Location via proxy:   [ UP ]  
[Report a bug]   [Manage cookies]                

Residual Stress and Deformation of Bogie Frame Steel Plate Weldment by Plasma-MAG Hybrid Welding Process

Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 5

5th International Conference on Information Engineering for Mechanics and Materials (ICIMM 2015)

Residual Stress and Deformation of Bogie Frame Steel Plate Weldment


By Plasma-MAG Hybrid Welding Process
Xiangyang Wu1, a, Zhiyi Zhang1, b, Weichuang Qi1, c,Renyong Tian2, d
1
CSR Qingdao Sifang Locomotive and Rolling Stock Co.,Ltd.,Qingdao 266111,China
2
Dalian Jiaotong University,Dalian 116028
a
sfxiangyangw@163.com, yefan_0954@163.com, cqwc5137@163.com, dtianrenyonghj@163.com
b

Keywords: plasma-MIG hybrid welding process; residual stress; welding deformation; bogie frame

Abstract. The residual stress and welding deformation were measured for the bogie frame steel
plate SMA490BW butt joint welded by using the plasma-MIG hybrid welding process and the
general MAG welding process respectively, as well as in different groove angle conditions. The
results indicate that the plasma-MAG hybrid welding can effectively reduce the residual stress and
the welding deformation compared with the classic MAG welding. With the decrease of groove
angles, the residual stress and welding deformation reduced accordingly. From the angle of
reducing the residual stress and the deformation, the plasma-MAG hybrid welding process should
be adopted in the way of narrow groove.

Introduction
The bogie frame is the main constructional part of weight bearing for the high-speed train. It is
not only supporting the train body and every kind of components, but also transporting every kinds
of loading. During the train body is manufactured the MAG welding process is mainly used for the
welding of bogie frame, but as the structure of frame is complicated, the distribution density of
welding line is large and the MAG welding process is possessed of itself characters, the
complicated residual stress and welding deformation will be produced after welding of the frame.
So there are bad influences to the bogie frame’s breakage, fatigue strength, and the accuracy of
shape dimension and the stability of the structure. And the residual stress is the main reason to the
welding deformation and fatigue damage [1-3]. Consequently, how to effectively reduce the residual
stress and the welding deformation is the main problem in the welding and producing process of the
bogie frame.
The impact elements of the residual stress and welding deformation are many and complicated,
which is caused by the nonuniform elastic-plastic strain during the nonuniform heating and cooling
in the welding process of the frame. The welding technique, joint type, welding heat imput,
assembling and welding sequence, the number of plies, the restrain intensity of frock and the fit-up
gap and so on directly influence on the residual stress and welding deformation of the frame [3,4].
The plasma-MAG hybrid welding is a new kind of welding technique which combines two
different welding techniques, Plasma welding and MAG welding . By complementing each other’s
advantages of these two welding heat sources, it can improve the welding quality and welding
efficiency. Compared with the classic MAG welding, the plasma-MAG hybrid welding can reduce
the welding heat input, concentrate on the welding energy and reduce the HAZ size, so it is hard to
produce deformation of the components and parts [5,6].
Therefore, this article respectively takes the butt weldments of SMA490BW steel for the bogie
frame to investigate the different welding techniques and groove angle conditions’ efforts to the
residual stress and welding deformation. And it provides the experimental basic theory for the
plasma-MAG hybrid welding process to be used in the frame welding.

© 2015. The authors - Published by Atlantis Press 712


Test materials and methods
Test materials
The SMA490BW steel plate (thickness of 12 mm) was slected for the test materials, and the size
of test plate is 350mm*150 mm. The welding wire choosed is CHW-55CNH solid core wire
(diameter of 1.2mm). The welding protective gas is 80% Ar +20%CO 2 mixed gases.

Test method
Welding procedure method
The MAG welding and the plasma-MAG hybrid welding, and the single v-shaped groove
multilayer multichannel welding process was used respectively. The joint type is butt joint,
welding’s groove angle is 60° for the MAG, and the plasma - MAG hybrid welding’s groove angle
is 30° and 60° respectively. The blunt edge and the gap is 1 mm. During the welding process, the
weldment keeps unconstrained state. The welding process parameters are listed in table 1.

Table.1 Welding process parameters


wroove plasma plasma MIG MIG welding plasma gas
welding weld
angle current voltage current voltage speed flow
process pass
/° /A /V /A /V /cm·min-1 /L·min-1
1 180 27.2 190-200 20.6 60 6
30
2 100 23 260-270 27.7 40 3
Plasma-MAG
1 120 24.6 180-190 19.4 60 5
60
2~3 80 22 255-260 26.3 35 3
1 / / 110-115 20.5 20 /
MAG 60
2~3 / / 265-270 28.1 30 /

Residual stress measurement


Residual stress measurement reference CB3395-92 using the blind hole method. The position of
the stress measuring point is shown in figure 1,weld residual stress along the direction of weld
direction is the longitudinal residual stress, expressed with sigma x, weld residual stress of
perpendicular to the direction is the transverse residual stress, with sigma y said. The distance
between the residual stress test point is not less than 30 mm.

Fig. 1 The location of residual stress measuring point Fig. 2 The scene of residual stress measurement

When it is measured, a resistance strain gage which model is BE120-2CA–K is pasted on the
position to be measured, the sensitive coefficient is 2.16. The CCZ-1 test drilling equipment is
adopted to drill a blind hole with diameter of 2 mm and 2 mm deep. According to the released
strains obtained throuth YJ-25 type strain gauge, the residual stress of the position is calculated by
713
means of elastic theory. The scene of residual stress measurement is shown in figure 2.
Welding deformation measurement
Using Hexagon three-dimentional coordinate measuring machine, the welding residual
deformation was precisely measured based on triggering and scanning technology. Welding
deformation test points are shown in figure 3.
When the deformation measured, the weldment was firstly fixed on the worktable, and then the
one side of the weldment was tightly pressed, the other side of the weldment appeared a free state.
Selected zero position as a benchmark, the three-dimentional space coordinates of each measuring
point of the welding pieces were measured, and then according to the corresponding coordinate
values of the two points, the angular deformation was calculated by the pythagore’an theorem. The
scene of welding deformation measurement is shown in figure 4.

Fig. 3 The location of welding deformation Fig. 4 The scene of welding deformation
measuring point measurementt

The test results and analysis


Residual stress
Welding residual stress distribution is shown in figure 5. Can be seen from figure 5, both MAG
welding and plasma-MAG hybird welding, longitudinal residual stress σ x of the weld seam and its
nearby regions are in tensile stress state, the stress value is close to or achieves the yield limit of
SMA490BW steel. With the increase of distance from the weld centerline, σ x gradually change
from tensile residual stress to compression residual stress. Compared with the longitudinal residual
stress σ x , transverse residual stress σ y is in lower stress levels.
Compared with the traditional MAG welding, under the conditions of the same welding process,
the longitudinal residual stress σ x and transverse residual stress σ y are all down to a certain extent
by using the plasma-MAG hybird welding, and among them the σ x reduce about 7.5% at the weld
seam and 18.1% at the near seam area. The main reason for residual stress decline with
plasma-MAG hybrid welding is the heat energy of plasma-MAG hybrid welding is more
concentrated than traditional MAG welding, heating range is shrink, and welding speed is rapid,
welding heat input is reduced, so as to reduce high temperature thermoplastic area to reduce
residual stress.
Using plasma-MAG hybrid welding method and at the same time the other welding process
conditions unchanged, with reduction of the weld groove angle, the welding residual stress also
reduced accordingly. Compared with the commonly used 60° groove angle, the σ x of weld area
reduces 6.7%, and the near seam regions the σ x declins 19.6% when the angle of 30° groove is
selected. Obviously, the groove angle is smaller, the weld beads and filler metals are less, and the
welding heat input is more reduced, so that the residual stress of joint is reduced.
Compared with the traditional MAG welding, choosing plasma-MAG hybrid welding process, or
reducing the weld groove angle, can all reduce the residual stress of near weld seam regions and
weld seam area, in the nearly seam area the effect of residual stress decrease is more obvious.

714
a) Longitudinal residual stress b) Transverse residual stress
Fig. 5 The residual stress distribution of weldments

The welding deformation


The results of welding deformation measurement are shown in figure 6. In the same groove angle
with 60°, the angular distortion of plasma-MAG welding is smaller than MAG welding, the average
angular distortion θ reduced from 3.14°to 2.69° ,decrease about 14.3%. Plasma-MAG welding
deformation is smaller than MAG welding, the main reason is the welding heat input is relatively
small.
With the welding method of plasma-MAG welding, the groove reduced from 60° to 30°, the
average angular distortion θ reduced from 2.69° to 2.50°, reduced 7.1%. Welding groove angle is
small, the filler metal and weld cross-sectional area is small, the contraction deformation is little
after cooling. In addition, the narrower the groove angle, the lower the difference from top to
bottom of the weld section, the smaller the bending deformation of wendment.
In the case of other welding conditions unchanged, with the plasma-MAG hybrid welding and
narrow groove welding technology the welding deformation can effectively reduce. Compared with
the effect of reducing the deformation by reducing groove angle, the effect of using plasma-MAG
hybrid welding instead of MAG welding to decrease welding deformation is better.

Fig. 6 The welding deformation of weldments

Summary
(1) Compared with the traditional MAG welding, the residual stress of SMA490BW weldment is
decreased obviously when the plasma-MAG hybrid welding process is adoped. At the same time,
with the decrease of the weld groove angle, the residual stress reduced accordingly.
(2) In the case of other welding conditions unchanged, by using plasma-MAG hybrid welding
instead of MAG welding, or by reducing weld groove angle, the welding deformations can all be
reduced.
(3) Plasma-MAG hybrid welding technology with narrow groove of weldment can reduce the

715
welding residual stress and deformation more effectively.

References
[1] Xinglong Liu, Xiaoyan Li.The study of bogie frame welding residual stress and deformation .
Journal of locomotive vehicle technology, 2006 (1) : 9-11
[2] Wei Zhuang. Bogie frame welding residual stress and deformation of control. Journal of
locomotive vehicle technology, 2013 (1) : 25-26
[3] Jie Zhou. The influence of welding residual stress for the structure fatigue strength. Southwest
jiaotong university, 2010, 1
[4] Huanjun Liu. Bogie side beam welding residual stress and deformation of the study. Southwest
jiaotong university,2012,5
[5] Changchun Wang, Du Bing. Composite heat source plasma-MIG/MAG welding technology
research Investigate and application . Welding, 2009, 10 (12) : 62-64.
[6] Juefu Heng Zhenmin Wang. The research progress of plasma-MIG welding. Electric welding
machine, 2013, 43 (3) : 28 to 30

716

You might also like