthem,
theywouldn'tinterfere.Why?.Americansthemselvesadmitthatdrugsareoftentransportedoutof
AfghanistanonAmericanplanes.DrugtraffickinginAfghanistanbringsthemabout50billiondollars
ayearwhichfullycoverstheexpensestiedtokeepingtheirtroopsthere."
JeffSteinreportedinTheWashingtonPostjustafewweeksagothatbagsofcashbelievedtobedrug
proceedsanddivertedforeignaidareleavingAfghanistanviatheKandaharairportwhichiscontrolled
byAhmedWaliKarzai.AccordingtoaformerC.I.A.official:
ThedirectArianaflightfromKandahartoDubaiinitscargoholdcarriesmanybalesofU.S.dollars
wrappedinburlap.Nohandcarry.ThisisAWKspreferredroute.
AfghanintelligenceagentshavecorroboratedthestoryandhaveprovidedtheexC.I.A.employeethe
locationsofwhereAhmedWalimeetsC.I.A.operatives,whathismonthlysalaryis,howitisdelivered
andthenamesofthetwoC.I.A.womenwhodotheactualcashtransfer.
Thesearestartlingreportsindeed,mademoredistressingbythefactthatnolawenforcementofficialof
fitmindwoulddareinvestigatetheC.I.A.anditsbeneficiary'sdrugtraffickingracket.
KeeplaughingatpeoplewhomakeclaimsthattheCIAisthebiggestillicitdrugsmugglingoperatorin
theworld...
http://bluelight.org/vb/archive/index.php/t524351.html
Within a few years, the currents of global geopolitics then shifted in ways that
pushed the CIA into new alliances with drug traffickers. In 1979, the Soviets
invaded Afghanistan and the Sandinista revolution seized Nicaragua, prompting
two CIA covert operations with some revealing similarities. During the 1980s,
while the Soviets occupied Afghanistan, the CIA, working through Pakistan's InterService Intelligence, spent some $2 billion to support the Afghan resistance.
When the operation started in 1979, this region grew opium only for regional
markets and produced no heroin. Within two years, however, the PakistanAfghanistan borderlands became the world's top heroin producer, supplying 60
percent of U.S. demand. In Pakistan, the heroin-addict population went from near
zero in 1979 to 5,000 in 1981 and to 1.2 million by 1985-a much steeper rise than
in any other nation.
CIA assets again controlled this heroin trade. As the Mujaheddin guerrillas seized
territory inside Afghanistan, they ordered peasants to plant opium as a
revolutionary tax. Across the border in Pakistan, Afghan leaders and local
syndicates under the protection of Pakistan Intelligence operated hundreds of
heroin laboratories. During this decade of wide-open drug-dealing, the U.S. Drug
Enforcement Agency in Islamabad failed to instigate major seizures or arrests.
In May 1990, as the CIA operation was winding down, The Washington Post
published a front-page expose charging that Gulbudin Hekmatar, the ClA's
favored Afghan leader, was a major heroin manufacturer. The Post argued, in a
manner similar to the San Jose Mercury News's later report about the contras,
that U.S. officials had refused to investigate charges of heroin dealing by its
Afghan allies "because U.S. narcotics policy in Afghanistan has been subordinated
to the war against Soviet influence there."
In 1995, the former CIA director of the Afghan operation, Charles Cogan, admitted
the CIA had indeed sacrificed the drug war to fight the Cold War. "Our main
mission was to do as much damage as possible to the Soviets. We didn't really
have the resources or the time to devote to an investigation of the drug trade,"
he told an Australian television reporter. "I don't think that we need to apologize
for this. Every situation has its fallout.... There was fallout in terms of drugs, yes.
But the main objective was accomplished. The Soviets left Afghanistan."
Again, distance and complexity insulated the CIA from any political fallout. Once
the heroin left Pakistan's laboratories, the Sicilian mafia managed its export to
the United States, and a chain of syndicate-controlled pizza parlors distributed the
drugs to street gangs in American cities, according to reports by the Drug
Enforcement Agency. Most ordinary Americans did not see the links between the
ClA's alliance with Afghan drug lords, the pizza parlors, and the heroin on U.S.
streets.
In Central America, proximity simplified the political equation. According to
sections of the San Jose Mercury News story that the mainstream press have not
contested, this "dark alliance" began in the early 1980s when the contra revolt
against Nicaragua's leftist Sandinista government was failing for want of funds. In
1981, the CIA hired ex-Nicaraguan army Colonel Enrique Bermudez to organize
what became the main contra guerrilla army, the Nicaraguan Democratic Front.
Bermudez then accepted funds from two Nicaraguan exiles active in the crack
trade to supplement meager Agency funding.
OpiumThroughoutHistory
c.3400B.C.TheopiumpoppyiscultivatedinlowerMesopotamia.TheSumeriansrefertoitasHul
Gil,the'joyplant.'TheSumerianswouldsoonpassalongtheplantanditseuphoriceffectstothe
Assyrians.TheartofpoppycullingwouldcontinuefromtheAssyrianstotheBabylonianswhointurn
wouldpasstheirknowledgeontotheEgyptians.
c.1300B.C.InthecapitalcityofThebes,Egyptiansbegincultivationofopiumthebaicum,grownin
theirfamouspoppyfields.TheopiumtradeflourishesduringthereignofThutmoseIV,Akhenatonand
KingTutankhamen.ThetraderouteincludedthePhoeniciansandMinoanswhomovetheprofitable
itemacrosstheMediterraneanSeaintoGreece,Carthage,andEurope.
c.1100B.C.OntheislandofCyprus,the"PeoplesoftheSea"craftsurgicalqualitycullingknivesto
harvestopium,whichtheywouldcultivate,tradeandsmokebeforethefallofTroy.
c.460B.C.Hippocrates,"thefatherofmedicine",dismissesthemagicalattributesofopiumbut
acknowledgesitsusefulnessasanarcoticandstypticintreatinginternaldiseases,diseasesofwomen
andepidemics.
330B.C.AlexandertheGreatintroducesopiumtothepeopleofPersiaandIndia.
A.D.400Opiumthebaicum,fromtheEgytpianfieldsatThebes,isfirstintroducedtoChinabyArab
traders.
1300's OpiumdisappearsfortwohundredyearsfromEuropeanhistoricalrecord.Opiumhadbecome
ataboosubjectforthoseincirclesoflearningduringtheHolyInquisition.Intheeyesofthe
Inquisition,anythingfromtheEastwaslinkedtotheDevil.
1500ThePortugese,whiletradingalongtheEastChinaSea,initiatethesmokingofopium.The
effectswereinstantaneousastheydiscoveredbutitwasapracticetheChineseconsideredbarbaricand
subversive.
1527DuringtheheightoftheReformation,opiumisreintroducedintoEuropeanmedicalliteratureby
Paracelsusaslaudanum.Theseblackpillsor"StonesofImmortality"weremadeofopiumthebaicum,
citrusjuiceandquintessenceofgoldandprescribedaspainkillers.
1600's ResidentsofPersiaandIndiabegineatinganddrinkingopiummixturesforrecreationaluse.
PortugesemerchantscarryingcargoesofIndianopiumthroughMacaodirectitstradeflowintoChina.
1606ShipscharteredbyElizabethIareinstructedtopurchasethefinestIndianopiumandtransportit
backtoEngland.
1680Englishapothecary,ThomasSydenham,introducesSydenham'sLaudanum,acompoundof
opium,sherrywineandherbs.Hispillsalongwithothersofthetimebecomepopularremediesfor
numerousailments.
1700TheDutchexportshipmentsofIndianopiumtoChinaandtheislandsofSoutheastAsia;the
DutchintroducethepracticeofsmokingopiuminatobaccopipetotheChinese.
1729Chineseemperor,YungCheng,issuesanedictprohibitingthesmokingofopiumandits
domesticsale,exceptunderlicenseforuseasmedicine.
1750TheBritishEastIndiaCompanyassumescontrolofBengalandBihar,opiumgrowingdistricts
ofIndia.BritishshippingdominatestheopiumtradeoutofCalcuttatoChina.
1753Linnaeus,thefatherofbotany,firstclassifiesthepoppy,Papaversomniferum'sleepinducing',
inhisbookGeneraPlantarum.
1767TheBritishEastIndiaCompany'simportofopiumtoChinareachesastaggeringtwothousand
chestsofopiumperyear.
1793TheBritishEastIndiaCompanyestablishesamonopolyontheopiumtrade.Allpoppygrowers
inIndiawereforbiddentosellopiumtocompetitortradingcompanies.
1799China'semperor,KiaKing,bansopiumcompletely,makingtradeandpoppycultivationillegal.
1800TheBritishLevantCompanypurchasesnearlyhalfofalloftheopiumcomingoutofSmyrna,
TurkeystrictlyforimportationtoEuropeandtheUnitedStates.
1803FriedrichSertuernerofPaderborn,Germanydiscoverstheactiveingredientofopiumby
dissolvingitinacidthenneutralizingitwithammonia.Theresult:alkaloidsPrincipiumsomniferum
ormorphine.
Physiciansbelievethatopiumhadfinallybeenperfectedandtamed.Morphineislaudedas"God'sown
medicine"foritsreliablity,longlastingeffectsandsafety.
1805AsmugglerfromBoston,Massachusetts,CharlesCabot,attemptstopurchaseopiumfromthe
British,thensmuggleitintoChinaundertheauspicesofBritishsmugglers.
1812AmericanJohnCushing,undertheemployofhisuncles'business,JamesandThomasH.
PerkinsCompanyofBoston,acquireshiswealthfromsmugglingTurkishopiumtoCanton.
1816JohnJacobAstorofNewYorkCityjoinstheopiumsmugglingtrade.HisAmericanFur
CompanypurchasestentonsofTurkishopiumthenshipsthecontrabanditemtoCantononthe
Macedonian.AstorwouldlaterleavetheChinaopiumtradeandsellsolelytoEngland.
1819WriterJohnKeatsandotherEnglishliterarypersonalitiesexperimentwithopiumintendedfor
strictrecreationalusesimplyforthehighandtakenatextended,nonaddictiveintervals
1821ThomasDeQuinceypublisheshisautobiographicalaccountofopiumaddiction,'Confessionsof
anEnglishOpiumeater.'
1827E.Merck&CompanyofDarmstadt,Germany,beginscommercialmanufacturingofmorphine.
1830TheBritishdependenceonopiumformedicinalandrecreationalusereachesanalltimehighas
22,000poundsofopiumisimportedfromTurkeyandIndia.
JardineMatheson&CompanyofLondoninheritIndiaanditsopiumfromtheBritishEastIndia
CompanyoncethemandatetoruleanddictatethetradepoliciesofBritishIndiaarenolongerineffect.
1837 ElizabethBarrettBrowningfallsunderthespellofmorphine.This,however,doesnotimpede
herabilitytowrite"poeticalparagraphs."
March18,1839LinTseHsu,imperialChinesecommissionerinchargeofsuppressingtheopium
traffic,ordersallforeigntraderstosurrendertheiropium.Inresponse,theBritishsendexpenditionary
warshipstothecoastofChina,beginningTheFirstOpiumWar.
1840 NewEnglandersbring24,000poundsofopiumintotheUnitedStates.Thiscatchesthe
attentionofU.S.Customswhichpromptlyputsadutyfeeontheimport.
1841 TheChinesearedefeatedbytheBritishintheFirstOpiumWar.Alongwithpayingalarge
indemnity,HongKongiscededtotheBritish.
1843 Dr.AlexanderWoodofEdinburghdiscoversanewtechniqueofadministeringmorphine,
injectionwithasyringe.Hefindstheeffectsofmorphineonhispatientsinstantaneousandthreetimes
morepotent.
1852TheBritisharriveinlowerBurma,importinglargequantitiesofopiumfromIndiaandsellingit
throughagovernmentcontrolledopiummonopoly.
1856 TheBritishandFrenchrenewtheirhostilitiesagainstChinaintheSecondOpiumWar.Inthe
aftermathofthestruggle,Chinaisforcedtopayanotherindemnity.Theimportationofopiumis
legalized.
OpiumproductionincreasesalongthehighlandsofSoutheastAsia.
1874Englishresearcher,C.R.Wrightfirstsynthesizesheroin,ordiacetylmorphine,byboiling
morphineoverastove.
InSanFrancisco,smokingopiuminthecitylimitsisbannedandisconfinedtoneighboring
Chinatownsandtheiropiumdens.
1878 BritainpassestheOpiumActwithhopesofreducingopiumconsumption.Underthenew
regulation,thesellingofopiumisrestrictedtoregisteredChineseopiumsmokersandIndianopium
eaterswhiletheBurmesearestrictlyprohibitedfromsmokingopium.
1886 TheBritishacquireBurma'snortheastregion,theShanstate.Productionandsmugglingof
opiumalongthelowerregionofBurmathrivesdespiteBritisheffortstomaintainastrictmonopolyon
theopiumtrade.
1890 U.S.Congress,initsearliestlawenforcementlegislationonnarcotics,imposesataxonopium
andmorphine.
TabloidsownedbyWilliamRandolphHearstpublishstoriesofwhitewomenbeingseducedby
Chinesemenandtheiropiumtoinvokefearofthe'YellowPeril',disguisedasan"antidrug"campaign.
1895 HeinrichDreserworkingforTheBayerCompanyofElberfeld,Germany,findsthatdiluting
morphinewithacetylsproducesadrugwithoutthecommonmorphinesideeffects.Bayerbegins
productionofdiacetylmorphineandcoinsthename"heroin."Heroinwouldnotbeintroduced
commerciallyforanotherthreeyears.
Early1900'sThephilanthropicSaintJamesSocietyintheU.S.mountsacampaigntosupplyfree
samplesofherointhroughthemailtomorphineaddictswhoaretryinggiveuptheirhabits.
EffortsbytheBritishandFrenchtocontrolopiumproductioninSoutheastAsiaaresuccessful.
Nevertheless,thisSoutheastregion,referredtoasthe'GoldenTriangle',eventuallybecomesamajor
playerintheprofitableopiumtradeduringthe1940's.
1902 Invariousmedicaljournals,physiciansdiscussthesideeffectsofusingheroinasamorphine
stepdowncure.Severalphysicianswouldarguethattheirpatientssufferedfromheroinwithdrawal
symptomsequaltomorphineaddiction.
1903 Heroinaddictionrisestoalarmingrates.
1905 U.S.Congressbansopium.
1906 ChinaandEnglandfinallyenactatreatyrestrictingtheSinoIndianopiumtrade.
Severalphysiciansexperimentwithtreatmentsforheroinaddiction.Dr.AlexanderLambertand
CharlesB.Townstouttheirpopularcureasthemost"advanced,effectiveandcompassionatecure"for
heroinaddiction.Thecureconsistedofa7dayregimen,whichincludedafivedaypurgeofheroin
fromtheaddict'ssystemwithdosesofbelladonnadelirium.
U.S.CongresspassesthePureFoodandDrugActrequiringcontentslabelingonpatentmedicinesby
pharmaceuticalcompanies.Asaresult,theavailabiltyofopiatesandopiateconsumerssignificantly
declines.
1909 ThefirstfederaldrugprohibitionpassesintheU.S.outlawingtheimporationofopium.Itwas
passedinpreparationfortheShanghaiConference,atwhichtheUSpressesforlegislationaimedat
suppressingthesaleofopiumtoChina.
February1,1909TheInternationalOpiumCommissionconvenesinShanghai.HeadingtheU.S.
delegationareDr.HamiltonWrightandEpiscopalBishopHenryBrent.Bothwouldtrytoconvincethe
internationaldelegationoftheimmoralandevileffectsofopium.
1910 After150yearsoffailedattemptstoridthecountryofopium,theChinesearefinally
successfulinconvincingtheBritishtodismantletheIndiaChinaopiumtrade.
Dec.17,1914 ThepassageofHarrisonNarcoticsActwhichaimstocurbdrug(especiallycocaine
butalsoheroin)abuseandaddiction.Itrequiresdoctors,pharmacistsandotherswhoprescribed
narcoticstoregisterandpayatax.
1923 TheU.S.TreasuryDepartment'sNarcoticsDivision(thefirstfederaldrugagency)bansall
legalnarcoticssales.Withtheprohibitionoflegalvenuestopurchaseheroin,addictsareforcedtobuy
fromillegalstreetdealers.
1925 Inthewakeofthefirstfederalbanonopium,athrivingblackmarketopensupinNewYork's
Chinatown.
1930's ThemajorityofillegalheroinsmuggledintotheU.S.comesfromChinaandisrefinedin
ShanghaiandTietsin.
Early1940'sDuringWorldWarII,opiumtraderoutesareblockedandtheflowofopiumfromIndia
andPersiaiscutoff.Fearfuloflosingtheiropiummonopoly,theFrenchencourageHmongfarmersto
expandtheiropiumproduction.
19451947BurmagainsitsindependencefromBritainattheendofWorldWarII.Opiumcultivation
andtradeflourishesintheShanstates.
19481972CorsicangangstersdominatetheU.S.heroinmarketthroughtheirconnectionwithMafia
drugdistributors.AfterrefiningtherawTurkishopiuminMarseillelaboratories,theheroinismade
easilyavailableforpurchasebyjunkiesonNewYorkCitystreets.
1950's U.S.effortstocontainthespreadofCommunisminAsiainvolvesforgingallianceswithtribes
andwarlordsinhabitingtheareasoftheGoldenTriangle,(anexpansecoveringLaos,Thailandand
Burma),thusprovidingaccessibilityandprotectionalongthesoutheastborderofChina.Inorderto
maintaintheirrelationshipwiththewarlordswhilecontinuingtofundthestruggleagainstcommunism,
theU.S.andFrancesupplythedrugwarlordsandtheirarmieswithammunition,armsandairtransport
fortheproductionandsaleofopium.Theresult:anexplosionintheavailabilityandillegalflowof
heroinintotheUnitedStatesandintothehandsofdrugdealersandaddicts.
1962 Burmaoutlawsopium.
19651970
U.S.involvementinVietnamisblamedforthesurgeinillegalheroinbeing
smuggledintotheStates.ToaidU.S.allies,theCentralIntelligenceAgency(CIA)setsupacharter
airline,AirAmerica,totransportrawopiumfromBurmaandLaos.Aswell,someoftheopiumwould
betransportedtoMarseillebyCorsicangangsterstoberefinedintoheroinandshippedtotheU.Svia
theFrenchconnection.ThenumberofheroinaddictsintheU.S.reachesanestimated750,000.
October1970 Legendarysinger,JanisJoplin,isfounddeadatHollywood'sLandmarkHotel,a
victimofan"accidentalheroinoverdose."
1972 HeroinexportationfromSoutheastAsia'sGoldenTriangle,controlledbyShanwarlord,Khun
Sa,becomesamajorsourceforrawopiumintheprofitabledrugtrade.
July1,1973
PresidentNixoncreatestheDEA(DrugEnforcementAdministration)underthe
JusticeDept.toconsolidatevirtuallyallfederalpowersofdrugenforcementinasingleagency.
Mid1970's
Saigonfalls.Theheroinepidemicsubsides.Thesearchforanewsourceofraw
opiumyieldsMexico'sSierraMadre."MexicanMud"wouldtemporarilyreplace"ChinaWhite"heroin
until1978.
1978 TheU.S.andMexicangovernmentsfindameanstoeliminatethesourceofrawopiumby
sprayingpoppyfieldswithAgentOrange.Theeradicationplanistermedasuccessastheamountof
"MexicanMud"intheU.S.drugmarketdeclines.Inresponsetothedecreaseinavailabilityof
"MexicanMud",anothersourceofheroinisfoundintheGoldenCrescentareaIran,Afghanistanand
Pakistan,creatingadramaticupsurgeintheproductionandtradeofillegalheroin.
1982 ComedianJohnBelushiofAnimalHousefame,diesofaheroincocaine"speedball"
overdose.
U.S.StateDepartmentofficialsconclude,aftermorethanadecadeofcropsubstitutionprogramsfor
ThirdWorldgrowersofmarijuana,cocaoropiumpoppies,thatthetacticcannotworkwithout
eradicationoftheplantsandcriminalenforcement.Poorresultsarereportedfromeradicationprograms
inBurma,Pakistan,MexicoandPeru.
1988 OpiumproductioninBurmaincreasesundertheruleoftheStateLawandOrderRestoration
Council(SLORC),theBurmesejuntaregime.
ThesinglelargestheroinseizureismadeinBangkok.TheU.S.suspectsthatthe2,400poundshipment
ofheroin,enroutetoNewYorkCity,originatedfromtheGoldenTriangleregion,controlledbydrug
warlord,KhunSa.
1990 AU.S.CourtindictsKhunSa,leaderoftheShanUnitedArmyandreputeddrugwarlord,on
herointraffickingcharges.TheU.S.AttorneyGeneral'sofficechargesKhunSawithimporting3,500
poundsofheroinintoNewYorkCityoverthecourseofeighteenmonths,aswellasholdinghim
responsibleforthesourceoftheheroinseizedinBangkok.
1992 Colombia'sdruglordsaresaidtobeintroducingahighgradeformofheroinintotheUnited
States.
1993TheThaiarmywithsupportfromtheU.S.DrugEnforcementAgency(DEA)launchesits
operationtodestroythousandsofacresofopiumpoppiesfromthefieldsoftheGoldenTriangleregion.
October31,1993Herointakesanotherwellknownvictim.TwentythreeyearoldactorRiver
Phoenixdiesofaheroincocaineoverdose,thesame"speedball"combinationthatkilledcomedian
JohnBelushi.
January1994 Effortstoeradicateopiumatitssourceremainsunsuccessful.TheClinton
Administrationordersashiftinpolicyawayfromtheantidrugcampaignsofpreviousadministrations.
Insteadthefocusincludes"institutionbuilding"withthehopethatby"strengtheningdemocratic
governmentsabroad,[it]willfosterlawabidingbehaviorandpromotelegitimateeconomic
opportunity."
April1994KurtCobain,leadsingeroftheSeattlebasedalternativerockband,Nirvana,diesof
heroinrelatedsuicide.
1995 TheGoldenTriangleregionofSoutheastAsiaisnowtheleaderinopiumproduction,yielding
2,500tonsannually.AccordingtoU.S.drugexperts,therearenewdrugtraffickingroutesfromBurma
throughLaos,tosouthernChina,CambodiaandVietnam.
January1996KhunSa,oneofShanstate'smostpowerfuldrugwarlords,"surrenders"toSLORC.The
U.S.issuspiciousandfearsthatthisagreementbetweentherulingjuntaregimeandKhunSaincludes
adealallowing"theopiumking"toretaincontrolofhisopiumtradebutinexchangeendhis30year
oldrevolutionarywaragainstthegovernment.
November1996Internationaldrugtraffickingorganizations,includingChina,Nigeria,Colombiaand
Mexicoaresaidtobe"aggressivelymarketingheroinintheUnitedStatesandEurope."
References
Booth,Martin.Opium:AHistory.London:Simon&Schuster,Ltd.,1996.
Latimer,Dean,andJeffGoldbergwithanIntroductionbyWilliamBurroughs.FlowersintheBlood:
TheStoryofOpium.NewYork:FranklinWatts,1981
McCoy,AlfredW.ThePoliticsofHeroin:CIAComplicityintheGlobalDrugTrade.NewYork:
LawrenceHillBooks,1991.
Musto,DavidF.TheAmericanDisease:OriginsofNarcoticControl.NewYork:OxfordUniversity
Press,1987.
http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/pages/frontline/shows/heroin/etc/history.html
Pharmaceuticals
Monsanto: The Enemy Of Family Farmers
Elizabeth Kucinich
Policy Director, Center for Food Safety
Posted: 04/02/2014
AfteryearsofworkbyscientificpublicinterestorganizationssuchasCenterforFoodSafetyand
governmentalbodiessuchastheUnitedNations,consumersaroundtheworldarebecomingawareof
thedangersofindustrial,chemicalbasedagriculture.Themostlegitimatescienceandresearchbodies
recommendturningtowardorganicandsustainableagriculture,shunninggeneticallyengineered(GE
orGMO)productsandthechemicalstheyaredesignedtopromote.YetdespitetheU.N.'sassessment
thatsustainableagricultureisthewaytofeedtheworld'sgrowingpopulation,U.S.government
agenciescontinuetosupportthebiotechnologyindustryanditspesticidepromotingcropsasthepath
forward.ButthemessageisfailingevenwiththebackingoftheU.S.governmentandabarrageof
advertisingfromcompanieslikeMonsanto.
Withthegrowthandpowerofthefoodmovement,corporategiantsarebeginningtotakeaction.
Accordingtonewsreportslastyear,Monsanto"[shook]upitsseniorpublicrelationsstaff,uppedits
relationshipwithoneofthenation'slargestpublicrelationsfirms andhelpedlauncha[new]
website..."Afterdecadesofemployinga"blockusandwe'llsueyou"approach,Monsantorecently
begananintensemakeoverPRcampaign:popularitybyassociation.
Monsantoiscozyinguptothereputation,authenticityandwholesomenessoffamilyfarmersand
hopingtheallAmericannostalgiamanyassociatewiththesmallscalefarmerrubsoffonthem.
DuringtheSuperBowl,keymediamarkets sawMonsanto's"ItBeginswithaFarmer"commercials,
whichwereintendedtodemonstratethatthecompanysharesthesamevaluesasfamilyfarmersandthe
consumerstheyfeedandclothe.
Considerthecold,hardfacts:
Addtothistherisingcostsofchemicalfertilizersandpesticides(includingherbicides)inthis
"onesizefitsall"agriculturalmodelwherechemicalcompaniesmakeoutlikebanditsonthe
saleofseedsandchemicalinputs.Intheend,familyfarmersgetsqueezedoutbythe
mammothfarmsenabledbybiotechnology.
operationshavebeeninvolvedincourtcasesinvolvingallegedpatentinfringement,andhave
paidthecompanynearly$24millionindamages,asumthatdoesnotincludeadditional
litigationcostslikeattorneyorwitnessfees.WhileMonsantohastakenactionagainst
thousandsoffarmers,onlythevastmajorityreachpretrialsettlementstoavoidfacingthe
multinationalgiantincourt.Whenthesepretrialsettlementsareincluded,farmershavepaid
Monsantoanestimated$85to160million.Monsantowouldliketodismissthesignificanceof
thesesuitsanddirectattentiontotheirnewwebsitefullofsmiling,meticulouslyselected
farmers.Thisissimplyadistractionfromthehundreds,ifnotthousands,offarmerswhohave
losttheirlivelihoodstothecorporatemachine.
Don'tbefooledbyMonsanto'sPRspinmachine.
Monsantodoesnotshareourvaluesandtheyaren'tinterestedinchangingtheirways.Tolearnmore
aboutissuesrelatedtogeneticengineering(orGMOs),visitwww.CenterForFoodSafety.org.
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/elizabethkucinich/theenemyoffamilyfarmers_b_4064134.html
Scandal of experts who rule on NHS statins but get paid by drugs firms
MOST of the experts who are set to recommend the widespread use of
statins next month are in the pay of the drug companies that
manufacture them.
By: Lucy Johnston
Published: Sun, March 9, 2014
DrAnthonyWierzbicki:ChairmanofstatinpanelhaslinkstodrugfirmsincludingPfizer
Anysuggestionthatmedicsorofficialsstandtopersonallyprofitfromdecisionsaboutourcarewill
rightlyworrypatientsAndrewGwynne,ShadowHealthMinister
ThespecialistssitontheGovernmenthealthwatchdog,theNationalInstituteforHealthandCare
Excellence(Nice).
Niceisexpectedtoissuenewnationaladvicesayingstatins,nowprescribedtoaboutsevenmillion
peopleayear,shouldbeofferedtoatleastoneinfouradults.
Themovehasbeencriticisedbymanydoctorswhosaythatformanylowriskpatientsthebenefitsof
statinsdonotoutweighpossiblesideeffectsincludingdiabetes,impotence,cataracts,musclepains,
mentalimpairment,fatigueandliverdysfunction.
ASundayExpressinvestigationhasdiscoveredeightoutof12membersoftheNicepanelwhichdrew
uptheguidancehavefinancialtiestocompaniesthatmakestatinsornextgenerationcholesterol
loweringdrugs.
ThefinancialtiesaredeclaredinanappendixtothenewdraftNicestatinguidanceandinclude
paymentsforspeeches,lecturesortoattendconferenceswhichcanreapthousandsofpoundsperhour.
Italsoincludessalariesforinvolvementinclinicaltrialsofnewstatinstyledrugs,whichcanamountto
tensofthousandsofpoundsayear,paymentfordrugcompanyadvisoryroles,andinonecasea
sponsorshipofaworkpost.
ToryMPDrSarahWollastonhasvowedtocallontheCommonsHealthSelectCommitteeto
investigatetherevelation.
GPDrWollaston,aformermemberofthecommittee,said:Thisshouldleadtoanexaminationby
Nice.Itisaconcernasthispanelsdecisionhassuchwidespreadimplicationsforprescribingandcost
totheNHS.
ShadowHealthMinisterAndrewGwynnesaid:Patientsacrossthecountrywillbeconcernedbythese
findings.Anysuggestionthatmedicsorofficialsstandtopersonallyprofitfromdecisionsaboutour
carewillrightlyworrypatients.Ministersmustaskthewatchdogtoinvestigatewithoutdelay.
AseemMalhotra,aLondonbasedheartdoctor,said:Iamastoundedthateightoutof12membersof
thestatinpanelhavedirectfinancialtiestothedrugsindustry.
IalwaysbelievedNicewascompletelyindependentofthedrugsindustry.Weneedresearchersand
scientiststoconcentrateonwhatisbestforpatientsandnotindividualcareersandprofitsofdrug
companies.
OneoftheeightNicememberswithfinanciallinksisDrAnthonyWierzbicki,chairmanofthestatin
panelandaheartdiseasespecialistatGuysandStThomasshospitalinLondon,whoisbeingpaidby
sixdruggiants,includingPfizer,SanofiandAventis,tohelpresearchnewgenerationcholesterol
loweringdrugs.DrRajaiAhmad,aheartspecialistatWestMidlandsHospital,hasreceivedspeaker
feesfrommultinationaldrugcompaniesinvestinginheartdrugs.
DrMichaelKhan,aheartspecialistatUniversityHospitalsofCoventryandWarwickshire,hasbeen
paidbydrugcompaniesinvestinginheartdrugsforlecturesandtositonfourdrugcompanyadvisory
boardsandisbeingpaidbydrugcompanyAmgentorunaclinicaltrial.
SpecialistheartnurseSisterEmmaMcGowan,whoworksatthesametrust,admittedherjobhasbeen
sponsoredbystatinmanufacturersAstraZenecaforayear.Shealsoreceivedadrugcompanypayment
forspeakingandanotherforattendingaconference.Shedeclared:Thepaymentsweremadetome
personallyasIhavebeeninformedtheyareunabletopayintoadepartmentalfund.
DrRobertDermotNeely,heartspecialistattheUniversityofNewcastle,declareddrugcompanycash
forsittingontheiradvisoryboards,workingontrialsintonewheartdrugsandforattendinga
conference.TheSundayExpressrevealedlastweekthatleadingspecialistsaredemandinganendto
thewidespreaduseofthecontroversialheartdrugs.
DrKailashChand,deputychairmanoftheBritishMedicalAssociation,suffereddebilitatingside
effectsafterhewasprescribedstatinsfiveyearsago.
DrChand,60,aGPinTameside,GreaterManchester,said:Thewholethingiscorrupting.Members
ofthepanelshouldbewhiterthanwhiteandnotinthepayofdrugcompanies.
DrMalcolmKendrick,whohasstudiedhearthealth,added:Niceisthejudiciaryfordrugs.Noone
whohasafinancialconflictofinterestshouldbeinvolved.Itmustbestopped.
AspokesmanforNicesaid:Theconflictsofinterestdeclaredbycommitteemembersinvolvedin
producingthisguidelinehavebeenmanagedappropriately.Theyhavenotinfluencedinanywaythe
draftrecommendationsontheuseofstatins.
http://www.express.co.uk/news/health/463873/Expertsrecommendingstatinsarepaidbydrugsfirms
WhattheTamiflusagatellsusaboutdrugtrialsandbigpharma
Wenowknowthegovernment'sTamiflustockpilewouldn'thavedoneusmuchgoodintheeventofa
fluepidemic.Butthesecrecysurroundingclinicaltrialsmeansthere'salotwedon'tknowaboutother
medicineswetake.
o
BenGoldacre
TheGuardian,Thursday10April2014
TodaywefoundoutthatTamifludoesn'tworksowellafterall.Roche,thedrugcompanybehindit,
withheldvitalinformationonitsclinicaltrialsforhalfadecade,buttheCochraneCollaboration,a
globalnotforprofitorganisationof14,000academics,finallyobtainedalltheinformation.Puttingthe
evidencetogether,ithasfoundthatTamifluhaslittleornoimpactoncomplicationsoffluinfection,
suchaspneumonia.
ThatisascandalbecausetheUKgovernmentspent0.5bnstockpilingthisdruginthehopethatit
wouldhelppreventserioussideeffectsfromfluinfection.ButthebiggerscandalisthatRochebroke
nolawbywithholdingvitalinformationonhowwellitsdrugworks.Infact,themethodsandresultsof
clinicaltrialsonthedrugsweusetodayarestillroutinelyandlegallybeingwithheldfromdoctors,
researchersandpatients.ItissimplebadluckforRochethatTamiflubecame,arbitrarily,theposter
childforthemissingdatastory.
Anditisagreatposterchild.ThebattleoverTamifluperfectlyillustratestheneedforfulltransparency
aroundclinicaltrials,theimportanceofaccesstoobscuredocumentation,andthefailureofthe
regulatorysystem.Crucially,itisalsoanillustrationofhowscience,atitsbest,isbuiltontransparency
andopennesstocriticism,becausethesagaoftheCochraneTamiflureviewbeganwithasimpleonline
comment.
In2009,therewaswidespreadconcernaboutanewflupandemic,andbillionswerebeingspent
stockpilingTamifluaroundtheworld.Becauseofthis,theUKandAustraliangovernmentsspecifically
askedtheCochraneCollaborationtoupdateitsearlierreviewsonthedrug.Cochranereviewsarethe
goldstandardinmedicine:theysummariseallthedataonagiventreatment,andtheyareinaconstant
reviewcycle,becauseevidencechangesovertimeasnewtrialsarepublished.Thisshouldhavebeena
prettyeverydaypieceofwork:thepreviousreview,in2008,hadfoundsomeevidencethatTamiflu
does,indeed,reducetherateofcomplicationssuchaspneumonia.ButthenaJapanesepaediatrician
calledKeijiHayashileftacommentthatwouldtriggerarevolutioninourunderstandingofhow
evidencebasedmedicineshouldwork.Thiswasn'tinapublication,orevenaletter:itwasasimple
onlinecomment,postedinformallyunderneaththeTamiflureviewontheCochranewebsite,almost
likeablogcomment.
Cochranehadsummarisedthedatafromallthetrials,explainedHayashi,butitspositiveconclusion
wasdrivenbydatafromjustoneofthepapersitcited:anindustryfundedsummaryof10previous
trials,ledbyanauthorcalledKaiser.Fromthese10trials,onlytwohadeverbeenpublishedinthe
scientificliterature.Fortheremainingeight,theonlyavailableinformationonthemethodsusedcame
fromthebriefsummaryinthissecondarysource,createdbyindustry.That'snotreliableenough.
Thisisscienceatitsbest.TheCochranereviewisreadilyaccessibleonline;itexplainstransparently
themethodsbywhichitlookedfortrials,andthenanalysedthem,soanyinformedreadercanpullthe
reviewapart,andunderstandwheretheconclusionscamefrom.Cochraneprovidesaneasywayfor
readerstoraisecriticisms.And,crucially,thesecriticismsdidnotfallondeafears.DrTomJeffersonis
theheadoftheCochranerespiratorygroup,andtheleadauthoronthe2008review.Herealised
immediatelythathehadmadeamistakeinblindlytrustingtheKaiserdata.Hesaidso,without
defensiveness,andthensetaboutgettingtheinformationneeded.
First,theCochraneresearcherswrotetotheauthorsoftheKaiserpaper.Byreply,theyweretoldthat
thisteamnolongerhadthefiles:theyshouldcontactRoche.Heretheproblemsbegan.Rochesaidit
wouldhandoversomeinformation,buttheCochranereviewerswouldneedtosignaconfidentiality
agreement.Thiswastricky:Cochranereviewsarebuiltaroundshowingtheirworking,butRoche's
proposedcontractwouldrequirethemtokeeptheinformationbehindtheirreasoningsecretfrom
readers.Morethanthis,thecontractsaidtheywerenotallowedtodiscussthetermsoftheirsecrecy
agreement,orpubliclyacknowledgethatitevenexisted.Rochewasdemandingasecretcontract,with
secretterms,requiringsecrecyaboutthemethodsandresultsoftrials,inadiscussionaboutthesafety
andefficacyofadrugthathasbeentakenbyhundredsofthousandsofpeoplearoundtheworld,andon
whichgovernmentshadspentbillions.Roche'sdemand,worryingly,isnotunusual.Atthispoint,many
inmedicinewouldeitheracquiesce,orgiveup.JeffersonaskedRocheforclarificationaboutwhythe
contractwasnecessary.Heneverreceivedareply.
Then,inOctober2009,thecompanychangedtack.Itwouldliketohandoverthedata,itexplained,but
anotheracademicreviewonTamifluwasbeingconductedelsewhere.Rochehadgiventhisothergroup
thestudyreports,soCochranecouldn'thavethem.Thiswasanonsequitur:thereisnoreasonwhy
manygroupsshouldnotallworkonthesamequestion.Infact,sincereplicationisthecornerstoneof
goodscience,thiswouldbeactivelydesirable.
Then,oneweeklater,unannounced,Rochesentsevendocuments,eacharoundadozenpageslong.
ThesecontainedexcerptsofinternalcompanydocumentsoneachoftheclinicaltrialsintheKaiser
metaanalysis.Itwasastart,butnothingliketheinformationCochraneneededtoassessthebenefits,or
therateofadverseevents,orfullytounderstandthedesignofthetrials.
Atthesametime,itwasrapidlybecomingclearthattherewereoddinconsistenciesintheinformation
onthisdrug.Crucially,differentorganisationsaroundtheworldhaddrawnvastlydifferentconclusions
aboutitseffectiveness.TheUSFoodandDrugAdministration(FDA)saiditgavenobenefitson
complicationssuchaspneumonia,whiletheUSCentersforDiseaseControlandPreventionsaiditdid.
TheJapaneseregulatormadenoclaimforcomplications,buttheEuropeanMedicinesAgency(EMA)
saidtherewasabenefit.Thereareonlytwoexplanationsforthis,andbothcanonlyberesolvedbyfull
transparency.Eithertheseorganisationssawdifferentdata,inwhichcaseweneedtobuildacollective
list,addupallthetrials,andworkouttheeffectsofthedrugoverall.Orthisisaclosecall,andthereis
reasonabledisagreementonhowtointerpretthetrials,inwhichcaseweneedfullaccesstotheir
methodsandresults,foraninformedpublicdebateinthemedicalacademiccommunity.
Thisisparticularlyimportant,sincetherecanoftenbeshortcomingsinthedesignofaclinicaltrial,
whichmeanitisnolongerafairtestofwhichtreatmentisbest.Wenowknowthiswasthecasein
manyoftheTamiflutrials,where,forexample,participantsweresometimesveryunrepresentativeof
realworldpatients.Similarly,intrialsdescribedas"doubleblinded"whereneitherdoctornorpatient
shouldbeabletotellwhetherthey'regettingaplaceboortherealdrugtheactiveandplacebopills
weredifferentcolours.Evenmoreoddly,inalmostallTamiflutrials,itseemsadiagnosisof
pneumoniawasmeasuredbypatients'selfreporting:manyresearcherswouldhaveexpectedaclear
diagnosticalgorithm,perhapsachestxray,atleast.
SincetheCochraneteamwerestillbeingdeniedtheinformationneededtospottheseflaws,they
decidedtoexcludeallthisdatafromtheiranalysis,leavingthereviewinlimbo.Itwaspublishedin
December2009,withanoteexplainingtheirreasoning,andasmallflurryofactivityfollowed.Roche
postedtheirbriefexcerptsonline,andcommittedtomakefullstudyreportsavailable.Forfouryears,
theythenfailedtodoso.
Duringthisperiod,theglobalmedicalacademiccommunitybegantorealisethatthebrief,published
academicpapersontrialswhichwehavereliedonformanyyearscanbeincomplete,andeven
misleading.Muchmoredetailisavailableinaclinicalstudyreport(CSR),theintermediatedocument
thatstandsbetweentherawdataandajournalarticle:thepreciseplanforanalysingthedata
statistically,detaileddescriptionsofadverseevents,andsoon.
By2009,RochehadsharedjustsmallportionsoftheCSRs,buteventhiswasenoughtoseetherewere
problems.Forexample,lookingatthetwopapersoutof10intheKaiserreviewthatwerepublished,
onesaid:"Therewerenodrugrelatedseriousadverseevents",andtheotherdoesn'tmentionadverse
events.ButintheCSRdocumentssharedonthesesametwostudies,10seriousadverseeventswere
listed,ofwhichthreeareclassifiedasbeingpossiblyrelatedtoTamiflu.
Bysettingoutalltheknowntrialssidebyside,theresearcherswereabletoidentifypeculiar
discrepancies:forexample,thelargest"phasethree"trialoneofthelargetrialsthataredonetogeta
drugontothemarketwasneverpublished,andisrarelymentionedinregulatorydocuments.
Thechasecontinued,anditexemplifiestheattitudeofindustrytowardstransparency.InJune2010,
RochetoldCochraneitwassorry,butithadthoughttheyalreadyhadwhattheywanted.InJuly,it
announcedthatitwasworriedaboutpatientconfidentiality.Bynow,Rochehadbeenrefusingto
publishthestudyreportsforayear.Suddenly,itbegantoraiseoddpersonalconcerns.Itclaimedthat
someCochraneresearchershadmadeuntruestatementsaboutthedrug,andaboutthecompany,but
refusedtosaywho,orwhat,orwhere."CertainmembersofCochraneGroup,"itsaid,"areunlikelyto
approachthereviewwiththeindependencethatisbothnecessaryandjustified."Thisishardtocredit,
buteveniftrue,itshouldbeirrelevant:badscienceisoftenpublished,andisshotdowninpublic,in
academicjournals,bypeoplewithgoodarguments.Thisishowscienceworks.Nocompanyor
researchershouldbeallowedtochoosewhohasaccesstotrialdata.StillRocherefusedtohandover
thestudyreports.
ThenRochecomplainedthattheCochranereviewershadbeguntocopyinjournalists,includingme,
ontheiremailswhenrespondingtoRochestaff.Atthesametime,thecompanywasraisingthebroken
argumentsthatareeerilyfamiliartoanyonewhohasfollowedthecampaignforgreatertrials
transparency.Keyamongthesewasonethatcutstothecoreoftheculturewarbetweenevidencebased
medicine,andtheolder"eminencebasedmedicine"thatwearesupposedtohaveleftbehind.Itis
simplynotthejobofacademicstomakethesedecisionsaboutbenefitandrisk,saidRoche,itisthe
jobofregulators.
Thisargumentfailsontwofronts.First,aswithmanyotherdrugs,itnowseemsthatnoteventhe
regulatorshadseenalltheinformationonallthetrials.Butmorethanthat,regulatorsmissthings.
Manyofthemostnotableproblemswithmedicinesoverthepastfewyearswiththearthritisdrug
Vioxx;withthediabetesdrugrosiglitazone,marketedasAvandia;andwiththeevidencebasefor
Tamifluweren'tspottedprimarilybyregulators,butratherbyindependentdoctorsandacademics.
Regulatorsdon'tmissthingsbecausetheyarecorrupt,orincompetent.Theymissthingsbecause
detectingsignalsofriskandbenefitinreviewsofclinicaltrialsisadifficultbusinessandso,likeall
difficultquestionsinscience,itbenefitsfromhavingmanyeyesontheproblem.
WhilethebattleforaccesstoTamiflutrialshasgoneon,theworldofmedicinehasbeguntoshift,
albeitatapainfulpace,withtheEuropeanOmbudsmanandseveralBritishselectcommitteesjoining
thepushfortransparency.TheAllTrialscampaign,whichIcofoundedlastyear,nowhasthesupport
ofalmostallmedicalandacademicprofessionalbodiesintheUK,andmanymoreworldwide,aswell
asmorethan100patientgroups,andthedrugcompanyGSK.Wehaveseennewcodesofconduct,and
Europeanlegislation,proposingimprovementsinaccess:allriddledwithloopholes,butimprovements
nonetheless.Crucially,withholdingdatahasbecomeaheadlineissue,andmuchlessdefensible.
Lastyear,inthecontextofthiswidershift,underceaselessquestionsfromCochraneandtheBritish
MedicalJournal,afterhalfadecade,RochefinallygaveCochranetheinformationitneeded.
SodoesTamifluwork?FromtheCochraneanalysisfullypublicTamifludoesnotreducethe
numberofhospitalisations.Therewasn'tenoughdatatoseeifitreducesthenumberofdeaths.Itdoes
reducethenumberofselfreported,unverifiedcasesofpneumonia,butwhenyoulookatthefivetrials
withadetaileddiagnosticformforpneumonia,thereisnosignificantbenefit.Itmighthelppreventflu
symptoms,butnotasymptomaticspread,andtheevidencehereismixed.Itwilltakeafewhoursoff
thedurationofyourflusymptoms.Butallthiscomesatasignificantcostofsideeffects.Since
percentagesarehardtovisualise,wecanmakethosenumbersmoretangiblebytakingthefiguresfrom
theCochranereview,andapplyingthem.Forexample,ifamillionpeopletakeTamifluinapandemic,
45,000willexperiencevomiting,31,000willexperienceheadacheand11,000willhavepsychiatric
sideeffects.Remember,though,thatthosefiguresallassumeweareonlygivingTamiflutoamillion
people:ifthingskickoff,wehavestockpiledenoughfor80%ofthepopulation.That'squitealotof
vomit.
Rochehasissuedapressreleasesayingitconteststheseconclusions,butgivingnoreasons:sonowwe
canfinallyletsciencebegin.ItcanshootdownthedetailsoftheCochranereviewIhopeitwilland
wewilledgetowardsthetruth.Thisiswhatsciencelookslike.Rochealsodeniesbeingdraggedto
transparency,andsaysitsimplydidn'tknowhowtorespondtoCochrane.This,again,speakstothe
paceofchange.Ihavenoideawhyitwaswithholdinginformation:butIrathersuspectitwassimply
becausethat'swhatpeoplehavealwaysdone,andsharingitwasahassle,requiringnewnormstobe
developed.That'sreassuringanddepressingatthesametime.
Shouldwehavespenthalfabilliononthisdrug?That'satrickyquestion.Ifyoupictureyourselfina
bunker,watchingacatastrophicpandemicunfold,confrontingtheendofhumancivilisation,youcould
probablypersuadeyourselfthatTamiflumightbeworthbuyinganyway,evenknowingtherisksand
benefits.Butthatfinalclauseisthekey.Weoftenchoosetousetreatmentsinmedicine,knowingthat
theyhavelimitedbenefit,andsignificantsideeffects:butwemakeaninformeddecision,balancingthe
risksandbenefitsforourselves.
Andinanycase,that500misthetipoftheiceberg.Tamifluisasideshow,theoneplacewherea
singleteamofdoggedacademicssaid"enough"andthecompanycavedin.Buttheresultsofclinical
trialsarestillbeingroutinelyandlegallywithheldonthemedicinesweusetodayandnothingabouta
finalansweronTamifluwillhelpplugthisgapinghole.
Moreimportantly,forallthatthereisprogress,sofarwehaveonlysentiment,andhalfmeasures.None
ofthechangestoEuropeanlegislationorcodesofconductgetusaccesstotheinformationweneed,
becausetheyallreferonlytonewtrials,sotheysharealoopholethatexcludesremarkablyallthe
trialsonallthemedicinesweusetoday,andwillcontinuetousefordecades.Totakeoneconcreteand
topicalexample:theywouldn'thavemadeablindbitofdifferenceonTamiflu.Wehaveseenvoluntary
pledgesforgreatertransparencyfrommanyindividualcompaniesJohnson&Johnson,Roche,GSK,
nowRoche,andmorewhicharewelcome,butsimilarpromiseshavebeengivenbefore,andthen
reversedafewyearslater.
Thisisapivotalmomentinthehistoryofmedicine.Trialstransparencyisfinallyontheagenda,and
thismaybeouronlyopportunitytofixitinadecade.Wecannotmakeinformeddecisionsaboutwhich
treatmentisbestwhileinformationaboutclinicaltrialsisroutinelyandlegallywithheldfromdoctors,
researchers,andpatients.Anyonewhostandsinthewayoftransparencyisexposingpatientsto
avoidableharm.Weneedregulators,legislators,andprofessionalbodiestodemandfulltransparency.
Weneedclearauditonwhatinformationismissing,andwhoiswithholdingit.
Finally,morethananythingbecausecultureshiftwillbeaspowerfulaslegislationweneedtodo
somethingevenmoredifficult.Weneedtopraise,encourage,andsupportthecompaniesand
individualswhoarebeginningtodotherightthing.ThisnowincludesRoche.Andso,paradoxically,
aftereverythingyouhavereadabove,withtheoutragefreshinyourmind,onthedaywhenitfeels
harderthananyother,Ihopeyouwilljoinmeinsaying:Bravo,Roche.Nowlet'sdobetter.
BenGoldacreisadoctorandtheauthorofBadPharma.
http://www.theguardian.com/business/2014/apr/10/tamiflusagadrugtrialsbigpharma
Drones
Living with death by drone
U.S. drones hover over villages in Pakistan, with the residents never
knowing when they will strike.
October 04, 2012 by Jennifer Gibson
Lastweek,StanfordUniversityandNewYorkUniversityreleasedamajorstudyabouttheuseof
dronesintheeverevolvingbutneverendingwaronterror.Unfortunately,manycommentatorsmissed
thereport'skeymessage:Dronesareterrorizinganentirecivilianpopulation.
Iwasoneoftheresearchersforthestudy,andspentweeksinPakistaninterviewingmorethan60
peoplefromNorthWaziristan.Manyweresurvivorsofstrikes.Othershadlostlovedonesandfamily
members.Allofthemliveundertheconstantthreatofannihilation.
WhatmycolleaguesandIlearnedfromtheseunnamedandunknown victimsofAmerica'sdrone
warfaregavethereportitstitle:"LivingUnderDrones."
PeopleintheUnitedStatesimaginethatdronesflytoatarget,launchtheirdeadlymissileswith
surgicalprecisionandreturntoaU.S.basehundredsorthousandsofmilesaway.Butdronesarea
constantpresenceintheskiesabovetheNorthWaziristantribalareainPakistan,withasmanyassix
hoveringovervillagesatanyonetime.Peoplehearthemdayandnight.Theyareaninescapable
presence,theloomingspecterofdeathfromabove.
AndthatpresenceissteadilydestroyingacommunitytwicethesizeofRhodeIsland.Parentsareafraid
tosendtheirchildrentoschool.Womenareafraidtomeetinmarkets .Familiesareafraidtogatherat
funeralsforpeoplewronglykilledinearlierstrikes.Driversareafraidtodeliverfoodfromotherparts
ofthecountry.
Theroutinesofdailylifehavebeenrippedtoshreds.Indisputablyinnocentpeoplecowerintheir
homes,afraidtoassembleonthestreets."Doubletaps ,"orsecondarystrikesonthesametarget,have
stoppedresidentsfromaidingthosewhohavebeeninjured.Aleadinghumanitarianagencynowdelays
assistancebyanastonishingsixhours.
Whatmakesthissituationevenworseisthatnoonecantellpeopleinthesecommunitieswhattheycan
dotomakethemselvessafe.NooneknowswhoisontheAmericankilllist,nooneknowshowthey
gotthereandnooneknowswhattheycandotogetthemselvesoff.It'sallterrifyinglyrandom.
Suddenly,andwithoutwarning,amissilelaunchesandobliterateseveryonewithina16yardradius.
Naturally,theObamaadministrationclaimsitstrikesonlymilitants.Butifwehavelearnedanything
since9/11,itisthatwemustallreadthefineprint.Whatpeopledonotappreciateisthatthe
administrationdefinesmilitantsasallmilitaryagemales,typicallythosebetween18and65.In
addition,becausetheU.S.generallydoesnotreleasethenamesofpeoplewhohavebeenkilled,we
cannotknowwhetherthevictimswereactuallymilitantsorweredeemedmilitantssimplybecause
Washingtonsaystheywere.
Indeed,theentireprocessisriddledwiththesamesortofflawsthatbesetthedetentionregimeatthe
militaryprisoninGuantanamoBay,Cuba.InAfghanistan,theBushadministrationpaidenormous
bountiesinanefforttogetinformationontheground.Inareasrifewithtribalandfamilialrivalries,the
resultwaspredictable:HundredsofinnocentpeoplewerewronglyfingeredasTalibanorAlQaeda,
manyofwhomspentyearsatGuantanamoorotherAmericanprisonsoverseas.
NowtheUnitedStatesisofferingsimilarincentivestopeopleinNorthWaziristanwhopromiseto
identifymilitants.Theallegedmilitants'homesaretaggedbyGPStrackersandlater,whenthe
informantisatasafedistance,blowntosmithereens.Andbecausenooneknowswhotheinformants
are,peoplearereluctanttoinviteneighborsintotheirhomes.Theentirecommunitywithdrawsfrom
thepublicsquare,afraidtoventureoutbutequallyafraidtobringtheoutsidein.
Thisiswhatitmeanstoliveunderdrones.IthasturnedNorthWaziristanintotheworld'slargest
prison,amassiveoccupiedzone.AhumanitarianworkerwhowasinNewYorkon9/11andisnow
workinginNorthWaziristantoldusthattheatmosphereinthetwoplacesfeelsverymuchthesame.
Theconstantsenseofterrorisafeelingthatknowsnoboundaries.
Ofcourse,weshouldaskwhetherdronesarelegalunderinternationallaw;myviewisthattheyare
not.Ofcourse,weshouldaskwhetherdronesarecounterproductive;myviewisthattheyare.
Butnodiscussionoftheissueisremotelycompleteunlesswecometogripswithwhatitmeanstobe
livingunderdrones.
JenniferGibsonisastaffattorneywithReprieve,aLondonbasedlegalcharitythatrepresentsdozens
ofPakistanidronevictims.ShewaspartoftheStanfordresearchteamthatvisitedPakistanandisa
coauthorof"LivingUnderDrones."
http://articles.latimes.com/2012/oct/04/opinion/laoegibsondronescivilians20121004