Fabrication and Testing of Pratt Bridge Truss Made Up of Bamboo
Fabrication and Testing of Pratt Bridge Truss Made Up of Bamboo
Fabrication and Testing of Pratt Bridge Truss Made Up of Bamboo
SUBMITTED TO
PUNE
SUBMITTED BY
(SCET- Block No - IT B1)
Course Faculty
1. Mr. Manish Khandare
2. Mr. Bhaskar Wabhitkar
3. Mr. Sitaram Suryawanshi
2018-19
SCHOOL OF MECHANICAL & CIVIL ENGINEERING
MIT ACADEMY OF ENGINEERING ALANDI (D)
PUNE
1
An Autonomous Institute
CERTIFICATE
This is to certify that the Credit seminar report entitled “Fabrication and testing of Pratt
Bridge Truss made up of bamboo" submitted by Shreyansh, Abhishek, Vivek, Aditya,
Pooja of School of Computer Engineer and Technology, MIT Academy of Engineering is
record of his own work carried out under my supervision and guidance. The matter enclosed
here is not been submitted elsewhere for award of any degree or diploma.
2
Acknowledgement
We are greatly thankful to the authorities of MIT AOE for providing us the necessary
facilities to successfully carry civil Prototype “Pratt Bridge Truss”
Firstly, we thank and express us solicit gratitude to our teacher Mr. Manish Khandare, Mr.
Bhaskar Wabhitkar, Mr. Sitaram Suryawanshi for their invaluable help and support which
helped us a lot in successfully completing our civil prototype.
Secondly, we express our gratitude to the Staff of Workshop Mr. N.D Sutar for their help in
operating various tools and machine and guiding us regarding material which helped us in the
successful completion of our civil prototype.
We would like to express our sincere gratitude to our Director Mr. Yogesh Bhalerao for
providing the necessary infrastructure to complete our project.
Finally, we would like to express our heartfelt thanks to our parents who were very
supportive both financially and mentally and for their encouragement to achieve our set goals
3
TABLE OF CONTENT
4
2.1 Planning 9
2.2 Reasons for Section Disposal 9
2.3 Workflow and Distribution 9-10
2.4 Cost Estimation 10-12
3. Pre-Testing Analysis 13-16
4. Compression, Tension and joint test 17
4.1 Tension Test 17
4.2 Compression Test 19
4.3 Joint Tension Test 21
5. Fabrication of Pratt bridge 22
5.1 Steps 22-23
5.2 Fabrication of joint 23-24
5.3 Difficulties faced while fabricating truss 24
5.4 Solution 24
6. Test Preparation, Test & Result 25
6.1 Test Preparation 25
6.2 Test 25
6.3 Result 26
7. Conclusion 27
8. Summary 28
9. References 29
5
LIST OF FIGURES
6
19. Fig no 6.2 – Result of Final test
LIST OF TABLES
7
Abstract
Including the undergraduate program of study, today we require that each student should
have basic practical knowledge in all the area of engineering and hence as a part of project
under name “Prototyping” student prepare projects on almost all field related to Engineering
and submits a report on it in consultation with the faculty members supervising the same.
The Bachelor’s Project is included in the curriculum with a view to synthesize the education
gathered during the various courses credited by the student during the undergraduate
program at MITAOE. Creating a report of the project is part of the training of skill building
of the student on of technical communication. Here the emphasis is on presenting a technical
matter in an objective written form.
This document is a record of the requirements for preparation of the Report of the Bachelor
of Technology Project submitted at the end of the SY BTECH. Program of study. It
prescribes typical contents that a Bachelor of Technology Project Report usually should
contain, and provides the format of its presentation. Some guidelines are mandatory to
follow during the preparation of the report, while the others help in improving the
presentation of the work accomplished in the p roject.
8
CHAPTER 1
1. INTRODUCTION
1.1 What is Prototype?
A prototype is an original model, form or an instance that serves as a basis for other
processes. In software technology, the term prototype is a working example through which a
new model or a new version of an existing product can be derived.
A prototype is an example that serves as a basis for future models. Prototyping gives
designers an opportunity to research new alternatives and test the existing design to confirm a
product’s functionality prior to production.
A prototype has many benefits, such as the developer and the implementer getting valuable
feedback from the user even before the actual project is started. The actual process of creating
prototype involves the following steps:
Identify Basic Requirements: Basic requirements are determined, including input and
output data needed.
Review: The clients and the end-users verify the prototype and provide valuable
feedback on additions or deletions. Also necessary changes are made to the final
product.
1
Revise and Improve the Prototype: Using the feedback from the client and end user,
both the specifications and the prototype can be changed accordingly and improved. If
changes are incorporated, a repeat of steps #3 and #4 may be required.
1.2 Bamboo
Bamboo is a strong, fast growing and very sustainable material, having been used structurally
for thousands of years in many parts of the world. In modern times, it has the potential to be
an aesthetically pleasing and low-cost alternative to more conventional materials, such as
timber, as demonstrated by some visually impressive recent structures.
Source:https://media1.picsearch.com/is?ePHrEvDRGDJXFHvBzZ7NWNfT3SKCcP9nzXRiX0x5nlU&height=341
Everyone is trying to be greener these days. We all know that the planet's in trouble, but it can
be difficult to know how to shop responsibly and we're often left feeling helpless. We rely on
retailers to provide information about the eco-status of their products, but in reality this rarely
happens.
That's why we want to tell you about bamboo. It has an amazing growth-rate. It produces
very little waste. It doesn't need herbicides or pesticides or any kind of agricultural chemicals
to grow. Eco-friendly doesn't quite cover it. It really is the superhero of woods (or grasses,
technically, but more of that later).
2
Truss is one of the most important support structures than can hold up roofs, walls, ceilings
etc. without maximal use of materials. For the purpose of learning basics of civil
prototyping, we have decided to build a Baily Truss using cheaper and greener materials like
Bamboo. As bamboo is available readily and is an eco-friendly material whilst making sure
that it is structurally strong, we have decided to use it and cut sections for multiple parts.
Source:
https://www.google.com/search?client=firefox-b-
ab&tbm=isch&q=bamboo+construction&chips=q:bamboo+building,g_3:building+material&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwj7r8D65
87dAhWaaCsKHW2CBwAQ4lYIKigB&biw=1536&bih=750&dpr=1.25
a) Ecologically Friendly: Bamboo is made from natural vegetation. The bamboo plant is a highly
renewable resource that is able to grow to maturity in as little as three to five years. This is much
faster than hardwood trees which can take upwards of twenty years or more to reach maturity.
b) Easy Maintenance: Bamboo is relatively easy to maintain. You just have to sweep or
vacuum it regularly to remove small particle debris. You can also occasional damp mop it, or
clean it with a non-wax, non-alkaline, hardwood or bamboo floor cleanser.
c) Water Resistant: This material is slightly more resistant to water damage, stains, and warping
than hardwood materials, although it is still a concern.
d) Natural Material: The use of natural materials is an important trend in the construction industry
right now. As people are becoming more ecologically conscious they are demanding products
that reflect these values.
3
e) Price: This material is priced at about the same level as most hardwood floors. You will often find
bamboo ranging from about $2-$8 per square foot. You should avoid bargain basement materials
as they are often lower quality castoffs.
f) Durability: There are certain types of bamboo that can be extremely strong, hard, and durable.
Natural, un-carbonized bamboo that was properly harvested and manufactured can be as
durable as red oak.
a) Emission of VOC’s: Bamboo floor planks are manufactured by slicing or shredding the stalk of the
bamboo grass plant and then adhering the pieces back together using heat, pressure, and a
resin-based adhesive. This adhesive can release volatile organic chemicals into the air of an
interior space over time.
b) Humidity: If the floor is installed in a very humid area, the moisture in the air can cause the floor
planks to plump. In a dry environment, the planks can shrink. In both cases, cracks in the bamboo
will be the result.
c) Lack of Hardness: While natural un-carbonized, and strand woven bamboo flooring is relatively
hard and durable, bamboo planks that are darker in color are generally also softer. That is
because the carbonization process used to color the wood also weakens it structurally.
d) Environmentally Ambiguous: Bamboo is a natural material that is made from a highly renewable
resource. However, there are a number of environmental concerns regarding bamboo. The
adhesive used in its construction can contribute to the toxicity of an interior space.
e) Scratches: While a bamboo floor is relatively easy to maintain it is nearly impossible to keep it
perfect if it is used regularly. There are a wide variety of things that can cause nasty scratches on
the surface of a bamboo floor.
Bamboo has been used for eons for many applications, from a food source to a building
material.
1. From picture frames to room dividing screens, bamboo can make some elegant
and exotic decorations for the home
4
2. More and more furniture, flooring, and even homes are being built with bamboo.
3. The bamboo fibres being used in fabrics and clothing.
4. The bamboo is widely used for construction purposes throughout the world. It can
support a large amount of weight, which makes it ideal for constructing bridges in
the rural parts.
5. In Asia especially, bamboo is widely used for cooking purposes. In lots of Asian
dishes, bamboo shoots are used. Bamboo beer is also quite famous in Africa and
Asia
6. Bamboo is used to make musical instruments in a majority of Asian countries. The
most popular instrument being the Flute.
7. Utensils made of Bamboo are in use for a long time. Utensils like Spoons, Spoon
holders, Chopping boards, skewer sticks, knife holders, cups, bowls, dish holders,
salt shakers etc.
8. Bamboo is being used as medicine in China for generations. Bamboo has
medicinal characteristics. It can cure cold, flu, fever etc
9. Long-time source of biomass for industry.
10. Soil stabilization, wind break, urban waste water treatment and reduction of
nitrates contamination
Source:https://media5.picsearch.com/is?WVveftN6KczJZTuS_h9IYSXRfCVRIfornSeR_RHAVro&height=240
1. Culm
2. Nodal ring
3. Supernodal ridge
4. Sheath scar
5. Limb
5
6. Branch Node
7. Sulcus Grove
8. Truss
Source:-https://www.google.com/search?
q=bamboo+parts&client=firefoxb&tbm=isch&source=iu&ictx=1&fir=Hethmg0605uj0M%253A
%252Cl3moGC8e1B7FYM
%252C_&usg=AFrqEzfWlUlQFSrAEnM5SpOwBhMjY3CQA&sa=X&ved=2ahUKEwiGj7nXo
bLdAhXLK48KHbKpAH0Q9QEwA3oECAMQCg#imgrc=Hethmg0605uj0M:
6
Octet Truss.
Warren Truss.
Baltimore Truss.
Pratt Truss.
The Warren Truss uses equilateral triangles to spread out the loads on the bridge. This is
opposed to the Neville Truss which used isosceles triangles. The equilateral triangles
minimize the forces to only compression and tension.
7
III). Baltimore Truss: -
The Baltimore truss is a subclass of the Pratt truss. A Baltimore truss has additional bracing in
the lower section of the truss to prevent buckling in the compression members and to control
deflection.
It is mainly used for rail bridges, showing off a simple and very strong design. Pratt truss uses
the intersection of the verticals and the lower horizontal tension members to anchor the
supports for the short-span girders under the tracks (among other things).
8
Fig no – 1.9 (Pratt truss)
CHAPTER 2
Planning is the development of goals, strategies, task lists and schedules required to achieve
the objectives of project. The planning process is a fundamental function of management and
should result in the best possible degree of need satisfaction given the resources available.
In the task of analysis reversed Baltimore truss we arranged all the operations which are
going to perform in order
9
• Over-sandpapering a section leads to obtain thin sections.
• Improper chiseling giving thin sections.
• Wearing off of pins while hammering them.
• Bending of keys during insertion in joints.
• Direct costs
• Indirect costs
The model cost estimation for a period of 5 days has been analysed to give an insight of total
expenditure. Worst cases have been accounted for and this might change the costs from what
has been provided in the estimation.
10
Fig no. 2.1
A. Direct Cost
1. Material cost
Cost of bamboo per meter = 26 Rs
Total length of bamboo(meter) = 4x2.1 + 0.13x10 + 4x0.55 = 12 m
Total cost of Bamboo = 26 Rs x 12 m = R312
Cost of keys = 1m = 26 Rs
Wastage of bamboo material=2m=52 Rs
2. Electricity Cost
Rate of electricity= Rs 9.5/unit
Units consumed =18 unit (approx.)
Total cost of electricity=18 unit *9.5 Rs
=171 Rs
11
TOTAL DIRECT COST=312+26+52+171 = Rs 561
B. Indirect Cost
1. Labour cost
Rate of skilled labour = Rs 500/day
Rate of semi-skilled labour = Rs 400/day
Rate of unskilled labour = Rs 300/day
2. Hiring of machine
a. Cut saw machine=Rs 1000/day
b. Drilling machine=2*600 Rs/day =1200 Rs
c. Hacksaw =2*100 Rs/day =200 Rs
12
4 Electricity 18 unit 9.5 Rs/unit 171 Rs
5 Labour 5 1900 Rs/day 3800 Rs
6 Transport N/A 200 Rs 200 Rs
Table. 2.1
CHAPTER 3
13
Fig no.3.1 (Diagram with Support condition)
Here,
L = 2100 mm
HT = 230 mm
Hence, α = tan-1 (230/500) = 24.7
Since the diagram is symmetric along the member CH (or y-axis), we only need to calculate
the forces for one half of the structure as the other half side forces will be exactly same.
1) Applying conditions of Equilibrium:
∑ Fx = 0
∑ Fy = 0 : Vi + Vj = P
2Vi = P
Vi = P/2 (Since, Vi = Vj)
∑ Mj = 0
2) Using Joints method:
14
At joint A:
∑ Fx = 0:
FAB = 0
∑ Fy = 0:
FAJ = 0
At joint J:
∑ Fx = 0:
FJBCos α + FJI = 0
∑ Fy = 0:
Vj + FJBSin α = 0
At joint B:
∑ Fx = 0:
FJBCos α + FBC = 0
∑ Fy = 0:
-FBI+ FJBSin α = 0
FBC = -1.09 P
FBI = 0.5 P
At joint I:
∑ Fx = 0:
-FIJ + FIH + FICCos α = 0
∑ Fy = 0:
15
FBI+ FICSin α = 0
At joint C:
∑ Fx = 0
∑ Fy = 0:
VI P/2 Compression
FAB 0 N/A
FAJ 0 N/A
16
FBC 1.09 P Compression
FCH 2P Tension
FEF 0 N/A
FED 0 N/A
Table. 3.1
CHAPTER 4
For tension test, Universal testing Machine was used. It is the fundamental test in which a
sample is subjected to a controlled tension until failure. In this truss is only subjected to
tension and compression.
17
In this testing we were carried out tension test of the sample member with the help of
machine
4.1.2 Setup
18
4 0.725692 47.575 31.86 10.45 3029.796 0.0820
5 0.676659 41.69 32.356 10.16 2827.84 0.0748
200
6 0.647239 46.105 35.936 10.95 3935.03 0.0641
Table No. 4.1
4.1.4 Conclusion:
The Compression test is carried out on the Member of the truss to determine the compression
failure of the sample member truss. This test is carried out because the truss is only subjected
to tension and compression.
In the pre-test analysis we concluded, that a bamboo truss can undergo either a tension force
or a compression force. Compression test specimens were fabricated by cutting bamboo in
different sizes namely 5cm, 10cm, 15cm, 20cm, 25cm and 30cm. Dimensions were
measured with help of Vernier caliper. The compression test was carried out on the universal
compression testing machine.
19
4.2.1 Machine and Setup
√ I
A
=1000P/A*
(mm)
10-3
1 50 46.58 14.98 6111.33 228611.09 6.12 6.94 47.06 7.7
2 100 42.84 24.03 3951.57 148968.52 6.158 13.80 35.92 9.1
20
3 150 42.02 16.5 4691.75 149397.81 5.64 22.6 37.12 7.92
4 200 40.12 17.83 4058.01 122217.40 5.49 30.96 35.25 8.69
5 250 39.7 20.32 3654.26 113567.16 5.575 38.12 32.99 9.03
6 300 39.63 20.55 3607.28 112324.05 5.58 45.69 34.38 9.53
Table no. 4.2
4.2.3. Conclusion
Joint tension test is used to determine tension which is acted upon the sample and failure of
the joints or keys. For this test, machine is required. In this test, sample member is prepared
from bamboo in the form of T joint with all pins and keys are attached to it.
4.3.1 Setup
21
Fig no. 4.3
4.3.2 Observation
1 233 2283.4
2 346 3390.8
3 430 4214.0
4 367 3596.6
5 325 3185
6 245 2401
4.3.3 Conclusion
Locking Key is the weakest part of the joint which is subjected to the failure first.
CHAPTER 5
22
Fabrication process contains various systematic operation which is start from calculation and
planning to finishing and planning. So, this fabrication part plays important stage for any
product. This operation like working, measuring, cutting, joining, grinding drilling.
5.1 Steps
1. Select straight and good quality bamboo which has specific difference between two
trusses.
2. As per reference of CMS machine, first of all take specific dimensions and mark on given
bamboo.
3. Cutting of bamboo using chop saw machine.
4. Take bevel and fish mouth cut as per requirement.
5. Grinding the end edges of the bamboo.
6. Drilling for the central keys per diagram.
7. Fabrication of central keys and locking keys.
8. Joining the cross members to the bottom member
9. Drilling hole of locking keys
10. Insert the locking keys
11. Joining the cross members to each other’s.
12. Joining of top members of second truss.
13. Grinding to extra part of central keys and locking keys and finishing.
14. Painting on warren truss.
1. JOINT A
23
Joint A is prepared by interconnection between the link AB and AE. In these joint the
link AB is cut in the form of bevel angle cut and drilling hole vertically upward
through members. After that central key is inserted and finally two locking one for both
members are put in and lock the joint.
2. JOINT E
The joint E is situated at the lower middle of the truss. In these joint four links AE, CE, BE,
DE are interconnection to each other. All the ends of the link CE, BE have bevel angel cut. In
these joint first link AE and BE are joined by the central keys and locked by locking key. In
these joint the face of the bevel cut plane is parallel to the surface of the surface of link AE
and DE.
These joints are used to connect the both trusses in parallel manner and to transfer the land
the joints only. There are total 4 connecting member are used in the warren truss bridge two at
the upper side and two at the lower side. In this joint the connecting links have fish mouth
end at both ends. The connection link is perpendicular to the both upper links. This process is
similarly done for all the end of the connecting links.
24
Fig No 5.3 (Connecting links)
5.3 Difficulties faced while fabricating Pratt truss and possible solutions or precautions:
5.4 Solution
• Use straight circular bamboo with good strength and good alignment
• Use skilled labours for drilling
• Fix thee member rigidly while joining it
25
CHAPTER 6
In this compression testing on Pratt truss bridge is supported in the compression testing
machine by wooden pallets. Then the load is applied slowly till the failure of the bridge.
6.2 Test
In the testing the load applied by the machine is transfer to the joint point of Pratt truss bridge
as truss subjected to loading at joint only. There is only tension and compression occurred in
the bridge, top member is subjected to the compression and bottom member are subjected to
the tension.
6.2.1 Setup
The setup for the compression test of Pratt truss bridge is as follows:
26
6.3 Result
The failure of Pratt truss bridge in the universal testing machine takes the load of 15.156 KN.
During testing, load increases gradually stress also increases.
The bottom right key goes failure first.
27
CHAPTER 7
7. Conclusions
• By performing this civil prototyping course, we got acquainted with various
interesting facts about bamboo and its uses in various structures. Also, we came to
know that the role of importance of accuracy in building structures.
• Introduction and interesting facts about bamboo were studied.
• Pre-test analysis is needed to be done for verification.
• The strength of failure member should be taken in consideration while designing and
fabricating truss.
• The predicted analysis was seen that major failure was seen in joints.
• Proper planning was done and analyses the difficulties to be faced while actual
construction.
• Method of joint was studied and study the magnitude of forces applying on members.
• Cost analysis was done to make truss in an economical way.
• Tests such as compression, tension and joint tests were done on specimens and find
the failure on joints.
• The weakest part is the key as it failed first.
28
SUMMARY
In the civil prototyping we are learnt about civil structures and trusses structure and locking
system
• In this prototype we were learn about the Fabrication, analysis and testing of the
warrant truss. In which two trusses are fabricated and by joining both we form pratt
truss.
• We also learnt, types of cuts such as fish mouth and bevel cut etc.
• Then, pre-test analysis is done to determine the forces and dimension of links in truss
by method of joints.
• Various test like Tension, compression and joint tension test on bamboo are
performed.
• Testing of structure is done using UTM machine
29
REFERENCES
file:///C:/Users/HP/Downloads/civil-BAMBOO-AS-A-BUILDING-MATERIAL-
report.pdf
https://www.garrettsbridges.com/design/pratt-truss/
https://www.guaduabamboo.com/working-with-bamboo/joining-bamboo
https://www.google.com/url?
sa=t&rct=j&q=&esrc=s&source=web&cd=1&cad=rja&uact=8& ved=2ahUKEwjps5
mhm9fdAhXMq48KHWr-
BIQQFjAAegQIAxAB&url=https%3A%2F%2Fen.wikipedia.org%2Fwiki
%2FBamboo&usg= AOvVaw33IShlwbvLfX9 HKt7tDxrf
http://www.softschools.com/facts/plants/bamboo_facts/563/
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bamboo#Construction
https://www.guaduabamboo.com/species/
https://english.vietnamnet.vn/fms/art-entertainment/106298/three-worldfamous-
bamboo-houses-in- vietnam.html
https://www.guaduabamboo.com/construction/advantages-of-building-with-bamboo
https://elemental.green/the-pros-and-cons-of-bamboo-in-green-building/
https://www.bamboo-earth-architecture-construction.com/bamboo-treatment/
http://bamboo.wikispaces.asu.edu/7.+Types+of+Joints
https://www.guaduabamboo.com/identification/bamboo-stem-anatomy
30
Group Photo
31