Design Report 1
Design Report 1
Design Report 1
No
Title
Pages
.
1.
Executive Summary
2.
Chapter 1 : introduction
3-12
3.
13-18
4.
19-32
5.
References
33
The project is mainly focused on the background study of 2-ethylhexanol which are general
view, properties of raw materials as well as product, market survey and process to manufacture 2ethylhexanol. Basically, 2-ethylhexanol is a branched, eight-chiral alcohol. This substance exists as
colourless liquid with strong odour at 15 0C and 1 atm. The main industrial application of 2ethylhexanol includes as the feedstock to produce low-volatility esters which then used as plasticizers.
Other applications of 2-ethylhexanol is low-volatility solvents for waxes, animal fats, vegetable oils,
disinfectants and insecticidal sprays. 2-ethylhexanol is widely used as feedstock for many chemical
substances such as 2-ethyhexyl esters of trialkyl phosphites, 2-ethylhexyl sulphate and herbicides. In
industry, 2-ethylhexanol is produced commercially by Oxo process from propylene and synthesis
gases. The market demand for alcohol plastizicers is influenced by the global current economic
situation. This is due to the fact that plasticizer alcohol is associated with a pattern of ups and downs
in the world economy. There are three processes to produce 2-ethylhexanol which are acetaldehyde
route, Oxo process and Aldox process. The selected process for this project is Oxo process. The
justification for the Oxo process to be selected is based on general comparison between the three
processes, economic feasibility and other considerations such as quality of product, efficiency of the
conversion and recovery of process.
CHAPTER 1
INTRODUCTION
2.2 PROPERTIES
2..2.1 Acetaldehyde Route
n-butyraldehyde (butanal)
Physical
Chemical
Insoluble in water.
Heat of combustion :
353.8105 J/kg.
iso-butyraldehyde
Physical
Chemical
Melting point : 65 C
An extremely unpleasent
smell.
Boiling point : 63 C
Flash point : 33 C
Density : 0.79 g/mL at 25 C
2-Ethyl hexanal
Physical
Chemical
Clear liquid.
Mild odor.
Boiling point : 55 C at
13.5 mm Hg
Float on water.
Insoluble in water.
Spontaneously flammable in
air.
Crotonaldehyde
Physical
Chemical
Suffocating odor.
As chemical intermediate in
industry.
Propylene
Physical
Chemical
Colourless gas/liquid.
Good smell.
propane
Physical
Chemical
Colourless gas.
Easily leak.
iso-butanol
Physical
Chemical
Nice smelling.
Flash point : 26 - 29 C
n-butanol
Physical
Chemical
Colourless liquid
Soluble in water.
Flash point : 26 29 C
Moisture sensitive
sodium butanoate
Physical
Chemical
White crystalline.
An unpleasent smell.
Soluble in water.
Hydroformylation
Oxo reactor
The first step in the Oxo process is hydroformylation in which the main product is nbutyraldehyde. The Oxo reactor operates at 130 0C and 350 bars and the reactor residence time is 1-2
hours. The reactor is fed with synthesis gas which is carbon monoxide and hydrogen (CO/H 2 mixture)
and propylene in the molar ratio of 2:1. Cobalt carbonyl in the solution (0.1-1.0 wt% cobalt
concentration) is used as catalyst. A little amount of methane (0.4%) in the synthesis gas acts as an
inert in the reactor. Hydrogen sulfide and triethylamine are the examples of impurities that should be
excluded from entering the reactor to prevent reaction with the active cobalt complex which can form
catalytically inactive complexes. During the start-up phase, oxygen also should be excluded from the
system as the active catalyst concentration is being established.
The feed may consists with polymer grade (99+%) pure propylene. Propylene feed should be
vaporized first and fed into the reactor in a gas phase. Propylene losses in the blowdown vent stream
can be minimized if propylene conversions greater than 95% per pass is designed. The main products
produces from the Oxo reactor are n- and iso butyraldehyde in the mole ratio of 4:1. Also, within the
reactor, 6% of n-butyrablahyle product is reduced to n-butanol, 4% of isobytyraldehyld product is
reduced to iso-butanol and molecular weight compounds (heavy ends) to the extent of 1% by weight
of the butyraldehyde/ butanol mixture is yielded by other reactions at the reactor exit.
Separator
Next, following the Oxo reactor, the reaction is continued in the separator. Here, the oxo-raw
product is separated from the catalyst solution and will be recycled back to the Oxo reactor.
Stripper
Meanwhile in the stripper, fresh synthesis gas is introduced to remove the unconverted
propylene from the Oxo-product. The synthesis gas is then recycled to the Oxo reactor.
10
Distillation Column 1
The first distillation column is focuses on the separation of alcohol and aldehyde components.
The stripper produces Oxo-product and passes them to distillation column where mixed
butyraldehyde is produced as top product and alcohols as the bottom product.
Distillation Column 2
After the first distillation column passed on butyraldehydes into the second distillation
column, the two butyraldehydes now are separated into iso-butyraldehyde which is the top stream that
contains 1.3% moles of n-butyraldehyde and n-butyraldehyde, the bottom stream containing 1.2%
mole of isobutyraldehyde.
ii.
Aldolization
Aldolization reactor
Next, the n-butyraldehyde stream will passes on into Aldolization reactor where Aldol
condensation occurs. In the reactor, n-butyraldehyde reacts vigorously to produce 2-ethylhexanal.
Also, 2% w/w aqueous sodium hydroxide, NaOH is introduced into the reactor as it is the standard
industrial catalyst. The reactor condition includes temperature of 80-130 0C and pressure 3-10 atm
while the conversion efficiency that can be achieved is 90%. Besides, local overheating must not
happening in the reaction mixture because it can develop secondary reaction hence yields may be
decreased and it is necessary for the two phases in the system to be mixed thoroughly. The ideal
equipment to be used as Aldolization reactor may be a packed column, a stirring vessel or a mixing
pump.
Separator
The Aldolization reactor passes on the products which are 2-ethylhexanal and n-butyraldehyde
into a separator. 2-Ethyhexanal is separated and then passed on to the hydrogenation unit.
iii.
Hydrogenation
Hydrogenerator
11
2.3.2
H3C-CH2-CH2-CHO + H3C-CH-CHO
(n-butyraldehyde)
(iso-butyraldehyde)
(Oxo-crude)
CH3-CH2-CH2-CH=C-CHO + H2O
(3-10) atm
CH2-H3C
(n-butyraldehyde)
(2-Ethyl Hexanal)
CH3-CH2-CH2-CH2-CH-CH2OH
CH2-H3C
CH2-H3C
(2-Ethyl Hexanal)
(2-Ethyl Hexanol)
CHAPTER 2
12
Asia (including Japan), Europe and North America were the largest market for the plasticizer alcohol
(2-ethylhexanol and n-butanol) which provides nearly 95% of world demand in 2014. Asia is also one
of the largest consume in the 2-ethylhexanol and n- butanol which was 55% of global consumption; In
Asia, China produced 36% of total world consumption. This shows that China was one of the largest
Asian countries to produce 2-ethylhexanol and n-butanol. Western Europe hold about 20% of the
world demand, and North America about 17% of global consumption.
Plasticizers are the largest consumption market for 2-ethylhexanol and n-butanol which was about
48% of world consumption in 2014 based on studies in Chemical Economics Handbook (2015), the
demand will grow slightly less than the demand for alcohol plasticizer in an acrylate / methacrylate
13
and acetate esters. Plasticizer area manufacturers, such as the United States and Western Europe,
experienced a moderate growth rate, while Japan was expected to see a slight decline for plasticizers.
Plasticizer market in China was expected to grow steadily during 2014-2019, although less than other
market segments plasticizer alcohol. The world consumption of alcohol plasticizer for plasticizers was
expected to grow at an average annual rate of 3.6% during 2014-2019, mainly as a result of stronger
growth in China, India, and other Asia
3.2 Production Data (Supply)
Based on statistical data in 2010, the annual production capacity of 2-ethylhexanol was 3,330 kmt/ yr
and the rate of consumption of the year reached 2,869 kmt / yr. The impact on operating rates were
too high .According to the operating rate in 2010 was recorded at 86.2%. According to analysis of
LIU Yuan and XUE Hui-feng, there were three continents that had large production capacity, namely
in Asia, Western Europe and North America, which produced at 51%, 17% and 12% in the world
market. According to the study, Asia was the most important in the use of the product 2-ethylhexanol,
which took about 65% of total world consumption. For Western Europe and North America, each of
which takes about 11%. It explained that the use and production of 2-ethylhexanol more focused on
Asia. Nowadays, the usage and production in North America and Western Europe are static. See detail
in table 1.0 and 1.1.
No
1
2
3
4
5
Company
SINOPEC
6
7
8
9
10
TOTAL
Oxea Group
LG Group
BASF
Eastman Chemical
Company
Formosa Plastics
Group
Kedzierzyn Nitrogen
Work
Mitsubishi Company
Group
Gazprom
Perstorp
All others
3330
Capacity
360
300
265
263
252
190
170
146
131
125
1128
14
.In 2010, n-butanol produced in China was 516kmt, net imports are 620kmt, apparent consumption
was 1,139kmt and the subsistence level was 45%. In 2000 ~ 2010 annual average growth rate of the
product is 7.09% and the use clearly is 11.93%. See details in Figure 2-3.
In 2010, the production of 2-ethylhexanol in China was 440kmt, net imports were of 460kmt,
apparent consumption was 900kmt and self-sufficiency level of 49% [6]. During 2000 to 2010, the
annual average growth rate of the product was 5.61% and the use clearly was 6.69%. See details in
Figure 2.2.
Nowadays, the mainstream technology for producing OXO in China is carbonyl synthesis method.
Till the end of 2010, there were totally 8 manufactures in China that applied this technology with a
total production capacity of 550,000 tons of n-butanol per year and 875,000 tons of 2-ethylhexanol
per year. There were totally 7 manufactures in China that used this technology in same period with a
production capacity of 215,000 tons of n-butanol per year. See details in Table 3.1.
NO
Manufactures
n-butanol
2-ethylhexanol
Total
I
1
2
3
OXO
Sinopec Qilu Co.
Sinopec Yazi-BASF
Sinopec Yanshan
Co.
CNPC Jilin
ChemicalCo
CNPC Daqing Co.
Shandong Lihuayi
Group
Tianjin Soda Plant
Shandong Jianlan
biological
fermentation
process
Total
550
50
100
20
875
255
110
50
1425
305
210
70
170
70
240
25
85
55
140
80
225
80
20
215
145
50
0
225
70
215
765
875
1640
4
5
6
7
8
II
III
In the total production capacity of n-butyl alcohol in China, Sinopec, PetroChina and local companies
respectively in 30.9%, 35.5% and 33.6%. it was indicating a close pattern.Their production capacity
2-ethylhexanol each take up 47.4%, 14.3% and 38.3%. Sinopec and its main and local enterprises are
predominant. This show in table 3.2
Variable
Base condition
Construction investment
Extension of construction
period
Operating food
Price of raw material
Product price
Rate of change
10%
-10%
1 year
1 year
-10%
10%
-10%
10%
-10%
Table 4.1 Sensitivity Analytical Statement
16.04
18.11
10.60
26.78
28.85
7.30
Based on finance research by Liu Yuan, and Xue Hui-Feng in 2012, the production load decreases
10% and the construction investment, material price and product price respectively fall 10%.
Sensitivity analysis is made for the change on internal rate of return. The results show in Table 4.1
Propane price
IRR
n-butanol
2-ethylhexanol
13%
6150
6580
4000
18%
6550
7010
23%
7000
7490
13%
6750
7230
5000
18%
7200
7720
23%
7660
8200
13%
7370
7890
6000
18%
7860
8410
23%
8290
8870
13%
8000
8560
7000
18%
8520
9110
23%
8970
9600
13%
8630
9240
8000
18%
9240
9880
23%
9690
10370
13%
9350
10010
9000
18%
9960
10060
23%
10420
11150
Table 4.2 : The Impact of Material and Product Price Variation on Benefit
17
Table 4.2 shown, when the price of propylene is certain, the variation of OXO price would causes
benefit change; the multiple slant lines show: when both the prices of propylene and OXO change, the
benefit would change. For instance: if the price of propylene was 7,000 Yuan/ton, the price of nbutanol was higher than 8,000 Yuan/ton and the corresponding price of 2-ethylhexanol was higher
than 8,560 Yuan/ton, the internal rate of return would be higher than 13%; if the price of propylene
doesnt change, the price of n-butanol was higher than 8,520 Yuan/ton and the corresponding price of
2-ethylhexanol was higher than 9,110 Yuan/ton, the internal rate of return will be higher than 18%; if
the price of propylene was 6,000 Yuan/ton, the price of n-butyl alcohol is 8,290 Yuan/ton and the
corresponding price of 2-ethylhexyl alcohol was 8,870 Yuan/ton, the internal rate of return would be
higher than 23%.
4.0 CHAPTER 3 :
PROCESS SELECTION
18
CH3-CHO
Acetaldehyde
Dehydrogenation
CH3-CH2-OH
CH3-CHO
2 CH3-CHO
CH3-CH-(OH)-CH2-CHO
iso-butyraldehyde
CH3-CH-(OH)-CH2-CHO
CH3-CH=CH-CHO +H2O
Crotonaldehyde
CH3-CH=CH-CHO +H2
CH3-CH2-CH2-CHO
n-butyraldehyde
2CH3-CH2-CH2-CHO
CH3-CH2-CH2-CH=C-CHO + H2O
CH3-CH2-CH2-CH2- CH=C-CHO +2 H2
CH2=CH2
2-Ethyl hexanal
CH2=CH2
CH3-CH2-CH2-CH2 CH-CH2OH +
2-Ethyl hexanol
CH2=CH2
2. Oxo route:
20
The n-butyraldehyde reacrs swiftly to create 2-ethylhexanal. The standard industrial catalyst
which is 2% w/w aqueous NaOH is used that helps the conversion efficiency to 90%. The operating
condition for temperature is between 80c - 1300c and the pressure is between 303.975 kPa - 1013.25
kPa. Overheating of the reaction mixture must be avoided due may cause secondary reaction, hence,
21
decreasing the yields. It is necessary for thorough mixing of the 2-phases in the system. The product
from aldolization reactor passes on to separator where 2-Ethyhexanol is separated and then sent to a
hydrogenation unit. In hydrogenator, by the presence of Raney Nickel, 99% conversion of 2Ethylhexanal to 2-Ethylhexanol can be obtained with selectivity being greater than 99% and 99.8% of
2-Ethylhexanol is recovered at purity of 99% by weight.
.
There are three steps in the oxo process which is important for the production of aldehydes
from alkenes. A formyl group (CHO) and a hydrogen atom to a carbon-carbon double bond is the
addition of this chemical reaction.Oxo synthesis or oxo process is an important homogeneously
catalyzed industrial process for the production of aldehydes from alkenes. The following is reaction
scenario of oxo synthesis.
The reaction includes :
a) Hydroformylation
b) Aldolization
c) Hydogenation
Process route:
a) Hydroformylation
H3C
130C, 100kPa
2H3C-CH=CH2+2CO+2H2
H3C-CH2-CH2-CHO+H3C-CH-CHO
The above is reaction of hydroformylation, which takes place at 130C, 100kpa. The molar ratio of the
feed reactor which is the propylene nad synthesis gas is 2:1.Cobalt Carbonyl is used as the catalyst in
the solution with the percentage of 0.1-1.0 wt% cobalt concentration.
b) Aldolization
2% NaOH and 80C-130C
2H3C-CH2-CH2-CHO
CH3-CH2-CH2-CH=C-CHO +H2O
303.975 kPa - 1013.25 kPa
CH2-H3C
The above Aldolization reaction takes place at80C-1300C and pressures 303.975 kPa - 1013.25 kPa.
22
c) Hydrogenation
CH3-CH2-CH2-CH=C-CHO +2H2
CH2-H3C
CH3-CH2-CH2-CH2-CH-CH2OH
Nickel
CH2-H3C
3.)Aldox process
23
24
Process route
Aldox process combines the oxo reaction with aldol condensation
CH3
HCo(CO)4
CH3CH2=CH2 + H2 + CO
CH3CH2CH2CHO + CH3CHCHO
Catalyst
2CH3CH2CH2CHO
H2
CH3CH2CH2CH2CHCHO
CH3CH2CH2CH2CHCH2CHCH2OH
CH2CH3
CH2CH3
Type of process
Main Materials
Propylene,
Ethylene,
carbon
monoxide,
acetaldehyde,
Caustic
Aldox met
soda
25
Propylene,
By products
Carbonyl
aldehydes
Cobalt acetate
synthesis
(NaOH)
Iso-butanol and C4 alcohols - aldehydes
Caustic So
Iso-butano
mixture
compoun
catalyst
insoluble
Normal butylaldehyde and isobutylaldehyde
hydride
Normal bu
isobutylaldehyde
20684 34473
3000- 20000
3447 344
(kPa)
Reaction
In range of 70-150
Around 2
temperature (C)
Percentage
of
99.8
99.8
95
Solvent
Reaction
Normal
pressure
butylaldehyde
and
conversion (%)
Technical
flow, Long flow and many equipments
Longer
number
of
equipments
Operation
temperature
medium
flow
and
higher
equipments
Low
Shorter flo
High
and
pressure
26
Figure 2.0 :
various 2routes
Yields from
ethylhexanol
Figure 2.1 :
production
Isooctanol
Economic Data
Figure
of higher
economic data
2.2 : Production
alcohols
The
various
routes
ethyl
hexanol
summarized
in
figure 2.0. The synthesis of acetaldehyde from ethyl alcohol or acetylene is also included. 70 kg nbutanol per metric ton of 2 ethyl hexanol or acetylene is also included. 70 kg n-butanol per metric ton
of 2 ethyl hexanol results as byproduct from acetaldehyde route, while with the oxo route, the
corresponding values are 130 kg n-and 350 kg iso-butanol. The yield of 85.5 kg of 2 ethylhexanol
from 100kg n-butyraldehyde shown for the oxo route in figure 2.0 is exceeded in modern oxo plants.
The economic superiority of the oxo route compared to those based on ethylene and the low cost of nbutyraldehyde from large modern oxo plants. In the future, acetaldehyde route will only be attractive
where inexpensive ethyl alcohol or inexpensive acetylene is available.
Quality of product
27
High quality product with percentage of purity is important. This is because the additives may
contain health hazard, Hence, high percentage of purity product would avoid these hazard. It is
important to use high quality, high purity supplements from professional supplement producers.
High efficiency conversion will result in saving cost and produce good quality products, these
criteria is important for building a plant due to the production
The investment cost of the process in economical aspect and consumption of energy
Investment cost must be low to avoid fluctuation of profit, the consumption energy must be low
to save cost.
Must be stable and short route of process to avoid high maintenance and using lots of manpower.
Recovery of the process
The catalyst and other materials used has a recovery system so that the recovered material can be
used again in following process to avoid increasing in cost.
Subject
quality
Oxo route
of
High
quality
product
Acetaldehyde route
Aldox route
products
Efficiency
of
conversion
99.8% purity
Same as oxo route but
purity
One-step reaction makes low
longer reaction
propylene conversion.
conversion
Due to medium reaction
Because
of
aspect, cost of
pressure
and
investment
reaction temperature,
reaction temperature,
because of complicated
operation is stable ,
management is needed
management needed is
and management is
modified
needed
hydride is expensive.
Shorter
but
stable
flexibility,
process
and
energy
higher
reaction
high
reaction
Cobalt
tetracarbonyl
activity is stable. No
need for management.
Operation
stable
and
high
plant
operation.
flow
but
only
has
no
alcohols
are
the
intermediate
are
isolated.
occurs
compounds.
Mixed
due
to
aldehyde
not
being
aldolization
presence
of
oxo product.
Recovery
the catalyst
of
to promote controlled aldolization which is a serious disadvantages when mixed aldolization with the
branched aldehyde, problem associated with recycling of the additives hence preventing wider use of
aldox process.
30
REFERENCES
1. 2-Ethylhexanol.
(2013).
Royal
Society
of
Chemistry.
Retrieved
from
http://www.chemspider.com/Chemical-Structure.7434.html
2. Technical Leaflet 2-Ethylhexanol. (1999) BASF Petronas Chemicals. Retrieved from
http://www.solvents.basf.com/portal/load/fid245412/Technical%20Spec%20%202%20Ethylhexanol_BPC.pdf
3. 2-Ethylhexanol (2-EH) Uses and Market Data. (2009) ICB Chemical Profile.
Retrieved
from
http://www.icis.com/resources/news/2007/11/05/9075782/2-
ethylhexanol-2-eh-uses-and-market-data/
4. ..MacKetta, J. J. (1984). Encyclopedia of chemical processing and design (Vol. 20).
New York u.a.: Dekker. pp (383 , 384)
5. Chauvel, L.Gilles Petrochemical Processes (Vol. 2). Paris u.a france pp (98, 99)
6. MacKetta, J. J. (1978). Encyclopedia of chemical processing and design (Vol. 5). New
York u.a.: Dekker. p.p (373,376,389)
7. .Mitsubishi Chemical Corporation | Oxo Alcohols and Acrylates Dept. (n.d.).
Retrieved from kagaku.co.jp/english/products/business/chemical/oxo/index.html
8. Olah, G. A., & Molnar, A. (1995). Hydrocarbon chemistry. New York: Wiley. pp
(377-378)
9. Borner, A., & Franke, R. (2016). Hydroformylation fundamentals, processes, and
applications in organic synthesis. Weinheim, Germany: Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH &
KGaA.
31