Green Guide Growing
Green Guide Growing
Green Guide Growing
State of Victoria through the Department of Environment and Primary Industries 2014
Except for any logos, emblems and trademarks, this work (Growing Green Guide: A guide to green roofs, walls and facades in Melbourne and Victoria, Australia) is licensed
under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 Australia licence, to the extent that it is protected by copyright. Authorship of this work must be
attributed to the State of Victoria, through the VAS Partnership, the Inner Melbourne Action Plan and the University of Melbourne. To view a copy of this licence, visit
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/4.0/
National Library of Australia Cataloguing-in-Publication data
Growing Green Guide: A guide to green roofs, walls and facades in Melbourne and Victoria, Australia
ISBN 978-1-74326-714-1 (Print)
ISBN 978-1-74326-715-8 (pdf)
Trademarks acknowledgment
Terms mentioned in this report that are known to be trademarks, whether registered or unregistered, have been indicated. Where trademarks are registered in Australia, this
has been noted by the addition of the symbol. The symbol is used where a mark is not registered. While all care has been taken in identifying trademarks in this guide,
users should rely on their own inquiries to determine ownership of trademarks, whether registered or unregistered, and the goods and services on which a mark is used or
which are covered by any registration.
Disclaimer
The information published in this guide is provided by the Growing Green Guide
partners to disseminate information in regards to the design, construction and
maintenance of green roofs, walls and facades. It is not, and does not purport to be,
a complete guide and is not a substitute for professional advice.
The design, construction and installation of green roofs, walls and facades is subject
to the relevant authorities granting the required permits, approvals and consents;
specific information should therefore be obtained from such authorities prior to the
commencement of any such projects.
The Growing Green Guide project partners (City of Melbourne, City of Stonnington,
City of Yarra, City of Port Phillip, the State of Victoria and The University of
Melbourne) and their employees do not guarantee that the publication is without
flaw of any kind or is wholly appropriate for your particular purposes, and therefore
disclaims all liability for any error, loss or other consequence which may arise from
you relying on any information in this publication.
Reference to any organisation in this guide is not to be construed as an endorsement
or recommendation of any information, goods or services supplied by that
organisation.
The Growing Green Guide partners accept no responsibility to you or anyone else
arising from any act or omission of any third party referred to in this booklet or any
loss, including damage or injury, when using and/or obtaining information, goods or
services.
The information contained in this guide is based on information available at the time
of writing. It is liable to change and we do not and cannot guarantee its currency.
The project partners reserve the right to make changes to the guide at any time.
Foreword
by Sidonie Carpenter
Foreword
Preface
ii
Acknowledgements
SECTION
iii
Introduction
01
Introduction
02
03
04
Definitions
04
08
11
SECTION
02
Evidence
15
Figure 3. Sensible heat flux under different roof treatments and albedo
15
Figure 4. Effect of a green roof on heat transfer for different types of roof construction
16
16
Figure 6. Heating and cooling energy demand in a room under a bare and a green roof 17
Figure 7. Internal room temperatures under different roof types
18
19
20
21
Figure 8. Theoretical graph comparing stormwater run-off from a bare roof and
green roof
Figure 9. Rainfall retention under three roof treatments for rain events of
different intensity
Figure 10. Rainfall retained by different types of green roofs
21
22
22
23
Figure 12. Rainfall retention on a green roof under different rainfall scenarios
23
24
24
25
26
Property value
26
27
1. Introduction
30
2. Site Analysis
31
SECTION
03
24
Technical Guide
32
34
34
35
2.3 Drainage
36
36
36
37
37
37
38
38
39
41
43
44
45
46
46
48
50
51
52
Figure 15. The substrate depth on a green roof influences the plant types
that can be used
Table 7. Suitable plants for green roofs in Victoria
Table 8. Suitable plants for green walls in Victoria
Figure 16. Climbing plants used on green facades
Table 9. Suitable plants for green facades in Victoria
53
56
59
60
61
62
63
64
64
65
65
66
67
68
69
70
71
Root barrier
Protection mat
71
71
72
72
73
74
75
75
76
77
78
78
79
79
80
81
82
83
84
84
6.2 Waterproofing
6.3 Irrigation and plant nutrition
6.4 Vegetation
6.5 Special considerations for walls
85
86
87
87
88
89
Figure 23. Support structures for green facades grown with twining climbers
89
90
90
91
8. Maintenance
92
93
94
95
96
SECTION
04
100
103
106
108
111
114
117
120
122
Appendix A
125
126
126
127
128
128
Glossary
129
130
ii
Preface
The Growing Green Guide (the guide) has been developed with advice from industry experts and knowledge from academic research,
to explain how to create high quality green roofs, walls and facades.
The development of the guide was supported by four inner Melbourne local governments through the Inner Melbourne Action Plan (the
cities of Melbourne, Port Phillip, Yarra and Stonnington) and by the State Government of Victoria, through the Victorian Adaptation and
Sustainability Partnership. The University of Melbourne is a project partner.
This guide is written for professionals who may be involved in the design, construction and maintenance of green roofs, walls and/or
facades. It is also relevant to developers, homeowners, and local and state governments.
The guide is targeted at projects based in Melbourne and Victoria, Australia, but is also largely relevant for a wider geographic area.
The Growing Green Guide is released under a Creative Commons licence to encourage periodic updates and use of the information in a
range of places.
Section 01
Explains what green roofs, walls and facades are, why they are important and the potential
benefits of these systems for Melbourne and Victoria. It also provides answers to some
frequently asked questions.
Section 02
Introduces some of the research that has been undertaken on green roofs, walls and facades to
provide a more specific understanding of their potential benefits.
Section 03
Was written in collaboration with industry experts to provide technical advice on the design,
construction and maintenance of green roofs, walls and facades.
Section 04
Highlights several existing green roofs, walls and facades in Melbourne and Victoria, as case
studies. Each example provides a description of the project, its design and components used,
maintenance, cost and results and reflections.
iii
Acknowledgements
The primary authors of this guide are Julie Francis (City
of Melbourne), Gail Hall (City of Melbourne), Sue Murphy
(University of Melbourne) and John Rayner (University of
Melbourne). Significant contributions were also provided from
the Guidelines Reference Group (see below) and support
was provided from the wider project team: Meg Jones (City of
Stonnington), Elissa McElroy (Inner Melbourne Action Plan), Kevin
Ayrey (City of Yarra), Lalitha Ramachandran and Nick Alsop (City
of Port Phillip) and staff from the Department of Environment
and Primary Industries.
This guide was put together with the assistance of a reference
group of experts on green roofs, walls and facades, including:
Nic Culnane, The Committee for Melbourne
Phil Edwards, Melbourne Water
Jock Gammon, Junglefy
Ken Hitchcock, KHD Landscape Engineering Solutions
Sam Innes, City of Port Phillip
Rafael Katigbak, Ronstan Tensile Architecture
Euan Laird, Nursery and Garden Industry of Victoria
Matthew Mackay, Hassell Pty Ltd
Carlo Missio, GHD Pty Ltd
Ben Nicholson, Groof Consulting
Clare Parry, Umow Lai
Merran Porjazoski, Bent Architecture
Warwick Savvas, ASPECT Studios
Nick Somes, Ecodynamics Pty Ltd
Erik van Zuilekom, Fytogreen
Scott Watson, VicRoads
Ralph Webster, Pad Creations
SECTION
01
Image: Fytogreen
An introduction to
green roofs, walls
and facades
Green roof for apartment residents at Freshwater Place, Queensbridge Square, Southbank, Melbourne
introduction
Green roofs, walls and facades are becoming more common in cities across the
globe. Growing numbers of Australians are realising the potential of these living
systems to improve the quality of their built environment to provide social,
aesthetic, environmental and economic benefits.
Introduction
Figure 1. Pressure builds over our cities, with the transition from natural landscapes to hard
infrastructure, an increasingly variable climate and a growing population
Hotter Cities
Heat-related illness & death.
Poor city liveability
Flooding
Extreme rainfall and fewer
permeable spaces clogs drains
& leads to localised flooding
Introduction
Figure 2. Vegetation can be added to a building as green roof, green wall or green facade
Definitions
Green roof
A vegetated landscape built up from a series of layers that are
installed on a roof surface as loose laid or modular (that is, installed
layer by layer on the roof or as pre-prepared layers in trays).
Green roofs are constructed for multiple reasons - as spaces for
people to use, as architectural features, to add value to property
or to achieve particular environmental benefits (for example,
stormwater capture and retention, improved species diversity,
insulation of a building against heat gain or loss).
Vegetation on green roofs is planted in a growing substrate
(a specially designed soil substitution medium) that may range
in depth from 50 mm to more than a metre, depending on the
weight capacity of the buildings roof and the aims of the design.
Green roofs have traditionally been categorised as extensive
or intensive.
Extensive green roofs are lightweight with a shallow layer of
growing substrate of less than 200 mm deep, requiring minimal
maintenance. They generally have lower water requirements and
use small, low-growing plant species, particularly succulents (see
images 1 and 5 opposite). Ecoroofs or brown roofs are terms
used to describe these extensive green roofs. Roofs that are
designed and planted specifically to increase local plant diversity
and provide habitat (food and shelter) for wildlife are known as
biodiverse green roofs (see image 3 opposite).
Intensive green roofs are generally heavier, with a deeper layer
of growing substrate, and support a wider variety of plant types
Introduction
1 Council House 2 in Melbourne has a non-irrigated, non-trafficable green roof comprised of modular trays
2 The demonstration green roof at The University of Melbourne, Burnley campus, is an accessible roof used by staff and students.
It demonstrates different irrigation regimes, growing substrates and plant species
3 A small-scale green roof at a public amenity block in Healesville, designed as an architectural feature and for biodiversity - it includes
indigenous species with the intent to create habitat. Image: Fytogreen
4 Lady Gowrie Child Care Centre, Docklands, is a roof garden designed for use and play. Image: City of Melbourne
5 The Venny, Kensington is a non accessible, light weight green roof with solar panels. Image: Andrew Wutke
Introduction
Green wall
A green wall is comprised of plants grown in supported vertical
systems that are generally attached to an internal or external wall,
although in some cases can be freestanding. Like many green roofs,
green walls incorporate vegetation, growing medium, irrigation
and drainage into a single system. Green walls differ from green
facades in that they incorporate multiple containerised plantings
to create the vegetation cover rather than being reliant on fewer
numbers of plants that climb and spread to provide cover. They
are also known as living walls, bio-walls or vertical gardens.
Green walls provide an attractive design feature, but also add to
building insulation by direct shading of the wall surface. They create
cooler microclimates and improve local air quality, and provide the
possibility of growing plants in locations that would not normally
support vegetation. A wide range of plants is used on green walls,
usually herbaceous, though some small shrubs can also be suitable.
1 Artificial lighting is an important element for this internal green wall in the foyer of Telstras Melbourne headquarters. Image: Fytogreen
2 Victorias Environmental Protection Authority has a green wall outside its head office in Carlton, signalling their interest in sustainability and a
visible cue to the buildings 6 star Green Star rating
3 Illura Apartments in West Melbourne have four green walls facing north-east, which helps to shade the wall surface in summer. Image: Fytogreen
4 The internal green wall is a design feature in the foyer of The Gauge, Docklands. Source: PAD Creations
Introduction
Green facade
A green facade is created by growing climbing plants up and across
the facade of a building, either from plants grown in garden beds
at its base, or by container planting installed at different levels
across the building (see image 4 below).
1 A wire mesh structure supports this green facade at the RMIT University City campus 2 Green facades are used as a screen to cover a
bland wall on the green roof at Crown Casino, Southbank 3 This climbing plant attaches directly to the facade of Victoria Barracks, St Kilda
Road, Melbourne 4 Twining plants are used to create a multi-level green facade at Council House 2 in Melbourne. Planter boxes located on
each balcony allow the facade to extend to the full height of the building 5 Deciduous climbing species provide an attractive feature in autumn
at the University of Melbournes Burnley campus 6 A climbing plant (with a scrambling habit) is used on this free-standing green facade in
Brisbane, Queensland
Introduction
Stormwater management
Green roofs absorb and retain rainwater and can be used to manage stormwater run-off in
urban environments. They can also filter particulates and pollutants. Stormwater run-off can be
reduced or slowed because it is stored in the substrate, used by or stored in the foliage, stems
and roots of plants, and also evaporates directly from the substrate. Additional water storage
capacity in green roof systems can be provided through incorporation of a water retentive layer
or drainage layer at the base of the green roof.
Several factors influence the extent to which a green roof can reduce the volume of water runoff into the stormwater system, including depth and properties of the growing substrate, type
of drainage layer used and roof slope. Plants and drainage systems are important considerations
in the design of a green roof for stormwater management. Details on research supporting
stormwater management are provided in Section 2.
Introduction
10
Introduction
Next Steps
Read the frequently asked questions and the rest of the guide to understand the details of green roof, wall or facade systems,
or seek advice from a professional in the industry to learn more about approaches that may be suitable to achieve particular
identified aims for your site.
Section 2 details some evidence of the benefits of green roofs, walls and facades. In Section 3, technical advice is provided
on how to design, construct and maintain green roofs, walls and facades. Finally, Section 4 provides detailed case studies of a
selection of Victorian green roof, wall and facade projects to give practical examples of design, construction and maintenance.
11
FAQ
Introduction
12
FAQ
Introduction
Will construction of
a green roof, wall or
facade cause delays in
the construction of my
building?
Although a green roof, wall or facade
should be considered an integral
component of a building, its construction
can usually be done independently from
the rest of the build, so it poses little risk
in causing delays. It is very important
to include the installation specialists in
early design discussions and associated
construction project timelines to establish
the most efficient construction timetable
and ensure that drainage, irrigation and
lighting are designed to include the green
roof, wall or facade.
How do I know if my
building has the capacity
for a green roof?
An architect, engineer and green roof
provider are needed to ascertain that
a green roof can be installed on a new
building. To retrofit a green roof on an older
building, consultation with an architect
and/or structural engineer is necessary to
determine the load-bearing capacity of the
structure. Consult with green roof, wall or
facade providers to discuss design ideas
and solutions for the site.
SECTION
02
Evidence-based
benefits of green
roofs, walls and
facades
14
Evidence
15
Evidence
treatment using reflective white paint was 10 times higher than for
the green roof, although its albedo was almost five times greater.
The sensible heat flux across the white roof surface is small
because most solar radiation is reflected, and little is absorbed.
Sensible heat flux across the green roof is small because of loss
of latent heat through evaporation of water from plants and the
growing substrate, even though the amount of solar radiation
absorbed is high. Grey paint and concrete have similar reflectance,
but heat flux with alternative cool roof paint (reflective grey) was
greater than the bare concrete roof alone.
Figure 3. Sensible heat flux under different roof treatments and albedo (ability to reflect solar radiation)
100
90
80
70
60
50
40
30
20
10
0
Albedo
:;<n/3-9-
1
0.9
0.8
0.7
0.6
0.5
0.4
0.3
0.2
0.1
0
Lawn
;<=n04.t.
-./.012.
w?it.
paint
Lawn
16
Evidence
Figure 4. Effect of a green roof on heat transfer (thermal conductance) modelled for different types of
roof construction
20
bare roof
18
Thermal
conductance
(U-value;
W/m2K)
16
14
12
10
25
cm
concrete
8
6
4
2
0
cm
concrete
concrete
2525
cm
roof deck
10 cm concrete
roof deck
Source: Niachou A,
Papakonstantinou
K, Santamouris M,
Tsangrassoulis
A,
bare
roof
Mihalakakou G, (2001)
with
green
roof
Analysis of the green roof
thermal properties and
investigation of its energy
performance, Energy and
Buildings 33: 719-729.
>10
cm
concrete
eck
sandwich
with
10
cm
10roof
cmdconcrete
:a<er
roofins9:a;on
deck with
10 cm
insulation layer
Figure 5. A comparison of thermal effects on a green roof under different types of vegetation cover
400
Total heat gain
350
300
250
200
150
100
50
0
bare
hard
bare
hard
surface bare soil
surface
turf
tree
tree
shrub
17
Evidence
Figure 6. Heating and cooling energy demand in a room under a bare roof and a green roof
Heating Energy
Cooling Energy
Cooling Energy
5000
1000
4000
800
3000
Axis Title
3ea4ng Energy
2000
1000
600
roof
Test
room
+
bare
400
200
Source: Chen and Williams (2009) Green roofs as an adaptation to climate change: modelling the green roof at the Burnley campus,
The University of Melbourne, Research Report for CSIRO Climate Adaptation Flagship.
18
Evidence
Internal
room
Internal
room
temperature
(C)
temperature
(C)
30
25
Figure 7. Internal temperature effects of different roof types
20
30
15
25
10
20
5
Under
metal
roof
15
0
10
5
0
Under
green
roof
Source:
Parizotto
S & Lamberts R (2011) Investigation of
green roof thermal performance in a temperate climate:
a case study of an experimental building in Florianpolis
city, Southern Brazil, Energy and Buildings 43:1712-1722.
Experimental green roof on ANZ House, Adelaide, with trafficable aluminium grating 150 mm above the substrate
19
Evidence
Parameter measured
Outcome
Source: Prez G, Rincn L, Vila A, Gonzlez JM, Cabeza LF (2011) Behaviour of green facades in Mediterranean Continental climate, Energy
Conversion and Management 52:18611867.
20
Evidence
21
Evidence
Figure 8. Theoretical graph comparing stormwater run-off from a bare roof and green roof
22
Evidence
Figure 9. Rainfall retention under three roof treatments for rain events of different intensity
100
Retained
rainfall
(as
%
of
total)
90
80
70
60
50
40
30
20
10
0
Light
(<2
mm)
Medium (2-6mm)
Type
of
rain
event
(volume
in
mm)
100
90
80
70
60
50
40
30
20
10
0
Bare
roofs
Bare
roofs
Ballasted
roofs
Extensive
Extensive
green
roofs
green roofs
Intensive
green roofs
Note: When considering international research results, keep in mind climate differences to Australia.
Many European and North American green roofs have very shallow substrates, such as the 2.5 cm deep
substrates described in Figure 9. In Melbourne conditions, a minimum depth of 10 cm is recommended for
a green roof substrate. Shallower substrates are likely to dry out too quickly, and plants will not survive.
23
Evidence
90
80
70
60
50
40
30
20
10
0
Medium (2-6mm)
Light
(<2
mm)
Type
of
rain
event
(volume
in
mm)
2%
slope
6.5% slope
100
90
80
70
60
50
Bare roof
40
Green roof
30
20
10
0
2.4
mm
rain
event
in
55
min
512.1
mm
rain
event
in
145
min
24
Evidence
in run-off from the bare roof is most likely due to the wash
down of contaminants in the first flush run-off after rain begins.
The greater surface area for potential capture and storage of
these contaminants on a green roof (on foliage, in the substrate)
reduces the nutrient loading entering stormwater run-off. In Table
2, the green roof included mixed herbaceous perennials, including
succulents, planted into 10.2 cm deep substrate held in modular
boxes that were installed on a roof. In Table 3, succulent species
were installed on a vegetated mat over 10 cm deep substrate.
Nutrient
content
Total N
(mg/l)
Total P
(mg/l)
Nutrient
content
Total N
(mg/l)
Total P
(mg/l)
Rainfall
0.51
0.007
Rainfall
0.6 - 1.3
0.012 - 0.019
Bare roof
run-off
0.896
0.197
Bare roof
run-off
1.4 - 2.6
0.102 - 0.104
Green roof
run-off
0.49
0.043
Green roof
run-off
1.2 - 2.1
0.026 - 0.09
25
Evidence
roof areas with deeper substrates was of higher quality than that
off shallow substrates, lower total dissolved salts and electrical
conductivity, and there were lower sediment levels. However, there
was also a trend for elevated nitrogen (measured as nitrate) and
phosphorus concentrations in run-off from green roofs with deep
substrates: these nutrients are highly soluble so their appearance
in run-off is expected, but given that fertiliser application was the
same for both the shallow and deep substrates, it is noteworthy
that the deeper substrate did not provide greater nutrient
retention. Comparison of measured run-off quality against local,
state and national water guidelines suggest that green roof runoff could be recycled for irrigation and other non-potable use.
A link to the report is available from the Government of South
Australias Building Innovation Fund ANZ House Green Roof Trials
Stormwater Quality Monitoring.
26
Evidence
Cities are noisy places to live in: construction, vehicular traffic and
the sounds of HVAC (heating, ventilation and air-conditioning)
equipment are constant features of Melbournes aural landscape.
Modelling studies show that although green roofs provide some
attenuation of noise, it is small: up to a maximum of 10 dB across
most of the frequency ranges that have been tested. Tests on a
range of green wall and facade systems in Singapores HortPark
revealed a similar outcome. So far, for green roofs, there is no
evidence for increased sound absorption beyond a substrate
depth of 20 cm (up to 40 cm). Any small decrease in the volume
of outside noise is an additional, unsolicited benefit of a green
roof, wall or facade. It has been suggested that the University of
Tasmanias green roof was a significant factor in sound reduction
emanating from its site, however the building had a number of
other technologies installed to reduce sound transmission, so
results cannot be attributed to the green roof alone.
Sources: Van Renterghem T, Botteldooren D (2008) Numerical
evaluation of sound propagating over green roofs, Journal of Sound
and Vibration 317:781-799; Wong NH, Tan AYK, Tan PY, Chang K,
Wong NC (2010) Acoustics evaluation of vertical greenery systems
for building walls, Building and Environment 45:411-420. Hopkins G,
Goodwin C (2011), Living Architecture, CSIRO Publishing.
Property value
There is very little published research on the impacts of green roofs, walls or facades on property value. Research in Canada estimated
that buildings with a recreational green roof achieve an 11 per cent increase in property value, and buildings with views onto green roofs
have a 4.5 per cent increase in property value.
Source: Tomalty, R. & Komorowski, B. 2010, The Monetary Value of the Soft Benefits of Green Roofs, Smart Cities Research Services, <http://www.
greenroofs.org/resources/Monetary_Value_of_Soft_Benefits_of_Green_Roofs.pdf>
27
Evidence
Green walls were installed on four aspects of the tower block used in the 2013 TV series The Block Sky High, 142 Park St, South Melbourne.
Image: Fytogreen
SECTION
03
Technical Guide
30
Technical Guide
Technical
Guide
Introduction
Refer to the introductory section of this guide for definitions of
green roofs, walls and facades. A glossary of other terms follows
Appendix A at the end of this document.
Including this Introduction, the Technical Guide has been divided
into eight chapters covering the following areas:
If, after reading this guide, it appears that green roofs, walls or
facades are not suitable for a particular building, consider other
greening options, from balcony plantings to backyard and naturestrip gardens. This guide does not cover these options, but many
books and websites are dedicated to these opportunities.
This guide has been published under Creative Commons licencing
as an invitation to others to adapt, update and improve the
guidelines as new technology is developed and research improves
our knowledge.
While it provides the key relevant information on this subject at
its publication, for more detailed information and updates visit the
Growing Green Guide website: www.growinggreenguide.org
The first step in any roof, wall or faade project is to visit the site and understand the local environment and built infrastructure. Image: ASPECT Studios
2. site analysis
Before designing a green roof, wall or facade it is important to understand the
characteristics of the site, as these factors will influence the feasibility and cost.
This chapter explains how to evaluate a proposed location for a green roof, wall
or facade. It is written for situations where there is an existing building on-site,
however it can be adapted by those planning to construct a new building.
32
Site
Site Analysis
Wind
Average wind speeds are greater at height than at ground level. Winds may be strong
around the edges of buildings, or from the down draft caused by tall buildings. It is
necessary to understand the likely wind load that a green roof, wall or facade will be
subjected to, so that it can be built to withstand the forces. Wind at high elevation will
also influence temperature, and wind has a direct dehydrating effect on vegetation,
therefore influencing species selection and irrigation requirements. See the Freshwater
Place and Victorian Desalination Project green roof case studies in this guide to learn more
about the challenges of wind.
Rainfall and
irrigation
Rainfall in Melbourne is generally not sufficient to support a green roof, wall or facade
throughout the year. It is important to establish whether rainwater or another water
source can be harvested from other areas on-site, and stored to supply an irrigation
system. This will avoid or minimise the need to use potable water for irrigation. It is
useful to carry out an irrigation water demand analysis, to estimate water needs.
Solar radiation
Light intensity tends to be greater at height than at ground level. At height there are
fewer structures, no vegetation to absorb solar radiation and increased reflection from
adjoining building and surfaces (such as glass and light-coloured walls). Conversely, there
are some roofs and walls that may receive significantly less solar radiation, due to intense
shading by nearby buildings. Shadowing and shading analysis can be used to assess areas
of light and shade on a site and possible changes over the year (for example, at the
equinox) and over time (for example, adjoining new building development).
Temperature
Microclimate
Enclosed spaces such as urban canyons can create their own microclimate where wind
turbulence, pooling of pollution, humidity and temperature can be intensified. The
localised climate of these areas will change the growing conditions for plants and needs
to be considered when planning and designing green roofs and walls.
33
Site Analysis
Site
34
Site
Site Analysis
For a green roof, wall or facade, the loads that the building structure must support include:
Dead load
The final constructed weight of all built elements and all components associated with the
roof or wall assembly, including plants, growing substrate and any water held in the system.
Live load
The weight of people who will use the space, and of any mobile equipment that will be
used periodically on the site, for example, maintenance (live load generally applies to
green roofs, not facades or walls, however it would be appropriate on a vertical surface
if a trafficable maintenance platform was built into the system).
Translent load
Species
6 - 12
3 - 12
12 - 26
10 - 26
35
Site
Site Analysis
Weight loading
(kg/m)
10.2
10.2 20.4
Turf
5.1
Shrubs up to 3 m
30.6
Small trees up to 6 m
40.8
Medium trees up to 10 m
61.2
Large trees up to 15 m
150
Some load-bearing
capacities used in
design of Melbourne
green roofs and walls
The University of Melbournes demonstration
green roof is designed for use by visitors and
staff. It is built on a heritage-listed brick building in
Burnley. It has areas of deep and shallow substrate
and is designed for a dead load of 300kg/m2 and a
live load of 300kg/m2 on the decking and walkway
mesh and 150kg/m2 on the planting area.
The Venny green roof has shallow substrates on
two types of roof, the first roof is on shipping
containers, and is designed for a dead load of
250kg /m2 and live load of 100kg/m2. The second
trussed roof is designed for a dead load of 160kg/
m2 and a live load of 40kg/m2.
The Triptych external green wall and the Telstra
Conference Centre internal green wall are both
designed for a dead load of 80kg/m2.
36
Site
Site Analysis
2.3 Drainage
Sites for green roofs should be assessed for drainage. Check
whether the site has primary and/or secondary drainage systems
(illustrated in Figure 13).
the roof s design weight loading. The need for overflow relief will
be established by looking at existing performance of the drainage
in conjunction with the historical data on rainfall intensity.
These are collector drains that are designed to flow when only
partly full. Primary drainage systems are not designed to remove
all of the water that falls on a roof during exceptionally heavy rain.
A green roof may require a separately plumbed secondary drainage
system, also known as the overflow relief system. For flat or nearly
flat roofs, primary drains are located at the lowest point of the roof:
flow of water into them is promoted by positive drainage.
Secondary (overflow) drains are located at a higher point on
the roof. These are designed to operate in a worst-case scenario
where the primary drains are completely blocked and water
builds up on the roof due to a torrential downpour of rain and/
or a failure of the irrigation system to shut off. Overflow drains
remove accumulated water to a depth that the roof can carry
without becoming unstable, and ensure that the roof weight
loading capacity is not exceeded. For roofs with a very low
parapet, overflow drainage may be achieved simply by flow over
the roof edges, if accumulation of water to this height fits within
When assessing the site and planning for the design of a drainage
system, consider:
the amount of rainfall that lands directly on the site, and any
that drains onto it from adjacent roofs or walls
length of rainfall event estimated from historical records
and forecasts of future extreme rainfall events under a
warmer climate
the speed at which rainfall will collect at the drains
(determined primarily by roof pitch)
the planned capacity of drains, including the drain dimensions
and diameter of gutters and drainpipes
Ponding
Eaves
gutter
Water
spout
Roof
outlet
Overflow
drain
Internal Drain
37
Site
Site Analysis
2.4 Existing
structure and size
2.6 Nearby
vegetation
2.5 Access
Evaluation of the site should review accessibility. Temporary
access will be needed for machinery, and delivery and storage of
materials during construction. For green roofs or multi-storey wall
and facade greening, this might involve a crane to lift materials
onto the site.
Consider how people will access the installation for maintenance,
viewing or standing on. This might require stairs, lifts and viewing
platforms for the general public or building tenants. It may also
require balustrades, cables for attaching harnesses and ropes (fixed
fall protection), ladders, elevated work platforms independent of
the building, or swing stages mounted on the top of the building
for maintenance personnel. Access for maintenance to walls and
facades can also be considered from below, in which case space
for a temporary elevated work platform is likely to be required.
Further information about site safety is provided in Chapter 4.
Access for passers-by must also be considered, as there are
regulations against vegetation that protrudes onto public space,
and even in the private realm it is important to be aware of
hazards that can be created for people using the space nearby.
38
Site
Site Analysis
Seasonal
considerations
and climate
Local environment
Assessment of opportunities or risks that nearby vegetation will have on the site - fire threat,
weed or pest invasion, biodiversity migration.
Weight loading
Load-bearing capacity.
Estimated transient loads, particularly wind forces.
Drainage
Irrigation
Water collection and storage opportunities, opportunities for delivery of irrigation water and for
co-locating stored water with other grey water systems in the building.
Existing structure
and size
Access
Access to site for cranes and other machinery, and for storage of materials during construction.
Access for maintenance and/ or visitors (consider safety such as a parapet on a
roof and disability access requirements too).
Access to utilities - water, electricity.
Ensure access for passers-by is not impeded.
39
Design
3. design &
planning
The most important decisions about a green roof, wall or facade are made at
the design stage. The benefits of the installation, how easy it will be to build and
maintain and how it will operate day-to-day, all depend on the initial design. This
chapter provides information to help develop a well-considered, achievable
design that will work in the long term.
40
Design
Along with understanding the site conditions (see Chapter 2), other
important issues to consider at the design stage are:
A range of factors needs to be considered when designing a green roof, wall or facade. This residential green roof in Brunswick, Melbourne, was
constructed over a small area due to budget constraints, and was planted with hardy flowering plants because its purpose was aesthetics with
minimal maintenance. Information was sought from green roof providers and the local nursery, prior to construction. The level of detail needed in the
design and planning stage will depend on the scale of the project being undertaken.
41
Design
It should be noted that green roofs, walls and facades will be part
of a broader urban green landscape and their design should ideally
ensure that they contribute to the goals for the surrounding
landscape, along with street trees and other forms of green
infrastructure.
Considerations
Increase depth and water-holding capacity of substrate, use plants with high
water uptake.
Increase weight loading, ensure ready roof access, planning and safety
requirements.
Select leafy plants, provide irrigation, plant around (but do not shade)
solar panels.
Increase substrate depth, provide irrigation, select species for leafy plant cover
in summer (passive heat gain in winter may be increased if the roof is bare in
winter but this strategy increases maintenance and reduces aesthetic benefit).
Produce food
Increase weight loading capacity of the roof, and depth and organic content
of substrate, ensure good access to the site, provide irrigation.
42
Design
Considerations
Consider DIY installations, minimise the size of the system, self-contained units
that recirculate water, systems that can be easily replanted.
Include a variety of species with habitat features such as fruits or nectarproducing flowers, or a niche design that provides protection from predators
for particular species.
Considerations
Use a direct attaching species of plant, grown from the ground at the base
of the wall.
Use deciduous species if heat gain is desired in winter; ensure very leafy
plants, covering the entire wall for providing best shade in summer, particularly
on north and west facing walls; provide a structure at least 100 mm off the
wall of a building for the plants to grow on, leaving an air gap between the
building and green plants to maximise cooling effect.
Produce food
Increase depth and organic content of the substrate, ensure good access to
the site, provide irrigation.
43
Design
44
Design
Edible plants in a rooftop garden in Marion, South Australia (Image: Fifth Creek Studio), at the Pop Up Patch gardening club in
Melbourne, and in a trial of vertical vegetables, in Perth, Western Australia (Image: Walls Alive!)
45
Design
This green roof at the Peter Doherty Institute, Grattan Street, Parkville,
functions as a grey water treatment system. Image: Eco Harvest
46
Design
47
Design
Project manager
Construction manager /
Principal contractor
Horticulturalist
Structural engineer
Builder
Building surveyor
Reviews and approves building plans
Reviews construction for compliance with the regulations
Arranges for Building Permits and Occupancy Permits with
local councils
Landscape manager /
Maintenance manager
48
Design
Green roofs
It should be noted that it is significantly cheaper per square
metre to install a green roof on a new building than to retrofit
an existing building, as the structural load-bearing capacity can
be more easily integrated into a new project compared to
augmenting the structural capacity of an existing building.
Notwithstanding this, it is feasible to retrofit many buildings, either
by providing additional structural supports or a new floating roof
to carry the green roof.
A small green roof (30-50 m2) with reasonable access would cost
between $150 and $400 per square metre to install. This does
not include:
design fees
planning and building permits
permits for lifts and cranes
demolition or relocation of existing infrastructure on the roof
addition of specific hard infrastructure elements, such as
furniture, shade structures, decking, paving, planter boxes or
structures to support climbing or trailing plants
It also assumes that the roof has sufficient structural capacity and
does not require strengthening.
Example costs for strengthening the roof
Existing roofs may require additional strengthening work in order
to accommodate the weight of people, plants, substrate, and other
items. The following rates for strengthening an existing roof can be
used as a guide. Please note that these costs may vary according
to the issues outlined earlier under Cost considerations.
Strengthen concrete roof
slab under trafficable areas
$450 -650/m2
$240/m2
49
Design
$100/m2
$20-30/m2
$100-$500/m2
Edge restraints
$50/lin.m
$200- 400/m2
Balustrading
$150-$300/lin.m
$25,000
Green walls
DIY individual wall components for retail sale may be relatively
cheap, at $160/m2 for the system and $150/m2 for the substrate,
plants and irrigation system.
Green facades
Professionally installed green facades will cost from $400/m2
upwards. DIY facades can be established more cheaply.
Example costs of individual components of
green facades
The following rates for green facade components can be used as
a guide. Please note that these costs may vary according to issues
outlined earlier under Cost considerations.
$150-$350/m2
$100-150/m2
$10,000
50
Design
Building
Local laws
Compliance with laws of the local council is required during the
building and maintenance of green roofs, walls or facades. Laws
will often address issues related to:
51
Design
52
Design
53
Design
Figure 15. The substrate depth on a green roof influences the plant types that can be used
Low growing
succulents
Substrate can be as
shallow as 50150 mm
Annual to biennial
plants, herbaceous
perennials
Substrate deeper than
150 mm
Small shrubs
& turf
Substrate deeper than
250 mm
Shrubs up to 2 m
Small trees
54
Design
Herbaceous perennials
This category includes a range of non-woody plants, many with persistent roots or
underground stems (such as rhizomes and stolons, etc.) that enable the plant to regrow
and persist for many years. The most useful herbaceous perennials for Melbourne green
roofs are those originating from dryland habitats. Flowering perennials are used mainly
for display and seasonal interest, and many indigenous flowering plants used will also have
significant habitat values. Ornamental grasses and grass-like plants, especially those forming
upright tussocks, provide useful contrasts in texture and form and can be managed through
pruning to maintain their shape and habit. Some may have high water needs over summer
and large biomass forms could present a fire hazard in some locations.
Geophytes (bulbs, corms, and tubers) are another group of herbaceous perennials that
can be extremely useful, particularly for seasonal interest and display. Many of the spring
and autumn flowering geophytes are also summer dormant, making them particularly useful
drought avoiders over the warmer months of the year. Larger succulents with upright growth
habits are also useful for green roofs, although their mass over time can be considerable.
While many herbaceous perennials can be grown in substrate depths as little as 150 mm,
irrigation will be needed for long-term success at these depths. Some caution is needed in
the use of plants with vigorous rhizomes or stolons (such as some Bamboo species); they
can become excessively dominant and damage green roof profile layers.
55
Design
Turf
Some green roofs are constructed specifically to support sports turf. Careful species
selection is needed to ensure outcomes can be met: the surface and play requirements
are much more demanding than for amenity turf.
Sports turf requires a designed soil or growing medium to ensure effective drainage and a
substrate depth of at least 250 mm. It also requires regular irrigation, fertilising and mowing
to maintain sward performance and health. Many facility managers seek expert advice on
the use of sports turf on green roofs to ensure design outcomes and maintenance can be
properly resourced and managed. On smaller scale green roofs, species with excessive vigour,
such as Couch Grass (Cynodon dactylon) and Kikuyu (Pennisetum clandestinum), should be
avoided: their rhizomes can be invasive and may damage waterproofing membranes.
Small shrubs
Shrubs to one metre in height are best used in substrate depths of 250 mm or more.
Small shrubs provide cover, display and habitat values, and often form the bulk of plantings
used on green roofs with deep substrates. Increasing the substrate depth and irrigation will
also increase the range of plants that can be used successfully. Excessively vigorous species
should be avoided unless there will be sufficient maintenance to manage their growth, some
low hedging plants could be in this category.
Cotoneaster dammeri
Shrubs
Shrubs up to two metres high can be used where substrate depths are at least 600 mm.
They provide screening, space definition, ground coverage and seasonal flowers. Like any
plant group, shrubs require careful selection and consideration of their maintenance needs.
Plants with dense, upright habits should only be used where there is minimal wind exposure
and/or significant protection can be afforded to support the canopy and prevent wind
forces. Hedges and screening shrubs will require regular maintenance, including pruning
and removal of biomass off the roof.
Juniperus sabina
Trees
While many small trees (to five metres) can be successfully grown on substrate depths
of 600 mm, depths of 1,000 mm or greater will ensure the best outcomes are achieved.
Trees are dominant elements in any landscape, and on a green roof trees will generally
be stunted in height and spread, when compared to those planted at ground level. The
greater the roof exposure and overall site hostility, the more important tree selection
becomes. Trees with sparse canopies, flexible stems and high tolerance to heat are best in
areas of high wind exposure, although some form of anchorage will always be needed to
manage them successfully.
56
Design
Examples
Crassula multicava
Sedum mexicanum, S. reflexum, S. sexangulare
Herbaceous perennials
Type
Examples
Upright flowering
perennials
Low, spreading
ground covers
Dichondra repens
Einadia nutans
Eutaxia microphylla
Grevillea lanigera
Kennedia prostrata
Myoporum parvifolium
Senecio spathulatus
Viola hederacea
Aptenia cordifolia
Cerastium tomentosum
Convolvulus sabatius
Glechoma hederacea
Tradescantia pallida Purpurea
Thymus pseudolanuginosus, T. serpyllum
Geophytes (bulbs,
corms, tubers, etc)
Arthropodium milleflorum
Bulbine bulbosa, B. crassa, B. vagans
Pelargonium rodneyanum
Larger succulents
(upright and
rosette forms)
Aeonium arboreum
Aeonium haworthii
Aloe mitriformis
Aloe Gemini
Aloe brevifolia
57
Design
Examples
Grasses
Dichelachne crinita
Orthrosanthus multiflorus
Helictotrichon sempervirens
Miscanthus cultivars
Flowering plants
with grass-like
foliage
Anigozanthos cultivars
Conostylis species and cultivars
D. caerulea, Dianella revoluta, D. tasmanica species
and cultivars
Ficinia nodosa
Lomandra micrantha, L. multifida and cultivars
Poa hiemata
Stypandra glauca
Themeda triandra
Armeria maritima
Sisirhynchum cultivars
Iris unguicularis
Liriope species and cultivars
Ophiopogon japonicus
Examples
Culinary herbs
and vegetables
Ocimum basilicum
Petroselinum crispum
Salvia officinalis, S. Greek Skies
Thymus vulgaris
Origanum vulgare
Turf
Type
Examples
Amenity turf
Zoysia macrantha
Stenotaphrum secundatum
Zoysia species
Festuca arundinacea
Sports turf
Cynodon dactylon
Pennisetum clandestinum
Digitaria didactyla
Lolium perenne
58
Design
Shrubs
Type
Examples
Small shrubs
(to 1 m)
Acacia amblygona
Correa glabra, C. reflexa, C. decumbens and cultivars
Olearia axillaris
Plectranthus argentatus
Buxus sempervirens and B. microphylla species and
cultivars
Cotoneaster dammeri
Erysimum xcherei
Gaura lindheimeri species and cultivars
Helichrysum italicum
Lavandula species and cultivars
Nandina domestica Nana
Plectranthus ciliatus, P. parviflorus
Salvia chamaedryoides, S. microphylla species and
cultivars
Santolina magonica, S. chamaecyparissus, S.
neapolitana cultivars
Teucrium marum
Shrubs (to 2 m)
Escallonia cultivars
Juniperus horizontalis, J. sabina
Leonotis leonurus
Nandina domestica
Pittosporum tobira
Raphiolepis umbellata, R. indica species and cultivars
Rosmarinus species and cultivars
Viburnum tinus
Examples
Trees
Cussonia paniculata
Jacaranda mimosifolia
Lagerstroemia indica xfauerii cultivars
Malus ioensis Plena
Metrosideros excelsa
Pyrus salicifolia
Quercus ilex, Q. suber, Q. coccifera
Geijera parviflora
Ulmus parvifolia
Olea europaea Tolleys Upright or Swan Hill
Laurus nobilis
Tree-like forms
Dracaena draco
Yucca gigantea
59
Design
Shrubs
Correa cultivars
Escallonia cultivars
Ficus species
Metrosideros excelsa Nana
Evergreen
herbaceous
perennials
Spathiphyllum cultivars
Philodendron Winterbourn and
Xanadu
Monstera species
Liriope species and cultivars
Schleffera species
Viola species
Erigeron karvinskianus
Chlorophytum comosum
Peperomia species
Plectranthus species
Rhipsalis species
Bromeliad species
Orchid species
Herbaceous
ground covers
Epipremnum species
Plectranthus ciliatus
Ferns
Asplenium species
Blechnum species
Davallia pyxidata
Humata tyermanii
Nephrolepis species
Grass-like
foliage forms
60
Design
Climatic factors
Species tolerant of low light are required for deeply shaded urban
canyons while high light tolerance is needed in exposed and
elevated settings. Generally, direct sunlight is considered to be four
hours of sun per day and most species will require at least some
direct sunlight to grow.
Facades can be established in areas of full shade, but the range
of species that will grow in these conditions is limited. Facades
at high elevation, in coastal areas or urban street canyons can be
exposed to strong and frequent wind. Some plant species, twining
climbers in particular, are more tolerant of wind and more mature
plants tend to be more resilient in these environments. Selfclinging facades may be pulled away from the wall in very windy
conditions. Small-leafed species with strongly attached foliage may
be more suitable on sites prone to strong blasts of wind: large
foliage may be stripped or shredded in these conditions.
Figure 16. Climbing plants used on green facades have different modes of attachment
Self-clinging plants
attach directly to
the building facade
61
Design
Long-term maintenance
The plants lifecycle and growth rate will affect the time it takes for
the facade to establish and the amount of ongoing maintenance
required. Consider the mature size of the species as well as the
level of foliage coverage required. Many climbing species exhibit
early rapid growth but slower mature growth rates. Some green
facade plants, such as Creeping Fig (Ficus pumila), require rejuvenation
pruning to ensure juvenile foliage is maintained. With this species,
adult foliage grows horizontally, does not attach directly to the
building and creates a deeper, denser canopy of woody stems.
While this may provide effective shading and create an insulating
layer of air between the foliage and the building, it is inherently
unstable because this canopy is not directly attached to the building.
Woody climbers need careful selection as maintenance needs often
increase over time, as stems grow larger and thicker and the plant
increases in size: for example, Wisteria sinensis and Vitis vinifera.
Type
Light Tolerance
Akebia quinata
Twining
Average
Aphanopetalum resinosum
Twining
Average
Cissus antarctica
Tendril
Clematis aristata
Twining
Clematis armandii
Twining
Average
Clematis montana*
Twining
Average
Distichtus buccinatoria
Tendril
Ficus pumila
Self-clinger
Hibbertia scandens
Twining
Muehlenbeckia complexa
Twining
Average
Kennedia rubicunda
Twining
Pandorea pandorana
Twining
Average
Pandorea jasminoides
Twining
Average
Parthenocissus quinquefolia*
Self-clinger
Average
Parthenocissus tricuspidata*
Self-clinger
Podranea ricasoliana
Scandent shrub
Vitis vinifera*
Tendril
Trachelospermum jasminoides
Twining
Average
Wisteria sinensis
Twining
*deciduous
62
Design
Stock that is too advanced or has overgrown its containers has high water
needs and can be slow to establish on a site. Planting stock should be of an
appropriate size to achieve the aims of the project, in terms of growth rate
and coverage. It should also be completely free of weeds, pests and disease.
Plant production in a
high quality growing
medium
In some cases using a medium with similar physical properties to the final
growing substrate will assist in promoting plant growth.
Working in with
seasonal conditions
Establishment irrigation
Weed control
Plants will often establish best on-site, and should not be planted
when they are large as they will grow to cover the site over time
63
Advice
4. Building &
installation
general advice
This chapter provides general advice about building green roofs, walls and
facades, including occupational health and safety, insurance considerations and
what to expect at project completion on a large-scale job which has a project
manager and several consultants.
64
Advice
Working at heights
The design and installation of all green roofs and many green
walls and facades involves work at heights. The associated risks
and responsibilities must be managed through a combination
of training and safety features on the site including the use of
barricades, railings, or other fall arrest systems, such as ropes and
harnesses.
Consult the WorkSafe Victoria Compliance Code Preventing Falls
in General Construction with regard to specific OH&S issues
associated with working at heights and management solutions.
Wherever possible, the risks and hazards of working at heights
should be removed or reduced and the design team must
consider these as part of project planning.
65
Advice
warranty on waterproofing
drawing showing as built planting (the actual planting may
have varied from the design drawings)
certificate of completion from a registered building inspector
certificate of electrical safety from a licensed electrician
(if relevant)
certificate of occupancy (if relevant) from a building
inspector/local council this will relate mainly to safety and
access requirements, including step heights and access points
66
Roofs
Green roof at the Museum of Old and New Art, Hobart. Image: Pad Creations
5. Building &
installation
green roofs
Once the planning and design stages of a green roof are complete, well-planned
construction can deliver the project objectives. This chapter provides specific
information about how to construct a green roof.
67
Roofs
Vegetation Layer
Growing Substrate
Filter Sheet
Drainage Layer
Protection Mat
Root Barrier
Waterproofing
Roof Deck
A green roof contains plants that are grown in a layer of substrate varying in depth from a few centimetres to well over a metre. The growing
substrate is usually composed of a high proportion of mineral particles with a long lifespan, with a small proportion of organic matter. A filter sheet
retains the substrate and prevents washout into the underlying drainage layer. A protection mat and a root barrier may be installed to prevent
damage to the underlying waterproofing membrane that covers the roof deck.
68
Roofs
the existing roof. Drainage from the green roof must connect
directly into the lower level roof drainage system. It may be more
economical to replace the roof to make it suitable for a green roof.
The components installed on the roof deck will be either looselaid over the roof surface or installed as modules that connect
together to form a continuous effect. Individual containers that
are separately placed on a roof deck are considered a roof garden
rather than a green roof, and because they do not cover a significant
proportion of the roof they do not provide most of the benefits
associated with green roofs.
It may be necessary to remove or relocate existing infrastructure
on roof decks, or the green roof can be built around the equipment.
Roof decks can be flat or pitched, and they are commonly made of metal or concrete
69
Roofs
5.2 Waterproofing
A watertight roof is critical to successful green roof construction.
While some roofs are intrinsically waterproof when built, most
will require some form of treatment to prevent water entry into
the building. Waterproofing treatment must provide a strong but
flexible layer that allows expansion under physical or thermal
movements of the building structure, without compromising
watertightness. Vegetation generally should not be installed over
areas such as expansion joints, where regular inspection of the
waterproofing will be necessary.
Advice should be sought from a specialist waterproofing
manufacturer to find the most suitable type of waterproofing
treatment for the roof structure and the proposed green roof
design. The manufacturing and installation of waterproofing
membranes should comply with Australian Standards (see
Chapter 6.2 for more information).
In Australia, waterproofing is likely to be installed by a third party
waterproofing contractor. The involvement of an independent
contractor means that a clear agreement between all parties
must be established for responsibility of the waterproofing
membrane once it has been installed and certified as watertight.
An independent leak detection specialist should test the
waterproofing after its installation, and again after the green roof
build-up is installed, prior to handover (see also Chapter 4.3).
The following tables contrast the two major types of
waterproofing liquid applied treatments and preformed sheets:
70
Roofs
Advantages
Disadvantages
Seamless
Often trafficable
Flexible and capable of elongation
Easy to apply
Tolerant of some degree of surface
imperfection
Easily repaired by re-application over
breaches
Bonded to the roof
Application
methods
Advantages
Loose-laid
Asphalt-based
Fully bonded
torch-down
Partly bonded
Thermo-plastic
Fully bonded
Thermo-setting
Fully bonded
Disadvantages
Upstands are structural penetrations from the roof such as vent pipes that will need to have the waterproofing layer brought up (dressed up) around
them to terminate above the level of the substrate.
2
Note that the waterproofing consultant must certify that the roof is fit to receive the membrane prior to installation.
3
Thermoplastic polymers composed of chlorinated polyethylene, polyvinyl chloride (PVC), thermoplastic polyolefin, ethylene vinyl acetate and ethylene
butyl acrylate.
4
Thermoplastic polymers composed of ketone ethylene ester.
1
71
Roofs
Protection mat
Plant roots can be very destructive, as shown by this image of tree roots
causing severe cracks in bitumen paving. A root barrier on a green roof
can protect the underlying layers
72
Roofs
Good drainage is critical for green roofs and ensures that large
amounts of water are not retained on the roof, compromising
both the structural integrity of the building and plant health
through waterlogging and oxygen-depleted substrates. Sub-surface
run-off must drain efficiently from the substrate, into the drainage
layer, off the roof surface, and into drains to the stormwater or
rainwater collection. The growing substrate must be kept separate
from the drainage layer with a filter sheet.
A layer of filter sheet will prevent substrate dropping into the drainage
layer. Enough filter sheet is set down over the roof so that at the
vertical edges of the planting beds the sheet will be the same height
as the substrate
73
Roofs
The University of Melbournes Burnley campus has a demonstration green roof with four distinct growing substrates. These are based on recycled
crushed roof tile; bottom ash from coal-fired power stations in NSW; scoria quarried locally to the west of Melbourne; and an ash-based mix with a
high proportion of composted pine bark. Substrates have been installed at different depths to compare the effects on plant growth
74
Roofs
Substrate installation
On large green roof projects, growing substrates can
be installed by crane or by blower. Substrate may be
delivered in multiple bulker bags, typically of one cubic
metre capacity, although a larger crane lifting bags of
greater volume may be possible if site access permits. Care
must be exercised in point loading of substrate on to the
roof and movement across the roof (see Chapter 4.1).
Blowing a substrate involves the use of a compressor
pump and hose to blow the substrate up to the roof.
Sometimes substrates that are blown onto a roof
will have altered properties (due to finer particles
aggregating during the process) and may need re-mixing
on the roof to ensure success.
Growing substrate should be delivered before the day
it is to be installed and stored as closely as possible
to the crane, with clear access for the forklift or other
machinery that will transport it to the crane lifting point.
Growing substrates should be installed with minimal
handling and be moist to reduce the release of fine
particles into the air. Appropriate personal protective
equipment should be worn: gloves, dust filter masks,
safety glasses and hardhat.
5.7 Vegetation
A range of planting stock can be used for green roofs,
including seed, cuttings, seedlings, tubestock and larger
containerised plants. See Chapter 3 for information on
species selection.
Planting is best completed in autumn and winter to assist
plant establishment before summer. Irrigation should be
provided while the plants establish. Depending on the
time of year and rainfall, establishment irrigation could be
required for up to six months.
It is helpful to acquire container-grown nursery plants that
have been grown in the substrate they are to be planted
into; otherwise, reduce the amount of potting mix held
around the roots when transplanting into the green roof.
Controlled release fertiliser (CRF) can be added to
the growing substrate or applied after planting is
completed (top dressing). Careful consideration of rates
and application methods is needed to ensure proper
distribution and to limit any rapid discharge of nutrients
(more information on plant nutrition is provided in
Chapter 8).
Trees planted on green roofs will require a deep substrate
as well as anchorage to prevent wind-throw. Various
anchorage systems are available as illustrated in Figure 19.
Tree bracings must be checked regularly to ensure they
are functioning as specified, and not causing damage to
the tree. Trees will require construction of a tree pit in the
substrate to house the tree roots: this needs to be deep
and wide enough for lateral root growth to ensure tree
stability. Consult an arborist for specialist advice.
75
Roofs
Plate anchorage
system
76
Roofs
Is suitable for electrically conductive and electrically grounded roof decks such
as steel and reinforced concrete roofs. EFVM can be used on wooden roofs or
precast concrete slab roofs if a conductive layer of metal foil or mesh is applied
to the roof deck before the waterproofing layer is installed. The decision to use
EFVM must therefore be made at the design stage.
Destructive testing
Flood testing
Is suitable only for flat roofs with slopes of up to 2 per cent. Flood testing
involves temporarily blocking the roof drains and flooding the roof membrane
with a known depth of water for a set period of time. The weight loading of the
roof must be checked against the weight of water that will sit on the roof during
the test. This ensures that the structural integrity of the building
is not compromised.
77
Roofs
5.10 Irrigation
An irrigation system is highly advisable on green roofs: to extend
plant species selection options, to improve plant growth rates and
increase long-term vegetation success thereby ensuring aesthetic
and environmental (such as building cooling, stormwater reduction)
outcomes can be achieved. Planning for irrigation on a green roof
should consider the site layout and conditions (access, exposure),
type of plants, climate and water supply issues (pressure, quality,
etc.). Substrate properties and depth are also important as they
influence water infiltration, holding capacity and drainage. In most
cases, irrigation design will be heavily influenced by the nature of
the water supply resource (for example, harvested vs. potable water)
and a water budget should be used to guide not just irrigation but
also plant selection (see Chapter 3). In larger green roof projects,
irrigation is best undertaken by a specialist consultant to guide
system design, component selection, installation and maintenance.
Table 11 provides an outline of different options for irrigation of
green roofs.
Automatic systems
If an automatic irrigation system is to be installed on a green roof,
consider a system that incorporates a rain sensor that shuts off
the system in the event of rainfall above a certain threshold. This
removes the risk that the roof loading may be compromised if the
irrigation system is running during a heavy downpour. Even automatic
systems require regular physical checks and operation tests.
Low irrigation
It is important to understand that, while some succulent species
can survive on rainfall alone, plants that experience moisture stress
will decline over time. This leads to a loss of vigour, leaf shedding,
canopy reductions and ultimately plant death. Plant failure means
more water run-off from the roof, less transpirational cooling
and more opportunities for weed invasion. As such, irrigation is
advisable. However, if designing for very low water use, select plant
species that are better able to tolerate the extreme moisture
Irrigation frequency
During the establishment phase after planting, irrigation may be
frequent, for example, two to three times per week. For food
crops, irrigation will also be necessary during high activity phases
of the growth cycle, such as when the plant moves into flowering
and fruit set. The frequency of irrigation should be matched to the
drainage and water-holding capacity of the mix: frequent irrigation
of a very free-draining substrate is likely to waste water.
The irrigation delivery method will partly determine the timing
of irrigation. Watering in high daytime temperatures will transfer
more heat into the building, as water heats up as it passes through
the hot growing substrate and transfers some of this heat into the
building when it drains onto the roof surface. For surface and subsurface irrigation, there is little to no wetting of the foliage, which
lowers the risk of fungal disease. If spray irrigation is used, it should
be applied very early in the morning to enable foliage to dry off
throughout the day and thus reduce the likelihood of disease.
Moisture sensors
Be aware that moisture sensors used to estimate moisture
content in standard landscaping soils do not provide reliable
information about the moisture content of free-draining, porous
growing substrates used on green roofs.
78
Roofs
Advantages
Disadvantages
Microspray
Surface drippers/
perforated pipes
Sub-surface drippers/
perforated pipes
Sub-surface capillary
High efficiency
Hose
rather than loose gravel ballast. The materials used must conform
to the design wind load calculated for the specific green roof
location.
On some green roofs, perimeter balustrades or parapet walls will
provide some protection against wind flow. Other treatments,
such as jute erosion control netting (see Chapter 5.12) or coated
wire retaining systems, may be useful.
Plant selection may also be used to mitigate the impact of winds. If
the tolerance of different species to wind exposure is understood,
plantings can be planned so that the lowest-growing, most robust
species are planted in the most exposed areas. Taller, less wind
tolerant species are installed behind them. The resulting gentle
gradation of vegetation heights interrupts, and slows, wind flow
over the planting.
79
Roofs
Growing
Substrate
Anti-shear
drainage layer
Roof
Protection
Layer
deck
Water-retention
matting
Waterproofing
Membrane
80
Roofs
non-vegetated zones
retaining edges
topographical construction
planting containers
drains and gutters
flashings
a range of other elements, not discussed in detail here, such
as: harness attachment points; controller boxes/solenoid
boxes (to house irrigation components); decorative and
functional landscape elements such as decking, paving, seating,
shade protection, ponds and lighting
Retaining edges
Edging can be used to define and retain planted and nonvegetated zones across a green roof. It can include concrete,
stainless steel, recycled plastic or aluminium products; L-shaped
edges are installed above the filter sheet and often have
perforations to allow drainage through the profile.
Non-vegetated zones
Non-vegetated zones are used to group roof penetrations, vent
pipes and other upstands and assist in lateral drainage. They are
generally constructed with large diameter aggregate rock or ballast
(16-32 mm size), rather than the growing substrate, and provide
additional lateral drainage into the roof drains. They are usually
between 300-500 mm wide and are separated from the roof
perimeter ballast by metal edging installed around the planting
area. Similar vegetation-free zones may be created through use of
paving slabs or ballast to provide access pathways across the green
roof, or as firebreaks on very large roofs.
Topographical construction
Blocks of polystyrene foam can be used to build up areas to create
mounds or hills without the additional weight of the substrate.
Topographical variations on a green roof create different growing
conditions and microclimates to increase habitat opportunities for
beneficial insects, as well as visual, aesthetic interest.
81
Roofs
Planting containers
Flashings
Roofs with a parapet that extends above the roof deck require
installation of a cover (flashing) to protect the building fabric.
This should be included in the waterproofing installation to
ensure that membrane terminations, and any areas of membrane
extending over the vertical and horizontal surfaces of the parapet,
are not exposed.
Figure 21. Functional elements on a green roof can include flashing (capping) and non-vegetated zones
Flashing
Non-vegetated
Zone
Growing
Substrate
Drainage Layer
Protection
Layer
Waterproofing
Membrane
Roof deck
82
Roofs
Stages of construction:
Building the City of Monash green roof
1
1 The roof deck is ready for installation of the green roof: waterproofing treatment was not required on this clip-lock steel roof
2 A protection layer is used to cover the roof deck 3 Drainage sheets are installed over the protection layer 4 Abutting drainage
sheets provide full coverage of the area to be planted 5 Substrate is pumped up to the roof from ground level and installed via a
blow hose. 6 Edging strips are used to separate planting areas from non-vegetated walkways 7 Planting follows a specified design
8 The final product
6. Building &
installation
green walls
Green wall systems vary greatly in their design and construction from DIY
projects to modular green wall systems available to buy off the shelf, through
to proprietary systems that are custom-fitted to a wall. Specialists in green
wall design and installation can provide advice on the most suitable system and
the best construction approach. Green walls can deliver more than aesthetic
benefits, and this requires consideration in the design stage. This chapter
provides advice on the structures and components required for green wall
systems, waterproofing, irrigation and nutrition, vegetation and lighting. This
information should be read prior to starting a green wall-building project.
84
Walls
Hydroponic system
Water proofing
Wall
Wall
Irrigation
Irrigation
Modular panel
(hydroponic)
Modular panel
(substrate)
Drip tray
Felt Covered
Panel (with
irrigation
concealed)
Support
structure
Drip tray
Support
structure
85
Drip trays are used to capture excess irrigation water from the
growing medium as well as water droplets that drip off foliage. The
size of the drip tray should be sufficient to hold an entire irrigation
cycles water volume (before draining away prior to subsequent
cycles starting). Drip trays may not be necessary if the run-off is
intended to irrigate vegetation below the green wall. If drip trays
are not used, ensure run-off does not create slip hazards, damage
the building fabric or provide excess moisture or nutrients to
ground-based plantings below.
Water captured in the drip tray or reservoir at the base of the
planting system can be pumped back to the top of the wall for
re-use rather than being wasted, provided that it is treated to
prevent build-up of nutrients. Drip trays should have a drainage
pipe of sufficient diameter to empty the drip tray or manage
water capture sufficiently to mitigate overflow of the tray. Fascia
treatments may be added to conceal the edges and functional
elements of the green wall system, such as the irrigation system
and drip tray.
6.2 Waterproofing
Walls
Waterproofing walls
- lessons learned
This indoor green wall is located within an office
conference room in Melbourne. Within a week
of installing the waterproofing and drip tray
treatments, water leakage was observed. The area
connecting the waterproofed wall to the drip
tray had not been completely sealed and allowed
water to collect and drain between the two.
The modular nature of the green wall assembly
enabled this fault to be easily repaired the area
was sealed, and this mitigated any further
damage.
This example reinforces the importance of
testing and checking the work undertaken and
completed by every contractor against project
specifications.
86
Walls
87
Walls
6.4 Vegetation
The size of plant materials used in green walls will depend on the
required look and finish of the wall at project completion. Planting
densities can be as high as 25 to 30 plants per square metre.
Decorative patterns can be designed by repeat planting across
an area; however, these patterns can be difficult to implement
if shadows and light across the different parts of the wall have
not been considered. Systems incorporating smaller plants at the
outset will take longer to fill out than those using well-established
container plants. The dimensions of the planting module will
determine the size of the planting stock. Different green wall
systems will be better for different types of plant growth habits,
from those that grow upright to those with a clumping growth
habit, scrambling, cascading or creeping. See Chapter 3 for
information on plant selection.
Facade greening on the Council House 2 rooftop, Little Collins Street, Melbourne. Image: Ronstan Tensile Architecture
7. Building &
installation
green facades
Green facades can range from complex systems for multi-storey buildings, with
plants growing in containers at different heights, to simpler systems where the
plants grow from the ground, allowing inexpensive installation of greenery on
low-rise buildings. This chapter provides information about building and installing green facades. The information should be considered prior to starting a
building project.
89
Facades
Figure 23. Support structures for green facades grown with twining climbers
90
Facades
7.3 Vegetation
For rapid coverage of a green facade, plant specimens should be
healthy and vigorous, with numerous basal shoots. They should be
of the largest possible size to suit the installation.
To support the vegetation at installation, the growing substrate
used to support container-grown facade plantings should
incorporate controlled-release fertiliser at planting (see more
information about plant nutrition in Chapter 8). New plantings
should receive irrigation to promote their strong establishment,
which depends on season planted and plant size. Establishment
is when new roots have grown and the plant is acclimatised and
actively growing.
Pruning and training of new plants is essential to promote the
development of an effective facade. Plants may need to be
trained to the facade support, or temporarily attached to the
wall after planting, to encourage upward growth. Once the plant
is established, the main runners should be trimmed to encourage
lateral shoots that will create a more radial growth pattern. If this
is not done, the climbers will typically branch out only once they
have reached a significant height, and it may take years for the
lower portions of the facade to receive any coverage. The use of
diagonally oriented cables on facade systems facilitates horizontal,
as well as vertical, growth of the plant (preferred over the plant
shooting straight up) and thereby increases the density of foliage
cover. For long-term installations, pruning to rejuvenate might be
required. As climbers age their growth can decrease and cutting
back to hard wood can revitalise a plant and allow for longer
lifespans. This means that after five to seven years, especially
with woody climbers, it may be necessary to prune back a large
portion of foliage.
91
Facades
Facades in containers
lessons learned
A roof garden incorporating green facades was built
at Council House 2, central Melbourne, in 2006. Its
design included the incorporation of 950 mm deep
plastic planters, connected to a cable and stainless steel
trellis (X-TEND) mesh for growth of the facade. The
intention was to increase greenery across the building
through use of the roof and facades.
Unfortunately, the facade plantings have not grown well
due to multiple problems with the planters, growing
substrate and irrigation. The black colour of the planters
leads to considerable heat gain in the root zone over
summer, causing difficulties for plant growth. The
planters also tend to split, the side wall plastic seemingly
unable to tolerate the high bulk density of the growing
substrate. Additional metal frames were used to support
the replacement containers. The substrate itself has also
had issues, with plants failing or growing poorly and a
considerable drop in the total volume since installation.
A further complication has been the irrigation system.
Each planter is irrigated via combination of a valve, water
reservoir and foam wicking, all enclosed in the base
of the container. The valves function at a much lower
pressure than the mains supply, meaning most failed
when they were first operated. This in turn affected
any possible capillary irrigation upwards to the root
zone in each container, leading to extensive plant death
shortly after installation. Replanting has occurred but
all containers now need to be hand-watered. The City
of Melbourne is currently investigating cost effective
options for resolving these problems.
The City of Melbourne recommends thorough research
or peer review to assist and support decision-making
around the design and use of new technologies.
Weeding the vegetable bed on the Demonstration Green Roof at The University of Melbournes Burnley campus
8. maintenance
This chapter provides information to help with the development of
maintenance plans. A detailed maintenance plan will outline performance
standards, tasks to be undertaken and the resources required to achieve
them. Once created, maintenance plans should be reviewed at least
annually to ensure all maintenance needs are being met.
93
Maintenance
Maintenance
Reactive maintenance was needed after a severe hail storm shredded succulent vegetation at The Venny, Kensington, in March 2010.
Image: PAD Creations
94
Maintenance
Maintenance
2.
3.
4.
5.
95
Maintenance
Maintenance
Maintenance Objective
Task
Remove waste plant material (leaf litter, prunings, weeds), inspect for signs of pests
or disease and treat as needed, make seasonal adjustments to irrigation volume and
frequency as needed, ensure adequate nutrition levels for plants; inspect after severe
weather events (e.g. wind or heat) to look for signs of stress
Minimise weeds
Manage lawns
Maintain trees
Annual or biannual pruning to maintain density and cover and to remove growth from
fixtures (windows, drains). Rejuvenate to renovate habit and growth
Vigorous pruning to renew stems and encourage new basal growth (every 5-7 years)
Maintain records of plant health, vigour and coverage, pest and disease impact
Maintain substrate
Top-up of growing substrate may be required due to wind, rain or animal activity (check
the depth of the growing substrate before any additions are made to ensure weight
loadings are not exceeded)
Manually test and inspect the irrigation system regularly and monitor any automated
systems (check volume of irrigation delivered, its frequency, substrate moisture content,
and, for hydroponic green walls, nutrient levels in the water supply)
Maintain a log of fertiliser additions and records of pH and electrical conductivity values
before and after addition of fertiliser
Maintain drainage
Ensure roof drains are clear and functioning, remove dirt, litter and other deposits from
drain inspection chambers, check plumbing hardware, check condition of filter sheet and
deeper layers if necessary
Remove vegetation from perimeter zones and around other equipment and fixtures
Check safety anchor points for fall arrest systems, check access points, e.g. ladders and
stairways, check electrical safety of power points, lighting and irrigation control system
Maintain waterproofing
Inspect flashings over waterproofing membrane terminations, inspect wall fabric for any
damage from water, fertiliser or plants, conduct leak detection of waterproofing on a
green roof if possible
Clean or oil decking or furniture, inspect green wall or facade support systems for any
loose attachments or fittings
96
Maintenance
Maintenance
Fire
Maintenance plans must ensure that the vegetation present on a green roof, wall or facade does not create fire hazards. Dead
or dry vegetation must be removed as part of regular maintenance. Fire resistance can be increased by installing breaks in the
vegetation or using plants with low biomass (such as native grass tussocks with a low amount of leaf matter). Green facades with
deciduous or evergreen climbers are unlikely to create a fire risk as long as dry leaf litter falls away cleanly and is removed during
routine maintenance. Vegetation on green walls that receives regular irrigation and maintenance does not pose a fire hazard.
CRF is the most suitable choice for plant nutrition in green roof
settings or green facades in containers. The fertiliser comes in
the form of water permeable resin granules or beads and is
applied on the substrate surface but should be raked or mixed
through, ensuring an even distribution. Each rain or irrigation event
dissolves a small amount of the inorganic nutrients stored in the
bead. If the roof or container is being irrigated from below (a subirrigation system) then it is important to mix the fertiliser well into
the substrate.
The elevated temperatures on a roof or facade can lead to
excessive fertiliser loss and damage plant growth. For Australian
natives on green roofs, low phosphorus CRF can be used at half to
quarter of the rate recommended for garden or container plants.
Liquid fertilisers are not suitable for routine use on green roofs,
as nutrients are more likely to leach out of the mix and leave via
stormwater run-off.
SECTION
04
Victorian
Case Studies
100
Case Study
Location
JJ Holland Park 85 Kensington
Road, Kensington,Victoria
Completion Date
September 2010
(remediation works July 2013)
Cost
$123,000
Area
Introduction
101
Case Study
Maintenance
Roof A was planted with a mix of Australian and exotic herbaceous and succulent plant species
102
Case Study
Component
Cost
Shipping container
steel frame
Recycled
$5,000
Bentonite Liner
$16,000
Concrete Screen
$18,000
Zinco System
(Supply)
$7,150
$1,360
$6,330
Substrate growing
median & crushed
brick paths
$5,900
$1,270
Plants (Supply)
$4,520
Plants (Install)
$3,540
103
Case Study
Location
8-10 Kavanagh Street,
Southbank,Victoria
Completion Date
2009
Cost
$350,000
Area
206m2 on a new building
Introduction
Visible from the street, the green wall
feature was considered by the developer to
provide a wow-factor, setting the building
apart from other inner-city residences and
blending in with the leafy streetscape.
This view of the established green wall shows how the concept was
translated into a lush, vegetated space
104
Case Study
Maintenance
By choosing species that respond well to
each other, the green wall requires less
maintenance than a more rigid design. The
owners favoured this approach because
it offered a long-term, adaptable and
sustainable solution.
Fytogreen is contracted to undertake the
maintenance. Maintenance is moderately
fluid, pending seasonal changes and the
clients aesthetic expectations. The Triptych
owners embraced natural aesthetic forms
and ongoing species self-adjusting, leading
to a less restrictive maintenance process.
Knuckle Boom lift access, requiring a
small team of horticulturists, is generally
conducted every three months.
Monthly checks, conducted by one person,
assess water supply, quality and general
garden condition.
105
Case Study
Cost
The green wall at Triptych adds another element to the street level vegetation
106
Case Study
Location
RMIT University city campus
124 La Trobe Street, Melbourne,
Victoria
Completion Date
2011
Cost
$230,000
RMIT University
Building 21 Green Facade
Description
Introduction
The RMIT University city campus in
Melbourne is a publicly accessible space
made up of historical and modern
buildings, interspersed with functional open
areas. With the completion of University
Lawn Precinct and the refurbishment of all
of the surrounding buildings, Building 21
needed a facelift as the last piece in the
precinct. A green facade was constructed
on the rear of the building.
The Building 21 green facade was a joint
project between RMIT University, Peter
Elliot Architecture and Urban Design,
engineers BHS Consultants, landscape
architects Rush Wright Associates and TJS
Services. The specific facade structure was
provided by Ronstan Tensile Architecture.
Area
122m2 on existing building
1 Pre-construction
2 8 months post-construction
3 26 months post-construction
Images courtesy Ronstan
Tensile Architecture
107
Maintenance
The design of the green facade included
maintenance requirements. The site can be
accessed with an elevated work platform.
The planter boxes are raised above
pedestrian level, but are low enough to be
accessed using a ladder.
The green facade requires a moderate
level of maintenance, contracted to the
universitys general landscaping contractor.
Regular maintenance tasks include:
Case Study
Cost
The project cost $230,000, excluding
ongoing maintenance. Specific costs
of project components are detailed in
the table.
Item
Cost
Planter boxes
$80,000
$25,000
Plumbing and
irrigation
$25,000
Trellis system
$90,000
Access
equipment hire
$10,000
The green facade is now a key element of the view from the University Lawn Precinct
108
Case Study
Location
Freshwater Place Apartments 1
Queensbridge Square, Southbank,
Victoria
Completion Date
2004
Cost
Undisclosed
Area
1650m2 on a new building
Introduction
Freshwater Place is a residential complex
containing 534 apartments, located on the
Southbank side of Melbournes Yarra River.
The aim of the project was to provide
residents with a functional outdoor space
that would enhance their inner-city lifestyle
and add value to the property. The green
roof is part of the communal facilities,
which include barbeque areas, pool, gym
and function spaces. Residents and their
109
Case Study
Pyrus ussuriensis
Manchurian Pear cultivar
Dianella Little Jess
Juniperus sabina Savin Juniper
Liriope cultivars Lily Turf
Viola hederacea Native Violet
Viola labradorica Labrador Violet
Ixia cultivars Corn Lily
Escallonia cultivars
Ipheion uniflorum Spring Star
Freesia cultivars
Iris cultivars
Rahiolepis umbellata Yeddo Hawthorn
Pennisetum clandestinum Kikuyu
Trachelospermum jasminoides
Star Jasmine
110
Case Study
Maintenance
Although the green roof at Freshwater
Place has been designed to minimise
maintenance, there are ongoing challenges.
A different level of maintenance is required
for the intensive garden beds and the
extensive lawn area. For an annual fee of
$25,000, the maintenance is carried out
under contract and includes replacement
of plants. Maintenance activities include:
Irrigation
Pruning
Plant
evaluation
Weekly
Lawn
mowing
Weekly in spring;
fortnightly at other
times
Scarifying
the grass
Fertilising
Plant
renewal
As required
in winter
Cleaning &
monitoring
of hard
landscape
elements:
Weekly
Inspection
of irrigation
system
function:
Daily in summer,
monthly at other
times
2.
3.
Manchurian Pear trees are a feature on the Freshwater Place green roof
111
Case Study
Location
290 Belmore Road, Balwyn,Victoria
Completion Date
December 2012
Cost
$306,000
Area
440m2 on a new building
Introduction
Minifie Park Early Learning Centre is a
council-owned, community-operated
childcare centre located in North Balwyn,
an eastern suburb of Melbourne. It was
built to replace an older building.
Council decided to include a green roof
as an integral part of the new facility. The
purpose of the green roof was to provide
thermal insulation and help the building
blend in to the surrounding parkland.
The building sits low in a park, meaning the roof can be easily viewed from street level
112
Case Study
Maintenance
Junglefy has maintained the roof since
planting. The intention had been that
roof management would move to the
City of Boroondara. However, due to
Junglefys experienced management and
competency to work at heights, they
have been sub-contracted by the Citys
Parks and Gardens team, and continue
to maintain the green roof on a monthly
basis. This arrangement has simplified
management for the City of Boroondara.
The potential for acidification of the growing
medium from the needles shed by a nearby
overhanging pine tree is a source for concern.
Performance evaluation of the green roof
plantings is being undertaken by the City
of Boroondara.
Plant nutrition is provided as eight to
nine-month low phosphorus controlledrelease fertiliser applied at half the
recommended rate.
Costs
Total cost was $306,000. This included:
113
Case Study
1 Sheets of drainage cells were cut to fit the width of the roof profile. Image: Junglefy
2 The unplanted perimeter zone prevents plant roots from growing into the drainage pipes
3 Native grasses on the green roof blend into the surrounding parklands and provide habitat
114
Case Study
Location
Lower Powlett Road,Wonthaggi,
Victoria
Completion Date
2012
Cost
$4,000,000
Victorian Desalination
Project Green Roof
Description
The Victorian Desalination Project
green roof is the largest in the southern
hemisphere. It covers a number of
buildings of the process plant, ranging
in pitch from 3.5 to 20 degrees. The
undulating slopes of the roof are designed
to limit visibility of the industrial buildings
from the surrounding public areas and link
to the nearby coastal landscape.
Introduction
The Victorian Desalination Plant provides
for desalinated water to be delivered
from the private sector to the State
Government owned water authorities.
The plant is capable of supplying up to 150
billion litres of water a year to Melbourne,
Geelong and via other connections to
South Gippsland towns.
Graphic depiction of the design shows how the green roof blends into the surrounding environment
Area
26,000m2 on a new building
115
Case Study
Maintenance
Fytogreen has a five-year contract to carry
out any maintenance required for the
green roof. Given the high profile of the
project and the community expectations
around aesthetics, the contract specifies
standards for maintenance. This includes a
requirement that vegetation cover must be
at least 95 per cent, with no more than five
per cent weeds. Fytogreen visits the site
as required, to ensure these maintenance
obligations are met. Visual inspections
of plant health are important to ensure
irrigation and nutrient levels are adequate.
116
Case Study
1 Irrigation pipes are embedded in the upper level of the growing media, above filter sheet and drainage layers
2 Plants were propagated offsite and delivered to the green roof for installation
3 Plants were well established by December 2013
4 Non-vegetated zone around the edge of the roof
All images in this case study are courtesy of ASPECT Studios and Fytogreen
117
Case Study
Location
Burnley Campus,The University of
Melbourne , 500 Yarra Boulevard,
Richmond,Victoria
Completion Date
February 2013
Cost
$13, 930
Burnley Biodiversity
Green Roof
Description
The green roof is located above ground
floor offices on a concrete roof deck with
a 1 degree slope. The roof is accessible
only to authorised staff or students with
Working at Heights certification; however,
it can be viewed from the first floor
hallway window.
The Biodiversity Green Roof features:
Introduction
The University of Melbourne has a campus
in Richmond, near the Yarra River, focusing
on horticultural research and education.
The main building was constructed
between 1946 and 1949 and is protected
by a Heritage Overlay, and the entire site is
listed on the Victorian Heritage Register.
The northern end of the roof of the
main building has been developed into
a Biodiversity Green Roof as part of the
Area
49m2 on an existing building with
heritage considerations
118
Case Study
Grasses and
grass-like forms
Orchid
species
Fern species
Arthropodium milleflorum
Pale Vanilla Lily
Linum marginale
Native Flax
Austrodanthonia carphoides
Short Wallaby-grass
Microtis unifolia
Common
Onion-Orchid
Cheilanthes
austrotenuifolia
Green Rock Fern
Asperula conferta
Common Woodruff
Lobelia pratioides
Poison Lobelia
Austrostipa scabra
Velvet Tussock Grass
Brachyscome basaltica
Swamp Daisy
Marsilea drummondii
Common Nardoo
Chloris truncata
Windmill Grass
Brunonia australis
Blue Pincushion
Microseris lanceolata
Yam Daisy
Dichelachne crinita
Longhair Plumegrass
Bulbine bulbosa
Bulbine Lily
Pelargonium rodneyanum
Magenta Storksbill
Lepidosperma concavum
Sword-sedge
Calocephalus citreus
Lemon Beauty-heads
Podolepis jaceoides
Showy Podolepis
Lomandra filiformis
Wattle Mat-rush
Calotis anthemoides
Cut-leaf Burr-daisy
Ptilotus macrocephalus
Green Pussytails
Themeda triandra
Kangaroo Grass
Chrysocephalum apiculatum
Common Everlasting
Ptilotus macrocephalus
Green Pussytails
Cullen tenax
Emu Foot
Rumex dumosus
Wiry Dock
Dianella revoluta
Black-anther Flax Lily
Rutidosis leptorrynchoides
Button Wrinklewort
Eryngium ovinum
Blue Devil
Selliera radicans
Shiny Swamp-mat
Eryngium vesiculosum
Prickfoot
Senecio quadridentatus
Cotton Fireweed
Helichrysum rutidolepis
Pale Everlasting
Stylidium graminifolium
Grass Trigger-plant
Hypericum gramineum
Small St. Johns Wort
Veronica gracilis
Slender Speedwell
Leptorynchos squamatus
Scaly Buttons
Vittadinia cuneata
Woolly Vittadinia
Wahlenbergia communis
Tufted Bluebell
Scaly Buttons
(Leptorhynchos squamatus)
119
Case Study
Maintenance
Staff maintain the Biodiversity Green Roof:
this takes about one hour per month. A
photographic record of weed species is
maintained to monitor those that germinate
on the roof. Timely removal of these plants
before they set seed prevents them from
becoming more widespread. Plant nutrition
is provided as eight to nine-month low
phosphorus controlled-release fertiliser,
applied at half the recommended rate.
Component
Cost
Preliminary costs:
design, project
management, etc.
$3,000
Repairs to existing
waterproofing
$1,500
Protection Mat
SSM 45
$250
Root barrier
$100
Aluminium retaining
edge (33 linear m)
$3,580
FD40 drainage
$1,100
Filter Sheet SF
$120
Scoria-based growing
substrate
(10 cm depth)
$680
Scoria aggregate
installed on nonvegetated perimeter
$350
Labour cost of
installation including
crane fees
$1,020
Labour cost of
installation including
crane fees
$630
Plant production/
purchase costs
$600
Materials collection
and planting
$1,000
Costs
120
Case Study
Location
Docklands Campus, Kangan
Institute, Harbour Esplanade,
Docklands,Victoria
Completion Date
November 2012
Cost
$56,000
Area
250m2 on a new building
Introduction
The Kangan Institute Automotive Centre
of Excellence (ACE) is located in the
Batman Hill Precinct of Melbournes
Docklands. The building holds a 5 Star
Green Star rating. The building houses a
2,000 m area of automotive workshops,
and 1,200 m of specialised training and
office areas.
The green roof is located adjacent to the
administrative offices, and over the learning
suites, which will benefit from reduced
heat loads.
The green roof was designed by ASPECT
Studios, in collaboration with Gray Puksand
Architects. Robert Bird Group provided
structural and civil engineering services.
The green roof was installed on the
concrete roof deck of the new concreteframed building.
121
Case Study
Maintenance
1 Roof deck with waterproof membrane prior to flood testing. The raised strip is a major structural movement joint which required specific attention
to maintain waterproofing 2 Views of the green roof at planting 3 Views of the green roof 10 months later 4 Anigozanthos Ruby Velvet
contributes a striking element to the green roof planting scheme at Kangan Institute
All images in this case study are courtesy of ASPECT Studios and Fytogreen
122
Case Study
Location
131 Queen St Melbourne,Victoria
Completion Date
July 2010
Cost
$219,000
Area
200m2 on an existing building
Introduction
131 Queen Street is managed by Quayles
Owners Corporation Managers. The
building was constructed in 1896 and the
tenants include a range of private and
public organisations. It was intended that
the rooftop garden be used by building
tenants for lunch and recreational breaks,
meetings, workshops and classes, as well as
special events.
The Growing Up roof was built after
the Committee for Melbourne ran a
design competition for a green roof. The
Committee identified three potential
CBD rooftops and ran the competition
to demonstrate how a vibrant, innovative
Timber decking, mosaic seating and permeable paving treatments are some of the functional and decorative features used
123
Case Study
Images in this case study courtesy Diana Snape Photography, for Bent Architecture.
124
Case Study
Culinary herbs
Climbers
Succulents
Trees
Shrubs
Lomandra
confertifolia
Little Pal
Origanum vulgare
Oregano
Passiflora edulis
Passionfruit
Sedum
pachyphyllum
Citrus limon
Meyer Meyer
Lemon
Banksia
spinulosa
Birthday
Candles
Anigozanthos
flavidus
Kangaroo Paw
Rosmarinus officinalis
R. officinalis prostratus
Rosemary (upright and
prostrate forms)
Sedum
xrubrotinctum
Olea
europaea
European
Olive
Hairpin
Banksia
cultivar
Dianella tasmanica
Tasmanian Flax-lily
Thymus vulgaris
Common Thyme
Aphanopetalum resinosum
Gum Vine
Sedum mexicanum
Mexican
Stonecrop
Themeda australis
Kangaroo Grass
Salvia officinalis
Culinary Sage
P. jasminoides Lady Di
Bower Vine cultivars
Kleinia repens
Chalk Sticks
Lampranthus
deltoides
Maintenance
The garden is maintained once a
month by a horticulturalist, and the
building management team carries out
some maintenance in between these
scheduled visits.
Plant nutrition is provided as eight to ninemonth low phosphorus controlled-release
fertiliser, applied at half the recommended
rate, as required.
Substrate installation
Costs
Component
Cost
$135,850
$14,500
$35,608
Permeable paving
$23,220
Ronstan cables
$2,000
Plants
$5,000
$2,500
in-kind*
Growing media
in-kind
Plants
in-kindn
Further structural rod & cable systems for green walls and landscaping and cable systems for
balustrades and railings were provided at cost price by Ronstan Tensile Architecture, a sponsor of
Growing Up
*The green roof system and labour for installation was provided as in-kind support by sponsor
Green Roof Technologies, this had an estimated value of $60,000
Provided as in-kind support by sponsor WeBlow
n
Provided by sponsors Proteaflora, Aloe-Aloe Horticulture, Merrywood Plants and Majestic Plants,
this had an estimated value of $8,500
Appendix A
126
Appendix
Appendix
for use with some green wall and facade systems. Referenced
standards used to develop this table are AS 3743 2003, Appendix
B, and the Singapore Centre for Urban Greenery and Ecology
Standards: these are listed in the References section. It is valuable
to obtain independent testing and verification of the properties of
substrate mixes on large scale commercial green roof projects.
Definition
Unit of
measurement
Saturated
bulk density
g/cm3 or kg/m3
Air filled
porosity
(AFP)
Property
Water
holding
capacity
(WHC)
pH
Electrical
conductivity
(EC)
% (of known
substrate volume)
% (of known
substrate volume)
No unit; range
from 1 (acid) to 14
(alkaline, or basic)
Solutions with
pH below 4 are
extremely acid,
and solutions with
pH above 10 are
extremely alkaline
deciSiemens per
metre (dS/m) or
measure total
dissolved salts in
ppm
127
Appendix
Appendix
Definition
Cation
exchange
capacity
(CEC)
Unit of
measurement
milliequivalents or
ppm
Infiltration
rate
mm/min or l/m2/h
coarse
fine
low
high
Air-filled
porosity
high
low
Nutrient
reserves
low
high
Water-holding
capacity
A growing substrate designed for a shallow green roof (left hand side)
will be more open and free draining than a substrate designed for a
deeper green roof (right hand side). Because of the shallow depth of
some roofs, the risk of waterlogging is great. Waterlogging decreases
oxygen in the root zone, and limits plant growth. Diagram adapted
from Zinco.
128
Appendix
Appendix
Intensive
<15% by mass
<20% by mass
Proportion of particles
> 4mm in diameter
Organic matter
Settling
Water permeability
0.6 - 70 mm/min
0.3 - 30 mm/min
Air-filled porosity
> 10%
> 10%
pH
6.0 8.5
6.0 8.5
mixes. Comparative values for topsoil and sand are also provided
for reference, but their high bulk density often limits or precludes
their use.
Table 15. Comparison of materials used in green roof growing substrates and their saturated bulk density
Component
Reason used
Saturated bulk
density (kg/m)
Ash
Waste product
1160 1310
640 900
930 1100
50 360
Crushed ceramics
(brick, roof tile)
Longevity, recycled
1090 1300
1640 1720
Longevity
1290 1560
670 1000
Scoria non-descript
crushed rock (NDCR)
Longevity
1530 1730
1030 1270
Perlite
Light weight
500 800
40
Pumice
(Hekla, Iceland)
540 753
260 490
Hydrocell
Inert, water-retention
660
27
Loamy topsoil
1700 2400
1000 1900
Sand
1800 2200
1440 1650
Water
1000
1370
Material
Recycled waste
products
Quarried products
Inert volcanic
products
Synthetic
additives
850
Values compiled from Handreck and Black, University of Melbourne Green Roof Infrastructure Group research data, Weiler and Scholz Barth, Dunnett
(Small Green Roofs) and JEI International.
129
Appendix
Appendix
Glossary
Basal shoots Shoots arising from buds at the stem bases or
roots of a plant. Continued production of basal shoots through
rejuvenation pruning is important to promote coverage of the
lower areas of a green facade, as some climbing plant species
open up at the base over time.
Stolons Stems arising from buds the base of a plant, that grow
horizontally at or just below the soil surface. Roots and shoots
(leaves) will develop at nodes on a stolon, to produce a series of
interconnected, genetically identical plants e.g. runners produced
by strawberry plants.