Holden Caulfield Case Study Report
Holden Caulfield Case Study Report
Holden Caulfield Case Study Report
Jocelyn Gonzalez
Dr. Smith
Period 2- English 11
30 May 2017
Gonzalez2
Holden Caulfield, a 16 year old male with personal struggles indicates he has clinical
depression. He seems to demonstrate bad habits such as smoking and drinking quite frequently,
using inappropriate language, lack of sleep, as well frequent mention of his suicidal thoughts. It
is apparent that Mr. Caulfield has not received adequate diagnoses therefore, has been analyzed
quite thoroughly. Through a thorough examination it has been discovered that the major impacts
in why he has developed clinical depression are: his low self esteem, the death of his brother
Allie Caulfield, and his parents unawareness to the support Mr. Caulfield needs. It is quite
transparent that he has a low self esteem in the way he considers himself to be the dumb one in
the family which has therefore, resulted to his dismissal at Pencey Prep, the private school in
which he was attending. As well at the age of 13, Mr. Caulfield experienced the death of his
younger brother Allie, who he cared for dearly. As a result to the death, Mr. Caulfield’s parents
have not allowed him to grieve properly and instead sent him away to different school, therefore
not helping Mr. Caulfield mental health. Therefore, as a nurse, the focus will be mainly on his
self esteem, coping with the loss of his brother, and gain a greater connection towards his
parents.
Pathophysiology
The symptoms of clinical depression, according to WebMD, include fatigue, low self
esteem, unable to stay focused, insomnia, disinterest in everyday activities, and frequent thoughts
of suicide, however these symptoms are not limited to. It usual to be diagnosed of clinical
depression when these symptoms occur every single day for 2 weeks straight. The major trigger
for clinical depression are loss of a love one possibly through a death, feeling of loneliness,
Gonzalez3
conspicuous that Mr. Caulfield trigger stems from his brother’s death in which can appear
dramatic in the sense Mr. Caulfield was only 13 years old and his younger brother dies of
leukemia which quite possibly is the start of harmful action such as breaking many windows
History
Holden Caulfield, a 16 year old male, has recently been diagnosed with clinical
depression due to the many comments of depression and death. As well, through his action
which are deemed dangerous such as heavy smoking and drinking that can affect his body
negatively. These are not the only actions in which demonstrate his depression it can be seen
frequently, such as the insomnia he experienced therefore results to his bad habits of alcohol
abuse. Another example includes: crying without a conscious reason, isolation toward people due
to their “phoniness,” poor academic habits such as Mr. Caulfield frequent dismissal of schools,
Mr. Caulfield is described to have a low self esteem which is noticeable when he either
compares his intelligence to his siblings or fulminate about Stradlater’s own looks which results
to having negative feelings towards him. “Like Stradlater. All these handsome guys are the same.
When they’re done combing their goddam hair, they beat it on you. When I finally got down off
the radiator and went out to the hat-check room, I was crying and all. I don’t know why, but I
was. I guess it was because I was feeling do damned depressed and lonesome” (Salinger 153).
Gonzalez4
Mr. Caulfield does not state the reason for his depression however, with the previous mention of
Stradlater it is evident that he is comparing attractive male youths to himself resulting to bringing
himself down. The results of low self esteem eventually made cry and made him feel lonesome
in the way he is not able to receive reassurance from others. The negative impact of the situation
results for Mr. Caulfield disliking others who he feels perceive themselves to be better therefore
he grows a hatred toward his own perception of them and does not realize in reality he does not
need to be comparing himself to others for he has his own good qualities, however with no push
was ever taken for him to follow the path of self-love he therefore feels lonesome.
The greatest stem of Mr. Caulfield depression come from the death of his younger
brother, Allie. “I was only thirteen, and they were going to have me psychoanalyzed and all,
because I broke all the window in the garage” (Salinger 39). After he had discovered the death of
Allie, Mr. Caulfield could not cope with the loss therefore, instead of talking to someone about
how he felt he became destructive. It is quite possibly that this is Mr. Caulfield first uproar from
known incidents. This portrays the dangers in which Mr. Caulfield can pose to himself as well as
others in the sense of not being able to control his emotions therefore resulting the physical
violence.
Though it is Allie’s death in which began the start for Mr. Caulfield depression the
greatest impact in which grew toward the loss he felt from the tragic event was the support that
his parent did not help provide for him when he needed it the most. “Boy, I felt miserable. I felt
so depressed, you can’t imagine. What I did, I started talking, sort of out loud, to Allie” (Salinger
98). Due to the loneliness Mr. Caulfield experience through dealing with the loss of his brother
his parents did not demonstrate a method of support for him. Instead of helping the 13 year old
Gonzalez5
child at the time, his parents would send him away therefore, make him feel as though he could
not share his pain with others. Which advanced his depression therefore affecting his mental,
physical and emotional state. Such can be seen when he is sometimes seen talking to Allie
outloud for he feels as though there is not one to talk to when he is feeling lonesome and
depressed.
The goal set for Mr. Caulfield is to have him address his major problem which is heal
from the death of his brother, Allie. According to Teens Health, the most effective ways of
healing through a death of a loved one is: let your emotions be expressed and released, talk about
it when you can, preserve memories, and join a support group. Therefore these are the essential
means for Mr. Caulfield to overcome the barrier of his depression and move forward for his
future and not to fall into the abyss of feeling lonely and helpless. The greatest change that is
expected for Mr. Caulfield is to bring light to his feelings and not hold them back for they must
be heard by expressing himself to others will he be able to lift the weight that he may be feel on
his chest.
Nursing Interventions
It is decided that he will be going through therapy every three times a week. The first two
session will include cognitive behavioral therapy and interpersonal therapy as for the third
therapy session it will be a family therapy. Through the family therapy, “parents are taught to
identify the symptoms, how to approach a depressed child, how to help him, information about
mood disorders, interpersonal skills, stress reduction, medication and medication side effects.
The effect of various stressor in a child's life is also examined in the context of different
Gonzalez6
environments such as school, home, community” (Sokolova 1). As a result to the family therapy,
Mr. Caulfield’s parents will gain a greater understanding on their son and his feeling which help
bring together the bond they had prior to the death of Allie.
Evaluation
After the meaningful session Mr. Caulfield had gone through there are few changes that
are seen. Though Mr. Caulfield experiences moments in which he feels like giving up, the great
support group has helped lead him to the bright side of things. The great change that is seen is his
the ability of being able to acknowledge that is not alone and by making that great breakthrough
in the last few months of therapy. By realizing he is not alone he has been able to open up to the
therapist as well a bit to his parents and peers. Though at times it appears instead of opening up
he backtracks and begins to show signs of initial symptoms of his clinical depression it is not
permanent and always overcomes them as a result, it is noticeable that he is gaining a positive
Recommendations
Holden Caulfield is clearly suffering from clinical depression, grieving the loss of his
brother and needs some direction in healing by following the right path by doing so will help
improve his health. Psychotherapies the National Institute of Mental Health are best suitable for
adolescent, “include ‘cognitive behavioral therapy,’ which helps people learn new ways of
thinking and behaving, and ‘interpersonal therapy,’ which helps people understand and work
through troubled personal relationships.” As well family therapy will be continued to further
improve his relationship with his parents therefore improve his mental health. Through this Mr.
Caulfield will be able to cope with the loss of his brother for his life to be able to surpass through
Gonzalez7
this traumatic event in his life. As well it is recommend Mr. Caulfield does an internship as a
student aid for he seems to turn to teachers quite frequently and by doing so it well help him
develop a positive relationship as well help push forward his career purpose of similar to being a
protector he will feel more at ease with his life and motivated in school. If he is motivated it will
be easier for him to make positive relationships and fit into social situations.
Gonzalez8
Works Cited
“Antidepressant Medications for Children and Adolescents: Information for Parents and
Salinger, J.D. The Catcher in the Rye. New York Boston London: Little, Brown and Company,
Sokolova, Irina. “Depression in Children: What Causes It and How We Can Help.” Rochester