Meghna Estuary Study
Meghna Estuary Study
Meghna Estuary Study
(1995 - 2000)
Study objectives
The objective of the MES estuarine surveys was to supply a part of the basis for assessment
of the physical behaviour of the estuary. The produced data served as a supplement to
results and data from other sources, such as ongoing routine monitoring by BWDB, BIWTA,
and Department of Meteorology, as well as satellite imagery, and historical data, notably
from the Land Reclamation Project and the Cyclone Shelter Preparatory Study.
Physical setting
Meghna Estuary is the easternmost sector of the Ganges delta. The Estuary conveys the
joint discharge of the Ganges/Padma, Jamuna/Brahmaputra, and Meghna Rivers. Hereby,
large volumes of water (some 1,200 km³ per year) and sediment (some 1,100 mio. t per
year) pass the area. The catchment area is 1,520,000 km². It covers parts of India and
China, all of Nepal and Bhutan, and almost all of Bangladesh.
There is a pronounced seasonal variation of wind, river discharge, and sediment supply from
the river system. The highest discharges occur in August-September and the lowest in
February. The 10-years peak flow at Chandpur has been estimated at 123,000 m³/s. The
estuary forms a complex network of braided tidal channels with strong tidal streams in many
places.
The entire Meghna Estuary (and a part of the upstream river system) is tidal-influenced all
year. The tidal range increases in the direction from SW (around 4 m range at S Bhola)
towards NE (around 7 m range at Sandwip). There is a pronounced seasonal sea level
variation. The sea level is highest during the SW monsoon and lowest in the winter. The
range of the seasonal variation is about 0.8 m in the southern part of the MES study area
and about 2.7 m at Chandpur (at the northern boundary of the area). Extreme set-ups occur
during cyclones, where the storm surge can reach 5 - 7 m (on a 20-100 years basis, in the
Chittagong-Bhola sector).
In the estuary, fresh water from the rivers meets
with saline ocean water from the Bay of Bengal.
Due to strong currents and shallow depths,
density stratification is not very characteristic.
Rather, there are fronts (or transition zones)
between the water masses. The location of these
transition zones depends on the river discharge
and the tide.
Sediments, fine sand and silt, are supplied by the rivers, and are transported within the
estuary mainly by the tidal streams. The area is characterized by a highly dynamic
morphology, with flow channels shifting their course, and with intermittent erosion and
accretion of banks and tidal flats. There is a moderate net accretion, currently estimated by
MES at around 10 km² per year (1976-96).
The cause-effect relationships and their interaction can be conceptualized in different ways.
One attempt to summarize the most important physical processes is shown below.
The variable forcings can be divided into external and local determinants. They comprise:
(vi) changed flow resistance caused by natural morphological development; (vii) changed
flow resistance caused by intervention (such as bank protection, cross-dams, etc.); (viii)
changed erosive capacity related to a changed flow resistance (causing a re-distribution of
the flow); and (ix) changed erosive capacity related directly to intervention (such as bank
protection, cross-dams, etc).
As clearly illustrated during the morphological studies carried out by MES, the natural
planform development is highly dynamic. The development seems to follow a certain pattern
over a period of several years, whereafter the pattern shifts to a new one, and the
development continues along a different path.
Regarding time scales for response to external forcing, it is noted that the hydrodynamic
effects (including surface water salinity developments) will be rather immediate (occurring
within one season or less), while the general morphological effects will develop unevenly and
slowly (over several years or even decades).
Surveys
During Phase 1 of the Project, the estuarine surveys of MES comprised instrumentation of
BWDB/SSD's 'Anwesha', field work, laboratory analysis of sediments, and data processing.
The marine surveys comprised 18 cruises, totalling 260 net operation days of 'Anwesha'. The
following activities were completed:
Data applications
Data applications within the framework of MES were:
Home
The project's main objective is to increase the physical safety of the people living in the
Meghna estuary.
The Meghna estuary, which covers 6,000km2, is one of the world's largest: the Ganges,
Brahmaputra and Meghna rivers all flow through it before discharging their waters into
the Bay of Bengal.
The extreme forces of nature - tropical cyclones, storm surges, floods, extremely high
river flows - cause severe problems in the area, and have led to the loss of thousands of
lives and much property.
The DHV-led consortium will be responsible for the masterplan for the development of
the Meghna estuary. The EDP requires the continuous updating of hydro-morphological
knowledge of the rapidly changing estuary. The consortium will manage extensive
surveys of the estuary, and analyze its morphological development using mathematical
modeling and remote sensing.
The programme will propose cost-effective means of erosion control and enhancement of
land accretion.
For specific locations, DHV and its consortium partners will identify, design and
implement suitable initiatives - such as cross-dams and erosion control works - in the
form of pilot projects.
The strengthening of the Bangladesh Water Development Board, which deals with
estuary development, as well as the sharing of knowledge and technology, are also an
important part of the project.
The consortium includes Royal Haskoning (the Netherlands) and four associated
Bangladesh companies.
The project, which is a continuation of the Meghna Estuary Studies (MES), which a
DHV-led consortium carried out from 1995 to 2001 under the Flood Action Plan (FAP),
commences this month.
The Meghna Estuary is a coastal plain estuary on the coast of Bangladesh. The important
driving forces for the flow in the Estuary are the bathymetry, tides and the outflow from
the Meghna River. A numerical model covering the northern half of the Bay of Bengal
including the Meghna Estuary was set up with the objective to increase our understanding
of the hydrographic features and morphological dynamics in the Estuary, especially in the
case where man-made physical interventions are constructed. The simulations revealed a
counter-clockwise residual circulation with a northward net flow in the Sandwip Channel
of 10 000 m3 s−1 during the dry season and 15 000 m3 s−1 during the wet season. The
residual flow is forced by tides together with the bathymetry. During the dry season the
flow is approximately equal to the river discharge and during the wet season it is
approximately one-third to one-sixth of the river discharge. The residual circulation to
some extent traps the river water inside the Meghna Estuary and is one of the reasons for
the relatively low salinity in the estuary even during the dry season. It is also believed to
be important for the morphological development. Finally, a suggested intervention north
of Sandwip shows to stop the residual circulation in the Estuary, for which reason it was
advised not to construct such an intervention without further detailed investigations.
Bangladesh is at risk of becoming submerged under the sea, but the government has
plans for three natural cross dams that will save 500 kilometers of land. With over 2
billion tons of sediment passing through Bangladesh’s vast network of rivers, the country
is claiming the opportunity to compact the sediments into livable land masses.
The cross dams will stretch between two islands, helping the mud to become packed onto
each shore. The first dam will be constructed this year at an estimated cost of $5.34
million.
“Effective measures to hold the 2.4 billion tons of sediment passing through the Ganges–
Brahmaputra–Meghna rivers system would have given rise to about 200 sq. km of land
each year in the Meghna Estuary,” said a report issued by Bangladesh’s Estuary
Development Programme under the Ministry of Water Resources at the Bangladesh
Water Development Board.
This is not a scheme dreamed up by a greedy developer. Bangladesh needs the space. Its
population–150 million people–is the 7th highest in the world and is extremely high for a
country that is ranked 94th in country size, one of the smaller countries in the world. 100
square kilometers of land are eroded each year by rivers and with the burdens of an ever-
increasing population at the rate of 2.1% each year, the country cannot afford to lose
more land.
But 180,000 people are expected to benefit from the cross dams, ensuring there is more
land for Bangladeshis to make their home
Bangladesh plans to build a series of dams to reclaim 600 square kilometres (230 square
miles) of land from the sea over the next five years, officials said Sunday.
The government has approved the ambitious project under which dams would be built in
the Meghna estuary to connect islands and help deposit hundreds of millions of tonnes of
sediment, project chief Hafizur Rahman said.
“The project would cost only 1.20 billion taka (18 million dollars). The dams will
expedite sedimentations and manage the tidal system. They won’t allow loss of any
sediments to the sea,” he told Media.
“The whole process will reclaim at least 600 square kilometres of new land from the sea
in just five years.”
The mighty Ganges and the Brahmaputra rivers join in Bangladesh before flowing into
the Bay of the Bengal.
Studies have found that the two rivers carry more than one billion tonnes of sediment a
year.
Rahman said the dams would be designed so that small islands would become linked with
the mainland as shallow areas in the estuary fill up with sediment.
A study by the Dutch-funded Institute of Water Modelling (IWM) has found that the
damming process would not affect other parts of the coastline or aggravate erosion of the
country’s largest island, Bhola.
“We have done some water models of the project and found some 600 square kilometres
of new land could be reclaimed without any side-effects,” IWM principal researcher
Jahirul Haq Khan told AFP.
Bangladesh reclaimed 1,000 square kilometres of new land in the Meghna estuary by
building two dams in 1957 and 1964. Despite the success, the reclamation process was
halted due to lack of donor financing.
The impoverished country has been one of the worse victims of climate change, with the
UN’s Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) predicting that 17 percent of
its land would go under a rising sea by 2050.
?More charlands have emerged than we have lost due to river erosion over the years,?
said Dr. Maminul Haq Sarker, a geo-morphologist who conducted the study at the Center
for Environment and Geographical Information System (CEGIS).
The new land, which emerged mostly in Noakhali, was discovered when Sarker and his
research team analyzed satellite pictures and other data from 1943 to 2008 tracking
sediments coming from the Himalayas and flowing down the Padma (Ganges in India)
and Jamuna (Brahmaputra) rivers. The rivers deliver about one billion tons of silt a year
from India, Nepal, China , and Bhutan to the Megnha estuary within the Bay of Bengal.
The study found that the 1950 earthquake accelerated the sediment flow by causing huge
landslides in the Himalayas, dumping an estimate 45 billion cubic meters of earth into the
rivers. Within a few years after the 1950 earthquake, silt and clay began to rapidly
accumulate in the estuary. In all, the sediment added 2970 square kilometers in new
charland while 1180 square kilometers were erodeda net gain of nearly 1800 square
kilometers.
Beside Noakhali, new land has accumulated at the Patuakhali, Shariatpur, Barisal and
Chittagong districts.
The findings, formally released yesterday, shines a ray of hope on otherwise dire
predictions by groups such as the International Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) that
Bangladesh will lose about 17 percent of its land area because melting polar ice daps will
increase sea levels.
?This is an indicative study,? he said. ?We need to continue our research to say
something concrete.?
?Now we might think to battle the climate change challenge in different way if we can
use the sediment in planned way,? he said. ?We can recover certain amount of our land
mass from the aggression of rising sea level.?
Citing a recent study of two American scientists, Saker said that the research suggests
that one-third of this sediment is deposited on the floodplain and tidal plain of
Bangladesh, thus continuously raising the land. One-third of the sediment is deposited on
the estuary thus building new islands. The final third is lost in the deep ocean, he said.
The research also found the main reason behind the erosion of 230 square kilometers at
Bhola Island, which many regard as an victim of rising sea levels due to climate change,
was instead caused by the shifting flow of the Meghna channel. The shift also eroded a
total of 195 square kilometers of land from Sandwip and Hatiya islands
The Bangladesh coast, which is already vulnerable to sea-level-associated disasters like
flooding and inundation due to monsoons and the tropical cyclones, is being threatened
by the phenomenon of sea-level rise, worsening the situation further in the densely
populated deltaic region which is hardly 1 m above mean sea level. The interannual
component of sea-level variability is very large on the Bangladesh coast. The present
paper deals with the problem of predicting mean tide level 1 month in advance in the
estuarine zone of the Bangladesh coast during the adverse weather period from
September to December. Regression equations have been presented using the Southern
Oscillation Index (SOI) as predictor and mean tide level in the Meghna estuary as
predicted. Mean tidal levels during the adverse period were found to be predictable on the
basis of SOI 1 month in advance. Consequently, the results may find applications in the
disaster preparedness programmes for Bangladesh.
A numerical model with a (1/120)° resolution is used in studying 1) the effects of tide–
surge interaction and 2) the effects of cyclone landfall on the Noakhali–Cox's Bazar coast
of Bangladesh (i) on the time deviation of the surge arrival from the landfall time of a
cyclone and (ii) on the duration of the maximum surge. The present study found that the
tide–surge interaction in the Meghna estuary shows, in general, the progressive wave
nature of the local tide. If the peak of the maximum surge coincides with the tidal peak
near the landfall, the surge propagates toward the north faster than when the surge peak
coincides with the tidal trough. Cyclones that make landfall before the arrival of the tidal
peak produce higher but shorter duration surges than those that make landfall after the
arrival of the tidal peak. If the landfall time of the cyclone is kept fixed, the surge peaks
are found to arrive earlier and to be of shorter duration with (i) an increase in the
propagation speed of the cyclone and (ii) a decrease in the radius of the maximum
cyclonic wind. For the peak of the maximum surge, it may take about 3–4 h to propagate
from the southern estuary to the northernmost estuary. The surge, which propagates
northward, reaches the northernmost estuary earlier and becomes longer in duration with
smaller angles of crossing of the cyclone with the coastline. A slow moving cyclone with
a larger radius of cyclonic wind, making landfall in the northernmost area, with a small
angle of crossing relative to the Noakhali–Cox's Bazar coastline, and landfall just before
the high tide is found to be the most severe cyclone, capable of producing the highest
surges in the vast and shallow estuary.
A depth integrated two-dimensional numerical modeling was carried out to study the
sediment dynamics within the Meghna estuary. The sediment — water dynamics within
this estuary are very complex due to its irregular shape, wide seasonal variation, and the
changing role of the tide. Both cohesive and noncohesive sediment transport formulations
were used to estimate the total transport. An interactive morphological computation was
also used to verify the bed level changes over 2 years. Sediment transports of both
monsoon and dry seasons (the two most hydrologically pronounced periods in this
region) were modeled, and a large seasonal variation in sediment transport pattern was
observed. Land reclamation dams were tested by the model and found to be effective in
enhancing the accretion in its vicinity.
Seasonal variation of residual currents in the Meghna Estuary, located at the northern part of the
Bay of Bengal, has been investigated through the use of a 3D numerical model. Residual current
in the Meghna Estuary appears to be strongly influenced by tidal currents and Coriolis Effect
under average meteorological and hydrological conditions of four different seasons considered,.
Average seasonal variation of wind speed and direction as well as fresh water inflow does not
seem to have significant influence on residual current. Only under the influence of average of
maximum wind speeds of different seasons, residual currents in the Meghna Estuary show their
dependency on wind stress. In general, at the surface layer northward and northwestward flow is
created during the pre-monsoon and monsoon periods and southwest and southeastward flow is
created during the post-monsoon and winter periods.
Negative surges destroy coastal aquaculture installations and hinder rescue-evacuation
operations during cyclones and storm surges in the Meghna estuary in Bangladesh. The
influence of the characteristics of the cyclones striking the Noakhali-Chittagong-Cox's
Bazar coast on the negative surges in the Meghna estuary is examined, This study uses a
(1/120)o resolution numerical model, which includes the offshore islands and
bathymetric details of the worst-affected northernmost part of the Meghna estuary. The
model was verified by the observed data of official agencies like the Bangladesh
Department of Hydrography. The negative surges in the Meghna estuary are found to
have …
Studies are described that use a fine-resolution numerical model and incorporate the
islands and detailed bottom topography of the Meghna estuary. They show that
depending on the characteristics of the atmospheric cyclone and the astronomical tide,
storm surges can be coastal trapped in the Meghna estuary and propagate like edge waves
along the coastline causing widespread devastation and enormous loss of life and
property. The funneling effect of the narrowing estuary acts strongly on the pressure
response and predominantly in the region north of Sandwip Island. The combination of
coastal trapping and the funneling effect results in the widespread nature of the surges in
the Meghna estuary. The widespread nature of the surges is directly proportional to the
wind inflow angle and to the radius of maximum cyclonic wind, but inversely
proportional to the angle of crossing of the cyclone as made with the coastline. The
cyclone striking the Noakhali-Chittagong coast produces more widespread surges than
does a cyclone striking the Chittagong-Cox's Bazar coast. A rapidly moving cyclone
drives the surges toward the northern coast. If a cyclone strikes during the ebb tide phase,
then nonlinear tide-surge interaction also generates separate surges far to the west in the
Khepupara region.
A very severe earthquake of the magnitude of 8.6 on the Richter scale occurred in August
1950 with its epicenter close to the border of Assam in India and Tibet in China. This
earthquake caused huge landslides in the Himalayas, estimated at about 45 billion cubic
meter. Within a few years, most of the debris generated from the landslides entered into
the Brahmaputra river through numerous tributaries in Assam. The fine fraction of
sediment mainly consisting of silt and clay very quickly transported through the
Brahmaputra/Jamuna river and deposited in the Meghna estuary area. It moved through
the river slowly like a sand wave and caused significant changes in river morphology.
Some recent research (by this writer) describes the responses of the rivers through
widening and increasing of erosive capacity during the propagation of the sand wave.
That was the main reason why the erosion along the Jamuna and Padma rivers was higher
in the 1980s and 1990s than in the previous and later periods.
As the silt and clay fraction of sediment entered within a few years after the 1950
earthquake, it caused very rapid accretion of land in the Meghna estuary area. On the
other hand, the leading edge of sand wave entered in the mid 1970s and contributed
incremental accretion in the following decades. It took more than 50 years for all the
extra sand fraction of sediment generated by the earthquake to enter into the Bay of
Bengal from Assam.
The long-term net accretion in the estuary has been estimated by different scientists by
comparing different historical maps like James Rennel's map (1776) or Commander
Lloyd's chart (1840) with the modern surveyed maps. The results of the estimates for the
long-term net accretion in the Meghna estuary area are found to vary from 4 to 10 km2
per year.
Comparing the map of 1943 with satellite images shows that from 1943 to 1973 net
accretion was more than 1200 km2. If it is assumed that most of the accretion occurred
between 1950 and 1973, the net annual rate of accretion becomes more than 50 km2/year,
which is 5 times higher than the long-term average rate. Later, the rate of net accretion
slowed down and from 1973 to 2008 it became about 17 km2 per year. The overall land
gain after the earthquake of 1943 is about 1800 km2.
In 1957 and 1963 two cross-dams were built in Noakhali, which contributed to the rapid
land formation and joining of the islands with the mainland. Nevertheless, the source of
the huge sediment that increased net accretion more than 5 times than in other periods the
massive landslides caused by the Assam earthquake in 1950. The rapid accretion in the
following two decades was mainly due to the rapid transportation of silt and clay to the
Meghna estuary.
Next to Noakhali district, accretion has been more than 4 times of erosion in Patuakhali
district -- and thus net gain of land has been about 325 km2 over the 60 years.
Adverse effects
Rapid advance of the mainland of Noakhali caused drainage congestion in the south of
Comilla and north of Noakhali. Huge erosion of old and fertile land in Sandwip, Hatiya
and Bhola can also be partly attributed to the rapid advancement of the mainland.
What next
The long-term sediment yield in the three great rivers -- the Jamuna, the Ganges and the
Meghna -- is about one billion tons per year. All extra sediment generated by the Assam
earthquake has already reached the Bay. It is likely that the rapid accretion rate will slow
down and come closer to the long-term net accretion rate i.e. less than 10 km2 per year.
While construction of many flood embankments and polders during the last 40 years has
restricted floodplain sedimentation, sea level rise would certainly reduce the rate of net
accretion.
While assessing the extent of inundation or flooding due to different probable magnitudes
of sea level rise and rainfall intensity, it is common practice in Bangladesh to consider
that the bed level of the estuary, riverbed and river bank levels, floodplain and tidal plain
levels would be constant in the future. Recent research of CEGIS indicates that as the
rivers of Bangladesh carry huge amounts of sediment, the levels of riverbeds and banks
as well as the bed and unpoldered tidal plains of the Meghna estuary will be raised as
well considerably.
Proper sediment management based on better understanding on the sediment distribution
processes in the floodplain, tidal plain and Meghna estuary may partly compensate for the
inundation of the coastal area, but the difference between these two processes, however,
depends on the rate of sea level rise in the coming decades. On the other hand, any
adaptation measures without considering appropriate sediment management may further
aggravate the situation by causing more drainage congestion and erosion in the coastal
areas.
A depth integrated two-dimensional numerical modeling was carried out to study the
sediment dynamics within the Meghna estuary. The sediment–water dynamics within this
estuary are very complex due to its irregular shape, wide seasonal variation, and the
changing role of the tide. Both cohesive and noncohesive sediment transport formulations
were used to estimate the total transport. An interactive morphological computation was
also used to verify the bed level changes over 2 years. Sediment transports of both
monsoon and dry seasons (the two most hydrologically pronounced periods in this
region) were modeled, and a large seasonal variation in sediment transport pattern was
observed. Land reclamation dams were tested by the model and found to be effective in
enhancing the accretion in its vicinity.