5
5
5
Module 5.1.3
Astronomy & Cosmology
5.1.3.A Astronomical distance measurements
Topic Notes
Name:__________
-1-
Aquinas College Physics Module 5.1.3: Astronomy & Cosmology
www.alevelphysicsonline.com/astrophysics
Excellent video tutorials made by an A level physics teacher for A level physics students.
If you need to go over any concepts again, this is the first place that you should look.
Login Username: physics@aquinas.ac.uk Password: 1234
www.aquinasphysics.com/kerboodle.html
isaacphysics.org/
www.gojimo.com/
-2-
Aquinas College Physics Module 5.1.3: Astronomy & Cosmology
Studentship checklist
Tick the boxes when you have completed each of the tasks to do with this topic:
Have you…
Completed the notes in this booklet so that all important details are recorded?
Answered all the questions in the main part of this booklet, practising the key skills needed
Made further notes from Prezis / videos / other sources in the spaces provided throughout the booklet
Completed and marked the homework booklet(s) associated with this topic?
Watched the video explaining all the questions on the homework(s) on this topic and taken detailed notes
of any corrections?
Found extra questions related to this topic to answer (e.g. on IsaacPhysics ; physicsandmathstutor.com ; the
stretch & challenge questions at the front of each physics lab.)?
Made revision resources for this topic (mind-maps / flashcards etc.)?
Found some stretch & challenge questions to practice at the front of the physics lab?
Which are the trickiest parts of this topic that you will focus your revision on when it comes to exam time?
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
-3-
Aquinas College Physics Module 5.1.3: Astronomy & Cosmology
-4-
Aquinas College Physics Module 5.1.3: Astronomy & Cosmology
Contents
Studentship checklist .................................................................................................................................. - 3 -
Contents ....................................................................................................................................................... - 5 -
Learning Outcomes ..................................................................................................................................... - 6 -
1. Measuring distances to nearby objects .............................................................................................. - 8 -
Using radar to measure distances ......................................................................................................................... - 8 -
Worldlines ............................................................................................................................................................. - 10 -
Space for your own notes ................................................................................................................................... - 11 -
Using radar to measure velocities ....................................................................................................................... - 12 -
Method 1: Using two distance measurements................................................................................................... - 12 -
Method 2: Using the Doppler Effect ................................................................................................................. - 13 -
Some practice questions on the Doppler Shift equation .................................................................................... - 13 -
An example exam question on radar measurements & world lines (June 2010 q11) ........................................ - 16 -
2. Measuring the distance to nearby stars: the parallax method ...................................................... - 18 -
Limitations of the Stellar Parallax...................................................................................................................... - 20 -
Space for your own notes ................................................................................................................................... - 20 -
3. Astronomical distance units.............................................................................................................. - 21 -
4. Measuring to more distant sources: standard candles ................................................................... - 22 -
Light intensity and the inverse square law ........................................................................................................ - 22 -
Some questions on the inverse-square law of light ............................................................................................ - 24 -
Some examples of standard candles often used in astronomy ......................................................................... - 25 -
Cepheid variables ............................................................................................................................................... - 25 -
(Type 1A) Supernovae ....................................................................................................................................... - 26 -
5. Mastery questions .............................................................................................................................. - 27 -
6. Space for your own notes .................................................................................................................. - 33 -
-5-
Aquinas College Physics Module 5.1.3: Astronomy & Cosmology
Learning Outcomes
You can be expected to be examined on your ability to…
5.1.3
(a) Describe and explain
the use of radar-type measurements to determine distances within the solar system; how
(i) distance is measured and defined in units of time, assuming the relativistic principle of the
invariance of the speed of light.
-6-
Aquinas College Physics Module 5.1.3: Astronomy & Cosmology
These notes act to complement the Prezi presentations 5.1.3.A found on the departmental website
(www.aquinasphysics.com). Please see the QR codes and urls below to access the relevant presentations.
5.1.3.A Astronomical distance measurements
goo.gl/QfktSj
In this unit we will look at a number of issues regarding our observations of deep space: what are the observations that
we need to make when investigating the distance to far-away objects, and how do we track the motion of objects such
as meteorites as they transit close to the earth?
In particular, our exam board are interested in us having an appreciation of the huge vastness of scales that we encounter
when considering astronomical and cosmological distances. You will need to be able to think of distances not in terms
of metres, but in terms of light years or other measurements such as astronomical units or even Parsecs.
We also look at some of the methods that we use to establish how far away distant objects are at a range of scales: from
relatively nearby objects such as meteorites and satellites to objects in distant galaxies.
-7-
Aquinas College Physics Module 5.1.3: Astronomy & Cosmology
RA D A R
2) What type of signal is emitted and received when object distances are found using RADAR?
4) Give a brief explanation of how distances to nearby objects can be found using RADAR techniques.
-8-
Aquinas College Physics Module 5.1.3: Astronomy & Cosmology
5) A radar measurement of the distance to the moon gives a round trip time of 2.57 s. Calculate how far away the
moon is.
6) A diagram may help you to answer this question. Earth has a radius of orbit of 1.496 × 1011 m. Venus has a
radius of orbit of 1.082 × 1011 m. Based on this information alone, what would you expect to be:
(a) the minimum round trip travel time for radio wave pulses reflected from Venus?
(b) the maximum round trip travel time for radio wave pulses reflected from Venus?
-9-
Aquinas College Physics Module 5.1.3: Astronomy & Cosmology
Worldlines
The situations we have considered so far when using radar to find the distance to nearby objects have largely focused
on objects that we assume to be stationary relative to Earth. In reality, of course, objects in space are moving relative to
the Earth, some of them at truly enormous speeds.
In the next section we will look at a couple of different methods we can use to establish an object’s velocity relative to
Earth. First however, we are going to consider a method for tracking the motion of an object that we are trying to either
communicate with or transmit and receive radar signals to and from.
For any moving object, we can plot its journey through space relative to us by using something called a WORLDLINE.
A worldline is simply line plotted onto a SPACE-TIME DIAGRAM: a graph showing how an object’s displacement
varies with time. Notable features of a space-time diagrams and worldliness include:
light minute
light second
light nano-second
The usefulness of worldlines in answering rather complicated questions that would otherwise require the use of
simultaneous equations is perhaps best illustrated with an example question.
Consider the scenario below.
- 10 -
Aquinas College Physics Module 5.1.3: Astronomy & Cosmology
Annotate the world line axes on the facing page and answer the questions below:
(a) How long does it take for the radio signal to reach the rocket?
(b) If the spacecraft sends a signal back to earth confirming that it has received the instructions and will be
returning, how long after sending the initial radio pulse do researchers on Earth have to wait to receive this
confirmation?
(e) Explain why the line drawn for the beam of light is always at 45o on the world line axes
- 11 -
Aquinas College Physics Module 5.1.3: Astronomy & Cosmology
v =
Complete the equation giving the velocity component, v, in terms of the two
distance measurements, d1 and d2, and the time between the measurements
being taken, t.
Explain why the actual velocity of the object will likely be different to the velocity measured.
(1) A pulse of radio waves from Earth was aimed at an asteroid. The time interval between the pulse leaving the
transmitter and the detection of the reflected pulse was 40.2 s. What is the distance to the asteroid? State any
assumption that you make.
distance = …………………. m
Assumption:
(2) The measurement was repeated 14 minutes later. The time interval was then 40.0 s. Calculate the average
relative velocity of approach of the asteroid at the time of the measurements.
- 12 -
Aquinas College Physics Module 5.1.3: Astronomy & Cosmology
When the source of a wave is moving relative to an observer, an apparent shift in wavelength
and frequency occurs:
If the source is moving towards the observer, the frequency appears to ………………… and
the wavelength appears to …………………
If the source is moving away from the observer, the frequency appears to ……………………
and the wavelength appears to …………………
The above is a description of how we would expect wave properties to change with different directions of relative
motion between the source and observer.
In the space below, give a more specific definition of what is meant by the DOPPLER EFFECT
The apparent change in frequency or wavelength (f or , respectively) depends on the velocity of the source relative
to the observer, v, and the speed
of light c. This relative shift in
frequency f or wavelength
gives a dimensionless quantity
known as z – the Doppler Shift
coefficient. State the equation
linking all these factors in the
box right.
z= = =
Some practice questions on the Doppler Shift equation
(1) A car whose engine emits a sound with a frequency of 8000 Hz is travelling towards you at 40 m s -1. What is the
apparent frequency of the sound that you hear?
(speed of sound in air = 340 m s-1)
- 13 -
Aquinas College Physics Module 5.1.3: Astronomy & Cosmology
(2) (a) A traffic camera compares the frequency of emitted and reflected microwaves to find out the speed of cars.
If a signal of 100 MHz reflects off a car travelling away from the camera at 25 m s-1, how much has the frequency
changed?
f = …………………. Hz
(b) Once you have checked your answer is correct, explain why you got the value that you did. For reflected
signal, what would we expect the equation to be linking the object velocity v and wave velocity c to the emitted
frequency f and the change in frequency f of the received signal?
=
- 14 -
Aquinas College Physics Module 5.1.3: Astronomy & Cosmology
- 15 -
Aquinas College Physics Module 5.1.3: Astronomy & Cosmology
An example exam question on radar measurements & world lines (June 2010 q11)
This question is about measuring the relative velocity of asteroids.
An asteroid is displaced from its orbit around the sun and heads towards Earth.
(a) A concerned astronomer uses radar to measure the distance of the asteroid from the Earth. This is the method:
[2]
(iii) Calculate the distance from the asteroid to the Earth at time 4.00 s.
distance = …………………….. m
[1]
(b) The astronomer sends out a second pulse at time 946.33 s, receiving an echo at time 953.67 s.
(i) Explain how the astronomer’s data show that the asteroid is getting closer to the Earth.
[2]
- 16 -
Aquinas College Physics Module 5.1.3: Astronomy & Cosmology
(ii) Use the data to calculate the component of the velocity of the asteroid towards the Earth.
(c) Explain how the astronomer could use the wavelength of a single radar echo to confirm the measurement of the
asteroid’s component of velocity towards the Earth.
[2]
- 17 -
Aquinas College Physics Module 5.1.3: Astronomy & Cosmology
More information on using Stellar Parallax to measure the distance to nearby stars can be
found by going to www.alevelphysicsonline.com/astrophysics and scrolling about half way
down the page to the video titled “Stellar parallax” (goo.gl/A5V5Gr; QR code left – username:
physics@aquinas.ac.uk; password: 1234). Another explanation is available from sixtysymbols
(goo.gl/E7Tdf4; QR code right).
The apparent change in position is measured as an angle in terms of our field of view. Think of someone stood on Earth
pointing their arm straight towards the star and tracking its motion over the next six months: the angle they pivot their
arm by would give the parallax angle. As this angle would be extremely small, we measure it not in terms of degrees,
but in terms of ARC-SECONDS.
Explain what is meant by an ARC-SECOND. What is one arc-second in degrees?
The figure on the facing page gives a representative view of how the position of our nearest star, Proxima Centauri,
appears to move across the night sky over a six month period.
The mean distance between the Earth and the Sun is known as ONE ASTRONOMICAL UNIT (1 A.U.), which is a
distance of 1.496 × 1011 m.
- 18 -
Aquinas College Physics Module 5.1.3: Astronomy & Cosmology
Annotate and add to the diagram above, and show full working throughout, to give the distance between Earth and
Proxima Centauri in:
(a) Metres:
distance = …………………………. m
(b) Astronomical Units:
- 19 -
Aquinas College Physics Module 5.1.3: Astronomy & Cosmology
- 20 -
Aquinas College Physics Module 5.1.3: Astronomy & Cosmology
Give definitions and explanations of the following units used to measure astronomical distances.
ATRONOMICAL UNIT (AU)
Definition
Distance in metres:
Distance in metres:
PARSEC (pc)
Definition (it may be worth including a diagram)
Distance in metres:
- 21 -
Aquinas College Physics Module 5.1.3: Astronomy & Cosmology
In order to use these standard candles as markers of astronomical distances, we first need to understand how we expect
the intensity of light from an object to vary as we move increasing distances away from that source.
In the Prezi presentation for this topic there is a video in which TV’s Brian Cox explains how the first
measurements were taken here on Earth to estimate the power of the Sun (goo.gl/J4TA7P; QR code right). A
number of extrapolations were needed in this calculation, not least of which is an understanding of how light
intensity varies with distance from a source of light.
The key measurement here is that the LIGHT INTENSITY at the Earth’s surface with the sun directly overhead is 1400
W m-2.
Use this information to estimate the power of the sun (you may want to do this on a whiteboard / scrap paper before
committing your reasoning to this booklet
Power = …………………………….. W
- 22 -
Aquinas College Physics Module 5.1.3: Astronomy & Cosmology
In order to help with your estimation, the following prompts may help:
(1) What is meant by the term POWER (also known as LUMINOSITY when considering stars and galaxies)?
(2) What is meant by the term INTENSITY of radiation of light? What are its units?
Units: …………………..
(5) What equation gives the area of the surface of this shape? A=
=
(6) State an alternative equation giving the light
intensity I at a distance d away from an
source of known power P
(7) Complete the sentence below to outline the relationship you would expect between light intensity received and the
distance you are from a point source of light (which radiates equally in all directions):
When you double the distance you are away from a point source of light, the light
intensity…
- 23 -
Aquinas College Physics Module 5.1.3: Astronomy & Cosmology
(b) 2 km?
(c) 4 km?
(2) Sirius A is the brightest star in the night sky. It is 8.6 light years from Earth.
(a) Show that this distance is approximately 8 × 1016 m.
(b) Hence determine the intensity of Sirius A as seen from Earth. The luminosity (or power) of Sirius A is 1.0 ×
1028 W
(3) Two distant stars are observed through a telescope. Star A is observed to be half as bright as star B. Star A is
calculated to be twice as far away as star B. Which one of the following is correct?
A Star A has half the luminosity of star B. B Star A has the same luminosity as star B.
C Star A has twice the luminosity of star B. D Star A has 8 times the luminosity of star B.
(4) A standard candle, within a nearby star cluster, is a distance D from the Earth. It produces a radiation intensity I
at the surface of the Earth. The intensity at the surface of the Earth, for a standard candle of the same luminosity
in a second star cluster, is 4I. The distance of the second star cluster from the Earth is:
A 4D B 2D C 𝐷⁄2 D 𝐷⁄4
- 24 -
Aquinas College Physics Module 5.1.3: Astronomy & Cosmology
Cepheid variables
Information on the discovery of Cepheid variables by Henrietta Swan Leavett can be found at
goo.gl/XS6kq2 (QR code left) and goo.gl/jQpysa (QR code right)
- 25 -
Aquinas College Physics Module 5.1.3: Astronomy & Cosmology
- 26 -
Aquinas College Physics Module 5.1.3: Astronomy & Cosmology
5. Mastery Questions
Isaac physics questions on Light Intensity & Amplitude online learning & skills check
*In these questions, use the relationship that the intensity of light arriving at a point is related to the amplitude of the
wave given the following relationship:
𝑰𝒏𝒕𝒆𝒏𝒔𝒊𝒕𝒚 ∝ 𝑨𝒎𝒑𝒍𝒊𝒕𝒖𝒅𝒆𝟐
Skill mastery level 8/10
D1.1 5.0 W of light from a lamp shines on 2.0 m × 3.0 m wall. Calculate the intensity.
- 27 -
Aquinas College Physics Module 5.1.3: Astronomy & Cosmology
D1.5 One laser emits light that has an amplitude 200 V m-1 and intensity 0.26 W m-2. Another laser emits light
that has amplitude 300 V m-1. In all other respects it is identical. Work out its intensity to 2 significant figures.
D1.6 A third similar laser emits light with intensity 1.5 W m-2. Work out the amplitude of the light.
D1.7 Three sets of ripples on the surface of a pond have amplitudes 1.5 cm, 2.25 cm and 3.0 cm respectively.
Which of the following give the ratios of the intensities of these three waves.
Answer ……………….
D1.8 The light from a bulb shines equally in all directions. If 20 W of light is given off, what will the intensity be
12 m from the lamp to 2 significant figures?
- 28 -
Aquinas College Physics Module 5.1.3: Astronomy & Cosmology
D1.9 What would the answer to question D1.8 be at a distance of 24 m, to 2 significant figures.
D1.10 The Sun is 1.5 × 1011 m from the Earth. If the power incident on Earth is approximately 1.0 kW m-2, calculate
the total power (luminosity) of the Sun. Give your answer in Watts.
These questions come from a number of sources, but mostly from the A level textbook available from the
link on the departmental website to kerboodle (goo.gl/AJTahM; see QR code right and follow the
instructions).
(1) Calculate the distance in light-seconds between the Earth and Mars when the two planets are at their closest, about
5.5 × 1010 m
(2) Give two reasons why radar is not suitable for measuring distances beyond the solar system
1.
2.
- 29 -
Aquinas College Physics Module 5.1.3: Astronomy & Cosmology
distance = ……………………… m
Assumptions
(b) The measurement was repeated 12.0 minutes later. The time for the return journey of the pulse was found to
be 40.1 s. Calculate the relative velocity of approach of the asteroid during this time.
- 30 -
Aquinas College Physics Module 5.1.3: Astronomy & Cosmology
(6) The star Alpha Centauri is one of the nearest to Earth. It is observed to shift in direction by 4.2 × 10-4 degrees when
observed from opposite sides of the Earth’s orbit (distance = 2 A.U.). Calculate the distance to Alpha Centauri in
metres and light-years.
(7) A space probe is travelling away from Earth at a speed of 30 km s-1. Show that the Doppler shift of the wavelength
of the 1 GHz radio wave signals being sent from the probe is 0.03 mm.
(ii) Draw the complete worldline of the pulse of light on the figure.
- 31 -
Aquinas College Physics Module 5.1.3: Astronomy & Cosmology
(c) The arrival of the pulse of light at the spacecraft is the signal for it to turn around and return to Earth.
(i) Explain how an observer can use the times of emission and reception to calculate that the spacecraft
was 4.0 light-years from the Earth when the pulse reached it.
(ii) Explain how an observer on Earth can use the time of emission and return of the pulse to deduce that
the spacecraft turned around when the Earth clock read t = 5.0 years.
(iii) Show that the outward speed of the spacecraft relative to Earth is 2.4 × 108 m s-1.
(9) A satellite in orbit around Mars uses pulses of light to map the surface of the planet.
(a) The satellite emits a brief pulse of light towards the surface and detects a reflected pulse after a time delay of
840 s. Calculate the distance d of the planet surface below the satellite.
(c) Suggest how the satellite could use pulses of light to check whether the altitude of its orbit was decreasing
gradually.
- 32 -
Aquinas College Physics Module 5.1.3: Astronomy & Cosmology
- 33 -
Aquinas College Physics Module 5.1.3: Astronomy & Cosmology
………………………………………………………………………………………………….
………………………………………………………………………………………………….
………………………………………………………………………………………………….
………………………………………………………………………………………………….
………………………………………………………………………………………………….
………………………………………………………………………………………………….
………………………………………………………………………………………………….
………………………………………………………………………………………………….
………………………………………………………………………………………………….
………………………………………………………………………………………………….
………………………………………………………………………………………………….
………………………………………………………………………………………………….
………………………………………………………………………………………………….
………………………………………………………………………………………………….
………………………………………………………………………………………………….
………………………………………………………………………………………………….
………………………………………………………………………………………………….
………………………………………………………………………………………………….
………………………………………………………………………………………………….
………………………………………………………………………………………………….
………………………………………………………………………………………………….
………………………………………………………………………………………………….
………………………………………………………………………………………………….
………………………………………………………………………………………………….
………………………………………………………………………………………………….
………………………………………………………………………………………………….
………………………………………………………………………………………………….
………………………………………………………………………………………………….
………………………………………………………………………………………………….
- 34 -
Aquinas College Physics Module 5.1.3: Astronomy & Cosmology
………………………………………………………………………………………………….
………………………………………………………………………………………………….
………………………………………………………………………………………………….
………………………………………………………………………………………………….
………………………………………………………………………………………………….
………………………………………………………………………………………………….
………………………………………………………………………………………………….
………………………………………………………………………………………………….
………………………………………………………………………………………………….
………………………………………………………………………………………………….
………………………………………………………………………………………………….
………………………………………………………………………………………………….
………………………………………………………………………………………………….
………………………………………………………………………………………………….
………………………………………………………………………………………………….
………………………………………………………………………………………………….
………………………………………………………………………………………………….
………………………………………………………………………………………………….
………………………………………………………………………………………………….
………………………………………………………………………………………………….
………………………………………………………………………………………………….
………………………………………………………………………………………………….
………………………………………………………………………………………………….
………………………………………………………………………………………………….
………………………………………………………………………………………………….
………………………………………………………………………………………………….
………………………………………………………………………………………………….
………………………………………………………………………………………………….
………………………………………………………………………………………………….
- 35 -
Aquinas College Physics Module 5.1.3: Astronomy & Cosmology
………………………………………………………………………………………………….
………………………………………………………………………………………………….
………………………………………………………………………………………………….
………………………………………………………………………………………………….
………………………………………………………………………………………………….
………………………………………………………………………………………………….
………………………………………………………………………………………………….
………………………………………………………………………………………………….
………………………………………………………………………………………………….
………………………………………………………………………………………………….
………………………………………………………………………………………………….
………………………………………………………………………………………………….
………………………………………………………………………………………………….
………………………………………………………………………………………………….
- 36 -