Clinical Study: Vacuum Assisted Closure Therapy Versus Standard Wound Therapy For Open Musculoskeletal Injuries
Clinical Study: Vacuum Assisted Closure Therapy Versus Standard Wound Therapy For Open Musculoskeletal Injuries
Clinical Study: Vacuum Assisted Closure Therapy Versus Standard Wound Therapy For Open Musculoskeletal Injuries
Advances in Orthopedics
Volume 2013, Article ID 245940, 8 pages
http://dx.doi.org/10.1155/2013/245940
Clinical Study
Vacuum Assisted Closure Therapy versus Standard Wound
Therapy for Open Musculoskeletal Injuries
Copyright 2013 Kushagra Sinha et al. This is an open access article distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution License,
which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
Background. This study was performed to evaluate the results of vacuum assisted wound therapy in patients with open muscu-
loskeletal injuries. Study Design and Setting. Prospective, randomized, and interventional at tertiary care hospital, from 2011 to
2012. Materials and Methods. 30 patients of open musculoskeletal injuries underwent randomized trial of vacuum assisted closure
therapy versus standard wound therapy around the upper limb and lower limb. Mean patient age was 39 18 years (range, 18 to 76
years). Necrotic tissues were debrided before applying VAC therapy. Dressings were changed every 3 or 4 days. For standard wound
therapy, debridement followed by daily dressings was done. Data Management and Statistical Analysis. The results obtained were
subjected to statistical analysis. Results. The size of soft tissue defects reduced more than 5 mm to 25 mm after VAC (mean decrease of
26.66%), whereas in standard wound therapy, reduction in wound size was less than 5 mm. A free flap was needed to cover exposed
bone and tendon in one case in standard wound therapy group. No major complication occurred that was directly attributable to
treatment. Conclusion. Vacuum assisted wound therapy was found to facilitate the rapid formation of healthy granulation tissue on
open wounds in the upper limb and lower limb, thus to shorten healing time and minimize secondary soft tissue defect coverage
procedures.
Saline-wet-to-moist
Measurements (mm) VAC ( = 15)
( = 15)
14.9 4 (26.66%) 14 (93.33%)
59.9 1 (6.66%) 0
1014.9 4 (26.66%) 1 (6.66%)
1519.9 3 (20%) 0
2024.9 1 (6.66%) 0
>25 2 (13.33%) 0
Chi Square = 14.4, d.f = 5, = 0.013.
Table 2: Mean wound size difference between VAC and saline wet to moist on day 8.
Table 4: Comparison of histological parameters from day 0 to day 8 by Wilcoxon signed ranks test.
Bacterial Growth. There was significant decrease in the influenced by locally acting growth factors that affect various
bacterial growth in the VAC group as compared to saline-wet- processes including proliferation, angiogenesis, chemotaxis
to-moist group, as shown in Table 3. and migration, gene expression, proteinases, and protein
On histological comparison too, there was a statistical production [8, 1114]. Disruption of any of these factors may
difference between the VAC group and saline-wet-to-moist adversely affect the healing process, resulting in a chronic or
group, value being less than 0.05 by using Wilcoxon signed nonhealing wound.
rank test between the findings from day zero to day eighth as Blood flow increases and bacterial colonization of wound
shown in Table 4. tissues decreases following the application of subatmospheric
pressure to wounds [7]. Any increase in circulation and
Case No. 1. In an 18-year-male old a case of open grade oxygenation to compromised or damaged tissue enhances the
IIIb fracture both bone right forearm (middle 3rd), wound resistance to infection [15]. Successful, spontaneous healing
was present over anterior aspect of forearm. After thorough and healing following surgical intervention are correlated
debridement and fracture fixation VAC was applied (see with tissue bacterial counts of less than 105 organisms per
Figure 5). gram of tissue [16]. Higher levels uniformly interfere in
wound healing. Increase in local tissue oxygen levels reduce
Case No. 2. In a 57-year-male old sustained injury open grade or eliminate the growth of anaerobic organisms, which have
IIIa olecranon, debridement was done, and VAC was applied been correlated to decreased healing rates [17, 18]. Addition-
(see Figure 6). ally, the increased flow should make greater amounts of oxy-
gen available to neutrophils for the oxidative bursts that kill
4. Discussion bacteria [19].
Healing is an intricate, interdependent process that involves Our study showed that in VAC group after day 4, there
complex interactions between cells, the cellular microenvi- were 20% of patients who had no bacterial growth, and on
ronment, biochemical mediators, and extracellular matrix day 8 there were 60% of patients who had no bacterial growth,
molecules that usually results in a functional restoration of whereas in saline-wet-to-moist patients only 20% of patients
the injured tissue [8, 9]. The goals of wound healing are had no bacterial growth on the 8th day. There have been
to minimize blood loss, replace any defect with new tissue similar studies by Morykwas and Argenta [7], Banwell et al.
(granulation tissue followed by scar tissue), and restore an [20], and Morykwas et al. [21] which showed clearance of
intact epithelial barrier as rapidly as possible. bacteria from infected wounds using VAC therapy.
The rate of wound healing is limited by the available On the other hand, Weed et al. while quantifying bac-
vascular supply and the rate of formation of new capil- terial bioburden during negative pressure wound therapy
laries and matrix molecules [10]. These events are heavily concluded with serial quantitative cultures that there is no
Advances in Orthopedics 5
(a) (b)
(c) (d)
(e) (f)
(g)
Figure 5: (a) Day 0: wound size, 146 135 mm. (b) Day 0: photomicrograph number 1-H and E stained section (100x) shows: dense
neutrophilic exudates on the surface of wound. (c) Day 4: wound size, 130 120 mm. (d) Day 4: photomicrograph number 2-H and E stained
section (100x) shows: fibrinous exhudate on the surface and base of ulcer is formed by moderately inflamed granulation tissue. (e) Day 8:
wound size, 130 117 mm. (f) Day 8: photomicrograph number 3-H and E stained section (100x) shows: many newly formed blood vessels
and dense fibro collagenous tissue. (g) SSG uptake seen.
consistent bacterial clearance with the VAC therapy, and the the cells when negative pressure is applied [23]. This allows
bacterial growth remained in the range of 104 106 [22]. the VAC to move distensible soft tissue, similar to expanders,
Thomas first postulated that application of mechanical towards the centre of the wound, thereby decreasing the
stress would result in angiogenesis and tissue growth. Unlike actual size of the wound [24].
sutures or tension devices, the VAC can exert a uniform force Our study showed a decrease in size of 1 to 4.9 mm in
at each individual point on the edge of the wound drawing 26.66% of patients in VAC group whereas 93.33% in control
it toward the centre of the defect by mechanically stretching group from day 0 to day 8. A decrease in size of 10 to 19.9 mm
6 Advances in Orthopedics
(a) (b)
(c) (d)
(e) (f)
(g)
Figure 6: (a) Day 0: wound size, 146 61 mm. (b) Day 0: photomicrograph number 1-H and E stained section (100x) shows: thick neutrophillic
exhudate on the surface and skeletal muscle bundles. (c) Day 4: wound size, 141 51 mm. (d) Day 4: photomicrograph number 2-H and E
stained section (100x) shows: Inflammed granulation tissue with little exhudate on the surface. (e) Day 8: Wound size, 135 51 mm. (f) Day
8: photomicrograph number 3-H and E stained section (100x) shows: healthy granulation tissue without any exhudate. (g) Secondary closure
done.
was seen in 46.66% of patients of VAC group and only 6.66% widths of wound over time compared to standard wound
in control group. A decrease in size of more than 25 mm was dressings.
seen in 13.33% in VAC group. Our study showed that VAC increases the vascularity and
There have been similar studies by Joseph et al. [1], the increase in rate of granulation tissue formation compared
Morykwas and Argenta [7], and Morykwas et al. [21] to standard wound dressing. Histologically, VAC patients
which showed that VAC proved effective in shrinking the showed angiogenesis and healthy tissue growth as compared
Advances in Orthopedics 7
to the inflammation and fibrosis seen in standard wound required to obtain adequate coverage, the use of this device
dressing. Inflammation had increased in those treated with appears to decrease their need overall.
standard wound therapy and decreased in those patients
treated with VAC. Disclosure
The highly significant increase in the rate of granulation
tissue formation of subatmospheric pressure-treated wound Regarding your statistical software SPSS-version 19, Himala-
is postulated to be due to transmission of the uniformly yan Institute of Medical Sciences had purchased the software
applied force to the tissues on the periphery of the wound. for data analysis for all its ongoing projects. So, even our
These forces both recruit tissues through viscoelastic flow and clinical trial was analyzed with the same software.
promote granulation tissue formation. Currently, the Ilizarov
technique and soft tissue expanders both apply mechanical
stress to tissues to increase mitotic rates [25, 26]. Conflict of Interests
Standard wound dressings adhere to devitalized tissue There is no conflict of interests of any sort regarding the
and within four to six hours the gauze can be removed, software.
along with the tissue, as a form of mechanical debridement.
This method of wound care has been criticized for removing
viable tissue as well as nonviable tissue and being traumatic References
to granulation tissue and to new epithelial cells [27].
[1] E. Joseph, C. A. Hamori, S. Bergman, E. Roaf, N. F. Swann, and
There is very little literature available especially on com- G. W. Anastasi, A prospective randomized trial of vacuum-
pound injuries using VAC. Open musculoskeletal injuries assisted closure versus standard therapy of chronic nonhealing
have very high incidences of nonunion and infection [28]; wounds, Wounds, vol. 12, no. 3, pp. 6067, 2000.
they require urgent irrigation and debridement. As wounds [2] M. J. Yaremchuk, Concepts in soft tissue management, in
are frequently left open and require repeated debridement, Lower Extremity Salvage and Reconstruction. Orthopaedic and
resulting in large soft tissue defects, early coverage of exposed Plastic Surgical Management, M. J. Yaremchuk, A. R. Burgess,
bone, tendons, and neurovascular structures is crucial. This and R. J. Brumback, Eds., pp. 95106, Elsevier Science, New
is to decrease the risk of infection, nonunion, and further York, NY, USA, 1989.
tissue loss. We believe that VAC therapy can be effective to [3] J. A. Haller and R. E. Billingham, Studies of the origin of the
overcome all the aforementioned problems. vasculature in free skin grafts, Annals of Surgery, vol. 166, no. 6,
The daily rental charges for a VAC machine and consum- pp. 896901, 1967.
ables are significant. This has discouraged many from using [4] M. Geishauser, R. W. Staudenmaier, and E. Biemer, Donor-
the system. However, there have been some reports showing site morbidity of the segmental rectus abdominis muscle flap,
that the increased healing times and downgrading of required British Journal of Plastic Surgery, vol. 51, no. 8, pp. 603607, 1998.
operations correlate to decreased overall costs of care. The [5] M. B. Kelly and A. Searle, Improving the donor site cosmesis
dressing should also enable larger wounds to be treated in the of the latissimus dorsi flap, Annals of Plastic Surgery, vol. 41, no.
community with minimal nursing care impact. This would 6, pp. 629632, 1998.
free up hospital beds permitting faster healing of operative [6] M. C. Y. Heng, Topical hyperbaric therapy for problem skin
patients and preventing waiting list buildup [29]. wounds, Journal of Dermatologic Surgery and Oncology, vol. 19,
VAC therapy can be regarded as a method that combines no. 8, pp. 784793, 1993.
the benefit of both open and closed treatment and adheres [7] M. J. Morykwas and L. C. Argenta, Vacuum-assisted closure: a
to DeBakeys principles of being short, safe, and simple. It has new method for wound control and treatment: clinical experi-
been shown to work and be beneficial to wound healing. VAC ence, Annals of Plastic Surgery, vol. 38, no. 6, pp. 563577, 1997.
therapy is not the answer for all wounds; however, it can make [8] R. A. F. Clarke and P. M. Henson, Eds., The Molecular and
a significant difference in many cases. VAC is most useful in Cellular Biology of Wound Repair, Plenum Press, New York, NY,
USA, 1988.
difficult cavity or highly exudative wounds. VAC is a useful
tool in moving a wound to a point where more traditional [9] I. K. Cohen, R. F. Diegelmann, and W. J. Lindblad, Wound Heal-
dressings or more simple surgical reconstructive methods can ing: Biochemical and Clinical Aspects, WB Saunders, Philadel-
phia, Pa, USA, 1992.
be used. As such it is a well deserved, although at present
pragmatic addition to the wound healing armamentarium [10] T. K. Hunt, Vascular factors govern healing in chronic
wounds, in Clinical and Experimental Approach to Dermal and
and the reconstructive ladder [30].
Epidermal Repair: Normal and Chronic Wounds, A. Barbul, M.
D. Caldwell, W. H. Eaglstein et al., Eds., pp. 117, Wiley & Leiss,
5. Conclusion New York, NY, USA, 1991.
[11] G. F. Pierce, J. Vande Berg, R. Rudolph, J. Tarpley, and T. A.
Vacuum assisted closure therapy appears to be a viable Mustoe, Platelet-derived growth factor-BB and transforming
adjunct for the treatment of open musculoskeletal injuries. growth factor beta1 selectively modulate glycosaminoglycans,
Application of subatmospheric pressure after the initial collagen, and myofibroblasts in excisional wounds, American
debridement to the wounds results in an increase in local Journal of Pathology, vol. 138, no. 3, pp. 629646, 1991.
functional blood perfusion, an accelerated rate of granulation [12] M. Laiho and O. J. Keski, Growth factors in the regulation of
tissue formation, and decrease in tissue bacterial levels. pericellular proteolysis: a review, Cancer Research, vol. 49, no.
Although traditional soft tissue reconstruction may still be 10, pp. 25332553, 1989.
8 Advances in Orthopedics
[13] M. Laiho and O. J. Keski, Growth factors in the regulation of [29] W. Fleischmann, W. Strecker, M. Bombelli, and L. Kinzl, Vac-
pericellular proteolysis: a review, Cancer Research, vol. 49, no. uum sealing for treatment of soft tissue injury in open fractures,
10, pp. 25332553, 1989. Unfallchirurg, vol. 96, no. 9, pp. 488492, 1993.
[14] D. J. Whitby and M. W. J. Ferguson, Immunohistological stud- [30] S. M. Jones, P. E. Banwell, and P. G. Shakespeare, Advances in
ies of the extracellular matrix and soluble growth factors in fetal wound healing: topical negative pressure therapy, Postgraduate
and adult wound healing, in Fetal Wound Healing, N. S. Adzick Medical Journal, vol. 81, no. 956, pp. 353357, 2005.
and M. T. Longaker, Eds., pp. 161177, Elsevier Science, New
York, NY, USA, 1992.
[15] T. K. Hunt, The physiology of wound healing, Annals of Emer-
gency Medicine, vol. 17, no. 12, pp. 12651273, 1988.
[16] J. O. Kucan, M. C. Robson, and J. P. Heggers, Comparison
of silver sulfadiazine, povidone-iodine and physiologic saline
in the treatment of chronic pressure ulcers, Journal of the
American Geriatrics Society, vol. 29, no. 5, pp. 232235, 1981.
[17] W. O. Seiler, H. B. Stahelin, and W. Sonabend, Einflus aerobe
und anaerober keime auf den heilungsverlauf von dekubitalulz-
era, Schweizerische Medizinische Wochenschrift, vol. 109, pp.
15951599, 1979.
[18] D. C. Daltrey, B. Rhodes, and J. G. Chattwood, Investigation
into the microbial flora of healing and non-healing decubitus
ulcers, Journal of Clinical Pathology, vol. 34, no. 7, pp. 701705,
1981.
[19] T. J. Ryan, Microcirculation in psoriasis: blood vessels, lym-
phatics and tissue fluid, Pharmacology and Therapeutics, vol.
10, no. 1, pp. 2764, 1980.
[20] P. Banwell, S. Withey, and I. Holten, The use of negative pres-
sure to promote healing, British Journal of Plastic Surgery, vol.
51, no. 1, pp. 7982, 1998.
[21] M. J. Morykwas, L. C. Argenta, E. I. Shelton-Brown, and W.
McGuirt, Vacuum-assisted closure: a new method for wound
control and treatment: animal studies and basic foundation,
Annals of Plastic Surgery, vol. 38, no. 6, pp. 553562, 1997.
[22] T. Weed, C. Ratliff, D. B. Drake et al., Quantifying bacterial
bioburden during negative pressure wound therapy: does the
wound VAC enhance bacterial clearance? Annals of Plastic
Surgery, vol. 52, no. 3, pp. 276280, 2004.
[23] R. Thoma, Ueber die histomechanik des gefasssystems und die
pathogens der angioskeleroose, Virchows Archiv fur Pathologis-
che Anatomie und Physiologie und fur Klinische Medizin, vol.
204, no. 1, pp. 174, 1911.
[24] T. E. Philbeck, K. T. Whittington, M. H. Millsap, R. B. Briones,
D. G. Wight, and W. J. Schroeder, The clinical and cost effec-
tiveness of externally applied negative pressure wound therapy
in the treatment of wounds in home healthcare Medicare
patients, Ostomy/Wound Management, vol. 45, no. 11, pp. 41
50, 1999.
[25] G. A. Ilizarov, The tension-stress effect on the genesis and
growth of tissues. Part I. The influence of stability of fixation
and soft-tissue preservation, Clinical Orthopaedics and Related
Research, no. 238, pp. 249281, 1989.
[26] G. D. Hall, C. W. Van Way, F. T. K. Fei Tau Kung, and M.
Compton-Allen, Peripheral nerve elongation with tissue
expansion techniques, Journal of Trauma, vol. 34, no. 3, pp.
401405, 1993.
[27] O. M. Alvarez, P. M. Mertz, and W. H. Eaglstein, The effect of
occlusive dressings on collagen synthesis and re-epithelializa-
tion in superficial wounds, Journal of Surgical Research, vol. 35,
no. 2, pp. 142148, 1983.
[28] A. L. Akin Yoola, A. K. Ako-Nai, O. Dosumu, A. O. Aboderin,
and O. O. Kassim, Microbial isolates in early swabs of open
musculoskeletal injuries, The Nigerian Oostgraduate Medical
Journal, vol. 13, no. 3, pp. 176181, 2006.
MEDIATORS of
INFLAMMATION
BioMed
PPAR Research
Hindawi Publishing Corporation
Research International
Hindawi Publishing Corporation
http://www.hindawi.com Volume 2014 http://www.hindawi.com Volume 2014
Journal of
Obesity
Evidence-Based
Journal of Stem Cells Complementary and Journal of
Ophthalmology
Hindawi Publishing Corporation
International
Hindawi Publishing Corporation
Alternative Medicine
Hindawi Publishing Corporation Hindawi Publishing Corporation
Oncology
Hindawi Publishing Corporation
http://www.hindawi.com Volume 2014 http://www.hindawi.com Volume 2014 http://www.hindawi.com Volume 2014 http://www.hindawi.com Volume 2014 http://www.hindawi.com Volume 2014
Parkinsons
Disease
Computational and
Mathematical Methods
in Medicine
Behavioural
Neurology
AIDS
Research and Treatment
Oxidative Medicine and
Cellular Longevity
Hindawi Publishing Corporation Hindawi Publishing Corporation Hindawi Publishing Corporation Hindawi Publishing Corporation Hindawi Publishing Corporation
http://www.hindawi.com Volume 2014 http://www.hindawi.com Volume 2014 http://www.hindawi.com Volume 2014 http://www.hindawi.com Volume 2014 http://www.hindawi.com Volume 2014