Perforating 20090717 PDF
Perforating 20090717 PDF
Perforating 20090717 PDF
Revision
Original
Revision
Date
July 1, 2009
Author/Reviser
E Coludrovich
Contributors/Reviewers
Table of Contents
Perforating .......................................................................................................... 1
Introduction......................................................................................................... 3
Well Control ........................................................................................................ 3
Extreme overbalanced ...................................................................................... 3
Overbalanced.................................................................................................... 4
Balanced ........................................................................................................... 4
Underbalanced.................................................................................................. 4
Dynamic underbalance ..................................................................................... 5
Deployment ......................................................................................................... 5
Formation Damage and Cleanup ....................................................................... 8
Perforation Geometry Considerations .............................................................. 9
Charge type selection ...................................................................................... 10
QA QC ................................................................................................................ 11
Safety ................................................................................................................. 12
Firing Systems .................................................................................................. 13
Tubing Pressure Activated .............................................................................. 13
Annular Pressure Activated............................................................................. 13
Mechanical Impact (Drop Bar) ........................................................................ 13
Electrically Activated ....................................................................................... 13
Retrievable Slickline Firing Head .................................................................... 14
Module 2 Perforating Procedures ................................................................ 14
Wireline Conveyed Perforating ....................................................................... 14
Casing Guns Run in Overbalance ................................................................... 14
Through Tubing Perforating ............................................................................ 15
Tubing Conveyed Perforating ......................................................................... 17
Appendix 1 - Over or Under Balance Perforating Calculation ...................... 21
Appendix 2 - TCP Perforating Schematic ....................................................... 22
Appendix 3 - Sample Pill Recipes ................................................................... 23
Appendix 4 - Acronyms.................................................................................... 24
INTRODUCTION
The primary purpose for perforating is to provide a connection between the
wellbore and the formation, that is to say a way to penetrate casing and cement
to provide reservoir communication. Below are some issues that should be
considered before selecting the perforation charge and technique.
The goals for perforating can also include:
WELL CONTROL
When perforating well control should always be kept in the forefront of the design
process. Remember, this process will bring hydrocarbons into the wellbore
potentially destabilizing hydraulic well control. The following is a short description
of the most common perforating scenarios and the various hydraulic influences
associated with each.
EXTREME OVERBALANCED
This technique can be performed with EL, TCP or CT guns and is typically used
in tighter formations where a short set of near well hydraulic fractures could
improve well connectivity. The expectation is that upon perforating the formation
will instantly fracture allowing whatever is in the wellbore to be blown into the
reservoir in such a manner as to improve the connectivity between the inside of
the well bore and the formation. If all goes as planned, there will also be some
stimulation benefits.
One method is to pressure up on the tubing well above formation fracture
pressure prior to detonating the perforation charges. Be aware that this technique
may result in exceeding the casing/tubing burst at surface for deeper wells.
Safety calculations should always be performed to insure this is not an issue.
OVERBALANCED
This technique is usually used when there is no pipe in the hole to circulate out
an influx of formation fluids. Sometimes this is done in conjunction with a kill pill
on bottom (solids laden with a cross-linked polymer). For example, when
perforating with casing guns on wireline one does not want to be facing a gas
kick while pulling out of the hole with the cable. It can be used with any
conveyance method.
It is important if possible to have clear completion fluid in the well to minimize
formation damage. An issue with overbalanced perforating is increased likelihood
of ineffective perforations due to plugging or a crush zone loss of permeability.
When the perforations are formed a compaction or crushed zone is formed along
the edge of the perforation tunnel. As a rule of thumb the permeability
associated with the crushed zone is 30% of formation permeability. Combine
this with a solids laden fluid and the resulting damage can become significant.
Note that this method compared to the other perforating techniques, all other
things being equal, results in the most amount of ineffective perforations.
BALANCED
This technique is usually used when perforating via wireline. This method
minimizes the risk of wireline guns blown being up the hole. Note when shooting
in multiple stages that even if the first set of perforations are shot under balanced
all subsequent perforation will be shot balanced.
UNDERBALANCED
This technique is frequently used in conjunction with sand control operations.
The advantage of this technique is the potential for removal of some if not most
the crushed rock debris in the perforation tunnel, which results from the
detonation event. It is important to remember that well control is necessary after
the perforating event; therefore, a fluid loss pill of some type is needed to seal off
the perforation tunnel immediately after the detonation of the shape charges.
The formulation of the fluid loss pill is critical to minimize the potential for
formation damage to the perforation tunnel. Fluid loss pills are discussed in a
following section.
DYNAMIC UNDERBALANCE
Conventional static underbalance perforating is believed to clean up the
perforation tunnel as a result of the surge flow from the reduction in near wellbore
pressure. Research has shown that fluctuations in the wellbore pressure
immediately after the perforating event are more important to the clean up of the
perforation. Testing shows that application of these dynamic wellbore pressures
does indeed help to clean up the perforation tunnels better than conventional
underbalance practices. The process uses custom shape charges, and fit-forpurpose gun configurations. Modeling by the service provider is required to
optimize the process.
Nodal analysis programs (e.g. WEM or Prosper or Net Tools) should be run to
evaluate the sensitivity of perforation geometry to inflow performance.
Perforation core test results provide more accurate charge performance
geometry if available. Post completion comparison using nodal analysis should
be run to develop a normalized model for future production planning.
Note: API Shape Charge performance data does not reflect actual performance in
field applications. The only true way to find out the performance of a particular
shape charge for your application is to conduct a Section II (stress rock) test
using the shape charge and actual field core or rock sample with similar
Unconfined Compressive Strength. Some service providers have programs that
predict actual shape charge performance. However, the data used in the
programs may not be from stressed rock tests, which can result in optimistic
predictions.
DEPLOYMENT
Perforating gun deployment can be made in different ways:
Wireline
Casing guns
Through tubing guns
Coiled tubing
Tubing conveyed
Easy to correlate
Large charges
Low cost
Good phasing
Proof of gun
firing
Cheap
No formation
damage
Easy to correlate
Safe as well as
wellheads may be
Doesnt require
rig
in placedeployed
under well
pressure
Well can be put on
production
Immediately
No long exposure
of charges to
hostile well
environment
long perf
assembly
Can use full size
charges
Good phasing
Well can be put
on production
Immediately
Perforate long
intervals in one
run
Good for highly
deviated or
horizontal wells
CASING GUNS
Weakness
Where to Use
Operating
Hints
Underbalance
may cause gun
to jump, leading
to fishing
problems; may
only be used on
first run in hole
Guns and
wireline can be
lost in the hole
Length of gun
limited by
wireline strength
Usually run in
kill fluid which
may cause
formation
damage
Port plugs may
come loose and
stick the gun
Wells which
always need
stimulation
For multiple
zones that are
far apart
Thin zones less
than 1 m which
must be
accurately
perforated
Use a surge
disk in the
tubing string to
simulate
underbalance
THROUGH TUBING
GUNS
TUBING
CONVEYED GUNS
Good productivity
wells with
production
restrictions
Re-perforating of
sweet wells
Low budget wells
Use a decentralizer
to reduce clearance
and improve
penetration
Most expensive
Depth correlation
is difficult
Must drop guns
for stimulation or
logging requires
more rathole
Requires rig
Long exposure of
charges to hostile
well environment
Must retrieve
entire assembly if
gun misfires
Cannot tell how
many charges
fired until gun is
retrieved
Deviated wells
Long intervals
Wells that flow
strong
immediately after
perforating
For multiple zones
that are close
together
There are several types of firing heads available for detonating the guns:
Electrically fired
Underbalanced perforating
Perforation surging/washing
Extreme-overbalanced perforating
Acid stimulation
Underbalance
Filtered fluid
Shot density
Perforation length
In critical wells, wells with greater than 10,000 psi bottomhole pressure, or
greater than 300 F temperature, or greater than 4,000 ft of water depth or
greater than 20,000 ft of well depth, perforating guns are run with redundant firing
heads to ensure the guns will fire.
Figure 1 - Temperature-time
RDX
HMX
HNS
Maximum Temperature
@100 hour
225
300
450
In higher temperature (> 200F), HMX charges should be used if exposed to this
temperature more than 100 hours. If > 300F, HNS charges should be used;
>380F, HTNS charges should be used; and, > 440F but < 500F, PYX charges
should be used.
Exceeding the ratings by only a few degrees is sufficient to show signs of out
gassing and decomposition resulting in loss of performance. At the next level of
degradation the explosive will start to burn. Taking HMX and RDX above 300
and going well beyond the time limits may result in auto detonation. Other
explosives are not known to auto detonate. - From Schlumberger
QA QC
The following quality control checks should be made in critical projects:
Detonating cord
o Cord is checked for holidays or defects (X-ray).
o Review of certification from manufacturer with documentation of
test results from critical properties.
Perforating shaped charges
o Explosives properties are checked and documented to ensure
conformance to specification
o Results of QC shots at regular specified intervals are reviewed. QC
checks of sensitivity are reviewed.
O-ring material
o Reliance on prior ERTs, history, or job-specific testing.
Boosters
o Review of composition and physical properties. Consignment
based on standard deviation.
Carriers
o Mill certification provided with results indicating carriers meet yield
strength, tensile strength, Charpy v-notch impact, material
composition, and material hardness requirements.
o Certification that carriers were inspected at the mill for non-metallic
inclusion and grain size.
Material traceability for explosives is by batch number/lot number. DSC and reel
number for cord. Hardware traceability is by heat number, P. O. number, part
number, and serial number.
SAFETY
In the event of any total misfire or no-fire of the perforating guns, it is imperative
that the perforating contractor is contacted immediately. The perforating
contractor should, after assessing the sequence of events, prepare a detailed
procedure for recovery of the guns.
General safety procedures exist as follows for perforating operations:
Perforation operations are not allowed during thunder, lightning, and thick
fog.
All radio transmitters, radio beacons included, within a radius of 1,500 ft.
from the well, shall be turned off. All portable transmitters shall be placed
inside the office and turned off to avoid accidental transmission.
Cranes and welding machines shall be taken out of service from gun
arming until gun is pulled out of the well and unloaded.
FIRING SYSTEMS
It is normal practice to run the TCP guns with two firing systems, whenever
possible, to improve the chance of a successful operation especially when
running the guns on the bottom of a completion. A common combination is to
use a tubing pressure actuated system as the primary means of detonating the
TCP guns with a mechanical system as a back up. There are four major types of
firing mechanisms for TCP guns. Only top down firing mechanisms should be
used for safety when arming the guns. The different firing mechanisms are listed
in the following.
ELECTRICALLY ACTIVATED
With this system, the guns are fired with an electrically-initiated detonator which must be
run on a logging cable. Therefore the pressure control system must be rigged up. Since
an inductive or wet electrical connection must be made at the firing head, the system is
also susceptible to debris.
The use of this type of system is increasing as advances are made in methods to initiate
the detonation process. The advantage of this type of firing system is that the firing
heads for this system are wireline retrievable, hence, the guns can be run unarmed and,
in the case of a misfire, the firing head can be recovered on wireline to determine the
cause of the misfire.
Radio silence must be in force before connecting the cable head until the
guns are 100 meters below the seabed.
On recovery of the guns, regardless of any indications that the guns have
fired, radio silence must be in force before the guns are pulled back past 100
meters below ground level and until the cable head is removed.
The logging engineer should be given a diagram of the well showing the
depths of all restrictions or changes in diameter. The well shall be circulated to
proper overbalance with perforation fluid (clean to XX NTUs per displacement
procedure). Prior to running perforating guns in the well a dummy (exact OD of
swollen guns) shall be run in the well to confirm no tight spots.
2) Wireline should be rigged up as per the procedure in the Wireline
Procedures Manual. Ensure lubricator has appropriate connection to BOPs.
Rig up lubricator and grease injector to BOPs. Guns will have been made up
and can be lowered through the BOPs if well has not been perforated and
pressure below the BOP is zero. If lubricator cannot be tested to bottomhole
pressure before rig up, please test lubricator to full bottomhole pressure test
before bringing on location.
3) If perforating inside casing ensure the length of the gun assembly is less than
the distance between the blind rams and the grease head. The length of the gun
assembly must be less than 1 stand of workstring in the rig. The length of the
gun assembly will include necessary logging tools to be run with the guns for
depth correlation.
4) The distance between the top shot and the GR/CCL should be measured. It
may sometime not be necessary to run a record of the depth by GR or CCL if
depth can be correlated to a sump packer or bridge plug.
5) The logging engineer must not connect the cable head until the Well
Operations Supervisor, or his designated representative, has confirmed that
radio silence is instated.
6) There is no restriction on running speed but care must be taken at any
restrictions and when applying the brake.
7) The Logging Engineer must inform the Completion Supervisor, or his
designated representative, when the guns are deeper than 100 meters below
ground level.
8) Tie on depth to the CBL/VDL/GR/CCL log if available and it has been tied to
openhole log from which perforations were picked. Record a short section of film
across the interval to be perforated showing at least five casing collars and the
pup joint at the top of the reservoir section and/or radioactive tagged joint(s). The
well should be perforated from the bottom upwards.
9) When the gun is on depth and ready to be fired, the logging engineer must
inform the Well Operations Supervisor, or his designated representative, and the
driller, who should observe the well for losses or gains when the gun is fired.
10) When the gun is free and the hole is stable (no significant losses or not trying
to flow), start to pull out of the hole. If necessary to perforate additional pay,
another set of guns should be prepared at surface and run into the hole as it is
stable.
11) Pull out at less than 5,000 ft/hour to avoid swabbing.
zone first, otherwise the well should be perforated from the bottom upwards to
minimize the chance of picking up debris on the cable.
1) A safety meeting will be held to review procedures and safety, specifically:
2) The well is underbalanced and will be live after the first run
3) The wireline BOPs and lubricator should have been pressure tested
4) The surface rig up must be pressure tested before each run
5) Ensure the GR/CCL log that has been tied to openhole log from which perfs
were chosen is available across zone of interest.
6) The logging engineer should be given a diagram of the well and test string
showing the depths of all restrictions or changes in diameter and he should
check that he has sufficient weights for the maximum anticipated wellhead
pressure.
7) Rig up wireline for a full bore drift run. Run in the hole and drift the tubing.
2) Hole pre-job safety meeting in accordance with Opco standards. Be sure all
rig and service personnel are clear on sequence of events for perforating and
safety considerations. The meeting should cover, but not be limited to the
following:
3)
Guns fail to fire
Severe fluid loss occurs
Tool failure occurs, surface and
downhole
Well control issues
Equipment layout
SIMOPS
Emergency events
4) Assuming cement bond is satisfactory; pick up TCP and test tools assembly
on workstring, as per example in attached schematic. The multi-purpose valve
should be in well test position. Adjust fluid level to achieve desired underbalance,
overbalance, or balance pressure at which to perforate.
5) Measure and record all assembly dimensions and lengths including running of
drift on location. Lower guns through floor. Place safety clamps on the top gun
before setting slips. Multi-purpose valve should be in test position. Clear rig floor
of all non-essential personnel before putting firing head on gun.
NOTE: 1. Rabbit all tubulars.
2. If pipe dope is to be used, apply sparingly to pin
ends only.
3. Pick up and sit down on slips gently.
4. Have tank on rig to flow back surge.
6) GIH to automatic fill valve closing depth. Verify valve is closed by pressuring
up on workstring to 500 psi.
7) Just prior to tagging the Sump Packer (1-2 stands above), accurately
determine and record pick up and slack off weights.
7-a)Rig up all surface lines and pressure test to X,XXX psi. Slowly lower guns
and snap in and out of sump packer to verify depth. Position guns to perforate
from X,XXX ft X,XXX ft. Pickup control head assembly and break circulation.
Do not go above XXX psi pressure.
7-b) If no sump packer is present in the well, rig up wireline and run correlation
gamma ray log down tubing/workstring to verify gun positioning via radioactive
sub above TCP guns and casing RA tag. Re-position guns if necessary. POOH
with wireline, rig down same.
NOTE: Do not cycle multi-purpose valve.
accidentally cut !
Wireline could be
8) PU control head and finish rigging up all surface control lines. Test lines to
X,XXX psi. Set service packer. Set down weight on packer (~50,000 lbs).
Pressure up on backside slowly to 1,000 psi to confirm packer is set and
multipurpose valve is in well test position.
9) Prior to firing guns, conduct a safety meeting.
10) This procedure is an example of an annular pressure firing method with a
drop bar backup.
Pressure up on annulus to XXXX psi to open annulus
production valve and actuate the annulus pressure firing device. Guns are
usually set to fire in 5-6 minutes when using time delay firing head.
Firing pin calculation sheet of Vendor workbook:
NOTE:
NOTE:
Appendices:
Appendix 1 Over or Under Balance Perforating Calculation
Appendix 2 TCP Perforating Schematic
Appendix 3 Sample Pill Recipes
Appendix 4 Abbreviations
APPENDIX 1 - OVER
Example: With 8.7 ppg completion fluid in the well, we have calculated that it would be
exerting 4,524 psi hydrostatic pressure on the reservoir. When the well is perforated,
the wellbore will see 6,000 psi from the reservoir trying to enter. The difference will be
1,476-psi underbalance in the wellbore.
6,000 psi (reservoir)
- 4,524 psi (wellbore)
1.476 psi into the wellbore or the wellbore is underbalanced.
APPENDIX 2 - TCP
PERFORATING SCHEMATIC
Tool Schematic
DST / TCP
Date:
Prepared For:
Attention Of:
Field Name:
Lease:
Casing:
Liner:
Drill Pipe:
Drill Pipe:
Drill Pipe:
Drill Pipe:
5
6
Item
Description
1 0
1 1
1 2
1 3
1 4
1 5
1 6
1 7
1 8
1 9
2 0
2 1
2 2
2 3
2 4
2 5
2 6
2 7
2 8
2 9
3 0
3 1
3 2
3 3
3 4
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
I.D.
(in)
4.670
4.276
4.276
2.250
3.500
3.500
2.250
2.250
3.500
3.500
2.250
3.500
4.910
2.870
3.500
2.764
2.441
2.250
2.250
2.250
2.250
2.250
2.250
2.440
O.D.
(in)
Length
(ft)
Depth
(ft)
7.000
6.000
6.625
5.030
6.375
6.375
5.030
5.030
6.375
6.375
5.000
6.375
6.120
7.950
4.750
4.750
3.668
3.668
5.030
3.668
3.668
5.030
3.668
3.510
3.375
3.375
3.375
4.625
4500.00
18000.00
3555.27
5.67
93.00
10.00
21.15
3.44
60.00
10.00
8.25
10.00
4.00
10.00
4543.13
2.50
2.00
31.00
15.85
31.00
10.00
9.50
63.00
1.50
2.91
3.41
3.42
10.00
0.00
4500.00
22500.00
26055.27
26060.94
26153.94
26163.94
26185.09
26188.53
26248.53
26258.53
26266.78
26276.78
26280.78
26290.78
30833.91
30836.41
30838.41
30869.41
30885.26
30916.26
30926.26
30935.76
30998.76
31000.26
31003.17
31006.58
31010.00
31020.00
4.625
152.00
31172.00
31172.00
APPENDIX 3 - SAMPLE
PILL RECIPES
Amounts
For 1,000 Gallons
1000 gal.
8 buckets
10 gal.
22.5 lbs.
5.0 gal. *
APPENDIX 4 - ACRONYMS
Acronyms
Description
API
ASS
ASV
BA
Breathing Apparatus
bbl
Barrels
BOP
bpd
BS&W
CCL
CHECT
CLD
CPDEP
CSON
CT
Coiled Tubing
D/P
Differential Pressure
DCR
deg
Degree
DST
Drillstem Test
EL
Electric Line
ESD
ESP
ETC
EWT
Extended Welltest
FO
Full Open
GLM
GLV
GOR
H2S
Hydrogen Sulphide
HMV
HPHT
hrs
Hours
HSE
HSP
ID
Inside Diameter
in
Inch
LIB
LMRP
LSA
Page 24 of 27
2009 Chevron Corp. All Rights Reserved
LSU
MD
Measured Depth
MLE
MMV
Acronyms
Description
NORM
NRV
OD
Outside Diameter
OIM
PA
Public Address
PBR
PBTD
PCT
PON
POOH
ppf
ppm
psi
QA
Quality Assurance
RAM
RCV
RIH
Run in Hole
RKB
RPM
SBA's
SG
Specific Gravity
SITHP
SIWHP
SL
Slick Line
SPM
SRB
SRO
SSLV
SSSV
SSTT
STT
TCP
TH
Tubing Hanger
THOJ
THRT
TIW
TRSSSV
Page 25 of 27
2009 Chevron Corp. All Rights Reserved
TVD
UKOOA
VPR
WEG
WHP
WL
Wireline
WP
Working Pressure
Page 26 of 27
2009 Chevron Corp. All Rights Reserved
Page 27 of 27
2009 Chevron Corp. All Rights Reserved