The Gate of Kashrut10 PDF
The Gate of Kashrut10 PDF
The Gate of Kashrut10 PDF
questions. Only in Chol Hamoed and Yom Tov was I able to ask the meaning of all his customs;
he replied he was sent and came for a secret issue, by order of the president of his land. There
were 96.000 Jews where he came from, and they all comply with the law of Maaser, and as per
the Torah, they have rulers for every 10 people, every 50, 100 and 1000... The president is a holy
man well versed in Kabballah. He directs the entire town. He is a Tzaddik fearful of G-d and not
only serves justice to his peoplebut like the tribe of Yssachar he knows the destiny of Israel
throughout the Galut and he has a book called SEFER HA ABIB (BEGINNING LETTERS OF:
ACHENU BENE ISRAEL BAGOLA), (Our brothers The sons of Israel in exile)
invent astounding midrashim and then reconcile them and they themselves are irreligious and
connivers. The pillar of worship was weakened by the cantors known for their irreverence and
irresponsibility, for in our times the prayer takes the place of the daily sacrifices, in whose place
the Rabbis instituted the daily prayers. The pillar of kind deeds was weakened by the shochatim
who take mitzvot lightly. The Talmud tell us (Taanis 23b) that when Abba Chilkiah prayed for
rain, a cloud ascended from the corner where his wife was standing, because a woman is usually
in the house and she gives bread to the poor, from which they benefit immediately.
house. She called him and told him her problem. He told her that he had just slaughtered a tender
calf.
THE BAAL SHEM TOV REVEALS AND EXPOSES
THE WICKEDNESS OF THE SHOCHET
The Baal Shem Tov said, "I prefer the head, but I beg you to bring it here when it is whole and
remove the veins in my presence." The shochet went quickly and brought the head to the rabbi's
house. The Baal Shem Tov began to converse with the shochet and said to him. There are
differences in the number of teeth in a calf. Count this calf's teeth." The shochet opened the
mouth of the slaughtered animal and inserted his hand to count teeth. But, lo and behold! As
soon as he had inserted his hand into the calf's mouth, it closed on him and he was unable to
extricate his hand from the trap. The teeth pressed into his hand and caused him such
excruciating pain that he screamed.
Said the Baal Shem Tov, "Wicked man, confess your sins! You never examined the lungs of an
animal. You arbitrarily declared them kosher or treifah." After the schochet confessed, he begged
the Baal Shem Tov to instruct him how to repent.
THE DESTRUCTIVE ANGELS IN THE SYNAGOGUE ARE
CREATED FROM THE SINS OF THE EVIL CHAZAN [CANTOR]
Then the Baal Shem Tov accompanied the rabbi to the synagogue. He passed his hand over the
rabbi's face and showed him how many destructive angels and spirits 'were sitting on the roof of
the synagogue. The rabbi was astounded at this. The Baal Shem Tov said to him, "You should
know that your cantor sins every night." They discharged the cantor and hired another in his
place (Shivchei Baal Shem Tov).
from other correspondence among them) as brought in the book Sefer ha Tamim, printed in
Warsaw the 12 of Tammuz, 5696 4th edition.
dead will come to life. The proofs mentioned in the Gemara were not sufficient for them, since
they felt that all the verses quoted by the Gemara could be explained otherwise.
NON KOSHER FOOD DEFILES THE SOUL OF THE PERSON
The Rambam refused to reply to them, but delegated the task to his disciple, Rabbi Shmuel ibn
Tibbon. The latter wrote as follows: "According to science, all food and drink are converted to
blood. From the blood, it goes into the liver, and from the liver, the purest goes into the heart.
From the heart, the best and most refined blood enters the brain, the seat of a person's intellect
and life. One who is cautious in the field of forbidden foods, is assured that his blood will be
pure and clear, and he will have a pure heart. His brain will be pure enough to attain a pure spirit
of life, which is the divinity of all the worlds, which keeps them all in existence. The more one
watches himself and sanctifies his eating habits according to G-d's Torah, the more his intellect
sanctifies all his two hundred forty-eight limbs.
THE HIGHEST DEGREE OF TUMAH [IMPURITY] IS DISBELIEF IN G-D AND HIS
TORAH. THIS PERSON IS REGARDED AS DEAD
Likewise, if one is lax in this respect, his intellect becomes defiled and is regarded as dead,
which is the highest degree of uncleanness. Thus the holy spirit of all the worlds leaves him,
leaving him vulnerable to all sorts of false doctrines and ideas. Therefore, the rabbis of the
Talmud were extremely conscientious in their observance of these laws, so as not to defile
themselves with food and wine of gentiles.
Consequently, their intellect was brilliant, the holy spirit of the Almighty rested upon them, to
enable them to explain every hidden meaning of the holy Torah. Since He and his Torah are one,
a divine power rested upon them and the light of their souls joined these two components to form
a three stranded cord, which will never be torn. These people (he addressed them
euphemistically), however, are surely unclean. Consequently, their blood is unclean, and their
hearts and brains have become clogged by dint of the forbidden and unclean foods. They,
therefore, are inclined to believe in apikorsus, denial of the Torah teachings, and have been
unable to accept the sweetness and pleasantness of our Sages' words, built on their divine
intellect. Since they have become brazen and have left the faith, the destroyer will come upon
them and will destroy them and theirs."
Not long afterwards, a powerful king invaded their country and put them to death, scattering all
their belongings. (This is a faithful translation of Degel Machanay Ephraim).
THE GATE OF KASHRUT 7
THE HOLY AUTHOR OF THE DIBRE CHAYIM ZTL REVEALS THAT IN EUROPE
MILLIONS TURNED AWAY FROM THE FAITH DUE TO FORBIDDEN FOODS
In the book Sheelot u Tshuvot Dibre Chayim (Yore Deah part A, siman 7) we read that in
Europe close to three and a half million Jews left the faith and clanged to foreign ideas and
beliefs, through the agency of evil shochatim and butchers that fed their communities terefot and
nevelot.
Who does not shudder upon reading this frightening account of how far laxity in observance of
the laws of kashruth can pull one down? How frightful it is to read that if one is not
conscientious in his observance of kashruth, he is vulnerable to the false doctrines of denial of
the Torah and the words of the Sages! How frightful it is to read the faithful testimony of the
Rambam and of the saintly disciples of the holy Baal Shem Tov! Unfortunately, now the breach
in the observance of kashruth has become much more widespread than in years gone by.
The nation of Amalek, descendants of Esav, bore a deeply ingrained hatred against the Jews.
They considered it their duty to take revenge for their forefather Esav on Yaakov's descendants.
As the very name "Amalek" denotes, they were thirsty for Jewish blood. (Amalek is a composite
of am la'k, the people that came to lick blood.) (Lekach Tov)
8 THE GATE OF KASHRUT
(As soon as the Bnai Yisrael left Egypt, the Amalekim suggested to the other nations, "Join us in
an attack against the Jews!" As a result, all the nations assembled while the Bnai Yisrael crossed
the Yam Suf. Hashem, however, rendered them all powerless, and they were unable to harm the
Bnai Yisrael. After witnessing the miracles of kerias Yam Suf, the rest of the nations trembled
and did not dare attack. Amalek then suggested to the other nations, "We Amalekim will attack
the Bnai Yisrael! Should they defeat us we will flee, but if we are victorious over them, then
come and join us in our battle."(Mechilta)
Amalek waited for an opportunity to attack, but Hashem protected Israel as long as they were
loyal to Him. Amalek had no power over them, except over sinful individuals. These were
expelled from the Camp by the Clouds of Glory, and were forced to travel outside the Clouds.
They were slain by Amalek. (Mechilta)
Hashem did not allow the Bnai Yisrael to annihilate Amalek since no nation can be destroyed
before its sar (spiritual image, minister) in Heaven has fallen first. Amalek's sar is Satan himself.
He will perish only when sin is no longer to be found in Yisrael. Every time a Jew sins, he adds
strength to the sar of Amalek. It is only when the Bnai Yisrael will be free from sin that Amalek
will be destroyed (Alshich).
REMEMBER THAT THE WORDS OF THE SAGES ARE VERY PRECISE WHEN
THEY SAY THE BEST BUTCHER IS A PARTNER OF AMALEK
Let it be made clear that people's thoughts and reasoning do not coincide with the thoughts and
reasoning of the Rabbis o.b.m. who enjoyed the presence of the Shechinah in their study hall,
and everything recorded in the Mishnah or in the Gemara is hallowed with all kinds of sanctity.
No one ever found fault with them except apostates and sectarians, who left the Jewish fold. See
how the Geonim and the Rishonim toiled to reconcile the presence of a single word and built
piles and piles of halachos upon it. Now, when they called the butcher "a partner of Amalek," the
Shechinah was actually speaking from their throats, and they were agents of the All-merciful,
and if we are human beings, they were veritable angels and seraphim, and all their words are like
fiery coals. Let no man be tempted to say that the Rabbis meant only the butcher but not the
shochet, because if you look at Rosh on Chullin p. 18, and in Maggid Mishneh, Laws of
Shechitah 1:26, you will see that the usual butcher in Talmudic times was also a shochet and an
inspector.
THE GATE OF KASHRUT 9
G-d forbid, by feeding them forbidden food in general and particularly through eating Chelev,
for eating Chelev warrants greater severe penalty than all other forbidden foods, it being of equal
stringency as eating Chametz on Passover and eating on Yom Kippur.
IT IS MORE SEVERE TO EAT FORBIDDEN FATS FROM
A KOSHER ANIMAL THAN TO EAT PORK
Everyone knows how much the Chafetz Chaim o.b.m. warned our brethren in his time,
when they were forced to wander to various places because of the terrible decrees of that
period. He warned them that if they have, G-d forbid, no choice but to eat pork and
animals that died without being properly slaughtered, they should, G-d forbid, not eat
meat from which the Chelev was not removed, but rather pork and animals that died
without being ritually slaughtered, whose prohibition is merely a negative commandment,
rather than, G-d forbid, to stumble upon the prohibition of Chelev, which is punishable by
Karet. Yet, in our times, the situation has reached such an alarming low that without a decree by
the government or any other coercion, they feed our brethren meat from which the Chelev is
either not removed at all or at best not properly removed and in their innocence, many innocent
G-d-fearing people are trapped in a terrible snare, whose results are so far-reaching, that it is
utterly unbelievable even catastrophic in many instances testifying to the terrible occurrences of
devastation we daily witness. Heaven have mercy.
THE JEWS WHO WERE METICULOUS ABOUT THEIR KASHRUT ARE THE ONES
WHO WERE ABLE TO KEEP THEIR FAITH AND TO OBSERVE THE TORAH
It is definite that nikkur of Chelev was always counted among the fields in which pitfalls were
common. This is because of the ignorance of menakkerim (those who purge the meats out of
forbidden fat) and the rabbis, as well as the slothfulness in doing the work with exactitude. Now
the children of Israel were tempted by paganism in every generation. It was those who passed
this test and also observed strictly the laws of prohibited food and drink, who merited leaving
pure and holy generations, from whom a chain or progeny blessed by G-d has emanated from
then until the present and from today until the coming of the righteous Mashiach.
EVERYONE MUST CHOOSE IF HE WANTS TO RISK
TRANSGRESSING THE PROHIBITION OF KARET
Now, the entire Jewish people hang in the balance. Every Jewish soul bears much weight.
Everyone can choose the path in which will bring him long blessed life with all the goodness in
this world in addition to the reward in store for the World to Come if he avoids a prohibition
listed among the most stringent, those punishable by Karet and those that clog the heart of the
THE GATE OF KASHRUT 13
souls of the great and the small, that separates the soul from its root, until it is entirely cut off
from the World to Come (as it stated in the holy Zohar quoted by Yesode Veshoresh Ha'avodah,
Gate 7). This is the prohibition of Chelev, punishable by Karet like Chametz on Pesach.
ARE YOU WILLING TO EXPOSE YOUR FAMILY TO
KARET BASED ON FALSE ASSURANCES
Now every G-d fearing person, who fears for his everlasting soul and for that of his
children dare not feel at rest by false assurances, for perhaps they are not true, or with any
other kinds of assurances, since thereby he is endangering his life and those of his children
for all time. Even eating Chelev inadvertently destroys from the soul to the flesh, surely to
behave in this manner all one's life. Especially this is true, when we see trouble increasing
daily, young people are being taken from the world and other troubles and sicknesses, which we
hesitate to print, take their toll on men, women, and children, much more than the usual.
Everyone wonders and asks, "What is this that G-d has done to us?"
WE DO NOT RESPOND TO THE INCREASING REPORTS
OF PROBLEMS WITH THE KASHRUT OF MEAT
Yet no one thinks that perhaps we have not paid enough attention to the growing reports that
increase daily, that the butcher shops are full of Chelev that is punishably by Karet! They turn
their backs to these reports as though they do not pertain to them in any way. They do not give
the matter any thought at all. In the manner they ignore the reports about Chelev, so are they
ignored by G-d in their time of need and distress. This is similar to what the Rabbis stated on the
verse: "And I separated you from the peoples to be Mine." If you are separated from prohibited
foods, you are Mine, and if not, you belong to Nebuchadnezzar and his like.
In conclusion of all the aforementioned, whose heart will not fear and whose hands will not
shake when he picks up a piece of animal flesh and puts it into his mouth without a definite
clarification that the Chelev has been removed properly? Indeed, even if the question would be
of a doubtful case of Chelev, it would still be highly advisable and intelligent to abstain
from eating such meat, for in the Torah we find the penalty of Karet for eating prohibited
foods in only four cases: 1) Eating Chametz on Pesach. 2) Eating on Yom Kippur. 3) Eating
Chelev, and 4) Eating blood. In the case of Chametz on Pesach and eating on Yom Kippur,
every simple Jew will quake in the fear of infracting these prohibitions, even if there is only
a slight chance, if there is a rumor that a food contains Chametz and so it is with Yom
14 THE GATE OF KASHRUT
Kippur. Why should the matter of Chelev be looked upon or felt to be of any lesser degree
than the other 3 cases mentioned?
A DOUBTFUL TRANSGRESSION REQUIRES MORE
REPENTANCE THAN AN INTENTIONAL ONE
Moreover, even if one ate something that was possibly Chelev, when the Temple existed, he
would be required to bring a guilt-offering to protect him from agonies until he found out
definitely what it was, as is delineated in the tractate Kerithus and in other places. Now how can
we allow ourselves to eat something for which one must bring a sacrifice along with other
dangerous circumstances. See Rabbenu Yonah's Commentary on the beginning of Berachos,
where he writes that a doubtful case of a sin requires more repentance than a definite
commitment of a sin, for a person regrets his sin more when he is certain that he has committed
in than when he does not know definitely. Therefore, a doubtful guilt-offering was to be more
extensive than a sin-offering. This is delineated in Kerisus 22, which see. ibid. See also Avot d
Rabbi Nathan, ch. 30: Rabbi Meir says: Whoever commits a doubtful sin is accounted as though
he has committed a definite sin: How so? If a person sins and his sin is known to him, he brings a
sin-offering for a sela (a coin), whereas if it is uncertain whether he sinned, he brings a doubtful
guilt-offering for two selaim (2 coins). It is indeed the decided halachah: (Rama, Orach Chaim
603): One needs to repent of a doubtful sin more than of a definite one. See further in books of
the poskim, where it is explained that, concerning atonement and repentance, one must fear even
a chance of less than half (Reponsa; Lev Aryeh on Chullin 11, Yismach Mosheh, parshas
Toledos, on the verse: "And Jacob approached," and in Responsa Avnei Zedek, Orach Chaim,
74). See also Mesillas Yesharim, that one must avoid a doubtful sin as one does actual poison.
See also Yoreh Deah, end of ch. 116, that a devout person would not eat of an animal upon
which a sage issued a decision, and it is understood that a case of doubtful Chelev upon which
sages issued a decision, which is prohibited by the Torah because of Chelev, even simple people
should not eat.
EVEN IF SOME FOODS ARE PERMITTED FOR CHILDREN
THEY NEVERTHELESS CLOG THE HEART
In conclusion, let us mention further what Pri Chadash writes in Yoreh Deah, ch. 81, that
something interdicted by the Torah, even if it can be permitted for small children, nevertheless
clogs the heart and brain, as we find a similar statement in Responsa Arugas Habosem
concerning a milk from a cow that eats Chametz on Pesach and in Ketzos Hashulchan, laws of
Shabbat, laws concerning the critically ill, in Baddei Hashulchan he quotes the Netziv, that, for
THE GATE OF KASHRUT 15
this reason, we slaughter for the critically ill, rather than feed him non-kosher meat that was
prepared from before Shabbat, (even though a critically ill person may eat it) it nevertheless,
clogs the heart and the brain. These facts are really awesome.
It is stated further in the same work that according to ARI zal, one should not eat the hind
quarters at all even if nikkur has been performed properly. In the United States they even sell the
hind quarters without informing the public. This can rightfully be termed the height of brutality.
It is indeed astonishing that everyone avoids matzah if there is the least doubt that it may
contain Chametz, even if it is kosher according to the Shulchan Aruch, whereas Chelev,
which is just as severe as Chametz, both of them being punishable by Karet and which
pertains all year round, not only on Pesach - when he hears any kind of excuse, he is happy
that he has an alibi to eat as much meat as his heart desires.
16 THE GATE OF KASHRUT
A Letter From Rabbi Shlomoh Greenberg of Niedderhaz Regarding the Status of Nikkur
(Purging the forbidden fats out of animals) in America
Although I would not allow any animal flesh to be brought into my home, I just couldnt
bear to see how people go in and out of butcher shops and buy all kinds of meats, including
salami, pastrami, frankfurters, etc. not knowing the damage that they are doing to their
souls and to the souls of their beloved children.
Peace and blessings to the honor of all my dear pupils and may the Al-mighty bless you. This
letter is directed toward the matter which I was asked many times about - in reference to meat -
about which many people have raised the question - that the forbidden fats (called Chelev) are
not properly removed. According to personal inspection this very week in the presence of highly
qualified specialists in the art of Chelev removal;
DUE TO OUR MANY SINS THE MEAT
WE EAT IS NOT KOSHER
It was clarified that unfortunately due to our great sins the meats which were bought in these past
few weeks from butcher stores renowned for the highest quality in Kashrus was not separated
from the forbidden fat properly. There remained upon the meat Chelev which is strictly
forbidden according to our Holy Torah. We found in the meat forbidden fat (Chelev) according
to our Torah including part from the hind quarters intact with its fat. This by no means a matter
dependent upon various customs or different opinions of Halachic authorities whatsoever.
I INVOKE YOU NOT TO EAT ANY MEAT
Hence it is unanimously forbidden according to the edicts of our Holy Torah beyond the
shadow of a doubt. Therefore, I sincerely appeal implore, beg and beseech you all to refrain
from consuming any more meat whatsoever until this deplorable situation becomes
completely and properly rectified with the help of the Al-Mighty according to all laws of
our Holy Torah. May the Al-mighty send us his blessings to be inscribed in the book of
good life amongst all of Israel with a year of redemption and salvation. For a verification I
hereby attest my signature.
On the 5th of NISSAN, 5762 we questioned the Kashauer Rebbe shlita on the following:
Has the situation today changed for the better, are we allowed to eat bovine meat, at least on
Yom Tov?
Can we rely today on the new slaughter houses that publicize the fact that they do everything
according to the strictest opinions of law LEMEHADRIN MIN MEHADRIN, can we eat their
meat?
UP UNTIL TODAY THINGS HAVENT CHANGED FOR THE BETTER
And this is what he answered: Due to our many sins the times havent changed for the better,
and he who guards his soul and the souls of his household that they dont stumble through
forbidden foods, and if he wants to continue being faithful to Hashem and His Torah, will
remove himself as far as possible from eating all bovine meat, no matter from where or
what slaughterhouse it comes from until the coming of our righteous Mashiach.
He also pointed out that Kashrut is one of the three things that caused the fall of Jewish belief
here in America as well as in the rest of the places as is brought in the Holy Zohar Shemini: He
who eats forbidden foods, joins himself to the SITRA ACHRA (forces of evil) and exiles his soul
and body, the spirit of TUMA (impurity) and he shows that he has no portion in the G-d of Israel.
THE GAON RAB ELIEZER SILBER ZTL WARNS AGAINST THE METHOD OF
SHECHITA TELUYA (THE ANIMAL IS MADE TO HANG IN THE AIR)
Published in the Monthly publication HAMAOR in TEVET 5719 (1960) The Gaon Rabbi
Eliezer Silber, av bet din of the city of Cincinnati writes the following letter to Rab Lipa
Deutsch, av bet din of the Holmetz Kehilla:
I will inform of the reasons and the arguments of those that waged wars against the grave
problems of the Shechita Teluya (the animal is made to hang in the air, thereby moving and
shaking with great force) This war was waged in many cities and many butcheries in the last
years and as it was already forbidden with strong arguments more than 50 years ago by the
RIDBAZ from Salutzk and Tzfat when he was here in Denver. And I also prohibited this method
of Shechita, after I saw how the gentiles that hold the head of the bulls and other animals that are
hanging, move the head at the time of the Shechita many times, and in particular when the
animal makes resistance and puts its head to the side, then the gentile with his hands presses the
head of the animal against the knife, and this is like him actually helping in the slaughter proper,
and as if the Jew and the gentile were slaughtering together. And the gentile brings the head of
the animal on the knife and the Shochet brings the knife on the neck of the animal. And many
times, the gentile actually presses the head of the animal against the knife. And this I saw so
many times that I prohibited this method of Shechita.
THE SATAN RULES IN THE SLAUGHTERHOUSES
And with the help of G-d, when I was in the slaughter houses as the supervisor, the shechita was
done by putting the animal on the ground on its back and this is how they were slaughtering up
until a few years in the large slaughterhouses in New York, Chicago, Boston. And only after the
older Rabbis passed away and the process of Shechita was given to the supervision of younger
men, they went back to the wrong ways without asking the older Rabbis and Talmide
Chachamim and I stand on my duty to warn you that theres doubts of nevelot in many of those
slaughterhouses.
FROM THE BOOK CHEN TOV, RAV AHARON TZVI FREEDMAN ZTL FORBIDS
THE METHOD OF SHECHITA TELUYA MORE THAN 130 YEARS AGO
After having worked as a shochet for over 30 years Rav Freedman declares that it is forbidden to
slaughter in this fashion (Shechita Teluya) and that he who slaughters thus feeds nevelot and
terefot to the Jews without a doubt and all those who fear Hashem will not dare eat any meat
because it is disqualified and surely contaminates and impurifies the soul.
THE GATE OF KASHRUT 21
Rav Freedman cites in the book that when the animal is hanging, as anything that hangs, has
more mobility making the slaughter much more difficult and it is known that if theres
movement at the time of the slaughter then it is not kosher. Also the movement of the animal
makes the Shochet be afraid lest the animal hurt him and not only that, but the gentiles that work
in the slaughterhouse are the ones holding the head of the animal against the knife, as the animal
moves violently and this without a doubt disqualifies the Shechita.
And so the Rav prohibited any slaughter from below toward above (as when the animal is
hanging) and all Shochatim should be refrained for doing this abomination, and anyone who can
help solve this situation and doesnt, will in the future have to give an accounting. Rav Freedman
said: Dont believe the Shochatim when they declare that their shechita is good, but it is evil in
the eyes of Hashem and they are great sinners those who say everything is fine.
SOMETHING THAT CAN BE DETERMINED BY THE PERSON (WHETHER THE
SHECHITA NOWADAYS IS GOOD OR NOT) AND IS NOT DETERMINED, DOESNT
FALL IN THE CATEGORY OF A DOUBTFUL THING ANYMORE (SHULCHAN
ARUCH, YOREH DEAH I, SIMAN 39) AND THE ONE WHO TRANSGRESSES IS
CONSIDERED A WILLFUL SINNER (MEZID) AND NOT A DOUBTFUL ONE
(SHOGEG)
This means, you have in your power to find out if the slaughterhouses really observe all the laws
as they should, but instead you choose to rely on the big kosher sign on the envelope surrounding
the meat, then you will be considered guilty of transgressing the prohibition of eating forbidden
foods on purpose, because it was in your power to find out and you didnt. And of course you
will make the effort to find out something for which a transgression warrants the punishment of
Karet (Excision, early death).
WHEN THERE IS A RUMOR (KOL RINUN), WHEN PEOPLE TALK ABOUT
SOMETHING CONSTANTLY, THEN IT IS FORBIDDEN TO EAT FROM THAT
PARTICULAR SHECHITA
This is brought in the Sheelot uTshuvot Divre Chayim and the Sheelot uTshuvot of the
Maharshag. In the Shulchan Aruch (Yoreh Deah, siman 21) we read further that it is forbidden to
disqualify a shochet unless we have the testimony of two witnesses on something that can
disqualify the shochet. But it is proper and it is a mitzvah for every Jew to worry about rumors
and the shochet about whom we hear the rumors should not be allowed a priori to slaughter.
22 THE GATE OF KASHRUT
IN RESPONSE TO INQUIRIES
With the help of G-d, who purifies us and sanctifies us through the sanctification of food, we
have been asked by G-d-fearing people for more than two years whether our ritual slaughter
department could also provide white veal.
We referred the matter to the rabbis of our community, and after examining the issue in depth
and in detail, they have determined that:
There are many questions about the way the white calves are fattened and raised, and many
questions about the possibility that the animals are rendered unfit for kosher ritual slaughter
because of problems in the lungs and other internal organs.
Therefore,
We are refraining from accepting White Veal in the ritual slaughter
department of Congregation Machzikei Hadas DChasidei Belz.
The Torah warned about both prohibited and permitted foods in the verses regarding
sanctification of the Jewish People and regarding not defiling ones soul. The holy book, The
Zohar, comments on this issue, stating that non-kosher food prohibited by the Torah carries
impure spiritual forces, and therefore anyone eating such food defiles his soul, and acts as if he
has no connection to things holy or to G-d himself. This is because the impure food becomes part
of the persons body and soul when he eats it, and it dwells in him, etc. A person should not eat
24 THE GATE OF KASHRUT
anything about which there is controversy per the verse that states that a person should not
follow the masses, because this involves an issue of Jewish law.
Whereas all Orthodox butchers sell meat known as white veal (black and white), we would like
to inform the public that many years ago the esteemed Rabbi Moshe Feinstein of New York
prohibited veal meat because of the following extremely serious problems:
1. These animals are grazed with non-kosher animals.
2. There are serious problems regarding the Jewish legal status of their lungs.
3. There are serious questions regarding their internal organs.
4. Only 10-15% of such animals slaughtered are deemed kosher by virtue of the status of their
lungs.
It is difficult to understand why all organizations involved in kashruth, even the finest among
them, have not considered it important to inform the public about the dangerous choice facing
Orthodox families on a daily basis.
N.B. We would like to make known that for the last ten years, ever since he learned of the
problem, Rabbi Avraham Kleinman, the head of the rabbinical court of the Margareten
community, has prohibited the slaughter of veal in his ritual slaughter department.
There are many questions about the way the white calves are fattened and raised, and many
questions about the possibility that the animals are rendered unfit for kosher ritual slaughter
because of problems in the lungs and other internal organs.
Note: The meat of these animals is sold in all kosher butcher stores in Boro Park, Williamsburg
and Monsey, and everyone eats the veal.
THE GATE OF KASHRUT 25
.With regard to calf slaughter that has recommenced recently, the animals are
fattened with very rich liquids that are not intended for animals, which is in
opposition to what is stated in the Talmud, tractate Bechoros, p. 39. In addition,
this makes the animals ill, causing them to need all types of medication. Highly-
skilled ritual slaughterers have themselves only deemed some 16% of the animals
as kosher. In general, most are thus not kosher. Although it appears that this is
because of problems in the lungs of the animals examined by slaughterers
according to laws pertaining to the lungs, it is also possible that animals are
considered unkosher by virtue of their internal organs, which must also be checked
because this is a very serious issue. Therefore, it is appropriate that this should be
forbidden, and G-d-fearing persons should not eat this type of veal even if their
internal organs are checked. Without examining the internal organs, these animals
may not be deemed kosher at all. An examination of the imperforated internal
organs, and of blisters that are perforated, and only a cursory examination of the
internal organs and the blisters caused by weak organs, without an examination of
the internal organs, may not be deemed kosher.
signed
RABBI MOSHE FEINSTEIN
26 THE GATE OF KASHRUT
UNTIL WHEN?
A PAINFUL CRY BY THE GAON AND
TZADDIK RABBI SHRAGA FEIVEL
MENDELOWITZ, O.B.M.
9 Then I said, I will not make mention of him, nor speak any more in his name. But his word was
in my heart like a burning fire shut up in my bones, and I was weary with restraining myself, and
I could not.
10 For I heard the calumny of many, fear on every side. Denounce him, we will denounce him,
say my close friends as they watch for my stumbling. Perhaps he will be persuaded, and we shall
prevail against him, and we shall take our revenge on him. 11 But the Lord is with me like a
mighty awesome one; therefore my persecutors shall stumble, and they shall not prevail; they
shall be greatly ashamed; for they shall not succeed; their everlasting confusion shall never be
forgotten. 12 But, O Lord of hosts, who tests the righteous, and sees the inwards and the heart,
let me see your vengeance on them; for to you have I opened my cause. (Jeremiah 20:9-12).
I accuse many rabbis who grant hechsherim, to whose attention many Jews have brought this
problem, that Trefot are being sold under their hashgachah, yet they have kept this matter quiet
and permitted the butchers to continue to sell Trefot to their hearts' content.
however, with a little effort, order could be brought into this chaos, and "if one can be good, why
should he be bad?"
Don't you see what has become of your youth? Don't you know that Jewish children have
become tramps, gamblers, gangsters, candidates for the electric chair, and all kinds of "ist"s only
because they have been raised on Nevelot and Trefot, yet you sleep. But for how much longer?
THE GATE OF KASHRUT 29
I know that you will reply that "Jacob is small and poor", but look what Jacob's brother on East
Broadway has accomplished, how he erected a fortress through the poor laborers, a fortress
against Judaism, because he has united forces. Yet you sleep and do nothing. But how much
longer?
OUR FATHERS DIED FOR KIDDUSH HA SHEM
AND YET HOW DO WE BEHAVE?
Gentlemen! Do a little soul searching and see how far you have strayed; remember that our
parents have sacrificed their lives for kiddush Hashem; they allowed themselves to be burned
and roasted in order to uphold our holy Torah, whereas you are not required to make any
sacrifice; with but a handful you can save the situation. Yet you sleep. But how much longer?
similar things expressed by the Toldos Yaakov Joseph, (Parshas Noso) and also by the Vilna
Gaon (Maasay Rav 90) who writes that it is preferable to eat dairy food on Shabbat, rather
than eating from a cow which was slaughtered by a Shochet who was not supervised by
anyone during the Shechita.
JEWS IN GERMANY BECAME HERETIC
THROUGH EATING FORBIDDEN FOODS
The "Divre Chayim" (Yoreh Deah 1, 7) mentions that he has seen many G-d-fearing men and
Torah scholars who had become Shochatim and then deviated from the path of righteousness. He
adds that because of Shochatim who were not conscientious, many communities in Germany
gave up their orthodoxy, may G-d protect us. From all this we see that if people are not very
careful with respect to the Shechita and are not G-d fearing, they will cause great damage.
All forbidden foods possess your nourishment and are harmful to the body. (Guide to the
Perplexed section 3 chapter 43.) All forbidden foods axe injurious to the body. (Ibn Ezra
Leviticus 11: 43) For it is known that the consumed body becomes the body of the consumer.
YZB=501=35=JAHFJ +466=PFSOZ
YZB=501=BHAB+ZDS+KWD
YZB=502=BY BYS HL
YZB=501=YZA---,EZSQ YZA ML [A SDJ JLDYOF
XJXJ+XZ=425=EZSQ
639=[SDE VS,637=XJXJ [AYJ,YZB NFW=638=[FBAE [FOZ
660 = [YL BMH , 661=Y[RA
1146=PIZE+XMOS+YZB BMH,1146=NMJO 2+1144=Y[RA [MJCO
931=PIZ+XMOS+EIJHZ ,932=SYF BFI [SDE VS
HJZO =358=XJXJ+EIJHZ,687=XJXJ+Y[RA, 687=YUAF XZ
MASOZJ NDA AYU=YUA,NFDA DCQ 400=XZ
HRU=148=(JMS) FOFWF
1130=NMJO 2+[FJ[A 6+ [YL YZB=1130=NJOJ [ZMZ
336=MLAOE+XMOS,336=NJYFU
337=[FJ[A 5+EIJHZ ,337=MMFL+NJYFU
335=POE+XMOS,336=NJYFU
[FJ[A 6+[JZAYB=919=YZB+NJYFULE NFJ
PIZ+YZB=861=EQZE ZAY
PIZ YD =ISO ZDXO=563=XMOS+IHFZ
359=PIZ , 358=ZHQ
954=NMJO 2+952=ZQFSF YLZ,954=474=BY BYS+480=AYHA AYIR
(TEHILIM 119:70) J[SZSZ K[YF[ JQA ,NBM BMHL ZUI
389= NMJO 2+387=EUYIF+EMBQ 389=ZUI
YZB=YAZ=ERJSBZ YAZ
34 THE GATE OF KASHRUT
the words,'his soul and himself.' Therefore, one should be strict in matters of food, making sure
there is no possible chance of any forbidden foods.
A G-D FEARING SHOCHET IS THE ONE WHO CARES FOR HIS SOUL AND FOR
THE SOULS OF FELLOW JEWS AND NOT FOR HIS MATERIAL WELFARE
Rabbenu Yonah writes in Shaarei Teshuvah, quoted by Beth Joseph (Tur Yoreh Deah, end of ch.
18): And it will be pleasant for those who admonish, who warn the people that they should be
conscientious in their observance of the laws of shechitah in every detail, and that they should
choose a G-d fearing shochet, for many Jews depend on him for their observance of the precepts
of shechitah and bedikah, etc, and many of the experts are from possessing fear of sin, and
whoever does not fear, will not be particular in the examination of the slaughtering knife etc, in
addition to the fact that a person devoid of fear will not be careful with examining the trachea
and the gullet after the shechitah, in addition to other necessities and details (Rabbenu Yonah).
36 THE GATE OF KASHRUT
An awesome and wonderful story told by the Chasid, Reb Israel of Kalisch.
The Grand Rabbi Chaim of Kossov was the treasurer of the charities of the Holy Land. He had
many collectors, who would make the rounds of the cities and villages to collect money. Among
the collectors was a chosid named Reb Shraga of Seniatin, who would travel from place to place
to empty out the canisters of Rabbi Meir Baal Haness. Once, Reb Shraga went on his travels; he
came to the city of Serit, where he lodged. He arose early, prayed at dawn as was his wont, and
then commenced to go from house to house to perform his assigned task faithfully. After he
completed his work at noontime, he decided to leave the city and to arrive at the neighboring
village toward evening. There he would make his collections and stay for the night. In the
morning he would resume his travels. So he did. But, just as soon as he left the city, the
THE GATE OF KASHRUT 37
coachman went off the road and began to stray. Night approached. It became darker and darker,
and they had no idea where they were. They were traveling for six hours without a stop, and still
the coachman had no idea where to go. They were very frightened.
A LARGE HOUSE IN THE MIDDLE OF THE FOREST
As they were traveling, they raised their eyes and saw a candle in a window some distance away.
They went toward the light of the candle until they came to a large house, the likes of which they
had never seen. The coachman looked around and remarked, "There is really a house in this spot,
yet I know nothing about it. I have been traveling around here all my life, and I am familiar with
all the roads and paths, all the houses and the inns in this section, but I have never before seen
this house." They alighted from the wagon and entered the house. They met the servants of the
house who were dressed in German garments, contrary to the custom of the locale. As soon as
they set foot in the house, one of the servants asked them, "Do you want to stay here?" They both
replied, "Yes," because it was very windy and rainy outside, and it was impossible to continue on
their journey.
TWO NOBLEWOMEN AND A JEW DRINKING WINE
AND HOW THE WOMEN MISTREAT HIM
When the servant heard their reply, he showed them a room on the side and told them to go in.
They went into the room where they saw a hot stove, and a table with a lit candle on it. Amidst
trepidation, they sat down at the table to rest from the fatigue of their trip, While they were
sitting there, the door suddenly opened, and two noblewomen, accompanied by a Jew wearing a
spodik, entered the room and sat down at the table. They called, "Servant, bring us three glasses
of wine." The servant went out and brought the wine. The two noblewomen drank, and the Jew
sat beside them but did not join them. They asked him, "Why aren't you drinking?" He replied,
"We may not drink gentile wine." They retorted, "Why did you drink it then?" The Jew remained
silent. When the noblewomen saw that he had no answer, they slapped him in the face on both
cheeks. Then they rose, and all three of them left the room.
THE CHASSID AND HIS COACHMAN TREMBLE WITH FEAR
When they left, Reb Shraga and the coachman quaked with fear. They did not know what to do,
whether to leave the room or to remain. After pondering the matter for a few moments, Reb
Shraga said to the coachman, "Let's not move from here, but let's sit together and hold each
other's hands until the fury passes over." A half hour later, the noblewomen returned with the
Jew, sat down by the table, and ordered the servant to bring wine as they had done before. The
servant placed three glasses of wine before them on the table. They poured the wine down their
38 THE GATE OF KASHRUT
throats, but the Jew did not touch his. When they asked him why he had drunk then, he did not
reply. Again, they slapped him in the face and went out with him. Reb Shraga sat in his place and
held the coachman's hands. He saw everything, but he was too frightened to talk.
THE JEW BEING PUNISHED BEGS FOR MERCY
He wanted to recite, "Shma Yisrael," but no sound would come out of his mouth. When the trio
entered the room for the third time and stated that he hit the Jew because he did not want to drink
with them, the Jew turned to Reb Shraga and said, "Reb Shraga! Why don't you say anything?
Don't you know who I am? I am...They do this to me every day I beg you to mention me to the
Grand Rabbi, Reb Chaim of Kossov." When they left for the third time, the rooster's crow was
heard, and everything disappeared; there was no house, no stove, and no candle. They were
standing in the field. At dawn, they praised and thanked the L-rd, Who had stood at their right
hand and saved them from the demons.
THIS JEW PREFERRED MONEY THAN OBSERVING G-DS COMMANDMENTS
On that same day, Reb Shraga returned from his travels and went to Kossov. Upon entering the
city, he went immediately to the tzaddik, Reb Chaim, and related to him the entire incident that
befell him on the road that night, mentioning the name of the deceased, an honest and pious Jew.
The rabbi listened to his tale and then replied, "True, that Jew was a pious man, but once in his
youth he stumbled on the sin of drinking gentile wine. This is the story. This Jew was an
innocent person, keeping G-d's commandments stringently in all details. He earned a livelihood
from brokerage. He would frequent the houses of the nobles and bring merchants to buy their
grain and forests. For this trouble, he was paid handsomely. Once they owed him a sizable sum
for brokerage, and he came to their house to collect his money, because he needed it urgently to
marry off his daughter. The nobles steadfastly refused to pay him until he would drink a glass of
wine with them. The Jew, thinking that they meant to tease him, as they were accustomed to
doing, refused to comply with their wishes. When he saw, however, that they were serious, and
that they would indeed not pay him unless he drank with them, his temptation told him that
drinking gentile wine was but a minor infraction of the law. He obeyed his temptation and drank
a glass of wine with them.
EVEN THOUGH HIS INTENTIONS WERE NOT EVIL
HE WAS SEVERELY PUNISHED
Even then, he did not do so with evil intentions, but for the sake of making his daughter's
wedding. Nevertheless, the Heavenly Tribunal passed this sentence upon him, as you saw at
midnight when you were on the road. But, to make you feel better, let me tell you that this was
THE GATE OF KASHRUT 39
the last day of his tribulations, and he has already rectified his sin. From that night on, his soul is
bound in the bundle of life."
After finishing his narrative, the tzaddik signed and said, "From all this we learn a lesson, how
much a person must watch himself not to stumble on anything the holy Torah prescribed, even if
we have good intentions for the sake of Heaven, and may G-d save us from all harm. Amen, so
may it be His will. (Sefer Even Shethiah p. 53)
salamis and pastramis, was established in this lower East Side and was owned and operated by
one of the most religious and observant Jews of the community.
Suddenly, one night the police made a startling discovery. Two large trailers were discovered
unloading horse and camel meat into the butcher store of this religious Jew. New York in the
1930's was extremely strict about their meat and the punishment very harsh. An investigation
was launched and revealed that this practice of taking in horse and camel meat had been going
on for quite a few years. The entire Jewish community of New York was in an uproar. Talk of
this dastardly act did not cease in the synagogues, mikvahs, stores - whenever two Jews met!
Even young children in yeshiva spoke with emotions of this cruel and inhuman swindle.
The children detested the thought that they had been fed non-kosher meat without their
knowledge when their Rebbes had taught them that it is forbidden to use them. Words cannot
describe the intense feelings of betrayal and treason felt by the Jewish community. In
frustration, one Jew had exclaimed in the synagogue: "We should catch that scoundrel and kill
him." "This, of course, is not the Jewish way," said a second Jew. "it is better to bring him into
the synagogue, let each Jew take a turn and hit him with all his strength, and then spit in his
face." Another declared that not only is the owner at fault, but the workers, mashgichim, and the
Rabbis who give the certification of Kashrut are equally guilty for allowing such a condition to
THE GATE OF KASHRUT 41
develop. The owner (who had gone into hiding) was apprehended by the police, brought up on
charges and sentenced to a prison term. He passed away in his cell, not long after. This story
was reprinted in all local newspapers, and further commentary is unnecessary.
The person may ask: "What can I do if all I bring into my home are foods with a Kosher
certification? Here, in the words of the Satmar Rebbe z.t.l. is the answer to this
question:
"It is heartbreaking to see how here, in America, everything is a business. The
main thing among businessmen is to turn out the highest profit possible and
disregard kashrut in the process. This is evident from the hashgachot as well,
since many rabbonim give their hechsheirim to products where the pitfalls are
numerous. This catastrophe came about since the entire process of kashrut and
hechsheirim have also become a business. Therefore, the reliability of the Rav
Hamachshir is automatically in question.