IEEE InterconnectionStandards2004
IEEE InterconnectionStandards2004
IEEE InterconnectionStandards2004
Tom Basso
Secretary: IEEE SCC21, Std 1547, P1547.2 & P1547.3 & P1547.4;
IEC TC8 US Technical Advisory Group;
NREL Distribution and Interconnection R & D
Distributed Energy and Electric Reliability Program
National Renewable Energy Laboratory
Golden, Colorado
1
Outline
2
Summary Remarks
• Standards Are Being Developed and Validated In a
Timely, Ongoing and Cohesive Manner.
• Standards Are Promoting Advanced Technology
Development That Is Successfully Incorporating Next
Generation Standardized Functionalities.
• Standardization Is Enhancing Systems Integration of
Sound Distributed Energy Resources With The Grid That
Are Contributing To Modernizing Our Electric Infrastructure.
3
Transmission and
Distribution System
Bulk Power
Substations
Distribution
Systems
Transmission System
sensors
Load
Communications – Information Flow, Data Management, Management
Monitor & Control
Interconnection
Combined Heat
Distributed
& Power
Generation
4
sensors
What is a DER ?
5
DER Technology Portfolio
Examples
Photovoltaics
Thermally Activated Microturbines
Wind Technologies 6
DER Grid Interconnection
9
IEEE Standards Coordinating Committee 21
(SCC21) ‘Fuel Cells, Photovoltaics, Dispersed
Generation, and Energy Storage’
Oversees the development of standards in the areas of
Fuel Cells, Photovoltaics, Dispersed Generation, and
Energy Storage, and coordinates efforts in these fields
among the various IEEE Societies and other affected
organizations to ensure that all standards are
consistent and properly reflect the views of all
applicable disciplines.
IEEE SCC21reviews all proposed IEEE standards in
these fields before their submission to the IEEE-SA
Standards Board for approval and coordinates
submission to other organizations.
10
IEEE SCC21 Approach
• National consensus standards established via industry driven
partnerships under IEEE SCC21; SCC21 also provides liaison
activities.
• Harmonization of national and international standards, codes,
and certification/laboratory accreditation
- International Electro-technical Commission (IEC) dual logo
arrangement for IEC to adopt IEEE standards for electronics,
telecom, and power generation.
- IEC Technical Committee 8 (electrical systems) scope and
purpose was reformulated spring 2003.
11
IEC TC8 System Aspects for Electrical Energy Supply
(International Electro-technical Commission Technical Committee 8)
TC8 Scope – To prepare the necessary standards framework and co-ordinate the
development, in co-operation with other TC/SCs, of the international standards
needed to facilitate the functioning of electricity supply systems in open markets.
(former scope – standardize voltages, current ratings, and frequencies).
12
American National Standard
ANSI/IEEE 1547 Std
Systems
IEEE 1547 Interconnection Projects
Title Scope and Purpose
P1547.4 Draft • This document provides alternative approaches and good
Guide for Design, practices for the design, operation, and integration of
Operation, and distributed resource (DR) island systems with electric power
Integration of systems (EPS). This includes the ability to separate from
Distributed and reconnect to part of the area EPS while providing power
Resource Island to the islanded local EPSs. This guide includes the
Systems with distributed resources, interconnection systems, and
Electric Power participating electric power systems.
Systems • This guide is intended to be used by EPS designers,
operators, system integrators, and equipment
manufacturers. The document is intended to provide an
introduction, overview and address engineering concerns of
DR island systems. It is relevant to the design, operation,
and integration of DR island systems. Implementation of this
guide will expand the benefits of using DR by targeting
improved electric power system reliability and build upon the
interconnection requirements of IEEE 1547.
17
Std 1547: Interconnection Is The Focus
Area
Distributed Interconnection Electric
Resource Power
(DR) System System
unit (EPS)
Figure 1. Definition of the installation and its content. (P1547.1 Draft 4 4/04) 19
P1547.2 Draft Development
IEEE P1547.2 application guide to 1547 is being developed; “guide” offers
alternate approaches – e.g., practical applications guidance, tips,
techniques and rules of thumb for applying IEEE 1547 to specific
interconnection situations on specific utility distribution feeders. Industry
identified this as critically important practical companion to 1547.
Example of an alternate
approach to 1547 requirements.
20
P1547.3 Draft Development
P1547.3 guide to information exchange, monitoring and control for DR is being
developed; “guide” offers alternate approaches – e.g., power industry
communications guidance for specific cases of DR interconnection situations.
DR Aggregator DR Operator
Point of Load
Connection
Point of DR
Connection … DR
DR
Unit DR Building
Unit Controller Load
DR EMS
Unit
Matter of Packaging
INTRODUCTION
1.0 OVERVIEW
1.1 Scope
1.2 Purpose – Uniform standard
requirements
1.3 Limitations – 10 MVA or less
2.0 REFERENCES
3.0 DEFINITIONS
24
• A Technical Standard –
Functional Requirements For
• the interconnection itself
IEEE 1547 • the interconnection test
• a design handbook
• an application guide
IEEE 1547 • an interconnection
agreement
Is NOT: • prescriptive, e.g., does not
address DR self-protection, nor
planning, designing, operating,
or maintaining the Area EPS. 25
IEEE 1547 Interconnection
26
IEEE 1547 Interconnection
27
IEEE 1547 Interconnection Definitions
• Distributed generator (DG) –electric generation facilities connected to an
Area EPS through a PCC; a subset of DR.
• Distributed resources (DR) – sources of electric power that are not directly
connected to a bulk power transmission system. DR includes both
generator and energy storage technologies.
• Electric power system (EPS) – facilities that deliver power to a load.
• Area EPS – an EPS that serves local EPSs.
• Local EPS – an EPS entirely within a single premises or a group of
premises.
• Interconnection – the result of the process of adding a DR unit to an area
EPS
• Interconnection equipment – individual or multiple devices used in an
interconnection system
• Interconnection system – the collection of all interconnection equipment,
taken as a group, used to interconnect a DR unit(s) to an area EPS
• Point of common coupling (PCC) – the point where a local EPS is
connected to the Area EPS.
• Pont of DR connection – the point where a DR unit is electrically
connected in an EPS. 28
1547 Interconnection Terms
Area Electric Power System (EPS)
Point of Common
PCC PCC
Coupling (PCC)
Point of DR
Connection Point of DR
Connection
Area
Distributed Interconnection Electric
Resource Power
(DR) System System
unit (EPS)
30
4.0 INTERCONNECTION TECHNICAL
SPECIFICATIONS AND REQUIREMENTS
4.1 General Requirements
– Voltage Regulation – Inadvertent Energizing
– Integration with Area of the Area EPS
EPS Grounding – Monitoring Provisions
– Synchronization – Isolation Device
– DR on Secondary Grid – Interconnect Integrity
and Spot Networks
31
4.0 Interconnection Technical Specifications and Requirements (cont’d)
32
4.0 Interconnection Technical Specifications and Requirements (concluded)
4.4 Islanding
– Unintentional Islanding
– Intentional Islanding
33
5.0 INTERCONNECTION TEST
SPECIFICATIONS AND REQUIREMENTS
34
5.0 INTERCONNECTION TEST SPECIFICATIONS AND REQUIREMENTS
(cont’d)
Annex A. Bibliography
36
Application of 1547 (e.g, P1547.2)
• “Prime mover” traditionally performs fuel/primary-input
energy conversion, e.g., recip engine, fuel cell, PV panel
Prime mover characteristics have had limited interaction
effects on utility grid; they drive the electric generators:
(synchronous, induction, or inverter–based).
• DG-grid interface is via “power conversion” devices and,
relaying and switching protective devices/schemes.
Power conversion characteristics largely contribute to DG-
grid interaction effects; relaying, switching and protection
devices/schemes largely contribute to DG-grid
coordination/operation interactions,
• Equipment technologies/approaches often combine above
differentiations of technical functionalities.
Std 1547 functional technical requirements remain valid.
37
E.g., Interconnection System Functional Block Diagram
AC Loads DC Loads
Interconnection System
Power
(within dot-dash lines) Distribution
on
m
m
in Co
er
et
DER
pl of
Transfer
M
g
DER Local EPS
ou t
(prime
C oin
Power Switch or
P
movers, Electric Protective
energy Conversion Paralleling
Generator Relaying
storage)) Switchgear
Area EPS
Protective
DER
DER Dispatch Relaying
monitoring/
control metering and control
Area EPS
Power Flow Power
Communications System
(grid)
The interconnection system (within the dotted line) is designed to handle the power between
and serve as the communication and control gateway among the DER, the Area EPS and the
customer loads. Workshops with industry provided a forum for furthering this activity and
several manufacturers are working on developing and validating standardized, advanced,
universal interconnection technologies [NREL/SR-560-32459].
38
Synchronous Machines
• Synchronous DG similar to large utility generation
• Runs at a constant speed in synch with grid
• Subject to dynamic angle swings following
disturbances
– Can go unstable, pull out of synch for long fault
or weak system connection
• Provides substantial short-circuit current
contribution e.g., 5x - 6x rating
MOTOR POWER
POWER
IN
0
TYPICAL INDUCTION POWER
GENERATOR OUT
OPERATING POINT GENERATOR
SPEED
40
System Commutated Inverter
C
+
DC A
B A
Source C
-
B
+
DC 1-ph ac
Source
• 1-ph or 3-ph
• Can operate isolated
• Can produce or consume reactive power
• Lower total harmonic distortion
– at higher frequency, easier to filter
– distortion depends on design 42
Comparison of “Converters”
43
Application of 1547: DR-Grid Interconnection
44
Distribution Protection/Coordination
• No “Absolute” Solutions
45
Nuisance Fuse Operations
DG
• Increased fault current blows
fuse before breaker opens
• current continues after
breaker opens
46
DG & System Protection
47
Recloser and Line Fuse Located
Down-line from DG
IUS IR
F1
S
DG IDG
IF = 1470 A
Without DG: IF = IUS = IR X
IF = 1825 A
With DG: IF = IUS + IDG
and
IR = IF IF = phase-to-ground without DG
but
IF = phase-to-ground with DG
IR ≠ IUS
48
Current in Amperes : x 1 at 12.5 kV.
1000
10
d
S i iT
0.1
IF without DG IF with DG
0.01
0.5 1 10 100 1000 10000
w/o DG
Range A
with DG
DG
Range A
VR
DG
50
Moving Forward:
Some Key 1547 Standards Issues (Research Activities)
• Develop interconnection technology (hardware)
• Address field testing vs. type testing
• Interconnection equipment certification
• Evaluate secondary grid and spot networks
• Develop grid/DG monitoring and control
• Understand voltage regulation/stability
• Address grounding/faults
• Establish basis for DG penetration/aggregation
• Develop islanding methods and requirements
51
Moving Forward: Grid Modernization & 1547 Activities
Validation of, and Research on Integration of DR with
Advanced Distribution Operating Concepts:
• IEEE 1547 covers Unintentional Islanding, Intentional Islanding,
Secondary Networks, and Spot Networks.
• The current version of IEEE 1547 minimizes the utilization of
distributed resources in the event of system disturbances.
• Research on the system integration of DR with all types of
distribution operational concepts is necessary to revise IEEE 1547 to
maximize the use of DR and realize the potential operational benefits
at the transmission and distribution level.
• E.g., P1547.4 Guide for DR Island Systems -- Work Group
inaugural meeting August 5 – 6, 2004.
52
Distributed Energy Interconnection Electric Power
Resources Technologies Systems
Utility
Functions Grid
Fuel Cell
PV •Power Conversion
•Power Conditioning (PQ)
Inverter
•Protection
Utility Grid Simulator
•DER and Load Control Micro Grids
Microturbine
Wind
•Ancillary Services Loads
Energy
Storage •Communications Local Loads
•Metering Load Simulators
Switchgear, Relays,
& Controls
53
Generator
Closing Remarks
¾ Industry driven partnerships a success for 1547
stakeholders.
¾DOE and NREL support -- facilitating and leading IEEE
industry driven efforts.
¾ IEEE 1547 American National Standard Published
(order at 800-678-4333, or http://shop.ieee.org/store/ search 1547)
55
Resource Information:
Basso, T.S. and DeBlasio, R. "IEEE P1547 Series of Standards for
Interconnection: Preprint for IEEE Power Engineering Society
Transmission and Distribution 2003 Conference and Exhibition"
NREL/CP-560-34003. Golden, CO: NREL, May 2003.
Basso T.S. and DeBlasio, R. “IEEE 1547 Series of Standards:
Interconnection Issues.” NREL Report No. 34882. September 2003.
Kroposki, B., Basso, T. and DeBlasio, R. “Interconnection Testing of
Distributed Resources” Preprint for 2004 PES General Meeting, June
2004, NREL/CP-560-35569. Golden, CO: NREL.
NREL/SR-560-32459 Distributed Energy Resources Interconnection
Systems: Technology Review and Research
NREL/BK-560-32865 Universal Interconnection Technology Workshop
Proceedings
56