Sci P166

P166: Design of Steel Framed Buildings for Service Integration
Discuss me ...
SCI PUBLICATION 166
DESIGN OF
STEEL FRAMED
BUILDINGS FOR
SERVICE
INTEGRATION
This material is copyright - all rights reserved. Use of this document is subject to the terms and conditions of the Steelbiz Licence Agreement
P D McKenna BSc
R M Lawson BSc(Eng), PhD, CEng, MIStructE, MICE
Published by:
The Steel Construction Institute
Silwood Park
Ascot
Berkshire SL5 7QN
Telephone: 01344 623345

Fax: 01 344 622944
Created on 22 July 2009
Discuss me ...
INTERFACES
0 1997 The Steel Construction Institute
Apart from any fair dealing for the purposes of research or

private study or criticism or review, as permitted under the

Copyright Designs and Patents Act, 1988, this publication
may not be reproduced, stored, or transmitted, in any form
or by any means, without the prior permission in writing of
the publishers, or in the case of reprographic reproduction
only in accordance with the terms of the licences issued by
the UK Copyright Licensing Agency, or in accordance with
the terms of licences issued by the appropriate Reproduction
Rights Organisation outside the UK.
Enquiries concerning reproduction outside the terms stated

here should be sent to the publishers, The Steel
Construction Institute, at the address given on the title page.
Although care has been taken to ensure, to the best of our

knowledge, that all data and information contained herein
are accurate to the extent that they relateto either matters of
fact or accepted practice ormatters of opinion at the time of
publication, The Steel Construction Institute, the authors and
the reviewers assume no responsibilityfor any errors in or
misinterpretations of such data and/or information or any
loss or damage arising from or related to their use.
Publications supplied tothe Members of the Institute ata

discount are not for resale b y them.
Publication
Number: SCI-P-166
ISBN 1 85942 047 8

British Library Cataloguing-in-Publication Data.

A catalogue record for this book is available from the British
Library.
..
II
Discuss me ...
This publication concentrates on the design of long

span composite beams with facility for service
integration. It is prefaced by a review of modern
building services and a brief statement as to the main
factors influencing the design of the building
structure and services throughout Europe. The
European context is introduced in order to reflect the
wide range of application of this information.
The publication was prepared by The Steel

Construction Institute, UK. Its authors were
Dr R M Lawson of SCI and M r P D McKenna,
consultant to SCI, with major contributions from the
following individuals and organisations:
Dr B Davidson Y R M AnthonyHunt Associates

(now at University of Sheffield)
M r J Berry and
M r P Sloman OveArup & Partners
M r P Trebilcock SCI ConsultantArchitect

M r R Smith and
M r J Blasby Davis Langdon & Everest
The illustrations of service layouts in Appendix B

were prepared by YRM Engineers.
Support was received for the dissemination phase of

this project from the European Commission (ECSC
Agreements 721 O/SA/833 and PHlN 0010). British
Steel Sections, Plates & Commercial Steels have
supported SCI in the research and development of
composite construction systems, and more recently
in the development of Slimdek.
The Department of the

DET R Environment, Transport
ENVIRONMENT
TRANSPORT
and the Regions sponsored
REQIONS development
the phase of
the project.
iii
Discuss me ...
CONTENTS
Page N o
...
SUMMARY Vlll
1 MODERN OFFICE BUILDINGS 1
1 . l European Context 3
1.2 Climatic Factors 4
1.3 Steel Framed Buildings 5
1.4 Services Integration 7
1.5 Scope of
Publication
the 9
2 INTRODUCTION TO
BUILDING
SERVICES 11
2.1 The Need

for Building Services 11
2.2 Types of Building Services 12
2.3
or Air Water Systems 12
3 FACTORS INFLUENCING
SERVICES REQUIREMENTS 15
3.1 Building Location 16
3.2 Building Use 16
3.3 Building Form and

Construction 16
4 TYPE OF AIR-CONDITIONING
SYSTEMS 19
4.1 Ventilation and Cooling 19
4.2 Types of Air-conditioning System 21
4.3 All-Air Systems 23
4.4 Air
Water
and Systems 27
4.5 All-Water Systems 27

4.6 Packaged Refrigeration Unit

Cooling Systems 30
4.7 Under-floor
Distribution 31
V
Discuss me ...
4.8 Laminar Flow System 34

INTERFACES
34 Ceilings
4.9 Chilled
4.1 0 Comparison of Systems 37
5 INTERNAL DISTRIBUTIONS
OF SERVICES 43
5.1 General
Recommendations 44
5.2 Vertical
Distribution of Services 44
46 Grids5.3 Ceiling
5.4 HorizontalDistribution of Services 47
6 STRUCTURAL OPTIONS FOR

SERVICES49INTEGRATION
6.1 Composite
Construction
49
6.2 Slim Floors

Slimdek
and
50
6.3 Medium
Systems
Span 52
6.4 Long Span Construction 53
6.5 Composite Beams with Web

Openings 55
6.6 Cellular and Castellated Beams 57
Haunched 6.7 Beams 60
6.8 Tapered Beams 61
6.9 Composite Trusses 62
6.10 Stub Girders 64
6.1 1 Parallel Systems

Beam 65
6.1 2 Summary of Service Zones

Provided by the Various
Structural Systems 67
6.1 3 Vertical Cores 67

vi
Discuss me ...
7 CASE STUDY: COMPARISON OF

STRUCTURAL OPTIONS 69
7.1 Typical SteelFramed Building 69
7.2Services Considerations 72
7.3 StructuralConsiderations 74
7.4 Structural Beam Details and

Building FramingPlans 77
8 CASE STUDY: SERVICE DISTRIBUTION 83
9 CASE STUDY: COST IMPLICATIONS

OF STRUCTURAL SYSTEM 85
9.1 General Aspects 85
9.2 Structure Cost 86

9.3 Cladding Costs 88
9.4Services Distribution 88
9.5 Foundation Costs 90
9.6 Speed of Construction 91
9.7 Overall Cost Estimates 92
10 CONCLUSIONS 95
11 REFERENCES 97
APPENDIX A: Suggested Best Practice Criteria

For Building Design 103
APPENDIX B: Service Distribution Drawings 107

vii
Discuss me ...
INTERFACES
SUMMARY
This publication summarises an investigation of the

design of structural systems in modern commercial
buildings which offer the facility for integration of
the structure and building services within the same
floor zone. Firstly, the publication reviews the
general requirements for building services,
particularly air-conditioning systems. Secondly,
structural systems, utilising the principles of
composite construction, are designed for spans of
15 m. Thirdly, the distribution of air-conditioning
ducts throughout these buildings is established with
respect to the structural systems considered in the
investigation. Finally, general estimates of
construction costs are made which take into account
the influence of the costs of service distribution and
other variable aspects of the construction.
The publication contains information on the

structural design of the long span systems and
includes examples of service drawings showing
the distribution of the majorservices with respect to

the structure and building frames considered.
It concludes that the additionalcosts in choosing
long span systems offering integration of structure
and services may only be 0.1 to 2% of the total
building cost in comparison to structures based on
traditional span of 6 to 7.5 m.
Integration des services dans les

ossatures en acier des immeubles
Resume
Cette publication resume une etude concemartla
conception de systemes structuraux dans des
bdtiments commerciaux modernes qui offrent l a
possibilite d'une integrationde la structure et des
services du bstiment sur le mGme itage sol. En
premier lieu, la publicationexamine les exigences
generales des services du bdtiment, particulierement
les systemes de conditionnement de /'air. En second
lieu, les systemes structuraux employant les
principes de construction mixte sontconGus pour
des portees de 15 m. En troisieme lieu, la
distribution des conduites de climatisation de I'air a
travers ces bdtiments est etablie entenant compte

des systemes structuraux consideres dans I'etude.
Enfin, des estimations generales des coiits de
construction sont r6alis6es en tenant compte des
...
v111
Discuss me ...
coljts de la distribution des services et d'autres

aspects variables de la construction.
f a publication comporte des informations sur la

conception structurale des systPmes A longue port6e
et comprend des exemples de plans des services
indiquant la distribution des plus importants services
concernant la structure et les bitis des constructions
consid6r6ses. f 'etude conclut que les coljts
supplementaires, lorsque I'on choisit les systemes de
longue port6e offrant /'integration de la structure et
des services, peuvent uniquement atteindre de 0. l A
2 % du coljt total du bitiment par rapport aux
structures bas6es sur des portees traditionnelles de 6
A 7,5 m.
integration der Installationen in

Stah Ibauten
Zusammenfassung
Das Buch faRt eine Untersuchung der Konstruktion
von Bausystemen in modernen Gewerbebauten
zusammen, die die Moglichkeit der lntegration von
Konstruktion und Gebaudeversorgungssystemen
innerhalb desselben Stockwerksbereichs bieten.
Zunachst untersucht der Bericht die allgemeinen
Anforderungen fur Gebaudeversorgungssysteme,
insbesondere Klimaanlagen. Dann werden
Konstruktionssysteme nach dem Verbundbauprinzip
auf Spannweiten von 7 5 m ausgelegt. Danach wird
die Fuhrung der Klimaanlagenleitungen durch die
Gebaude hinsichtlich der untersuchten Bausysteme
festgestellt. AbschlieBend fuhrt der Bericht
allgemeine Baukostenschatzungen a u t die den
€influR der Kosten fur die Verteilungssysteme und
weitere variable Aspekte des Baus berucksichtigen.
Das Buch enthalt lnformationen zu den

konstruktiven Gegebenheiten der Bausysteme fur
groBe Spannweiten und enthalt Beispiele von
Versorgungseinrichtungszeichnungen, die die
Verteilung der Hauptversorgungssysteme
hinsichtlich der aufgefuhrten Konstruktions- und
Gebauderahmen darstellen. Die Untersuchung
kommt zu dem SchluR, daR die zusatzlichen Kosten,
die bei der Wahl von Systemen fur groBe
Spannweiten, die die lntegration von Konstruktion

und Versorgungssystemen bieten, entstehen, bei nur
0.1 bis 2 % der Gesamtbaukosten im Vergleich zu
Standardkonstruktionen mit traditionellen
Spannweiten von 6 bis 7,5 m liegen.
ix
Discuss me ...
INTERFACES
Integracion de servicios en edificios
aporticados de acero
Resumen
Esta publicacidn resume un estudio sobre el
proyecto de sistemas estructurales en edificios
comerciales modernos que ofrecen la posibilidad de
integracidn de la estructura y /as instalaciones del
edificio dentro de la misma zona de 10s forjados.
En primer lugar se pasa revista a /os requisitos

generales que deben cumplir /as instalaciones en /os
edificios, en especial /os sistemas de aire
acondicionado. A continuacidn se proyectan, para
luces de 15 m, sistemas estructurales seglin 10s
principios de /as estructuras mixtas. En tercer lugar
se establece la distribucidn de conductos de aire
acondicionado ajustindose a 10s sistemas
estructurales considerados en el estudio.
Finalmente se hacen estimaciones globales de /os
costes de construccidn que tienen en cuentala
influencia de /os costes de la distribucidn de

instalaciones y otros aspectos variables de la
construccidn.
La publicacidn contiene datos sobre el proyecto de

sistemas estructurales de vanos grandes e incluye
como ejemplos dibujos de instalaciones mostrando
la distribucidn de /as m i s importantes en relacidn
con /os pdrticos de la estructura del edificio
considerado. E l resultado de la investigaci6n indica
que /os costes adicionales resultantes al escoger
sistemas de luces grandes con posibilidad de
integracidn de la estructura y /os servicios puede
ilegar a ser solo del 0.1 a / 2 % del coste total del
edificio en comparacidn a proyectos tipicos con /os
tradicionales vanos de 6 a 7.5 m.
X
Discuss me ...
lntegrazione degli impianti in edifici a

struttura intelaiata
Sommario
Questa pubblicazione presenta in sintesi uno studio
condotto sulla progettazione strutturale di moderni
edifici ad us0 commerciale per i quali si vogliano
integrare, all'interno del solaio di piano, i sistemi
impiantistici dell 'edificio. Nella pubblicazionesono
dapprima analizzatri i requisiti generali relativi ai
servizi dell'edificio, con particolare riferimentoai
sistemi per /'aria condizionata. In secondo luogo, e'
affrontato il tema della progettazione strutturaleper
interassi fino a 15 metri, sulla base delle regole di
dimensionamento delle struttura composte. I / terzo
punto affronta invece il problema della distribuzione
dei condotti dell'aria condizionata all'interno
dell'edificio, con riferimentoa diverse tipologie
strutturali. Infine viene presenta una valutazione
globale dei costi di costruzione tenendo in conto
l'incidenza economica degli impianti e dei loro

sistemi distributivi oltre che di aspetti di altra natura
legati alla fase costruttiva.
Questa pubblicazione riporta dettagli sulla

progettazione strutturale di sistemi con travi di
grande luce e presenta esempi di disegni
impiantistici mostrando la distribuzione dei
principali servizi per strutture e edificia ossatura
portante intelaiati. A conclusione di questo studio
viene infine sottolineatoohe i costi aggiuntivi legati
alla scelta di sistemi portanti con trave di grande
luce per i quali sia possibile una concreta
integrazione tra struttura e impianti possono essere
sensibilmente limitati, variando tra 0.1 % e il 2% del
costo totale dell'edificio, se paragonati con quelli
associati invece a una progrettazione tradizionale
riferita agli usuali interassi di 6 o 7.5 metri.
lntegrering av installationer i
byggnader med stilstomme
Sammanfattning
Denna publikation sammanfattar en studie av
utformningen av de stomsystem till moderna
kommersiella byggnader som mojliggor en

integrering av installationerna i byggnadens
bj8'lkagskonstruktion. forst ger publikationen en
oversikt over generella krav p i byggnadens
installationer, speciellt ventilationssystemet.
xi
Discuss me ...
Darefter ges en oversikt over stomsystem, baserade

INTERFACES p i samverkansteknik, och som ar dimensionerade
for spannvidder p i upp till 15 m. Kanaldragning av
ventilationskanaler anpassade till de stomsystem
som redovisats i studien. Slutligen ges en
uppskattning av bygglostnaden med hansyn till
inverkan av installationsdragningarna.
Publikationen innehiller information om

dimensionering av stomsystem med stora
spannvidder samt olika exempel p i hur
installationernas dragning kan utfcjras si att man
anpassar dessa till den barande stommens
fcjrutsdttningar. Studien fastslir att tilldggskostnaden
f6.r att vdlja stomsystem med stora spdnnvidder och
ell integreral installationssystem bara uppgir till 0.1
till 2% av den totala byggkostnaden i jdmfcjrelse
med tradionella stommsystem med spdnnvidder p i 6
till 7.5 m.
xi i
Discuss me ...
1 MODERN OFFICE
BUILDINGS
Office space is an increasingly international

commodity, and the days of separate national
cultures in workplace design and lifestyle may well
be nearing an end. ‘Global’ companies seek office
space in all key countries and compare national
standards and products. Developers move from
country to country, following demand. Investors buy
property in any market that offers good growth
prospects. Office staff are increasingly mobile and
aware of opportunities afforded in other countries.
Interchange is increasing.
The UK office market is dominated by commercial

developers, for whom investment value is

paramount, and a smaller owner-occupier market.
North America is looked to as the most efficient r61e
model for commercial development, and whilst
1
Discuss me ...
British cultural and economic norms are still very

INTERFACES different, convergence is occurring.
In Continental Europe, however, office development

is currently dominated by ‘owner-occupation’.
Companies build for themselves, or buy ’developer
buildings’. Some cities have strong developer
markets but the style is set by corporate buildings.
This produces a radically different set of priorities in
office design from the UWUS model. Buildings,
especially corporate headquarters, tend to be more
idiosyncratic, often free-standing, high quality and
staff-oriented, compared to the standardised,
relatively modest specification and investor-oriented
space in the UK and US. In all countries, concern
for health and comfort in offices is encouraging a
move away from sealed, buildings towards more
environmental friendly developments.
These commercial trends and attitudes exert a strong

influence on all aspects of the building, such as
choice of space planning modules, structural grid,
services installations, as well as exterior and interior

finishes. Despite the apparent ‘international’
consistency in buildingdesign, some countries have
developed their own particular structural and
environmental systems, reflecting the local climate,
culture, national resources, as well as technological
skills.
Steel framed buildings have become increasingly

popular in Europe because they bring together the
facility for speed of construction, column-free space,
flexibility in planning, and adaptability to suit future
needs. The market for steel frames in the
commercial building sector is over 50% in the UK
and Scandanvia, although it is less than 20% in
France and Germany. This aspect suggests that the
perceived advantages of steel in some countries have
not extended throughout Europe.
The economic constraints on building construction

have led togreater awareness of the cost of services
and the potential for reducing costs without
adversely affecting the use of the building. Recently,
the British Council for Office$’) addressed the
important issues in the design and specific form of
modern commercial buildings, and a precis of their
requirements is presented in Appendix A.
2
Discuss me ...
1 .l European Context
The structure of the construction industrywithin

each of the European countries dictates how
buildings are procured. The client has a major
influence on the building quality, butsocial attitudes
and regulations also influence the buildingdesign.
Therefore, the building stock within each country
varies considerably. The following table defines, in
general terms, the main factors influencing the
commercial building market in the major countries
of the European Union.
Table 1 Summary of the European market for building
Country Clients Resulting

Concerns
Social Quality
UK Property development Regulations permit Construction

companies with funds flexibility and standards suitable
from banks, pension innovation. for rented
funds, and insurance Increased move to occupation. Quality

companies. low energy solutions. could be improved.
Scandinavia Developers, Banks, High level of High quality

insurance companies, awareness of thermal solutions with
contractor Syndicates. performance and innovative
hygiene, supported manufacturer-led
by strict National solutions.
regulations.
Germany and Banks and insurance High awareness of High cost, but low
Netherlands companies for owner- green issues and energy buildings of
occupiers. hygiene, supported good quality.
by National
Regulations.
~~
France and Property developers, Well regulated with Simple tried and
Belgium owner-occupiers, bias to French tested solutions that
banks and insurance products. are economic and
companies. functional.
Spain and ItalyFunding by banks and Complex regulations Initial costs are low.
insurance companies. and relatively poor Specifications have
Buildings often for building standards, little consideration
sale, not rent. improving in line for cost in use.
with European
Standards.
The general factors that influence the choice of

structure, major services, and building form are as
follows:
National building regulations, and the building
approval process.
3
Discuss me ...
Form of construction contract, for example, the

INTERFACES influence of ‘design and build’, or traditional
’client-consultant-contractor’ relationships.
Scope for innovation within the design and
construction process. This may also be
influenced by thefees to architect and other
designers.
Activity within the building, including space
requirements, occupancy patterns, and circulation
areas.
Climatic factors (see below).
Economic arguments, as influenced by material
and construction costs, and speed of construction.
Other factors such as architectural style, and local

planning requirements, have an important effect on
the form and appearance of the building.
1.2 Climatic Factors

Any discussion of building services in modern

buildings in Europe should take into account the
external environmental conditions, which can
change dramatically from winter to summer. Five
distinctive climatic regions may be identified in
Europe, namely:
North west maritime countries; UK, Ireland, and
Benelux and Northern France.
Western maritime regions; Western France and
Northern Spain.
Northern European countries; Scandinavia.
Central European or continental countries;
Germany, Eastern France, Austria, Switzerland.
Southern European countries; Spain, Portugal,
Italy and Greece.
The general climatic zones are shown

diagrammatically in Figure 1 . The temperatures
shown relate to ‘design’ maximum and minimum
temperatures which may be experienced over a
number of days.
Table 2 presents the environmental factors, and the

relevant features of the building design that differ
among these regions. This information should be

taken into account when assessing the application of
the design guidance contained in this publication.
4
Discuss me ...
Key Summer Winter

Figure 1 European climatic variations
1.3 Steel Framed Buildings

Steel frames are increasingly used in commercial
buildings, and most steel frames are designed to
achieve composite actionwith the concrete floor
slab. The advantages of 'composite construction' are
now well understood in terms of structural economy,
good performance in service, and ease of
construction. Design of composite structures i s
covered by ENV 1994: Eurocode 4(*)and by national
codes.
Coupled with this increase in the use of steel frames

has been a demand for higher quality in the building
fabric and services. It is recognised that the cost of
the frame may only be 10 to 15% of the overall
building cost, and therefore decisions on the choice
of the structural form are more influenced by the
usability and adaptability of thebuilding tochanging
requirements.
5
Discuss me ...
Table 2 Summary o f climatic conditions and building features

INTERFACES
Climatic
Country Features of building design
SummerNinter Air-conditioning Structure
UK + 2 7 "4C° C
/- quality
high
Most 3.5 to 4.5 m
high humidity and buildings have floor-floor.High
potentially high VAV/Fan Coil a/c. market share for
winds. Mild Trend to passive steel. Long span
winters. cooling. systems used in
prestige buildings.
Scandinavia +28"C/-
15°C Sealed, well 3.3 to 3.6 m
cold winters insulated buildings floor-floor.High
and short hot of high quality. Air market share for
summers. change 8-1 0 steel using shallow
I/s/person. VAV
floor
construction.
and over-floor
systems commonly
used.
~ ~~
Germany "C/-
+31 1 1 "C Often sealed 3.5
floor-floor
m
cold
winters and buildings. VAV/Fan typical.
Low
hot summers, coil and chilled market share for
ceilings
typical
of steel.
used. Concrete is
continental
climate. Trend to passive dominant. Short
cooling. spans common.
France +33"C
5 °/ C
- Infrequent use of 3 to 3.2floor-
m
warm generally, a/c in all except floor. Low market
high humidity in high quality share for steel. Pre-
west. buildings. Fan coil cast concrete
systems
are widely used.
preferred.
Bene1ux + 2 7 "4C°/C- Often air- 3.3 to 3.8

floor-
m
can be affected byconditioned.Trendfloor.Low market
continentalclimate.to passive cooling. share for steel.
._
Italy
and Spain + 3 5 " C / + 1 "C Air-conditioning 3 to 3.2 m
floor-
longhot summers. often essential. Fan floor.Low market
coil systems share for steel,
preferred. although increasing.
a/c =air-conditioning. VAV -

Variable Air Volume. Vs -
litres/second.
These climatic observations apply to the typical conditions ineach country.
6
Discuss me ...
Table 3 gives the proportion of buildingcost

attributed to thevarious key elements of the
construction, and their expected life to major
renovation or replacement.
Table 3 Element Proportion of Expected life

Typical costsofand life cost (0%) (years)
elements of building Structure
150
0 - 15 - 100
construction
Foundations 3-10 100 +
Facade & roof 20 - 40 20 - 40
Internal finishes 12 - 25 5 - 15
Services 20 - 35 10 - 15
Preliminaries 7 - 15
(site costs)
An important factor, from the point of view of the

structural design, has been the demand from many
clients, letting agents and users, for longer
column-free spans and greater usable space. This
can be readily achieved with steel frames, but as
spans increase, so does the depth of the floor

structure necessary to achieve economic design. As
the ceiling to floor depthincreases, so the building
heights and cladding costs increase. The challenge
for structural engineers is therefore to develop long
span systems that achieve a ceiling to floordepth
consistent with traditional construction in steel or
concrete.
1.4 Services Integration

In traditional construction, the services are located in
a horizontal layer or zone that is below the floor
structure. Therefore there are two separate zones
between the ceiling and the floor; a ‘structure’ zone
and ‘services’ zone. This is called complete
‘separation’ of services and structure.
Systems achieving complete separation of services

are usually characterized by relatively short spans
and shallow construction depths. For example, the
‘slim floor’ or ‘integrated beam’ systems have been
specifically developed to create a flat floor, and to
provide flexibility in horizontal service distribution.
When the floor slab is supported by beams of

moderate depth, some services can be positioned in

the depth between the beams, but ducts and pipes
still have to pass beneath the beams. This
arrangement i s called ‘partial integration’ of services.
7
Discuss me ...
If the beams are deep enough, it i s possible to pass

INTERFACES the services through the beams at pre-determined
locations so that the structure and services occupy
the same horizontal zone. This is called 'full
integration' of services. These forms of structure-
service integration are illustrated in Figure 2.
I -L T floor
I Raised
- Floor slab
Secondary beam Primary beam zone

Structure
-
l
- - - - - - - - -_-_ ~
1 Service zone
1. Separation of structure and service zones

(Medium span composite beams)
\ L -
, , - _$.
\ Opening in web of primary beam
2. Partial integration of structure and service zones
(Long span composite beams)
T J I I
. , . :, ;,
, , I . , ;:
T
beam/
'
0 \
Primary beam
\
\
1 Structure and
service
zone
- 1 L -
3. Complete integration of structure and service zones

(Parallel beam system)
Figure 2 Various forms o f structure-services integration
Long span beams with facility for service integration

can be designed to achieve a ceiling - floor depth
close to that of traditional construction. Often,
careful layout of the structural elements can lead to
flexibility in service distribution, as illustrated in
Figure 3 where a 'corridor' zonefor major ducts
provides 'partial' integration of services in a
conventional composite beam and slab arrangement.
8
Discuss me ...
Much information on structuralsystems that achieve

effective integration of services is available from
North America(3) and theUK(4),where long span
composite buildings have been in vogue for 10 to 15
years. There are now many examples of where these
systems have been used in practice: guidance on
their design features is covered in Section 6 and in
other publications in thereference list.
Figure 3 Example of partial services integration
1.5 Scope of thePublication

The publication addresses the potential use of longer
span beams offering facility for integration of
services, and reviews the buildingservices that may
be used in modern commercial buildings throughout
Europe. The benefits of different structural systems
are assessed for one building form whichis typical of
a modern commercial building. The conclusions
from this assessment may be readily extended to
other building forms and spans.
The structural systems are based on a 15 m span

between facades. This span was considered to be
the most representative for therange of longspan
structural systems currently in use. Comparisons are
made with shorter span systems which use a central
line of columns.
9
Discuss me ...
This publication will assist clients and designers in

INTERFACES making decisionsat the concept or scheme stage of a
building project. It addresses the spatial and
performance requirements of modernbuilding
services in air conditioned offices, and compares
these spatial requirements to the service zones
provided by thestructural systems that have been
developed for long span applications.
10
Discuss me ...
2 INTRODUCTION
TO BUILDING
SERVICES
2.1 The Need for BuildingServices

Building services provide and maintain an artificial
internal climate within the building when subject to
a range of external climates. The building envelope
is the barrier between the two climates. When
carefully designed to interact with the service
systems, the building envelope is not only the
weatherproof barrier, but can also assist in creating
the appropriate internal environment economically.
Building services have evolved and become more

complex as the expectations of the quality of the
environment within buildings has increased.
Discuss me ...
The use of the building dictates the internal

INTERFACES requirements, the degree of control to beexercised
over the conditions, and the operational duration
over which they must be maintained (8, 10 or 24
hours a day). The operation of the building will
dictate specific requirements for such factors as:
temperature control
room acoustics
roodtask lighting levels and quality
air quality and space cleanliness
humiditycontrol
smoke or other gas exhaust
odourcontrol.
2.2 Types of Building Services

Building services are generally divided into three
categories:
Mechanical Services
Electrical Services
Fire SafetyServices
Mechanical services include the heating, ventilating

and cooling systems. They generally occupy the
largest volume, and emphasis is given here to fully
explain the various mechanical systems that are most
commonly installed in modern commercial
buildings. Low capital cost, low running cost or
accurate temperature and humidity control influence
the type of system that is selected. The advantages
and disadvantages of the more commonlyused
systems are discussed. General guidance on
building services is given in References (5) and (6).
2.3 Air or Water Systems

The different types of heating, ventilating and
cooling system will be discussed i n Section 4.
Air or water is used in buildings as the medium by

which energy is distributed. However, to transport
energy by air takes up much morespace than by
water. This is because:
12
Discuss me ...
Specific heat capacity of air = 1.02 kJ/kg"C

Specific heat capacity of water = 4.1 8 kJ/kg"C
These figures mean that water can carry

approximately four times moreenergy per kg than
air, and 4000 times more in terms of unit volume.
Although air systems take up more space than water

systems, they are invariably used in modern office
buildings, particularly those with 'sealed' windows.
This is because most buildings require fresh air to be
circulated to occupants in sufficient volume to
achieve air quality, and therefore heating and
cooling are most easily provided by enhancements
to the air circulationsystem.
13
This material is copyright - all rights reserved. Use of this document is subject to the terms and conditions of the Steelbiz Licence Agreement Discuss me ...
INTERFACES
14
Discuss me ...
3 FACTORS
INFLUENCING
SERVICES
REQUIREMENTS
The air-conditioning or mechanical ventilation

system selected to serve the needs of the building
occupies considerable space, and is a considerable
proportion of the total building cost. Hence, these
requirements should be considered at the initial
stages of the conceptual design of a building,
including whetheror not an air-conditioning system
is needed.
The factors influencing the sizing andselection of

the air-conditioning system are given'below.
15
Discuss me ...
INTERFACES 3.1 Building Location

(a) Climate - Variations in solar radiation, air
temperature and humidity allaffect the energy
requirements of a building [refer to Table 21.
(b) Exposure - The height of the building and the

direction and strength of prevailing winds will
also affect the energy usage in a building.
(c) Pollution - This is usually only a consideration in

an urban environment, and can be in the form of
noise and traffic fumes. The building may need
to be ‘sealed’ thus requiring use of mechanical
ventilation systems.
(d) Shape of Site - The shape of the site may dictate

the size and shape of the building, which affects
both system selection and energy usage.
(e) Surrounding Buildings - Other buildings may

create problems by reducing daylight
penetration and solar gains, and possibly

unacceptable wind patterns around the building
which affect the ventilation conditions.
(f) Planning Considerations - National and local

regulations, and the restrictions imposed for fire
protection purposes may combine to influence
the building services used.
3.2 Building Use

The use of the building, or even parts of the building,
dictates the desired internal temperatures, the
required degree of control and the operational
duration over which the temperatures must be
maintained (see Section 2.1).
Capital and running costs should also be taken into

consideration in the selection of the building
services.
3.3 Building Form andConstruction

(a) Shape - Ideally, the ratio of the envelope surface
area to usable floor area should be minimized.
Interpreting this general principle literally leads
to the conclusion that large buildings, having a

smaller ratio of surface area to floor area, are
more economical in heating/cooling
requirements than are small buildings.
16
Discuss me ...
However, relatively narrow buildings may in fact

use less energy than deep plan structures
because they may not need air-conditioning and
so much artificial lighting. Benefits from
windows that provide natural light and
ventilation can extend up to 6 m inwards from
the windows.
(b) Mass - All major elements of a building; floors,

external walls and roof contribute to determine
the building mass.
The effect the building ’thermal capacity’ has on

the selection of the air-conditioningsystem may
be important in terms of acceptable internal
conditions and running costs. In buildings of
high thermal inertia, external climatic changes
are slow to affect the internal environment, as
these buildings heat up and cool down slowly.
In a lightweight building, with large amounts of

glass and/or lightweight highly insulated
cladding panels in the external envelope, speed

of response is therefore important in the design
of the services system if a constant internal
temperature is to be maintained. Studies have
shown that the concrete floors in a composite
structure are able to regulate daily internal
temperatures even in a lightweight structure.
This is a subject of a recent SCI publicatiorf”.
(c) Orientation - Beneficial heating through south

facing windows can occur. In air-conditioned
buildings, the major axis of the building should
ideally be in the EasWest direction for optimum
performance, as it gives a lower cooling load,
which becomes more significant as the amount
of glass in the building envelope increases (see
Figure 4).
(d) Insulation Levels - The walls and roof of a

building should have an appropriate level of
thermal insulation to reduce heat loss. The heat
loss through the roof can be a major factor for
low rise buildings of large plan.
(e) Glazing - The amount of glazing provided in the

external envelope is the most influential factor
on the sizing of the heating and cooling systems.
A simple rule often used i s that 20-30% glazing
of the outside facade provides the benefit of
natural lighting and ventilation to a depth of

about 6 m from the windows. If a greater
amount of glazing is used, more solar protection
17
Discuss me ...
INTERFACES
A
Glass area 7 5 % of
Increasing external wall
building
cooling load
i\
I I
I Glassarea 25% of
external wall
I
I I l buildingI I Major
axis alignment
N-S Alignment W-E Alignment N-S Alignment

The cooling load is increased with greater area of glass
Figure 4 Cooling load variationwith building orientation
may be necessary to prevent excessive heat

gains and to reduce coo1in.g loads.
The choice between openable orsealed

windows is dependent upon a number offactors;
building use, external noise levels, external
pollution levels, site wind speeds, building
height and the building's thermal inertia. To
many occupants, the opportunity to open a
window also gives great psychological benefit.
(f) Lighting - The level of lighting provided in the

space is totally dependent upon thetask being
performed. Recommended task lighting levels
are given in National Codes and are dependent
on building shape, location and the percentage
of glazing in the external facade. Deep plan
buildings have a greater requirement for artificial
lighting and for ventilationsystems to remove
the heat generated by the lights.
18
Discuss me ...
4 TYPES OF AIR-
CONDITIONING
SYSTEMS
The term ‘air-conditioning’ defines the control of

internal space temperature, via heating and cooling,
and humidity to pre-determined levels. These
settings are maintained within limits all year round.
Air-conditioning systems which control only the air
temperature are more correctly termed ’comfort
cooling’ systems.
4.1 VentilationandCooling
Ventilation
In a situation where natural ventilation through
opening windows in theexternal walls is not
possible, or where the internal environment
19
Discuss me ...
necessitates a particular degree of control, fresh air

INTERFACES w i l l have to be continually provided to thespace via
mechanical ventilation. Fresh air supply is normally
expressed in terms of the ‘air change rate’, or air
changes per hour. Typical recommended air change
rates range from 6 per hour in offices, to 10 - 15 in
restaurants and other special applications.
Alternatively, the air supply may beexpressed in

terms of the air required by each occupant. For high
quality applications, an air supply rate of 8-10
litres/sec/person is required to maintain a fresh
atmosphere.
The various components of an air-conditioning or

comfort cooling system are shown diagrammatically
in Figure 5.
In all cases, cooling is provided by refrigeration, and

the low grade heat extracted from the building is
ejected to the atmosphere. The refrigeration system
is required to do more work insummer, both to cool
the internal space, and also to ensure that the ejected

air is at a higher temperature than the ambient air.
When included the system may then be

said to be an air conditioning system
Frost l
Intake
louvre
protecting
heating coil
-----
Filter Cooling
coil *
Humidifier
F-------
Heating
coil
Supply
fan
I--- /-‘ .l
I I ; \
10 > II O 0
L-I
I
- -
\
- ~ - ‘ LZ‘I-
) ,
T- -____ J
Q;’
Combination of these units make air handling units
TJ-
l
+
R
Exhaust
air
/ I 1
CondGoned
supply air
Occupied space
Exhaust Exhaust
louvre fan
Figure 5 Components of an air-conditioning or comfort cooling system
Mechanical ventilation, with heating

The air change rate has to be enhanced

mechanically in areas which cannot be naturally
ventilated by opening windows in theexternal wall.
20
Discuss me ...
When both the cooling coil and humidifier are

removed from the air-conditioning system in
Figure 5, the remaining system is known simply as a
‘mechanical ventilation’ system.
The air is heated in winter, but in summer, air is

supplied at the prevailing external temperature,
which is often in excess of the desired internal space
temperature. The internal temperatures in the
summer are therefore dependent upon the outside
temperature, which may be unacceptable to the
occupants, or to the processes inside the building.
Comfort criteria
The cooling effect on the occupants within a
building is influenced by three factors: the ambient
air temperature, the surface temperature (radiation),
and air movement (convection). These three effects
influence the design of the ventilationand cooling
system.
Detailed research of occupant comfort in buildings

has led to theestablishment of an empirical comfort

factor called the ‘resultant temperature’, which is
defined as follows:
Resultant temperature = ’/2 x Air temperature

+ ?h x Room surface
temperature.
Air speed is usually low in modern commercial

buildings and its effect on the resultant temperature
can be neglected. The total cooling effect is
therefore a combination of supplying coolair, and/or
cooling of the surfaces of the space thereby affecting
radiant cooling. Consideration of this aspect has led
to the development of chilled ceilings (see
Section 4.9).
4.2 Types of Air-conditioning System

There are three main components to an air-
conditioning system; the central heating/cooIing
machinery, the distribution/control system and the
terminal outlet devices. The central machinery
varies little in functionand size, or in plant room
location from country to country. Fuel sources and
machine design may vary but this has little overall
effect on the building form and structural solution for

a typical commercial development.
21
Discuss me ...
However, the distribution system comprising

INTERFACES terminal heating, cooling, ventilating and air-
conditioning equipment can vary significantly in
shape, size and function. It is this part of the system
that is located within or adjacent to the occupied
zone of the building, and as such can influence the
shape or depth of the structure andthat of the
services zone.
The terminal equipment provides the link between

the central items of machinery and the occupants of
the building. Its function is to create the desired
thermal environment by utilising the heating, cooling
and air handling capabilities of the main plant.
The generic types of air-conditioning or ‘comfort

cooling’ systems are:
All air systems: Constant Volume, or Variable

Air Volume (VAV)
Air-water systems: Induction units, Fan Coil Units

(FCU) and chilled ceilings with
a primary air supply.
All water systems: Unitary Fan Coil Units and

reversible heat pumps, Fan Coil
Units without primary air
supply.
Refrigerant Split
and packaged refrigerant
systems:
systems, with
without
or
primary systems air supply.
The most commonly used ‘comfort cooling systems’

for office building applications are the Variable Air
Volume system (VAV) and the Fan Coil system.
Often, VAV systems are used in buildings withsingle

owner occupiers, because of their lower running
costs. Fan Coil systems are more often used in
speculative buildings because of the lower capital
costs and greater degree of local control to the space
being serviced.
There are also significant differences in the use of

these systems throughout Europe, because of the
climatic conditions that prevail (see Table 2).
22
Discuss me ...
4.3 All-Air Systems

4.3.1 General features of all-air systems
An All-Air system provides temperature and
humidity control of the air supplied by the system.
No additional cooling is required in the occupied
space. The system supplies and extracts a constant
volume of airand provides ventilation of the
building spaces served. The air may be 100°/ofresh
or, in order to save energy, may consist of a mixture
of fresh and re-circulated air. Heating of thespace
may be provided by thesame airstream or enhanced
by local heating panels at the building perimeter.
Air is heated or cooled centrally, and where it is

reheated in sub-distribution ducts it is termed a
Constant Volume-Multi-zone system. These systems
offer improved local control over single zone
systems, but may increase energy use.
The cooling coil in All-Airsystems makes use of

chilled water provided by the refrigerationplant, and

’comfort cooling’ is provided. With the addition of a
humidifier, ‘air-conditioning’ is also provided (see
Figure 5).
‘Comfort cooling’ normally suffices in temperate

climates because people can tolerate typically
20-60% relative humidity withoutsevere discomfort.
The acceptable degree of humidity may also depend
on sensitive equipment or other uses within the
controlled space, and this may be a more important
consideration than the needs of the occupants.
The circulation of air around the building for heating

and cooling also has other benefits. It provides the
mechanism by which fresh air for ventilation and
control of odours can be introduced into every space
served by the system. Also, in case of fire, the
ductwork system can be used to provide smoke
clearance, most importantly in multi-storey buildings
which have phased evacuation from the building. In
an emergency, an All-Air ductwork system having an
automatic fire emergency mode of operation can be
used to maintain smoke-free escape routes.
The design of the ductwork system for the

distribution of air throughout the building is based
on either low or high velocity air movement. Low
velocities are suitable for simple systems, but would

result in loss of useable space because of the use of
large ducts in complex or large buildings. Most large
cooling and ventilation systems therefore utilise high
velocity air movement.
23
Discuss me ...
Although high velocity systems reduce duct sizes

INTERFACES and save space, they usually have high system
resistances, increasing the fan motor size and the
running costs. High velocity air movements are also
noisy and therefore, in most buildings, the velocity
of the air introduced into the occupied space has to
be reduced and the noise generated has to be
attenuated (dampened).
All-Air systems of all types have the following

features and advantages:
The central location of major equipmentmeans
that operational maintenance is confined to
plant room areas.
Heat recovery systems may be readily
incorporated.
Free cooling using outside air alone can be
maximised. This reduces the use of the
mechanical refrigeration equipment, hence
saving on runningcosts.
They allow good design flexibility for optimum

air distribution, draught control and local
requirements.
They are well suited to applications requiring
unusual exhaust air rates.
Drain pipes and filters are not needed in
occupied space.
Air can be delivered through floor, ceiling and
displacement diffusers.
The disadvantages of All-Air systems are:

Large ducts for air distribution take up space.
This can potentially increase the floor to ceiling
depth, and thus increase the building height.
In locations with low outside temperatures, and
where the air system (not radiation) is used to
heat perimeter areas, fans must operate longer
during unoccupied periods to maintain the
desired temperatures.
Air balancing of the completed system can be
difficult especially in cases without built-in self
balancing devices.
Access to air terminals demands particular
attention to ensure that the system can be fully
maintained after completion ofother room

finishes and features.
24
Discuss me ...
4.3.2 VAV systems

One type of All-Airsystem keeps the supply air
temperatures constant andvaries the volume of air
supplied. This is known as a Variable Air Volume
(VAV) system.
All-Air VAV systems can be further divided into two

classes; single duct systems and dual duct systems.
A single duct system has a common duct for
distribution of air, usually at a preset temperature,
and this feeds all terminal devices. A dual duct
system has separate hot and cold air distribution
ductwork and each terminal unit blends the air to
achieve the required supply temperature.
All-Air VAV systems are generally used in buildings

that require individual control andhave multiple
zones, such as cellular offices. These systems are
also used in special applications for close control of
temperature and humidity, including ‘clean rooms’
and computer rooms.
The Variable Air Volume (VAV)system has the same

advantages as those for other All-Air systems, but has
the following additionaladvantages:
Higher air velocities can be used in the main
distribution ductwork, consequently reducing
duct sizes and saving space and costs.
The high velocity distribution of air to terminal
devices which house their own volume
regulators make the system virtually self
balancing, reducing on site commissioning time.
The size of a typical VAV terminal box is
900 mm long by400 mm square or diameter
(Figure 6). The VAV boxes can be located
between beams so that they occupy less
apparent space.
Full advantage can be taken of the changing heat
loads in the building. The air quantities may be
reduced from the designed peak load to match
the actual load and can operate between65%
and 100% of the maximum load.
Varying the total air volume that is delivered,
according to the requireduse, reduces running
costs.
Local control of the supplied air is available to
suit individual needs.

VAV systemsare relatively quiet, particularly
when operating at reduced volumes.
Separate perimeterheating can beprovided.
25
Discuss me ...
Some VAV systems are fan assisted in order to

INTERFACES reduce the volume of primary air by mixing it
with the room air for low coolingloads.
VAV systems have the following disadvantages:

Equipmentselection is more critical (to avoid
discomfort and poor controlat low cooling
loads).
Somesystems require additional power wiring to
the terminal devices (e.g. fan-assisted VAV).
Thedisperse equipment increases running costs.
Perimeterzonesoften require separate heating
provisions by radiators or heaters on the VAV
box to offset fabric heat loss.
Figure 6 Typical Variable Air Volume (VAV) terminal unit
4.3.3 Diffusers
In All-Air systems, the conditioned air is passed into
the room space via diffusers. These diffusers are
incorporated into the ceiling and may be in the form
of circular, square or linear units.
Diffusers are usually positioned oneevery

6 m x 6 m area internally, and at greater frequency
at the edges of the building whereheat gains are
likely to be greater. Additional heating may also be
provided by radiators around the perimeter of the

building, or by additional heating facilities within the
VAV system, such as re-heat coil or fan-assisted VAV
boxes.
26
Discuss me ...
4.4 Air and Water Systems

In this type of system, air and waterare cooled or
heated in central plant rooms. Air is supplied to a
unit, which mixes the supply air with the room air,
before being further heated or cooled, if required, by
the water coil served from the central plant room.
These units, which are generally located around the

perimeter of a building, are called Air-Water
Induction Units. They provide temperature control
in perimeter areas with high solar heat gains, but
close control of relative humidityis not possible with
this system. A separate system may therefore be
required for other building areas and rooms
requiring a greater degree of control. Because of
these additional requirements, and hence costs, this
type of system is not commonly installed in modern
buildings in the UK.
4.5 All-Water Systems

All-Water systems heat and/or cool a space by direct

heat transfer between the water and thecirculating
air in the rooms. This room air must be moved by
force, i.e. a fan, in order for it to be distributed into
the room space. The terminal units which are
designed for this are called Fan Coil Units (FCU).
The size of a typical Fan Coil Unit is 1000 mm wide
by 300 mm deep (see Figure 7).
The basic elements of a Fan Coil Unit are: finned

tube coils, one for heating and one for cooling; a
filter; a fan; and a condensate tray and drain for the
cooling coil. The fan recirculates air from the room
across the coils, where the air is heated or cooled, as
necessary, before being discharged back into the
space.
A cleanable or replaceable filter is incorporated

ahead of the fan to stop dirt inthe recirculated air
clogging up the coils. This also protects the fan and
its motor, and reduces the level of dust within the
space served by the Fan Coil system.
27
Discuss me ...
INTERFACES
Figure 7 Typical Fan Coil Unit
Fan Coil Units are available in a variety of

configurations to fit horizontally above suspended

ceilings, or under floors, or vertically in separate
recesses behind walls, or under window sills.
Horizontal overhead units may be fitted with
discharge ductwork to allow the supply of a number
of outlets. However, the addition of ductwork
increases the fan static pressure and the motor size of
the unit.
Fan Coil systems are commonly used in buildings

requiring individual temperature control, because
the space served by the Fan Coil is effectively one
zone, which can be controlled by the temperature
setting on the Fan Coil Unit.
A further variant of theFan Coil System provides

variable air volume supply which has improved local
control.
The advantages of All-Water air-conditioning and

comfort cooling systems are:
Water distribution systems (piping)require less
space. Hence, smaller central air handling plant
rooms and duct space are required than for
All-Air systems.
Terminal units can easilybelocated in ceiling
voids or small compartments.
Individualroomtemperaturecontrol is provided
economically without any cross-contamination
of re-circulated air from onespace to another.
20
Discuss me ...
Fan Coil Units can be slightly oversized to allow

for rapid control of temperatures.
The system can utilise low temperature water for
heating and hence is compatible with the heat
recovery side of refrigeration equipment.
Routes for pipework and wiring can be more
easily located through existing buildings than the
large openings for ducts needed for All-Air
systems. This makes the Fan Coil system ideal
for refurbishment projects.
Fan Coil systems are slightly cheaper to install
than All-Air systems.
The disadvantages of All-Water systems are:

Maintenance requirements for All-Water systems
are greater than for All-Air systems and this work
must be carried out in the occupiedspaces.
(Although this can be organised on an ‘out of
hours’ basis).
Fan Coil Units operating with low chilledwater

temperatures require condensate trays and
drains which must be cleaned and flushed
periodically. Obtaining a suitable fall on pipe
drains in ceiling voidscan be difficult.
Fan Coil Unit filters are small and low in
efficiency, and require frequent changing to
maintain unit performance and air quality.
Effective and constant ventilation rates are not
always achieved throughout the space.
Ventilation can be provided by opening
windows or external wall apertures, but both are
affected by wind and vertical air movement.
Alternatively, a constant volume of air
movement via a mechanical ventilation system
may be used.
Fan Coil Units may be noisy in operation.
Fan Coil Units require increased electrical
distribution.
A variant of the Fan Coil system is the use of a

reverse-cycle heat pump in place of the Fan Coil.
The heat pump supplies or extracts heat from the
single pipe water distribution system. A common
application is use of heat pumps at the perimeter of
the building.
29
Discuss me ...
INTERFACES
4.6 PackagedRefrigeration UnitCooling
Systems
Packaged refrigeration units, as the name suggests,
are air cooling units containing an integral
refrigeration cycle. The components are
factory-assembled into an integrated package which
include fans, filters, heating coil, cooling coil,
refrigerant compressor, and refrigerant and air
controls. These factory assembled units can be
manufactured in a variety of configurations to
broaden the range of applications available. Typical
types are: through-the-wall packaged units, window
packaged units, and split systems (a room located
conditioner inter-connected via refrigeration
pipework to a remote external refrigeration unit). In
a purely coolingmode, they reject heat to the
outside air.
Packaged refrigeration units can be used in any

building space where cooling is required for a low
initial capital cost. They are less widely used in

offices, but are more common in hotels and similar
buildings. They can be installed as single stand-
alone units or a number of units can be combined to
form a complete air-conditioning system for a
building. Roof-mounted units, which provide
cooling toa large zone are often of substantial size
and incorporate distribution ductwork to connect to
the zone served.
A basic packaged refrigeration unit will provide

cooling only. Heating can be provided to the room
air by the use of an electric resistance heater in the
airstream. Other systems use a heat pump to provide
both heating and cooling. This is achieved by the
use of a reversing valve in the refrigerant pipework
which maintains the same flow direction through the
compressor but changes the flow tothe coils
effectively reversing their function. Electric heating
to the space is only needed when outside
temperatures fall below 3 ° C . The heat pump can
achieve savings in energy consumption of 10% to
60% over conventional electric heating, depending
upon the external climate.
Packaged refrigeration units may also be combined

with heat recovery. Water source heat pumps may
be made up of a number of water to airheat pumps
connected to a common closed loop water

circulating system. This water circuit is maintained
at a temperature between 16 and 33"C, and this
allows each heat pump connected to it to provide
30
Discuss me ...
the necessary heating or cooling. On heating mode,

the units extract heat from the water, while on
cooling reject heat to the water. Hence, the water
circuit redistributes building energy to where
required. Each heat pump is controlled by a local
room thermostat.
The latest development in refrigerant-based systems

allows a number of units within individual rooms to
be connected to one external condensing unit
(cooling only), or heat pump (heating and cooling)
via one refrigeration pipework circuit. These
Variable Refrigerant Volume (VRV) systems are
independently controlled by a temperaturesensor in
the area served by each unit. The refrigerant
pipework is relatively small. These systems still
require supply andextract air viaducts to provide
comfort cooling withfurther control over humidity
and air filtration. These VRV systems comprise
multiple cassette units which may be located
horizontally in the ceilingvoid, or attached to the
ceiling, or vertically on thewalls.
4.7 Under-floor Distribution

It is a common assumption that all air-conditioning
system distribution and terminal equipment is
located overhead in the ceiling void with the cool
supply air entering the room from ceiling or high
level wall mounted diffusers. However, there are
certain systems which provide the supply of
conditioned air from under the floor which can offer
certain positive features (see Figure 8).
In under-floor systems, the air or water distribution

and terminal devices are located in the floor void,
hence minimising the overhead services to perhaps
lighting and fire detectors only. By making the floor
void deep enough, the power, telecommunications
and computer wire-ways may be incorporated into
the one void, all being easily accessible by merely
opening up the floor plenum.
Under-floor cooling is particularly beneficial for

computer rooms, as here the comfort of the
occupants is of secondary importance. Air velocities
from floor grilles and resultant room noise levels are
both very much higher for cooling of equipment
than those which would be acceptable for people.
The advantages of under-floor systems are:

The need foroverhead services andconsequent
service access is reduced, if not avoided
31
Discuss me ...
completely, by providing all ormost of the

INTERFACES services under-floor.
9 Suspended ceilingsmaynotbe necessary, and
even if provided, there is little chance of
maintenance damage to ceilingtiles, because
there is almost no need for access to services
above. Hence maintenance access is easier i.e.
at floor level.
Powerlcomsldata outlet
150T
I t
Floor void
a
150 5t - . .. . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . .. .. . . . .. . . . .. . . . .. . . . .. . . . .. ..
. . . . .. . .. . .. . . . .. . .. . . . . . . . . . . .. . .. . . . .. . ..
. .. . . . .. .. .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . ..
. . . . . . .
.
Ceiling void
400 1
12501
i-
425 1
D Supply duct
Air conditioning overhead
, Air outlet through plenum flool

A .~
~~~~~~~~ . . . .. . .. . . , I _ . . . . .. . .. . . . .. . . . .. . . ., F.. ., . . , . , . . , . , ,
. , , ~
150 . . . . . .. . .. . .. . .. . .. . .. . .. . .. . .. . .. . . . . . . . . .. . .. . .. . .
. . .. . . . . . . . . . .. .
. . . . .. ., . . 1250
n
Y~
With uplighters the depth of the
ceiling void may be reduced
Air conditioning underfloor
Figure 8 Overhead and under-floor air conditioning

The architect and interior designer have more

scope for selections a variety of ceiling finishes
and expression of the structure.
32
Discuss me ...
Conditioned air is supplied where it is required,

at the level of the occupants. By displacement
ventilation, a layer of cooler clean air is created,
and the stale air rises and is extracted above.
A floor extract system prevents soiling to ceiling
tiles adjacent to grilles for the return air.
(Although a ceilingextract system would provide
an opportunity to recover the heat emitted by
any ceiling mounted light fittings).
Floor grilles may bedesigned to be an integral
part of the raised floor, and can be repositioned
to suit modifications in the furnitureand
equipment layouts.
By using the floor void as a plenum, ductwork is
reduced and more space is available for data and
communications cabling.
The use of higher supply air temperatures,
means that external air can provide 'free cooling'
for longer periods.
Under-floor systems may be used with VAV or Fan

Coil systems located on the floor slab. Air is
supplied at floor level and may be extracted eitherat
floor, or ceiling level (see Section 4.8).
The operational disadvantages of an under-floor

system, when used in occupied spaces such as
offices, are as follows:
The ankles and the back of the neck are the most
temperature sensitive parts of the body. Hence,
introducing cold airat low level to avoid
creating a chill to the ankles becomes difficult.
Particular types of floor diffusers have to be used
that swirl and mix the cold air quickly with the
room air without creating low level cold air
streams.
To avoid draughts at low level, the temperature
of the supply air is raised. A 5°C temperature
differential between the cooler supply air and
the room air is commonly used, which compares
with differentials of up to 10°C with an
overhead system. Hence, the amount of air
which has to be introduced into the occupied
space for the same cooling load can double,
which increases equipment and running costs
for the system.
Dirt and gravity can combine to make the

cleaning requirements for an under-floor
air-conditioning system more difficult than for a
similar overhead system.
33
Discuss me ...
The floorgrilles can becomeblocked

INTERFACES accidentally by inappropriate positioning of
furniture or equipment.
Inhighly serviced under-floorapplications,the
air flow through the void can become restricted
in certain areas due to the density of cables.
In a Fan Coil system, there may be a reluctance
to combine data and electrical cabling with
water pipes within the same floor void.
Architecturally, a large array of floor grilles,
however neatly arranged, may be unacceptable
in certain situations.
The floor grilles may be relocated by the
usedclient, which although providing greater
flexibility, often removes any form of order to
the pattern of floor grilles.
4.8 Laminar Flow System

This is a hybrid system, which combines both

under-floor and overhead distribution and return air
flows. Essentially this is an All-Air system where the
supply air is fed into the occupiedspace via floor
grilles. The raised floor acts as a supply plenum, and
requires a clear depth of about 500 mm, depending
on the volume of thespace to be supplied. The
return air is extracted through the suspended ceilings
and directed back to the plant room for retreatment.
Laminar flow systems have not been widely used to

date, but they can provide a ’clean’ environment.
The advantages of laminar flow systems are similar to
those for under-floor systems, although the floor-
ceiling zone may be deeper than in conventional
systems.
4.9 Chilled Ceilings

Chilled ceilings provide radiant cooling toa space.
By reducing the surface temperature of the chilled
ceiling, higher room air temperatures can be
accepted for a given comfort level, and the cooling
load is reduced (see explanation under ‘Comfort
Criteria’ in Section 4.1).
In chilled ceilings, cool water (at 15 to 18°C) passes

through a series of pipes which are connected to
metal panels that act as radiator panels to
34
Discuss me ...
disseminate the cooling effect. A chilled ceiling is

illustrated diagrammatically in Figure 9.
This technique is well proven in continental Europe

and is a serious alternative to All-Air systems. The
installation requires substantially less space, smaller
ceiling voids , reduced vertical and horizontal
services space, and a smaller central plant room.
The use of water as the primary cooling mediumhas
another distinct advantage of reducing theenergy
used to deliver the coolingeffect, and maintenance
costs are minimal, with virtually no movingparts
outside the main plant room.
Support from floor slab above

tions act as spacers

panels and as a fixing
Web ( or ''lattice") of small-bore tubes carrying

chilled water is pressed against the steel
under (visible) surface of the panel
Figure 9 Illustration of chilled ceilingsystem
A radiant cooling system is unlike more conventional

systems in that it is designed to be partly exposed to
view, and each system provides a ceiling witha
decorative appearance which can be selected on the
basis of suitability and cost to match the
requirements. Alternatively it can be semi-concealed
behind an 'open style' decorative ceiling (e.g. metal
slatted or open cell format). A design solution
incorporating both convectiveand radiant system
can be used where appropriate.
This type of system provides only cooling. The

heating, fresh air supply, humidity levels and
ventilation control must be provided by other means.
The heat losses through the fabric of the building
need to be overcome, and this is dealt with by a
perimeter heating system. Chilled ceiling systems

can be used in naturally ventilated buildings, but
only in areas of low occupancy and of low latent
heat gains, in order to avoid the risk of condensation.
35
Discuss me ...
Chilled ceilings can lead to a reduced ceiling void,

INTERFACES but spatial allowance must also be made for separate
fresh air ventilation ducts, which reduces the
benefits of this system. An extract ventilation system
should also be provided. The ventilation system is
an integral part of chilled ceilingsystems so that
humidity levels are controlled, and condensation on
the chilled ceilingis avoided.
Chilled beams are a variant of this system which also

introduce recirculated cooled air to the space. An
example of a chilled beam unit i s shown i n Figure
10. As its name suggests, it is a linear rather than flat
element. The cooling capacity obtainable from a
chilled beam is increased when used in combination
with the supply air. In this case, a separate air
extract system is required.
Air supply
$>
Return air
Figure 10 Illustration of a chilled beam

36
Discuss me ...
The advantages of chilled ceilings and chilledbeams

are:
Reduced ceiling voids.
Ceiling panels can provide a decorative finish.
Reduced energy use due to the use of high air
temperatures whilst achieving the required
comfort level.
Lowmaintenance costs.
Chilled beams may fit between the ribs of
concrete slabs.
Chilled beams may incorporate fresh air-supply
through ductwork.
The disadvantages of chilled ceilings or chilled
beams are:
Possibility of condensation on the cooling
elements and pipework, particularly in naturally
ventilated spaces.
Additional fresh air supply is required in a sealed

building, which leads to further ductwork.
Risks of water leaks in the occupied space.
4.1 0 Comparison of Systems

The relative meritsof all the above systems are best
presented in a tabular form. Table 4 describes the
main design criteria, and Table 5 addresses the
features of their installation andmaintenance.
The different types ofVAV and Fan Coil Systems and

their distribution system and terminal units are
illustrated in Figures 11 and 12.
37
Discuss me ...
Table 4 Relative merits of heatinglventilationlcooling systems - design aspects
The following tables demonstrates some of the key factors in the design of the main
'air-conditioning' systems
System Provision
MaximumMaximum lowest Comfortable
Equipment
Impact on Air Quality Localised
of Useable/ lnspace Operating
Working
and
Life Aesthetics
Provided
Control
Heating,
Flexibility
Lettable Costs Options
Room
Environment
Replace-
of
mentControl/User Floor
Cooling, Costs
Humidity Space
ALL AIR
Constant
Volume/ 1 1 2 3 2 1 2 1 3
Single Zone
Constant
Volume/ 1
Multi-Zone
VAV with
Perimeter 1
Heating
VAV
Under-floor 1 2 1 2 2 1
VAV with Fan

Assisted Boxes 1 2 l 3 2 2
___.___ ~ - . -.
AIWATER
Airmater
Induction 1 3 2 3 2 2 3 3 2
- - -
ALL WATER
Fan Coil -
Horizontal l
Fan Coil -
Vertical 1
Fan Coil -
Variable Air 2
Supply
Chilled
Ceiling 3 2 3 2
Heat Pump -
Vertical Units 1 2 3 1
at Perimeter
-
REFRIGERANT
Multiple
Cassette (VRV) 3 2 3 3 1
Wall Mounted
Package 3 3 3 3 1
Roof Mounted
Packaae 2 2 3 3 3
1
2 ---
very good
good
3 average
Notes: All VAV systems require some perimeter heating tooffset fabric heat losses.
38
Discuss me ...
Table 5 Relative merits of heatinglventilatinglcooling systems - installation aspects
The following table demonstrates some of the key factors i n the installation and
maintenance of each of the main ‘air-conditioning’ systems (refer also to Table 4).
System Minimum
Plant Extent of Vertical
Window System Water Ease of Ease of
Ceiling Room Ductwork Service Sill Electrical Pipework Extension Maintenance
depth Space Shaft Heights Distribution Distribution and of Equipment
Adaption
ALL AIR
Constant
Volume/ 3 3 3 3 1 1 1 3 1
Single Zone
Constant
Volume/ 3 3 3 3 1 1 2 3 1
Multi-Zone
VAV with
Perimeter 2 3 2 2 2 1 2 3 2
Heating
VAV
Under-floor l 3 2 2 1 1 1 2 1
VAV with Fan

Boxes Assisted 3 2 2 2 1 3 2 2 3
AIMATER
Airmater
Induction 1 2 1 1 3 3 3 1 3
ALL WATER
Fan Coil -
Horizontal 2 1 1 1 1 3 3 1 3
Fan Coil -
Vertical 1 1 2 2 3 2 2 1 2
Fan Coil -
Variable Air 2 l 1 1 1 2 2 1 3
Supply
Chilled
Ceiling 1 2 1 1 1 1 3 2 2
Heat Pump -
Vertical Units at 1 1 1 1 3 3 3 1 2
Perimeter
REFRIGERANT
Multiple
(VRV) Cassette 2 1 1 l 1 3 1 1 3
Wall Mounted
Package 1 1 1 1 3 3 1 1 3
Roof Mounted
Package 2 3 3 1 1 1 1 1 1
--
1 very good
2 good
-
3 average
Notes: All VAV systems require some perimeter heatingto offset fabric heat losses. The refrigerant systems use minimal
local ventilation.
39
Discuss me ...
INTERFACES
HIGHVELOCITYSUPPLY -
AIR DUCTWORK
DAMPERCONTROLTO
VARY
THE
VOLUME OF
COOL AIRDELIVERED
TO THE SPACE
l 1
EXTRACTAIR THROUGH
l LIGHTFITTINGS,EXTRACT
l CEILING
PLENUM & INTO
EXTRACTSTUB DUCTWORK
l LOW VELOCITYEXTRACT DUCTWORK

COLUMN AI/ ' G
F L E X I B L E DUCTWORK L PERIMETER SUPPLY DUCT HEADER
CONNECTION
Variable Air Volume boxes with perimeter heating

Units are installed in the ceiling voidand chilled air is
ducted to them. Air is extracted by a separate duct back to
the central plant. The perimeter heating system can take the
form of radiators, convectors or sill-line heating grilles. The
central plant comprises boilers and refrigeration equipment,
which provides heating and coolingrespectively to the
central air handling units.
Figure 11
Variable Air Volume system
showing the distribution system

and terminal units
40
Discuss me ...
EXTRACT OUCTWORK
FRESHAIRSUPPLY OUCTWORK
4 PIPEFANCOILUNIT
HEATING
PROVIDING & L 1
COOLING I\ I
I ~
FLEXIBLE OUCTWORK \ .
I
CONNECTION
l
150mm
RAISED
FLOOR
130mmCOMPOSITESLAB
406mm BEAM
314mm VOID
200mmLIGHTING ZONE
AN0TOLERANCE
PERIMETERSUPPLYAIR ROOM AIRRETURNS EXTRACTAIR THROUGH

SLOTDIFFUSER & PLENUM TO FANCOILVIA LIGHTFITTINGS,EXTRACT
BOX PLENUM CEILING FITTINGS LIGHT & INTO
EXTRACTSTUB OUCTWORK
COLUMN 4
CONDENSATEDRAIN TO F A L L S F&R
Horizontal Fan Coil Unit

Fan Coil Units are installed in the ceiling void where they
are supplied with hot and chilled water from centrally
located boilers and refrigeration plant. A separate air
handling unit introduces external air directly intothe Fan
Coil Unit for ventilation. Air is extracted by a separate duct
back to the central plant. Locally mounted controls
sequence the heating and cooling delivered by the Fan Coil
Unit to maintain the desired room conditions.
Figure 12
Fan Coil Unit system
showing the distribution
system and terminal units
41
INTERFACES
42
Discuss me ...
5 INTERNAL
DISTRIBUTION OF
SERVICES
For many reasons, ranging from planning height

restrictions to maximising thenet lettable area of
commercial office building, there is pressure to
minimise the space allocated to the building
services. Therefore, it is necessary to ensure an
efficient use of space for the service distribution
system and in the plant rooms.
The following Sections review the spatial aspects of

the vertical and horizontal service distribution.
43
Discuss me ...
INTERFACES 5.1 General Recommendations

General recommendations@)on the location of
central plant rooms are as follows:
Ensure that plant rooms are not separated from
vertical service routes (risers) by difficult or
restrictive distribution routes. Passing major
services through a narrow corridor is not
recommended.
Position vertical routes for services at the
boundary of the plant room. A riser that passes
through the middle of the plant room effectively
renders large areas of the plant room unusable.
Avoid services crossing a major fire barrier.
Take account of the building form (Sections 5.2
to 5.4).
5.2 VerticalDistribution of Services

The following recommendations apply to the vertical

distribution of services:
Provide continuous and uninterrupted vertical
service routes.
Maintain a constant cross-section of the service
route. Lift shafts are always designed as constant
dimension elements - apply the same principle to
service routes.
Position the plant room so that it is as close as
possible to the centre of the plan area it serves.
Consider the connection between horizontal
services and vertical services routes.
Provide separate routes for different services.
The minimum is two; one for electrics and one
for water pipes etc., although most buildings
require more service routes.
Horizontal distribution should ideally not extend
more than 25 m from a vertical service route.
Longer distances w i l l impose penalties on the
system design and increase the depth of
horizontal service ducts.
Position plant rooms at no more than 10 storeys
apart vertically.
44
Discuss me ...
Examples of these recommendations applied to

typical building forms are shown in Figures 13
and 14.
Plan Notes
l
Small building One plant room, one riser

(up t o f o u r Location of riser not
storeys and up to important, due to small
61
2 5 0 0 m’ total floor size of building (central
area) locationpreferred).Plant
room must be adjacent to
the riser.
I Plant
room
I
I
~~
I Large plan building 150 m Several plant rooms
E
(4000 m2 total floor adjacent to areas served.
area) Some central plant, for
example for gas intake
and boilers, may be
required.
Large, tall building Plant room floors at

(over 15 storeys) basement and roof level.
El
Intermediate plant rooms
may be required. Vertical
distribution within central
core.
L-shaped building 60 m Several plant ro’oms,

(1000m 2 t o K-- severalrisers.Risersand
3000 m 2 per floor) air plant rooms adjacent
(3-10 storeys) t o cores.Separateroom
located at
ground/basement level for
new electric supply.
Building with atrium 60 m Four roof air plant rooms,

(typically 2000 m’ i( 4 one basement plant room.
per floor) Four risers related to
cores.Basementplant
below atrium gives best
connection to risers.
Figure 13 Typical arrangements of plant rooms and vertical service routes

(taken from Reference (S))
45
Discuss me ...
Location
INTERFACES
Effects of riser
location on duct
depth.
Example building,
40 m x 40 m, with air
duct riser located
(a) centrally, (b) a t a
V I
Duct
V
corner.
/
I
The longer the duct,
the deeper it is where
it joins the riser (and
hence increased depth
of ceiling/floor zone) \ /
The examples show

that with a central
riser, ducts can be
shorter and so maximum
duct
depth 400 maximum
duct
depth 600
shallower.
V V
Typical ductwork
layout in ceiling void
Relationship of vertical riser location to duct size and distribution
Figure 14 Key aspects o f efficient duct distribution (taken from

Reference (8))
5.3 Ceiling
Grids
In heavily serviced buildings, it is often the case that
air griIIes/diffusers, sprinklers, luminaries and smoke
detectors can all be usefully placed in the same
location on the ceiling. A modular layout of the
ceiling area is required in order to provide a defined
space for each element on plan. This involves the
sub-division of the ceiling into aregular grid pattern.
The dimension of this ceiling grid has, with

experience, been regulated to 1200 mm, 1500 mm
or 1800 mm. Multiples of these grid dimensions are
suitable office space and structural grid dimensions.
Typically 1200 mm or 1500 mm have become
common structural grid dimensions.
The grid dimensions allow an economic selection

and distribution of light fittings and linear air
diffusers. Sub-division of the grid dimension by
600 mm or 300 mm leads to sensible ceiling tile
46
Discuss me ...
dimensions and the possibleuse of square lights and

diffusers. Figure 15 shows tvpical linear air diffusers
and lighting units located within a modular ceiling
panel.
Figure 15 Example of air diffusers located in lighting units
5.4 HorizontalDistribution of Services

Conventionally, the horizontal distribution of
services is arranged within a horizontal layer which
is generally located below the structure. This layer
accommodates both the distribution system (ducts,
pipes etc), the terminal units and lighting units. The
raised floor is placed on the floorslab and
accommodates the electrical and communication
cabling. The lighting units are often located within
the ceiling depth.
To determine the spatial allowance for these

elements, three dejign cases may be envisaged
corresponding to different structural configurations:
1. A flat slab with flexibility of service routing.
2. A slab and downstand beam arrangement.

3. A long,span beam system with facility for service
integration.
47
Discuss me ...
In case 1, the ducts pass within the depth allowed for

INTERFACES the terminal units. However, cross-overs of ducts
must be avoided in order to minimize this depth. In
cases 2 and 3, the terminal units may belocated
between the beams, which means that additional
space below the beams is required only for the major
ducts, ceiling and l i g h t k g units. In case 3, the ducts
are located entirely within the structural zone.
Typical dimensional allowances for service zones in

typical modern air-conditioned buildings are
presented i n Table 6 for these three cases. It can be
seen that the dimensions allowed for thevarious
components lead to ceiling-floor depths of 1100 mm
to 1250 mm. The differences between the flat soffit
and the long span systems with integrated services
are relatively small in terms of overall ceiling-floor
depths. The comparable ceiling-floor depths for a
non-air-conditioned building would be 650 mm,
875 mm and 1250 mm respectively for the three
cases, and the differences between the systems are
obviously much greater.
Tab'e Vertical
Dimension
Downstand
Flat
the
for Long
Span
Typical VeftiCaI Following
Components:
Beams
Beams
Soffit
dimensions between(mm) (mm) (mm)
Ceiling and floor 1. Allowance
deflection
for 75 50 25
and fire protection
2. Lighting
and
units ceiling 125
125
175
(units located between
the beams)
attachments
3. VAVand
box 450 nilnil
(boxes between beams)
4. Ducts
insulation
and <2
450(+ 75 nil
insulation)
TOTAL
structure)
(below 200 500 650
5. Raised floor 150 150 150
6. Structural
(typical)
depth 300
___
550 900
TOTAL (ceiling-floor)
1250 1200 1100
Note: These approximate dimensions may be used for

planning purposes.
It i s possible to reduce these ceiling-floor depths, but

the cost of the structure, and services (due to
inefficient duct shapes, or number of separate ducts)
may increase. For example, some of the structural
systems investigated in Section 7 achieve depths
varying by 100 mm from these approximate
dimensions.
48
Discuss me ...
6 STRUCTURAL
OPTIONS FOR
SERVICES
INTEGRATION
The following sections describe the main structural

systems that may be used in steel framed commercial
buildings, concentrating on the long span systems
that have been developed. All the systems described
use composite floor slabs.
6.1 Composite
Construction
In composite construction, steel beams act

structurally with an in situ and lightly reinforced
concrete slab on steel decking, which is used as
permanent f o r m w ~ r k ( ~ Shear
, ~ ) . connectors are used
49
Discuss me ...
to develop composite action between the concrete

INTERFACES slab and the steel beams. All materials act together
'compositely', after the concrete has gained sufficient
strength, to provide a strong, efficient method of
floor construction.
The main reasons for using composite construction

are economic, i n most instances. Faster erection of
the steel frame, and the elimination of temporary
propping of theslab, facilitates earlier completion of
the building, which in turn reduces interest charges
and advances rental income. There are also
significant savings in use of steel, as a composite
beam may be twice the strength of the equivalent
non-composite beam in conventional steelwork, and
up to fourtimes stiffer. This means that shallower
structural depths can be achieved which permits use
of lower storey heights and leads to savings in
cladding costs, or alternatively, provides more space
or flexibility for services within the same overall
floor-to-floor height.
6.2 Slim Floors and Slimdek

Slim floors (also called integrated beams in some
countries) have been specifically developed to
achieve minimum structural depth and therefore
provide maximum flexibility for distribution of
services beneath the f l ~ o r ' ~ , 'The
~ ) . beam consists of
an H section (usually UC) with a welded bottom
plate. The registered British Steel trademark is
Slimflor in the UK. Two alternative floor systems
may be used: either precast concrete (pc) units, or a
deep deck composite slab. Both elements are
supported by the plate in order to form a flat soffit.
The Slimflor beam using deep decking is illustrated
in Figure 16. Small openings may be formed in the
web of the section for pipes and small ducts. The
space between the ribs may also be utilized for
fitments and cross-overs of ducts.
Recently, British Steel has launched the Slimdek

system("!'*' which comprises a rolled asymmetric
beam (ASB) used with a deep deck composite slab.
This new form of construction is illustrated in
Figure 17. The ASB can be up to 25% lighter than
the equivalent Slimflor beam, and requires much less
fabrication. The Slimdek system is considered as a
variant of the slim floor system in this study, and it

increases the economy of this form of construction.
50
Discuss me ...
Figure 16 Slim floor construction using deep decking
Figure 17 Slimdek construction using a rolled asymmetricbeam and deep decking
Spans of Slimflor or Slimdek construction using deep

deck composite slabs are usually in the range of 5 to
8 m. In the precast concrete slim floor option, the pc
units may span a longer distance (up to 9 m). Slim
floor construction is not appropriate for long span

applications. However, general comparisons have
been made in order to identify theadvantages and
disadvantages of the varioussystems.
51
Discuss me ...
Slim floor and Slirndek construction w i l l be

INTERFACES beneficial either in highly serviced buildings, where
maximum flexibility ofservice distribution is
required, or in buildings without air-conditioning, in
which the floor depth is minimised.
6.3 Medium Span systems

The most common framing plans used in medium
and long span buildings are illustrated in Figure 18.
In all cases, the composite slab spans typically 3 to
4 m between the beams. The upper limit often
depends on the ability of thesteel decking tosafely
support the wet weight ofconcrete during the
construction stage without temporary propping.
Secondary beams are used to support the slab and
these beams span between primary beams. Clearly,
a balance has to be achieved between the provision
of a smaller number of primary beams supporting
heavier loads (i.e. spaced wider apart), and a greater
number of more lightly loaded beams.
Medium span systems generally use standard hot

rolled beam sections (UB, or continental IPE or
equivalent sections). For a uniformly loaded
composite beam, a steel beam depth of
approximately span/25 would be required.
Serviceability limits (i.e. control of deflections or
floor vibrations) may control the choice of thesteel
section rather than the bending resistance of the
composite section.
In medium span systems, no attempt is usually made

to achieve full services integration, and the depths of
the primary and secondary beams are selected so
that the services distribution systems pass beneath.
The terminal units in the services system are located
between the beams, either partly or wholly within
the structural depth. The more heavily loaded
primary beams are generally arranged to span the
shorter distance in the column grid inorder to
minimize their depth, as shown in Figure 18(a).
52
Discuss me ...
H 6
2.5 -4m
'H
Secondary beam
(span 6- 12 m)
(a) Typical framing plan for medium span beams

l
H
Primary beam
(span 5- 8 m)
Primary beam
(man 12 - 18 m)
(b) Typical framing plan for long span beams
Figure 18 Typical framing plans for medium and long

span beams
6.4 Long Span Construction

Building users and developers are increasingly
demanding more column-freespace, and 12 to 18 m
column spacings have become more popular.
Agents find that column-free spaces easier to let and
may well command a rent premium. A variety of
structural solutions for long spans, (i.e. above 9 m)
will be considered in the following Sections. A
typical framing plan is shown in Figure 18(b).
One of the principal advantages of steel over

concrete construction is its ability to span further
with less use and weight of materials. However,
costs per square metre increases as the column
spacing increases, although these additional costs
may be small in comparison to the economic and
functional benefits realised from greater areas of
uninterrupted usable floor space. Internal columns

are often unwelcome, particularly when they
become large in cross-section due to their high
loading in tall buildings.
53
Discuss me ...
Fabricated tapered girders, haunched beams, parallel

INTERFACES beam systems, composite trusses, stub girders and
cellular beams are examples of modern long span
structural systems, which are described in detail in
the following Sections.
The optimum structural solution depends on the:

spans of the primary andsecondary beams.
Often the long span beam is used as the primary
beam, as shown in Figure 18(b)
span/depth ratio of the members
necessity to contribute to the resistance to lateral
loads applied to the building
location and cross-sectional area of major ducts
across the span (including consideration of
general distribution routes and crossover
positions)
‘looseness of fit’ between services and structure,
(especially important for ‘shell and core’
developments, where particular tenants may
require additional provisions)

structure cost (including the savings on cladding
and other costs).
Since it is now almost inevitable that building

services w i l l change significantly during the life ofa
commercial building, the designer should take future
adaptability into account whenselecting the
structural system to be used.
The different long span alternatives that may be

considered and their span capabilities are presented
in Table 7. These data are for guidance only, as
many of the systems can be used over a much
greater range of application. Also shown in Table 7
are the comparable medium span systems in steel
and concrete construction.
54
Discuss me ...
Table 7 Summary of typicalspans o f different structural systems in steel and

concrete construction
Span (m) 6 a 10 16 13 20
Reinforced concrete (r.c.1 flat slab
Slirndek with deep composite slab

I
R.C. waffle slab 1 I
Shelf angle beam with precast slabs
Slirnflor with precast slabs I I
IR.C. beam and slab I I I I

I I
Post-tensioned concrete flat slab
Composite beam and slab l I
Parallel beam approach
Composite beam with web openings I
Cellular composite beam I

I
I
Tapered girder I
Haunched composite beam
Composite truss
Note: Minimum and maximum spans are given for general guidance of the capabilities of each
system.
6.5 Composite Beams withWeb

Openings
Reserve capacity exists over much of the length of a
standard beam section and this w i l l permit
rectangular or circular openings to be cut in theweb,
provided these openings are located away from the
supports. Relatively large openings can usually be
provided without theneed for strengthening by
horizontal stiffeners, provided that there is adequate
shear resistance in the remaining web. A typical
web opening suitable for a large rectangular duct is
shown in Figure 19. The high degree of composite
action around the openingsmeans that the loss of
bending resistance of the beam due to the web
openings i s often not as significant as in a steel
beam.
55
Discuss me ...
INTERFACES
Figure 19 Openings in the webs of composite beams
If larger service zones are necessary, more costly

‘stiffened’ openings are required. Circular openings
are more efficient structurallythan rectangular
openings, but are usually less practical-as they are
generally smaller in area. By deepening the primary
beams, and forming larger openings, the flexibility of
service distribution can be increased.
However, a major disadvantage of this simple option

is the relative inflexibility of thesystem. Openings
‘tailored’ to meet the requirements of a particular
service installation provide littlescope for future
changes in service layout. Furthermore, after a beam
size has been selected, it may be impossible to
accommodate even a slight increase in duct size
without increasing thebeam depth.
When locating rectangular openings in the webs of

composite beams, the following g~idelined’~)
should
be considered:
Openings should not be located closer than two
times the beam depth D from the support, or
1Ooh of the span, whichever is the greater.
Thebest location for any opening is between 1/5
and 113 of the span from a support in uniformly
loaded beams.
Forbeams subject to point loads, the location of
the openings depends on the relative importance
of moment and shear along the beam.
56
Discuss me ...
Openings should not be less than the beam

depth, D, apart.
Unstiffenedopeningsshouldnotgenerallybe
deeper than 0.6 D, nor longer than 1.5 D. The
shear resistance and instability of the web
should be checked.
Stiffened openingsshouldnotgenerallybe
deeper than 0.7 D, nor longer than 2 D.
Stiffeners should be in the form of horizontal
plates welded above and below the opening.
Point loads should not be applied atless than D
from the side of the adjacent opening.
As an alternative near supports, beams may be

notched by cutting away the lower part of the beam
web and flange. As much as half of the beam depth,
D, can be removed extending up to distance D into
the span. This permits the use of modest service
zones adjacent to the supports of long span beams.
6.6 Cellular and Caste1lated Beams

For long spans, a deep beam is often required in
order to provide adequate stiffness. In the standard
range of rolled sections, flange and web thicknesses
increase with beam depth. These sections are
adapted to non-composite applications, but are often
heavier than needed when acting as composite
beams.
Lighter deeper sections can be fabricated from

structural sections in the form ofcastellated or
‘cellular’ beams(14).These sections are produced by
cutting standard sections and re-welding in a
particular pattern to create deeper beams with a
series of hexagonal or circular holes. A castellated
beam is shown in Figure 20.
The sections are structurally efficient, and relatively

large openings can be created through which
services can be passed. The numerous openings
through the web provide good flexibilityfor future
re-servicing, although the finite size of the openings
may restrict the duct sizes that can be used.
57
Discuss me ...
INTERFACES
l!
Figure 20 Castellated beam
Castellated and ‘cellular beams’ are more suitable for

use as long span secondary beams than for primary
beams with point loads, as the shear capacity of the
web is considerably weakened by the openings.
However, they can be designed for use as primary
members by strengthening the openings where shear
forces are very high, either by infilling the openings
or by using horizontalstiffeners, although this adds
considerably to the fabrication costs.
Castellated beams formed from structural sections

have an overall depth, D, 50% greater than the
parent beam. Standard castellations comprise
hexagonal holes of maximum depth 0.67 D at
0.72 D centres which would allowthe passage of
circular ducts of up to 0.4 D diameter. The loss of
the beam web reduces its bending and shear
strength. Typical span/depth ratios are
approximately 20.
For ’cellular beams’, a wide range of opening sizes

and beam sizes is possible, although the diameter
and spacing of openings must be constantalong the
length of a beam. Circular openings can be created
with diameters of 0.6 to 0.8 times the final beam
depth and at spacings of 1 .l to 1.5 times the opening

diameter. Furthermore, in some cases, the openings
may be enlarged byremoving the ‘webpost’
separating two adjacent openings. This can be
58
Discuss me ...
achieved in the middle third of thespan, though

additional stiffening is generally required.
A cellular beam may also be formedby welding two

different sections together. For composite beam
design, where the concrete slab acts in compression,
the top flange may be significantly reduced in size.
A combination of different UB and UC sections (or
continental IPE and HE sections) can reduce the
weight of abeam by up to 30°/0, whilst providing the
same composite stiffness as a solid beam of the same
depth. The production process for cellular beams
also allows the sections to be pre-cambered during
production, effectively overcoming deflection
problems due toself weight.
The ability of cellularbeam to accommodate alarge

number of circularducts is illustrated in Figure 21.
. Cellular beams are often used where a high degree
of flexibility in service routing is required. The
structural properties of cellular beams lend
themselves to use as both secondary and primary
beams. These alternative configurations are

considered in the later sections of this publication.
There are a growing number of buildings where this
form of construction has been used to provide a
highly serviced and visually attractive floor system.
Figure 21 Cellular beam showing distribution of circular ducts

59
Discuss me ...
INTERFACES 6.7 Haunched Beams

Haunching of beams to reduce the rafter depth is
standard practice in portal frame structures.
Haunches, or local deepening of thebeam adjacent
to the beam to column connection, can also be used
to reduce beam depths for long span
By
providing a rigid connectionat the beam ends, the
bending moment at mid-span can be considerably
reduced and a smaller steel section used. The beam
may also be designed to act compositely with the
floor slab in the mid-span zone. This system is
illustrated in Figure 22.
Large moments are transferred into the columns,

resulting in more expensive connections and heavier
columns. In long span, low rise buildings this may
result in reduced frame costs, as the total beam
length and weightare significantly greater than the
column length and weight. Haunched beams can
also be designed to provide thesway stability of the
building without requiring verticalbracing.
Figure 22 Haunched composite beam
The rigid connectionsat the ends of haunched

beams also considerably stiffen thebeam and reduce

deflections. Therefore, span/beam depth ratios can
be increased to around 35, corresponding to about
30% reduction in beam depth relative to simply
60
Discuss me ...
supported beams. The critical section for design is

the beam at the tip of the haunch. The length of the
haunch is selected to achieve an efficient moment
connection to the column. A haunch cut from the
same section (of depth D) is usually used, resulting
in an overall depth at the supports of approximately
2 D. Consequently, a clear zone of depth D is
produced across approximately 85% of the beam
span.
A shallow beam depth therefore permits the services

to be passed beneath both the primary and
secondary beams within the depth of thehaunches.
Apart from zones adjacent to column lines, the
haunched beam solution offers almost total flexibility
for service layout. This gives greater freedom i n
design of the service layout and easier installation on
site.
Despite these advantages, the haunched beam

solution requires careful structural design because
the beams must frame into themajor axis of columns
in order to transfer moments to the columns. The
haunched beam system is ideally suited to buildings

with rectangular plan form and approximately equal
adjacent spans. The system is not generally
appropriate for irregular building plan shapes.
6.8 Tapered
Beams
As an alternative to rolledsections, fabricated steel
sections produced from flat plate can be used.
Additional fabrication costs can be offset against
reduced material costs, resulting in a structurally
efficient and economic design. Fabricated sections
may be of uniform depth, but tapered beams offer
advantages in highly serviced b u i l d i n g P . By
tapering the beam along its length, the bending
resistance of the section can be made to closely
follows the shape of the bending momentdiagram.
A typical example of a tapered beam is illustrated in
Figure 23.
At the ends of the beam, the depth may bereduced,

depending on the required shear resistance. This
saves weight of steel, but more importantly, releases
space below the beam for service distributions. Thus
a reasonably sized zone is created in which large
services may be accommodated adjacent to the
columns. Service distribution in the other direction

can usually be provided in the zonebeneath the
secondary beams.
61
Discuss me ...
INTERFACES
Figure 23 Tapered fabricated beam
In the case of fabricated steel sections, the structural

engineer has the greatest freedom in the selection of

section size. These beams may have straight tapers,
or alternatively be semi-tapered, i.e. the beam is of
uniform depth in the mid-span region. A straight
taper is simpler to fabricate and, in many cases, is
the most economic shape. Typical tapered girders
reduce to approximately half depthat the supports
with a maximumtaper angle of about 6". A vertical
stiffener may be required at mid-span for deeper
sections. A practical range of span/depth ratios is
from 15 to 25, but as the ratio increases (i.e. beam
depth reduces), the material costs increase, although
the variation in depth still permits more ready
accommodation of services.
6.9 Composite Trusses

The use of trusses (or lattice girders) for longspans is
well established in non-composite construction, but
they can also be used in composite construction,
where the concreteslab becomes an effective
compression membeP. During construction, the
truss must be capable of supporting the wet concrete
and other construction loads, but after the concrete
has gained strength, the top chord is no longer
required to resist compressive forces.
In terms of steel weight, trusses can .be efficient, but

increased fabrication costs erode much of this
economy. In order to provide service zones of
62
Discuss me ...
usable size, the trusses need to relatively deep. Fire

protection to the diagonalmembers may be quite
thick, and may considerably reduce thespace
available for services. Furthermore, fire protection
can be significantly more complex and costlythan
for conventional beams, as illustrated in Figure 24.
Figure 24 Composite truss showing fire protection
Trusses can be manufactured from ‘tee’ and angle

sections, or alternatively from tubular (CHS or SHS)
sections. They are generally welded together to
avoid the effect of cumulative bolt slip on
deflections. The standard form of truss is of the
Warren (W) form, which gives the greatest space
between the bracing members. Cylindrical ducts are
often preferred for use in trusses.
Structural hollow section (SHS) members are usually

more efficient foruse in long span trusses.
Composite trusses are suitable for use as secondary

and primary members with spans of 12 to 20 m.
Trusses placed at relatively closecentres can support
the slab directly. In this case local bending of the
top chord must be considered. Furthermore, as web
members are invariably welded to the top chord,
local moments may develop in the members.
Where trusses are used as primary members, the top

chord does not support the floor directly, but must
support a series of point loads from secondary
63
Discuss me ...
members. Connection of the secondary beams to

INTERFACES the trusses will often require use of vertical posts at
these beam locations, thus reducing the size* of
openings available forservices.
Shallower trusses can be achieved by confining large

services to a single ’Vierendeel’ panel (a rectangular
opening withno diagonals) at the centre of the span.
The shear resistance across such an opening derives
mainly from local composite action with theslab.
Alternatively, the bracing members within a regular
truss may be offset slightly to accommodatelarger
services zones. This can be achieved most easily at
mid-span where shear forces are small. Trusses
generally offer a high degree of flexibility for
servicing and future adaption.
6.10 Stub Girders

Stub girders are ’Vierendeel assemblies’ consisting of
a UC or HE steel section as a bottom chord and a
concrete slab as a top chord18). Intermittent short

lengths of a standard steel section, connected by
shear studs to the concrete slab and welded to the
bottom chord, act as ‘vertical web members’ to
transfer longitudinal forces between the two
elements. One form of stub girder construction is
illustrated in Figure 25.
Figure 25. Stub girder, not requiring propping during

construction (photo by Grant Smith, NCE)
64
Discuss me ...
When the stub girders are placed wide apart,

secondary beams, usually of the same depth as the
stub lengths, span between the girders and may be
continuous over a number of bottomchords, which
improves their spanning capabilities.
The main advantage of this form of construction is

that large spaces between the secondary beams and
the stubs provide natural openings for the passage of
services. The main disadvantage is often the need
for propping duringconstruction, as the bottom
chord alone may not have sufficient strength and
stiffness to support the construction loads.
To avoid this problem, a stub girder has been

developed which does not require propping (see
Figure 25). A Tee section top chord is provided
(with its leg uppermost) which achieves adequate
bending strength for the construction condition
when combined with the bottom chord. Bar
reinforcement is passed through holes in the Tee and
this section is embedded in the slab. N o shear
connectors are required in this case.
With conventional stub girder construction, the

depth of openings is generally determined by the
depth of the secondary beams, and as these
secondary beams may be continuous, the depth of
openings may be quite small. If larger openings are
required, the stubs can be cut from deeper sections
and the secondary beams framed into them rather
than being seated on the bottom chord.
Although widely used in North America and Canada,

experience of stub girders in European practice is
limited toa small number of projects in the UK.
They offer good flexibility of service layout across
the span, and by virtue of the number of openings,
they offer scope for future re-servicing. In
conventional stub girders, opening widths of
approximately three times the opening depthcan be
used in low shear regions, reducing to twice the
opening depth in highshear regions.
6.1 1 Para1 le1Beam Systems

In the structural forms discussed previously, the
primary members usually span the greater distance
between the columns. They are therefore ideally
suited to single bay buildings without internal

columns. In multi-bay construction, it may be
preferable to design the secondary members to span
the greater distance.
65
Discuss me ...
In the parallel beam system, (also known as parallel

INTERFACES beam approach (PBA)), long span secondary (or rib)
beams pass over twin main (or spine) beams.
Continuity of the secondary beams reduces their
depth and eight''^,^^). Passing the twin primary
beams either side of the columns achieves continuity
in this direction without the need for expensive
moment-resisting beam to column connections. The
beams are also easy to erect on site.
The parallel beam system offers a high degree of

flexibility of service routing by accommodatingducts
running in either direction, as illustrated in
Figure 26. Its ’loose fit’ nature permits adjustment of
the service routes, and allows for relatively easy
future re-servicing.
Figure 26 Parallel beam system illustrating the means of

service integration
The span/depth ratio of the composite ‘rib’ beams is

typically 30, but the ratiofor the ‘spine’ beams,
which are continuous but non-composite, reduces to
15 to 20. In some long span applications, the
combined structural depth of the rib and spine
beams may exceed that of the other systems.
However, parallel beam systems are very economic
in multi-bay structures, where the benefits of
structural continuity and a high degree of flexibility

in servicing can be realised. The typical span of the
rib beams is in the range 8 to 13 m, and the spine
beams usually span a shorter distance than the ribs.
66
Discuss me ...
The later assessments use 7.5 m span rib beams in

order to achieve continuity ina 15 m wide building.
6.1 2 Summary of Service Zones Provided

by theVarious Structural Systems
Each structural option outlined above can
accommodate openings for services but to varying
degrees. Some are particularly well adapted to the
provision of a large number of small openings,
whereas others provide a small number of larger
openings in certain prescribed locations. In the
selection of a particular structural system, it is
therefore necessary to consider the requirements of
the services system. As a broad guide, Table 8
presents typical opening sizes for the range of
structural system types covered in Sections 6.6 to
6.12. The table is based on the guidelines presented
earlier for efficient structural design. Larger
openings may be possible, if the structure is over-
designed.
6.1 3 Vertical Cores

Vertical cores provide vertical zones for stairs, lift
shafts, service ducts, toilet accommodation etc. They
usually act as a key structural element offering lateral
stability to the main structural frame. Reinforced
concrete cores are widely used, but can be slower to
construct, and openings for doorways and service
penetrations must be carefully pre-determined, as
later alterations may be expensive and difficult. The
number and size of the openings may be limited by
structural requirements.
Alternatively, vertical steel bracing in steel frames is

easier and quicker to erect, and is lightweight.
Bracing may be in ‘X’ or ‘K’ form and may use angle,
tube or 1 sections depending on the horizontal forces
to be resisted. X bracing in the form of cross-flats
may be used, particularly in cavity wall applications.
Dimensionally exact zones for services and door
openings are not required until the later stages of
design, and the location of the bracingmembers
should permit some flexibility in planning.
Steel plate cores may be used in tall buildings where

more stiffness is required than with bracing. The

stiffened plates are more similar to bridge
construction than to buildings, and are more efficient
when designed for heavy shear loads.
67
Discuss me ...
Plated steel cores can be builtsimultaneously with

INTERFACES the main frame, whereas concrete cores must
generally be built in advance. It is not unusual for a
building tohave more than one type of core
depending upon the structural requirements and
relative positions of the cores on plan.
Table 8 Summary of typical gross opening sizes for efficiently designed long span
composite beams incorporating service zones
Spanldepth
Opening Size for Beam
Span of:
Structural
Option Primary
of Beam’
12 m 15 m
Composite beam with 25 2 Q 300 x 600 1 Q 400 x 1000

openings
stiffened in + 2 Q 350 x 700
l o w shear regions 20 2 Q 400 x 800 1 Q 500 x 1200
+ 2 Q 450 x 900
Composite beam with 25 2 Q 250 x 450 4 @ 300 x 600
stiffened openings in
high shear region 20 2 Q 300 x 500 4 Q 375 x 750
Composite beam 25with 2 Q 250 x 450 2 @ 300 x 600

notches at ends of beam
20 2 Q 300 .x 600 2 Q 375 x 600
Castellated Beam’ 20 20 20240

Q Q 300 diameter
diameter
Cellular Beam 20 20 Q 350 22 Q 400 diameter

diameter
Haunched Beam 250 30 x 9000 300 x 12000

Tapered Beam 20 2 Q 200to 400 2 Q 250to500 x 3000
x 3000
Composite Truss 17 for
12 m span
4 Q 400 diameter 4 Q 400 diameter
or20 for 15 m span + 6 Q 250 diameter + 6 Q 250 diameter
+ 1 Q 4 5 0 x 1000
Stub 20
Girder 4 Q 300 x 900 2 Q 4 0 0 x 1000 +
+ 4 Q 300 x 600 4 @ 400 x 700
4 Q 400 x 500
Parallel Beam 30 - secondary 400 deep 400 deep3
System 15 - primary continuous continuous
Assumptions:
Ceiling - floor zone = 1250 mm
Structural zone (beams and slab) = 900 mm
Beam spacing = 6 m
1
Depth is steel section depth. Slab depth (about 130 mm) to be added
’ May be restricted to applications as long spansecondarybeams
Structural zone deeper than900 mm
68
Discuss me ...
7 CASE STUDY:
COMPARISON OF
STRUCTURAL
OPTIONS
7.1 Typical Steel Framed Building

Steel framed buildings require a design approach
which encompasses not only thestructure but also
the services, cladding and finishes. The design
process should involve continual liaison and close
co-ordination between architect, structural engineer
and services engineer. The structural grid selected
must be compatible with othergrids, such as services

layouts for air handling, power, lighting etc.
By way of a Case Study, a hypothetical but

representative building is considered in this Section
69
Discuss me ...
in order to draw out the importantstructure-service

INTERFACES
interactions for a range of structural systems that may
be employed. The building is illustrated in Figures
27 and 28.
a*U
Figure 27 Illustration of the typical officebuilding used in this study
The building inthis Case Study has the following

features:
Single 15 mbeam span between facades.The
floor space can be divided by a central column
to give spans comparable short span systems.
Columns are spaced at 6 m centres along the
facade.
Length of 60 m long with a central core and
vertical service zone, and two smaller stairways
70
Discuss me ...
with vertical service zones at each end of the

building.
Height of 6 storeys, with a central plant room on
the roof.
A floor-floor depth of 4.25 m, and a floor-ceiling
depth of 3 m. A 150 mm deep raised access
floor is also provided. In some cases, a slightly
deeper floor-floor depth is required (and this
depth is noted in reviewing the particular
structural system).
A typical cross-section through the floor zone is

shown in Figure 29.
i -
130
Figure 29 Vertical section through a typical floor
In order to determine themember sizes, the floor

loading was assumed to be 5 kN/m2 (imposed load
and partitions) and 1 kN/m2 (finishes), which i s
typical for modern commercial buildings. The
primary beams are designed to span the longer
distance, and the secondary beams span 6 m.
This Case Study building may be considered

representative for other configurations, for example

the atrium-shape building shown in Figure 30. In
this building, the linear form is repeated around the
atrium (refer later to Figure B 1 0 in Appendix B).
71
Discuss me ...
INTERFACES
x-
Alternative
corner
plan
> Atrium
>
3
Figure 30 Structuralarrangement for a typicalatrium building
7.2 Services Considerations

A typical specification for the services performance
appropriate to an office building was used as a basis
for the design of the services, as follows:
The building is located in Greater London.

The external windows are sealed fornoise and
pollution control.
No external shading of the windows i s provided
and the glazing typeused is clear double glazed
units.
The external walls are of a medium weight
curtain walling construction of a U-value of
0.3 W/m2 "C.
The office space is generally open plan but has

the facility to be cellularised intosmaller
individual offices.
Full access raised floor and suspended ceilings
72
Discuss me ...
are to be installed. The depth of the raised floor

is 150 mm for power, telecommunication and
computer cable trays.
The ceiling grid is 1500 mm square to match the
planning gridand to relate to the structural
module.
The floor to ceiling height is 3 m.
Windows occur all around the building
perimeter. The height is 1500 mm and the
window sill level is 1000 mm above the raised
floor level.
The major services plant is located at roof.
The building operating times are 8.00am to
6.00pm.
The office population density is 1 person for
every 1 o m2 of floorarea.
The building design temperatures are:
Internal External
Winter 20°C
-3°C bulb
dry
-3°C wet bulb
Summer 20°C
28°C bulb
dry
20°C wet bulb
The acoustic criteria for the office space is

NR 40.
The building internal heat gains are:
Specification Specification for

in this study: Urban Offices:
Lights 1 5 W/m2 12 W/m2

Equipment 45 Wfm2 15 to 25 Wfm2
People 10 W/m2 1 0 WJm2
___
Total internal
heat
gains: 70 W/m2 4 7 W/m2
Recent research indicates that it is possible to

reduce internal heat gains by 3 0 to 45%.
However, the specification of 70 W/& is typical
of many modern offices and is used in this
study. Lower heat gains may well lead to more
effective use of chilled ceilingdbeams, and
mixed-mode ventilation systems.
Only comfort coolingis provided to the
occupied space. Since people can tolerate
changes in relative humidity between 20 and

60% without great discomfort, the provision ofa
humidifier inthe system is omitted in most
commercial office applications. Hence, year
73
Discuss me ...
round temperature control without humidity

INTERFACES control is provided. The implication of adopting
a full air-conditioning system is to introduce
further plant equipment, requiring larger plant
rooms and further space within the overall
building volumefor ducts and/or pipework.
The building is designed with a sprinkler fire
protection. An automatic fire detection system
is also installed throughout the building.
Lifts are required for passenger transport andfor
fire fighting.
Fire "means of escape" assumptions:
(a) In assessing the population density per unit
floor area, it is assumed that the nett floor
area is 80% of the gross area, with the
remaining 20% for lift/stairs/ toilets/plant.
(b) Buildings of three storeys or more require
at least two means of escape for fire
evacuation.
(c) The numbers of stairs required for means of

escape is based on a direct distance to any
protected stairway not exceeding 30 m
radius. A total travel distance of 45 m is
allowed once the internal layout is known.
(d) A fire fighting lift is required in all the
examples. Each lift requires a plan area of
approximately 2.5 m x 2.2 m. Fire fighting
shafts are required for each 900 r d of floor
area. Stairs in fire fighting shafts should be
a minimum of 1100 mm width. Staircases
may be pressurized, but this requires an
additional vertical riser to provide this
pressurisation.
7.3 Structural Considerations

The structural framing configuration comprises
primary beams spanning 15 m spaced at 6 m centres,
and supporting secondary beams at 3 m centres. A
composite slab with lightweight concrete acting
compositely with the primary and secondary
members is adopted in all the composite beam
designs. Structural designs have been made for the
long span structural systems described in Section 6.
These designs follow the principles ofEurocode 4(*),

and are based on published design m e t h ~ d s " ~
All designs are based on the use of S355 steel and

C25/30 concrete. Welded shear connectors are used
74
Discuss me ...
in all thesteel designs, except for the slim floor or

Slimdek schemes. All the steel members are fire
protected, except for the slim floor or Slimdek
schemes which have protection only to the bottom
plate or flange.
Table 8, and the figures contained in Section 7.5,

summarise the designs for the building form defined
in Section 7.1. When considering the tabular
information, a number of factors should be borne in
mind. First the lightest structural frame may not be
the most economic if the associated fabrication costs
are high. Design complexity or novelty may be a
disadvantage for some structural systems.
Although a 15 m x 6 m grid has been assumed for

design of each structural system, this is not
necessarily the optimum for all systems. In
particular, the stub girder and parallel beam systems
would benefit by increasing the spacing between
primary beams, thus exploiting continuity in the
secondary members. In the case of haunched
beams, floor beam weights are reduced at the

expense of increased column weights, and this is
reflected in the overall weight of the system.
Alternative forms of the cellular beam, stub girder,

and composite truss systems were also evaluated in
order to assess beam layouts and section types. The
stub girder (Type 2) uses deeper openings than the
alternative form (Type 1).
For comparison, the design of the same building

form has also been carried out using a 7.5 m x 6 m
column grid. This requires the use of internal
columns and shorter span beams. Standard
composite beams and slim floor or Slimdek
constructions were included in these assessments. In
this simple building form, the parallel beam system is
considered only in its shorter span configuration in
order to develop continuity in both directions.
Table 9 summarises the steel weights obtained from

these designs including also the weight of the
columns, but excluding vertical bracing, trimming
members and wind posts etc. A complexity factor is
introduced to take nominal account of the extra
fabrication and fire protection costs involved in the
systems relative to the compositebeam scheme.
Table 10 summarises the number and size of

openings provided by thevarious structural schemes

considered in this publication. For a given
arrangement of services, a 'tailored' structural
solution could reduce the floor zone slightly, or
75
Discuss me ...
permit improvements in structural efficiency.

INTERFACES However, this would be at the expense of flexibility
of service routing and requirement for future re-
servicing. The opening sizes stated are gross sizes.
The available space for services may be reduced by
fire protection to the structural members, and the
insulation around the service ducts.
Table 9 Summary of steel weights for the long span and medium span
structural systems
Weight of steel (expressed as kglm' floor area)
Structural System Primary

Including
Total,
Beams Secondary including
Complexity
Columns
Beams Factor'
15 m span beams
Beam with Web Openings 26 36 47 49
Cellular Beam as Primary Beam 23 33 44 46
Cellular Beam as Secondary Beam 9 33 44 46
Haunched Beam 16 26 44 48
Tapered Beam 22 32 43 46
Composite Truss (SHSl2 23 33 44 48
Composite Truss (T and L)2 26 36 47 52
Stub Girder (Type 1 ) 23 37 48 51
Stub Girder (TvDe 2) 30 40 51 54
7.5 m span beams
System
Parallel Beam 39 13
37 24
Composite Beam 35 35 9 22
Slim Floor with
Deck3
Deep 28 23 41 43
40 40 Slimdek3 27 22
Note: 1. The complexity factor is a multiple on the weight of the beams reflecting
the increased fabrication and fireprotection cost in some forms of
construction.
2. Alternative truss configurationsusing hollow sections (SHS) orT and L
members.
3. Reduced costs of fire protection in the slim floor and Slimdek schemes are
considered later.
76
Discuss me ...
Table 10 Summary of gross opening sizes for long span structural

systems considered in this study
Opening
Gross
Structural
Size
Beam
Floor
Option Size
Depth (15 m span) xOpening
Width
(mm) Area t
Composite
Beam with 1200 686 x 254116 152 3 Q450 x 1100 11
or OpeningsStiffened
686 x 254 U B 1703 G3485 x 1000
Cellular Beamas 1300 835 x 229 cutfrom 550 dia Q 750 ctrs 30
Primary Beam 610 x 229UB 140 ( = 18 openings)
Cellular Beam
as 11 50 457 x 152 x 30T 400 dia Q 600 ctrs 23
Secondary
Beam + 533 x 210 x 41T ( = 23 openings)
_._______ ~-
Haunched Beam 1250

457 x 191UB 82 1 Q 310 x 12500 29
Tapered
Beam 1300 750 max.
deep 2 Q 450 to 200 x 23
5000
Truss - Type 1 (SHS) 1350 870 overall
depth 1 550 x 1500 17
+ 8 Q 300 dia
Truss -Type 2 (T and L) 1350 870 overall
depth + 2oo x loo0 or 15
or 4 Q 400 dia
Stub Girder - Type 1 1200 305 x 305 UC 1 1 8 10 Q 400 x 750 22
plus406 x 140UB39
stubs
Stub Girder - Type 2 1350 254 x 254UC89 1 Q 600 x 1200 31
(deeper openings) plus 610 x 2 Q 600 x 1000
229UB101 stubs 2 @ 600 x 750
Parallel
BeamSystem 1 100 305 x 165UB46 2 Q 300 x 7200 32
span)
(7.5 m + 254 x 146UB31 cross-over to
250 x 5700
Composite
Beam 1200 406 x 178UB54 2 x 310 x 7200 35
(7.5 m span)
Floor/S/imdek
Slim 1000 254 x 254UC89 2 x 350 x 7200 52
span)
(7.5 m + 450 x 15 plate
or 280 AS6 136
t expressed as percentage of beam span x floor to ceiling zone (less raised floor and
lighting)
7.4 Structural Beam Details and Building

Framing Plans
The elevations of the various beam designs
considered in this report are shown in Figures 31 to
38, together with the framing plans for the building
shape considered. For comparison, alternative 7.5 m
span designs are presented in Figures 39 and 40.
The 7.5 m span composite beam scheme is not
illustrated, as it is conventional technology.
The elevations show the dimensions for the beams

based on the design criteria stated earlier. Some of
the beams could have been shallower, but the need
77
Discuss me ...
to provide sensible openings for services has led to

INTERFACES the dimensions as shown. The figures show the
details of the form of construction foreach structural
system. Also given is the equivalent weight of each
primary beam and the weight of each secondary
beam expressed in kg of steel per m2 plan area.
Heavier edge beams may be required to support the
cladding. Shear connectors are not shown in
Figures 31 to 38, but are required in all the
composite schemes.
254x1 02x25 UB
Notes: 485 deep, openinqs : 6 8 6 x 2 5 4 ~ 1 7 0UB, + stiffeners

Beamwelght = 650 kg = 29.4 kglm
4 5 0 deep, openin S . 6 8 6 x 2 5 4 ~ 1 5 2UB + stiffeners
Beam welght = 9 3 8 0 k 8 = 26.4kg/m2
Secondary beams = IO. kg/mz
Figure 31 Structural design of composite beam with web openings
r -2 5 4 ~ 1 0 2 ~ 3UB
1 /-
2 5 4 x 1 0 2 ~ 2 5UB
/-
130 composite slab
l-- ll l C 1
I ! l!
\i-500mm diameter holes ' L C e l l u l a r beam fabricated from

75
a0tm
c emn 0
t6
rxe12s2 9 ~ 1U4B0
Beam weight = 2 1 0 0 kg = 2 3 . 3 k g / m 2
Secondary beams = 10.8 kg/m2
Figure 32 Structural design of cellular beam as primary beam
78
Discuss me ...
, 130 composite slab
Lo
(D
(D
4 5 7 x 1 9 1 ~ 6 7U
-4
Beams at 3 m spacing
7 457x1 52x60UB 'T' Weight = 2x1 070 kg per 6m along
the building
Section = 23.7 kglml
through beam
I 5 3 3 x 2 1 0 ~ 8 2UB 'T'
Edge beams = 8.9 kglm'
Figure 33 Alternative structural design of cellular beam as secondary beam

2 5 4 x 1 0 2 ~ 2 5UB 130 composite slab

3000 3000 3000
ImL1
& &
r
7=
3
m
1 1
4 5 7 x 1 9 1 ~ 8 2UB
Haunch cut from 4 5 7 x 1 9 1 ~ 8 2UB
I
r
- 15000 ---A
TI
Additional weight of column not included Beam weight = 1450 kg = 16.1 kg/mz
Secondary beams = 10 kglm'
Figure 34 Structural design of haunched composite beams
2 5 4 x 1 0 2 ~ 3 1UB 2 5 4 x 1 0 2 ~ 2 5UB 1 3 0 composite slab

/ / /
3 0 0300 0 0 3000 3000
<
\J
7. >< .L
F.
1500
4-
4-4 r l l
h
t-L7
In
PI
m -
PI k
Tapered beam (fabricated from plate) ----$--
Flanges - 2 5 0 wide x 25 thick
-
Web 9 mm thick
15000
L- - _ _ ~ _ _ _ . _ _ 4
Weight = 2015 kg =22.3 kglm2

Secondary beams = 1 0 k g / m z
Figure 35 Structural design of tapered beam
79
Discuss me ...
INTERFACES ~
I
3000 =i: ,/3000
2 5 4 x 1 0 2 ~ 2 5UB
~ -/ 130 composite slab
3000 ~ ~~ 3000/=+
3000
150x1
14
50x8
,00
SHS top chord
~___
dia. rnax
~
/
'
l
l
I
300 dia. m a d
1000x200 max
100x1
00x6.3 SHS
(Typical verticals)
/ Vierendeel /
1500~570(approx.)
15000
1 1 20x1
20x8
\l 50x1 50x16SHS bottom 'chord
SHS
(Typical diagonals)
1 - ,
Alternative T and Angle sections:
Truss weight S.H.S.sections = 2100
kg = 23.3 kglrn'
Top chord = 305x152x49
kg/m T Secondary
beams = 1 0 kglm'
Bottom Chord = 305x1 52x69 kg/mT
Diagonals = 2 No 120x120x1 2kglmAngle
Truss weight = 2325 kg = 25.8 kglm'
Figure 36 Structural design of composite truss using hollow sections

Requires propping during construction Beam weight = 2060 kg = 22.9 kglm'

Secondary beams = 13.7 kglm'
Figure 37 Structural design of stub girder (Type 7)
1 2 25x21x 2 4 T 2 5 40x21xU
02xB
52 2 9 ~ 1U
0B1 stubs
15 000
- _ _ _ - . _ ~ ~ ~ _ . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ . ~
4
Beam weight = 2700 k g = 30 kglm'
Secondary beams = 10 kg/m*
Figure 38 Structural design of stub girder (Type 2)

80
Discuss me ...
I I
2 5 4 x 1 4 6 ~ 3 1UB 1 ip'-
''r 305x1beam
spine 65x46 UB
'
rib beams at 3m spacing
15000
4
Based on 7.5117x 6 m grid Total weight = 2200 kg = 24.4 kglm'
but may be adapted to longer (including column brackets)
wans in both directions
Figure 39 Structural design of parallel beam system

(7.5 m span in this application)
290 mm slab 2 5 4 x 1 0 2 ~ 2 5UB

Tee 1 5 2 x 8 0 ~ 1 9UB 'T'
embedded in slab
.
2 5 4 x 2 5 4 ~ 8 9kglm UC wit
15mm x 450mm flange plate
L
1-
15000
Based on 7.5m x 6m grid Beam weight = 2090 kg = 23.2 kglm'

Secondary beams (and tie) = 4.6kg/mz
Figure 40 Structural design of slim floor beam and deep composite decking
Note to Figure 40: The Slimdek scheme is of the same form but the
beam is a rolled asymmetric 280 ASB 136 section (136 kg/m) which
does not require a welded plate.
81
INTERFACES
a2
Discuss me ...
8 CASE STUDY:
SERVICE
DISTRIBUTION
This Section reviews the servicedistribution for the

various structural systems described in Section 6, for
the building form in theCase Study described in
Section 7.
To meet building and fireregulations, a building of

this shape would require three vertical service
zones. It is considered that escape stairways would
be placed at each end of the building, and that a
core area for lifts and toilets would be provided in
the centre. Thus, these vertical riser positions dictate
where the vertical services distribution can be

economically located.
Natural cross-flow ventilation in a long thin building

is feasible, but it imposes limitations on the use of
83
Discuss me ...
internal partitions. Internal offices, for example,

INTERFACES would require mechanical ventilation. It has
therefore been assumed that the windows are sealed
and mechanical ventilation is provided throughout
the whole floor area. Good daylight penetration is
achieved with this building shape leaving only a
central 7 m wide strip cequiring permanent artificial
lighting. The simple shape of the building allows
maximum use of linear air diffusers along the
perimeter of the building.
It is considered that the major vertical services would

be located in the central core in order to facilitate the
use of a single plant room. Therefore, both outlet
and inlet ducts or pipes would emanate from this
area and would have to be designed to pass through
or under the long span beam systems.
This simple buildingshape would be ideally suited

to any of the structural forms used for long span
buildings. A complete range of long span structural
and service designs has therefore been studied for
this building and the solutions are presented in

Figures B1 to B 7 (Appendix B). Application of the
scheme in Figure B1 to an alternative building form
is shown in Figure B10.
The Variable Air Volume (VAV) air-conditioning

system reviewed in Section 4.3 occupies the greater
volume within the floor-ceiling zoneand therefore is
more problematical in terms of the structure-service
integration. Nevertheless, the Fan Coil system is also
considered, for comparison, in one case (see Figure
82). Additionally, the service distribution for the
short (7.5 m) span composite beam, and slim floor
systems are also considered in Figures B8 and B9.
The service arrangements are shown in the following

sequence in Appendix B. All are Variable Air
Volume (VAV) systems, except where noted. These
figures are:
B1 Uniformdepthcomposite beam with web
openings
B2 Uniform depth composite beam with web
openings - Fan Coi I system
B3 Cellular beam as primary beam
B4 Haunched beam
B5 Tapered beam
B6 Composite truss using SHS
B7 Stub girder (Type 2)

B8 Composite beam (7.5 m x 6 mgrid)
B9 Slim floor with deep composite decking
B10 Application to alternative building form
84
Discuss me ...
9 CASE STUDY:
COST
IMPLICATIONS OF
STRUCTURAL
SYSTEMS
9.1 General Aspects

The choice of structural system is obviously
influenced by thecost of materials and construction.
Any broad economic assessment should take into
account the whole cost of the building which-should

include the:
Structure andfloors
Cladding
85
Discuss me ...
Services distribution
INTERFACES
Foundations
Finishes
Speed ofconstruction
Other aspects such as increased lettable area, and

flexibility in use of internal column-free space
represent value to the client, butare not considered
in this Study.
Clearly, the absolute level of costs of construction is

strongly influenced by global and local economic
factors. Since early 1990, prices for all construction
materials have fallen significantly reaching a low
point at late 1992 and then rising graduallysince
then. Therefore, it is important to address the cost
differences in relative, rather than absolute terms in
order to providegeneric guidance on the economy
of different forms of construction.
The form of the buildingconsidered in this

publication is also simplified. It may be expected

that structure costs, in particular, are lower than
those of recently constructed buildings which may
have variations on shape and often have substantial
basements, or temporary works during construction.
The following sections describe how the cost

differences among thevarious structural systems
have been determined. All the systems are assessed
on the basis of prices of tendered projects in the UK
(mid 1995).
Cost estimates have only been made for the building

considered in this publication, but it may be
expected that the general conclusions are relevant to
the other building forms. The costs are comparable
to those presented in SCI Publication 1 3Y2’).
9.2 Structure Cost

The structural costs of the various systems comprise
common and variable items. For example, common
to all long span steel systems i s the use of composite
slabs. Variable items are the:
Weightof steelused
Complexity of the steel fabrication
Fire protection costs
The basic cost of fabricated steel used in beams and

columns i s taken as f 850honne (l 190 ecushonne)
for grade S 235 or S 275 steel, and €900/tonne
86
Discuss me ...
(1260 ecus/tonne) for grade S 355 steel. This rate

includes delivery and erection, but excludes
corrosion or fire protection costs. These rates will
increase with increasing irregularity of the structural
form. In Table 9, the additional fabrication cost in
some structural systems is reflected in a complexity
factor applied to the basic weight of steel in each
scheme.
The weight of the vertical bracingand other

secondary steelwork is taken as equivalent to
4 kg/m2 floor area. This is costed at f5/m2
(7 ecus/m2) in all the steel schemes due to thegreater
fabrication effort required for the bracingelements.
Shear connectors are placed at one every 150 mm
along the primarybeams, and are costed at f3/m2
(4 ecus/m2) floor area in all the composite schemes
(excluding slim floorand Slimdek).
Similarly, fire protection costs may be evaluated by

taking account of the size of the steel beam and
column sections to be protected. In this case, fire
protection is assumed to be vermiculitespray of a

thickness (20 to 25 mm) suitable for 90 minutes fire
protection. Typically, fire protection costs are
approximately 20% of the cost of the fabricated
steelwork, and are taken as a global figure of f9/m2
(1 3 ecus/m2) floor area for all the composite
schemes, reducing to f4/m2(6 ecus/m2) for the slim
floor and Slimdek schemes. The complexity factor in
Table 9 also takes into account the reduced or
increased complexity of fire protection, as required
for each system.
The cost of the composite slabs, lightweight

concrete, steel decking and reinforcement is taken as
a common figure of f25/m2(35 ecus/m2) floor area
for all the composite structural systems. For
comparison, cost estimates are also made of slim
floor and reinforced concrete designs based on a
7.5 m x 6 m grid. The longer spanning deep deck
composite slab is costed at €38/m2 (53 ecus/m2). The
reinforced concrete design is based on a 300 mm
deep flat slab with 600 mm square internal columns.
It is costed at f 80/d (1 12 ecus/m2), as obtained from
typical cost data-bases in the UK22). A further f8/m2
(1 1ecus/m2) is allowed for the shear walls and cores
etc., in this concrete scheme.
Various other common structural items, such as

cladding supports, plant room, roof, stairs, lift

supports etc., are taken as f 2 4 / d (34 ecus/m2) for a / /
schemes, as obtained from other studied2'). The total
87
Discuss me ...
structural cost is therefore in the range of f 9 8 to

INTERFACES 11 5/m2 floor area.
9.3 Cladding Costs

Cladding costs are assumed to vary in proportion to
building height, which is itself dependent on the
depth of the floor zone. In these estimates it is
assumed that the building is clad in brickwork with
double glazed windows. The brickwork is assumed
to have various complex features and is costed at a
rate of f 200/m2 (280 ecus/m2) wal I area.
The cost of modern buildingfacades may vary

between f 100 and 500/m2, depending on the
materials used and, therefore, the influence of
cladding cost may be estimated proportionately. The
variable cost of the claddingis due to the difference
in the depth of the structural system, and hence floor
zone, that is used. The cost of.the cladding is
presented as relative to the floorarea, which is
therefore dependent on theshape of the building.
9.4 Services Distribution

A major study was carried out of the influence of the
various structural options on thecost of service
distribution, using the designcriteria given in
Section 7.3. Both VAV and Fan Coil systems were
costed.
The cost estimates included the followingcommon

and variable items in a typical air-conditioning
system, as follows:
Common Items
Centralplantmachineryandcontrols
Vertical
ducts
Outletair diffusers
Variable Items
Rectangularairducts
Circularair ducts
VAVor Fan CoilUnits
Perimeter
heating
Volumecontrol dampers
In both air-conditioningsystems, VAV and Fan Coil,

it is assumed that the VAV or Fan Coil Units are
80
Discuss me ...
positioned one every 36 m2floor area internally, and

one every 27 m2 around theedges of the building.
The main cost differences arise from the method of

air distribution, circular ducts being generally more
efficient and cheaper than rectangular ducts. The
length, and number of ducts is also influenced by the
choice ofstructural system.
The costs of the VAVand Fan Coil systems for this

Case Study building are presented in Table 1 1 . The
cost differences are only significant for the VAV
system and, therefore, this system is used as a basis
for comparison among the structural systems. Fan
Coil systems are slightly cheaper (by 2 to 5%) but are
not so widely used for this type of building.
The total cost of the air-conditioning system for the

building inthis study is estimated as approximately
f 178/m2 (249 ecus/m2) floor area, and comprises
three main parts as follows:
Air
ducting f 77/m2 (108 ecus/m2)
Perimeter heating f 1O/m2 (1 4 ecus/m2)

Central plant f 88/m2 (1 23 ecus/m2)
(averaged over the
total floor area)
These costs depend on the particular building

configuration and services specification, and may
vary significantly in other projects. However they
have been used to illustrate the principalfactors that
influence the service costs in this Case Study.
Table 11 Costs of VAV and Fan Coil Systems for the Case Study building
expressed as €/m2 floor area (E 7 = 1.40 ecus)
(a) Cost of VAV Air-conditioning System
Structural System Ductwork Insulation Volume VAV Perimeter Total

~.
- to Ducts Control Boxes Heating Cost
Circular Rectangular/ Dampers ffm*
Other
Beam with Web Openings 12.5 13.1 3.2 11.0 33.3 10.0 83.1
Cellular Beam 3.2
15.8 8.0 11.1 33.3 10.0 81.4
Haunched Beam
10.0 33.3 11.0
Beam
Parallel
2.8
1 14.5 11.2 82.8
Tapered Beam 12.8 17.610.8 3.5 33.3 10.0 88.0

Composite Truss 14.6 10.9 3.1 11.3 33.3 10.0 83.2
Stub Girder 12.6 13.5
11.0 3.1 33.3 10.0 83.5
Composite Beam (7.5 m span) 12.3 17.9 3.1 10.9 33.3 10.0 87.5
Additional cost of central plant apportioned over this floor area = f88/m2
89
Discuss me ...
Table 11 continued
INTERFACES (b) Cost of Fan Coil Air-conditioning System
Structural System Ductwork Insulation Volume Fan Coil Pipe Total
to Ducts Control Units Work Cost
Circular Rectangular/ Dampers Elm2
Other
Beam with WebOpenings 14.1 10.9
4.1 9.5 25.5 36.9 101.0
Cellular Beam 17.4 8.3
4.3 9.3 25.5 36.9 101.7
Haunched Beam
Parallel Beam l 13.3 12.3 9.6 4.1 101.7
36.9
25.5
BeamTapered 103.0 36.9 15.4 25.5 11.0

4.5 9.7
101.7 36.9 25.5 Composite
3.9 Truss
9.5 9.6 16.3
Stub Girder 102.2 8.436.9 17.0
25.5 4.8 9.6
Composite
span)m (7.5
Beam
102.7
36.925.54.0 9.611.3
15.4
Additional cost of central plant apportioned over this floor area - f66/m2
Notes: Costs in Table 11 are appropriate to the UK in 1995.
The approximate variation in cost of the service

distribution, as influenced by the choice of the
structural system, may be summarised as in
Table 12. These variations are.rounded in terms of
percentages relative to thecost of services in a
standard composite beam system.
In comparison, it may be assumed that systems

offering a flat or ribbed floor, such as slim floors,
provide complete flexibility ofservice distribution
and, therefore, are similar in service cost to the best
of the long span systems.
Table 12 Structural system Variation in Total Cost of

Variable cost of Services
service distribution due Percentage Elm2 ecus/m2
tostructural system Cellular Beam
-3.5% -f 6 (8)
Parallel Beam System -2.5% -f 5 ( 7)
Haunched Beam -2.5 "lo -f 5 ( 7)
Stub Girder -2.0% -f 4 (5)
Composite Truss -2.0% -f 4 (5)
Beam with Web Openings -2.0% -f 4 (5)
Tapered Beam 0 0 0
Beam with Services Below 0 0 0
These percentage variations are approximate and arranged in
decreasing order of cost saving.
9.5 Foundation Costs

The foundation costs depend on the number and
size of the foundationsand, therefore, on the vertical

load to be resisted. These costs are likely to be
similar for all the long span structural systems
examined in this study.
90
Discuss me ...
In comparison, the systems based on a 7.5 m x 6 m

grid require more foundations, although they are
smaller in size. A parallel study by the SCP) has
shown that the overall foundation costs of the long
span systems are approximately 10% lower than
those of the short span systems. In this Case Study,
foundation costs are assumed to be approximately
3% of the total building cost, although these costs
may increase considerably in inner city sites.
The concrete scheme is heavier than the steel

schemes and, therefore, requires larger foundations.
It may be assumed that foundation costs are in
proportion to the total load to be supported.
9.6 Speed of Construction

All steel systems have the inherent benefit of speed
of construction. The long span systems may be
assumed to be of similar complexityand may be
slightly faster to construct than the short span
systems due to the smaller number of steel elements

that have to be lifted into place. However, this
benefit is neglected conservatively in this Case
Study.
Comparisons of speed of construction of steel

construction with equivalent reinforced concrete
designs have concluded that overall time savings
may be of the order of6 weeks in a construction
period of 70 weeks for a steel framed building of the
size considered in this publication. Therefore,
time-related savings may be estimated on the basis
of:
Reduced site preliminaries (cost of site
accommodation, equipment and site
management).
Reduced financial cost of borrowing the capital
for the building construction.
Early rental
income.
Site preliminaries are conservatively based on 7.5%

of the project value, although traditionally 12 to 20%
has been the case on large projects. For an assumed
total building cost of f 8 5 0 / d (1 190 ecus/m2), a
reduction of one week in a construction period of 70
weeks corresponds to f0.9/m2(1.3 ecus/m2)
equivalent saving per unit floor area. Furthermore,
the financial cost of borrowing to the client over the

construction period may be estimated using a
representative interest rate of 8% applied to the
payments for the building averaged over the period,
91
Discuss me ...
which is equivalent to f0.7/rd (1 .O ecus/m2) for each

INTERFACES week of the construction. The total potential saving
is therefore at least f 1.6/rd (2.2 ecus/m2) per week
saving in construction time.
9.7 Overal I Cost Estimates

The structure costs can be determined reasonably
accurately using the information presented in
Section 9.2. The results are presented in Table 13,
expressed in terms of cost per square metre of gross
floor area. Also shown for comparison are the best
estimates of the cost of the slim floor(and Slirndek)
and the reinforced concrete (RC) flat slab schemes.
Alternative cellular beam, stub girder and composite
truss schemes are included for the long span options.
Account is taken of the variable costs, as covered in

Sections 9.2 to 9.6. The true comparison of the cost
of the construction should, therefore, be the sum of
the structure cost and these variable costs.
The standard 7.5 m span composite beam and slab

system is used as the ‘base’ cost, and all the other
systems considered in this study are expressed as
’plus’ or ’minus‘ relative to the base value. These
results are consistent with a recent cost study carried
out by SCI on behalf of British Steef2’).
For this Case Study, it is apparent that the variable

costs can be as significant as the variations in
structure cost among all theschemes, and that the
potential savings in cladding and services cost are as
important. If the service distribution had been more
complex, then the variation in these costs would
have been greater. The long span systems also offer
greater flexibility in internal planning which could
be taken into account i n terms of the rental of the
space.
It is concluded that the cellular beam system is the

cheapest of all the longspan systems and adds a
negligible 0.1 to the overall cost of the bljilding,
relative to the shorter span ‘base’ scheme. The
typical average cost increase of all the longspan
systems is less than 2% relative to the ‘base’ scheme.
The Slirndek and parallel beam systems are the
cheapest overall, but are only considered as a 7.5 m
x 6 m grid. The reinforced concrete scheme is the
most expensive of all theshorter span systems, due

largely to the implications of speed of construction.
92
Discuss me ...
Table 13 Summary of total building costs (relative to the composite beam and slab scheme) in the Case Study
ervices
Integrated
of Element Integrated Services
Parallel
Composite
Cellular
Haunched
Tapered
Stub
Composite
Construction
Composite
Floor
Reinforced
Slim
and
BeamandDeepDeck or ConcreteBeam
Flat Beam Beam with Beam Beam Girder Truss
Slab Slirndek Slab System
Web Openings
Foundations 20 0 +5 0 -1 -1 -1 -1 -1 -1
Structure, roof, stairs 98 ++9l /4+ 1 2 +l3 +4 + 10 l 2 +14/+17 + 10
+ +12/+15
Cladding -7 140 -7 -3 0 -2/+ 3 +2 +3 0/+ 5 +5
-5
Services
Mechanical -6
178 -6 -6 -4 -5 - -41-6 -4
CommonOther 350 approx - - - - - - - - -
costs
liminaries Site 64 0 +5 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
TOTAL COST (flm' -41-1
850 +l1 -4 +8 +11+6 +8 +l2 +g/+ 15 + 12/+15
floor area)
Cost Financing 46 - +4 ~ - - - - - - -
VARIATION Base -0.41-0.1 '10 + 1.7% 1 -0.4% +0.9%
+0.1/+0.7% + 0.9% + 1.3% + 1.O/+ 1.7% +1.7%
1.3/+
Note: Costs are given as +/- relative to the 'base' 7.5 m composite beam and slab scheme.
Alternative cellular beam, stub girder and truss schemes are costed.
The costs in this table have been derived for the Case Study in this publication. Absolute costs may vary considerably for other building forms and specifications. However, the
cost variations are typicalof other SCI cost studies. The building cost increase in the UK from mid-l 995 to late 1997 is approximately 8%
INTERFACES
94
Discuss me ...
10 CONCLUSIONS
The integration of building services in the

floor-ceiling zone of modern commercial buildingsis
addressed by first considering the differenttypes of
air-conditioning and comfort cooling systems, and
then reviewing the various structural systems that
may be used. The use of steel and composite
construction is often associated with longer spans in
which greater flexibility of internal planningis
provided. Many long span structural systems have
been developed in recent years which provide for
various degrees of service integration. Conversely,
the slim floorand other forms of shallow floor
construction have been developed to achieve a
medium span solution in which services are mainly
located beneath the floor.
This publication reviews the benefits of long span

beams utilising the principles of composite

construction, which offer the facility for integration
of structure and services within the same horizontal
zone. Each of the structural systems has been fully
95
Discuss me ...
designed for a 15 m span and compared to

INTERFACES equivalent designs for a more traditional 7.5 m span.
The building adopted in this Case Study was typical
of modern commercial buildings of2000 to 5000 m2
floor area.
Service distribution drawings for the building of this

Case Study have been provided in order to examine
the differences among all the systems. It was found
that horizontal air conditioningducts could be
readily incorporated but thatin some systems smaller
sized ducts had to be used, or alternatively theducts
routed differently. In some cases, the depth of the
beams or floor zone had to beincreased to
accommodate these ducts.
An economic comparisonwas made among all the

systems on the basis of structure cost and variable
costs which included the extracost of cladding and
service distribution, etc. It was found that the
additional structural cost of long span beams with
facility for service integration was typically 10 to
15% in comparison to theshorter span systems.
However, this increase represents only 0.1 to 1.7%

in terms of the total buildingcost, when all the
relevant cost savings are included. These variable
costs include foundations, cladding, mechanical
services and site preliminaries. Advantages not
considered in this Study were the increased lettable
area and freedom of use of the internal column-free
space.
The most economic long span system was the

cellular beam scheme, which was equivalent in cost
to the shorter span composite scheme when other
variable costs were included. The recent Slirndek
and parallel beam systems were the cheapest overall,
but they were designed only for ashorter span
application. The slim floor and Slirndek systems
have the minimum ceiling and floorzone.
Some systems were more economic for certainspans

and plan configurations than others. All the systems
had some advantages and should be considered to
be of broadly equal merit. The Case Study
concludes that the additional costs of long span
systems are negligible when consideringcosts and
value in a more holistic manner.
96
Discuss me ...
1 l REFERENCES
1. Specificationfor urban offices

British Council for Offices, July 1994
2. BRITISH STANDARDS INSTITUTION

Eurocode 4: Part 1 .l : Design of composite steel
and concrete structures
ENV 1994-1-1, 1993
3. CHIEN, E.V.L and RITCHIE, K.

Design and construction of composite floor
systems
Canadian Institute of Steel Construction, 1984
4. LAWSON, R.M.
Design of composite slabs and beams with steel
decking
The Steel Construction Institute, 1989
5. Charter Institute of Building Services

CIBSE Design Guide, Volumes A, B and C
(1 986)
97
Discuss me ...
6. JONES, W.P.
INTERFACES Air-conditioning engineering, Third Edition
1985
7. AMATO, A., OGDEN, R. and PLANK, R.

Environmental floor systems
8. A J guide to space for services (Reprint from

Architects Journal, 12.2.86, 19.2.86, 26.2.86,
5.3.86, 12.3.86, 19.3.86 and 26.3.86)
9. MULLETT, D.L.
Slim floor design and construction
10. LAWSON, R.M. and MULLETT, D.L.

Slim floor construction using deep decking
11. LAWSON, R.M., MULLETT, D.L. and

RACKHAM, J.W.
Design of asymmetric slimflor beams using
deep composite decking

12. MULLETT, D.L.

Design of RHS slimflor edge beams
13. LAWSON, R.M.

Design for openings in the webs of composite
beams
Construction Industry Research and Information
Association (CIRIA) and
14. WARD, J.K.

Design of composite and non-composite
cellular beams
15. LAWSON, R.M. and RACKHAM, J.W.

Design of haunched composite beams in
buildings
The Steel Construction institute, 1989
16. OWENS, G.W.

Design of fabricated composite beams in
buildings
17. NEAL, S. and JOHNSON, R.

Design of composite trusses
98
Discuss me ...
18. LAWSON, R.M. and McCONNEL, R.

Design of stub girders
19. BRETT, P. and RUSHTON, J.

Parallel beam approach - A design guide
20. BRETT, P.R., NETHERCOT, D.A. and

OWENS, G.W.
Continuous construction in steel for roofs and
composite floors, and Discussion
The Structural Engineer, 1987 and 1988
21. LAWSON, R.M.

Comparative structure costs of modern
commercial building
22. Spon’s architects‘ and builders’ price book

E & FN Spon, 1996
Bibliography
PARSLOE, C.
Design for maintainability
The Building Services Research and Information
Association, 1992.
HAJEB, M. and PARSLOE, C.

Space allowances for building services distribution
systems
The Building Services Research and Information
Association, 1992.
Energy and environment in non-domestic buildings

A Technical Design guide by Cambridge
Architectural Research Limited for the RIBA.
Space and weight allowances forbuilding services

Plant - Inception Design Stage - TN9/92
The Building Services Research & Information
Association, 1992.
Small Power Loads - TN 8/92

Association, 1992.
Over engineering in buildingservices - TR21/95

Association, 1992.
99
Discuss me ...
Indications of sustainable development for the

INTERFACES United Kingdom
Department of Environment, 1996.
JONES, W.P.
Air conditioning applications anddesign, 1980
Fundamentals and HVAC systems and applications

ASHRAE Handbooks.
l00
APPENDIXA:
101
SUGGESTEDBESTPRACTICE
CRITERIA F O R BUILDING DESIGN
Discuss me ...
APPENDIXA:SUGGESTED BESTPRACTICE
CRITERIA FOR BUILDING DESIGN
This information is taken from the report by The British Council for Offices"), and
concerns their suggested criteria for economic design of modern offices. It is
paraphrased, where appropriate.
General Criteria
The general criteria regarding the building design and use are as follows:
External environment Local noise and air pollution may

dictate use of sealed external facades.
If so, mechanical ventilation and/or
cooling of the internal space w i l l be
necessary.
Building
orientation Where possible, consider orientating
the building to admituseful daylight,
while reducing glare and solar heat
gain.
External solar shading Shading reduces solar heat gain and

glare. It should be installed where it
can be beneficial.
Occupational
density A density of one person per 14m2 net
floor area gives acceptable utilization of
space. This may be reduced to one per
1Om2 in circumstances where the
working environment is not adversely
affected.
Lighting and small power loads Make a realistic assessment of the heat
gain within an office space. Set realistic
power levels required for equipment.
Comfort
conditions Determine the expectations of
occupants within the office space. If
wider bands of tolerance can be set for
temperature ranges within this space, it
provides an opportunity to consider
ventilation systems with reduced
cooling capacity, or to avoid the need
for additional cooling.
Partitioning The need to provide substantial

flexibility in partition positions has an
important effect on the environmental
control system that i s employed.
103
Discuss me ...
Air Conditioning Systems
Many air conditioning systems are available, each of which has particular
performance characteristics, and are therefore suitable for installation in differing
locations and building forms.
1. The different air conditioning

systems that are generally used in
offices and similar buildings are:
Variable Air Volume (VAV)
Fan Coil Systems
Displacement ventilation
Chilled ceilingbeams
2. Energy consumption and life cycle The system should be designed to take
cost of the system. maximum advantage of natural or low
cost energy sources. This should
include ‘free cooling’ principles.
3. The system should be designed for Occupants should be able to run their
air-conditioning systems in a simple but
separate operation of floors and

part-floors. effective manner regardless of other
occupants.
4. Consideration should be given to Consider access and removal of grilles

ease of maintenance. to ducts.
5. The system should be adaptable to Consider adaptability issues in the

meet occupiers’ future initial design of the structure.
requirements
Fresh Air
Best practice: Notes:
In general office areas, a rate of fresh air The system should be designed as a
supply of between 8-12 litres per non-smoking environment. If occupiers
second per person should be supplied. want to provide smoking areas, the
system should be enhanced to cater for
increased ventilation rates.
Within the total system, provision Cooling or heating excessive quantities

should be made for additional fresh air of fresh air can cause significant
for meeting rooms or other higher consumption of energy. Systems
occupancy uses. should be designed to provide the
minimum supply of minimal fresh air in
line with standards.
104
Discuss me ...
Cooling Load
Suggested cooling loads are as follows:
Small power: 15 W/m2 Cooling loads due to power

consumption by office equipment rarely
exceed 15 W/m2.
Ability to adapt facility to 25 W/& Higher coolingloads may be met by

provision of space for additional
cooling plant, larger risers and
provision of increased electrical power.
Heat gain from lighting: 12 W/& Lighting should be designed to ensure

no more than 12 W/m2 heat gain to the
chilling plant.
Ensure that central plant can operate An allowance of 10 W/m2 for heat gain
efficiently when only part cooling loads from the occupants is applicable for
are applied. offices of general use and occupational
densities.
Horizontal Zoning
Best practice:
Zoning of air-conditioning supply to The size of these zones should be

follow the perimeter and internal zones matched to the selected column grid.
should take account of the likely
partitioning, occupancy, and use of the VAV systems permit use of larger zones.
space. However, excessively large zones limit
local control.
Perimeter: provide one air-conditioning The size of zone should bematched not
terminal unit from not more than 6m of only to the expected spatial planning of
perimeter space, assuming perimeter the user, but also to the choice of
offices depths of between 4.5 and 6m. indoor climate control. Zoning of
mechanical equipment should follow
the 1.5m planning module.
Internal: provide one air-conditioning Internal areas do not attract solar gains
terminal for a maximum size of internal and have more stable conditions, which
zone of 50 to 80m2 floorarea. allows larger service zones to be
accommodated in these areas.
No humidity control is required within Humidity control is rarely needed for

most office applications. general office use.
Allow space for the provision of steam If installed, the humidification system
humidification by the occupier, if should be designed to ensure there is
required. no opportunity for in-duct condensation
or bacterial growth.
105
Discuss me ...
Controls
Theinternaltemperatureshouldbe A wider temperature range maybe

controlled
22°C
+/-2"C.
to accepted in extreme climatic
conditions.
Controls should be designed to operate The system should be capable of

the mechanical system according to the operation on a part-floor basis.
anticipated occupancy.
The central plant control system should Controls should enableoccupants to

be simple tooperate with minor local make limited adjustment via local
control for the occupant. controls to the heatingair conditioning
system.
NATURALLY OR MECHANICAL VENTILATED SYSTEMS
Ventilation, as opposed to air conditioning, does not rely on mechanical cooling to

control the internal temperature closely. Fresh air i s circulated either naturally
through windows or other openings, or mechanically within ducts.
Consider designing thebuilding to The facility toaccommodate a

permit mixed-mode systems, or future mechanical cooling system to cater for

installation of an air conditioning higher heat gains should be considered.
system to whole or part of the building.
Design for good draught-free cross The depth of the office space may have
ventilation. to be limited toobtain sufficient cross
ventilation within the space.
Use dynamic thermal modelling to Consider using the thermal capacity of

predict performance. the structure combined with night-time
purging to cool down thestructure and
provide radiant cooling ('coolth') during
working hours.
Correct building orientation, external

shading, thermal mass and fenestration
can all help to minimiseheat gains
within the officespace.
The internal temperatures in a The ability to providenatural

ventilated building will be more ventilation in a building couldhave a
dependent on the prevailing external limiting effect on the types and
temperatures, leading potentially to a positions of partitions within the office
greater internal temperature range. space.
106
APPENDIX B:
107
DRAWINGS
SERVICE DISTRIBUTION
108
Discuss me ...
Figure B1 Composite beam with rectangular web

openings
Service layout of VAV system
Key to the colours:

Blue = Medium
velocity supply ducts
Purple = velocity
Low supply ducts
Red (lines) = Extract ducts
Red (boxonplan) = Lightfitments
G reen = Terminal units
Black = Building elements
Discuss me ...
-MEDIUM VELOCITY
SUPPLY OUCTWORK
-LOW VELOCITY
SWPLY OUCTWORK
ELECTRICAL
RISERS
STAIRCFlSE
MEA
NOTE
EXTRFlCTPkTH THROUGH LIGHT FITTINGS M D

CEILING VOID INTO STUB EXTRACT OUCTWORK
888x308 EXTRACT 315 DIMETER PERIMETER

SUPPLY DUCT HEAOER
X DUCT 200 DIAMETER
lzB0 OVERALL
SB0x35B SUPPLY D U C T W O R K 1 30Bmm SaUClRE L 5 i X 3 6 x Z 5 0 SUPPLY DUCTWORK

315 DIAMETER P E R I M k T E R l DIFFUSERS
SUPPLY DUCT HEADER 380r50mm ELECTRIC& 300x50mmm ELECTRICAL
TRUNKINC TRUNKIMG
SECTION SHOWING UNIFORM DEPTH 8EAM. (WITH HOLES IN WEB1 SCALE 1~50,
NOTES
OXTWDRK OISTRIBUTIMJ LhYOUT8 GOO0 Projac t
SCI./E.C.S.C, SERVICES STUDY
FUTURE FLEXIBILITY: POOR title SFRVICES I AYOUT FOR;
OVERClLL SERYICES/STRUCTURE DEPTH 12BBmm
1. UNIFORM DEPTH BEAM WITH
CIDDITIOIML COMMENTS: ClCCOMMOMTION OF

HEIXIMW DUCT SIZE DETERMINES BEhM SIZE
AN0 OVERALL DEPTH HENCE ClCCURATE WEB OPENINGS
SERVICES INFORMFlTION REOUIREO AT FIN 2 VAV BOX SYSTEM (all awl
EWLY STAGE 1N THE DESIGN PRDCESS.
3. BUILDING TYPE A
JOB DRAWING REV.
201284
Discuss me ...
Figure B2 Composite beam with rectangular web

openings
Service layout for Fan Coil system
Key to the colours:

Blue = Medium
Purple = Low velocity supply ducts
Red (lines) - Extract ducts
Red (boxon plan) = Lightfitments
Discuss me ...
SLOT DIFFUSERS
WITH MhTCHING
SUPPLY PLENUM
SECTION
1- LCENTRCI CORE WEA
INCLUDING LIFTS TOILETS
LINE SERVICES RISES e-.
m OFFICE PLAN. SCALE h208
EXTRACT PClTH THROUGH LlMT FITTINGS AW

CEILING VOID INTO STUB EXTRClCT DUCTWORK
PIPEWDAK FLOW RN0

-F+EX DUCT
I
1280 OVERPlLL
CWDENSATE HA1 R€DUC€S TO 2&lx200

IWITHIPl ITS OWN r0 FALLS WITHIN ITS
OWN O P E N M
OW AND RETURN
CHILLED WATER PIPEWORK FLOW hMD RETURN.
SECTION SHOWING UNIFORM DEPTH BEAM. (WITH HOLES WITHIN) SCALE 1~50.
RECTANGULClR DUCTWORK USEO: RATIO 2tl
FUTURE FLEXIBILITY8 POOR t 1 - h

OVERALL SERVICES/STFKICTURE DEPTH = l m m m
1. UNIFORM DEPTH BEAM
ClWITIONllL MlHHENTSt HOLES ClRE TAILORED

FOR THE INITICIL SERVICE INSTALLhTIDN WITH WEB OPENINGS
WITH LITTLE SCOPE FOR FURTHER
RE-SERVICING. ClOJUSTING HOLE SI= 2. FAN COIL UNIT SYSTEM (all uaterl
OURING OESlGN DEYELWHENT M Y M)T
BE POSSISLE. 3. BUILDING TYPE A
I I
I
I
REV'
Discuss me ...
Figure B3 Cellular beam as primarybeam
Service layout for VAV system
Note: The alternative structural arrangement with the

cellular beams as long span secondary beams is
more cost-effective in this Study.
Key to the colours:

Blue = Medium
velocity
supply ducts
Purple = velocity
Low supply ducts
Red (Ii nes) = Extract ducts
Red (box on plan) - Lightfitments
Green =units
Terminal
B lack - Building elements
Discuss me ... 400 DIMETER 480 DMMETEA

EXTRClCT DUCTS? I EX
DUCTS
-MEDIUM VELOCITY
SUPPLY OUCTWQRK
.LOW VELOCITY
SUPPLY DUCTWORK
, ELECTRIChL
RISERS
,STAIRCASE
&RE&
SECT [ON
LCENTROL
CORE &REA
INCLUDIMG LIFTS TOILETS
LINE
NOTE
EXTRACT PClTH THROUGH LIGHT FITTINGS AND OFFICE PLAN. SCALE 1:280
CEILING VOID INTO STUB EXTRACT DUCTWORK
315 OIClHETER SUPPLY DUCT

ZSB DIFlHETER SUPPLY DUCT
150 DEEP RAISE

r
308x50mm ELECTRICR
TRUNKING
400 DIPlMETER EXTRAUT
315 OIAMETER SUPPLY OUCl
UCT 200 DIAMETER
1300 OVERALL
ENUM & DIFFUSER

MBINEO
280 LIGHTING
TDLERFlNCE I
I 300rnmSOUARE OIFFUSEds
I
2
i
315 DIAMETERPERIMETER -315 OIFIMETER PERIMETER
SUPPLY DUCT HEADER SUPPLY DUCT HEADER
tTYPICAL) tTYPICAIJ
VAY BOX VFlV BOX
SECTION SHOWING CELLULAR BEAM. SCALE 1:50
(500mrn DIAMETER OPENINGS)
NOTES
DUCTWORK DISTRIBUTIUM LPIYOUTE GOOD ProJect
CIRCULClR DUCTWORK USED: 315 MAXIMUM OMMETER. SCI./E.C.S.C. SERVICES STUDY
-.
FUTURE FLEXIBILITY: M3OD
title SFRVICFS I AYOUT FnR;
OVERALL SERVICEWSTRUCTURE DEPTH t300mm
AOOITIONhL COMMENTS: ClRCtlLFtR HOLE SIZES
1. CELLULAR BEAM
ARE DETERMINED BY THE BEAM DEPTH-OPTIMUM

USE M CIRCULAR DUCTWORK OFFSETS THE
2. VAV BOX SYSTEM (all err)
INCREQSED COST RSSOCIPITED WITH SPLITTING 3. BUILDING 'TYPE A
THE: MAIN DUCTS.
JOB
20128A I DRAWING
l I
Discuss me ...
Figure B4 Haunchedcomposite beam
Key to the colours:

Blue = Medium
Purple = Low velocity
supply ducts
Red (box onplan) = Lightfitments
B lack = Building elements
Discuss me ...
1B00x300 MAIM 1000x300 NPIIN
1-
EXTRACT DUCT -EXTRACT DUCT
SECTION INCLUDING LIFTS TOILETS

L [NE SERVICES RISERS etc.
NOTE
OFFICE PLAN. SCALE 1:200
EXTRACT PCITH THROUGH LiGHT FITTINGS AND 3Q0x50mm ELECTRlCPlL

CEILING VOID INTO STUB EXTRACT DUCTWORK TRUNKING
508x250 SUPPLY DUCTWORK
300x50mrn VAV BOX
ELECTRICAL TRUNKING
315 DIAMETER PERIMETER
608x250 SUPPLY DUCTWORK SUPPLY DUCT HEADER
1
150 OEEP RAISE UCT 200 DIAMETER
1250 OVERALL
20b LIGHTING
ZONE AND
I I 'l I I I I
DIFFUSERS
315 OMMETER PERIMETER^
SUPPLY DUCT HERDER
VAV BOX I
SECTION SHOWING HAUNCHED UNIVERSAL BEAM. SCALE k50.
NCITES
DUCTWORK DISTRIBUTION LAYOUT: GOOD ProJsct
RECTRNGULFlR DUCTWORK USED: RATIO 4 1 SC1JE.C.S.C. SERVICES STUDY
FUTURE FLEXIBILITY: EXCELLENT SFRVKES I AYOUT FOR;
OVERClLL SERYICES/STRUCTURE DEPTH l250mm
1. HAUNCHED UNIVERSAL BEAM
ADDITIONAL COMMENTS: CEILING VOID DEPTH 2. V.A.V. BOX SYSTEM (all a w l

CAN BE INCREFISED EPISILY BY LOWERING
SUSPENDED CEILING 3. BUILDING TYPE A
Discuss me ...
Figure B5 Tapered composite beam
Key to the colours:

Blue = Medium
Red (box onplan) = Lightfitments
G reen = Terminal
units
B lack = Building elements
Discuss me ...
600x250 MAIN
SUPPLY DUCT 7
CLQLE
EXTRClCT PATH THROUGH LIGHT FITTINGS AND
CEILING VOID INTO STUB EXTRACT DUCTWORK.
300xSBmm
ELECTRICAL TRUNKING
75Bx300 EXTRFlCT OUCTWORK I
680x258 SUP
150 DEEP RA
I 3 0 0 OVERALL
200 LIGHTING
300mmSDUtN3E DIFFUSERS
SECTION SHOWING TAPERED BEAM. (FABRICATED FROM PLATE.) SCALE 1:50.
NOTES
OUCTWUAK DISTAIBUTIDN LAYOUT: FAIR ProJect
RECTANGULPIR OUCTWORK USED: RATIO 2.5:l SCI./E.C.S.C. SERVICES STUDY
FUTURE FLEXIBILITY: FNR trtle SFRVICES 1 .AYOUT FOR;
OVERALL SERVICES/STRUCTURE DEPTH: 1330mm
1. TAPERED BEAM
FlDDITIONAL COHMENTSI CEILING SPACE CAN

BE INCREASED EASILY BY LOWERING 2. VAV BOX SYSTEM (all awl
SUSPENDED CEILING.
3. BUILDING TYPE A
JOB DRAWING REV

20128A
Discuss me ...
Figure B6 Composite truss (using SHS sections)
Key to the colours:

Blue = Medium
Red (box onplan) = Light fitments
Green = Terminal units
Discuss me ...
SECTION
LINE
NOTE
OFFICE PLAN. SCALE 2200
EXTRllCf PATH THROUGH LIGHTFITTINGS

CEILING YQID INM STUB EXTRACT DUCTWORK
380x58mm ELECTRIC&
300x50mrn ELECTRICnl. TRUNK I N G
TRUNKING
315 DIClHETER SUPPLY DUCTWORK >35 OUCTWORK
DIAMETER SUPPLY
1 -FLEX DUCT 200 DIclHETER
1 9 DEEP RFlISE
1
I ! I
1350 OVERALL
208 LIGHTING
SECTION SHOWING COMPOSITE TRUSS (TYPE 1 1 WITH VIERENDEEL PANEL A T MIDSPAN.
HOTES
DWCTWOF~KOISTRMUTIOM LAYOUT: GDOD
SCI./E.C.S.C. SERVICES STUDY

FUTURE FLEXIBILITY: EXCELLENT tltle?
1. COMPOSITE TRUSS -TYPE I
ADQtTIOAIAL COHMEHTSr GOO0 CHOICE FOR

SERVICES DISTRIBUTION REOUIREHENTS BUT ISOUARE HOLLOW SECTION1
HAY BE EXPEWSIVE IN B E N FABRIMTION
CH83 FIRE PROTECTION COSTS. 2. VAV BOX SYSTEM (all air)
3. BUILDING TYPE A
Discuss me ...
Figure B7 Stub girder(Type 2)
Note: An alternative stub girder configuration (Type 1) was

also investigated in this Study.
Key to the colours:

Blue = Medium
Purple = velocity
Low supply ducts
Red (I i nes) = Extract ducts
Red (box onplan) = Light fitments
Discuss me ...
10B0x300 MAIN
I EX
DUCT
NOTE
EXTRACT PATH THROUGH LIGHTFITTINGS FlND OFFICE PLAN, SCALE 1200 300w50rnm ELECTRICN
CEILING VOID INTO s w e EXTRACT DUCTWDRK TRUNK ING

308n5Plmm
ELECTRICAL TRUNKING I I L
I I I
150 DEEP RAISE
13P COMPOSITE
I350 OVERNL
1 5 OMMETER PERIMETER
SUPPLY DUCT HEADER SUPPLY WCT HEADER
VAY BOX
SECTION SHOWING STUB GIRDER, (TYPE 2)
SCALE 1:50
NOTES
OUCTWORK DISTRIBUTION LAYOUTI EXCELLENT
RECThNGULAR DUCTWORK USED1 RATIO 411
FUTURE FLEXIBLITY: EXCELLENT

t l t h Z R V I C F S LAYOUT FOR;
OVERALL SERVICES/STRUCTURE DEPTH :135Bmm
1. STUB GIRDER (TYPE 21
ADDITIONAL COMMENTS: SERVICE OPENING

DEPTH NOT DICTE~TED ev DEPTH OF SECONDARY 2. VAV BOX SYSTEM (all mr)
BEAMS.
3. BUILDING TYPE A
JOB DRAWING
20128A
Discuss me ...
Figure B 8 Composite beam (for 7.5 m x 6 m

grid)
Key to the colours:

Blue = Medium
Red (I i nes) = Extract ducts
Green =units
Terminal
Discuss me ... 880x250 MhIN

-EX TRACT OUCT
SECTION -F] -CENTRAL CORE ~ R E F I

INCLUOING LIFTS TOILETS
LIME SERVICES RISERS etc.
NOTE
OFFICE PLAN. SCALE 1200
EXTRACT PATH THROUGH LIGHT FITTINGS AND

CEILING VOID INTO STUB EXTRACT DUCTWORK
308x5hm
ELECTRICCIL TRUFlKfNG
315 OMMETER PERIMETER
SUPPLY DUCT HEAOER
150 DEEP RFlISE
1200 OVERFlLL
280 LIGHTING
315 DIMETER
SUPPLY DUCT
SECTION SHOWING UNIVERSAL BEAM ON 7.5m X 6171STRUCTURAL GRID
SCALE 1:50
MOfES
DUCTWORK OISTRIBUTION LAYOUT1 GUOO
RECTANGULClR DUCTWORK USED2 RATIO 511
FUTURE FLEXIBILITY: GOOD

I SCI./E.C.S.C.
PraJact
SERVICES STUDY
-~ltleSFRVICFS j AYOUT FOR;
OVERclLl SEAYICES/STRUCTURE DEPTH = 1200mm
1. 7.5m x 6rn STRUCTURAL GRID
ADDITIWhL COMHENTSz CEILING VOID DEPTH 2. V.A.V. BOX 5YSTEM (all awl
C M BE INCREASED EASILY BY LOWERING
SUSPENDED CEILING 3. BUILDING TYPE A
JOB ORFlWING REU

20128A
Discuss me ...
Figure B9 Slim floor beam and deep composite

decking
Note: The Slimdek arrangement is the same as this.
Key to the colours:

Blue = Medium
Discuss me ...
700x30P 7Wx380
EXTRACT HEADER ~ E X T R C ~ HEADER
C T
SECT ION 1-1 [NCLUDING LIFTS TOILETS

LINE SERVICES RISERS e-.
NOTE
EXTRFlCT PClTH THROUGH LIGHT FITTINGS FlND

CEILING VOID INTO STUB EXTRACT OUCTWORK
OFFICE PLAN. SCALE 1:200
500x250 SWPLY DUCTWORK
300x50mrn
fLECTRICAL TRUNK1
600x250 SUPPLY DU 900 x 300 c RIBS USED a
EXTRACT WCTS
150 RAISED FLO UCT 208 DMMETER
295 SLIM
FLOOR BEAM
l000 OVERALL
ZB0 LIGHTING
380mmSWARE
DIFFUSERS INTO EXTRACT V I A RIBS
SECTION SHOWING SLIMFLOOR. SCALE 1:50.
d!xEs
DUCTWORK DISTRIBLlTION LFlYUUT: GUOO ProJec t
RECTFlntGULAR DUCTWORK USE01 RflTIO .Zm5:l SCI./E.C,S.C. SERVICES STUDY
FUTURE FLEXIBILITY: EXCELLENT
OVERRLL SERVICES/STRUCTURE DEPTH i000rnrn

ADDITIONALCOMMENTS; CEILING VOID DEPTH

ChN BE INCRECISEO EClSIlY BY LOWERING
SUSPENDED CEILING
L
I
Discuss me ...
Figure B10 Applicationtoalternativebuilding

form (see Figure 30)
Service layout VAV system and composite beam with

web opening
Note: This building form illustrates two possible core

positions and demonstrates how the scheme
considered in Figure B1 may be adapted to this
building form.
Key to the colours:

Blue = Medium
Purple = velocity
Low supply ducts
Red (boxon plan) = Lightfitments

Discuss me ...
FIRE COMPARTMENT ZONES

OPTION I
RISERS I N h
CENTRALISED
POSlTlOM
L
P-
TOILET!
SWTS
ESCAPE STAIRS
Pro@e t
1S.C.I. /E.C,S.C.SERVICES STUD'
t%%h m F S 1 AYOUT
1. UNIFORM DEPTH BEMl
OFFICE PLAN, SCALE lt2m WITH WEB OPENINGS
2. V.A.V. BOX SYSTEM (all nrr)
3. BUILDING TYPE B

Sci P166

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

Sci P166

Uploaded by

Document Information

Original Title

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

Sci P166

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

P166: Design of Steel Framed Buildings for Service Integration

SCI PUBLICATION 166

Telephone: 01344 623345

0 1997 The Steel Construction Institute

Apart from any fair dealing for the purposes of research or

private study or criticism or review, as permitted under the

Enquiries concerning reproduction outside the terms stated

Although care has been taken to ensure, to the best of our

Publications supplied tothe Members of the Institute ata

ISBN 1 85942 047 8

British Library Cataloguing-in-Publication Data.

This publication concentrates on the design of long

The publication was prepared by The Steel

Dr B Davidson Y R M AnthonyHunt Associates

M r P Trebilcock SCI ConsultantArchitect

The illustrations of service layouts in Appendix B

Support was received for the dissemination phase of

The Department of the

1 MODERN OFFICE BUILDINGS 1

1.2 Climatic Factors 4

1.3 Steel Framed Buildings 5

1.4 Services Integration 7

2.1 The Need

2.2 Types of Building Services 12

3.1 Building Location 16

3.2 Building Use 16

3.3 Building Form and

4.1 Ventilation and Cooling 19

4.2 Types of Air-conditioning System 21

4.3 All-Air Systems 23

4.5 All-Water Systems 27

4.6 Packaged Refrigeration Unit

4.8 Laminar Flow System 34

4.1 0 Comparison of Systems 37

5.4 HorizontalDistribution of Services 47

6 STRUCTURAL OPTIONS FOR

6.2 Slim Floors

6.4 Long Span Construction 53

6.5 Composite Beams with Web

6.6 Cellular and Castellated Beams 57

Haunched 6.7 Beams 60

6.8 Tapered Beams 61

6.9 Composite Trusses 62

6.10 Stub Girders 64

6.1 1 Parallel Systems

6.1 2 Summary of Service Zones

6.1 3 Vertical Cores 67

7 CASE STUDY: COMPARISON OF

7.1 Typical SteelFramed Building 69

7.4 Structural Beam Details and

8 CASE STUDY: SERVICE DISTRIBUTION 83

9 CASE STUDY: COST IMPLICATIONS

9.1 General Aspects 85

9.2 Structure Cost 86

9.3 Cladding Costs 88

9.5 Foundation Costs 90

9.6 Speed of Construction 91

9.7 Overall Cost Estimates 92

APPENDIX A: Suggested Best Practice Criteria