Donevan2017 PDF
Donevan2017 PDF
Donevan2017 PDF
PII: S1877-5756(16)30101-X
DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.srhc.2017.03.002
Reference: SRHC 291
Please cite this article as: M. Donevan, M. Mattebo, The Relationship between Frequent Pornography Consumption,
Behaviors, and Sexual Preoccupancy among Male Adolescents in Sweden, Sexual & Reproductive Healthcare
(2017), doi: http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.srhc.2017.03.002
This is a PDF file of an unedited manuscript that has been accepted for publication. As a service to our customers
we are providing this early version of the manuscript. The manuscript will undergo copyediting, typesetting, and
review of the resulting proof before it is published in its final form. Please note that during the production process
errors may be discovered which could affect the content, and all legal disclaimers that apply to the journal pertain.
The Relationship between Frequent Pornography Consumption, Behaviors, and Sexual
Preoccupancy among Male Adolescents in Sweden
Corresponding author:
Magdalena Mattebo
Ph.D.
E-mail. magdalena.mattebo@kbh.uu.se
Tel. +46 (0)73-673 13 75
Fax. +46 (0)21-173733
1
Introduction
consumed prior to the Internet, online pornography is accessible, affordable, anonymous, and, by
and large, acceptable.1 Accessed on any kind of internet-enabled device, pornography has become a
primary source of sexual education for young people. 2 Research in Sweden reveals that nearly all
adolescent boys (96%) have viewed pornography by the time they reach 16, and the average age
they began to actively search for pornography is approximately 12 years old. 3,4 Similar trends have
For several decades, researchers have attempted to disentangle the effects of pornography.
One area of research has looked at the relationship between exposure to pornography and risky
sexual behaviours, defined as sexual behaviours that pose an increased risk of a negative outcome
within a sexual interaction. 9 Such risks may include an increased chance of contracting sexually
between pornography consumption and risky sexual behaviours like engaging in vaginal intercourse
and oral sex at earlier ages ("sexual debut"), 4,10-13 anal sex,4,14,15 and sex with multiple partners. 13,16
consumption is associated with verbal and physical sexual aggression, to the extent that
pornography consumption, then speculations about pornography's addictive potential become all the
more concerning. Adolescents possess a natural sexual curiosity, so greater interest in sexuality
does not necessarily imply compulsive and addictive behaviour. Nevertheless, Peter and
Valkenburg18 show that exposure to pornography can lead to sexual preoccupancy, defined as a
2
“strong cognitive engagement in sexual issues, sometimes at the exclusion of other thoughts.” 15(p208)
The authors argue that pornography exposure can catapult adolescents’ interest in sex beyond their
natural sexual curiosity. In addition, neuroscientists have begun to map the effects of pornography
on a viewer’s brain.19-21 A recent thorough review by Love et al. 21 concludes that compulsive
internet pornography consumption should indeed become an official diagnosis in the addiction
framework, sharing similar basic mechanisms with substance addiction. Moreover, the overall
literature asserts that adolescents are “at a higher risk for developing problematic pornography use
Theory
A particularly relevant theoretical framework for the present research is Wright’s 22,23
acquisition, activation, and application model (3AM) of mediated socialization. This model is based
on sexual scripting theory, which predicts that by consuming pornography, individuals acquire new
sexual scripts they were unaware of. 24 They are further encouraged to apply these scripts in real life,
since behaviours are portrayed as normal, acceptable, and rewarding. The model therefore suggests
that pornography becomes a template for how consumers should behave sexually, with consumers
using “[pornographic] sexual scripts to navigate real-world sexual experiences and guide sexual
expectations.”24(p4) Furthermore, it predicts that “on average, males who view more pornography
will … engage in different sexual behaviours than males who view less pornography.” 25(p7)
A content analysis of the 250 best-selling and most-rented pornography films in the US
offers an indication of the type of pornographic sexual scripts consumers are likely to adopt. 26 Of
the 304 scenes analysed, only one (0.3%) contained any discussion about pregnancy or STI risks
and less than 11% of the scenes showed explicit condom usage, even though 56% of the scenes
contained anal sex.23 Furthermore, physical aggression and verbal aggression were present in 88%
3
and 49% of the scenes respectively, while only 10% of the scenes contained any positive behaviour
such as compliments, caressing, and kissing. Given these content findings, the 3AM predicts that
frequent pornography users are more likely to engage in riskier sexual behaviours.
Hypothesis
The aim of this study was to investigate the relationship between frequent pornography
consumption, sexual behaviours, and sexual preoccupancy among adolescent 18-year-old Swedish
boys. Based on the above theoretical framework and in light of previous research, we hypothesized
that frequent users of pornography would report greater engagement in risky sexual behaviours and
show higher signals of sexual preoccupancy and compulsive pornography consumption compared
Methods
Data collection was completed among 18-year-old, third-year high school students in a medium
and large sized Swedish town in 2013. The total population of third-year students in both towns
was 946 students (510 girls and 436 boys). A power analysis was calculated based on previously
adolescents in the county where data collection was performed. 27 This sample size was determined
users of pornography with a p-value of 0.05 and a power of 80%. At the time of data collection, 24
senior high schools with 115 classes were eligible. The power analysis resulted in a sample of 53
randomly selected classes in 13 senior high schools. During data collection, 730 (77%) of all
available third-year students in the selected classes were available (359 girls and 371 boys). This
4
paper reports findings from the participating boys.
Instrument
characteristics, physical and psychological health, experiences of and perceptions about sex, and
usage of pornography. Participants were able to rate self-reported questions from a scale, and a “not
relevant to me” response was available when they had no experience with the topic. Nearly all
questions used have been asked in previous research within Sweden (Spearman 0.90 and Kappa
0.86).3,4 In this study, we report findings from experiences of and perceptions about sex and usage
of pornography (Table 1). A pilot test, where the items used in this study were test/retested, was
performed in 2011 in a similar sample (n = 35) in another town. Correlation tests using Cohen’s
kappa (nominal data) and Spearman’s rank order correlation test (ordinal data) were used, and an
acceptable degree of correlation was found between the two tests (mean values of 0.81 and 0.61,
respectively).3
Measures
Pornography consumption
statements are specified in Table 2. Those who reported daily consumption were categorized as
frequent consumers, those who reported weekly consumption average users and those reporting
Sexual experiences
5
We asked participants to respond to 11 items related to sexual experiences.
Four items (Have you received oral sex? Have you given oral sex? Have you had vaginal
intercourse? Have you had anal sex?) had the following response alternatives: no, yes. These
Three items (Have you had sex with someone on your first date, a so-called one-night stand? Have
you had sex with a friend? Have you had group sex?) had the following response alternatives: no;
once; yes, between two and five times; yes, between six and 10 times; yes, more than 10 times.
Perceptions of sexuality
One item (How often do you think about sex?) had the following response alternatives: Almost
never, Rather seldom, neither seldom or often, Rather often, Almost all the time/all the time. One
item (If you compare with peers, do you think you are more or less interested in sex) had the
following response alternatives: A lot less, A little less, Neither less nor more, A little more, A lot
more.
Procedure
The first step was to obtain permission from the Director of the Senior High School Department
of the County Council. Subsequently, each principal was informed about the nature of the study and
contacted for permission via email or a telephone call. Two schools were added to replace two
schools that declined participation. A letter explaining the aim of the study was sent to every
teacher, followed by telephone calls when necessary. When the second author of this paper and two
experienced research assistants visited each class, they provided a description of the survey and
emphasized that participation was strictly voluntary. Those that refrained from participating were
6
able to leave the classroom or stay and read through the survey. Consent was acquired by
emphasizing that students could decline participation. One respondent declined participation. The
survey was completed in the classroom with separated desks to maintain privacy when respondents
filled in the form. In total, the survey took 25–30 minutes to complete. A research assistant
collected the questionnaires in a sealed envelope. Cards for the local youth clinic were handed out
to ensure students had access to counselling if needed. Finally, the data were anonymized before
Ethics
The Regional Ethical Review Board in Uppsala, Sweden approved the study (Dnr 2010/369).
Statistical analysis
All statistical analyses were performed in IBM Statistical Packages of Social Sciences, SPSS
20. For statistical tests, a p-value level of 0.05 or less was deemed to be statistically significant.
Three sub-samples were constructed, based on the reported frequency of pornography use: frequent,
average, and infrequent users. Frequent users were defined as participants who watched
pornography one or more times per day. Average users watched pornography at least once a month
up to several times a week, but less than once per day. Infrequent users watched pornography less
than once a month. Outcome variables included measures for pornography consumption, sexual
experiences, and perceptions of sexuality. To determine differences between frequent, average, and
infrequent users, chi-square (χ²) and Fisher’s Exact test statistics were applied to contingency tables
for nominal outcome variables while interval outcome variables were tested using the one-way
7
RESULTS
Results are reported in the following order: frequent users, average users, and infrequent users
of pornography.
Pornography consumption
Nearly all respondents (98%, n = 361) had watched pornography, although to different extents.
Eleven percent were found to be frequent users (n = 42), 69 percent average users (n = 256), and 20
percent infrequent users (n = 72). When they watched pornography, the majority took the initiative
to watch it (89%, n = 332) and watched it alone (90%, n = 336). Among frequent users, the most
common type of pornography consumed was hard core pornography (71%, n = 30) followed by
lesbian pornography (64%, n = 27), while soft core pornography was the most commonly selected
genre for average (73%, n = 186) and infrequent users (36%, n = 26). There was also a difference
between the groups in the proportion who watched hard core pornography (71%, n = 30; 48%, n =
122; 10%, n = 7; p < 0.001) and violent pornography (14%, n = 6; 9%, n = 26; 0%, n = 0; p =
0.011).
Sexual behaviours
The sexual behaviours reported by the respondents are shown in Table 3. Frequent users were
more likely to have participated in a wider range of sexual activities, such as giving oral sex (76%,
n = 31; 61%, n = 156; 49%, n = 34; p = 0.017) and receiving oral sex (76%, n = 32; 66%, n = 165;
53%, n = 37; p = 0.032). Table 4 shows that there was also a significant difference for whether or
not a participant had participated in anal sex or not (29%, n = 12; 20%, n = 50; 10%, n =7; p =
0.039). Frequent users were also more likely to have tried sexual acts seen in pornographic films
(50%, n = 20; 39%, n = 100; 17%, n = 17; p < 0.001). These acts included: oral sex (33%, n = 14;
8
21%, n = 53; 3%, n = 2; p < 0.001), vaginal intercourse (45%, n = 19; 30%, n = 77; 8%, n = 6; p <
0.001), and anal sex (17%, n = 7; 10%, n = 26; 0%, n = 0; p = 0.005). Results for sexual debut are
presented in Table 4. Mean age of first oral sex received (F(2, 228) = 3.99), p = 0.020) and mean
age at first vaginal sex (F(2, 250) = 7.59, p = 0.001) differed significantly between frequent,
average and infrequent users. Post hoc comparisons using the Tukey HSD test indicate that the
mean age of first oral sex received (M = -0.38, SD = 0.31) and the mean age at first vaginal
intercourse (M = -0.36, SD = 0.29) for frequent users were significantly different from average
Several responses may be associated with sexual preoccupancy and compulsive pornography
consumption. Referring to Table 5, frequent users considered themselves more interested in both
sex (19%, n = 8; 8%, n = 17; 1%, n = 1; p = 0.002) and pornography (19%, n = 8; 4%, n = 10; 0%,
n = 0; p < 0.001) compared to peers. Frequent users were more likely to think about sex almost all
the time (53%, n = 21; 50%, n = 123; 25%, n = 18; p = 0.001), and much more likely to have
fantasies about trying sexual activities seen in pornography several times a week (44%, n = 18; 9%,
n = 23; 6%, n = 3; p < 0.001). A higher proportion of frequent users who had watched hard
pornography, stated more pornography consumption than wanted compared with peers (Table 6).
Only one respondent of all (n=1, average user) stated experience from having watched violent
pornography and stating more pornography consumption than wanted. It was equally uncommon
among frequent and average users to have experience of watching violent pornography and state
thinking about sex all the time (60%, n=3; 42%, n=10; p=0.520). However, a higher proportion
frequent users stated experience from having watched violent pornography and stating fantasies
9
about trying sexual activities seen in pornography several times a week (n=3, 50%; 25%, n=6,
p=0.012). No infrequent user stated experience from having watched violent pornography.
DISCUSSION
Our findings show that frequent users more often report behaviours associated with sexual risk
taking including earlier age at sexual debut, anal sex, and having tried acts seen in pornography.
Sexual debut is “important because it affects the duration of exposure to STIs”, 9(p1207) and evidence
suggests that individuals who have sex at younger ages may have riskier behaviour over a lifetime. 9
Although anal sex is not necessarily a risky behaviour if adequate protection is utilized, the higher
instance of anal sex found among frequent users of pornography is concerning when considering
the prevalence of unprotected sex presented in pornography. Based on the 3AM, if frequent users
are more likely to test out sexual acts seen in pornography, it is not far-fetched to presume that the
risky manner in which they have seen the acts performed might also be internalized (acquired) and
We also found that frequent users were more likely to consider themselves having a greater
interest in sex and pornography compared to their peers, fantasize trying acts seen in pornography
several times a week, think about sex almost all the time, and watch pornography more than they
wanted. These results offer compelling insights about sexual preoccupancy and compulsive
pornography consumption. The fact that frequent users on average consider themselves more
interested in sex and pornography compared to peers does not in itself indicate a problem. However,
in lieu of the 44 percent of frequent users having fantasies about trying sexual activities seen in
pornography several times a week and the 53 percent that think about sex almost all the time, these
findings together provide stronger evidence for sexual preoccupancy. It is difficult to determine the
direction of causality: are people consuming pornography because they were more interested in the
10
first place, or is it because they watch pornography that they end up thinking more about sex? Peter
and Valkenburg’s15 findings suggest that there could be a cyclical relationship: these individuals are
more interested in sex in the first place, but pornography triggers an even greater, potentially
It is also noteworthy that a statistically significant relationship was found between fantasizing
about pornography several times a week and watching hard core pornography. Since verbal and
hard core pornography could likely be defined as violent pornography. 24 If this is the case, and in
light of the suggested cyclical nature of sexual preoccupancy in Peter and Valkenburg, 15 it may be
that rather than ‘purging’ individuals of their fantasies and inclinations of sexual aggression,
watching hard core pornography perpetuates them, thereby increasing the likelihood of manifested
sexual aggression.
users admitted they watch pornography more than they want to. As stated above, a growing body of
empirical research considers pornography potentially addictive. Since adolescents’ brains are still in
their development phase, young people may be especially vulnerable to problematic pornography
use. “Unlike adults, adolescents are believed to lack sufficient maturation and integrity in frontal
cortices necessary to exert cognitive control required to suppress sexual cravings, thoughts, and
behaviours elicited by pornographic content.”2(p114) This, combined with the notion that adolescents
process and retain images far better than written or spoken words, 2 means that the development of
relevant, effective sexual education becomes all the more crucial to counterbalance the messages in
The classrooms were randomly selected so the results should be representative of the two towns
included. Results are however not necessarily representative of Sweden in general, or to other
11
countries. Future research could be conducted in areas with different demographics. The cross-
sectional nature of the data places a limit on the possible conclusions drawn from this study, since it
prevents any causal interpretations being drawn. For example, it is unclear whether pornography
usage results in earlier sexual debut, or if earlier sexual debut is associated with other confounding
variables related to social and behavioural factors. The body of literature would benefit from quasi-
experimental designs that deal with these confounding variables. Further, this study would benefit
from longitudinal measures, since this would enable an examination of how pornography
consumption affects individuals over time. Still, the strength of this study rests in its convergence
with theory and support from similar studies using alternative methodologies.
A further limitation in the present study was that pornography was not clearly defined. In other
words, the participants could define pornography as naked images of women/men or as images
may have more likely embraced one definition over the other. However, asking the participants to
rate to what extent different genres of pornography were consumed provided the participants an
Despite pornography acting as a first ‘sex educator’ for many young people, there is a general
pornography’s effects. However, research among adolescents appears substantially less ambiguous
than research on adults, with this study among a plethora of others indicating that frequent
pornography consumption is associated with negative outcomes. When it comes to prevention and
ways forward, the 3AM maps out the importance of pre-existing scripts: the more incompatible a
consumer’s pre-existing scripts are to the pornography script, the less the pornography script will
dictate their future script upon exposure. 28 Accordingly, robust sexual education at relevant ages is
crucial, complemented by efforts to minimize children’s access to pornography. The model further
12
locates ‘audience criticality’ as a key moderator to the pornography script. 28 In this sense,
educational strategies such as media literacy would help to equip young people with the critical
thinking skills necessary to minimize the harms of pornography. Finally, since the results of the
present study are consistent with the argument that pornography has addictive properties,
appropriate support to young people struggling with problematic pornography consumption must be
Results indicate that frequent users of pornography have sexual debuts at younger ages, engage
in a broader range of sexual encounters, and are more likely to struggle with sexual preoccupancy
and problematic pornography use. This study contributes to a growing body of research providing
Funding: This work was supported by The European Society of Contraception and Reproductive
Health [grant number 11065], Uppsala-Örebro Regional Research Council [grant number RFR
References
1. Carroll JS, Padilla-Walker LM, Nelson LJ, Olson CD, Barry CM, Madsen SD. Generation
XXX: pornography acceptance and its use among emerging adults. Journal of Adolescent
2. Owens EW, Behun RJ, Manning JC, Reid RC. The impact of Internet pornography on
adolescents: A review of the research. Sexual Addiction & Compulsivity 2012; 19:99–122.
13
3. Mattebo M, Tydén T, Häggström-Nordin E, Nilsson K, Larsson M. Pornography and sexual
experiences among high school students in Sweden. Journal of Developmental & Behavioural
sexual practices among adolescents in Sweden. International Journal of STD & AIDS 2005;
16:102–7.
5. Ybarra ML, Mitchell KJ. Exposure to Internet pornography among children and adolescents: A
6. Sabina C, Wolak J, Finkelhor D. The nature and dynamics of internet pornography exposure for
43:45–60.
9. Slaymaker E, Walker N, Zaba B, Collumbien M. (2004) Unsafe sex. In: Ezzati M, Lopez AD,
Rodgers A, Murray CJL, eds. Comparative Quantification of Health Risks: Sexual and
10. Brown JD, L’Engle KL. X-Rated: Sexual attitudes and behaviours associated with U.S. early
11. Kraus SW, Russell B. Early sexual experiences: The role of Internet access and sexually explicit
12. Bulot C, Leurent B, Collier F. Pornography sexual behaviour and risk behaviour at university.
14
13. Morgan EM. Associations between young adults’ use of sexually explicit materials and their
14. Braun-Courville DK, Rojas, M. Exposure to sexually explicit web sites and adolescent sexual
15. Tyden T, Rogala C. Sexual behaviour among young men in Sweden and the impact of
16. Hald GM, Kuyper L, Adam PC, de Wit JB. Does viewing explain doing? Assessing the
association between sexually explicit materials use and sexual behaviours in a large sample of
Dutch adolescents and young adults. J Sex Med 2013; doi: 10.1111/jsm.12157
17. Wright PJ, Tokunaga RS, Kraus A. A meta-analysis of pornography consumption and actual
acts of sexual aggression in general population studies. Journal of Communication 2015; doi:
10.1111/jcom.12201.
18. Peter J, Valkenburg P. Adolescents’ exposure to sexually explicit internet material and sexual
19. Voon V, Mole T, Banca P, Porter L, Morris L, Mitchell S et al. Neural Correlates of Sexual Cue
Reactivity in Individuals with and without Compulsive Sexual Behaviours. PLoS ONE 2014;
21. Love T, Laier C, Brand M, Hatch L, Hajela R. Neuroscience of internet pornography addiction:
22. Wright PJ. Pornography and the sexual socialization of children: current knowledge and a
15
23. Wright PJ. Mass media effects on youth sexual behaviour. Communication Yearbook 2011;
35:343–86.
24. Sun C, Bridges A, Johnason J, Ezzell M. Pornography and the male sexual script: an analysis of
consumption and sexual relations. Archives of Sexual Behaviour 2014; DOI 10.1007/s10508-
014-0391-2.
25. Wright PJ, Bae S. (in press, 2016) Pornography and male sexual socialization. In: Wong YJ,
Wester SR, eds. APA handbook of men and masculinities. Washington DC: American
Psychological Association.
26. Bridges A, Wosnitzer R, Scharrer E, Sun C, Liberman R. Aggression and sexual behaviour in
best-selling pornography videos: a content analysis update. Violence Against Women 2010;
16:1065–85.
27. Aslund C, Starrin B, Nilsson KW. Social capital in relation to depression, musculoskeletal pain,
28. Currie C, Roberts C, Morgan A, et al. (2004) Young people’s health in context. Health
behaviour in school-aged children (HBSC) study: International report from the 2001/2002
survey health policy for children and adolescents, No. 4. Copenhagen, Denmark: WHO Europe.
16
TABLE 1. QUESTIONNAIRE DESCRIPTION
17
TABLE 2. STATEMENTS REGARDING USE OF PORNOGRAPHY
How often do you watch I don´t watch pornography, More seldom than once
pornography? a year, A few times every year, A few times every
month, Every week, Every day, Several times every
day.
If you watch pornography, with whom Alone, Boyfriend/Girlfriend, Male friends, Female
do you do it? friends, Gender mixed group of friends, I don´t
watch pornography.
Who takes the initiative to watch Myself, Boyfriend/Girlfriend, Male friends, Female
pornography? friends, Gender mixed group of friends, I don´t
watch pornography.
Do you fantasize about performing I don’t watch pornography, No, Yes, seldom, Yes,
sexual acts you have seen in sometime every month, Yes, sometime every week,
pornography? Yes, a few times every week, Yes, several times
every day.
Have you ever tried to perform sexual I don’t watch pornography, No, Sometimes, Often
acts seen in pornography?
If yes, give example of what you have Oral sex, Vaginal intercourse, Anal sex, Group sex,
tried. Other
I watch pornography Much more than I want to, As much as I want to, A
lot less than I want to, I don’t watch pornography
18
To what extent do you think Very much, Rather much, Neither much nor little,
pornography affect your sexual Rather little, Very little/Not at all, I don’t watch
behaviour? pornography
To what extent do you think Very much, rather a lot, Neither much nor little,
pornography affect your sexual Rather little, Very little/Not at all, I don’t watch
behaviour? pornography
If you compare with same sex peers, A lot less, A little less, Neither more nor less, A
do you think you are more or less little more, A lot more.
interested in pornography?
19
TABLE 3. SEXUAL BEHAVIOURS AMONG 18-YEAR-OLD MALE ADOLESCENTS
n = 370 n = 42 n = 256 n = 72
(%) (%) (%) (%)
Oral sex, given 221 (61) 31 (76) 156 (61) 34 (49) 0.017
Oral sex, received 234 (65) 32 (76) 165 (66) 37 (53) 0.032
Sex with friends 270 (73) 31 (74) 185 (73) 54 (76) 0.934
Tried sexual acts 129 (37) 20 (50) 100 (39) 9 (17) 0.002
seen in
pornographic films
*Chi-square and Fisher exact tests, significance level: p < 0.05.
20
TABLE 4. MEAN AGE AT SEXUAL DEBUT AMONG 18-YEAR-OLD MALE ADOLESCENTS
21
TABLE 5. INDICATORS OF SEXUAL PREOCCUPANCY AND COMPULSIVE PORNOGRAPHY USE
AMONG 18-YEAR-OLD MALE ADOLESCENTS
Think about sex almost all 162 (45) 21 (53) 123 (50) 18 (25) 0.001
the time
22
TABLE 6. INDICATORS OF SEXUAL PREOCCUPANCY AND COMPULSIVITY
- Watch
pornography more 15 (9) 9 (30) 5 (4) 1 (14) <0.001
than wanted
- Thinking
about sex most of 91 (58) 19 (66) 69 (58) 3 (43) 0.512
the time
23
Highlights
Frequent users watched hard core pornography and violent pornography to a higher extent
Frequent users were more likely to have engaged in a wider range of sexual activities
Frequent users fantasised about trying sexual activities seen in hard core pornography
Frequent users showed signs of sexual preoccupancy and problematic pornography use
24