Term Paper Investment Analysis
Term Paper Investment Analysis
Term Paper Investment Analysis
A Report On
The Environment of Capital Market in
Bangladesh
Submitted To:
University Of Dhaka
Submitted By:
Name Id
Mohammad Arman Reza 34003
Department Of Finance
University Of Dhaka
University of Dhaka
Respected Sir,
With due respect, I would like to inform you that, it is a great pleasure for me to submit
the report titled “The Environment of Capital Market in Bangladesh”. My main incentive
was to prepare this report according to your guidelines and in accordance with your
directions. I have tried my best to make the work as per your structures. I hope that I have
done a satisfactory job considering my level of experience and capability and have been able
to relate the fundamental things with realistic applications.
So, I therefore, request and hope that you would be kind enough to accept my report and
oblige thereby.
Sincerely Yours
I also want to thank all who have helped me in preparing this report and worked hard to
make this report happen.
Bangladesh has recently achieved the status of developing country but it is a matter of sorrow
that the environment of capital market in Bangladesh is not satisfactory. An International
Finance Corporation (IFC) diagnostic mission has recently found the Bangladesh capital market
environment not conducive to the issuance of debt instruments or mobilisation of debt to help
local businesses with long-term finance. The mission that visited the country in December last
said long-term debt issuance is subject to higher issuance cost and rigorous regulatory due
diligence.
Earlier in April 2015, the IFC proposed to help Bangladesh in floating US$1.0 billion worth taka
bond. But later in October 2016, it retreated from the proposal for 'failing to raise funds'.The
IFC came up with the proposal as Bangladeshi businesses lack long-term debt in
absence of a 'vibrant stock market' in the country. It identified poor governance in both
public and private sector commercial banks, rising non-performing loans and other
structural constraints which also limit banking sector's capacity to remove the long-
term finance bottlenecks.
The IFC, the private-sector arm of the World Bank Group, said the long-term financing could
have been less difficult to mobilise had there been a deep and vibrant capital markets 'with
lead-ins for intermediation of long-term debts'. Presently, over 80 per cent of debt financing
comes from the banking sector, in particular commercial banks. "Dominance of commercial
banks also indicates prevalence of short and medium-term lending and limit on the capacity of
long-term financing."
The IFC identified three reasons behind long-term lending limitations of domestic banks. It said
the banks have no easy access to foreign exchange resources thus cannot lend in foreign
currency, they are short on long-term taka resources resulting in failing to lend in takas beyond
five to six years of maturity, which is significantly shorter than the economic life of most long-
term investment projects.
Another reason, the IFC found, is that the banks rely on variable-rate resources (deposits) thus
cannot provide fixed rate loans although this will be the best practice for projects creating long-
term assets.
However, the performance of the Dhaka Stock Exchange during the last two years has raised
questions about the structural impediments facing the capital markets in Bangladesh. Many
small investors saw their life savings dissipate due to a free fall in the price of the stocks that
they had invested in. This is not what it was supposed to be. Unfortunately, this phenomenon is
not unique to Bangladesh. While the large emerging markets and world equity benchmarks are
enjoying strong investor demand, the world's next emerging markets the so-called Next-11 (N-
11) markets including, Bangladesh, Pakistan, Sri Lanka and Vietnam, have lost some of their
attractiveness. Rampant inflation, chronic trade deficits, and a lack of structural reform have
deterred investors.
Despite a growing global risk appetite in early 2012, which would usually see money flow into
emerging markets, N-11 markets have barely moved. These markets are less liquid, although
their relative underperformance probably means investors expect lower near-term growth.
Investors find that it is much tougher to do business in these countries as rampant corruption
has stifled economic reform and development. In Bangladesh, political and security concerns, in
particular, add to the downside risk.
Another challenge is inflation. Rising food prices and energy shortages are driving up inflation,
creating a headache for investors and policymakers. As the world's larger economies are easing
off the monetary breaks and beefing up liquidity to safeguard growth, a tightening bias persists
in many of the Asian countries. Stocks in both Bangladesh and Sri Lanka, for example, have
declined substantially in recent months as authorities have lifted interest rates to slow double-
digit inflation, reduce credit growth, and narrow the trade deficit.
Experience has shown that development boosts imports and weakens currency. Most
developing economies including Bangladesh run trade deficits, with a heavy reliance on imports
of capital goods and oil to drive development. Machinery and equipment and energy products
account for a large portion of Bangladesh's imports, for example. Since these economies
typically produce low-value-added goods such as textiles, one unit of domestic production
contains a high-import component. In Bangladesh, this ratio of imports to domestic production
is estimated to be more than 75%, making it difficult to narrow the trade deficit without a
substantial move up the value chain of production.
covering both equity and debt markets in creating a congenial investment climate.
To provide a useful basis for building a sustainable capital market with a view to
In order to complete the study, two types of data have been used-
Data Collection
Primary Data
Secondary Data
Secondary data sources are World Development Indicators, International Financial Statistics,
Asian Development Outlook, Annual Reports of Bangladesh Bank and BAPLC, including various
reports and publications of SEC, Chittagong Stock Exchange (CSE) and Dhaka Stock Exchange
(DSE). I have completed my report by taking information from different journals from
Bangladesh Bank regarding capital market of Bangladesh. I have also taken information from
different websites.
1.3 Limitations
There are a number of limitations while making this report. A time limitation is the biggest of them.
With this short time making such a report is really difficult. The most difficult part of the report was
lack of adequate knowledge about the selected topic. As I am very new to this arena, it is an arduous
task to do such a report on environment of capital market in Bangladesh. However, I have tried my
best to make this report successful.
Since the 1990s, the banking sector has gone through a long reform process with the ultimate
objective of making it more efficient, competitive and resilient to adverse economic conditions.
Although a gradual improvement in banking sector has been observed but the potential of this
sector is still untapped. Some major limitations of the banking sector are mentioned below:
One of the major problems in the financial system of Bangladesh is the absence of an exit policy.
In one way or another, banks are allowed to continue their operation even in the face of severe
problems. A number of banks in our country, in the past, continued their operation without
meeting the minimum capital requirement and with a substantial amount of defaulted loans. It
seems that depositors were also not made aware of varying levels of risk with different banks
and, as a result, are unable to take their deposit decisions based on the riskiness of the bank.
This is an example of a moral hazard problem where weak banks are not pressurized by the
stakeholders, especially by the depositors although they have representation in board of
directors of banks, to make their operation sound and efficient. This problem implies that
Bangladesh’s banking sector does not have adequate market discipline.
A major problem in our banking sector is the accumulation of huge amounts of non-performing
loans. Almost, all the state owned banks are facing a very high defaulter rate. Comparing to
developed countries, where the tolerance range of non-performing loan is up to 3 percent, and
the performance of the banking sector of Bangladesh is very poor. Even comparing to the
neighboring south Asian countries, the non-performing loan amount is much higher in
Bangladesh.
In many cases, banks place an undue weight on collateral security rather than on forecasted
cash flow in approving/rejecting a loan application which makes it difficult for some potential
entrepreneurs to meet the banks’ requirement (The World Bank Report, 2008). As a result the
idea of ‘entrepreneurship development’ by banks is not practiced or cultured in our banking
system.
Bank management must ensure the same set of standards both for the insider loan and loans
granted to the others. The issue of loans given to insider parties emerged as a matter of concern
in the mid ’80s after the operation of private commercial banks in Bangladesh has begun.
Although Bangladesh Bank has adopted various measures for ensuring prudent management of
insider-loans, our banking sector is still burdened with a high amount of defaulted loans granted
to insiders.
The functioning of an efficient capital market may ensure smooth floatation of funds from
the savers to the investors. When banking system cannot meet up the total need for funds
to the market economy, capital market stands up to supplement. To put it in a single
sentence, we can therefore say that the increased need for funds in the business sector has
created an immense need for an effective and efficient capital market. It facilitates an
efficient transfer of resources from savers to investors and becomes conduits for channeling
investment funds from investors to borrowers. The capital market is required to meet at
least two basic requirements:
(b) It must be safe and efficient in discharging the aforesaid function. It has two segments,
namely, securities segments and non-securities segments.
The SEC classified firms in terms of A, B, G, N and Z categories that had not only guided retail
investors to know weak shares but also helped reducing netting and gambling done by a few
hidden consortia
“A” Category Companies: Companies which are regular in holding the Annual General
Meetings (AGM) and have declared dividend at the rate of 10 percent or more in a calendar
year. (Mutual fund, debentures and bonds are being traded in this category).
“B” Category Companies: Companies which are regular in holding the AGM but have
“N’ Category Companies: All newly listed companies except Greenfield companies will be
placed in this category and their settlement system would be like B-Category companies.
“Z’ Category Companies: Companies which have failed to hold the AGM or failed to
declare any dividend or which are not in operation continuously for more than six months
or whose accumulated loss after adjustment of revenue reserve, if any is negative and
The capital market is the market for long-term loans and equity capital. Developing
countries in fact, view capital market as the engine for future growth through mobilizing of
surplus fund to the deficit group. An efficient capital market may perform as an alternative
to many other financing sources as being the least cost capital source. Especially in a country
like ours, where savings is minimal, and capital market can no won- der be a lucrative
source of finance.
The securities market provides a linkage between the savings and the preferred in-
vestment across the business entities and other economic units, specially the general
households that in aggregate form the surplus savings units. It offers alternative in-
vestment windows to the surplus savings units by mobilizing their savings and channelizes
them through securities into optimal destinations. The stock market enables all individuals,
irrespective of their means, to share the increased wealth provided by competitive
enterprises. Moreover, the stock market also provides a market system for purchase and
sale of listed securities and thereby ensures liquidity (transferability of securities), which is
the basis for the joint stock enterprise system. (The existence of the stock market makes it
possible to satisfy simultaneously the needs of the firms for capital and of investors for
liquidity.) Especially at times when the banking sector of the country is facing the challenge
of bringing down the advance-deposit ratio to sustainable level, the economy of the country
is unfolding newer horizon of opportunities. Due to over-exposure level of the financial
system the securities market could play a very positive role, had there been no market
debacle. Due to the last market crash and follow through events, it will be difficult to utilize
the primary market to raise significant volume of funds. Thus the greatest economic
importance of securities market at this point can be understood from the opportunities
The Environment of Capital Market in Bangladesh 13 | P a g e
being lost. Bangladesh having its target to become a middle income country must have
significant level of rise in investment, which at the present state of banking system cannot
be met. The securities market could play the key role in meeting these huge investment
demands if the secondary market would remain stable.
The capital market also helps increase savings and investment, which are essential for
economic development. An equity market, by allowing diversification across a variety of
assets, helps reduce the risk the investors must bear, thus reducing the cost of capital,
which in turn spurs investment and economic growth. However, volatility and market
efficiency are two important features which will ultimately determine the effectiveness of
the stock market in economic development. If a stock market is inefficient due to
insufficient informational supply, investors face difficulty in choosing the optimal
investment as information on corporate performance is slow or less available. The resulting
uncertainty may induce investors either to withdraw from the market until this uncertainty
is resolved or discourage them to invest funds for long term. Moreover, if investors are not
rewarded for taking on higher risk by investing in the stock market, or if excess volatility
weakens investor’s confidence, they will not invest their savings in the stock market, and
hence deter economic growth. The emerging stock markets offer an opportunity to examine
the evolution of stock return distributions and stochastic processes in response to economic
and political changes in these emerging economies.
Bangladesh capital market is one of the smallest in Asia but within the south Asian re- gion,
it is the third largest one. It has two full-fledged automated stock exchanges namely Dhaka
Stock Exchange (DSE), Chittagong Stock Exchange (CSE) and an OTC exchange operated by
CSE. It also consists of a dedicated regulator, the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC),
since, it implements rules and regulations, monitors their implications to operate and
develop the capital.
It consists of Central Depository Bangladesh Limited (CDBL), the only Central Depository in
Bangladesh that provides facilities for the settlement of transactions of dematerialized
securities in CSE market and DSE.
Amid all the formidable obstacles, our country’s securities market has been gaining
momentum. Even in the backdrop of Global Financial Crisis 2008 when the stock mar- kets
size of nearly US $90 Million, Bangladesh is the 70th largest exporter and the 4 largest
th
RMG exporter in the world, Bangladesh is also the 21 st fastest growing economy.
Impressive growth of 5% and above in the last two decades have indeed taken the economy
to a new growth trajectory contributed by steady agricultural production, increased export
earnings, healthy remittance and vibrant domestic demands. The steady growth of GDP
during recent global recessions has demonstrated the resilience of our economy, adding
that the economy has strong fundamentals.
Bangladesh has through unique times just as many of the countries in the region passed
through in the recent past. Several International banks and risk analysts have given strong
recommendation to Bangladesh's steady growth recently. They recognized that Bangladesh
has:
The world's two top credit rating agencies, Standard and Poors (S&P) and Moody's
Investor Service, for the first time, assigned sovereign credit ratings to Bangladesh.
S&P assigned BB- and Moody's Investors Service assigned Ba3 to Bangladesh and
termed the countries macroeconomic outlook stable, putting Bangladesh at par
with Philippines, Vietnam and Turkey. In the South Asian context, Bangladesh is
positioned higher than Pakistan and Sri Lanka.
Several global financial institutions have also identified Bangladesh as one of the
potential economies of the world, heading US investment bank Goldman Sachs has
included Bangladesh as one of the Next 11 (N1l) countries, after the BK1C nations
of Brazil, China, India and Russia as one of the rising economies of the world.
The Environment of Capital Market in Bangladesh 15 | P a g e
Similarly JP Morgan, another global leader in investment banking has included
Bangladesh in its 'JP Morgan frontier Five'. And in a recent update of their 2006
report on "The World in 2050-Price Waterhouse Coopers" extended their analysis
to include 13 other emerging economies including Bangladesh in their new ' PWC
30 list' as one of the long term potential growth economics by 2050.
JP Morgan in its "Ho Chi Minn Trial to Mexico" research report states that it is the
demographics that justify the inclusion of Bangladesh in the "JP Morgan Frontier
Five". Their report identifies that:
Over the past two decades, privates sector has been contributing hand in hand with the
state-owned industries. The policy makers are taking initiatives for the private sector to grow
even further while dynamic entrepreneurs joined the race with their inimitable ideas.
There is also an inflow of qualified and matured professionals in the service industry
including the financial sector.
Bangladesh stock markets have grown significantly during the last decade. Still, the size of
the market is relatively small compared to other Asian Markets. Size and liquidity of the
companies provide some distinguishing features of developing markets. The market
capitalization ratio, defined as the value of listed stocks divided by GDP, is used as a
measure of stock market size. It has got economic significance because market size is
positively correlated with the ability to mobilize capital and diversify risk. Total market
capitalization of DSE was US $ 1.049 billion in 1994 compared to US $ 127.515 billion in
India, US $ 12.263 billion in Pakistan, US $ 191.778 billion in South Korea and US
$199.276 in Malaysia. This market is also small relative to the size of the economy. Market
capitalization in Bangladesh was only 4.07 per cent of GDP in 1994 against 25.77 per cent
in Pakistan, 24.03 per cent in Sri Lanka, 104.14 per cent in Thailand and 294.56 per cent in
Almost 33 lakh investors are now involved in the capital market at the moment; more than
70% of which are general investors. The total market capitalization of all shares and
debentures of the listed securities stood at USD 49.4 billion by the end of 2010, indicating an
84% growth from the year before. The total turnover has increased from USD 0.13 billion
to USD 0.25 billion at the end of 2010 which indicates a 91% growth. However, the capital
market has been exposed to greater risk since PE ratio rose from 19.9% to 29.71% from
January, 2010 to November, 2010.
During 1996 some local and foreign initiatives succeeded in drawing some international
attention which was followed by an international conference in 1994. The conference
followed by some regional as well international market destabilizing events, some hedge
fund managers started investing in the local capital market. The market was neither
operational nor in terms of legal structure ready to absorb such sudden surge in demand
both at home and abroad. Consequently within a very short tenure (from July to October of
1996) the market price level soared to a record level (of that time) height with the index
rising from 894 levels lo 3627 level. The market P/E ratio of all the listed securities reached
to the level of 66.5 within a short period of 4 months. The 'cry-out' auction based trading
system of DSE could not handle the huge demand coming from several thousand investors
who crowded the Motijheel thoroughfare. Consequently street based curb market took over
the legal trade executed through stock market sys- tem. Unsuspecting inexperienced new
entrant investors allured by very quick profit potentials were buying anything without
understanding substance, legality and validity of their investment. Unscrupulous market
players (which even include some issuers) were minting fortunes by selling fake securities
to the crowd who were eager to make quick profit from the market. Thereafter, for obvious
reason the market experienced first major crash in l996 affecting about fifty thousand
investors.
The market crash of 2010 drew greater degree of attention because much larger segments
of population spreading all around the country are affected this time as the market in this
period has gained significant growth. The securities market debacle in 2010 need to be
viewed from different perspectives. The following section attempts to examine those issues
mostly from demand side factors. This is a plain logical analysis supported by some facts
and figure. The analysis covered the period from 2004 till 2010 because, the impacts of
1996 continued until 2003 period. It can be considered that, the market started
consolidation and development from 2004.
Analysis shows that, the capital market of the country experiences some abnormal
upheaval during the last few years, which had full bubble effects in 2010 concluding with
the burst. The causes and factors to such behavior are as following:
The Environment of Capital Market in Bangladesh 19 | P a g e
3.3.1 Political economy inducing demand since 2 00 7
The political reality of 2007 was one of the major reasons for creating a sudden rise in the
market. Until 2006, the growth pattern in the market was gradual and moderate. From
January 2007, the market experienced a sharp rise in terms of transaction and price level.
Especially the political situations in late 2006 made the market little shy of investment. The
emergence of military backed caretaker government (CTG) initially encouraged the
investors to come back to capital market. At the time of declared campaign against
corruption, budgetary policy support for legalization of undisclosed in- come through
investment in securities market also encouraged new investors to transfer their funds to
this market. Besides new civilian investors, influx of armed forces members as investors
also boosted the demands in the market.
a) Amendment of the SEC Act 1993 to empower SEC a vetting power, financial
penalty power with a view to monitoring and enforcing compliance of rules.
SEC is also allowed to conduct special audit to detect window dressing in the
accounts of the listed firms, if it suspects.
c) In the new issue rule, the pricing of IPOs has been delegated to the issue
manager.
c) Separation of the management from the ownership at both DSE and CSE
d) Inclusion of the representatives of the listed companies and the investors on the
governing bodies of both DSE and CSE
e) Automation of trading at both DSE and CSE introducing order-driven system re-
placing out-cry system
f) Amendment of the Trust Act, 1882 enabling pension fund and insurance fund
investing in securities market and thereby create demand for securities.
g) Enactment of the Central Depository Act enabling national securities ltd. com- pany
to establish CDS. The implementation of the on-line CDS will in fact avoid problems
of "fake shares" and "short sale" to a great extent.
However, a few important reform measures are still pending. These include, among others:
Thus the period of 2003 to ‘06 can be viewed as a period of consolidation & restoration.
The Government has been regularly depending upon the borrowing both from internal and
external sources. Because of huge Government borrowing from the country’s formal
banking sector private industrial ventures and other commercial set ups have been on
declining trend. Instead of borrowing from banking sources and other foreign lenders
Government should depend on raising fund from the country’s capital market.
Due emphasis should be given to implement the existing rules and regulations;
4.3 Recommendations
Capital market in Bangladesh is now going through a hard time currently as there are some
upheavals in the market and there exists an upsetting condition in the stock markets. But as
per the past occasions, it is evident that our current capital market has a good ground now
for future developments. We should take this opportunity to boost up the market as well as
contribute to our economy. In addition, our mindset needs to be changed regarding earning
profit from the capital market overnight. Foreign investments also need to be increased to
ensure a sound capital and along with this, the government should make an authentic list of
the companies that has credibility and accountability. If we can develop our capital market, it
will definitely enhance our national economy.
2. Barth, James R., McCarthy, Donald, Phumiwasana and Yago, Gleen. (2006).
Markets , edited by Arner, Douglas, Park, Jaeha, Lejot, Paul and Liu, Qiao, Milken
3. Barth, James R., Nolle, Daniel E., Root, Hilton L. and Yago, Gleen (2001). ‘Choosing
the Right Financial System for Growth,’ Applied Corporate Finance, 13, 116-123.
4. Bencivenga, Valerie R., Smith, Bruce D. and Starr, Ross M. (1995). ‘Transactions
67(1), 53-177.
5. Bhide, Amar (1993). ‘The Hidden Costs of Stock Market Liquidity’, Journal of
International Comparison’ Discussion Paper no. 948, London: Centre for Economic
Policy Research.
7. Demirguc-Kunt, Asli and Vojislav Kamsimovic. 1998. ‘Law, Finance, and Firm
Control, 21 , 145-82.
9. Herring, R. and Chatusripitak, N. 2001. ‘The Case of Missing Market: The Bond
11. Levine, Ross and Zervoss, Sara. (1998). ‘Stock Markets, Banks and Economic
12. Lian, Teo Swee (2002)."Debt Market Development in Singapore." BIS Policy Paper
13. Nakamura, Masao (2002). ‘Mixed Ownership of Industrial Firms in Japan: Debt
Financing, Banks and Vertical Keiretsu Groups,’ Economic System, 26, 231-247
14. Rhee, S. Ghon. (1993). “Fixed-Income Securities Markets of Six Dynamic Asian
Ryrie, William.(1991). “Stock markets and their role in economic development,” The Stock
Exchange Review.