Small Stability SMIB Example
Small Stability SMIB Example
Small Stability SMIB Example
Website: www.ijetae.com (ISSN 2250-2459, ISO 9001:2008 Certified Journal, Volume 3, Issue 10, October 2013)
129
International Journal of Emerging Technology and Advanced Engineering
Website: www.ijetae.com (ISSN 2250-2459, ISO 9001:2008 Certified Journal, Volume 3, Issue 10, October 2013)
There are two types of non-linearities in the state The load is represented as constant impedance in this
matrix of a machine viz. trigonometric and product treatment.
nonlinearities. They can be eliminated by trigonometric Power station managers are provided with
and algebraic manipulations[7]. manufacturers data from which the equivalent circuit for
The generator-transformer may be treated as one the direct& quadrature axes can be found out. The
machine on infinite bus provided the capacity of the parameters are generally given in p.u. and time-constants
machine is small compared to that of the grid. A in seconds.
multimachine problem can be reduced to a problem of These parameters are with reference to the classical
one machine on infinite bus, by load flow analysis and model of Park, Concordia & Adkins. The effect of
network reduction. However, this approach hampers saturation and distributed eddy currents in the solid iron
accuracy of the solution[1][3]. rotor are not accounted for in the classical model. Such
effects can also be included in the dynamic studies by
II. T HE INITIAL C ONDITIONS extended mathematical models advanced by various
In dynamic studies, the initial conditions of the system authors [11][12].
are required. For one machine on infinite bus with
specified boundary conditions, the pertinent equations for III. LINEARISATION - E IGENVALUE TECHNIQUES F OR
estimation of steady state conditions and the T HE P REDICTIONOF DYNAMIC STABILITY
corresponding phasor diagrams are given in text-books. It has been already stated that for linearisation of non-
The system is shown in fig. 1. The effect of local load linear state space equations [7][13] of transient stability
and transmission line capacitances can be included in the analysis, we have to make trigonometric and algebraic
study [8]. manipulations. If Xo be the initial states & X be the
small departure, then the non-linear state space form:
X = f(X, U, t) (1)
130
International Journal of Emerging Technology and Advanced Engineering
Website: www.ijetae.com (ISSN 2250-2459, ISO 9001:2008 Certified Journal, Volume 3, Issue 10, October 2013)
Both the forms are used for dynamic performance j 2H (12)
studies. These matrices can be extended to include the
effects of: Extensive application of this model has been made in
i. Excitation control various power system problems for its simplicity. A
ii. Turbine-governor control comprehensive report of the applications has been
iii. Power system stabilizer produced by P.M. Anderson et al [7] and P. Kundur [13].
Additional equations are used to include the effects of the
Detailed discussion of such methods has been made in
solid state exciter [7] shown in fig. 2.
the texts [2][12][13]. The dynamic stability is assessed by
finding eigenvalues of the state matrix. The characteristic
equation is found out by Fadeev-Leverrier method and
the eigenvalues by Lin-Bairstow method [14][15].
MATLAB-tools are frequently used for finding out the
eigenvalues and hence to predict the stability of the
system [16]. Its use reduces programming efforts.
E'
IV. S IMPLIFIED LINEAR MODELS - T HE q -M ODEL,
CONCORDIA AND DE MELLO S CONSTANTS Fig. 2. Block diagram representation of exciter- model IEEE 1s.
While some investigators have tried to model a TABLE-I
machine elaborately to get more accurate predictions, [ Type1S model of IEEE has been used, Ref. Fig. 2]
others have tried to reduce the model through idealising
assumptions and approximations[7,12]. Obviously, there Eq' 1 K4 1 x Eq'
is loss of accuracy in prediction with this approach, but K 3Tdo' Tdo' Tdo'
the dimension of the model gets reduced which saves
computer memory space and run time. It is a useful
technique particularly for large interconnected systems. K2 D K1
Individual machines or group of machines remote from j j j
the point of perturbation does not appreciably affect the
system dynamics. Hence it is expedient to use a reduced
model for them. = 1
With this idea in view, a reduced order model was
developed by Concordia and De Mello, based on V1 (T3 K f K a ) K f V1
(E' - E'q ) concept. Their analysis gave rise to a set of T f Ta
TaT f
equations in terms of constants K1 to K 6 . The
expressions for constants of Concordia and De Mello are
given below: EFD Ka 1 EFD
Ta Ta
K1 KiVb [ Eqao {Re sin ( o ) ( X d ' X e )cos( o )}
I qo ( X q X d' ){( X e X q )sin( o ) Re cos( o )}] Including the effect of a modern solid state exciter, the
where, 1/ Ki Re ( X q X e )( X d X e ) (6)
2 ' machine model in terms of these constants is given
below:
A similar model has been developed for the type 1 of
K2 Ki [{Re . Eqao I qo {Re2 ( X e X q )2 }] (7)
IEEE by Anderson and Fouad [7]. The mathematical
models based on constants K1 to K6 are sufficiently
1/ K3 1 Ki ( X d X d' )( X q X e ) (8) accurate. The pertinent equations are given below:
K 4 Vb Ki ( X d X d' ){( X q X e )sin ( o ) K3 EFD KK
(9) Eq' = 3 4 ' (13)
Re cos( o )} 1 K3Tdo 1 K3Tdo
'
132
International Journal of Emerging Technology and Advanced Engineering
Website: www.ijetae.com (ISSN 2250-2459, ISO 9001:2008 Certified Journal, Volume 3, Issue 10, October 2013)
D-Q axes components of the voltage and current: TABLE-3
(Rouths tabulation)
Vd = -0.6469 ; Vq = 0.7626 ; I d 0.9516 ; 1 1.004536 0.00232515 0.000000846
s7
I q 0.3074 ; E E fd 2.8804 ; I fd 2.4067 2933
133
International Journal of Emerging Technology and Advanced Engineering
Website: www.ijetae.com (ISSN 2250-2459, ISO 9001:2008 Certified Journal, Volume 3, Issue 10, October 2013)
TABLE-3 TABLE-4
(Elements of State-Matrix A(7,7)*1000) (Elements of State-Matrix A(7,7)*1000)
-19.65 1.089 8.055 -6408 -6408 -5062 1618 -19.65 1.089 8.055 -6408 -5585 -3802 3603
7.376 -4.256 14.072 2405.0 2096.1 1899.7 -607.2 7.376 -4.256 14.072 2405.0 2096.1 1426.9 -1352
11.688 3.015 -23.25 3811 3321.6 3010.4 -962.3 11.688 3.015 -23.25 3811.2 3321.6 2261.2 -2143
5276.1 4631.4 4631.4 -15.39 20.523 1279.4 3946.4 5276.1 4631.4 4631.4 -15.39 20.523 2831.4 2971.9
-4848 -4255 -4255 14.143 -23.55 -1176 -3626 -4848 -4255 -4255 14.143 -23.55 -2602 -2731
-3.622 -65.29 -65.29 -128.9 -92.45 -119.6 0 -2.72 -49.04 -49.04 -85.75 -30.69 -119.6 0
0 0 0 0 0 1000.0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1000.0 0
Coefficients of characteristic polynomial (found out by Coefficients of characteristic polynomial (by Fadeev-
Fadeev-Leverrier method) are given below: Leverrier method) are given below:
As all the coefficients of the characteristic polynomial The real roots by N-R method: s(1) =-2.949653e-02
are not positive, the system is unstable. This is confirmed No more real roots- 3 pairs of complex roots are being
by finding out the real root of the polynomial by N-R found out by Lin-Bairstow's method:
method: s = 9.302644E-04. It is a pole in the right half
of the s-plane showing instability of the system at the Complex pair(1): 5.1354e 03 j 7.216e 03
specified operating condition. frequency of oscillation= 0.3608 Hz.;
damping ratio= 0.6198
ii. Half rated power P =0.425 at 0.985 leading power
factor. Boundary conditions given at generator node Complex pair(2): 6.1265e 02 j 0.5755
The generator terminal voltage: Vg = 1.05 0o; frequency of oscillation= 28.78 Hz.;
damping ratio= 5.196e-02
The infinite bus voltage: Vinf = 1.0591 3.0116o ; Complex pair(3): 2.1709e 02 j 0.9992
Power angle: = 43.46o; frequency of oscillation= 49.95Hz.;
Axis components of voltage and current: dampingratio= 0.1466
Vd = -0.7223 ; Vq = 0.7621
As all the eigenvalues are either negative real or
I d = -0.227 ; I q = 0.3425 ; complex with negative real components, the system is
Induced emf and field current: stable.
E EFD 1.2678 ; I FD 1.0592 C. Case-3(Based on Reduced Order Model, Including
D-axis/Q-axis armature linkage = 1.321/ 1.2519; Exciter)
Infinite bus constant, K =1.8345 ; Now, the current state space model is being worked
Its D & Q-axes components- K d , K q :-1.3302 /1.2632 out in terms of Concordia and D'melloconstants.
Saturation and the effect of exciter have been included in
the study.
134
International Journal of Emerging Technology and Advanced Engineering
Website: www.ijetae.com (ISSN 2250-2459, ISO 9001:2008 Certified Journal, Volume 3, Issue 10, October 2013)
C1. Machine parameters: Table- VI
' (The Routh's tabulation)
X ds = 1.7 ; X qs = 1.64 ; X ds = 0.245 ; Z e = 0.02 + j 0.4;
other parameters are unchanged. s5 1.0 0.02146044 0.000003341687
135
International Journal of Emerging Technology and Advanced Engineering
Website: www.ijetae.com (ISSN 2250-2459, ISO 9001:2008 Certified Journal, Volume 3, Issue 10, October 2013)
Sometimes reduced order models are also used to [2] Klein M., Rogers G.J., Moorty S. and Kundur P., Analytical
investigation of factors influencing power system stabilizer
reduce the dimension of the state matrix and run-time of
performance, paper 92WM016-6EC, presented at the IEE PES
the computer. The idealization of one machine on infinite Winter meeting, New York, January, 1992.
bus is made if the rating of the machine is small [3] Klein M., Rogers G.J., and Kundur P., A fundamental study of
compared to the total capacity of the grid. Otherwise interarea oscillations, IEEE Trans, Vol. PWRS-6, No. 3, pp-914-
multimachine dynamic stability analysis has to be made. 921, August, 1991.
If the addition of fast excitation controller gives rise to [4] Kundur P., Lee D.C., Zein EI-Din H.M., Power system
poor or negative damping, then a variable structure stabilisers for thermal units: analytical techniques and on-site
validation, IEEE Trans., Vol. PAS-100, pp. 81-96, January,
Power System Stabilizer (PSS) should be added. 1981.
Dynamic stability analysis has been made in this paper [5] Kundur P., and Dandeno P.L., Practical application of eigenvalue
for 210 MW turbo generator set using both flux-linkage techniques in the analysis of power system dynamic stability
and current state space models for different conditions of problems, Proc. of 5th. powers system computation conference,
loading. While the machine delivers rated power at rated Cambridge, England, September, 1975.
p.f., it is found to be stable. But when the power factor is [6] Radhakrishna C., Stability studies of AC/DC power systems,
Ph. D. Thesis, Indian Institute of Technology, Kanpur, India,
slightly leading (0.985), the generator becomes 1980.
dynamically unstable. But under light load condition (0.5 [7] Anderson P.M. and Fouad A.A., Power System Control and
p.u. loading) the generator becomes dynamically stable. Stability- IOWA State university, Galgotia Publications.
In each case, the machine has been idealized as one [8] Singh L.P., Advanced power system analysis and dynamics,
machine on infinite bus and the effect of exciter has been New Age Int. 3rd. Ed., 1996
neglected. [9] Kundur P., Power system stability and control, The EPRI Power
The other case study has been made on the same System Engineering Series, McGraw-Hill, Inc., 1994.
machine. This time the effect of saturation and the solid [10] Farmer R.G., Power system dynamics and stability, Book,
Arizona state university.
state exciter have been included. A reduced order model
[11] Adkins B. and Harley R.G., Generalized theory of a.c.
based on the constants K1 K6 of Concordia and machines, Book, Chapman & Hall
DMello has been made. The exciter has been [12] Venikov V., Transient processes in electric power system,
represented according to IEEE model 1s. Dynamic Book, MIR Publishers.
stability study has been made for operation at continuous [13] Kundur P., Power system stability and control, The EPRI power
maximum rating (CMR), using Rouths array on the system engineering series, McGraw Hill.
characteristic equation of the state matrix. It is found that [14] Kreyszig E., Advanced engineering mathematics, Wiley, New
York, 2001.
the machine at this operating condition is dynamically
[15] Rajaraman V., Computer-oriented numerical methods, PHI,
stable. 1995
REFERENCES [16] Pratap R., Getting strated with MATLAB7, Oxford, Indian Ed.
[1] Watanabe M., Mitani Y., Iki H., Uriu Y., and Urano Y.,Dynamic
stability assessment of customers power systems with detailed
models implementation, 17th Power Systems Computation
Conference Stockholm Sweden - August 22-26, 2011
136