Principles of Taxation Report
Principles of Taxation Report
Principles of Taxation Report
Nature
1.) Legislative – this power can only be exercised by the law making body (Congress)
not the executive or the judicial branch of the government, except when delegated
by the national legislative body to a local legislative body or to the executive
branch, subject to limitations as may be provided by law;
Scope
The scope of Taxation is that it is comprehensive, unlimited, supreme and plenary, but
subject to constitutional and inherent limitations.
Classifications of Taxes
As to scope
a.) Personal, poll or capitation –a fixed amount tax that is imposed upon individuals,
whether citizens or not, residing within a specified territory without regard to their
property or the occupation in which he may be engaged.
b.) Property – tax imposed on property, whether real or personal, in proportion either
to its value, or in accordance with some other reasonable method of
apportionment.
c.) Excise – any tax which does not fall within the classification of a poll tax or a
property tax. This is a tax on the exercise of certain rights and privileges. It may
also refer to the tax levied or imposed on sin products and non-essential goods
such as cigars and liquors.
a.) Direct – tax which is demanded from the person who also shoulders the burden of
tax or tax which the taxpayer cannot shift to another. Both the incidence (liability
for the payment of the tax) as well as the impact or burdent of the tax falls on the
same person (e.g. income tax, estate tax, donor’s tax.)
b.) Indirect – tax which is demanded from one person in the expectation and intention
that he shall indemnify himself at the expense of another. These are taxes wherein
the incidence of or the liability for the payment of the tax falls on one person but
the burden thereof can be shifted or passed on to another person.
As to determination of amount:
a.) Specific – tax of fixed amount imposed by the head or number, or by some
standard of weight or measurement.
b.) Ad Valorem – tax of fixed proportion of the value of the property with respect to
which the tax is assessed.
As to purpose:
a.) Primary – tax imposed solely for the general purpose of the government.
b.) Secondary – tax imposed for a specific purpose/
As to graduation or rate:
a.) Proportional – tax based on a fixed percentage of amount of the property, receipts,
or other basis to be taxed
b.) Progressive or graduated – tax the rate of which increases as the tax base or
bracket increases
c.) Regressive – tax the rate of which decreases as the tax base or bracket increases.
As to taxing authority:
a.) National – taxes imposed under the National Internal Revenue Code collected by
the national government through the Bureau of Internal Revenue and other
national government agencies.
b.) Local – taxes imposed by local government units.
ESSENTIAL CHARACTERISTICS
- An enforced contribution
- Generally Payable in Money
- Proportionate in Character
- Levied on Persons
- Levied by the law-making body of the state.
- Levied for Public Purpose
CASE EXAMPLE:
EN BANC
Provincial Fiscal Zoila M. Redona & Assistant Provincial Fiscal Bonifacio R Matol and
Assistant Solicitor General Conrado T. Limcaoco & Solicitor Enrique M. Reyes for
appellees.
MARTIN, J.:
This is an appeal from the decision of the Court of First Instance of Leyte in its Civil Case
No. 3294, which was certified to Us by the Court of Appeals on October 6, 1969, as
involving only pure questions of law, challenging the power of taxation delegated to
municipalities under the Local Autonomy Act (Republic Act No. 2264, as amended, June
19, 1959).
On July 23, 1963, the parties entered into a Stipulation of Facts, the material portions of
which state that, first, both Ordinances Nos. 23 and 27 embrace or cover the same subject
matter and the production tax rates imposed therein are practically the same, and second,
that on January 17, 1963, the acting Municipal Treasurer of Tanauan, Leyte, as per his
letter addressed to the Manager of the Pepsi-Cola Bottling Plant in said municipality,
sought to enforce compliance by the latter of the provisions of said Ordinance No. 27,
series of 1962.
Municipal Ordinance No. 23, of Tanauan, Leyte, which was approved on September 25,
1962, levies and collects "from soft drinks producers and manufacturers a tai of one-
sixteenth (1/16) of a centavo for every bottle of soft drink corked." 2 For the purpose of
computing the taxes due, the person, firm, company or corporation producing soft drinks
shall submit to the Municipal Treasurer a monthly report, of the total number of bottles
produced and corked during the month. 3
On the other hand, Municipal Ordinance No. 27, which was approved on October 28,
1962, levies and collects "on soft drinks produced or manufactured within the territorial
jurisdiction of this municipality a tax of ONE CENTAVO (P0.01) on each gallon (128 fluid
ounces, U.S.) of volume capacity." 4 For the purpose of computing the taxes due, the
person, fun company, partnership, corporation or plant producing soft drinks shall submit
to the Municipal Treasurer a monthly report of the total number of gallons produced or
manufactured during the month. 5
On October 7, 1963, the Court of First Instance of Leyte rendered judgment "dismissing
the complaint and upholding the constitutionality of [Section 2, Republic Act No. 2264]
declaring Ordinance Nos. 23 and 27 legal and constitutional; ordering the plaintiff to pay
the taxes due under the oft the said Ordinances; and to pay the costs."
From this judgment, the plaintiff Pepsi-Cola Bottling Company appealed to the Court of
Appeals, which, in turn, elevated the case to Us pursuant to Section 31 of the Judiciary
Act of 1948, as amended.
LIFE APPLICATION:
The Government expects each person to know the Law as well as know Taxation. It is
expected that we obey and have knowledge towards Taxation and that we as Philippine
Citizens have an obligation to pay our Taxes so that our Government can be able to
provide us the benefits and privileges they can accommodate to us from our paid taxes.
The importance of knowing how taxation works will give future taxpayers ideas and
financial strategies to overcome collections of taxes and it will give them an explanation
on why it is important to contribute to paying taxes.
1.) Fiscal Adequacy – The sources (proceeds) of tax revenue should coincide with
and approximate the needs of the government expenditures.
2.) Theoretical Justice – The tax system should be fair to the average taxpayer
and based upon his ability to pay.
3.) Administrative Feasibility – The tax system should be capable of being properly
and efficiently administered by the government and enforced with the least
inconvenience to the taxpayer.
HYPOTHETICAL CASE: In order to find out Taxpayer A’s Tax due amount
without being unjust and with the least amount of inconvenience, The Tax Due
shall be computed by Adding all of his Annual Income and reducing the amount
by his expenses and basic and personal exemptions, after that we will be able
to identify his taxable income which will then be checked using the graduated
tax table (SECTION 24A-NIRC) In order to get his Tax due for the year.
Life Application: As the time comes when we finally have a livelihood, we are
also required to pay the government our contribution in the form of taxes. Every
person has a different amount of taxable income but Taxes are to be paid in an
amount which does not put taxpayers in a very tight financial situation. Taxes
should be estimated without giving so much inconvenience to the tax payer and
those said taxes should be placed in funding of important government
expenditures that can benefit said tax payers in the future.
A.) Direct
Classification is permitted:
1.) If the standards used therefor are not arbitrary but reasonable and substantial.
2.) If the classification is germane to achieve the purpose of the legislation.
3.) If that classification applies to both present and future conditions, other
circumstances being equal.
4.) If the classification applies equally to all those belonging to the same class.
No person shall be imprisoned for non-payment of a poll tax (Art II, Sec
20)
6.) Congress shall evolve a progressive system of taxation (Art VI, Sec
28, par 1)
As resources of the taxpayer becomes higher, his tax rate likewise
increases
13.) Special purpose – special fund for said purpose, balance goes
to general funds
B.) Indirect
1. Freedom of religion
2. Freedom of press/ expression
3. Mandatory Character of Constitutional Provision
CASE EXAMPLE:
LIFE APPLICATION:
Knowing the Limitations of the Power of Taxation can give us a proper
understanding of how Taxation treats other types of businesses and specific
organizations. It also shows us an insight on how to taxation is treated towards
non-profit and religious organizations.
Tax Evasion – a.k.a Tax Dodging – connotes fraud through the use of pretenses and
forbidden devices to lessen or defeat taxes; must be willful and intentional
Tax Avoidance – a.k.a Tax Minimization – tax saving device that is legally permissible
HYPOTHETICAL CASE:
Taxpayer A donates his property to a non-profit institution which is qualified for Tax
exemption. Taxpayer A Commits Tax Avoidance.
Company C made a taxable income report with an amount that is less than what it is really
amounted to, Company C Commits Tax Evasion.
LIFE APPLICATION: One way to distinguish an Evasion from Avoidance is from the way
it is committed. If committed though unethical standards of reporting or making off record
sales which cannot be found in company records can be said to be an evasion to pay
taxes while making donations or reducing owned properties through selling them is
considered Tax Avoiding because of the legal means of reducing tax payment. The
importance of distinguishing tax avoidance and tax evasion will help those who are
planning on starting a business of their own. Being able to understand both terms can
prevent illegal applications of tax evasions while giving businessmen wise thoughts on
applying tax avoidance in their businesses.
SITUS EXAMPLES:
Double Taxation can be referred to as direct duplicate taxation or indirect double taxation.
It is when a person, property or right is being taxed twice. It isn’t considered an illegal
practice; however, it is mostly frowned upon due to its unjust application.
Direct Duplicate:
Indirect Duplicate:
The Supreme Court held that there is no constitutional prohibition against “double
taxation” in the Philippines. However, in its strict sense, there is “direct” double taxation
(strict sense) when the same property is taxed twice when it should be taxed once
provided both taxes must be imposed.
LIFE APPLICATION:
Double Taxation can be a big problem towards tax payers. Despite being legal in the
Philippines, this kind of practice is also unfavorable. This, however, can be avoided.
Knowing Double Taxation can be helpful especially when you are being a victim of Double
Taxation and this concept may also provide a good amount of knowledge toward your
rights as a tax payer.
Tax law in the Philippines covers national and local taxes. National taxes refer
to national internal revenue taxes imposed and collected by the national
government through the Bureau of Internal Revenue (BIR) and local taxes refer
to those imposed and collected by the local government. The Legislation of tax
laws are not simply declared but they are processed and passed on to different
departments and government official to ensure its lawful and just in order for
the public to accept and obey those said laws.
a.) Constitution
b.) National Internal Revenue Code
c.) Tariff and Customs Code
d.) Local Government Code (Book II)
e.) Local tax ordinances/ City or municipal tax codes
f.) Tax Treaties and International Agreements
g.) Special Laws
h.) Decisions of the Supreme Court and the Court of Tax Appeals
i.) Revenue Rules and Regulations and Administrative Rulings and Opinions
-except when the law otherwise expressly provides, the aforesaid revenue tax issuances
shall not begin to be operative until after due notice thereof may be fairly assumed.
CASE EXAMPLE:
Applying the foregoing rationale of the provision on tax-exemption, the Court found
Revenue Memorandum Order (RMO) No. 20-2013 unconstitutional as it imposes as a
prerequisite to the enjoyment by non-stock, non-profit educational institutions of the
privilege of tax exemption under the Constitution both a registration and approval
requirement particularly, that they submit an application for tax exemption ruling (TER)
which is valid for a period of 3 years and subject to renewal. This requirement of filing a
TER is in addition to the filing of an Annual Information Return that they are currently
required to submit to the BIR pursuant to Section 4 of DOR Order No. 137-87.
LIFE APPLICATION: The Tax Laws are to be taken in a strict manner and we should
realize that these laws are not simply made, but they are constructed through thorough
research and are decided by high officials in the government. It is our obligation to know
and understand these laws so that we may not commit mistakes in the future and to also
not become victims of violations that we have not seek to know about.
It is understood that as we gain our own source of income and when we are above the
minimal wage earners, we are obliged to pay our annual tax. These taxes are what makes
our country progress, when it comes to Tourism, Economy, Agriculture, etc. Our
contributions in the form of tax payments helps us build a nation that is striving to become
a Developed Country. If our contributions are consistent and continuous, the nation would
develop new projects that would be of great benefit to our citizens and to those residing
in the Philippines.
HYPOTHETICAL EXAMPLE:
With our tax contributions, the Government could create more developed ways of
transportation for the citizens in both cities and provinces. Our Government could develop
new roads that can loosen traffic as well with the right budget.
LIFE APPLICATION: As Citizens of the Philippines, no matter how much taxes are a
burden towards our savings, it is a sworn duty to us for being a citizen of the Philippines,
we may not see it but as time goes by, our Nation could become a better place if we would
put our contributions in the hands of the Government.
Paying taxes can give heavy burdens not only to individual tax payers but also to
businesses in the Philippines. The tax compliance in the Philippines today can be
considered to be stable and individuals are still cooperating when it comes to their
taxes due. Exemptions to taxpayers are accommodating and with the use of the
graduated tax table and with the exemptions of minimal wage earners to pay taxes is
a fair practice to all citizens in the Philippines.
The Tax Administration in the Philippines is very uniform and strict when it comes to
Tax Collecting and Recording. Because of its wide array of tax laws, Organizations
like BIR for example take Taxation seriously by keeping all records in order and have
a strict approach when bringing notices to individual and corporate taxpayers.
BIR CASE:
Summary: The Estate is suspected to be adjusting its income tax returns in order to avoid
payment of taxes, the BIR took action and filled a case towards the estate of Toda to
clarify if the estate did commit tax evasion by adjusting its records.
The Organization of the BIR is headed by the Office of the Commissioner of Internal
Revenue, which composes of 7 Offices. Those departments responsible for future
developments and further improvements of the organization are found in the Planning
and Management Service, Project Management and Implementation Service. It’s
offices for financial and tax services are found in the Large Taxpayers Service and the
4 Groups of the Office of the Deputy Commissioner (Operations, Legal, Information
Systems, Resource Management).
2.) Bureau of Customs
The Bureau of Customs are responsible for the control and monitoring of the export-
import of Weapons of Mass Destruction and dual purpose articles in the Philippines. Its
power makes them the first and last line of defense in enforcement of export control laws
in the country. The Bureau of Customs are the ones who assess and collect the lawful
revenues from imported articles and other fees, dues, charges, fines and penalties
accruing under the tariff and customs laws. They also function as a means of preventing
and suppressing incidences of smuggling or frauds that occur in the Philippines, as well
as supervise and control the entrance and clearance of vessels and aircraft who are
engaging in foreign commerce. They strongly enforce the tariff, custom and other laws
which makes them an organization dedicated to the law and for the sole purpose of
protecting the country from illegal means of importing and exporting unauthorized and
unlawful cargo.
Commissioner of Customs
1.) Internal Administration – those responsible for the management of the Bureau of
Customs itself and consists of Divisions which keep track of the organization’s
finance, budgeting, administration, accounting, etc.
2.) Assessment and Operation and Coordination Group – those who are in charge of
assessing various imports, exports and other forms of exchanges that occur in the
Philippines.
3.) Revenue Collection Monitoring Group – those who monitor the flow of revenues
that occur in the Philippines for the purpose of regulation and security of our
citizens and our economy.
4.) Intelligence Group – those who collect data and conduct researches that may
predict potential outcomes as well as investigate on those who may or may not
commit unlawful acts in the Philippines.
5.) Enforcement Group – those who take action in cases of serious events and those
willing to take risks for the protection and prevention of unlawful, illegal and harmful
transactions in the country.
7.) Post-Entry Audit Group – those who keep track of transactions that have passed
the lawful standards of the organization and are being recorded in this group.
The Local Financial Systems, drawn from the theory and practice of local fiscal
administration of the Philippines, encompasses the systems of development planning,
taxation and revenue generation, budgeting and spending, borrowing, budget
accountability and audit.
There are four classifications of Local Governments in the Philippines with each
classification having a set of officials, both elective and appointive, and performs a well-
defined set of executive or legislative functions.
The Governor or Mayor is the Chief Executive Officer of a province, city and municipality,
while the Barangay Captain is the Chief Executive of the Barangay Government. On the
side of the Legistlative Branch, the Local Sanggunian (Council) headed by the Vice-
Governor in Provinces or the Vice Mayor in Cities and Municipalities, along with the
members of the Sanggunian, exercise the power of legislation.
The Sanggunian makes policies through ordinances and resolutions, and approves
among others:
Table 1. LGU Elected Officials and Members of the Sanggunian (RA 7160)
The Philippine Economic Zone Authority (PEZA), attached to the Department of Trade
and Industry, is tasked to promote investments, extend assistance, register, grant
incentives to and facilitate the business operations of investors in export-oriented
manufacturing and service facilities inside selected areas throughout the country
proclaimed by the President of the Philippines as PEZA Special Economic Zones.
The PEZA Head Office is can be Metro Manila (National Capital Region).
The Organizational Chart of the PEZA consists of several groups operated by the Office
of the Director General:
1.) Office of the Deputy Director General for Policy and Planning
- handles Management Information System and Corporate Planning functions.
- it is tasked on future development planning and promotes its on-going policies in
the organization.
2.) Office of the Deputy Director General for Finance and Administration
- handles the Financial tasks and Personnel of the Organization
- in charge of keeping records of the organization transactions and financial
budgeting, accounting, bookkeeping as well as handle employees with its Human
Resource Department under the organization’s Personnel and Administrative
Services Group.
REFERENCES:
Adviento, L. (n.d.). Bureau of Customs: It’s Role in Export Control. Lecture. Retrieved
from http://www.meti.go.jp/policy/anpo/outreach/Industry_PH/pdf/ph04.pdf
Davide, Jr., C.J. (Ed.). (n.d.). G.R. No. 147188 September 14, 2004. Retrieved from
http://www.lawphil.net/judjuris/juri2004/sep2004/gr_147188_2004.html
Martin, J. (Ed.). (n.d.). G.R. No L-31156 February 27, 1976. Retrieved from
http://www.lawphil.net/judjuris/juri1976/feb1976/gr_31156_1976.html
Tabag, E.D., & Garcia, E.J. (2017). Income Taxation, Quezon City: MaxCor Publishing
House, Inc.