Post Bubble City
Post Bubble City
Post Bubble City
States and Japan . In their home country of Brita in, there was no
work for architects in the design of individual houses. Although t hey
made a great variety of drawings, t heir comprehension of t his issue
was to the effect, " when the individual becomes the basis of
architecture, what happens to the relationship between architectu re
Ind ividual houses were sufficient for a ful l career in Japan, so even
after Toyo Ito and Riken Yamamoto had begun to do publ ic work,
they somehow showed a consistent attit ude of givi ng consideration
to individual bodies in pub lic buildings. Lacking the foundation of
an abstract commun ity or society , much less a nation, it was a
scal ing-up of the ind ividua l that had been cultivated in detached
houses to became the basis for making public build ings. I think t his
aspect is also manifest in the accumu l at ion of re si dential
arch itecture in Japan . That reminds me, during a lecture Toyo Ito
Momoyo Kaijima
Dialogue on DEPTH
Ka ijima ln the room arrangements of ready-bui lt houses, there are
laces that can be described as having OKU (depth). On the other
p d whe n look ing at traditional private houses in Japan , the
han ,
tatam1 rooms described as OKU actually face onto the engawa
(veran 1a Al though they may be OKU if traced on the circulation
route. f looked at from their connection with the garden, they are
open rather than deep. Because the plans of ready-built houses
result rom no more than functional ordering, I suspect that the
OKU 1 ac hieved inadvertently . Tsukamoto Looked at as a
phenomen on, there is OKU as a representation of wealth, and
conversely there is OKU as an appearance of poverty. The former is
fou nd 1n t he architecture of things l ike tradit io nal Japanese
resta uran ts; class divisions become represen ted in architectural
des1gn, which gives me an unpleasant feeling. What I have begun
to nnt1ce IS that there are two grades of OKU : there is OKU as a
c~ar ter of place that results from the spatial organ ization , and
OKU IS layered mean ings that satisfy various social contexts. The
former is a phenomenon caused by topologica l relationships of
spaces (parallel , layered , nested) and connective relationships of
room due to circulation routes and apertures , and the latter is
pro)e t1on of the social hierarchy of 0-0KU (the ladies' territory in
fe1 1al castle). Our entry in the 1992 Shinkenchiku Residential
Des1 n Competition , entitled House without " Oku " Depth , was an
a11aly 1s an d critica l reconstruction of the formative mechanism of
OKU as a character of place . With Fumihiko Maki as the judge, we
prop1 ,ed th at OKU has van ished as a property of present-day urban
house First of all , the phenomenon of OKU as a characteristic of
place was co mprehended as the supe rimpos ition of mult i ple
explanatory var iables , such as the topological relationsh ips and
conne !ions of rooms, as well as apertures making connections with
()UtSide . Rearranging these relationsh ips brough t about a state
lackmg any definitive OK U. So sha llow / deep and interior / exterior ,
as ch 1racteri st ics of place, became relative, undergoing various
nve 1on s depend i ng on your i ocation . The number of
explanatory variables used to distinguish between " inside and
outside" and " part and whole " gradually increases based on social
transform ations, thereby becom ing increasingly complex, but even
so, I feel that there is an opportunity to disman t le OKU by
quest ioning whether on ly arch itectura l space can provide the
ongoing production of constant ly stable re lationships between
"1ns1 de and outside" and between " part and whole." Because this
IS fixed in the form of spatial composition rhetoric, with a presentday urban house it first seems necessary to relativize this rhetoric. I
studied spat ial composit io n rhetoric as a theory of arch itectural
composition, in other words, a system of differences based on the
operati on of architectural mean ing, under Professor Kazunari
Sakamoto . Taking the semiotics developed by Roland Barthes as a
basis, ana lyses of various cultural expressions were applied to the
Momoyo Ka iji ma
1994
illlDO)r::~.-7'
Opening Tube
lfi:O)tlOH't>t.;:~ >ll!l"'
Nobody's Room
ff!l:!t.
Pnvatized
}..00)7::~.-7'
Entrance Tube
~.
7-f77-f/0)7:~.-7'
Llfelt ne Tu be
J)<@JI)O)ft
Cube Containing San itary
4 : ~i.!fir:J:.Q51"751":.-c0)!*ft
;::n*<'O)fi!fOO)~r.,r:r;~: ,
-r-:J < LJ t.=~n.Q r~J tJ!;Jil.i'f~tl.-r~t.:. -:J*LJ ll!ll IO)'eJfl:IIIHif.L', fl'l r:t.J:
.Q~)i.JTI:IIJ** I :J:.Qj~~llll D I:J: L) ~ft~tl.f.J:l l;::_ci'Jl!lf.J:LJ, ~I'J>.:,{ii]
m: r :t.~-r.:,nt.: r~J nf!nt~n-c~t.::. L.tJ>L.Illf-tO) ~ r., r:r;J:1UH:.-
l I?~O)ti*~t>7J'~L'~,
ilil~ e::st-trt.:,nt.:.
.
.......
............
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
...............................
......... ....................
. . . ........
.. .. ... ..
"
. ...... .........
. ........
.
....................
. ..
........................ ....
...................... ..
....................... .. ..
2'?0)~0)r., O)~r.,
'l '"'tJ::I:l.~0)&/19{>7y"!t-t'
Facade with Repeating Circle Windows
_D _
D
GL +200'I'imlill
s,
1/300
Gl +200 Plan
7)
)...
GL + 1900'l'imlill
Gl + 1900 Plan
As such, under the new definition , a house without the concealed area is
s, 1/300
GL +4400'l'imlill S: 1/300
Gl + 4400 Plan
considered possible. A space can be " in" and "front" and connected, or
" out" and " back" and not connected . The House without "Oku" {Depth) is
an attempt to present th is possibility using two nested cu bes connected
by tubes. In addition , the space between two cubes was identified to be a
space not belonging to either outside of the house nor inside of the inner
cube and was named "nobody's room. "
Articulator's House
<Piil
Courtyard
1993
~
Outer Shell
Bath
Bed Room
7:::~. - /
Tube
.Ill
Livi,.Room
i*~L'~~J::>I:::L.., P<Jc?1-0)~Ji:tJ~-ft-t~mJJIY-ltJ:ij\c-t~.::e:-e;;;~.
;:O)J:'Jf.i:l-:11.7-0)~IJlL'Ii, ~llJM~'l' ~l \fJ:tJ>L'L'~~t.:lt*~tJ:-i*O)
ggr.,Hii*L..J:?cT~I~'t>L'~~.
,.
J7 y"!f- 1'
:7-.:J. -/J::~Jl7?tA T:'t!.Q~{)!I
n Fa~ade
.llf;:}..tl.f-:!XC7)f"'llilC7)7-.:J.--;/ / T:fi
is Otrectly Accessible from Wester
~ :~~Ill!!:!/ _t;fi :ij{)!IJ/lll D1J,6
rn Wtndow I bottom right: Tube
rtght: Nested Tube Seen from Southe
e t: Decomposed MOdel / above
is a strong
small boxes in bigger boxes
The nested stru cture , puttin g
re . It is a
tectu
archi
l
entia
nese resid
ch arac teris t ic of post war Japa
method to connect unit
from
s
differ
that
n
ositio
topologica l spatial comp
of t his
rooms. One of the intentions
spaces or to divide a space into
without a pre-set purpose
space
odd
or
nce
cleara
leave
compositio n is to
tive space
er intention is to make a primi
between functiona l boxes. Anoth
perceived from inside as well as
be
can
house
the
of
shell
Where the outer
e to get
also can be considered as a devic
from outside. This composi tion
boxes
ner
in
the
case,
most
et boundary. In
the largest space within a pre-s
the larger space
s,
room
bed
and
s
loset
c
,
are a bathroom , a kitch en
smaller
boxes is livi ng room , and the
between an outer shell and inner
are not
segments of space and function
spaces are corridors. However,
change
to
t
rimen
expe
an
is
lator 's House
necessary to correspond . Articu
corridor connected to
a
as
tube
A
.
boxes
ner
in
the
the contents and roll of
d by
the outer shell. The rooms divide
outsi de articulates the space inside
shell connecting to
outer
the
of
inside
the
of
part
a
the closed corridor are
ants in
physical movement of the in habit
each other above the tube. The
.
or on the tube articulates the space
11
2004
T Clin ic
S LI I*i~
t- ;; :171 t-
Sky Light
. ,, i*J~O)i*Jf!
Blue Inner Wall of Inner Shell
ill~0)9j.~O);I;#
~::.0~17.)~1'1
.=ctJf-e~~J:?I:tJ:-:Jt.:. , $1-~0)~iliil:v.c.-:>t::lt:!!~:~t't~-=c.':~-c.
I"<JJ51lO)J51l/iO)/!liaii:I!P~t::.'JI~tJ:!!!Hilt. -t-O)r.,l:ffli>~
,-"',,._''"'"-
t.l.O:.tl.-cl ~~.
.=
I"Hi;>liJ'":>ftf
"bright, wi th no hospital
The client, a doctor, wanted a clinic that would be
of the hospita l
antness
unpleas
the
change
to
sought
sm ell. " He
narrow internal
in
waits
long
and
experience, with its antisept ic smell
in recent years seen an
has
area
ing
surround
the
,
addition
In
.
corridors
particularly targeted. In
Increase in petty crime, with the clinic being
floor" was specified .
first
the
on
windows
no
"
for
ent
requirem
a
,
response
and we decided to
,
clinic
the
in
needed
About 20 different rooms were
The idea was for a
develop the simplest possible spatial arrangement.
rooms is sheathed in an
nested box, in which a layered battery of small
all around . This gap
outer she ll , with the intervening gap circulat ing
the cellular rooms to
of
that
and
floor
second
the
enabled the position of
:tr::Ji!ij""f
left: Corridor
{'j :ffl ~~
right: Wa itmg Room
~-~
Treatment Room
__
-:::::
u
0 1-1-10
L_L_L_
llilf'fitil@
IF Plan
r!
!'
:.
(_
L!:::===~==~===========:::!J
2111f'Fitiliil
2f Plan
"--.::::::
____ :
I=
... '
::
'
..
-..::.
r~-;:n JO)litJ:~
~!i'; (( 7 =/\? .::z O)~rr-c I;:L ~ful:: '7 /JL--~~c?
ci.J.:.
tJ:tftJ,cll?c, u-c-:JI::I;:t ,
tm~0)5J' lll'J~i!C9'J u~p~~.., cL.,a=: ?J: ?tJ: , ~~0):17 / =
/~t <?L.,~ .::C:HlcfvcL.,tJ: l 1-z'fi"f:O)~rs,~ ;:t~'t'~tJ:
l ltJ'c .l!t ~t.:1J'<?'t'9. 'b?Uc-:JI;:t, ~t!lmJillO)fi"f:fuO)~
~~tJ:~*~~ .~, i5'L.,l lc.li!:t ~t.:/J' <?'t'L.,t.:tl. .
~* ~
ci61vtC: fi"f: fuO) .~, iS' L.,~ l;:t , -tn -fn O) ft? O) i!C il rriOO
1::J: ~-c ~ 1~ R .:: ~n-c l I.Qc ~/Jl. -:J l 1f.:O)'t'9 . ?~ c fi
"f: O) ~ii , i!Cii:rr iOO O) m" ~ 'F f~t l ;:t , ~ ~tJJ~ :It 1:~tt-cm 1:
i!/:9
~~tiJ O)mJ
1'
l:ti;!M-1:
. lj(:<$;EI3~
CfJ ~
-
Wiiilli!lll:
<1>9'/:i!lll:
Center Position
!!
e on BUILT FORM
e.
g from below
ulat
circ
ndin
to
asce
in
t
beg
ligh
y
,
antl
ows
inst
wind
t can
s and making horizontal
van ishes, and air and ligh
the interior
l planning was eave
es of the ceiling, flooding
convent ional architectura
cts on the metal su rfac
refle
al most total absence of
cts
effe
m
effect. A
imu
ting
max
ligh
g
erin
cted
end
xpe
eng
une
of
an
ieving
a notion
also due to imp lementi ng
with indirect light and ach
ted
Faustino ,
wan
er
we
s,
Didi
t
word
itec
uguese arch
l operations. In other
ours , the Paris-based Port
with mm1 mum architectura
ration " is
le th rough friend of
nste
who
"Mo
the
n."
ing
ratio
rmin
nste
dete
y
as "mo
of instantl
described the Gae Hou se
to dev1se a luci d method
thought it might has
visible their distinctive
way of making places. We
everyday things to make
of
ent
rgem
enla
one s1m ple principle and
the
life is
ily
da
n
whe
sters lurking with in
rge
mon
eme
the
invoke
tions wi ll first
es, producing shapes that
be good if so-ca lled func
throughout the valu
differently. Perhaps
an,
Jap
seen
In
be
.
also
ized
will
t
real
men
so
overla1 d on t he places
reality. The same environ
at,
defe
time
ve in them , they
war
belie
the
to
t
you star
growth that followed
ghouls and goblins, once
period of high economic
aps e, many just like
monsteration ."
coll
t
"deis
uen
this
seq
of
sub
its
osite
y and
The opp
t hen th e bub ble econom
seem to be everywhere .
I
and
,
ture
the Gae House
itec
rd,
arch
rega
sters. In this
buil t as works of
words, to block the mon
detached houses have been
same time , In other
ture without
itec
the
at
Arch
Yet
like
e.
ks
valu
Boo
ural
e cult
monster .
has been called a cute
acknowle dge their collectiv
stic
neri
in groups.
Man
ear
y
app
s
fairl
such monster
itionally they occupy a
are interesting because
systemat ically and compos
small, but
reality of Architects
be
the
all
from
may
ted
now
to
isola
t
up
produced
that they exis
The houses that we have
realm, and in this I feel
of
we want
nce
gs,
abse
l
thin
"
tota
and miserable
i Hou se, there is an almost
being negative "narrow
life. Therefore , in the An
, such rather than
resi dential
ture
new
itec
t
arch
itan
of
com
work
con
a
with
expected from
birth to small monsters
the thi ngs that would be
trast, relative to give
ough points is in BUI LT
spaces, directionality, con
k that one of ou r breakthr
thin
I
ns.
ditio
con
as a hierarchy of internal
to
how
of
stion
que
the
is, we addressed
.
stren gths... Instead of th
about the BUILT FORM
other words, by thinking
in
e;
scap
town
the
in
build
of
kind
this
oses
encl
in the context that
FORM, conversely, we drew
Momoyo Kai Ji ma
the loco House , the entry point is on the corner, and the surface of
the volume is folded and torn . A barbershop entrance was made by
putting in glazing at the corner, turning it into a storefront. The
courtyard of the loco House is vi sible from an aperture on the
corner of the volume , but this is interesting. It causes a courtyard
that might tend to be closed to become very open . This is a result
of plac i ng a courthouse on a small corner site . I f the site
characteristics and the architectural form can become organically
interrelated in this way , the lifestyle will not be restricted and
choked by the site conditions. I think that drawing out maximum
synergy from the site characteristics and the architectural form is
linked to obtaining a degree of freedom of lifestyle, not only a
degree of freedom in the design . Depending on the way the
"shape" of the SITE is parsed and used, there are cases where it
wil l be invigorated , and cases where wi ll not be .
they are wide to the rear but have a narrow access road,
must be at least 2m wide to allow building on the site .
by other buildings that make construction work
I they are inexpensive, but if this is also regarded as a
it can perhaps be eva luated affirmatively. Although
,~]
on CONVENTIONAL ELEMENT
interest in conventional elements was triggered by
cammiss;ionl!d to us due to an introduction from one of the big
companies . Because it was an introduct ion, the
not feel as though they had commissioned us from the
In this case, it seemed like ly that we would be rejected if we
Momoyo Kaijima
Tsukamoto
12.1
14 7
I
I
Momoyo Kaiji ma
Yosh iharu Tsukam oto
1'1'1
'
on OCCUPANCY
quickly. This approach gives
a beauty supported from the
inside, by
the inevitable layout of objects
and usage of spaces. This
is also
the meri t of Pet Architecture .
Although the scale is different,
I
think
that there is a similar beauty
between " making" and "usin
in my experience of Made in
g. " Furthermore , although
Tokyo such as in the way scenes
wrapped in neon are beautiful
despite
being chaotic . As for the over
corr espo nden ce with "m akin
whelming quantities of com
g " and " usin g." When
modities
on
the
she
lves
that line convenience stores,
or carpenters are directly enga
I feel this is beautiful
ged , that is, in cases where
in itsel f. It seems that
are their own clien ts, it wou
pet arch itect ure as well as
ld norm al ly be thou ght that
worthless
arch
itect
ure
arises from the " usin g " imag
g" and " usin g " are inco ngru
inati on. At the Gae
ous, but from my own
House (p.38) , there is an OCC
, there is a cons idera ble
UPANCY of the spaces by the
over lap of "ma king " and
books
kept underground, and the
and they should permeate each
light entering from the eave
other. If this office space seco
s on the
nd level. By preparing place
which we cu rrently work is seen
s directed toward OCCUPA
from the aspect of "mak ing,"
NCY
it before daily life begins, the
users will then make various
scenes of
OCCUPANCY with in the build
drawings and models from its
ing. Accepting the clien t 's
usage as a design office , it
request
has that, "rather than a wide
a unique space. In this way,
single space , I would prefer
it is clear that a "usi ng" orde
many smaller
r rooms," the Gak Hous e (p.92
been over laid on the com posi
) is composed only of small spac
tiona l orde r of " mak ing ."
es. The
width of one room is less
For instance , inside a hobb
than two tatami mats, but
y collector's room, things are
by placing
diffe
rent
thing
s
in
each
d i n perf e c t orde r . Alth ough
room , such as the book room
, the musical
ther e are diffe renc es instr
ument room , the television
on the person, I think people
room, every room has been
find beauty and comfort in into
made
a scene of OCCUPANCY.
Stro lling throu gh each one,
the
expe
rience is like walking around
in this is that the division of
a small palace . I think that
"making I using " just kind
this
of " making" is achieved by
means of a jig for the behavior
of
peop le and the accu mula tion
. We are now groping for a way
of obje cts. In a place aime
to exceed this scheme, by a
d at
mult
iple
phen
ome
na
, the composition unavoidab
of those spatial qualities that
ly remains in the
emerge only from ongoing
arch itect ure. Taking this com
into the "mak ing." We want
position as a jig, I think that
to make a vibrant architecture
it is
impo rtan t to relocate it. By
the mutu al enhanceme nt of
doing this, arch itect ure can
" mak ing " and "usi ng." One
indu
ce
conditions that trigger the beha
for this is to take scenes
vior of people and the acc umu
of OCCUPANCY , rathe r than
lation
of
obje
cts.
I
n the Juicy House, a single color
itions of spat ial char acte ristic
has been applied to
s. "Ow ners hip" may be the
rooms , occupying this place
even if t ime and the living
. The dimension of OCCUPA
body are not brought into due
NCY
to
peop
le
will appear in contrast with
has been designated as the
this . Color can also
subj ect, but I think that give
a sense of encouraging peop
will not occur unless one's own
le to occupy: " hey, it would
body is thrown in and good
be
to occupy something like this.
is allowed to pass. The repetition
" Luis Barragan also colored
of human behavior and the
room
s
pi
nk
and
yello
w,
and
of places by objects will dete
there too is a sense of occu
rmine the qualities of the place
pying a
due to the way light responds
that emerge due to th is OCC
to the colors. The light entering
UPANCY . For instance, an
from the eaves of the Gae
workshop is also beautiful. This
House is also like that , but
is not the contrived beauty actio
when the
n of the light starts to be
an objective exte rior . It is
affected by the presence of
generated by work that requ
this
ires bui lding , the light beha
the tools for easy use , and alwa
ves like a living thing , so it feels
ys being able to find things
like you are
occupying the space together
with it.
Momoyo Kaij i ma
Yoshiharu Tsuk amot o