Chap 007
Chap 007
Chap 007
Chapter 7
Inflation, Yield Curve, and Duration:
Impact on Interest Rates and Asset Prices
Learning Objectives
You will discover what inflation is all about and how inflation can impact
interest rates and the prices of financial assets.
You will see how yield curves arise and view the controversy over what
determines the shape of the yield curve.
You will discover how yield curves can be a useful tool for those interested in
investing their money and in tracking the health of the economy.
You will be explore the concept of duration a measure of the maturity of a
financial instrument and see how it can be used to assist in making
investment choices and in protecting against the risk of changes in interest
rates.
Chapter Outline
7.1. Introduction
7.2. Inflation and Interest Rates
7.2.1. The Correlation between Inflation and Interest Rates
7.2.2. Nominal and Real Interest Rates
7.2.3. The Fisher Effect
7.2.4. Alternative Views about Inflation and Interest Rates
7.2.4.1. The Harrod-Keynes Effect of Inflation
7.2.4.2. Anticipated versus Unanticipated Inflation
7.2.4.3. The Inflation-Risk Premium
7.2.4.4. The Inflation-Caused Income Tax Effect
7.2.4.5. Conclusion from Recent Research on Inflation and Interest
Rates
7.3. Inflation and Stock Prices
7.4. The Development of Inflation-Adjusted Securities
7.5. The Maturity of a Loan
7.5.1. The Yield Curve and the Term Structure of Interest Rates
7.5.2. Types of Yield Curves
7-1
Chapter 07 - Inflation, Yield Curve, and Duration: Impact on Interest Rates and Asset Prices
7-2
Chapter 07 - Inflation, Yield Curve, and Duration: Impact on Interest Rates and Asset Prices
2. Explain how inflation affects interest rates. What is the Fisher effect? What
does it assume?
Answer: Interest rates represent the "price" of credit, so interest rates are also affected
by inflation, although there is considerable debate as to exactly how and by how much
inflation affects interest rates.
The nominal interest rate is the rate quoted by lenders to investors. The real
interest rate is the purchasing power return to the lender of funds. If the lender
expects prices to rise during the life of a loan, he or she will have to adjust the
nominal rate of interest to keep pace with inflation so that the lenders purchasing
power is protected. Therefore, inflation tends to drive up interest rates.
Irving Fisher argued that the nominal interest rate is the sum of the real rate
plus the inflation premium. He contended that the real rate is relatively stable so that
inflation only affects the nominal rate. Expected inflation causes the expected nominal
rate of interest to increase by the same amount. The Fisher effect assumes that
inflation is fully anticipated.
3. Explain how nominal contracts may cause inflation to affect the stock prices of
some firms differently than it affects the stock prices of other firms.
Answer: The nominal contracts theory examines the responsiveness of business
revenues and expenses as well as the composition of a firms balance sheet to changes
in the rate of inflation. Companies that have pricing flexibility often gain additional
revenues as prices go up due to inflation and may secure larger profits if their
expenses are more or less fixed. Their stock prices tend to rise in such situations. In
contrast, other firms may experience rapidly rising expenses due to inflation and
possibly their stock price as well.
7-3
Chapter 07 - Inflation, Yield Curve, and Duration: Impact on Interest Rates and Asset Prices
5. What are TIPS? What advantages do they offer investors? Any disadvantages?
Answer: Treasury inflation protected securities are issued in order to help protect
investors in U.S. government securities from lower rates of return due to inflation.
The coupon interest income and the principal payment from the indexed bonds are
both fixed in terms of purchasing power. However, not all inflation risk is eliminated
by TIPS because rising inflation can drive an investor into a higher tax bracket,
resulting in an after-tax rate of return somewhat less than the full inflation-adjusted
real interest income from these special Treasury bonds. Moreover, TIPS are subject to
market risk if an investor wishes to sell them ahead of their maturity date.
6. Explain the meaning of the phrase term structure of interest rates. What is a
yield curve? What assumptions are necessary to construct a yield curve?
Answer: The term structure of interest rates refers to the relationship between the
rates of return (yield) on financial instruments and their maturity. A yield curve is a
visual representation of the term structure of rates for all securities of equivalent grade
or quality. The yield curve represents only one moment in time with all other factors
held constant.
7-4
Chapter 07 - Inflation, Yield Curve, and Duration: Impact on Interest Rates and Asset Prices
The preferred habitat view is closely allied with the market segmentation view,
though it also brings in elements of the expectations and liquidity premium
arguments, thus providing a composite theory of the determinants of the yield curve.
Preferred habitat argues that investors select a preferred maturity range along the yield
curve on the basis of their risk preferences, tax exposure, liquidity requirements,
binding regulations, expectations, and other factors. Each investor will tend to stay in
his or her preferred maturity habitat unless induced to leave by higher yields or other
considerations. Moreover, investors expect that interest rates will tend to move back
toward their normal range based on historical experience.
The expectations hypothesis implies that changes in the volume of long-term
versus short-term securities will not affect the shape of the yield curve. Thus, the
central bank or the government cannot alter the shape of the yield curve by changing
the relative amounts of long-term and short-term securities. If the segmented-markets
or preferred-habitat theories are true, however, the government could alter the shape
of the yield curve by changing the supply of securities in one or more market
segments.
8. What are the implications for investors and for public policy of each of the
yield-curve ideas mentioned in the preceding question?
Answer: While the expectations theory holds that investors are profit maximizes who
will seek securities offering the highest rate of return (regardless of maturity), the
segmented markets theory says that investors will not stray from their maturity
preferences unless they are induced by significantly higher yields or other favorable
terms on securities with different maturities.
Preferred habitat argues that investors select a preferred maturity range along
the yield curve on the basis of their risk preferences, tax exposure, liquidity
requirements, binding regulations, expectations, and other factors. Each investor will
tend to stay in his or her preferred maturity habitat unless induced to leave by higher
yields or other considerations. Moreover, investors expect that interest rates will tend
to move back toward their normal range based on historical experience.
The expectations hypothesis implies that changes in the volume of long-term
versus short-term securities will not affect the shape of the yield curve. Thus, the
central bank or the government cannot alter the shape of the yield curve by changing
the relative amounts of long-term and short-term securities. If the segmented-markets
or preferred-habitat theories are true however, the government could alter the shape of
the yield curve by changing the supply of securities in one or more market segments.
9. What uses does the yield curve have? Why is each possible use of potential
value to borrowers and lenders of funds?
Answer: One use of the yield curve is to forecast interest rates. The slope of the yield
curve can signal borrowers and lenders of funds to move away from or towards long-
term securities or short-term securities. For example, if the yield curve is upward-
sloping, rates are expected to rise. Lenders (investors) should move toward short-
term securities whose prices will fall less as rates rise. Borrowers should try to
borrow longer-term.
7-5
Chapter 07 - Inflation, Yield Curve, and Duration: Impact on Interest Rates and Asset Prices
10. What conclusions can you draw from recent research regarding the
determinants of the yield curve? Which theory of the yield curve appears to be
most supported by recent research studies?
Answer: A number of research studies seem to reject the unbiased expectations
hypothesis and find that the yield curve does not have significant predictive power in
forecasting interest rates.
Recent research has delved more deeply into the issue of what kinds of events
cause the yield curves overall shape to change. Statistically, yield curves may change
along any of at least three different dimensions: level, slope, or curvature. A change in
level of the yield curve means that interest rates all along the curve move roughly in
parallel, shifting the whole curve up or down. The curves slope or steepness changes
when shorter-term interest rates rise or fall by greater amounts than longer-term
interest rates. The curvature of a yield curve may change when interest rates in the
middle of the maturity spectrum are impacted. This development would tend to give
the yield curve a greater or lesser hump along its midsection. These various
dimensions of a yield curve suggest that these curves are far more complex and more
intimately connected with the economy and government policy than was once
thought.
7-6
Chapter 07 - Inflation, Yield Curve, and Duration: Impact on Interest Rates and Asset Prices
11. What is the price elasticity of a financial asset, and what useful information
can it provide to an investor or portfolio manager?
Answer: Price elasticity is the measure of how responsive of a bond or other debt
securitys price is to changes in the interest rates Usually the price elasticity attached
to a bond or other debt security must be negative, because rising interest rates (yields)
result in falling debt security prices, and conversely.
It is useful information for an investor or portfolio manager, because higher
price elasticity means that an asset goes through a greater price change for a given
change in market rates of interest. Longer-term debt securities generally carry greater
price risk (their price elasticity is larger) than shorter-term debt securities.
12. What is the coupon effect? How would it figure into the assessment of
selecting financial assets for an investment portfolio?
Answer: The coupon effect is the relationship between the annual coupon rate and the
price of a debt security. The price of low-coupon securities tend to rise faster than the
prices of high-coupon securities when market interest rate decline. Similarly, a period
of rising interest rate will cause the prices of low-coupon securities to fall faster than
the prices of high-coupon securities. Thus, the potential for capital gains and capital
losses is greater for low-coupon than for high-coupon securities.
13. What is meant by the term convexity as it relates to the price of a financial
asset? In what way could it be useful information to an investor?
Answer: The relationship between price risk and yield can be quantified by a measure
called convexity, which measures the rate of change of the elasticity of prices with
respect to yield, or how rapidly the investors risk diminishes as interest rate rise. The
convexity measure for an asset would give the investor a precise relationship between
changes in price elasticity and yield, and could assist him in choosing fixed-income
securities he may wish to incorporate into his investment portfolio.
7-7
Chapter 07 - Inflation, Yield Curve, and Duration: Impact on Interest Rates and Asset Prices
16. What are the limitations of duration and the portfolio immunization
technique?
Answer: The limitations are that are often difficult to find a collection of assets
whose average portfolio duration exactly matches the investors planned holding
period. Another limitation is always some risk associated with the use of conventional
measures of duration due to uncertainty about future interest rate movements
(stochastic process risk). For immunization using duration to work well, the interest
rate movements should have the parallel change in all interest rates, but in reality the
interest rates of various maturities tend to change in accordance with the level, slope
and curvature of the yield curve. However, the duration model seems to be robust
under a variety of market conditions.
7-8
Chapter 07 - Inflation, Yield Curve, and Duration: Impact on Interest Rates and Asset Prices
2. Mark wants a 3 percent real rate of return to invest in stock XYZ, and a 5
percent real rate of return to invest in stock ABC. Heidi believes that both
stocks are less risky than Mark, and is willing to accept real rates of return of
2 percent on XYZ and 4 percent on ABC. Mark expects the inflation rate to
be 3 percent and Heidi expects the inflation rate to be 5 percent. If the
current yield on both XYZ and ABC is 6 percent, then:
(A) Mark would be willing to invest in XYZ, but not in ABC, while Heidi
would not want to invest in either.
(B) Mark would invest in both XYZ and ABC, while Heidi would not invest
in either.
(C) Both Mark and Heidi would be willing to invest in XYZ, but not in ABC.
(D) Both Mark and Heidi would be willing to invest in both XYZ and ABC.
ANSWER: (A)
5. Suppose that the actual U.S. Treasury yield curve is approximately flat. This
yield curve would suggest that the markets are expecting:
(A) short rates to remain essentially unchanged in the future.
(B) long rates to fall in the future.
(C) long rates to increase in the future.
(D) short rates to fall in the future.
ANSWER: (D)
7-9
Chapter 07 - Inflation, Yield Curve, and Duration: Impact on Interest Rates and Asset Prices
8. Repeat problem 7, but where the market interest rates are: 7 percent for the
one-year, zero-coupon bond and 5 percent for the two-year, zero-coupon
bond.
ANSWER: Under the strategy buy-and-hold by holding T-note yielding 5 percent, the
total return after 2 years is:
Total Return of buy-and-hold = $1,000 (1+R1)2 = $1,000 (1.05)2 = $1,102.50
Under the strategy roll-over by investing in one year left to maturity yielding 7
percent, the total return after 2 years is:
Total Return of roll-over = $1,000 (1+r1) (1+Er2)
= $1,000 (1.07) (1+Er2) = $1,070.00 (1+Er2)
Hence the strategy buy-and-hold will succeed if:
Total Return of buy-and-hold > Total Return of roll-over
Or, $1,102.50 > $1,070.00 (1+Er2) and Er2 < 0.0304 or 3.04%
Hence the strategy buy-and-hold will fail if:
Total Return of buy-and-hold < Total Return of roll-over
Or, $1,102.50 < $1,070.00 (1+Er2) and Er2 > 0.0304 or 3.04%
7-10
Chapter 07 - Inflation, Yield Curve, and Duration: Impact on Interest Rates and Asset Prices
9. Calculate the price elasticity of a 15-year bond around its $1,000 par value
and 10 percent coupon rate if market interest rates on comparable bonds
drop to 6 percent. The market price of the bond at a 6 percent yield to
maturity is $1,392. Suppose now that the yield to maturity climbs to 14
percent. If the bonds price falls to $751.80, what is the bonds price
elasticity?
ANSWER: From price elasticity equation (7.14):
The price elasticity from a 10% yield drop to 6% yield is:
1,392 1,000
1,000 0.392
Price Elasticity = 0.98
0.06 0.10 0.4
0.10
The price elasticity from a 6% yield climb to 14% yield is:
751.80 1,392
1,392 0.460
Price Elasticity = 0.345
0.14 0.06 1.33
0.06
The price elasticity from a 14% yield drop to 10% yield is:
1,000 751.80
751.80 0.330
Price Elasticity = 1.155
0.10 0.14 0.286
0.14
10. Calculate the value of duration for a four-year, $1,000 par value U.S.
government bond purchased today at a yield to maturity of 15 percent. The
bonds coupon rate is 12 percent, and it pays interest at years end. Now
suppose the market interest rate on comparable bonds falls to 14 percent.
What percentage change in this bonds price will result?
ANSWER:
Expected Present value of
Cash Flows expected Cash Time Period Present Value
Period from Flows (at 15% Rate Cash is to be of Expected
Security of Discount) Received (t) cash flows x t
1 120 104.35 1 104.35
2 120 90.74 2 181.47
3 120 78.90 3 236.71
4 120 68.61 4 274.44
4 1,000 571.75 4 2,287.01
$914.35 $3,083.98
Duration = $3083.98/$914.35 = 3.37 years.
Present value of the bond at a 14% yield to maturity:
7-11
Chapter 07 - Inflation, Yield Curve, and Duration: Impact on Interest Rates and Asset Prices
11. A bank buying bonds is concerned about possible fluctuations in earnings due
to changes in interest rates. Currently the banks investment officer is
looking at a $1,000 par-value bond that matures in four years and carries a
coupon rate of 12 percent. Market interest rates are also at 12 percent, but
the banks officer believes there is a significant probability that interest rates
could drop to 10 percent or rise to 14 percent during the first year and stay
there until the bond matures. What would be this bonds total earnings over
the next four years if interest rates rise to 14 percent? Fall to 10 percent?
Remain at 12 percent? What will happen to total earnings if the investment
officer finds another bond whose maturity is reached in five years but whose
duration is four years--the same as the banks planned holding period?
ANSWER:
Earnings at 12 percent
7-12
Chapter 07 - Inflation, Yield Curve, and Duration: Impact on Interest Rates and Asset Prices
Earnings at 10 percent
Earnings at 14 percent
12. The 10year Treasury bond rate is trading at 6.08 percent, while the one-year
bond rate carries a yield to maturity of 5.35 percent. What is the yield spread
between these instruments? What is this yield spread forecasting for the
economy in the period ahead? Please explain.
ANSWER: The current yield spread is 73 basis points. The yield spread is forecasting
that investors expect somewhat higher short-term interest rates in the future.
Suppose the 10year T-bond rate falls to 5.57 percent, while the oneyear
T-bond yield rises to 6.04 percent. What change in yield spread has
occurred? What is the expected outlook for economic conditions following
this particular change in the yield spread? Can you explain why?
ANSWER: The yield spread is now negative at 47 basis points. The downward
slope suggests the likelihood of near-term declines in short-term interest rates and a
slowing of the economy.
7-13
Chapter 07 - Inflation, Yield Curve, and Duration: Impact on Interest Rates and Asset Prices
14. A four-year TIPS bond promises a real annual coupon return of 4 percent
and its face value is $1,000. While the annual inflation rate was
approximately zero when the bond was first issued, the inflation rate
suddenly accelerated to 3 percent and is expected to remain at that level for
the bonds four-year term. What will be the amount of interest paid in
nominal dollars each year of the bonds life? What will be the face (nominal)
value of the bond at the end of each year of its life?
ANSWER: The results show in the table:
Nominal Interest
Actual TIPS's Pricipal Nominal Interest Payment from a
Annual Rate Nominal Value at Payment to the TIPS Conventional
of Inflation the End of Each Bond's Holder at Year (Non-Inflation-
Period (%) Year End Adjusted) Bond
First Year 3% 1030.00 41.20 $40
Second Year 3% 1060.90 42.44 $40
Third Year 3% 1092.73 43.71 $40
Fourth Year 3% 1125.51 45.02 $40
EXCEL 15. Jon wishes to invest $10,000 in U.S. Treasury securities for 10 years.
He is considering the following investment strategies: (1) Buy a 10-year T-Note
and hold it to maturity; (2) Buy a 5-year T-Note and upon maturity roll-over the
principal and interest in a second 5-year T-Note; (3) Buy a Treasury with one
year to maturity, and continuously roll-over the investment in one-year Treasury
for 10 years. The current yields are: 2 percent on the 1-year Treasury; 4.25
percent on the 5-year T-Note; and 4.5 percent on the 10-year T-Note. Jons
financial analysis indicates that market expectations are for the 1-year Treasury
yield to rise by 50 basis points every year for the first 5 years, and then remain
unchanged for the next 5 years, and for the 5-year T-Note to be the same in 5
years as it is today. Using a spreadsheet, display the total return (including the
initial investment) that Jon would have FROM his investment in each of the 10
years under each of the three investment strategies. (Hint: Let column one
display the value of the investment (1) after one year in the first row, after 2
years in the second row, etc., then repeat for investment (2) in column 2, and for
investment (3) in column 3. Use additional columns for questions d, e, and f.)
7-14
Chapter 07 - Inflation, Yield Curve, and Duration: Impact on Interest Rates and Asset Prices
7-15
Chapter 07 - Inflation, Yield Curve, and Duration: Impact on Interest Rates and Asset Prices
d. Suppose that the actual short rate remained unchanged during the entire 10
years, how would that affect the 10-year rate of return on investment (3)?
ANSWER: The total return on unchanged actual short rate is:
5-year T-Note 1-year T-note 1-year T-note
Period 10-year T-Note roll-over roll-over (unchanged)
1 10450.00 10425.00 10,200.00 10200.00
2 10920.25 10868.06 10,455.00 10404.00
3 11411.66 11329.96 10,768.65 10612.08
4 11925.19 11811.48 11,145.55 10824.32
5 12461.82 12313.47 11,591.37 11040.81
6 13022.60 12836.79 12,055.03 11261.62
7 13608.62 13382.35 12,537.23 11486.86
8 14221.01 13951.10 13,038.72 11716.59
9 14860.95 14544.02 13,560.27 11950.93
10 15529.69 15162.14 14,102.68 12189.94
e. What would happen to the investments 10-year rate of return if the one-year
rate continued to rise at 50 basis points per year for years 5 through 10?
ANSWER: The total return on rising 50 basis points for 10 years in short rate is:
5-year T-Note 1-year T-note 1-year T-note (50 basis
Period 10-year T-Note roll-over roll-over points for 10 yrs)
1 10450.00 10425.00 10,200.00 10,200.00
2 10920.25 10868.06 10,455.00 10,455.00
3 11411.66 11329.96 10,768.65 10,768.65
4 11925.19 11811.48 11,145.55 11,145.55
5 12461.82 12313.47 11,591.37 11,591.37
6 13022.60 12836.79 12,055.03 12,112.99
7 13608.62 13382.35 12,537.23 12,718.64
8 14221.01 13951.10 13,038.72 13,418.16
9 14860.95 14544.02 13,560.27 14,223.25
10 15529.69 15162.14 14,102.68 15,147.76
f. If the 5-year T-Note yield fell 50 basis points after five years, how much
would this reduce the 10-year rate of return on investment (2)?
7-16
Chapter 07 - Inflation, Yield Curve, and Duration: Impact on Interest Rates and Asset Prices
7-17
Chapter 07 - Inflation, Yield Curve, and Duration: Impact on Interest Rates and Asset Prices
Web-Based Problems
1. Yield curves can be constructed for assets drawn from similar risk classes.
Traditionally there are three types of yield curves that are typically followed
in the financial markets. The dominant one is for U.S. Treasury securities. It
is a plot of the yields on on-the-run (or most frequently issued) Treasuries
for maturities: 3-months, 6-months, 2-years, 3-years, 5-years, 10-years, and
30-years. It is a simple matter to find this information from a wide variety of
internet sites, such as the U.S. Treasury Department, the Federal Reserve, etc.
This question asks you to search the internet for the information you need to
construct the other two yield curves that are often followed in the financial
press. One is for the highest quality debt of major U.S. corporations, which
would range from 30-day commercial paper rates to 30-year corporate bonds.
The second is similarly rated municipal bonds. These debt instruments of
state and local governments have a much higher volume at longer maturities
than shorter maturities, but see how much of the maturity spectrum from 3
months to 30 years you can find. Once you have gathered these data, plot all
three yield curves on the same graph. You should see similar patterns in all
three. Why? However, you should also see that the corporate yield curve lies
everywhere above the Treasury yield curve. Why? And the Treasury yield
curve should lie everywhere above the municipal yield curve. Why?
7-18
Chapter 07 - Inflation, Yield Curve, and Duration: Impact on Interest Rates and Asset Prices
The corporate bonds always give the highest yield to investors because of their
greater default risk. Municipal bonds typically offer lower yields than Treasury
securities because their interest payments are tax exempt. Hence the yield curve of
corporate bonds lies above the yield curve of U.S. Treasury bonds and then Municipal
bonds.
2. During the late 1970s the inflation rate in the United States was in double
digits. In response, the Federal Reserve decided to raise short-term interest
rates dramatically to bring it down.
a. What would you expect the yield curve to look like after this policy
change?
Answer: The yield curve will tilt up at the shorter-term side and it will slope
downward.
b. Visit the Feds web site at www.federalreserve.gov and click on the
Economic Research and Data tab; then click on the Statistics: Releases
and Historical Data tab and obtain historical data on Selected Interest
Rates from the H.15 release. From these data construct a Treasury yield
curve for April 1980 and for the most recent month you can find.
Answer: Compare the Treasury yield rate between 1980 and July 16, 2007:
Maturity Period U.S. Treasuries in 1980 U.S. Treasuries on July 16, 2007
3-months 4.74
6-months 4.95
1-years 12.00 4.96
2-years 11.73 4.98
3-years 11.51 5.00
5-years 11.45 5.03
7-years 11.40 5.05
10-years 11.43 5.10
20-years 11.36 5.29
30-years 11.27 5.20
7-19
Chapter 07 - Inflation, Yield Curve, and Duration: Impact on Interest Rates and Asset Prices
c. Search the Internet for data on the current inflation rate (measured by
the CPI) in the United States and the U.S. inflation rate in 1980. Does this
information help you to explain the shapes of the yield curves for these
two time periods?
Answer: Yes, the inflation rate information helps explain the shapes of the yield
curves on both cases. Higher inflation rates tend to shift the yield curve upward.
7-20