Stress Failure Modes Notes
Stress Failure Modes Notes
Stress Failure Modes Notes
Composites
Failure
Modes
Marine
Composites
Webb
Ins1tute
Senior
Elec1ve
Spring,
2013
Failure Modes
Compression
Webb
Ins1tute
Senior
Elec1ve
–
Spring
2013
page
2
Marine
Composites
First
Ply
Failure
based
on
Cri1cal
Strain
Failure
Modes
First Ply Failure Based on First Play Cri1cal Strain Limits from the ABS Guide for Building and Classing High-‐Speed CraA
Webb
Ins1tute
Senior
Elec1ve
–
Spring
2013
page
3
Marine
Composites
Micro-‐buckling
Failure
Modes
The
schema1c
diagram
showing
the
forma1on
of
kinking
failure
mode
and
its
geometry:
(a)
in-‐plane
buckling
of
0°
fibers
with
an
ini1al
fiber
misalignment
ϕo,
(b)
deforma1on
of
0°
fibers
via
fiber
microbuckling
mechanism
when
it
is
loaded
in
compression
σ∞
and
(c)
fibres
kinking
phenomena
causing
catastrophic
fracture
of
the
UD
laminate.
The
kink
band
geometry:
w
=
kink
band
width,
β
=
boundary
orienta1on
and
ϕ
=
ϕo
+
γ
=
inclina1on
angle.
[A.
Jumahata,
C.
Sou1sa,
F.R.
Jonesb,
and
A.
Hodzica,
“Fracture
mechanisms
and
failure
analysis
of
carbon
fiber/toughened
epoxy
composites
subjected
to
compressive
loading,”
Composite
Structures,
Jan
2010.
Webb
Ins1tute
Senior
Elec1ve
–
Spring
2013
page
4
Marine
Composites
Fa1gue
Failure
Modes
Webb
Ins1tute
Senior
Elec1ve
–
Spring
2013
page
5
Marine
Composites
S-‐N
Curves
for
Composite
Laminates
Failure
Modes
Comparison
of
Fa1gue
Strengths
S1ffness
S-‐N
Curve
for
J/24
Sailboat
Sandwich
Laminate
from
of
Graphite/Epoxy,
Steel,
Fiberglass/ Paul
Miller’s
“Fa9gue
Predic9on
Verifica9on
of
Fiberglass
Hulls”
Epoxy
and
Aluminum
[Hercules]
Webb
Ins1tute
Senior
Elec1ve
–
Spring
2013
page
6
Marine
Composites
S-‐N
Curves
Comparing
Failure
Modes
Material
Systems
Fiber
Architecture
Comparison
S-‐N
Curves
Resin
Comparison
S-‐N
Curves
Compara1ve
Fa1gue
Strengths
of
Nonwoven
Unidirec1onal
Comparison
of
Fa1gue
Behavior
of
Epoxy
Glass
Fiber
Reinforced
Plas1c
Laminates
[ASM
Engineers’
and
Polyester
Resin
Guide
to
Composite
Materials]
Webb
Ins1tute
Senior
Elec1ve
–
Spring
2013
page
7
Marine
Composites
Design
for
Fa1gue
Failure
Modes
Webb
Ins1tute
Senior
Elec1ve
–
Spring
2013
page
8
Marine
Composites
Types
of
Point
Impact
Load
Damage
Failure
Modes
reported by Mar1n Hildebrand in VTT pub 281, “A comparison of FRP-‐sandwich penetra1ng impact test methods”
Webb
Ins1tute
Senior
Elec1ve
–
Spring
2013
page
9
Marine
Composites
Impact
Damage
Failure
Modes
M. Gower
Webb
Ins1tute
Senior
Elec1ve
–
Spring
2013
page
10
Marine
Composites
Hull
Skin
Delamina1on
Failure
Modes
Tony Guild
Failure Modes
Det Norske Veritas Offshore Standard DNV-‐OS-‐C501, Composite Components, January 2003.
Webb
Ins1tute
Senior
Elec1ve
–
Spring
2013
page
12
Marine
Composites
Summary
of
Sandwich
Failure
Loads
Failure
Modes
Face Yielding
Face Wrinkling
Core Shear
Bond Failure
Sandwich
failure
presenta1on
developed
by
Dr.
John
Pilling,
Technical
Director
of
Electric
Park
Research
[hMp://home.comcast.net/~brandihampson/ep.html]
Webb
Ins1tute
Senior
Elec1ve
–
Spring
2013
page
13
Marine
Composites
Core
Failure
Failure
Modes
D. Roosen M. Gower
Crushing
Fatigue Skin-to-
Core Debond
D. Zenkert
C. Berggreen
Webb
Ins1tute
Senior
Elec1ve
–
Spring
2013
page
14
Marine
Composites
Core
Shear
Failure
Failure
Modes
“EGB-‐150”
Balsa
Core
Material,
Vacuum-‐ “SAN-‐95”
Foam
Core
Material,
Vacuum-‐
Infusion
(top),
Hand
Lay-‐up
(boYom)
Infusion
(top),
Hand
Lay-‐up
(boYom)
Kurt
Feich1nger,
Wenguang
Ma
and
Russell
Elkin,
“Proper1es
of
Structural
Sandwich
Core
Materials:
Hand
Lay-‐
up
vs.
Vacuum-‐Infusion
Processing,”
COMPOSITES
2006
Webb
Ins1tute
Senior
Elec1ve
–
Spring
2013
page
15
Marine
Composites
Honeycomb
&
Foam
Core
Failures
Failure
Modes
Digital
photograph
of
impact
delamina1ons
Digital
photograph
of
skin
to-‐core
de-‐bond
in
a
in
top
skin
of
a
sandwich
construc1on
GRP
skin,
PU
foam
sandwich
Gower,
M.,
Sims,
G.,
Lee,
R.,
Frost,
S.
and
Wall,
M.,
“Assessment
and
Cri1cality
of
Defects
and
Damage
In
Material
Systems,"
Na1onal
Physical
Laboratory,
Teddington,
Middlesex,
United
Kingdom,
June
2005
Webb
Ins1tute
Senior
Elec1ve
–
Spring
2013
page
16
Marine
Composites
Honeycomb
Core
Failures
Failure
Modes
Adhesive
bond
failure
modes
for
honeycomb
sandwich
panels
Flatwise
tension
failure
of
a
sandwich
panel
M.J.
Davis
and
D.A.
Bond,
“ The
Importance
of
Failure
Mode
Iden1fica1on
in
Adhesive
Bonded
Aircras
Structures
and
Repairs,”
Royal
Australian
Air
Force
Webb
Ins1tute
Senior
Elec1ve
–
Spring
2013
page
18
Marine
Composites
Bonded
Joint
Failures
Failure
Modes
Adhesive
Failure:
Failure
of
a
bonded
joint
between
the
adhesive
and
the
substrate
• Primarily
due
to
a
lack
of
chemical
bonding
between
the
adhesive
and
the
bonding
substrate
• Can
be
indica1ve
of
poor
surface
prepara1on
or
contamina1on
• Or,
incorrect
adhesive
selec1on
for
the
substrate
materials
Cohesive
failure:
Failure
of
an
adhesive
joint
occurring
primarily
in
the
adhesive
layer
• Op1mum
type
of
failure
in
an
adhesive
bonded
joint
when
failure
occurs
at
predicted
loads
• Lower
failure
loads
are
indica1ve
of
poorly
cured
adhesive
or
moisture
or
other
contaminants
present
in
the
adhesive
Webb
Ins1tute
Senior
Elec1ve
–
Spring
2013
page
19
Marine
Composites
Bolted
Connec1on
Failure
Modes
Failure
Modes
Webb
Ins1tute
Senior
Elec1ve
–
Spring
2013
page
20
Marine
Composites
Visible
Surface
Damage
Failure
Modes
Air
bubbles,
voids
Air
entrapment
in
and
between
plies;
Blisters
Rounded,
some1mes
sharply
defined
eleva1ons
of
noninterconnected
spherical
voids
laminate
surface
resembling
blisters.
Impact
cracks
Separa1on
of
material
through
en1re
thickness
Crazing
PaYern
of
fine
cracks
on
or
and
visible
on
surfaces.
beneath
surface.
Dow
Chemical
Company
Webb
Ins1tute
Senior
Elec1ve
–
Spring
2013
page
21
Marine
Composites
Visible
Surface
Damage
Failure
Modes
Pit
or
pinhole
Small
regular
or
irregular
Resin
pocket
Apparent
accumula1on
of
crater
on
surface,
usually
with
excess
resin
in
a
small
localized
area
nearly
equal
width
and
depth
Worm
hole
Elongated
void
in
surface
or
covered
by
Wrinkle
Crease
or
wrinkle-‐like
surface
thin
film
of
cured
resin.
imperfec1on
in
one
or
more
plies
of
molded-‐in
reinforcement.
Delamina1on
Separa1on
of
layers
Fisheye
Small
globular
mass
that
has
not
blended
into
surrounding
material.
Par1cularly
evident
in
transparent
or
translucent
materials
Dry
Spots
Area
of
reinforcement
that
was
not
weYed
Pimple
Small
sharp
or
conical
pimple-‐like
with
resin.
Usually
at
laminate
edge.
eleva1on
on
surface.
Usually
resin-‐rich.
Webb
Ins1tute
Dow
Chemical
Company
Senior
Elec1ve
–
Spring
2013
page
23
Marine
Composites
Gel
Coat
Cracking
Failure
Modes
Gougeon
Brothers
Inc.,
“WEST
System
Fiberglass
Boat
Repair
&
Maintenance,”
15th
Edi1on,
April
2011
Webb
Ins1tute
Senior
Elec1ve
–
Spring
2013
page
24
Marine
Composites
Gelcoat
Cracking
Failure
Modes
www.walshsurveyor.com
Gower,
M.,
Sims,
G.,
Lee,
R.,
Frost,
S.
and
Wall,
M.,
Measurement
Good
Prac1ce
Guide
No.
78
“Assessment
and
Cri1cality
of
Defects
and
Damage
In
Material
Systems,"
Na1onal
Physical
Laboratory,
Teddington,
Middlesex,
United
Kingdom,
June
2005
Webb
Ins1tute
Senior
Elec1ve
–
Spring
2013
page
26
Marine
Composites
Lightning
Damage
Failure
Modes
Gower,
M.,
Sims,
G.,
Lee,
R.,
Frost,
S.
and
Wall,
M.,
Measurement
Good
Prac1ce
Guide
No.
78
“Assessment
and
Cri1cality
of
Defects
and
Damage
In
Material
Systems,"
Na1onal
Physical
Laboratory,
Teddington,
Middlesex,
United
Kingdom,
June
2005
Webb
Ins1tute
Senior
Elec1ve
–
Spring
2013
page
28
Marine
Composites
Damage
in
Foil
Spar
Structures
Failure
Modes
Types
1
(skin/adhesive
debonding)
and
2
(adhesive
Damage
types
4
(delamina1on
driven
by
buckling
joint
failure
between
skins)
at
the
leading
as
well
load)
in
upper
flange
and
5
(fiber
failure
in
tension;
as
the
trailing
edge.
Types
4
(delamina1on
driven
laminate
failure
in
compression)
in
the
web
by
a
buckling
load),
5
(laminate
failure
in
compression)
and
7
(gel-‐coat
cracking
and
gel-‐
coat/skin
debonding)
Sørensen,
B.F.,
Jørgensen,
E,
Debe,
C.P.,
Jensen,
F.M.,
Jensen,
H.M.,
Jacobsen,
T.K.and
Halling,
K.J.,
“Improved
design
of
large
wind
turbine
blade
of
fibre
composites
based
on
studies
of
scale
effects
(Phase
1)
-‐
Summary
Report,”
Risø
Na1onal
Laboratory,
Roskilde,
Denmark,
September
2004.
Webb
Ins1tute
Senior
Elec1ve
–
Spring
2013
page
29
Marine
Composites
Ship
Structural
Failures
Failure
Modes
Webb
Ins1tute
Senior
Elec1ve
–
Spring
2013
page
30