Section 9.1.1-6 GER3621
Section 9.1.1-6 GER3621
Section 9.1.1-6 GER3621
GE Power Generation
Steam Turbine-Generator
MaintainabilityA Means to Improve Unit Availability
R.T. Bievenue
GE Company
Schenectady, New York
GE TURBINE REFERENCE
LlSRARY
RT. Bievenue
GE Company
Schenectady, New York
INTRODUCTION
Reliability, availability, and efficiency are the
three critical performance
measurements for
industrial steam turbine-generator units. Reliability
is a measurement of freedom from unexpected
(forced) outages due to equipment component or
system failure that prevents operation of the unit. As
normally defined*, reliability of industrial steam
turbine-generator units can be expected to be about
99%. Availability is a measurement of the time the
unit is available for and capable of serving the
intended function. In defining availabilityt, the
unavailable time is due to forced outage time and
planned maintenance time. Forced outage time
should obviously be minimized because it is always
disruptive to the normal plant operations and can
be very expensive and time consuming to make the
necessary repairs, depending on the nature of the
failure. However, it is not obvious that time spent on
planned maintenance should be minimized because
the degree and frequency of maintenance can and
does have a direct impact on the other two critical
performance measurements: reliability and efficiency. Too little maintenance can increase forced
outages to an unacceptable level and also result in
decreased unit efficiency such that operating costs
are considerably greater than desired. Too much
maintenance means unnecessary work is being
done, thus expending time and resources that could
be used better elsewhere. Hence, maintenance
planning
should be aimed at optimizing
the
planned outages such that overall costs are minimized while satisfying the operational requirements
placed on the unit
The owners/operators have the primary responsibility for and control over the maintenance of the
steam turbine-generator. However, GE contributes
to the maintenance of the equipment in two significant areas: the original design of the components
* Reliabilitv (%) = [Period Hours - Forced Outage Hours (loo%)] /
Period Hours
t Availabilitv (%) = [Period Hours - Forced Outage Hours Planned
Outage Hours (lOO%)] / Period Hours
DESIGNING FOR
MAINTAINABILITY
The optimum time to consider turbine-generator
maintenance is in the initial design stages of the
various components and systems. Over the past
decades, many maintenance features have been
designed into the steam turbine-generators manufactured by GE, features we may now refer to as
traditional maintenance features. These will be
discussed in some detail.
In designing for maintainability,
the primary
functional requirements of the equipment cannot
be ignored. Many features could be incorporated
that could be very helpful strictly from the standpoints of assembly, disassembly, and inspection.
However, some features that would be ideal for
maintainability
may be detrimental to the operational reliability and efficiency of the machine.
Fewer and/or smaller bolts, for example, would
make assembly and disassembly of the turbine
easier but would probably result in steam leakage
through the bolted flanges. Larger flanges, both
internal and external to the turbine shells and lowpressure inner casings, could provide better access
to bolts for the use of hydraulic or pneumatic tools.
The larger flanges, however, could result in
efficiency losses because of flow obstructions. They
could also result in reliability problems due to
greater thermal stresses in the more massive and
rigid structures. For this particular example, reli-
Rotors
TRADITIONAL
FEATURES
Numerous maintainability
features have been
designed into the major turbine-generator
components and systems for many years. Some of the
significant features are described in the following
paragraphs.
Turbine
Shells
Low-Pressure Turbine
and Inner Casings
Exhaust Hoods
Primary
Steam Valves
System
Bolting
Various alloy steels are used for bolting applications, ranging from low-alloy steel to 12% chromium
alloy for the high-temperature locations. For highly
stressed tap bolts and studs, tapered threads are
used to obtain a more uniform load distribution
over the engaged threads, which can be beneficial
in avoiding cracking at the first or second engaged
thread, the location of high load concentration for
the nontapered thread design. Where required, the
large bolts used in turbine shells are prestretched by
heating to obtain the required bolting force. Heater
holes are provided for the use of electrical resistance
heaters for assembly and disassembly. Tapped
holes are provided in the large studs and nuts for
lifting.
Turbine-Generator
Control
Supervisory Systems
and
The turbine-generator
control and supervisory
systems must be highly reliable to satisfactorily
perform the critical functions of accurately controlling speed, load, and extraction steam flows of
the unit by regulating very large steam flows and
continuously
monitoring
numerous operating
parameters to detect potentially dangerous conditions. The fast response and degree of redundancy
built into the modern electrohydraulic
control
(EHC) system components provide reliable protective action while minimizing false trips. Some of
the significant maintenance features are:
l
l
l
Two-out-of-three
logic for many protective
devices in the EHC system to permit on-line
service on units having modem digital controls.
Selective operating modes of the EHC Control
system to permit on-line maintenance of control
circuits.
Available annunciation contacts that provide
valuable troubleshooting
information in the
event of protection system action.
Functional separation of EHC circuit boards to
facilitate troubleshooting.
Availability of analog signals from turbinegenerator supetisory instrumentation to permit
on-line servicing of digital systems.
STEAM TURBINE-GENERATOR
MAINTENANCE
As previously stated, maintenance of the steam
turbine-generator should be performed in a manner
Table 1
INDUSTRIAL
STEAM TURBINE-GENERATORS
RECOMMEN-DED
INTERVAIS
FOR SECIIONALIZED
MAINTENANCE
COMPONENT/SYSTEM
1YR
2YR
TIME INTERVAL
3YR
4YR
5YR
2 Stop valves
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
6YR
(internal)
Nonreturn valves
Admission/extraction
valves
EHC or three-arm
governor system
Turbine-generator
supervisory instrumentation
Bearings
Hydrogen seals
Hydrogen seal regulator
Lube oil system
Exciter - rotating or
excitation system - static
Steam seal system
Borescope inspection
(ienerator inspection
Polarization index
Lube oil pump test run
Lube oil filtering system
X
X
X
x
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
AS NEEDED BASED ON H2 USAGE
EVERY 4 YEARS OR AS NEEDED
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
RECOMMENDATIONS FOR
INDUSTRIAL STEAM TURBINEGENERATOR SECTIONALIZED
MAINTENANCE PROGRAM
Shell
-Inner
Surfaces. Visual and magnetic particle
test all accessible inner surfaces.
-Diaphragm
fits. Check for erosion and wear.
-Vertical
and Horizontal joints. Check for
erosion and wear.
-Spill strips. Check for erosion, wear, cracking,
missing pieces.
-Nozzle bore. Take flatness checks.
Diaphragms
This inspection includes complete turbine disassembly, steam path inspection, and all other
components included in the sectionalized maintenance program. A complete generator disassembly
and inspection is also performed during this outage.
When planning is complete and spare parts are
available, the major inspection could be performed
during the fifth year if maintenance requirements
warrant. The turbine-generator
should not be
operated beyond the six-year major inspection.
The following turbine components are to be
inspected:
and Nozzle
Plates
-Partition
Welds, Horizontal Joints, Rings,
Webs, Packing Fits. Nondestructive exam
(NDE) for cracks and check for-erosion.
-Sealing
and Radial Spill Strips. Check for
looseness, scoring, breakage.
-Centering
and Crush Pins. Take clearances
and check for wear, galling.
-Sealing Faces. Check for scoring and flatness.
-Nozzle
Plate Partitions and Body. Remove
and inspect. NDE for cracks. Bolting. Ultrasonic test.
0 Packings
-Teeth.
Check for wear, breakage, tooth
profile.
Rotor
-Deposits.
Identify locations and take samples, determine types and concentrations of corrosioncausing contaminants.
-Erosion.
Check first, last, and reheat stages.
-Tenons
and Shroud Bands.
Inspect for erosion, rubbing, looseness, and
deposits.
-Buckets.
Dovetail fit cracking and looseness. Vane
pitting and erosion. Erosion shield cracking,
erosion, loose joints.
-Steam Balance Holes.
Check for cracking and erosion.
-Thrust runners.
Check for fretting, scoring, and cracking.
-Packing and General Area Damage.
Check for rubbing, wear, scoring, out of
round, tapering, cracking, and discoloration.
-Balance Plugs and Holes.
Check for cracking, tightness, staking, and
open hole conditions.
-Couplings.
Check for cracks, scoring, and high spots.
Check for bolt hole galling and out of round.
Check face and rim runout, measure rabbet
fit and record.
-Dovetail Pins.
Check for cracking, staking, and looseness.
0 Packing
Steam Shields
Oil Deflectors
-Teeth.
Check for breakage, rubbing, and
wear areas.
-Sealing Surfaces. Check for scoring and high
spots.
l
Dowels
-Fits.
Inspect
tolerances.
for scoring,
galling,
and
Stop Valve
A leakage test, quick-closing, and uneven-operation check is performed yearly to determine if
deposits or internal
l
l
l
l
l
l
l
l
l
l
l
l
l
l
l
l
l
l
l
l
l
l
l
l
l
l
l
Complete
Valve
disassembly and inspection
is per-
Seals
Drains
Body NDE
Strainer
Valves
Seat
Disk
Packing Glands
Rocker Shaft
Weighted
Linkages
Operating
Level
Cylinder
Admission/Extraction
Valve
(tover
Nonreturn
Nuts
Control
Springs
Bolting
Cam Bearings
Cam Followers
Rocker Arm Bearing
Knockdown Pins
Cam Shaft Alignment
Linkage Connections
Gear Pinion to Rack Contact
Crosshead
Stem Bushings
Valve Timing
Valve Stroke
Sealing Welds
Seat Contact
Stem NDE
Seat
NDE
Disk
Disk Pin
Stem Sealing Grooves
l
l
l
l
l
l
l
l
l
Lift Rod
Bushing
Guide Bracket
Body
Spacer
Extraction Diaphragm
Strainer Plate
Seat NDE
Seat Contact
Valve Clearances
Gear Bearings
Gear Clearances
Governor
Systems
These governor control systems are to be inspected and calibrated every two years. Whenever
control valve maintenance is performed that
requires adjustments to the EHC feedback components, the control system must be rechecked.
Normal operational checks will indicate if there are
control problems.
Electrohydraulic Control System -The following
components are to be checked and calibrated:
6
Electrohydraulic
Control
Center
Hydraulic
l
l
l
l
l
l
l
l
l
l
Power Unit
-Tank Condition
-Fluid Condition
-Piping Connections
-Filters
-Relief Valves
-Pump Start and Alarm Switches
-Heaters
-Coolers
-Water Regulator
-Gauges
-Air Dryer
-Main
and Reserve Pump Condition
-Power Actuator Assemblies
l
Permanent
-Speed Control
-Load Control
-Flow Control
-Power Supplies
-Pressure Sensors
- Servovalves
-Alarm Trips
-Switches
-Monitor
Circuits
l
l
l
l
l
l
l
l
l
Magnet Generator
The following
needed basis:
-Output
Voltage
-Output
Frequency
-Terminal
Connections
-Cleanliness
-Bearing
Conditions
-A.lignment
Three-Arm Governor ponents are to be checked:
l
l
l
The following
com-
@Linkages
l Pins
l Ball Bearings and Guides
l Cylinder Travel
l Tip-over Assembly
l Hydraulic Relays
l Pressure Governor
0 Sensing Lines
Turbine/Generator
Supervisory
l
l
l
l
Bearings
Turbine/Generator
Instrumentation
l
l
l
l
l
Babbitt Condition
Journal Condition
Ball Contact
Ball Pinch
Ball Torque
Oil Feed and Drain Holes
Bore Diameters
Journal Diameters
Deflector Diameters
Insulation Resistance
Thermocouples
checks are to
l
l
l
l
l
l
l
l
l
l
l
l
l
l
Hydrogen
Seals
l
l
l
l
l
l
Hydrogen
Inspections
l
l
l
l
l
l
l
l
l
Enlargement
Exhauster.
Hydrogen
Drain
Bearing
Alarm.
vu
Seal Regulator
Level
High
-Open,
Inspection of the HP seals will be on an asrequired basis as judged by HP usage and seal oil
flows, but will be thoroughly inspected during major
outages every six years.
l
Float Trap.
-Open,
l
l
Booster or Eductor
Turning Gear
Main Shaft
Emergency
Auxiliary
Seal Regulator.
-Diaphragm-Operated
Regulator Valve
Inspected
-Filter Housing Cleaned
- Kelief Valves Inspected (Filter)
- Flowmeter Cleaned
-Calibrate
Filter Pressure Gauges
-Calibrate
Differential Pressure Switches
-Calibrate
Differential Pressure Gauges
-Calibrate Seal Oil Pressure Gauges
Exciter
Inspections
Rotating
Exciter
Electrical.
-Commutator
Surface
-High Mica
-Brush Surface
-Brush Clearance in Holder
-Holder
Clearance to Communtator
-Brush Spacing
-Pigtail Condition
-Armature Winding Condition
-Field Winding Condition
-Polarization
Index - Field and Armature
-Field Windings, Copper Resistance
- Buswork Connections
-Resistance Temperature Detector (RTD)
Checks
Rotating
Exciter
Mechanical.
-Bearing
-Deflectors
-Insulated
Coupling
-Air Gap Clearances
-Alignment
to Generator Field
\
-Filters
-Cleanliness
0 Static Exciter
Inspections.
-Cleanliness
-Proper Ventilation Provided
-Exposed Connections Tight
-Rectifier Short/Open Checks
-Other
Inspections Based on Operational
Problems
Borescope
Generator
Mechanical
Mechanical
General.
Inspections
Rotor.
-Bearings, Journals
-Fan Blades and Fan Ring
-Seal and Deflector Surfaces
-Rotor Body Surface
-Retaining
Ring Surface
-Wedges
-Collector
Rings
-Balance Weights
- Body Plugs
-Coupling
Inspections
-Bearings
-H2 Seals
-Oil Deflectors
-Fan Discharge Baffle
-Fan Blades
-Fan Nozzle Ring
-Fan Nozzle Segments
-Inner
and Outer End Shields
-Hydrogen
Coolers
Inspection
Inspection
Mechanical
Inspection
Stator.
-Internal
Winding Hardware
-Terminal
Box Hardware
-High Voltage Bushings
-Bushing
Terminals
-Current
Transformer Assembh
-Core Iron
-Outside Space Blocks
-Inside
Space Blocks
-RTD and TC Hardware
l
Winding
Inspections
>lechanical-hydraulic
units is to be tested:
l
l
-Armature
Bars - Slot Portion
-End Windings Insulation
-End Windings Blocking and Support
-Connection
Rings
-Lower Leads
-Slot Wedges
-Filler Strips
-RTD s
-Field Lead Wedge Insulation
-Field End Winding
l
Electrical
l
l
Electrical
Testing
Field Winding.
-Insulation
Resistance and Polarization Index
-Winding
Copper Resistance
-AC Impedance
Polarization
-Insulation
Resistance and Polarization Index
-Winding
Copper Resistance
-DC Leakage
-DC High Potential Test (Optional AC Hipot)
- RTD Resistance and Insulation Resistance
l
The following
equipment
Index
l
l
l
l
PLANNING FOR
MAINTAINABILITY
.4 systematic and structured maintenance program should result in the most efficient utilization
of time and resources during a scheduled maintenance outage. To successfully achieve maximum
turbine-generator
availability, planning for future
maintenance outages should begin immediately
upon completion of the last major outage. A comprehensive outage report is an essential document and
should be the basis for this planning. The report
should describe the condition of parts and systems
as found at the beginning of the outage, the work
accomplished during the outage (parts replaced or
repaired), and the conditions existingwhen the unit
was returned to service (clearances, rotor runouts,
etc.), and should contain a good record of observations about conditions that were less than desirable
but did not require immediate attention.
4 postoutage meeting should be held soon after
completion of any major maintenance outage. This
meeting should result in the development of an
action plan to cover the period up to the next
planned outage. The plan should include any
minor maintenance work for auxiliary equipment
as well as for the main turbine-generator unit. The
postoutage meeting should include a critical review
of unexpected and nonproductive delays experienced during the outage. The objective of this
review should be to improve scheduling of labor,
develop better tooling and procedures, determine
requirements for advanced ordering of parts, and
make station modifications that would be costeffective in eliminating similar future delays. Additional followup postoutage meetings should be held
to ensure that the long-lead-time maintenance
activities (securing of special parts, tools, etc.) are on
schedule, and to add new requirements to the
workplan.
About 18 months prior to the next planned major
maintenance outage, another formal advance maintenance planning meeting should be held to review
the workplan status and to review any recent
applicable industry experience or manufacturer
recommendations that could affect the maintenance
plan. A GE representative should be invited to this
meeting to review applicable industry-wide experience, as well as the history of the specific unit under
consideration. The l%month lead time for this
meeting usually is sufficient for obtaining funding
authorization
and ordering and receiving parts
required for the outage.
System
com-
Filter Delta P
Outlet Sight Oil Discharge
l Oil Tank Discharge Pipe
0 Inlet Pressure
l Heavy Phase Outlet Water Flow
l Oil Heating Operation
l Brake Release
l Casing Drain
0 Inlet Stop Valve
0 Centrifuge Cleanliness
0 Seals
l Filter Replacement
0 Inlet Strainer
l Flow Rate
0 Inlet Pump Clearances
l Gage Calibrations
l
l
11
SUMMARY
Maintainability
of industrial turbine-generator
units is a significant factor in the overall plant
economics. Recent dramatic increases in fuel and
capital investment costs and governmental regulation simply place a higher value on maintainability.
In response, GE is prepared to work with owners
and operators to optimize their maintenance
outages. Recommendations given in this paper
provide <guidelines for such maintenance planning.
12
I GER-3633
I
~GER-3636
I
1GER-3642
/
I
/ GER-3643
GER-3644
GER-3645
GER-3646
GER-3647
GER-3648
GER-3649
GER-3650
GER-365 1
Turbine
Technology
Reference
3ER-3424
Aircraft-Derivative
Gas Turbine
Maintenance Practices
SER-3425 GE LM5000 Aircraft-Derivative
Gas
Turbine Systems
SER-3430 Cogeneration Application Considerations
SER-3434 Gas Turbine Design Philosophy
ZER-3456
Cogeneration Financial Incentives
GER-3478 Reducing Solid Particle Erosion Damage
in Large Steam Turbines
GER-3507 Technical Challenges in Replacing Large
Generators for Utility Power Plants: An
Update
GER-3541 SPEEDTRONIC Mark IV Control System
GER-3551 Development of the GE Quiet Combustor
and Other Design Changes to Benefit
Air Quality
GER-3558
New Developments in Steam Turbines
for Cogeneration Systems
>ER-3567
Gas Turbine Performance Characteristics
>ER-3568
Dry Low NOx Combustion for GE
Heavy-Duty Gas Turbines
SER-3569 Advanced Gas Turbine Materials and
Coatings
GER-3570 Gas Turbine Standardization for Better Value
GER-3571 Performance and Reliability Improvements for Heavy-Duty Gas Turbines
GER-3572 GE Aeroderivative Gas Turbine
Performance
GER-3573 TEPCO 2OOOMW Combined-Cycle
Power Plant: Design, Construction and
Operation
GER-3574
Combined-Cycle Product Line and
Performance
GER-3575
Legislation and Regulations Affecting
Power Generation Systems
GER-3576
Steam Turbine Digital Control and
Monitoring (DCM) Systems
GER-3577 An Update on Steam Turbine Redesigns
for Efficiency and Availability
GER-3578
Generators for Small and Mid-Size Fossil
Fuel Plants
GER-3579
GER-3580
GER-3581
GER-3582
GER-3583
GER-3584
GER-3590
GER-3614
GER-3615
GER-3616
(
GER-3617
GER-3618
GER-3619
GER-3620
GER-3621
GER-3622
GER-3623
!
GER-3624
GER-3631
GER-3632
Library
Improved Generators for Gas and Small
Steam Turbine Drives
Generator Parameters and
Characteristics
Generator Excitation Systems the Right Product for Each Application
Steam Turbines for Combined-Cycle
Power Systems
Power Plant Upgrading: An Increasingly
Attractive Alternative
Combined Cycle Economics
Continuously-Coupled
40-Inch Titanium
Last-Stage Bucket Development
Steam Turbines for Industrial and
Cogeneration Applications
Steam Turbine Controls and Their
Integration into Power Plants
Extending the Useful Life of Industrial
Steam Turbines
Recent Advances in Mechanical Drive
Turbine Technology
Recent Advances in Centrifugal
Compressors
Generator Inspection and Maintenance
Gas Turbine Operating and
Maintenance Considerations
Steam Turbine-Generator Maintainability
A Means to Improve Unit Availability
MS7001F Gas Turbine Design Evolution
and Verification
Positive Pressure Variable Clearance
Packing
X Technical Assessment of TurbineGenerator Upgrading
Steam Turbine Controls and Their
Integration Into Power Plants (Magazine
Reprint)
Fist-Stage Bucket Coatings - Description,
Life and Refurbishment
publications.
GE Power Generation
GE Power Generation Marketing Communications
One River Road (2-IOlA)
Schenectady, NY 12345USA