Thesis
Thesis
Thesis
HEALTH MANAGEMENT
PROJECT REPORT
Dr K Sarala Kumari
Under the guidance of
Dr Suresh Munuswamy
I hereby declare that the thesis entitled “Assessment of Weight Gain of Children
Admitted to Nutrition Rehabilitation Center at Sangareddy (Medak) & Afterwards
at for Two Years” submitted by me for the award of the Degree of Post Graduate
Diploma in Public Health Management of Indian Institute of Public Health,
Hyderabad, is original and it has not been submitted previously to this or any
other institute/university/ organization for any Degree, Diploma or Associateship.
Date:
CERTIFICATE
Certified that the dissertation entitled “Assessment of Weight Gain of Children Admitted to
Nutrition Rehabilitation Center at Sangareddy (Medak) & Afterwards at for Two Years”
submitted for the award of the Degree of Post Graduate Diploma in Public Health Management
of Indian Institute of Public Health, Hyderabad is a record of research work done by Dr. K Sarala
Kumari under my guidance and it has not been submitted previously to this or any other
institute/university/organization for any Degree, Diploma or Associateship.
Date:
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
I am happy to Acknowledge Dr. G. V. S. Murthy, Director IIPH, Hyderabad for his continuous
care and support.
I express my extreme gratitude to Dr. M. Jayaram, Academic Register and Senior Administrative
Officer IIPH, Hyderabad, for his moral support and continuous co-ordination and guidance.
My Sincere thanks to Dr. J. K. Laxmi and Dr. Srikrishna, course coordinators PGDPHM of IIPH, for
their continuous encouragement and support. I am expressing my heartfelt respect and honor
to my course guide Dr. Suresh Munuswamy for his precious guidance and continuous
monitoring throughout the course of the project with great interest and timely support.
I thank Mr. Stephen Raj (Masters, Health Informatics Department) for his in data analysis and
support in thesis formulation.
I am extremely thankful to all the faculty members of IIPH, Hyderabad, who enlightened me on
course modules and oriented on research work during my course.
I am very much thankful to Dr. K Raju Goud, Superintendent of Government District Hospital
Sangareddy for his support, guidance, and granting me permission for the study at the Nutrition
Rehabilitation Center (NRC) Center.
I thank Medical Officer and Nutrition Counsellor and all the staff at NRC for their support and
feedback extended in doing the project work.
Dr K Sarala Kumari
ABSTRACT
BACKGROUND
Under nutrition is an important factor contributing to the death of young children. If a child is
malnourished, the mortality risk associated with respiratory infections, diarrhea, malaria,
measles, and other infectious diseases is increased. In Andhra Pradesh State (latest data
available is from before bifurcation of the state) according to NHFS-3 National Family Health
Survey (2005-2006) data 12.2% (3.22 lakh) of children in the state are suffering from Severe
Acute Malnutrition (SAM).
RESULTS
The infrastructure parameters and the human resources were found to be less than adequate
but functional. The study included 187 children in the age group of 0-5 years. There were 79
boys and 108 girls, out of which the highest representation was from the age group of 1 to 12
months. A 38% of study population belonged to BC, ranking next is SC at 35%, OC at 24% and
the lowest was SC at 3%. The average weight gain during the stay at the Center was 430 g. The
median length of the stay at the Center was 11 days with 60% of patients leaving the facility
prematurely (before 14 days). A 30% of the mothers of the children felt that infection was the
cause while only 10% thought that inadequate diet was the cause of malnutrition. A 60% had
no knowledge about cause of malnutrition. Mothers lacked adequate information on
composition of therapeutic diets, although 85% learnt about time interval between feeds.
CONCLUSION
NRC provides a great platform for treating SAM children, but is not utilized by all intended
population. There is lack of uptake of services due to low awareness in the community and
poor service due to lack of timely release of funds. So, community awareness and participation
has to be scaled up while management should act more responsibly in releasing the funds on
time and with proper supervision.
CONTENTS
INTRODUCTION ..................................................................................................................................................... 9
BACKGROUND ..................................................................................................................................................... 10
OBJECTIVES OF NRC.....................................................................................................................................................11
TRAINING ...........................................................................................................................................................51
TYPES OF SERVICES .............................................................................................................................................51
CHALLENGES FROM HEALTH SYSTEM PERSPECTIVE ..........................................................................................52
DISCUSSIONS ....................................................................................................................................................... 53
CONCLUSION ....................................................................................................................................................... 55
LIMITATIONS ....................................................................................................................................................... 55
Nutrition being the core pillar of Human development. The high mortality and disease burden
resulting from undernutrition requires call for urgent need for implementation of interventions
to reduce their occurrence and consequences.
Undernutrition encompasses Stunting children are too short for their age group compared to
the WHO child growth standards (chronic malnutrition). Wasting (acute malnutrition) resulting
from failure to gain weight or actual weight loss and deficiencies of micronutrients (essential
vitamins and minerals).
Severe Acute Malnutrition (SAM) is an important contributing factor for most deaths amongst
children accounting for under-five child mortality.
NFHS 3 shows that the proportion of children who are stunted or underweight increases rapidly
with the child’s age from birth to age 20-23 months; peaking at age 20 months. Even during the
first six months of life, when most infants are breastfed, 20-30 percent of children are
underweight. It is notable that by age 18-23 months, when many children are being weaned
from breast milk, 30 percent of children are severely stunted and one-fifth are severely
underweight.
Forty three percent of children under age five years are underweight (low weight for age).
Forty eight percent of children under age five are stunted (low height for age).
Twenty percent of children under five years of age are wasted (low weight for height); over 6%
of these children are severely wasted (< -3SD). Since ‘wasting’ denotes acute malnutrition,
these children are said to have Severe Acute Malnutrition.
BACKGROUND
Undernutrition is an important factor contributing to the death of young children. If a child is
malnourished, the mortality risk associated with respiratory infections, diarrhea, malaria,
measles, and other infectious diseases is increased.
More than half (54 percent) of all deaths before age five years in India are related to
malnutrition.
Because of its extensive prevalence in India, mild to moderate malnutrition contributes to more
deaths (43 percent) than severe malnutrition (11 percent).
In Andhra Pradesh State according to NHFS-3 National Family Health Survey (2005-2006) data
18.7% are severely stunted and 24.0% are moderately stunted.
Deaths amongst SAM children are preventable, provided timely and appropriate actions are
taken.
ESTABLISHMENT OF NUTRITION REHABILITATION CENTERS
Under nutrition is an invisible problem. It jeopardizes children survival, health, growth and
development. To combat this menace, the Government of India is working with the United
Nations Children Fund (UNICEF) aimed at identifying and treating malnourished children.
To prevent deaths among Severe Malnourished children under five years of age (0-5), identified
under the drive, the Government further started the Nutrition rehabilitation Centers (NRCs)
with support from UNICEF.
Objectives of NRC
To provide clinical management and reduce mortality among children with severe acute
malnutrition, particularly among those with medical complications.
To promote physical and psychosocial growth of children with severe acute malnutrition
(SAM).
To build the capacity of mothers and other care givers in appropriate feeding and caring
practices for infants and young children
To identify the social factors that contributed to the child slipping into severe acute
malnutrition.
NRC IN TELANGANA STATE
PREVALENCE OF MALNOURISHMENT IN TELANGANA STATE
In Telangana State the prevalence of Severe Acute Malnourishment (undernourished children
0-5 years) in children remains high despite overall economic growth.
It is estimated that 3.22 lakh children in the state are suffering from Severe Acute Malnutrition,
a condition associated with high mortality and morbidity that requires specialized treatment
and sustained follow-up.
It was also observed that majority of children with SAM suffer silently without access to
appropriate treatment.
Hence, the government has decided to establish the NRCs to ensure that every child is born
healthy and grows and thrives to realize his/her full potential. The objective is to ensure that
children with SAM have access to inpatient treatment.
The Government with intention to provide medical care to the SAM children established 30
NRCs.
The objectives of the program are to control malnutrition among the children aged 0-5 years in
the state and to bring down the percent of severe malnourished children.
One NRC is present in every district hospital. In Telangana State, there are 10 such NRCs
providing services to SAM children. These are all 20-bedded NRCs.
Funds will be provided from the allocations made under National Rural Health Mission (NRHM).
RESEARCH STUDY TOPIC
Assessment of Weight Gain of Children Admitted to Nutrition Rehabilitation Center at
Sangareddy (Medak) & Afterwards at for Two Years.
OBJECTIVES
To assess facilities at Nutrition Rehabilitation Centers.
To evaluate the services being provided under facility based nutritional interventions.
REVIEW OF LITERATURE
There are few studies for the evaluation of services provided at NRCs which was a specific
initiative program by the Government under NRHM to combat malnutrition.
These studies were conducted in the states of Madhya Pradesh Uttar Pradesh Bihar and Orissa
where the prevalence of SAM children was high and children were severely malnourished. NRC
Centers were set up in these states with the support from United Nations Children Fund
(UNICEF). The concurrent assessments of NRCs in selected states have come with some results
and recommendations.
The findings of this study conducted on effects of NRC showed that the NRCs were effective in
improving the condition of admitted children, but the effects of interventions were not
sustained for longer durations following discharge which reflected through high drop-out rate
and lack of adequate parental awareness. There is an alarming need to link these centers with
community-based models for follow-up and improve health education measures to maintain
the gains achieved.
This study in the districts of Madhya Pradesh sought to explore design issues of nutritional
rehabilitation centers in order to inform its effectiveness in settings where the prevalence of
chronic poverty and malnutrition is high. Limited success was obtained (marked by poor cure
rates and high non-responder rates) to high prevalence of chronic malnutrition, particularly in
nutritional rehabilitation centers located in peripheral areas. There is a failure to recognize
severe chronic malnutrition as an epidemiological entity and gear wide-ranging programmatic
and social interventions.
STUDY AREA
DEMOGRAPHICS OF SANGAREDDY, MEDAK
Description 2011
Male 1,523,030
Female 1,510,258
Density/km2 313
Literates 1,637,137
STUDY LOCATION
At Nutrition Rehabilitation Center (NRC) Sangareddy District Hospital of Medak District.
TOOLS USED
1. Check list based on Operational Guidelines of Nutrition Rehabilitation Center to assess the
facilities at NRC.
2. Observational notes and secondary data collected from NRC were used for the research
study.
3. Semi structured Interview guide for the service providers and beneficiaries.
PARTICIPANTS/SUBJECT SELECTION
Service providers at the Nutrition Rehabilitation Center and mothers of children admitted at
NRC at the point in time of the study will be included in the study.
EXCLUSION CRITERIA
Beneficiaries who stayed for less than three days at NRC were excluded from the study.
DATA COLLECTION
Data collection was carried out over a period of two months, during 15 September 2015 to 15
November 2015. Initially the required permissions were taken from the Superintendent of
Sangareddy District Hospital, Medak. After the approval for the study was given, I have
approached the concerned medical officers of the NRC and sought for their cooperation.
DATA ANALYSIS
The analysis of the quantitative data collected as the part of the research study was carried out
with Microsoft Excel and Google Maps. The qualitative data was transcribed, translated and
manually analyzed according to the themes identified.
RESULTS & OBSERVATIONS
FUNCTIONAL ANALYSIS OF NRC AT SANGAREDDY
Nutrition Rehabilitation Center (NRC) also called as AKSHAYA AROGYA PUNARJEEVANA
KENDRAM. The approach to NRC is very feasible located near the registration for O.P. The
Center is near the pediatric ward hence patients do not have any difficulty in accessing the
Center. Written on the entrance is “Akshaya Arogya Punarjeevana Kendram” in local language,
Telugu. The Center is properly ventilated and spacious. Infrastructure at the facility was
assessed as per the NRHM Operational Manual for infrastructural parameters: building,
available rooms, kitchens, play areas, toilets, counselling area, staff position, clinical equipment,
kitchen equipment and pharmacy supplies. Items on observational checklists included hand
washing, general hygiene, laundry, waste disposal, feed preparation and weighing. Knowledge
levels of admission, monitoring and discharge criteria were also assessed. They were found to
be adequate and functional.
Drawings and displays charts for personal hygiene practices and feeding practices are displayed
on the walls which makes the Center more welcoming and interesting for the children.
Severe malnourished children are recognized in their respective localities by the frontline
workers (ANM, ASHA, AWW’s, CHW’s, MSW, OP and PGW) and PHC Medical officers and are
referred to NRC.
ADMISSION CRITERIA
Admission in to NRC for SAM children is done according to admission criteria.
Therapeutic feed (F-75, F-100 and SF) is prepared using locally available foodstuff. Supervised
feeding of therapeutic diets is done by the NRC staff Feeding Demonstration is given by the
Cooks under the supervision of nutrition counsellor and medical intervention is provided by the
doctor in charge and the nurses at the Centers.
The mothers of the children are made to stay at the Centers where counselling sessions
focusing on health, personnel hygiene and nutrition aspects are conducted for them.
Mothers or care takers of the SAM children are also given wage compensation of Rs 100 per
day for the stay and are offered two meals per day. Anthropometric indicators [weight, height,
and mid upper arm circumference (MUAC) are measures and noted down immediately in the
case sheet and are monitored to observe the effect of interventional measures on the health
status of the admitted children. Anthropometric assessment of the children is done by the NRC
staff using standard validated measurement techniques. Weight of the children is taken using
electronic weighing scales and height is measured.
The NRC has the patient area to house the beds. Mother and child are kept in the same bed so
that mother can be with the child.
It has a counselling area and audiovisual equipment (TV and DVD player) which plays rhymes
for children.
There are toys available but no separate play area for the children.
Kitchen and storage area is attached to the ward with enough space for cooking.
There is an attached toilet and bathroom facility for the mothers and children and is properly
maintained and cleaned twice a day. There is 24-hour uninterrupted water and power supply.
Ward has a Nursing Station.
HUMAN RESOURCES
The NRC has adequate staff for smooth functioning of NRC with two medical officers, a
nutrition counsellor, three staff nurses, two cooks/caretakers, two attendants and a vacant
position for a medical social worker.
MEDICAL OFFICER
There are two medical officers. The senior medical officer underwent training for three days. It
was facility based training and he was trained on screening of SAM children, admission criteria
for SAM children, on therapeutic feeding practices and treating the SAM children with any
other medical complications.
NURSING STAFF
Out of required eight staff nurses only three are in position and there is requirement for staff
nurses. The three nurses work on rotation duties and are overburdened with work. The facility
needs to fill in this gap and the vacancies.
Nurses posted in the ward are responsible for weight recording, recordings of MUAC, timely
supervision of patient condition and distribution of oral drugs and IV fluids. They also assess
clinical signs and record the information in the case sheet.
NUTRITION COUNSELLOR
Two nutrition counsellors with a diploma in nutrition were recruited and trained for three days.
The duty of the counsellor is to prepare the specific therapeutic diet chart according to the
requirement for individual child in consultation with the medical officer each day, also
responsible for monitoring the preparation, demonstrate the distribution of complimentary
foods to the mothers/caregivers. They assess the feeding problems in each child and give
counselling to mothers. They also give counselling on sanitation, feeding practices and personal
hygiene.
ATTENDANTS/CLEANER
Two attendants working in the shift duties are responsible for the keeping the ward clean.
Cleaning of the ward floors twice daily and cleaning and discarding the dustbins. They help in
maintaining the cleanliness of the NRC.
KITCHEN EQUIPMENT
The supplies and stores in the kitchen were found to be adequate and stored properly Table.9
Equipment Availability
Cooking Gas Present
Dietary Scales (to weigh to 5 g), Present
Measuring Jars Present
Electric Blender (or manual whisks) Present
Water Filter Present
Refrigerator Present
Table.9
Utensils (large containers, cooking utensils, feeding cups, saucers, spoons, jugs, etc.)
KITCHEN SUPPLIES
The staff has provision for hand wash and the maintain cleanliness and hygiene during the
preparation of food and during handling and distribution of food.
Bedding is changed once in three days or whenever it gets wet/soiled. Mothers have to do the
laundry outside.
Food is stored properly. Food is prepared and served hot and whatever leftovers there are, are
discarded.
HANDWASHING
MOTHERS CLEANLINESS
FOOD STORAGE
DISHWASHING
TOYS
Children are weighed at the screening into NRC for the admission criteria. The weights of the
child are noted down immediately on the case sheets. They are weighed on the standardized
electronic weighing scales. Staff takes care to adjust the zero reading before weighing each
child.
The weights are recorded daily to see the improvement of the interventions and are noted
down in the case sheets to see the result.
Are children fed with a cup (never a No They are fed with
bottle) bottle
WEIGHING
OBSERVE YES NO COMMENTS
WARD ENVIRONMENT
OBSERVE YES NO COMMENTS
PHARMACY SUPPLIES
The following medicines are available at NRC.
ANTIBIOTICS
Ampicillin, amoxicillin, benzylpenicillin, chloramphenicol, cotrimoxazole, gentamicin,
metronidazole, tetracycline or chloramphenicol eye drops, atropine eye drops
IV FLUIDS
Ringer’s lactate solution with 5% glucose; 0.45% (half normal) saline with 5% glucose; 0.9%
saline (for soaking eye pads)
CONSUMABLES
Cannulas, IV sets, pediatric nasogastric tubes.
SOCIO DEMOGRAPHIC PROFILE FOR PARTICIPANTS
NUMBER OF PARTICIPANTS
The 2014-2015 data included 187 children, with 63 children in the age group of 0-12 months, 73
children in the age group of 13-24 months, 18 children in the age group of 25-36 months, 19
children in the age group of 27-48 months and 14 children in the age group of 49-60 months.
Number of Children
in Each Age Group
5 yrs - 14
4 yrs - 19
1 yr - 63
3 yrs - 18
2 yrs - 73
1 2
3 4
5
SEX DISTRIBUTION OF CHILDREN
The 2014-2015 data included 79 boys and 108 girls, in which 34% of the children were in the
age group of 0-12 months, 39% in the age group of 13-24 months, 10% in the age group 25-36
months, 10% in the age group 39-48, and 7% in the age group 49-60 months.
Gender Distribution
Male 42%
Female
58%
F M
80
70
Gender Distribution
in Each Age Group
60
31
50 25
M
40
F
30
20 42
38
No. of Days
9 10
10 4
9 9 10
0
1 2 3 4 5 Age in Years
WEIGHT DISTRIBUTION ON ADMISSION
The mean weight of children in the age group of 0-12 months is 4.49 kg, in the age group of
13-24 months is 6.73 kg, in the age group of 25-36 months is 8.08 kg, in age group of 37-48
months 10.32 kg, in the age group of 49-60 months is 11.03 kg.
12.00
11.03
10.32
10.00
8.08
8.00
6.73 1
2
6.00 3
4.49 4
5
4.00
Mean Weight in Kg
2.00
0.00
1 2 3 4 5 Age in Years
CASTE DISTRIBUTION
Out of total study population of 187 children, 38% of the study population belonged to the
backward caste, 35% belonged to the scheduled caste group, 24% belonged to the other caste
and only 3% belonged to the scheduled tribe caste.
Caste Distribution
BC
38%
OC
24%
ST SC
3% 35% BC
OC
SC
ST
PARENTS BACKGROUND
A semi structured interview schedule was used to interview the mothers of the admitted
children on awareness focusing on nutrition, basic concepts of nutrition, causes of malnutrition,
and the impact of hands on training provided at the center, which focused on the composition
and preparation of therapeutic diets at the center.
Above
22%
A
B
Below
78%
EDUCATION STATUS OF PARENTS
An 80% of the parents of the admitted children were illiterate, while about 10% were educated
up to primary school, and 10% up to high school.
High School
10%
Primary 10%
1
2
3
Illiterate
80%
LEVELS OF KNOWLEDGE AMONG MOTHERS OR BENEFICIARIES ATTENDING THE NRC
Inadequate diet and poor quality of food were considered to be the main reasons responsible
for malnutrition and only 10% of the mothers thought that inadequate diet was the cause of
malnutrition and the rest 30% thought that infection was the cause.
Causes of Malnutrition
Infection
30%
No
Knowledge
Inadequate
60%
Diet
10%
No Knowledge
Inadequate Diet
Infection
Knowledge Regarding Therapeutic Feeding Practices at NRCs
A 10% of subject beneficiaries had knowledge about the type of feed provided at the center.
Only 5% of them knew about the composition of feed and 85% of the mothers knew about the
time interval between feeds.
Therapeutic Feeding
Type of
Feed Composition
10% 5%
Time
Interval
85%
Type of Feed
Composition
Time Interval
Knowledge about Preparation of Complimentary Food
A 55% of the mothers had no knowledge about complimentary food preparation and 45% of
them had knowledge.
Don’t Know
Know 45%
55%
Know
Don’t Know
Awareness on Personal hygiene
About 30% of the mothers had no knowledge about personal hygiene and a good 70% of them
had knowledge.
Don’t
Know
30%
Know
70%
Know
Don’t Know
Knowledge about Preparation of Nutritious Food and Feeding Practices
A 45% of the mothers had the knowledge about preparation of nutritious food and 55% had no
knowledge. While about 50% of them had knowledge about feeding practices and 50% had no
knowledge.
Know Feeding,
50%
Know
Preparation, 45%
Feeding
Know Don’t Know
Preparation
IMPACT OF NRC ON SAM CHILDREN
Performance of NRCs may be assessed based on the criteria described below.
Achieved target weight - The guidelines prescribe that the children should achieve at least 15%
of their body weight gain from the date of admission to date of discharge.
The complete data including 79 boys and 108 girls were analyzed for the effect of nutritional
interventions at NRC. When the mean and median weight gain was assessed the following
were the observations.
0.60
0.50
0.40
Weight in Kg
0.30
0.20
0.10
0.00
1 2 3 4 5F
Age in Years
M
AVERAGE WEIGHT AT ADMISSION AND DISCHARGE FOR GIRLS
A total of 187 children were included in the analysis and 180 girls (58%) were analyzed for the
effect of nutritional interventions at NRC. The maximum average weight gain appears to be in
the age group of 25-36 months at 550 grams. The minimum average weight gain appears to be
in the age group of 37-48 months at 320 grams.
12.00 11.29
10.90
10.33
10.01
10.00
8.25
7.70
8.00
6.87
6.40
Weight in Kg
6.00
4.73
4.34
4.00
2.00
0.00
1 2 3 4 5
F
Average of WT ADM
Age in Years
Average of WT DISC
AVERAGE WEIGHT AT ADMISSION AND DISCHARGE FOR BOYS
A total of 187 children were included in the analysis and 79 boys (42%) were analyzed for the
effect of nutritional interventions at NRC. The maximum average weight gain appears to be in
the age groups 13-24 and 37-48 months at 460 grams. The minimum average weight gain
appears to be in the age group of 37-48 months at 320 grams.
10.00
8.85
8.47
7.64
8.00 7.18
6.00 5.13
Axis Title
4.71
4.00
2.00
0.00
1 2 3 4 5
M
Average of WT ADM
Average of WT DISC
LENGTH OF STAY
The guidelines suggest a 14-day stay for a child’s medical recovery. However the child requires
follow up for another 4-6 months for full recovery, depending upon the child’s progress at
home. The average length of the stay at this NRC was found to be 11 days, with 60% of the
patients leaving before 14 days and out of this set, 60% of them appear to have left on or
before 8th day. The criticality of malnutrition seems obviously of no importance for the parents.
14.00
12.70
12.01
12.00
10.39
10.00
8.43
8.05
No of Days
8.00
Total
6.00
4.00
2.00
0.00
1 2 3 4 5
Age in Years
Defaulters' Pattern
20
10 16 18 Total
8 9 11 12 12 8 9 10
7 7 4
0 Total
2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14
DEFAULTERS
A Defaulter will be a child with SAM admitted to the ward but absent (from the ward) for three
consecutive days without been discharged. There were 126 defaulters (who stayed below 14
days). The observed fact is that parents were only bothered about the symptoms and were
leaving the premises once the symptoms were cured. They had no understanding or interest
on malnourishment and its consequences.
11
10
8
8
No. of Days
7
6
F
5 5
M
5
4 4
4
4
2
2
0
1 2 3 4 5
Age in Years
REFERRAL PRACTICES
Malnourished children are referred to the NRC through frontline community workers like ASHA,
Anganwadi workers, Community Health workers, etc.
Out of 187 children 137 were from Outpatient Department (OPD), 34 were referred from
Anganwadi Workers (AWW) and the rest were distributed according to the graph below.
60
50
No. of Patients Referred
40
30
20
10
0 1
ASHA 2
AWW
CHW 3
NRC Age in Years
4
OPC
OPD 5
OWN
PHC
INTERVIEWS WITH SERVICE PROVIDERS
Interviews with service providers were conducted to check the existing awareness levels and
knowledge levels.
TRAINING
Two Medical Officers, Two Nutrition Counsellor and three Staff nurses underwent training at
“GANDHI HOSPITAL”. It was Facility based training for 3 days.
Training was beneficial for them as they were trained about Functioning of NRC Admission
criteria of SAM children into NRC, about Special therapeutic feeds and feed preparation and
demonstration.
“Apart from treating the patent with therapeutic feeds we also counsel the parents and give
medical treatment for any other complications if any.” (MO, NRC)
“They explained about people and their hygienic conditions responsible for infections in rural
areas. They explained about NRC and its importance.”
TYPES OF SERVICES
Medical Officer, Nutrition Counsellor, and Staff Nurse were aware about the proper admission
criteria for children into NRC.
“When a SAM case comes we examine thoroughly for admission after that they will be given
special feed and checked for appetite test. Then he will be given SF AND F100 EVERY 2ND
hourly.”(MO, NRC).
One of the Nutrition Counsellor stated “Severe Acute Malnourished children, like chidren with
edema, low birthweight, MUAC < 11.5 cm, weight for height” cases are treated at NRC.
Daily morning we prepare the diet plan. Daily we check the weight and according to that we
give above diets. Daily morning we paste the diet in the kitchen.” (NC, NRC)
On enquiring about what kind of counselling aspects are covered. “Nutritional care for young
children, appropriate way of cooking food and how to make nutritious food with available
resources at home. Importance of weighing the children and growth monitoring. Preparation
of complimentary food are covered.” (Nodal Officer, NRC)
“We do cooking and cleaning of the utensils, boil milk, prepare special food and complimentary
food as directed by the madams.” (Cook)
“We have sufficient stock, if no stock available we keep indent and it is seen to be provided
timely.” (Cook)
“We have everything available from spoon to filter and other stocks.” (Cook)
“We clean the ward and the toilets twice daily and also clean the dustbin.” (Attender)
INFRASTRUCTURE
“Pediatric BP apparatus which is necessary for recording the BP while blood transfusion is
necessary.” (M O, NRC) Better if we have a separate play area (NC, NRC).
HUMAN RESOURCES
Shortage of nurses, only three nurses are being appointed in place of eight. It is difficult to
manage the services
“Mothers are not co-operative to feed their children in proper way. They do not want to spend
14 days, not much awareness of feeding practices, even after our repeated counselling
sometimes they do not listen to us.” (NC, NRC)
Services are properly accepted by the patients but not the FOLLOW UPS. (MO, NRC).
“They are not aware of Malnutrition, they feel their children are healthy, and malnutrition is
not an issue. They sometimes refuse the admission; they say that we can manage this at
home”. (NC, NRC)
RECOMMENDATIONS FOR
BETTERMENT OF SERVICES
Awareness of symptoms versus actual problem (weight gain).
ST referrals increased.
“Increase in manpower and awareness in community, referrals form community and from
private practitioners to be increased.” (MO, NRC).
Increase in beds and awareness about NRC services in the community especially in rural areas.
(MO, NRC)
DISCUSSIONS
The study findings showed that the facilities at the NRC were adequate. The infrastructure and
human resources were not optimal. The nursing staff available were only about 40% (3 out of
8). The social worker position was vacant. The infrastructure parameters assessed on the basis
operational guidelines for facility based management of SAM children showed that the
infrastructure parameters such as building area, patient counselling area, clinical equipment
and medicines (except for pediatric BP apparatus), toilets, kitchen and kitchen supplies, hand
washing and hygienic conditions, feeding and weighing were assessed and found to be
adequate.
There is a high default rate with 67% of them leaving before the recommended 14 days.
Symptoms versus weight awareness should be created. A 75% of children left the facility
before 14 days, as soon as the symptoms seem to subside. Only 25% of children stayed for 14
days.
Medical Social Worker (MSW) plays an important role in identifying the SAM children at field
level and encouraging them to visit facility and receive proper treatment. MSW also counsels
the frontline workers about their role of identifying the SAM children. This position being
vacant contributes to the decreased number of cases from field and remote locations.
Knowledge levels of service providers on admission criteria, monitoring and managing of SAM
child and discharge criteria were adequate and their roles were properly described by them as
compared to NRHM guidelines for operation of NRC.
The one year data consisted of 187 children between 0-5 years and children in the age group of
7 to 24 months were found to be admitted in the highest number at 109. This is generally the
age of starting of solid food diet and weaning.
Children were typically admitted for 14 days and discharged (on the 14th day) irrespective of
their attaining/not attaining target weights, but in some cases of inadequate weight gain they
stayed more days. The average length of the stay of children admitted at this NRC was 11 days.
The study results show that most of the children belonged to marginalized population. Most of
them belonged to BC & SC population. This is in accordance with NFHS-3 Survey and the study
by Taneja, et al. Effect of NRCs on Admitted Children which says that children with illiterate
mothers and belonging to caste SC, ST & BC are more malnourished.
The study findings show that 80% of the mothers of admitted children were illiterate. The
mothers attending the Centers had a very limited knowledge about concepts of nutrition.
Mothers are kept in the center so that they can be taught about importance of nutrition and
preparation of nutritious food from locally available food. Mothers are specifically integrated
into the effective care of children and are educated about personal hygiene and to continue it
even after discharge from the center.
A 55% of subject beneficiaries had knowledge about the type of feed provided at the center.
None of them knew about the composition of feed. About 60% of the mothers knew the time
interval between feed. Whereas the study by Taneja, et al. showed that 44% of the mothers
said that they had not been taught the preparation of the therapeutic diets and 56% of the
mothers said that they had been taught the preparation of the therapeutic diets at the center,
although majority of mothers had proper information regarding the time interval of feeds at
the NRCs.
The study findings show there is increase number of defaulters, defaulters being 60% children
in a period of one year. Increase in number of drop outs during each successive follow up is
also a major concern in the study population. A comprehensive review by Ashworth et al.,
comparing inpatient, outpatient, and home-based care and home-based care alone in
Bangladesh revealed a dropout rate of 23% for the inpatient group over a 12 month period, the
highest in the three groups.
NRCs provide care for children with as demonstrated by the high survival rates of the program.
However, outcomes are below optimal. Two program outcomes – the high defaulter rate and
the low recovery rate are of particular concern.
Their average daily weight gain was sub-optimal. Therefore the protocols and therapeutic
foods currently used need to be improved.
CONCLUSION
Facility based in-patient care in treating SAM children is useful for only 25% of the admitted
children as they are the only percentage staying the recommended number of days for effective
treatment.
1. The NRC is effective in improving the condition of admitted children provided they stay
for the recommended length of stay (14 days).
2. The study also shows that parents are focusing only the symptoms rather than on
malnutrition (weight for height).
3. The study also shows that only 3% of the patients are from ST background. This can be
improved by creating awareness among that specific community through
healthworkers, ANMs and AWWs.
4. The female admissions (58%) are more than the male admissions (42%).
However the study found that measures have to be taken to improve the functionality of NRC.
Awareness at community level and community based participation plays a major role for the
success of the program. Treating SAM children requires a multi-sectoral approach to bring in
behavioral change, adaption of hygienic practices, improve child feeding practices. For the
sustainment of the results parental awareness and health education plays a vital role.
LIMITATIONS
Due to very short period of the study of only for two and a half months and shortage of
resources (single person data collection) and high defaulters, data collected is limited. Further
study with large sample size should be done for the proper results.
RECOMMENDATIONS AT COMMUNITY LEVEL
Community mobilization plays major role. Marginalized population should be reached
through volunteers, ASHAS, Anganwadi workers and other community health workers
and should be made known about facility based treatment for malnutrition at NRCs.
They also should monitor the follow up of discharged children and help in decreasing
the number of dropouts.
Increase the transport facility from rural areas and interior and unreachable/tribal hilly
areas. Also create awareness to the parents of the SAM children regarding malnutrition
rather than symptoms.
Train and encourage the health workers, supervisors, AWWs, ASHAs, etc., to create
awareness among the rural people. Conduct convergence meeting monthly once with
all the lane departments (Panchayat raj, ICDS, RWS, Education) and ask them to create
awareness and identify the SAM children for referral and also to follow up after
treatment.
Create awareness among the parents of SAM children about the daily wage
compensation of Rs. 100/- per day for 14 days along with food and accommodation.
IEC activities focused on NRC programs mainly for awareness on target specific name
activities.
Health education programs and programs that include the knowledge about educating
malnutrition at rural areas are advised.
Promotion of low-cost sustainable solutions like optimal infant and young child feeding
so that SAM does not occur. This can be achieved through promotion of breastfeeding,
education of mothers regarding proper infant feeding practices, transferring the skills in
preparation of low-cost high-energy foodstuffs to mother.
Increase the human resources and health care infrastructure to ensure the proper
functionality of NRC.
The location of the NRC is also at a corner of the district, making it very difficult for the
other side of the population to reach the facility. The geographic distributions shows
that most of the patients admitted are coming from nearby the roadways and highways.
Population in the district interiors seems to be not able to utilize the services.
There is only one NRC at the District Hospital for the entire district that plays a major
role in combating the issue of malnutrition but as the district is big so the services are
only utilized by the limited number of population. This is also not in a geographically
central point but rather in a corner. It would be of major help if such model is
established at an area hospital on the other side of the district so that it will be
reachable, and might even decrease the defaulter rate and dropouts.
Encourage health personnel to use every health contact for providing appropriate
nutritional advice and for appropriate breastfeeding and young feeding practices.
Ensuring for optimal utilization of health promoting practices like immunization, growth
monitoring and antenatal checkups.
As always, prevention is better than cure! What we need is promotion of low- cost sustainable
solutions like optimal infant and young child feeding so that SAM does not occur. And
encourage in preparation of nutritious diet with locally available energy rich foods.
REFERENCES
1. Taneja G1, Dixit S, Khatri A, Yesikar V, Raghunath D, Chourasiya S. A Study to Evaluate the
Effect of Nutritional Intervention Measures on Admitted Children in Selected Nutrition
Rehabilitation Centers of Indore and Ujjain Divisions of the State of Madhya Pradesh (India)
Indian Journal of Community Medicine/Vol 37/Issue 2/April 2012
2. Singh K1, Badgaiyan N, RanjanA, Dixit ho et all- Management of children with severe acute
Malnutrition : experiences of nutrition rehabilitation Centers in Uttarpradesh, India. Indian
Pediatrics January 2014, Volume 51, Issue 1, pp 21-25 Indian Pediatr.2014 Jan;51(1):19-20.
3. Elizabeth KE Nutrition rehabilitation centers and locally prepared therapeutic food in the
management of severe acute malnutrition. Pediatrician's perspective. Indian Pediatr.2014
Jan;51(1):19-20.
9. Dasgupta R, Arora NK, Ramji S, Chaturvedi S, Rewal S, Suresh K, et al. Managing childhood
under-nutrition role and scope of health services. Economic andPolitical
Weekly.2012;57:15-9
10. Dalwai S, Choudhury P, Bavedkar SB, Dalal R, Kapil U, Dubey AP, et al. Consensus Statement
of the Indian Academy of Pediatrics on integrated management of severe acute
malnutrition. Indian Pediatr.2013;50:399-04
11. Collins S, Sadler K. Outpatient care for severely malnourished children in emergency relief
programs: A retrospective cohort study. Lancet. 2002; 360:1824-30.
12. Dubey AP, et al. Consensus Statement of the Indian Academy of Pediatrics on integrated
management of severe acute malnutrition. Indian Pediatr.2013;50:399-04.
13. WHO, UNICEF. WHO child growth standards and the identification of severe acute
malnutrition in infants and children A Joint Statement by the World Health Organization and
the United Nations Children’s Fund.2012.
14. NRHM, Madhya Pradesh Facility Based Management of Severe Acute Malnutrition (SAM) in
Children. Reference Manual for Medical and Paramedical Staff of NRC.2011
15. Collins S, Sadler K. Outpatient care for severely malnourished children in emergency relief
programs: A retrospective cohort study. Lancet. 2002; 360:1824-30.
16. Singh K, Badgaiyan, Ranjan A, Dixit HO, Kaushik A, Kushwaha KP, et al. Management of
children with severe acute malnutrition: experience of nutrition rehabilitation center in
Uttar Pradesh, India. Indian Pediatr. 2014;51:21-5.
17. Ashworth A, Khanum S. Cost-effective treatment for severely malnourished children: What
is the best approach? Health Policy Plan 1997;12:115-21.
18. Khanum S, Ashworth A, Huttly SR. Growth, morbidity, and mortality of children in Dhaka
after treatment for severe malnutrition: A prospective study. Am J Clin Nutr 1998;67:940-5.
19. Kadam DD, Kulkarni RN, Subramanium P. Anthropometric and socio- economic profile of
children referred to nutritional rehabilitation Center. Indian Pract 2001;54:476-85.
20. Meshram II, Laxmaiah A, Gal Reddy Ch, Ravindranath M, Venkaiah K, et all Prevalence of
under-nutrition and its correlates among under 3 year- old children in rural areas of
Telangana State, India: Ann Hum Biol.2011 Jan;38(1):93-101.
APPENDICES
I. SERVICE PROVIDERS (STAFF) INTERVIEW GUIDE.
VI. PHOTOS
SERVICE PROVIDERS (STAFF) INTERVIEW GUIDE
Name:
Age/sex:
Qualification:
Experience:
10) Does each nutrition therapeutic feed meet the requirement of the calories needed?
15) Is the kitchen monitored (chance for deadliness) and other things?
MEDICAL OFFICER & NUTRITION COUNSELLOR
INTERVIEW GUIDE
Name:
Age/sex:
Qualification:
Experience:
13) What is your opinion are the construability factors for malnutrition?
14) Does the care takers (Beneficiaries) understand the reason for malnutrition?
15) In your view how are the services received by the beneficiaries?
20) In your opinion do anganwadis (frontline community health workers) have knowledge
about NRC?
21) In your opinion do you think NRC is providing better services for treating malnutrition?
Infrastructure –
• Human resources –
• Duty rooster –
• Sanitation/cleanliness –
• Others –
23)Do the patient follow the discharge criteria and the follow up
25) Do you provide any special care for medically compromised (HIV/TB/any other
complicated)-children?
27) In your opinion any other suggestions that would contribute to the selterment of the
services NRC.
QUESTIONNAIRE FOR BENEFICIARIES
1. Name of the child
2. Name of the parent (father/mother) or guardian
3. Age of the child
4. Sex of the child
5. Number of children
6. Relationship of the guardian with the child
7. Date of delivery
8. Annual family income
9. Education status
10. Occupation
11. Number of children below the age of 5 years
12. Weight of the child at birth
13. Date of birth
14. Place of birth
15. Weight of the child at NRC on day of admission.
16. Weight of child at NRC on day of discharge.
17. Are the service providers at NRC able to explain you about the services that are being
provided at NRC?
18. Can you recall any two services
19. Will you be able to practice at home, the instructions that has been given by the staff?
20. What is the type of feed, composition and time interval of feed at NRC
21. Is the staff able to explain you about personal hygiene and sanitation?
22. What do you know about malnutrition and its causes
23. Is NRC able to create awareness regarding nutritional aspects?
24. Are you able to prepare energy dense child foods using locally available food items?
25. Will you be able to provide nutritious food to the child at home.
26. Are you satisfied with the services delivered from NRC?
CHECK LIST FOR FUNCTIONAL PRACTICES
MONITORING HYGIENE
OBSERVE YES NO COMMENTS
HANDWASHING
MOTHERS CLEANLINESS
GENERAL MAINTENANCE
FOOD STORAGE
DISHWASHING
TOYS
WARMING
OBSERVE YES NO COMMENTS
WEIGHING
OBSERVE YES NO COMMENTS
Table.15
WARD ENVIRONMENT
OBSERVE YES NO COMMENTS
EXPLAINING THE IMPORTANCE OF NRC, 14-DAY STAY, AND NUTRITIOUS FOOD TO THE MOTHERS
LIST OF TABLES
Table No Heading Page No
1 Staff position MO 17
2 Nursing staff position 17
3 Nutrition counsellor staff 18
position
4 Cook cum care taker staff 19
position
5 Attender/cleaner 19
6 Medical social worker 19
7 Ward equipment check list 20
8 Other ward equipments 20
9 Kitchen equipment 21
11 Kitchen supplies 21
11 Monitoring hygiene 22
12 Monitoring ward procedures 26
13 Monitoring medical supplements 28,29
LIST OF FIGURES
FIGURE. NO Heading Page No
1 Number of Participants 31
2 Sex distribution 32
3 Mean weight on admission 33
4 Caste distribution 34
5 Parents Income distribution 35
6 Education status of mothers 36
7 Awareness regarding feeding 37
practices
8 Knowledge about causes of 38
nutrition
9 knowledge about therapeutic 39
foods
10 Knowledge about complimentary 40
food preparation
11 Personal hygiene 41
12 Nutritious food feeding practices 42
13 Age wise average weight gained 44
14 Average weight gained –boys. 45
15 Average weight gained-girls. 46
16 Average length of stay. 47
17 Referral practices. 48
ABBREVIATIONS
AHS Annual Health Survey
HFA Height-for-age
IV Intravenous
IU International Unit
mcg micrograms
MO Medical Officer
NG Nasogastric
NRC Nutrition Rehabilitation Center NFHS National Family Health Survey NC Nutrition
Counsellor
OPD Outpatient Department ORS Oral Rehydration Solution PHC Primary Health Center
SC Scheduled Caste
ST Scheduled Tribe
SD Standard Deviation