An Explanation of Possible Damascus Steel Manufacturing Based On Duration of Transient Nucleate Boiling Process and Prediction of The Future of Controlled Continuous Casting
An Explanation of Possible Damascus Steel Manufacturing Based On Duration of Transient Nucleate Boiling Process and Prediction of The Future of Controlled Continuous Casting
An Explanation of Possible Damascus Steel Manufacturing Based On Duration of Transient Nucleate Boiling Process and Prediction of The Future of Controlled Continuous Casting
Abstract - In the paper the new explanation in cementite microstructure were also found in the
manufacturing of Damascus steel, based on discovered archeological items from Pol'tse, a settlement at Amur
the specific characteristics of transient nucleate boiling river, V-IV century B.C. Raw materials and Damascus
processes, is provided. Also, the future of continuous steel crafting instruction are not longer available. Details
casting in the paper is discussed. According to of technology, which was used by the capable
discovered characteristics, duration of transient nucleate metallurgists from Pol'tse, is not known [8]. The ancient
boiling process is directly proportional to squared size of technique reached modern - day Turkmenistan and
a steel part and inversely proportional to thermal Uzbekistan around 900 A.D., and then the Middle East
diffusivity of material, depends on configuration and circa 1000 A.D. There are numerous publications where
initial temperature of component, thermal properties of this matter is widely discussed [9 - 16]. It is underlined
liquid. The surface temperature of steel part during that India has been reputed for its iron and steel since
transient nucleate boiling process maintains at the level ancient times, the time of Alexander the Great (356 B.C.
of boiling point of liquid and cannot be below it. Based - 323 B.C.) [5] . When Alexander the Great got to India
on these characteristics, the new hypothesis regarding he ordered to be delivered to him “100 talents of Indian
manufacturing of Damascus steel is proposed according steel” [5]. Studies on “wootz” indicate that is was an
to which the melted high carbon steel (containing 1 – 2% ultra - high carbon steel with 1 - 2% carbon. Metal
carbon) was casted into copper forms cooled by cold smiths in India and Sri Lanka developed a technique that
water and then the steel was many times forged and produced unusually high purity “wootz” steel. Glass was
quenched in special water salt solutions until finishing added to a mixture of iron and charcoal and then heated.
transient nucleate boiling process. Such simple The glass would act as a flux and bind to other
technology provided extremely small spherical carbides impurities in the mixture, allowing them to rise to the
distributed in steel which acted as a saw and made steel surface and leave a pure steel when the mixture cooled.
very strong. It is stated that high strength materials with It is interesting to know that more than two millennium
fine microstructure can be achieved by applying ago ancient metallurgists manufactured pure ultra - high
intensive cooling to continuous casting. carbon steel which was of high quality [4, 5]. Later the
main features of the method of ancient metallurgists
Keywords - Transient nucleate boiling process, were rediscovered by Anosov in his systematic research
Damascus steel, Hammering, HTMT and LTMT at Zlatoust Arms Factory in Russia during 1828 - 1840
processes, Highly strengthened plain carbon steels, [1, 2]. The essence of the Anosov's method consists in
Continuous casting. many cycles of forging the ultra - high carbon steel at
high temperature with intermediate annealing. Accurate
I. INTRODUCTION microstructure studies of Damascus steel with correct
explanation of its strengthening due to formation of fine
Damascus steel was a hot - forged steel which was used
spheroidized carbides were published by N.T.Belaiew in
in Middle East's sword making from 1000 to 1700 A.D.
Journal of the Iron and Steel Institute [3]. Microstructure
[1-5]. The foundation for Damascus steel was "wootz"
of a typical Damascus sword is characterized by
steel which originated in India, Sri Lanka and later
formation of spherical cementite particles of 5 - 20 µm
spread to Persia [4 - 7]. Steel making sites were found in
Sri Lanka that made high carbon steel as early as 300 [3, 8]. Fundamental scientific research on the
B.C. According to Ref. [8], the small spherical grains of development of high-carbon steel with the uniform
submicron-size cementite structure was performed by Below are equations describing the two mechanisms of
Sherby in the 1970s and 1980s. The Sherby method for precipitation hardening. Dislocations cutting through the
forming high-carbon steel closely resembles the method small carbides [19]:
of Damascus craftsmen. Both methods include numerous
cycles of intensive high temperature deformation and rγπ
annealing. While Damascus steel was formed by στ = (1)
forging, the Sherby method utilized rolling as the bL
deformation means. Several U.S. Patents of Sherby
describe an ultra high-carbon steel having a carbon about where στ is material strength, r is the second phase
1.0% - 2.3 % and an iron grain matrix with uniformly particle radius, γ is the surface energy, b is the
dispersed cementite [14, 15, 16]. magnitude of the Burgers vector, and L is the spacing
between pinning points. This governing equation shows
that the strength is proportional to r. This means that it is
easier for dislocations to cut through a material with the
smaller second phase particles. As the size of the second
phase particles increases, the particles impede
dislocation movement and it is very difficult for
dislocations to cut through the material. It means that the
strength of a material increases with increasing r.
Gb
στ = , (2)
L − 2r
diffusivity of material. The character of surface thermomechanical treatment (LTMT) can be easily
temperature changing during transient nucleate boiling fulfilled for high carbon steel and UHCS. It cannot be
(self- regulated thermal process) is shown in Fig, 5 (see done when quenching high carbon steel and UHCS in
curve 2). Such trend can be written as [22]: oil. Only alloy steels can be used for LTMT processing.
Discovered characteristics (see (Eq.(4) and Eq. (5))
Tsf = TS + ξ 0 ≈ const , (5) make LTMT possible and this process is effective for
plain carbon steels including high carbon steel and
where T sf is average surface temperature of a body; TS is UHCS. There is a great probability that ancient
saturation temperature; ξ 0 = Tsf − T S is average wall metallurgists might have used some empirical data
connected with the boiling processes. It could be copper
overheat. Very fast cooling can cause martensite melting form immersed into cold water (see Fig. 3).
transformation which will results in crack formation (see After the melted material is powered into the form, water
curve 1 in Fig. 5). is heated to boiling point and remains at this
temperature until end of solidification. Since martensite
Equation (4) can be used at continuous casting
start temperature is equal to boiling point of water, no
secondary cooling to accelerate cooling rate of
martensite transformation occur. Then UHCS was
solidifying slabs. It can be also widely used when
heated to high temperature and many times forged. Low
intensive quenching IQ-2 process is applied to
temperature and high temperature thermomechanical
quenching of slabs after their solidification. Both
treatment possibly was used to improve significantly
processes increase significantly mechanical properties of
mechanical properties of UHCS. During
materials due to formation of fine microstructure during
thermomechanical treatment, quenching process should
intensive quenching.
be interrupted at the end of nucleate boiling process to
prevent martensite transformation at LTMT.
material based on phenomena of non- linear mechanics is martensite start temperature; AC3 is critical point of
[26, 27]; 5 is vibrating hole tube to deliver nano – austenite transformation.
particles; 6 are movable air – water sprayers; 7 is support
roll; 8 is boundary between melted and solid material. Turning on and off air – spray method was used by
authors [29] in 1991 to simulate oil cooling. There is no
doubt that turning on and off air – spray method can be
used to simulate transient boiling process which occur
during quenching in cold water and water salt solutions
of optimal concentration. Therefore, the air – spray
controlled cooling can be used to optimize quenching
processes shown in Fig. 9. This process is called the
secondary cooling because metal is cooled second time
after its solidifying.
VI. DISCUSSION
VII. CONCLUSION