Lafarge Pakistan Cement WPU 200 C380 JCP 09 2011 Assembled Report
Lafarge Pakistan Cement WPU 200 C380 JCP 09 2011 Assembled Report
Lafarge Pakistan Cement WPU 200 C380 JCP 09 2011 Assembled Report
– Pakistan
Inspection of gear unit
Visiting period: 10th – 15th of September, 2011
Client representative:
Mr. Muhammad Tariq, Head of Maintenance
Mr. Asim Saeed, Methods Manager
Mr. Tabish Iqbal, Team Leader, Inspection; Methods Department
FLS specialist:
Jens Christian Poulsen, Field Engineer, BSc. (Mech.)
Gear inspection report
1. Conclusions:
The visual inspection proved that the general, mechanical operating condition of the gear
unit is acceptable.
All visible working flanks were fine and polished and that all contact during tooth meshing
appeared good.
The frequency analysis of the vibration measurements shows that the vibration level of
the gear unit is still satisfactory but it also revealed impulse frequencies at the high speed
bearings. The situation should be monitored.
Based on the current operating condition we recommend to implement the spare parts
already on site at the next scheduled kiln stop together with two new high-speed bearings.
2. Recommendations:
We recommend that the quality of the oil be analysed twice a year. The oil sample should be
taken in a place which represents the oil circulating in the gear unit. The oil must meet the
requirements of ANSI / AGMA standard 9005-E02. As to foaming, the requirements of
ASTM standard D892-4 must be complied with.
We recommend implementing the spare parts already on site at the next scheduled kiln stop.
3. Introduction:
The purpose of the visit was to inspect the gears at Lafarge Pakistan Cement according to
the agreement with FLS.
4. Inspection:
The inspection comprised a visual check of the components of the gear unit and vibration
measurements taken at the measuring points indicated on the diagram of Enclosure 3.
The results of the inspection appear from the following sections and the enclosures.
Pump station:
The general condition of the oil station is considered good. Housekeeping is good; filters
are changed as needed, oil samples are taken for analysis and oil changed if needed.
Gear inspection report
WPU-200/C380,
200/C380, M/N 16003866/10 for raw mill ATOX 50 5.507937
Gear inspection report
The frequency analysis of the vibration measurements shows that the overall vibration level
of the gear unit is still normal. The variations seen are due to operation conditions.
The amplitude levels around the high-speed and low-speed gear mesh frequencies are still
considered normal.
Shock pulses in the form of impulse frequencies that could indicate wear on or defects in
the various roller bearing components were registered at the bearing frequencies of the
high-speed spherical roller bearings.
5. Enclosures:
Enclosure 1: History
Enclosure 2: Inspection check list
Enclosure 3: Vibration measurements, spectrograms
Plant: Lafarge Pakistan Cement
Country: Pakistan
History
2006: April. Installation.
2006: June. Commissioning
2007: December. Inspection and vibration measurements.
2008: May. Damage to gear investigation commencing
2008: June. Repair completed
2009: September. 1000 hours check after repair incl. vibration measurements.
2011: September. Inspection and vibration measurements.
Plant: Lafarge Pakistan Cement
Country: Pakistan
Type and size of gearbox: WPU – 200/C-380 Total service time: 26937 hours
Order No: 16003866 Lube oil diagram: 50077835 Insp. by: JCP
Motor data: 3900 kW, 993 RPM Consumption: 3000 kW Insp.date: 12-09-2011
o
Oil temperature inlet C Yes 42
o
Oil temperature outlet C Yes 51
o
Oil temperature tank C Yes 53
o
Oil temperature gear C Yes 58
Yes
Pressure before filter Bar Yes 7
Pressure after filter Bar Yes 6.5
Vibration measurements
0,95
0,9
0,85
0,8
0,75
0,7
g
0,65
0,6
0,55
0,5
0,45
0,4
0,35
01-12-2007 29-05-2008 25-11-2008 24-05-2009 20-11-2009 19-05-2010 15-11-2010 12-09-2011
Measurement Time Stamp
Active Trace
POINT Information Value
WPU-200/C-380 \ 00 ACC POINT description HS. BEARINGS
Machine description WPU 200/C-380
SET name Pakistan Cement \ WPU-200/C-380 \ 00 ACC
Location
Orientation None
Units g
Full scale 5
Mean 0,5643
Std. deviation 0,3311
POINT Summary
POINT Information Value
WPU-200/C-380 \ 00 ACC POINT description HS. BEARINGS
Units g
Measurement 12-09-2011 15:23:39, 0,9466
Measurement 02-09-2009 06:38:39, 0,3807
Measurement 01-12-2007 11:02:00, 0,3657
Single Cursor
POINT Date/Time Amplitude
WPU-200/C-380 \ 00 ACC 12-09-2011 15:23:39 0,9466
1,5
mm/s - RMS
0,5 3
995 RPM
4
5
6 7 8 9 10
0
0 50 100 150 200 250 300 350 400 450 500 550 600 650 700 750 800 850 900 952,7
Frequency - Hz
Active Trace
POINT Information Value
WPU-200/C-380 \ 00 VEL Measurement 12-09-2011 15:23:49
Speed 995
POINT description HS. BEARINGS
Machine description WPU 200/C-380
SET name Pakistan Cement \ WPU-200/C-380 \ 00 VEL
Location
Orientation None
Units mm/s
Full scale 10
Low frequency cutoff 5
Frequency range 0 - 2000 Hz
Detection RMS
Window Hanning
Lines 3200
Averages 3
Save Data FFT and time
Threshold 1
Spectrum Overall 3,755
Sync 1,232
Subsync 0,3669
Nonsync 3,528
POINT Summary
POINT Information Value
WPU-200/C-380 \ 00 VEL POINT description HS. BEARINGS
Units mm/s
Measurement 12-09-2011 15:23:49
WPU-200/C-380 \ 00 VEL POINT description HS. BEARINGS
Units mm/s
Measurement 02-09-2009 06:39:02
Frequencies
POINT Label Harmonic Frequency Amplitude
WPU-200/C-380 \ 00 VEL No FAM visible
Single Cursor
POINT Frequency Order Amplitude Phase
WPU-200/C-380 \ 00 VEL 208,8 12,59 1,759 (mm/s)
Harmonic Cursor
POINT Harmonic Frequency Order Amplitude % of Fund.
WPU-200/C-380 \ 00 VEL Fund. 88,13 5,31 0,3171
2 176,3 10,63 0,7114 224,4
3 264,4 15,94 0,4791 151,1
4 352,5 21,26 0,201 63,38
5 440,6 26,57 0,1137 35,85
6 528,8 31,88 0,04212 13,28
7 616,9 37,2 0,02533 7,988
8 705 42,51 0,04898 15,45
9 793,1 47,83 0,02915 9,192
10 881,3 53,14 0,01144 3,609
22
23
22
23
22
23
22
23
22
23
22
23
22
22
23
22
23
22
23
0,3
0,25
gE - Peak To Peak
0,2
0,15
0,1
995 RPM
0,05
0
0 25 50 75 100 125 150 175 200 222,8
Frequency - Hz
Active Trace
POINT Information Value
WPU-200/C-380 \ 00 ENV Measurement 01-12-2007 11:02:24
Speed 995
POINT description HS. BEARINGS
Machine description WPU 200/C-380
SET name Pakistan Cement \ WPU-200/C-380 \ 00 ENV
Location
Orientation None
Units gE
Full scale 25
Low frequency cutoff 0
Frequency range 0 - 1000 Hz
Detection Peak to peak
Window Hanning
Lines 1600
Averages 1
Save Data FFT
Threshold 2,5
Spectrum Overall 0,4696
Sync 0,1492
Subsync 0,2077
Nonsync 0,3939
POINT Summary
POINT Information Value
WPU-200/C-380 \ 00 ENV POINT description HS. BEARINGS
Units gE
Measurement 01-12-2007 11:02:24
WPU-200/C-380 \ 00 ENV POINT description HS. BEARINGS
Units gE
Measurement 12-09-2011 15:23:57
WPU-200/C-380 \ 00 ENV POINT description HS. BEARINGS
Units gE
Measurement 02-09-2009 06:39:11
Frequencies
POINT Label Harmonic Frequency Amplitude
WPU-200/C-380 \ 00 ENV 23144C (SKF) BPFO 1 163,1 0,06134
2 326,3 0,01541
3 489,4 0,02304
4 652,5 0,03021
23144C (SKF) BPFI 1 208,1 0,08011
2 416,3 0,01495
3 624,4 0,04105
4 832,5 0,038
23144C (SKF) BSF 1 66,88 0,05356
2 133,8 0,04471
3 200,6 0,05341
4 267,5 0,04257
23144C (SKF) FTF 1 7,298 0,04318
2 14,6 0,1224
3 21,89 0,1209
4 29,19 0,07874
22352C (SKF) BPFO 1 111,3 0,08393
2 222,5 0,04532
3 333,8 0,03204
4 445 0,03327
22352C (SKF) BPFI 1 155,6 0,08759
2 311,3 0,05631
3 466,9 0,01129
4 622,5 0,05142
22352C (SKF) BSF 1 46,88 0,05219
2 93,75 0,07736
3 140,6 0,1422
4 187,5 0,03937
22352C (SKF) FTF 1 6,896 0,01328
2 13,79 0,04501
3 20,69 0,06287
4 27,59 0,09949
Single Cursor
POINT Frequency Order Amplitude Phase
WPU-200/C-380 \ 00 ENV 1,875 0,1131 0,1026 (gE)
0,1
0,08
g - RMS
0,06
0,04
0,02
995 RPM
0
0 500 1000 1500 2000 2500 3000 3500 4000 4500 5000 5455
Frequency - Hz
Active Trace
POINT Information Value
WPU-200/C-380 \ 01 ACC Measurement 12-09-2011 15:24:20
Speed 995
POINT description HS. BEARINGS
Machine description WPU 200/C-380
SET name Pakistan Cement \ WPU-200/C-380 \ 01 ACC
Location
Orientation None
Units g
Full scale 5
Low frequency cutoff 5
Frequency range 0 - 10000 Hz
Detection RMS
Window Hanning
Lines 1600
Averages 3
Save Data FFT and time
Threshold 0,5
Spectrum Overall 0,4453
Sync 0,3639
Subsync 0,001508
Nonsync 0,2568
POINT Summary
POINT Information Value
WPU-200/C-380 \ 01 ACC POINT description HS. BEARINGS
Units g
Measurement 12-09-2011 15:24:20
WPU-200/C-380 \ 01 ACC POINT description HS. BEARINGS
Units g
Measurement 02-09-2009 06:39:32
Frequencies
POINT Label Harmonic Frequency Amplitude
WPU-200/C-380 \ 01 ACC No FAM assigned
Single Cursor
POINT Frequency Order Amplitude Phase
WPU-200/C-380 \ 01 ACC 87,5 5,28 0,1041 (g)
23
22
22
23
22
23
22
23
22
23
22
23
22
23
22
23
22
22
23
23
0,14
0,12
0,1
gE - Peak To Peak
0,08
0,06
0,04
995 RPM
0,02
0
0 50 100 150 200 250 300 350 400 450 500 550 600 650 700 750 823,4
Frequency - Hz
Active Trace
POINT Information Value
WPU-200/C-380 \ 01 ENV Measurement 12-09-2011 15:24:39
Speed 995
POINT description HS. BEARINGS
Machine description WPU 200/C-380
SET name Pakistan Cement \ WPU-200/C-380 \ 01 ENV
Location
Orientation None
Units gE
Full scale 25
Low frequency cutoff 0
Frequency range 0 - 1000 Hz
Detection Peak to peak
Window Hanning
Lines 1600
Averages 1
Save Data FFT
Threshold 2,5
Spectrum Overall 0,4978
Sync 0,1607
Subsync 0,1588
Nonsync 0,4436
POINT Summary
POINT Information Value
WPU-200/C-380 \ 01 ENV POINT description HS. BEARINGS
Units gE
Measurement 12-09-2011 15:24:39
WPU-200/C-380 \ 01 ENV POINT description HS. BEARINGS
Units gE
Measurement 02-09-2009 06:39:53
Frequencies
POINT Label Harmonic Frequency Amplitude
WPU-200/C-380 \ 01 ENV 23144C (SKF) BPFO 1 156,9 0,02045
Single Cursor
POINT Frequency Order Amplitude Phase
WPU-200/C-380 \ 01 ENV 6,25 0,3769 0,06928 (gE)
1,5
mm/s - RMS
0,5
995 RPM
0
0 200 400 600 800 1000 1200 1400 1600 1800 2000
Frequency - Hz
Active Trace
POINT Information Value
WPU-200/C-380 \ 01 VEL Measurement 12-09-2011 15:24:30
Speed 995
POINT description HS. BEARINGS
Machine description WPU 200/C-380
SET name Pakistan Cement \ WPU-200/C-380 \ 01 VEL
Location
Orientation None
Units mm/s
Full scale 10
Low frequency cutoff 5
Frequency range 0 - 2000 Hz
Detection RMS
Window Hanning
Lines 3200
Averages 3
Save Data FFT and time
Threshold 1
Spectrum Overall 2,232
Sync 0,2927
Subsync 0,9077
Nonsync 2,018
POINT Summary
POINT Information Value
WPU-200/C-380 \ 01 VEL POINT description HS. BEARINGS
Units mm/s
Measurement 12-09-2011 15:24:30
WPU-200/C-380 \ 01 VEL POINT description HS. BEARINGS
Units mm/s
Measurement 02-09-2009 06:39:43
Single Cursor
POINT Frequency Order Amplitude Phase
WPU-200/C-380 \ 01 VEL 88,13 5,31 1,826 (mm/s)
1,5
0,5
0
g
-0,5
-1
-1,5
-2
0 0,02 0,04 0,06 0,08 0,1 0,12 0,14 0,16
Time - Seconds
Active Trace
POINT Information Value
WPU-200/C-380 \ 02 ACC Measurement 12-09-2011 15:25:00
Speed 249
POINT description HS. BEARINGS
Machine description WPU 200/C-380
SET name Pakistan Cement \ WPU-200/C-380 \ 02 ACC
Location
Orientation None
Full scale 5,000
Units g
Time range 0 - 0,16 Seconds
Detection RMS
Lines 4096
Averages 3
Save Data FFT and time
Threshold 0
POINT Summary
POINT Information Value
WPU-200/C-380 \ 02 ACC POINT description HS. BEARINGS
Units g
Measurement 12-09-2011 15:25:00
WPU-200/C-380 \ 02 ACC POINT description HS. BEARINGS
Units g
Measurement 02-09-2009 06:40:19
Time
POINT Amplitude Time
WPU-200/C-380 \ 02 ACC 1,337 0,04407
1
mm/s - RMS
0,5
249 RPM
0
0 50 100 150 200 250 300 350 400 450 506,8
Frequency - Hz
Active Trace
POINT Information Value
WPU-200/C-380 \ 02 VEL Measurement 12-09-2011 15:25:11
Speed 249
POINT description HS. BEARINGS
Machine description WPU 200/C-380
SET name Pakistan Cement \ WPU-200/C-380 \ 02 VEL
Location
Orientation None
Units mm/s
Full scale 10
Low frequency cutoff 5
Frequency range 0 - 2000 Hz
Detection RMS
Window Hanning
Lines 3200
Averages 3
Save Data FFT and time
Threshold 1
Spectrum Overall 1,824
Sync 1,209
Subsync 0
Nonsync 1,366
POINT Summary
POINT Information Value
WPU-200/C-380 \ 02 VEL POINT description HS. BEARINGS
Units mm/s
Measurement 12-09-2011 15:25:11
WPU-200/C-380 \ 02 VEL POINT description HS. BEARINGS
Units mm/s
Measurement 02-09-2009 06:40:30
Single Cursor
POINT Frequency Order Amplitude Phase
WPU-200/C-380 \ 02 VEL 86,88 20,93 0,4288 (mm/s)
23
24
24
23
23
24
23
24
23
24
24
23
23
24
23
24
24
23
24
23
23
0,095
0,09
0,085
0,08
0,075
0,07
0,065
gE - Peak To Peak
0,06
0,055
0,05
0,045
249 RPM
0,04
0,035
0,03
0,025
0,02
0,015
0,01
0,005
0
0 50 100 150 200 250 300 350 400 450 500,9
Frequency - Hz
Active Trace
POINT Information Value
WPU-200/C-380 \ 02 ENV Measurement 12-09-2011 15:25:22
Speed 249
POINT description HS. BEARINGS
Machine description WPU 200/C-380
SET name Pakistan Cement \ WPU-200/C-380 \ 02 ENV
Location
Orientation None
Units gE
Full scale 25
Low frequency cutoff 0
Frequency range 0 - 1000 Hz
Detection Peak to peak
Window Hanning
Lines 1600
Averages 1
Save Data FFT
Threshold 2,5
Spectrum Overall 0,2939
Sync 0,1831
Subsync 0,1108
Nonsync 0,2014
POINT Summary
POINT Information Value
WPU-200/C-380 \ 02 ENV POINT description HS. BEARINGS
Units gE
Measurement 12-09-2011 15:25:22
WPU-200/C-380 \ 02 ENV POINT description HS. BEARINGS
Units gE
Measurement 02-09-2009 06:40:41
Frequencies
POINT Label Harmonic Frequency Amplitude
WPU-200/C-380 \ 02 ENV 23980CAC (SKF) BPFO 1 72,5 0,009949
Single Cursor
POINT Frequency Order Amplitude Phase
WPU-200/C-380 \ 02 ENV 2,5 0,6024 0,09677 (gE)
0,55
0,5
0,45
0,4
0,35
0,3
0,25
0,2
0,15
249 RPM
0,1
0,05
0
0 50 100 150 200 250 300 350 400 450 500 550 600 650 700 750 803,1
Frequency - Hz
Active Trace
POINT Information Value
WPU-200/C-380 \ 03 VEL Measurement 12-09-2011 15:26:42
Speed 249
POINT description LS.
Machine description WPU 200/C-380
SET name Pakistan Cement \ WPU-200/C-380 \ 03 VEL
Location
Orientation None
Units mm/s
Full scale 10
Low frequency cutoff 5
Frequency range 0 - 2000 Hz
Detection RMS
Window Hanning
Lines 3200
Averages 3
Save Data FFT
Threshold 1
Spectrum Overall 1,787
Sync 1,114
Subsync 0
Nonsync 1,397
POINT Summary
POINT Information Value
WPU-200/C-380 \ 03 VEL POINT description LS.
Units mm/s
Measurement 12-09-2011 15:26:42
WPU-200/C-380 \ 03 VEL POINT description LS.
Units mm/s
Measurement 02-09-2009 06:41:03
Frequencies
POINT Label Harmonic Frequency Amplitude
WPU-200/C-380 \ 03 VEL No FAM assigned
Single Cursor
POINT Frequency Order Amplitude Phase
WPU-200/C-380 \ 03 VEL 13,75 3,31 0,7846 (mm/s)
2,4
2,35
2,3
2,25
2,2
2,15
2,1
mm/s
2,05
1,95
1,9
1,85
1,8
1,75
1,7
01-12-2007 29-05-2008 25-11-2008 24-05-2009 20-11-2009 19-05-2010 15-11-2010 12-09-2011
Measurement Time Stamp
Active Trace
POINT Information Value
WPU-200/C-380 \ 04 VEL POINT description LS.
Machine description WPU 200/C-380
SET name Pakistan Cement \ WPU-200/C-380 \ 04 VEL
Location
Orientation None
Units mm/s
Full scale 10
Mean 1,952
Std. deviation 0,3687
POINT Summary
POINT Information Value
WPU-200/C-380 \ 04 VEL POINT description LS.
Units mm/s
Measurement 12-09-2011 15:27:28, 1,719
Measurement 02-09-2009 06:41:36, 2,377
Measurement 01-12-2007 11:07:17, 1,76
Single Cursor
POINT Date/Time Amplitude
WPU-200/C-380 \ 04 VEL 12-09-2011 15:27:28 1,719