Victims Not Criminals: Psychosocial Dynamics of Juvenile Delinquency in The Philippines
Victims Not Criminals: Psychosocial Dynamics of Juvenile Delinquency in The Philippines
Victims Not Criminals: Psychosocial Dynamics of Juvenile Delinquency in The Philippines
the Philippines
Department of Psychology
Research Methods
By
October 2018
I. The Problem and its Background
Introduction
children as well as for the different cases they are involved in (as cited
above mentioned.
“A child nine (9) years of age and above but below eighteen (18) years
Juvenile Delinquency Act of 2006 which stated that a child will take
1
criminal responsibility if he/she committed a heinous crime such as rape,
the minimum age of criminal liability to nine (9) years old. Additionally,
committing crimes because of the fact that they can get away with it.
They also stated that adults are using these children to commit crimes.
However, some lawmakers including the one who wrote the Juvenile
act, Senator Kiko Pangilinan stated that the gravity of the crime should
be considered not the age of the child. “Children who steal to have
something to eat should not be treated the same way as children who
Children in conflict with the law are the victims of the failure of the
This calls for assistance of the whole society to provide guidance for the
misled children who made wrong choices. On the other hand, Messy
2
products provide opportunities for children at risk to improve the quality
of their life and make a living not only for themselves but also for their
A recent survey conducted by the Pulse Asia about the minimum age
regarding the issue. Respondents were asked to choose from nine (9)
years old, twelve (12) years old and fifteen (15) years old. Results of the
survey stated that only nine (9) percent of the respondents answered
that children as young as nine (9) years old should be held accountable
for criminal cases, while twenty (20) percent stated that it should be
lower to twelve (12) years old. Moreover, fifty-five (55) percent of the
respondents stated that the minimum age of fifteen (15) should remain
(Rappler, 2016).
that led fifteen (15) children in conflict with the youth in Bahay Pagasa,
3
Background of the Study
Republic Act No. 9344 or the “Juvenile Justice and Welfare Act”
with children at risk and children in conflict with the law, which provides
ensure their normal growth and development. Instead of using the word
R.A. No. 9344, “Child” is a person under the age of eighteen (18) years.
While “Child at Risk” refers to a child who is vulnerable to and at the risk
criminality or drug abuse. “Child in Conflict with the Law” or CICL on the
other hand refers to a child who is alleged as, accused of, or adjudged
Under Republic Act 10630, offences which only apply to a child and not
disobedience and the like. Before R.A. No. 9344 was enacted, children
4
at risk and CICL were treated much like adult offenders as when former
the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child (UNCRC), the
R.A. No. 9344 intends to deal with these children without resorting to
future offences.
deviates from the normal pattern of rules and regulations, custom and
culture which the society does not accept” (as cited in Bocar, 2012).
Intersect in 2016 reported that there are 1,297 children in conflict with
the law for the first quarter of 2016 alone consists of 1,119 males and
178 females. 57.7% of CICL came from poor or without stable income,
abuse. Moreover, males ages between 14 and 17 years old are the
has low educational attainment and has stopped schooling and belongs
5
to a family of six are the factors common among these youths. Property-
related crimes such as theft are the most frequent offense they commit.
as theft and drug abuse are the common offense made by the youth.
the general public should focus more in addressing the issue of poverty
liability will be lower. The problem is not the children, there is a bigger
plate.
Studies regarding the gender, social class and biological factor are
law being the subject of the study, they are adolescents who are still in
6
psychosocial and decision-making capacity is not comparable to the
adults. They also elaborated that criminalizing children will result to low
the general public what are the possible solution and intervention for the
youth.
Research Locale
providing short-term residential care for children in conflict with the law
who are above fifteen (15) but below eighteen (18) years of age who are
7
asa'. The team will work on the individualized intervention plan with the
personal, familial and social may be one risk factor for these children.
Having that said, the state must give further assistance to these children
Act of 2006 indicating that a children as young as thirteen (13) years old
may experience identity crisis that may lead to withdrawal from the
normal life stages (as cited in Schultz & Schultz, 2005). More so,
to juvenile delinquency yet, local studies are still limited. Thus, this study
will investigate the (1) personal factor that lead to committing crimes (2)
8
Hypothesis
providing help for the family and (3) being out of school. Environment
juvenile offense committed are (1) thief and (2) drug use.
conflict with law who committed crime for the first time to preclude those
solely from the child that might cause to recall bias. Knowing they are
neutrality and objectivity may be affected. The researcher is not after the
Parañaque City.
9
Significance of the Study
Results of this study will be beneficial for the following (1) Parents.
bestow to the children. (2) Local Government. This study may serve as
in Conflict with the Law. More so, seminars for parents and guardians
supervision for these children. (3) Social Workers. Through this study,
they may gain insights that will aid them to provide counselling that will
redirect these children’s thoughts and behaviors. Lastly, this study will
will need in their research that has a similarity in the current paper. It
juvenile delinquency.
Definition of Terms
as a crime.
10
child who is alleged as, accused of, or adjudged as, having
11
II. Review of Related Literature and Studies
Related Literatures
one of the most important assets of every nation and the foundation of
a nation begins with education. The family, being the one who molds the
not only the physiological needs but also the intrapersonal needs. The
Howell (2009) in his book stated that there are myths about juvenile
problem in the past than it is today. (2) delinquency in the past was about
the same as it is today. (3) delinquency was a less serious problem than
it is today. These are belief that are strongly held by the general public
in the past that are based on little information. These myths are not
necessarily false however, people do not know whether they are true or
times. This refers to the new breeds of offenders. These are youth who
has no respect for the human life and has no sense of the future. They
12
Public health considers juvenile delinquency as an epidemic health
concern in the 90’s. Although evidence does not necessarily support the
starting the early times. The literature specified the importance of the
and a lot of factors are targeted by the second phase of the continuum.
youth who has serious physical fight with peers or family members,
13
or threats of suicide. Students who are seen to have or had involved in
of the problematic behavior, gravity of the crime, age, and the frequency.
Related Studies
hard and fast of behaviors that are not in line with the norm and ethics
skipping school and much more. Related research into this complex
factors (Taskiran, Mutluer, Tufan & Semerci, 2018; Garg & Prusty, 2017;
Ndaita, 2017; Delos Santos, Padawil & Vedaña, 2016; Sabia, 2016;
14
Underwood & Washington, 2016; Abella, 2016; Siddique, 2016; Staden,
2015; Rahman, 2014; Sahmey, 2013; Ttale, 2013; Kostic, 2013; Bocar,
2012; Ardoin & Bartling, 2010; Dogar, Akhwanzada, Bajwa, Haider, &
Asmet, 2010; Schwalbe & Maschi, 2008; Gutierrez & Shoemaker, 2007;
Alampay, 2006).
Kostic, 2013 and Ardoin & Bartling, 2010 in their study tackled a
use or abuse in the family, parent or sibling who have been incarcerated,
towards the child. It has been proven that victims of violence may also
15
father usually takes after them as these behaviors sends a negative
crime severity and gender or age yet, younger males were engaged with
stated in the study is that substance use in the family appeared to have
Mutluer, Tufan & Semerci, 2018). This study relates to Garg & Prusty in
Dysfunctional family, large family size, low socio economic status, harsh
punishments, drugs use and abuse in the family, low attention and
youth. On the other hand, violent video games, watching too much
16
juvenile delinquency. Another critical risk assumes that provoke youth
bad behaviors are low experiences and low school accomplishment, low
Family, being the building block of the society plays an important role
from parents why they are not involved include for example the
17
study coincides with this revealed that family bonding is considered to
their risk of maladaptive outcomes. Despite the fact that theorists and
delinquency for the adolescent sample in this study with one exception.
anxiety and school problems, more so than the children in two parent
families. The lack of a male presence seems not to be less critical than
the lack of male income in the family. Some of these problems may be
The highest percentage of drunk drivers was found among males who
18
of the mother. Also, among females with single-parent family
parent family and lack of a father during childhood constituted the family
type as the most likely cause of criminality. When a mother raises a child
explanation for these findings is not that the lack of the father per se
affects the child but rather its being a marker of genetic vulnerability.
especially those who are slum dwellers are being deprived of education
necessities such as water use for both drinking and toilet use are hardly
given for these people. More so, they often get sick because of the
unhealthy and dirty environment in the slum but they do not get better
treatment from the doctors in the hospital or good clinic due to their
19
social controls, increased crime rates, exposure to community disorder
potential for youth to learn antisocial behaviors from adults and peers in
with deviant peers can influence youths’ positive attitudes towards and
indicated that the issues of peer pressure are a strong predictor for
20
The role of education was seen as an influential means to prevent
express themselves easily, who are easily affected by peer pressure and
who acts very impulsively (Staden, 2015). Another study reported that
21
behaviors. In this case, self-control may have a buffering effect against
of delinquency for the sample in the study. Findings of the study have
22
norms and increase engagement in delinquency. Feeling of revenge as
by externalizing their blame for failures that lead to anger and hostility.
Conflicts in love affair at the same time as having low self-esteem has a
the expected directions. One would expect, for instance, that officers
their interventions and might make fewer contacts with youths on their
behalf. Alternatively, one would expect that officer who strongly endorse
supervision and would devote more time to each case. Younger youths
23
independence from older youths, allowing them the freedom to make
2008).
stated that delinquency prevalence varies for males and males and the
exam with 63%, truancy with 42%, lying about age, 29% sneaking out
of the house without the parent’s knowledge, 23% drinking alcohol, 43%,
smoking 39% and 7% of the respondents ran away from home. Property
than PHP50) moderate theft (less than PHP100) and grand theft (more
than PHP500), avoiding payment for fares and foods, stealing money
from family members, swindling for money, motor vehicle theft and
forcibly opening a car is listed. For violent offenses, rates are lowest
24
someone with intent to seriously harm or kill at 2%. On the other hand,
participation in group fights 21%. The author also stresses in his study
a higher rate of involvement to gang fights in the study. More so, few
prevalence admissions. The present findings that youth from the lower
class are, statistically speaking, no more delinquent than youth from the
middle and upper income groups and that upper-status youth have the
& Shoemaker, 2007). Another related study looked into the four factors
investigated also which among the factors pushes at all times or never
25
pushes the youth to engage in law breaking activities. Findings of the
study reported that the teachers, students and parents manifested that
police officers and teachers as a factor that frequently pushes the young
that environment would push the youth to commit wrong doings. The
against the law. However, police officers believed that school is often
the factor that pushes the youth to do erroneous acts. Lastly, other
officer as never or not at all predictors that push the youth to commit
youth were only through elementary level of schooling. The result also
showed that family size is a factor to which these children went out and
occupy the streets of Manila and other provinces where most of these
children were taken from. Their parents though employed still cannot
26
support their family’s need because of the family sized which is
comprised of 7 members and more. The findings also revealed that the
most prominent internal factor that affects a child delinquent act is due
27
counterbalance or compensate for the imperfections of family and
study asserted that the bad influence of a repeat juvenile offender exerts
a strong force on kids nearby. It was believed that this force of influence
could be the reason certain areas become known for a particular type of
of one criminal resident. The related study concludes that there a strong
positive relationship between internal and external factors was found out
(Abella, 2016).
the juvenile justice and welfare law in an urban poor city in the
28
during investigation. Further, youth detention homes are still at scarce
care support services for juvenile delinquents are not provided. Slightly
receiving bribes from parents of children in conflict with the law is also
for children in conflict with the law by improving their safety, fairness and
each developing child, their family and the community are reinforced.
Family, school, peer and the community have important effects on the
is still limited.
29
Synthesis
of related data to back up the current study. It has been discovered that
environment that interact with each other. It has been discovered that
for their children up to the time when they would be in the position that
they can stand on their own. This includes providing the children’s
parents, re-marriage, working parents, large family size and etc. has
attainment. In addition, minors get into crime due to peer pressure and
behind bars will not resolve the kind of factors which caused their
30
Communities must also help the government to reduce number of
Majority of the reviewed literatures and studies are foreign and there
are only several local literatures that tackles about the variables. The
studies locally.
Theoretical Framework
study. This theory attempts to describe that all forms of behavior can be
the one considered to be the role model. Individuals are more influenced
the behavior of a child model in the same room, a child in a film, and a
31
filmed cartoon character, the extent of the modeling decreased as the
similarity between the model and the subject decreased. The children
cited in Schultz & Schultz, 2005). Minors violent behavior may be a result
of behavior modelling from one of the role models (Serbia, 2013). In the
Philippine context, children in conflict with the law take after their parent
Prusty, 2017; Ndaita, 2017; Delos Santos, Padawil & Vedaña, 2016;
2016; Staden, 2015; Rahman, 2014; Sahmey, 2013; Ttale, 2013; Kostic,
Bajwa, Haider, & Asmet, 2010; Schwalbe & Maschi, 2008; Gutierrez &
to meet and maintain them reduces it. People who are low in self-
32
confidence and self-esteem are much more likely to imitate a model’s
life events. They believe any effort they make is futile. When they
efficacy will not even attempt to cope because they are convinced that
nothing they do will make a difference (Schultz & Schultz, 2005). Low
Siblings, peers and other adults are added role model as the child is
abilities and problem solving skills which are vital to efficient adult
33
in development because this is where transitional experiences happen.
of the choice they can attain whether about their gender preference,
Conceptual Framework
Psychosocial Juvenile
Factor Delinquency
The study will explore the psychosocial factors that could influence
hypothesis are indicated in the study which are gathered from other
age. In the current paper, the research will focus solely on the
34
first time and are currently under the supervision of Bahay Pagasa in
35
III. Methodology
This chapter presents the method the researcher will use toward a
gathering data and the statistical tool used for analyzing the gathered
data.
Research Design
36
Respondents of the Study
The participants of the study are fifteen (15) children in conflict with
the law who are currently staying at Bahay Pagasa, Parañaque City. The
selecting the sample is (1) committed a juvenile offense for the first time.
(1) engaged in juvenile act twice or more (2) not able to read, write
and/or comprehend any form of language, (3) not able to perform simple
task physically or mentally and/or (4) follow simple instructions from the
researchers.
Research Instrument
37
Data Gathering Procedure
Groundwork stage
• researcher generated the
research idea,
• literatures were
reviewed,
• research problem was
identified,
• hypothesis was
formulated,
• research begand
Organization Stage
• consent and author's
permission letters were
prepared
• participants and locale was
chosen,
• draft for chapters 1 to 3 will
be done
38
The researcher of the study will orient and brief respondents
regarding the objective of the study, the process of data collection and
the right and benefit of all individuals who will be involve in the study.
factor influencing juvenile delinquent and possible ways to avoid it. It will
respected. Any further explanation regarding the study, its benefit, and
Treatment of Data
39
comprehensive process wherein the researcher identifies themes
The current paper adopts the Braun & Clarke’s Thematic Analysis
thematic analysis. First step is to become familiar with the data, before
going any further in doing the analysis, the researcher must be very
familiar with the data by re-reading it. Next step is to generate initial
definition of the themes or basically what the theme is all about, how
does the themes relate to each other and to the research questions.
40
References
Abella, J. L. (2016). Extent of the Factors Influencing the Delinquent Acts among
Children in Conflict with the Law. Journal of Child & Adolescent Behavior.
doi:10.4172/2375-4494.1000288
pjp01/article/download/1403/1335
https://fac.ksu.edu.sa/sites/default/files/ta_thematic_analysis_dr_mohamm
ed_alhojailan.pdf
Ardoin, L., & Bartling, C. (2010). Biological, Psychological, and Sociological Effects
11%20Ardoin%204-06.pdf
http://ssrn.com/abstract=2191280
41
Braun, V. & Clarke, V. (2006) Using thematic analysis in psychology. Qualitative
http://dx.doi.org/10.1191/1478088706qp063oa
congress-lower-age-criminal-liability-death-penalty
Semi-3629.html
Congress of the Philippines. (2013) Republic Act No. 10630. Retrieved from
https://www.lawphil.net/statutes/repacts/ra2013/ra_10630_2013.html
Congress of the Philippines. (2006) Republic Act No. 9344. Retrieved from
https://www.lawphil.net/statutes/repacts/ra2006/ra_9344_2006.html
42
Cullen, S. (2017). Stories and Statistics of Children Behind Bars. Preda.org.
statistics-of-children-behind-bars/
Delos Santos, M. M., Padawil, A. K., & Vedaña, M. B. (2016). Juvenile Justice and
0216022.pdf
_rules_and_regulations_irrs/Revised-Implementing-Rules-and
Regulations-of-RA-9344-as-amended-by-RA-10630.pdf
Dogar, I.A., Akhwanzada, W.A., Bajwa, A., Haider, N., & Asmat, A. (2010). Self
ttp://apmc.com.pk/vol-4-no-2-2010/
43
Elemia, C. (2016). Pangilinan to Alvarez: Gravity of crime, not kids' age, should
930-kiko-pangilinan-lowering-age-criminal-responsibility-juvenile-justice
School Students in Metro Manila: Gender and Social Class. Youth &
/40/1/55
(Macr): Why The Macr Should Not Be Lowered. Intersect 3(2). Retrieved
from http://www.jjcicsi.org.ph/wp-content/uploads/2016/10/IQF-Vol-III-No-
2MACR.pdf?fbclid=IwAR3F1ZaGkyoGu6GR0v5bDTBI3IcGtHOCCX9XEt3
zCkKtzRb0VLgp3vupGw4
44
Kostić, M. (2013). Biological and Psychological Theories on Juvenile Delinquency.
lap201301/lap201301-01.pdf
Maguire, M., & Delahunt, B. (2017). Doing a Thematic Analysis: A Practical, Step-
by-Step Guide for Learning and Teaching Scholars. All Ireland Journal of
from http://ojs.aishe.org/index.php/aishe-j/article/view/335
Mathers, N., Fox, N. & Hunn, A. (2002). Trent Focus for Research and
courses/CUAcourses/lsc745/sp06/Interviews.pdf
http://erepository.uonbi.ac.ke/bitstream/handle/11295/102303/Tiampati_P
sychosocial%20Factors%20Influencing%20Juvenile%20Delinquency%20
Among%20Girls%20at%20Kirigiti%20and%20Dagoretti%20Rehabilitation
%20Centres.pdf?sequence=1&isAllowed=y
45
Ospina, S. (2004). Qualitative Research. Encyclopedia of Leadership. Retrieved
from https://ualr.edu/interdisciplinary/files/2010/03/Qualitative_Research.
Passion, P. (2017). More Rehab Homes for Child Offenders to be built in 2018.
rehabilitation-children-conflict-law-2018-dswd-budget
and Children in Conflict with the Law. Quezon City. Retrieved from
http://www.pnp.gov.ph/images/Manuals_and_Guides/DIDM/MANUAL-IN-
HANDLING-CASES-OF-CHILDREN-AT-RISK-AND-CHILDREN-IN-
CONFLICT-WITH-THE-LAW.pdf
201608pappositionpaperhb002-f.pdf
46
Rahman, H. (2014). Juvenile Delinquency in the Slum Community: A Study on
70?show=full
majority-filipinos-reject-lower-age-criminal-liability-pulse-asia
er=https://www.google.com/&httpsredir=1&article=3333&context=dissertati
ons
.ac.in/4634/1/411HS1010.pdf
Cengage Learning.
47
Schwalbe, C. S., & Maschi, T. (2008). Investigating Probation Strategies with
10.1007/s10979-008-9158-4
doi:10.13140/RG.2.1.3067.7923
http://etd.uwc.ac.za/xmlui/handle/11394/5003
https://www.pressreader.com/philippines/sunstarp-davao/20151201/28150
5045140043
Taskiran, S., Mutluer, T., Tufan, A., & Semerci, B. (2018). Understanding the
48
Tlale, L. D. (2013). Understanding and Giving Support to Children in Conflict with
http://uir.unisa.ac.za/bitstream/handle/10500/11963/thesis_tlale_ldn.pdf?s
equence=1&isAllowed=y
Underwood, L. A., & Washington, A. (2016). Mental Illness and Juvenile Offenders.
49