Carlson
Carlson
Carlson
▀▀
Characterizing the Harmonic Attenuation Effect
of High-Pressure Sodium Lamps
A. Gil-de-Castro, A. Moreno-Munoz, Member, IEEE, J.J.G. de la Rosa, Member, IEEE
8 10 N=2
5th Harmonic Current in % of Fundamental
N=3
9 N=4
7
8
6
7
5
6
4 5
3 4
3
2
2
1
100 200 300 400 500 600 700
1
Dimming (Power in W) 40 50 60 70 80 90 100
Dimming (% load)
rd
Fig. 3. Reduction in 3 harmonic current with power for tests 1, 2, 3 and 4.
Fig.5. Evolution of 5th harmonic current with load for tests 1, 2, 3 and 4.
Fig. 4 as well as showing a drop of current harmonic value
the more lamps are connected, the harmonic current value is With respect to 5th harmonic, tests 1 and 2 are below 3 and
higher at half load than at full load. This is more 4 tests. It should be noted that the 5th harmonic behavior is not
representative the lower the number of lamps, because in test the same that harmonics 3rd and 7th behavior, which have the
4 the difference between at half and full load is 26%, and in same as it is observed by comparing Fig. 4 and Fig. 6.
test 1 the difference is 71.7%. Another important result is the 4.5
higher the power the nearer current harmonic value. N=1
N=2
4
7th Harmonic Current in % of Fundamental
N=3
3.5 N=4
2.5
1.5
0.5
0
40 50 60 70 80 90 100
Dimming (% load)
Fig. 6. Evolution of 7th harmonic current with load for tests 1, 2, 3 and 4.
▀▀
▀▀
In conclusion, we can see that it is produced a decrease on equation doesn’t fit in the case of CFL; consequently, they
the harmonic value as higher the number of lamps connected. propose the below index, which is obtained by employing 12
Because we have the value of the harmonic depending on the CFLs connected to different wire lengths.
power, we are going to study the attenuation effect on these Neqh = I hN / I h1 _ 0 (2)
lamps.
After using both formulas and in the case of sodium lamps,
neither the first nor the second is consistent with our data.
V. ATTENUATION EFFECT CHARACTERIZATION
Because of that, we decided to propose another equation that,
Nonlinear loads produce harmonic distortion according to based on field experiment could justify the results obtained. It
their individual harmonic current spectrum. Traditionally, is inspired on the IEC 61000-3-2 [21], where, for devices
large single-point harmonics-producing loads have been belonging to D class, the maximum permissible harmonic
treated as fixed harmonic current injectors. The same method current is rated with power, and harmonic value depends on
has been used to predict the harmonic levels in distribution the power of the system. We have mixed up the effects
systems caused by large numbers of distributed single-phase produced by dimming lamps in a wide range with the fact that
loads, where the typical harmonic current spectrum of one we have four combinations of lamps with different power.
load is scaled in proportion to total load power [15]. However, Thus, the equivalent lamp index proposed here is the
a large number of a variety of linear and non linear loads following:
connected at the low/medium voltage bus of a distribution
Neqh = I hPi /( Pi * I h _ 0 ) (3)
transformer, commonly known as the point of common
coupling (PCC), really form an aggregate load [22]. Net where I hPi is the measured total hth for Pi power of four
harmonic current produced by aggregate harmonic loads
lamps and I h _ 0 is the hth current harmonic produced by less
(AHL) is usually significantly smaller than the algebraic sum
of the harmonic currents produced by the individual nonlinear power. This index is essentially the ratio of the hth harmonic
load, mainly due to phase cancellation [22]. Therefore, THDI current produced by P power to the hth harmonic current
of the aggregate load (i.e, THDI at the PCC) is influenced by produced with less power considered weighted with the power
both the participation (fraction) of linear loads into the total in this moment.
-3
demand of the aggregate load as well as composite harmonic x 10
current spectra of the AHL. Field measurements have 3rd current harmonic
5th current harmonic
indicated that THDI at the PCC of low-voltage buses typically 12 7th current harmonic
do not exceed 20% in comparison to THDI of an individual
nonlinear load, which ranges between 20%–120%. In this 10
Attenuation Factor
produced by aggregate harmonic loads is that they are random Fig.7. Attenuation effect of the HPS lamps for 3rd, 5th, and 7th harmonics.
with a changing average over time. Here we are in the This results in a family of Neqh curves, each representing
presence of the cancellation related with the same kind of the attenuation effect at a particular harmonic number. The
lamps (HPS), although with different power, but dimming three sample curves shown in Fig. 7 reveal the consistency of
with the same levels. In order to represent the attenuation our approximation. In addition, this figure indicates that a
effect of multiple identical loads, it is used in [14] the reduction of the harmonic current occurs when the supply
traditional index given as follows: voltage becomes more distorted. Harmonic 3rd has higher
AFh = I hN /( N × I h1 ) (1) value than the rest; the higher the power the lower the
This formula indicates that, in general, the attenuation due harmonic value for all the orders; and at the highest power of
to a shared system impedance is more pronounced for higher- the load, all of the harmonic values tend to the same one.
order harmonics, and tends to increase with N. Although the
attenuation factor increases in 13th and 15th harmonics, it is not VI. CONCLUSIONS
important since current magnitudes will be negligible in those This paper reports the dimming characteristics of large
orders. lighting networks based on HPS lamps. It is found that the six
By the contrary, [5] and [23] stated that the previous types of HPS lamps under test can work smoothly without
flickering under dimming conditions. For 70, 150 and 250 W
▀▀
▀▀
HPS lamps that are commonly used in road lighting systems Technology - Spring Conference, IACSIT-SC 2009, art. no. 5169423, pp.
598-603.
and are of similar dimensions and structures, their trends for [4] Ceclan, A., Micu, D.D., Simion, E., and Donca, R. Public lighting
the light output variations with input voltage are similar. systems - an energy saving technique and product.
There are two types of results: analysis of harmonic according [5] Nassif, A.B., Xu, W. Characterizing the harmonic attenuation effect of
compact fluorescent lamps. 2009. IEEE Transactions on power delivery,
to the level of dimming for all the tests, and analysis of
24 (3), pp. 1748-1749.
harmonic attenuation by analyzing each harmonic for all the [6] Nassif, A.B., Acharya, J. An investigation on the harmonic attenuation
tests. In this way we have the evolution of each harmonic effect of modern compact fluorescent lamps, 2008, ICHQP 2008: 13th
order according to their power and we also have it according International Conference on Harmonics and Quality of Power, art. no.
4668759
to each test. Both types of result reveal the same phenomenon [7] El-Saadany, E.F., Salama, M.M.A. Effect of interactions between
but present it from different perspectives. voltage and current harmonics on the net harmonic current produced by
In this paper we have presented a harmonic analysis on single phase non-linear loads. 1997 Electric Power Systems Research 40
(3), pp. 155-160
four tests that implied four HPS lamps, electronic ballasts and [8] Suárez, J.A., Di Mauro, G.F., Anaut, D.O., Agüero, C.A. Partial
controllers to dim the light. We have compared this analysis cancellation of harmonic currents caused by nonlinear residential loads.
with others made by different authors over CFLs. The results 2005 Informacion Tecnologica 16 (3), pp. 63-70.
[9] Manzano, E.R., Carlorosi, M., Tapia Garzón, M. Performance and
obtained are partially similar, i.e., the decrease in the measurement of power quality due to harmonics from street lighting
harmonic value as increase the harmonic order, and also the networks. 2009 International Conference on Renewable Energies and
decrease in the value at half load. But the pattern isn’t the Power Quality (ICREPQ’09). ISBN: 978 84 612 8010 8
same because it changes with higher order harmonic. [10] Power quality guidelines for energy-efficient device application.
Consultant report. Prepared By: Electric Power Research Institute.
This study also found that THDI is lower with HPS lamps January 2003.
than with CFLs, and THDI. The harmonic current distortion in [11] Moreno-Muñoz, A. Power quality. Mitigation Technologies in a
a single type load is highly dependent on the loading level distributed environment. 1st edition. London. Springer. 2007.
[12] Salmerón, P., Herrera, R.S., Valles, A.P., Prieto, J. New distortion and
because is higher at half load than at full load. unbalance indices based on power quality analyzer measurements. 2009
Combining different types of loads can effectively reduce IEEE Transactions on Power Delivery 24 (2), pp. 501-507.
the harmonic current distortion due to attenuation. In order to [13] Acarkan, B., Erkan, K. Harmonics modeling and harmonic activity
analysis of equipments with switch mode power supply using MATLAB
assess this issue and due to others equations stated by different and simulink. 2007 Proceedings of IEEE International Electric
authors don’t fit with our results, we have presented a Machines and Drives Conference, IEMDC 2007 1, art. no. 4270692, pp.
proposal on an equation that represents the harmonic 508-513.
[14] Mansoor, A., Grady, W.M., Chowdhury, A.H., Samotyj, M.J. An
attenuation effect over these HPS lamps.
investigation of harmonic attenuation and diversity among distributed
Although the technical features of a lighting installation are single-phase power electronic loads. 1995. IEEE Transaction Power
the first determinant of power efficiency, the ultimate Delivery, 10 (1), pp. 467-473.
determinant is effective operation management. The operation [15] Grady, W.M., Mansoor, A., Fuchs, E.F., Verde, P., Doyle, M. Estimating
the net harmonic currents produced by selected distributed single-phase
of lighting installations presents unique features (variation of loads: Computers, televisions, and incandescent light dimmers. 2002
use periods, lights degradation, environmental aggression, Proceedings of the IEEE Power Engineering Society Transmission and
etc.) that, besides geographical dispersion, make the right Distribution Conference 2, pp. 1090-1094.
[16] PM130EH Plus, SATEC is the Company. Available at:
management difficult. http://www.satec-global.com/eng/products.aspx?product=44
[17] SELC 2000 HID Smart Ballast 150 W. Available at:
VII. ACKNOWLEDGMENT http://www.selc.ie/media/pdf/SELC2000-1.pdf
[18] ROMlight International Inc. HID Electronic Ballast. Available at:
This research was supported by the Company Telvent http://www.romlightintl.com/ballasts.cfm
Energy, Spain, through the project Malaga SmartCity under [19] SELC 2000 HID Smart Ballast 70 W. Available at:
http://www.selc.ie/media/pdf/SELC2000-2.pdf
contract number 12009028. SmartCity’s budget is partly
[20] SELC CANDELON NODE C100 – Outdoor Lamp Controller. Available
financed by the European regional development fund (ERDF) at: http://www.selc.ie/media/pdf/C100-10.pdf
with backing from the Junta de Andalucía and the Ministry of [21] IEC 61000-3-2 Standards on Electromagnetic Compatibility (EMC), Part
Science and Innovation’s Centre for the Development of 3, Section 2: Limits for Harmonic Current Emissions, 2005
[22] Au, M.T., Milanović, J.V. Development of stochastic aggregate
Industrial Technology. The authors would like to thank the harmonic load model based on field measurements. 2007 IEEE
Spanish Ministry of Science and Innovation for funding the Transactions on Power Delivery 22 (1), pp. 323-330
research project TEC2009-08988. [23] Yong, J., Chen, L., Nassif, A.B., Xu, W. A frequency-domain harmonic
model for compact fluorescent lamps. 2010 IEEE Transactions on
Power Delivery 25 (2), art. no. 5332254, pp. 1182-1189
VIII. REFERENCES
[1] Electricity for More Efficiency: Electric Technologies and their Energy
Savings Potential. Union of the Electricity Industry-EURELECTRIC.
July 2004
[2] Energy Efficient Streetlights -- Potentials for Reducing Greater
Washington’s Carbon Footprint --. Prepared by: Robert T. Grow, ACCE
Ford Fellow (Greater Washington Board of Trade). March 18, 2008
[3] Ali, N.A.M., Fadzil, S.F.S., Mallya, B.L. Improved illumination levels
and energy savings by uplamping technology for office buildings. 2009
International Association of Computer Science and Information