1) The document provides a research defense rating form for panel members to evaluate student research proposals.
2) The rating form includes criteria such as the clarity of the problem statement, adequacy of the literature review, methodology, and organization of the manuscript.
3) Panel members are asked to assign a numerical score and rating to each criteria based on their objective assessment of the proposal using the provided rating guide that defines scores and ratings.
1) The document provides a research defense rating form for panel members to evaluate student research proposals.
2) The rating form includes criteria such as the clarity of the problem statement, adequacy of the literature review, methodology, and organization of the manuscript.
3) Panel members are asked to assign a numerical score and rating to each criteria based on their objective assessment of the proposal using the provided rating guide that defines scores and ratings.
1) The document provides a research defense rating form for panel members to evaluate student research proposals.
2) The rating form includes criteria such as the clarity of the problem statement, adequacy of the literature review, methodology, and organization of the manuscript.
3) Panel members are asked to assign a numerical score and rating to each criteria based on their objective assessment of the proposal using the provided rating guide that defines scores and ratings.
1) The document provides a research defense rating form for panel members to evaluate student research proposals.
2) The rating form includes criteria such as the clarity of the problem statement, adequacy of the literature review, methodology, and organization of the manuscript.
3) Panel members are asked to assign a numerical score and rating to each criteria based on their objective assessment of the proposal using the provided rating guide that defines scores and ratings.
Download as DOCX, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
Download as docx, pdf, or txt
You are on page 1/ 2
Holy Child College of Information Technology Inc.
Orchid St., Brgy. Libertad, Surallah, South Cotabato
RESEARCH DEFENSE RATING FORM
Researchers: Name of Panel Member: Date of Proposal Defense: __________________________ Place: _________ Time __________ Rating Guide: 4 – Outstanding - Meets the criteria in all indicators 3- Very Satisfactory - Meets the criteria in most indicators 2- Fair - Meets criteria in some indicators 1 – Needs Improvement – Meets criteria in very few indicators Please write the score based on your objective assessment. Criteria/Indicators 4 3 2 1 Score 16-20 11-15 6-10 1-5 Clarity and Importance of Problem Statement (20 %) Problem statement builds a logical, coherent argument for the relevance of the study. It leads to the hypotheses to be tested and/or the questions to be answered. It is clear precisely what this study is intended to accomplish. Study contributes to educational theory, policy, and/or practice. Adequacy of Literature Review/Conceptual Framework (20%) The literature review show how the proposed study will build upon and go beyond previous research on the subject. The analysis is a critical review of the literature. The key concepts are clearly defined and organized in a way that makes sense. Adequacy of Methodology (20%) The research design is clear. The selection of sample from the population is specified. The sample size is adequate. The kinds and sources of data required to carry out the study are specified and available. The data collection methods are adequately described. There is a clear strategy to analyze the data and/or to test the hypotheses? Manuscript/Organization (20%) The manuscript shows clarity and style; cogency, logic, sequencing of information; completeness and follows prescribed format. Oral Presentation/Delivery (20%) The presenter/s speaks with confidence and manifests adequacy of vocabulary; right use of words; mastery of research proposal; is able to respond to inquiries; and used appropriate visual aid.
Noted by: Chairperson Holy Child College of Information Technology Inc. Orchid St., Brgy. Libertad, Surallah, South Cotabato
COMMENTS AND SUGGESTIONS
Researchers: _______________________________________________________________________________ Name of Panel Member: _____________________________________________________________________ Date of Proposal Defense: __________________________ Place: _______________ Time________________
Please read the research manuscript ahead of the defense schedule and write your comments and suggestions below (Use the back of the sheet if needed).
