EGR-Systems For Diesel Engines: Simon Reifarth
EGR-Systems For Diesel Engines: Simon Reifarth
EGR-Systems For Diesel Engines: Simon Reifarth
SIMON REIFARTH
Licentiate thesis
KTH CICERO TRITA MMK 2010:01
Department of Machine Design ISSN 1400-1179
Royal Institute of Technology ISRN/KTH/MMK/R-10/01-SE
SE-100 44 Stockholm
TRITA MMK 2010:01
ISSN 1400-1179
ISRN/KTH/MMK/R-10/01-SE
EGR-Systems for Diesel Engines
Simon Reifarth
Licentiate thesis
Academic thesis, which with the approval of Kungliga Tekniska Hgskolan, will be presented
for public review in fulfilment of the requirements for a Licentiate of Engineering in Machine
Design. The public review is held at Kungliga Tekniska Hgskolan, Brinellvgen in 83, room
B242, 26th of March at 10:00.
Abstract
It is today undoubted that humans have to reduce their impact
on the environment. Internal combustion engines, being the
major power source in the transportation sector as well as in
individual transport, play an important role in the man-made
emissions. While the mobility in the world is growing, it is
important to reduce the emissions that result from
transportation.
The diesel engine provides a high efficiency and hence it can
help to reduce CO2 emissions, which are believed to be the
main cause of global warming. Diesel exhaust also contains
toxic gases, mainly nitrogen oxides (NOX) and soot particles.
These emissions are therefore limited by the authorities in
most countries.
A way to reduce the nitrogen oxide emissions of a diesel
engine is the use of exhaust gas recirculation, EGR. Here, a
part of the exhaust gases is rerouted into the combustion
chamber. This leads to a lower peak combustion temperature
which in turn reduces the formation of NOX.
In modern turbocharged engines it can be problematic to
provide the amount of EGR that is needed to reach the
emission limits. Other concerns can be the transient response
of both the EGR-system and the engine.
This work provides a simulative comparison of different EGR-
systems, such as long-route EGR, short-route EGR, hybrid
EGR, a system with a reed valve and a system with an EGR-
pump. Both the steady-state performance and transient
performance are compared. In steady-state the focus is the
fuel efficiency. In transient conditions both the reaction on
changed EGR-demands and the torque response are analyzed.
iii
Preface
This work treats different ways of achieving EGR flow in both
steady-state and transient conditions.
It consists of a general introduction, giving an overview of the
field of EGR and diesel combustion and presenting the
methods used in this work. Two papers are appended that
treat different EGR-systems in more detail.
Paper 1
Transient EGR in a long-route and short-route EGR-system
ICES2009-76107
Presented at the ASME Internal Combustion Engine Division
2009 Spring Technical Conference
Simon Reifarth and Hans-Erik ngstrm
Paper 2
Transient EGR in a High-Speed DI Diesel Engine for a set of
different EGR-routings
SAE Technical Paper 2010-01-1271
Simon Reifarth and Hans-Erik ngstrm
Accepted for presentation at the 2010 SAE World Congress,
Detroit
iv
Abbreviations
BMEP Break Mean Effective Pressure
CA Crank Angle
CO Carbon Monoxide
HC Hydrocarbons
LR Long-Route
PM Particulate Matter
SR Short-Route
v
Table of Contents
Abstract....................................................................................iii
Preface ....................................................................................iv
Abbreviations ........................................................................... v
Table of Contents....................................................................vii
1 Introduction ....................................................................... 1
1.1 Motivation .................................................................. 1
1.2 Emission Legislation.................................................. 1
1.3 Emission Formation in Diesel Combustion ................ 3
1.4 Exhaust Aftertreatment Systems ............................... 8
1.5 Exhaust Gas Recirculation (EGR) ........................... 11
1.6 Different EGR-Systems ........................................... 13
2 Experimental Setup ........................................................ 22
2.1 Engine ..................................................................... 22
2.2 Engine Test Cell ...................................................... 23
2.3 Simulation Model ..................................................... 27
3 Discussion ...................................................................... 36
3.1 Summary of Papers ................................................. 36
3.2 Ongoing Work.......................................................... 39
4 Conclusions .................................................................... 43
5 Outlook ........................................................................... 44
6 Acknowledgements......................................................... 45
7 References ..................................................................... 46
vii
1 Introduction
1.1 Motivation
An important task in the development of internal combustion
engines is the reduction of emissions. As the individual mobility
in the world is increasing and the transportation sector is
growing [1], it is important to limit the impact of traffic on both
the environment and the health of the population. The main
combustion products that are contained in engine exhaust
gases are water vapor (H2O), carbon dioxide (CO2), nitrogen
oxides (NOX), particulate matter (PM), hydrocarbons (HC) and
carbon monoxide (CO). All of these, except for the water vapor,
are considered environmentally harmful. This is also reflected
in the fact that governments all over the world enact limits for
the emission of these gases. Therefore, engine developers
work on diminishing these emissions.
A way to reduce the formation of NOX in diesel engines is the
use of EGR, recirculated exhaust gas. Part of the exhaust gas
is rerouted into the combustion chamber, where it helps to
attenuate the formation of NOX by reducing the local reaction
temperature.
The amount of EGR that can be used is limited by different
factors. One of them is the need for delivering enough fresh air
for the combustion to take place; another is the decrease of
engine efficiency that can be caused by high amounts of EGR.
Furthermore, on turbocharged engines, in load points with
good turbocharger efficiency, the intake pressure is higher than
the exhaust pressure. This makes it difficult to get any EGR, as
there is no pressure difference to drive it.
To overcome these problems, different EGR-routings can be
used. The scope of this work is to compare some of these with
experimental and simulative methods. Main focuses are the
effects on fuel consumption and transient behavior.
1
EGR-Systems for Diesel Engines
Time [s]
Figure 1: Speed profile of the MNEDC
2
Introduction
3
EGR-Systems for Diesel Engines
O + N2 NO + N
N + O 2 NO + O
N + OH NO + H
The triple-bond in the N2 molecules makes a high energy
necessary to activate these reactions. Therefore, they are only
fast enough to form significant amounts of NOX if the
temperatures are above 2200 K [4].
The equilibrium of these reactions is not reached in
combustion engines, because the needed temperature level is
only maintained a very short while. Instead, the reactions
freeze as soon as the local temperature falls below 2200 K.
This explains the steep decrease of the NOX formation rate
during the expansion stroke in Figure 3. If the temperatures
stay below a certain level during the whole combustion process,
the formation of NOX can be avoided almost completely, Figure
4.
4
Introduction
5
EGR-Systems for Diesel Engines
6
Introduction
Hydrocarbons (HC)
HC formation is usually not problematic in diesel engines. It
occurs when combustion is not completed which can happen
when there is a lack of oxygen or close to cool walls. Another
phenomenon that leads to HC formation is caused by the
injector sac volume. In this volume, a small fuel portion is left at
the end of injection. It is evaporated by the combustion heat
and enters the combustion chamber with a low pressure. This
leads to a slow mixing with air and thus some fuel can escape
the combustion [3].
As diesel combustion usually is run with excess air, the fuel is
burned almost completely. Modern combustion systems with
high EGR-rates tend to have HC-emission problems. An
oxidation catalyst can be used to eliminate occurring HC and
CO emissions.
HC is suspected to be highly carcinogenic and is one of the
causes of smog.
7
EGR-Systems for Diesel Engines
8
Introduction
9
EGR-Systems for Diesel Engines
10
Introduction
this, the exhaust gas is set to rich conditions and the catalyst is
heated to more than 650 C for at least 5 minutes [2].
Air Exhaust
11
EGR-Systems for Diesel Engines
12
Introduction
13
EGR-Systems for Diesel Engines
into the intake manifold where it is mixed with the fresh air. The
pipe usually contains one or more coolers for the EGR and a
valve to regulate the amount of EGR. The valve can be placed
on either the hot or the cold side of the cooler. A placement on
the hot side gives advantages in transient response [20], while
a placement on the cold side makes the choice of valve easier,
as it will be placed in a colder environment.
14
Introduction
15
EGR-Systems for Diesel Engines
16
Introduction
Figure 14: Exhaust pulses that could be used with a Reed-valve [26]
The peak pressure of the exhaust pulses lies over the boost
pressure and would allow EGR flow. Between the peaks, the
EGR pressure is to low and there is a risk for backflow. This
risk can be eliminated by using a Reed-valve. Figure 15 shows
what such a valve could look like.
17
EGR-Systems for Diesel Engines
18
Introduction
Pump
A pump can be used in the EGR-system, to drive the flow. This
enables to deliver the desired amount of EGR in any driving
19
EGR-Systems for Diesel Engines
Turbocompound
A different kind of throttling the exhaust gas is the use of a
turbocompound turbine [29]. Here, an extra turbine is mounted
after the turbochargers turbine. This results in a higher exhaust
gas backpressure which enables higher EGR-flow. The
increased pumping work is not entirely lost in this case, as the
power turbine recovers some of the work and transmits it to the
crank shaft via a transmission, see Figure 21.
20
Introduction
21
2 Experimental Setup
For the work that was done in this study, both engine tests in
the test cell and a simulation of the engine in a computational
environment were used.
2.1 Engine
The engine used is a 1.9 liter direct injection diesel engine with
a VGT-turbocharger and cooled short-route EGR. More details
can be obtained from table 1. Figure 22 shows the engine in
the test cell.
Table 1: Engine details
Engine type DI turbocharged diesel, Euro 4
No. of cylinders 4
22
Experimental Setup
23
EGR-Systems for Diesel Engines
24
Experimental Setup
Engine Dynamometer
The engine dynamometer allows to control the torque at which
the engine is driven. The dynamometer used here is a
Schenck W260. It is designed for steady state driving
conditions, but with a modern control unit it is now possible to
run load transient with an acceptably stable engine speed.
25
EGR-Systems for Diesel Engines
26
Experimental Setup
Model Calibration
In the first step, the model was calibrated in steady state. For
this calibration, a set of load points along the full load curve
was chosen. In the next step, the model was tested on nine
points in lower load areas. These nine points were chosen to
27
EGR-Systems for Diesel Engines
cover the area that is important for the modified new European
driving cycle, MNEDC.
The calibration process started with the full load points. Here it
was found that a small change in the compressor efficiency
multiplier helped to match the pressure ratio that occurred on
the engine and the turbocharger speed.
Another issue was the pressure loss over the intercooler as
well as the intercoolers damping behavior on pressure waves.
The intercooler had to be dismounted for measurements of the
internal volumes and cooling channels. The cooling efficiency
is provided by an efficiency map that represents the original
cooler.
When testing the calibration on the low-load points, it was
found that the turbocharger behavior was simulated with
insufficient accuracy. This is caused by the large extrapolation
that has to be done in the turbocharger maps. At these load
points, the turbocharger only runs at speeds around 30000 rpm,
while the lowest mapped speed lies at 70000 rpm. The large
extrapolation results in an overestimation of the turbine
efficiency. Therefore, the turbine efficiency multiplier has to be
reduced to reproduce the engines behavior. As the nine load
points tested result in different turbine speed regions, they all
get individual efficiency multipliers for the turbine. Figure 26
shows the found efficiency multipliers as a function of turbine
speed.
28
Experimental Setup
1.1
Turbine Efficiency Multiplier
1
0.9
0.8
0.7
0.6
0 20000 40000 60000 80000 100000 120000 140000
Turbocharger Speed [rpm]
2
p_plenum measured
1.9 p_plenum simulated
Inlet and Exhaust Pressure [bar]
29
EGR-Systems for Diesel Engines
140000
measured
simulated
120000
Turbocharger Speed [rpm]
100000
80000
60000
40000
20000
0 2 4 6 8 10
Load Point Number
30
Experimental Setup
31
EGR-Systems for Diesel Engines
32
Experimental Setup
33
EGR-Systems for Diesel Engines
Heat-Release Rate
A problematic issue in 1-dimensional simulations is the
simulation of diesel combustion. To come around this, it is
common practice to use measured combustion profiles from
real engines as an input to GT-Power. This is straightforward if
running in steady-state, if measurement data of the simulated
engine is available. During transients it can be more
complicated to find the right burn rate for a certain cycle. For
the transient simulation used in this work, a database of heat-
release rates was built up.
In the publications attached, load transients at three different
engine speeds are treated. To find matching combustion rates
for all cycles in the transients, the transients were run several
times with different settings for VGT-position and EGR-valve
position. This resulted in a large number of heat-release rates
for each transient, which had to be handled.
A matlab routine was developed that sorted the heat-release
rates into a map with respect to the cycle-individual intake
pressure and the EGR-rate. Figure 33 shows an example of a
group of heat-release rates of one transient. Figure 34 shows a
group out of this transient after the sorting with respect to
EGR-rate and intake pressure.
34
Experimental Setup
140
120
Heat-release-rate [J/degCA]
100
80
60
40
20
0
-40 -20 0 20 40 60 80 100
Crank Angle [deg]
60
pintake-interval: 1.30-1.52 bar
50 EGR-interval: 0.180-0.275
Heat-release-rate [J/degCA]
40
30
20
10
0
-40 -20 0 20 40 60 80 100
Crank Angle [deg]
Figure 34: One group of HRR, for a certain range of intake pressure
and EGR-rate
To be able to use a map in the simulation, one typical heat-
release rate from this group was chosen and put into the map
used for the simulation.
In the simulation of a transient, the heat-release rate is then
chosen individually for every cycle.
35
3 Discussion
36
Discussion
Figure 35: Compressor Efficiency Map with Working Points for SR and
LR system
The transient section is divided in two parts, transients with
EGR and transients without EGR. The analyzed transients are
load transients from 30 Nm to 120 Nm engine load and at 1500,
2000 and 2500 rpm.
The systems are compared with respect to the transient
response they provide. In transient with closed EGR valve,
there is almost no difference in the load response of SR and
LR system, as Figure 36 shows.
8
6
BMEP [bar]
Figure 36: Comparison of transient BMEP with open vs. closed EGR-
valve at 2000 rpm
For the transients with open EGR-valve, it is analyzed which
system allows to run the transient with EGR and thus to
decrease the transient NOX emission peak. Here, the long-
37
EGR-Systems for Diesel Engines
40
EGR-rate [%]
35
30
25
20
15
10
0 0.5 1 1.5 2
Time [s]
38
Discussion
39
EGR-Systems for Diesel Engines
40
Discussion
Air
m
1.4
& air p
p 1.2
EGR 0.8
Ploss [Bar]
p,T 0.6
pLoss 0.4
0.2
-0.2
0
2 1.5 1 0.5 0.05
0 -0.5
0.1
rate
m
& EGR
&
V EGR
41
EGR-Systems for Diesel Engines
0.8
0.6
CD
0.4
0.2
0
0 100 200 300
Throttle Angle []
42
4 Conclusions
This study gives an overview over different ways to achieve
EGR-flow in diesel engines. Advantages and drawbacks of
these ways are analyzed and compared with regard to fuel
consumption, achievable maximum EGR-rate and transient
response.
It is shown that the long-route EGR path leads to lower fuel
consumption. This extra potential can also be used to increase
the EGR-rate without increasing the fuel consumption. The
cooler does not have to be bigger than in the short-route
system. In the contrary, it is important not to cool the EGR too
much, as condensation droplets could destroy the compressor
wheel.
The long-route system has a slower response to changes in
the EGR demand than the short route system, because of its
larger volume that is filled with a mixture of fresh air and EGR.
However, the long-route system provides a faster response to
load increases, due to its better use of the turbocharger. In
addition to that it can tolerate a certain amount of EGR during
the transient, without losing transient performance.
To overcome the slow transient EGR response in the LR-
system, for example in negative load transients, it can be
combined with a SR-system. Together, they form a hybrid
system where each of the EGR-paths is used when it is best.
In steady-state they can be used together to optimize the use
of the turbocharger. In cold conditions the SR-path can be
used to make sure that no condensation occurs before the
compressor.
As another step in optimizing the EGR-system a pump can be
used in the long-route path to provide the needed pressure
drop to drive the EGR-flow. This can further improve the EGR-
potential and increase the overall efficiency of the engine, if the
pump has a good efficiency.
43
5 Outlook
Further research in this project will analyze the use of a Venturi
injector to increase the pressure drop to drive EGR. Another
system that will be analyzed uses rotating valves to induce
pressure pulses, which in return help to provide higher EGR-
rates.
A detailed analysis of EGR distribution in a heavy duty engine
is planned. Both steady-state and transient measurements will
be carried out. This will provide data to compare with CFD
simulations that will simultaneously be carried out at KTH
mechanics.
In cooperation with the CERC center in Gothenburg, the
gained knowledge of EGR-systems and simulation tools will be
used to design the gas management system for an engine. In a
CERC project, a low-emission diesel combustion concept is
developed that has high demands on both EGR-rate and
charge air pressure.
44
6 Acknowledgements
I would like to thank my supervisor Hans-Erik ngstrm and
my co-supervisor Nils Tillmark for the provided support and
interesting discussions we had.
Thanks go also to the people at Saab Powertrain and Scania
who provided support, information and the test-engine.
This work was supported by CICERO (Centre for Internal
Combustion Engine Research Opus), a competence centre at
KTH, sponsored by the Swedish Energy Agency, vehicle
industry in Sweden and KTH.
For the nice working atmosphere I would like to thank all
colleagues at the internal combustion engines division. Special
thanks go also to our lab technicians Eric, Tommy, Bengt and
Jack for helping me with all my engine and measurement
problems.
Last but not least I would like to thank my family and friends for
their continuous support. I thank Anna for her love and Ida for
the joy she gives us.
45
7 References
1 Verband der Automobilindustrie, VDA Jahresbericht 2009
46
References
16 http://www.truckscr.com/SCRNews.htm on 2010-01-22
47
EGR-Systems for Diesel Engines
29 Heil; B., Schmid; W., Teigeler, M., Sladek, W., ing, H.,
Arndt, S., Melcher, S., The New Daimler Heavy
Commercial Vehicle Engine Series, MTZ worldwide
Edition: 2009-01
48
References
49