Nature and Scope of Relationship Between Banker and Customer
Nature and Scope of Relationship Between Banker and Customer
Nature and Scope of Relationship Between Banker and Customer
The present chapter deals the nature and scope of relationship between bankers
and customers. It provides the theoretical background for the empirical study which
constitutes the core of the thesis. It explains the different kinds of relationships
between customers and bankers. The emphasis of the chapter is on the banker
The relationship that exists between a banker and his customer is significant.
This significance is due to the interdependence of both the parties. In this context, the
terms “Banker” “and “Customer” have been explained. The term “Banking” is
defined ‘as accepting for the purpose of lending or investment, of deposits of money
draft order or other wise as per “Section 5(B) of 1949 Banking regulation Act. The
term “Customer” of a bank is not defined by law. Ordinarily a person who has an
account in a bank is considered its customer. In Sir. John Puget’s view “To constitute
a customer there must be some recognizable course or habit of dealing in the nature of
the duration of the dealings between the banker and the customer and is, therefore,
104
According to Hart “a customer is one who has an account with a banker or for
Broadly speaking, a customer is a person who has the habit of resorting to the
is a person whose money has been accepted on the footing that the banker will honor
up to the amount standing to his credit, irrespective of his connection being of short or
long standing.
company, a society or any separate legal entity may be a customer, and includes a
A person who does not deal with the banker in regard to the essential functions
of the Banker i.e., accepting of deposits and lending of money, but avails of any of the
services rendered by the banker, is not called a customer of the Banker. For
example:- any person without a bank account in his name may remit money through a
bank draft, encash a cheques, deposit cash in the bank to be credited to the account of
the LIC or any Joint Stock company issuing new shares. But he will not be called a
customer of the banker as his dealings with the banker are not in regard to the
1 Shekar. K.C. & Shekar, Lekshmy. “Banking Theory and Practice", Vikas Publishing House Pvt. Ltd., New
Delhi, 1998, pp. 167-169.
105
essential functions of the banker. Such dealings are considered as casual dealings and
fulfilled.2
• The dealing between the banker and the customer must be of the nature of
banking business^
his customer. The relationship between them primarily is that of a creditor and
debtor. A Banker also acts as an agent or trustee of his customer if the latter entrusts
the former with agency or trust work. In such cases, the banker acts as a debtor, an
creditor On the opening of an account, the banker assumes the position of debtor. He
is not a depository or trustee of the customer’s money because the money handed
over to the banker becomes a debt due from him to the customer.
2 Tarapore, S.S., Chairman. “Report of the Committee on Fuller Capital Account Convertibility”,
Reserve Bank of India, July 2006, p. 66.
106
The creditor has the right to demand his money from the banker, and the
banker is under an obligation to repay the debt as and when he is required to do so,
But it is not necessary that the repayment is made in terms of the same currency notes
and coins, The payment of course, must be made in terms of legal tender currency of
the country.
customer’s account is overdrawn. Banker becomes creditor who has taken a loan
from the banker and continues in that capacity till the loan is repaid. Though the
relationship between a banker and his customer is mainly that of a debtor and
creditor3, this relationship differs from similar relationship arising out of ordinary
The deposit accounts are a source of banker and customer relationship. There
are different kinds of deposits. In this category are included the deposits with the bank
3 Sundharm, K.P.M. “Money Banking-Trade and Finance”, Sultan Chand & Sons Publishers,
New Delhi, 1998, p.78.
107
for a fixed period which is specified at the time of making the deposit. Such deposits
are, therefore, called Fixed Deposits or Term Deposits. A Fixed deposit is repayable
Qn the expiry of the specified period, chosen by the depositor to suit his purpose and
to enable him to get back the money as and when he needs it. For example, if a
person intends to utilise his money for any purpose after a few years, he may deposit
it for 3,5 or 6 years, whereas if his purpose is to meet some urgent need in the near
future, the fixed deposit may be made for 3,6 or 9 months. As the date of repayment
of a fixed deposit is determined in advance, the banker need not keep more cash
The banker, therefore, offers higher rate of interest on such deposits because
the depositor parts with liquidity for definite period. Fixed deposits have grown in
importance and popularity in India during recent years. There are Fixed Deposit
Schemes for Senior Citizens. Reserve Bank of India has also permitted the banks to
formulate fixed deposit schemes specially meant for senior citizens on which they
may offer higher and fixed rates of interest as compared with normal deposits. These
schemes will also incorporate simple procedure for automatic transfer of deposits to
i,
application form wherein he mentions the amount of the deposit and the period for
which deposit is to be made. He also gives his specimen signature. A Fixed Deposit
108
Receipt is thereafter issued to the depositor, acknowledging the receipt of the sum of
money specified therein, to be repaid at the expiry of the period mentioned therein
along with interest at the specified rate. Reserve Bank of India has made it absolutely
necessary to indicate on the Fixed Deposit Receipt the date of receipt, the period for
which the deposit has been accepted and due date, as also the applicable rate of
interest.
inculcate the habit of saving on a regular basis as an inducement is offered in the form
or 10, in his account every month for a period selected by him. The period of
recurring deposit varies from bank to bank. Banks open such accounts for periods
compared to the rate of interest on the saving bank account because the former partly
resembles the fixed deposit account. According to the directive of the Reserve Bank,
banks are required to ensure that the rates of interest offered by them on recurring
deposits are generally in accord with the rates prescribed for various term deposits.
The rate of interest is, therefore, almost equal to that of the fixed deposit account.
109
In case a depositor is compelled to close the account before its maturity, the
bank pays no interest if the deposits are made for less than 3 months, interest at 114
per cent is payable for deposits made up to 6 month, up to 4 per cent for deposits
made up to 12 months and 1 per cent below the rate applicable to a recurring deposit
of the period for which the deposit has actually run in case deposits are held for over
year. The accounts are transferable from one branch to another without charge.
The recurring deposit account can be opened by any person, more than one
person jointly or severally, by a guardian in the name of a minor and even by a minor.
While opening the account, the depositor is given a Pass Book which is to be
presented to the bank at the time of monthly deposits and repayment of amount.
Installments for each month should be paid before the last working day of that month.
Accumulated amount with interest will be payable after a month of the payment of
The Reserve Bank of India publishes4 the classification of deposits with the
commercial banks under two broad heads, namely: (i) Demand Deposits, and (ii)
Time Deposits. The various types of deposits included in these heads are as follows:
portion of savings bank deposits, (iii) margins held against letter of credit /
guarantees (if payable on demand), (iv) balances in overdue fixed deposits, cash
110
certificates and recurring deposits, (v) outstanding telegraphic and mail transfers,
demand drafts, (vi) unclaimed deposits, (vii) credit balances in cash credit accounts
and (viii) deposits held as security for advances which are repayable on demand.
The Deposits include: (i) fixed deposits, (ii) cash certificates, recurring
deposits, (iii) time liabilities portion of savings bank deposits, (iv) staff security
-deposits (v) margins held against letter of credit if not payable on demand, and (vi)
It is to be noted that the savings deposits are apportioned in both of the above
categories. The portion which be withdrawn notice is treated as demand deposits and
Vaghul), Reserve Bank of India has permitted the banks to issue Certificates of
Deposit Reserve Bank has issued guidelines also in this Regard, which have been
not by the Regional Rural Banks. Through CDs banks accept short term deposits of
substantial amounts from the investors who have liquid funds for temporary period.
111
associations, etc. Non-resident Indians (NRIs) may subscribe to such certificates but
on a non-reportable basis and such CDs cannot be endorsed to another NRI in the
secondary market.
A large number of Indian citizens and aliens of Indian origin live abroad and
are in a position to save a good deal of money. The Government of India realised the
urgency of mobilising their savings in the from of bank deposits in India and have,
therefore, offered them certain concessions and incentives to remit money to India for
investment5. Banks in India at present operate various types of deposit accounts for
nationals abroad both in Indian Rupees and foreign currencies. These accounts may
Savings bank accounts are another source of banker and customer relationship.
A savings bank account is meant for the people of the lower and middle classes who
wish to save a part of their current incomes to meet their future needs and also intend
to earn an income from their savings. The banks, therefore, impose certain restriction
on the savings bank account and also offer a reasonable rate of interest. The need of
keeping cash reserves against such deposits is comparatively larger vis-a-vis the fixed
5 Reddy, A. “Banking Sector Liberalisation and Efficiency of Indian Banks, ICFAI Journal of
Banking Management, May 2004, pp. 1-3.
112
deposits but smaller as against the current deposits, because of the restrictions on the
number of withdrawals.
With the extension of banking facilities during the last decade and the growth
of banking habit amongst the people, the savings deposits of all scheduled
commercial banks have gone up substantially playing a vital role in banker and
customer relationship6. The customer may deposit any amount in the savings bank
account subject to a minimum of Rs500. The banks do not accept cheques or other
instruments payable to a third party for the purpose of deposit in the savings account.
Banks prescribe the minimum balance that is to be maintained in the savings Bank
accounts. For this purpose they take into consideration the cost involved in
maintaining and servicing such account. They also levy specific charges, if the
A current account is a running and active account which may be operated upon
number of times during a working day. There is no restriction of the number and the
to repay these deposits on demand, they .are called demand liabilities of a banker. To
meet such liability, the banker keeps sufficient cash reserves against such deposits
6 Chitra Andrade, Banking Products & Services, 2nd edn., Taxmann Publications Private Limited,
2007, pp. 101-104.
113
vis-a-vis the savings and the fixed deposits. Current accounts suit the requirements of
big businessmen, joint stock companies, institutions, public authorities and public
•»
1. A current account is meant for the convenience of his customers, who are
relieved of the task of handling cash themselves and to take the risk inherent
therein. Thus the primary deposit accounts which are meant to solicit the
2. As the banker undertakes to make payments and to collect the bills, drafts,
cheques etc., any number of times daily, the operating cost, i.e., the cost of
customary for the banks not to pay any interest on the credit balance in the
current account The Reserve Bank directive prohibits the payment of interest
account maintained by a borrower with any bank. Banks may pay interest on
current account of Regional Rural Banks at half per cent below the borrowing
rate fixed for the RRB by the sponsor bank. Since May 1983, banks have
t •
been permitted to pay interest on balances lying in current accounts in the
114
name of a deceased depositor from the date of death of the depositor till
3. The State Bank makes no charge for keeping an account provided the balance
maintained is sufficient to compensate the bank for the work involved. In case
customer. The public sector banks now impose a uniform “Ledger folio
charge” of Rs.20 per folio (i.e., one side of the ledger page) on accounts
4. A current account carries certain privileges which are not given to a savings
iii) The loans and advances granted by the banks to their customers are not
given in the form of cash but through the current accounts. Current
accounts thus earn interest on all types of advances granted by the
banker.
8 RBI Bulletin, “Monetary Policy and Exchange Rate Frameworks”, The Indian Experience, 2006.
115
5.5 Attractive Savings Schemes
various attractive savings schemes9. These have their bearing on banker and customer
(1) Re-investment Plan. This is just like fixed deposits with the difference that
deposits are accepted for a fixed period ranging between 12 and 120 months
This plan provides for the re-investment of interest also. In case of premature
withdrawal or renewal under such plan, compound interest with quarterly rests
(2) Cash Certificates. These certificates are issued with different face values
payable after specified maturity periods. The issue prices for different maturity
periods are specified in advance; for example, one can get a Cash Certificate
with face value of Rs.100 after 12 months by paying its discounted value.
9 Dale, Richard “International Banking De-regulation", “The Great Banking Experiment", Blackwell
publishers, London, 1992, pp. 121-123.
116
(3) Multi Option Deposit Scheme, State Bank of India has introduced this scheme
to provide liquidity to term deposits and other facilities. Under this scheme,
term deposits are accepted in conjunction with Savings Bank / Current a/c or
Savings Bank a/c without attracting any penal rate of interest. The remaining
(4) Savings Accounts linked with Fixed Deposits. Under this scheme the
depositor specifies the maximum amount in his savings bank account, beyond
(5) Super Savings Account. Bank of Baroda has launched this scheme wherein a
latter, but in certain circumstance he acts as a trustee also. On the other hand, if a
customer instructs his bank to purchase certain securities out of his deposit with the
latter, but the bank falls before making such purchase, the bank will continue to be a
debtor of his customer (and not a trustee) in respect of the amount which was not
withdrawn from or debited to his account to carry out his specific instruction. The
relationship between the banker and his customer as a trustee and beneficiary depends
117
upon the specific instructions given by the latter to the former regarding the purpose
functions for the convenience of his customers.10 For example, he buys or sells
securities on behalf of his customer collects a cheques on his behalf and makes
payment of the various dues of his customer, e.g., Insurance premium etc.
The Aim of this research study is to investigate the strength of banker and
customer relationship in bank service. A model that relates service quality and
based on a qualitative study concerning customers and banker relationship from micro
- level in India. A Look at the definitions of relationship in the Banker and Customer
relationship literature reveals that the concept rarely is defined directly at all. The
literature often, discusses activities the firm should engage in to develop, maintains
with customers are often discussed as well. Within, Industrial, Micro credit,
Agricultural, Business and General relationships have been studied more in depth
10 Agarwal, B.P. “Commercial Bank in India”, Classical Publishing Co., New Delhi, 1981, pp.23-28.
118
Although the ideal is that both parties should be positively committed to the
industrials marking, this kind of relationship is not usual in consumer market when
talking about consumer services, the focus has to be on the customer side.
customer buys nothing from the firm, there is no relationship. It might be concluded
that the firm is engaged in relationship marketing with the aim of creating a
Thus a customer who has purchased twice from the company, feels some
positive commitment to it, and/or has bonds with it has a stronger relationship than
some one who gas purchased twice without being committed and/or having bonds.
Bonds can be studied at both company and individual levels. A customer may be
committed to, and have a social bond to a specific person in the company, without
11 Sheth N.J. Mittal, B. and Newman, J.B. “Customer Behaviour-Consumer Behaviour”, The Dryden
Press, New York, 1999, pp.145-155.
12 Mohan Rao, P., Trilok Kumar Jain, “Management of Banking and Financial Institutions”, Deep &
Deep Publications Pvt. Ltd., New Delhi, 2002, p. 201.
119
extent to which the customer favours a particular bank and spreads positive
customer showing an active interest in the company and speaking well of it. A weak
loyalty can be measured by many measures e.g. as the number of bank relationship,
customer’s own perceived and verbally expressed loyalty. Their actual behaviour
which is the base for the traditional loyalty concept might differ from their own
customers who are customers in more than one bank may perceive it as easier to
change the main bank. Customer’s relationship to banks were found to be very strong.
Most customers have used the same bank for more than 15 years and up to the time of
their retirement.
Banking services need to keep in view the requirements of the Swadesh groups
and also focus their attention on globalisation efforts.13 They require a balancing
effort. The technology driven foreign banks have aroused customer’s expectations
13 Varughese, A.G. “Retail Banking in India”, Professional Banker, The ICFAI University Press,
Hyderabad, April 200S, p. 27.
120
high. In the wake of new client expectations, satisfying the customer requires a new
promotion of the interest of the depositors, giving fair and adequate return on the
deposits, assisting the people who are in need of financial assistance to raise their
and accountable role to Government, safeguarding the rights and interests of the
employees, and apart from all these roles, in the commercial banks have to earn
profits to sustain their existence and to do justice to all these roles. Hence, the
responsibilities.14
power and prominence in the economy. Their performance affects the whole of the
economic system since they constitute an important element in the total financial
system of the country. The establishment of these banks for the attainment of Good
relationship has aroused many expectations in the public. Press and Parliament. The
real justification for their existence depends on how efficiently and effectively they
14 Ranade, A., and G. Kapur, “Appreciating Rupee: Changing Paradigm”, Economic and Political
Weekly, February, 2003, pp. 1171-1179.
121
discharge these relationships. Considering all the relevant aspects of the Indian
economy, viewing various arguments for and against nationalisation of these banks
and keeping in view all the structural changes the various responsibilities of these
banks may be as under. These responsibilities may be grouped under the following
heads
The whole philosophy of the commercial banking centres on the service to its
customers. Customers of a commercial banks are those who have bank accounts in
their names and such accounts are used essentially for the business of banking i.e.,
accepting the deposits and lending of money. Thus, both the suitors and borrowers
are termed as customers of a commercial banks. Both individuals institutions and the
corporate bodies may be included in the term customers of a banks. Depositors are
lenders of money to the community through banks. Apart from comparatively higher
rates of interest, they are also interested in the safety and liquidity of funds. Easy
122
efficient and quick service particularly at counters, convenient banking hours etc., are
the expectations of the customers of a bank. This leads to good image of banks, which
As the rates of interest are being regulated by RBI, the management of these
banks cannot do much in this respect. However, it should try to see that these
expectations are fulfilled. Through insurance of deposits, yet good behaviour and
Borrowers are the purchasers of services of these banks. They are always interested
in good service easily and efficiently available and that too without any cumbersome
procedures.
adequately and easily. As purveyors of credit, the management of these banks should
grant credit to all those who deserve it and to those sectors the financing of which
helps to maximise the use of scarce resources. Credit should also be followed by
sectors. Credit should be given for approved purposes where the proposals should be
technically feasible and economically viable. Proper care should be taken so that the
borrowers do not have any misunderstanding about the nationalised banks and their
information oriented publicity in turn with its changing concepts and objectives.
Customers, at all types of areas should be provided with convenient banking hours
123
suited to the needs of different places. Besides, banking offices should be kept open
for long houses for transacting banking business. This is because banks in India are
kept open for 22 hours a week, as against more than 42 hours a week in Zurich and 40
hours a week in New York15. The Courteous treatment of the customers from rural
areas is another major relationship on the part of banks. As the commercial banks
have certain responsibilities towards the customers, the customers are also required to
information, behaving with a sense of discipline and projecting rational behaviour are
national and social institution. As the enterprise grows and attains prominence, its
influence upon the society becomes important and hence its working should not be in
any way detrimental to the interests of the society. The nationalised banks as centres
of economic activity are called upon to solve many of the problems of the society
lopsided economic development etc., Banks have been entrusted with the task of
15 Narayana, M.S. “Social Banking”, Ph.D. Thesis submitted to Nagaijuna University, Guntur District
2002, pp. 67-78.
124
centres, commercial banks should also ensure that greater confidence of the society is
inspired by providing efficient and regular services. This has been rightly stated by
Edward W. Reed16 that “the safely of commercial banks has always been of concern
failures have a more adverse effect on the economy than do failures in any other type
of business”. The commercial banks are supposed to see that evils like red-tapism,
which adversely affects the image of the banks. In turn, society should also extend
its full co-operation to the banking industry by providing an amicable and legitimate
government committed to social welfare always strives to enhance the social welfare.
The nationalisation of these banks is a step in that direction. As the sole owner of
these banks, the objective of the government is not to make them unprofitable entities
and philanthropic institutions but to ensure wider social service by maintaining their
commercial nature. This requires that these banks are expected to give reasonable
return to the government. There has been a spate of discussion over the issue of
125
public enterprises are meant for discharging social responsibilities and hence profit
making is not a major concern for them. But in a developing country like India,. The
from operations. Besides, the major source of funds for commercial banks is the
deposit of the customers. The increase in the deposits of commercial banks depends
to a large extent upon the faith reposed in them by the depositors.17 This faith inter
alia is the outcome of profits, and continuous fall in the profits would mean loss of
these banks to ensure the functioning of these banks is in conformity with the plan
strategy. The success of economic planning depends largely upon the co-operation
' from all sectors of the economy including the financial institutions the major part of
which consists of these banks. The government has identified certain sector as
priority sectors and timely and adequate credit should be extended to these sectors.
viable projects. Further, commercial banks are expected to be responsible to the RBI,
which is the monetary authority in our country . It works in consultation with the
government and is ultimately responsible for the sound banking system in the country.
126
It has been assigned both primitive and regulatory functions. As a result, it also gives
directions to the nationalised banks from time to time for a sound banking system
with a view to serving the best interests of the society. In this connection all the
commercial banks are expected to implement the several directions in respects of bills
market, several schemes like lead bank, service area approach financing several
farmers credit co-operative societies etc,., in turn RBI should also consider the nature
of commercial banks and limitations of theses banks while exercising its regulatory
infrastructure of the country. Apart from these banks, the financial infrastructure
includes private banks, foreign banks, co-operative banks, Regional Rural banks as
the constituents of the money market and LIC, IFC, SFC, ICICI, IDBI, UTI as
between the various institutions of both money and capital markets is required. These
institutions should act in an ethical, manner, properly guide the clientele, participate in
their activities, provide consortium leadership to other institutions and agencies, resort
18 RBI Bulletin, “Monetary Policy and Exchange Rate Frameworks: The Indian Experience”, 2005.
19 RBI Bulletin, “Reforms, Productivity and Efficiency in Banking: The Indian Experience.” March,
2005, pp. 279-293..
127
5.9.5 Relationship with their employees
affected by the skill and attitude of employees. who are in direct contact with
other aspects like security of job, human treatment for labour and adequate facilities
for their promotions to higher status. Lack of cordial relations between the
satisfaction which is visible through strikes, ghetto etc., which are the causes for the
working conditions, ensuring security to the job, resorting to fair Human resource
development practices, positive motivation etc. As it has been rightly pointed out that
a “strike bears a triple curse. It brings financial ruin upon both the employees and the
employees. It victimises the public and the consumers. It may and often does hurt
national interests when the public utility and defiance industries are involved.” But
these responsibilities are a two-way traffic, the employees have also many
responsibilities towards the management of these banks. It can be remarked that “ the
20 Reddy, Y.V. “Development of Money Market in Indid’, Address at the Fifth J.V. Somayajulu
Memorial Lecture at Madras, February, 1999.
128
L
harmonious industrial relations can develop only on the basis of mutual understanding
A stable and consistent growth in the banking industry is very much required
for a developing country like India. This growth ensures the fulfilment of the
different needs of the economy . To ensure this growth banks should properly
organised and efficiently managed. The administrative machinery should ensure easy
the new tasks and challenges of the commercial banking. It should also ensure
efficient and optimum utilisation of men and material resources of these banks.
Thus, the relationship between a banker and his customer begins with the
opening an account by the former in the name of the latter. Initially all the accounts
are opened with a deposit of money by the customer and hence these accounts are
called deposits accounts. The banks have introduced different types of accounts
which are classified into three categories: (1) The saving deposit account, (2) The
fixed deposit accounts, and (3) The current accounts. In recent years a few new types
of accounts have also been introduced by banks. All these have changed the nature
and scope of relationship among banker and customer. It is against this background,
129