Location via proxy:   [ UP ]  
[Report a bug]   [Manage cookies]                

White Paper: 5G Evolution: On The Path To 6G

Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 47

5G Evolution: On the Path to 6G

Expanding the Frontiers of Wireless Communications


5G Evolution: On the Path to 6G

White Paper

Dr. Nishith D. Tripathi &

v.1
Dr. Jeffrey H. Reed
White Paper
Table of Contents

Table of Contents
1 5G Phase 1 and Evolution Toward 6G .......................................................................... 4

2 Service Expansion Beyond Release 15 ........................................................................ 8


2.1 5G LAN……………………………………………………………………………………………………………….8
2.2 Satellite Access ........................................................................................................................................ 10
2.3 Critical Medical Applications................................................................................................................... 11
2.4 5G V2X……………………………………………………………………………………………………………12
2.5 UAVs or Drones ........................................................................................................................................ 13
2.6 Audio-Visual Production .......................................................................................................................... 14
2.7 Cyber-Physical Control Applications ..................................................................................................... 15
2.8 Positioning…………………………………………………………………………………………………………16
2.9 Haptic Services ......................................................................................................................................... 18

3 NR Enhancements Beyond Release 15 .......................................................................19


3.1 Integrated Access and Backhaul (IAB) .................................................................................................. 20
3.2 NR-Unlicensed (NR-U) .............................................................................................................................. 21
3.3 URLLC Enhancements ............................................................................................................................. 22
3.4 Industrial IoT (IIoT) Enhancements......................................................................................................... 24
3.5 New Frequency Bands ............................................................................................................................. 25
3.6 Miscellaneous NR Enhancements .......................................................................................................... 26

4 5G Network Architecture Enhancements ....................................................................28

5 Miscellaneous Enhancements .....................................................................................30


5.1 SEAL………………………………………………………………………………………………………………...30
5.2 5G SON……………………………………………………………………………………………………………..31
5.3 Security Enhancements ........................................................................................................................... 32

6 6G: A Crystal Ball Perspective .....................................................................................34


6.1 Predicting the 6G Future .......................................................................................................................... 34
6.2 Key Technologies as 6G Enablers .......................................................................................................... 35
6.2.1 Artificial Intelligence ................................................................................................................................. 35
6.2.2 RF and Optical Technologies .................................................................................................................. 37

v.1 Rohde & Schwarz 5G Evolution: On the Path to 6G 2


Table of Contents

6.2.3 Network Technologies ............................................................................................................................. 39


6.3 Potential Performance Targets for 6G .................................................................................................... 39
6.4 Potential 6G Services ............................................................................................................................... 39

7 Summary………………………………………………………………………………………..41

8 Literature…………….. ....................................................................................................43

v.1 Rohde & Schwarz 5G Evolution: On the Path to 6G 3


1 5G Phase 1 and Evolution Toward 6G
3GPP1 defined the fifth-generation (5G) cellular technology in Release 15 to meet ITU’s
IMT-20202 performance requirements and to enable a variety of services associated with
the usage scenarios such as enhanced Mobile Broadband (eMBB), Ultra Reliable Low
Latency Communications (URLLC), and massive Machine Type Communications (mMTC).
Example 5G performance requirements are 20 Gbps peak data rate, 1 ms radio network
latency, 10 Mbps/m2 area throughput, and 1 million (low-rate) IoT devices per square
kilometer. Key building blocks for 5G are New Radio (NR) air interface, new radio and core
network architectures, virtualization and automation technologies, and new types of
devices [1]. These building blocks enable 5G to offer target 5G services.
While Release 15 provides a solid framework for enhanced network performance and
mass offering of amazing services, 3GPP is actively working on further enhancing the
framework as shown in Figure 1.1.

13GPP stands for Third Generation Partnership Project. 3GPP has previously defined specifications for third-generation
Universal Mobile Telecommunication System (UMTS) and fourth-generation Long Term Evolution (LTE).
2
ITU is International Telecommunication Union. A network is said to be a 5G network if it can meet International Mobile
Telecommunications (IMT)- 2020 performance requirements.

Rohde & Schwarz 5G Evolution: On the Path to 6G 4


ı Release 15. 3GPP defined 5G Phase 1 in Release 15 (R15). Example features of R15
include New Radio (NR) air interface, new radio network architecture called Next-
Generation Radio Access Network (NG-RAN), new core network architecture called
Next Generation Core (NGC) or 5G Core (5GC), Service Based Architecture (SBA),
Network Slicing, and Edge Computing.
ı Release 16. Planned features for Release 16, also called 5G Phase 2, include NR-
Unlicensed (NR-U), Integrated Access and Backhaul (IAB), enhanced Vehicle-to-
Everything (eV2X), URLLC and Industrial IoT (IIoT) enhancements, and Service
Enabler Architecture Layer (SEAL) for verticals.
ı Release 17. Potential Release 17 features include Non Terrestrial Networks (NTNs)
(i.e., those using satellites), new frequency bands (e.g., 7-24 GHz and > 53 GHz), and
NR-Light.
ı 6G. 5G Phase 1 deployments have started only recently, and, releases beyond R15
will continue to tap into the tremendous potential of 5G. However, as a new generation
of the cellular technology typically appears every 10 years, 6G can be expected

Rohde & Schwarz 5G Evolution: On the Path to 6G 5


around 2030. 6G could offer high-fidelity holograms, multi-sensory communications
(e.g., touch, taste and/or smell!), Tera Hertz (THz) communications, and pervasive
Artificial Intelligence (AI).
Some features may initially be introduced in one release but may be defined in an
elaborate fashion in a future release. In this white paper, the 3GPP work in R16 and R17
has been classified in the following categories: (i) service expansions, (ii) NR
enhancements, (iii) network architecture enhancements, and (iv) miscellaneous
enhancements. Sections 2 to 5 contain an overview of the 3GPP work based on these
categories. Our crystal ball view of 6G is given in Section 6. Finally, Section 7 summarizes
key findings of the paper.
Before diving into R16 and beyond, here is a quick look at key features of 5G Release 15
[1].
ı NR Air Interface. Like LTE, NR uses Orthogonal Frequency Division Multiplexing but
makes it highly flexible. For example, variable subcarrier spacing, flexible radio frame
structure including a self-contained slot, and carrier Bandwidth Parts are introduced.
Both sub-7 GHz spectrum and millimeter wave spectrum are supported. New high-
performance channel coding techniques of Low Density Parity Check Coding and polar
coding are defined. Spatial multiplexing techniques used in LTE, SU-MIMO and MU-
MIMO3, are enhanced in 5G. NR is a beamformed air interface with fewer beams at
low frequency bands and more beams at high frequency bands. 5G supports hybrid
beamforming, where both digital beamforming (available in LTE) and analog
beamforming are combined.
ı NG-RAN, NGC, and SBA. NG-RAN includes NR-based 6G Base Stations called next-
generation Node Bs or gNBs. A gNB can be decomposed or disaggregated into a
Central Unit and a Distributed Unit. Such gNB architecture reduces infrastructure and
transport costs and provides scalability. While LTE uses a limited number of nodes in
the Evolved Packet Core (EPC), 5G defines more Network Functions (NFs) that have
fewer responsibilities. The overall 5G system is based on SBA, where NFs
communicate with each other using service-based interfaces. SBA facilitates design
and deployment of the 5G system using virtualization and automation technologies
such as Network Functions Virtualization (NFV), Software Defined Networking (SDN),
OpenStack, and Orchestration.
ı Deployment Options. Release 15 fully defines two deployment options for the
network architecture, Non-standalone NR and standalone NR. Non-Standalone NR
with the EPC uses the LTE eNB as the master node and makes use of additional NR
radio resources of a gNB when possible. Standalone NR with the NGC does not rely
on LTE eNB at all and allows direct communications between the UE and the gNB.

3
SU-MIMO and MU-MIMO refer to Single User Multiple Input Multiple Output and Multi User Multiple Input Multiple
Output, respectively.

Rohde & Schwarz 5G Evolution: On the Path to 6G 6


ı Network Slicing. 3GPP introduces the concept of Network Slicing, where different
logical networks are created using the same physical network to cater to different
services and different customer requirements for a given service. Three standard
slices of eMBB, URLLC, and massive IoT are defined with the support for numerous
operator-defined Network Slices.
ı Edge Computing. 3GPP supports edge computing, where the applications are
located close to the UE. More specifically, 3GPP allows the selection of a gateway that
is close to the gNB. Since the use traffic passes through a local gateway instead of a
remote gateway located deep inside the core network, the end-to-end latency is
reduced, and transport requirements are also reduced.

Rohde & Schwarz 5G Evolution: On the Path to 6G 7


2 Service Expansion Beyond Release 15
Although the work done in R15 would be useful for URLLC and mMTC usage scenarios,
3GPP focused more on the eMBB usage scenario in R15. Figure 2.1 shows how 3GPP
expands services beyond eMBB-related services in R16 and beyond. Since 3GPP is
focusing on different verticals (i.e., industries), many of these services are related to
verticals. Note that these services are not necessarily distinct from each other; there could
be overlap among some services. These services are described in Sections 2.1 to 2.9.

2.1 5G LAN
Figure 2.2 shows the key concepts related to 5G Local Area Network (LAN) services
[TR22.821].

Rohde & Schwarz 5G Evolution: On the Path to 6G 8


Similar to a fixed or wireless LAN, a 5G LAN provides private communications among a
restricted set of UEs in the residential, enterprise, or industrial setting. A 5G system can
either augment or supplement an existing fixed or wireless LAN or completely replace such
LAN. A Private Virtual Network (PVN) can be created using a 5G system. Compared to a
traditional LAN, such 5G-based PVN offers benefits such as superior performance, long-
distance access, mobility support, and enhanced security.
In the residential setting, different devices in a single home or different users in an
apartment complex can obtain enhanced 5G QoS and maintain privacy and isolation of
communications where needed. In the enterprise setting, 5G LAN helps connect
computers, printers, scanners, and servers and facilitates access to such private and
secure environment in a large area or even across distant sites. In the industrial
environment, controllers, actuators, and sensors can be connected without the need for
wires and with low-latency communications. Reliable 5G wireless connectivity eliminates
the need for Ethernet cables in a hazardous environment or in moving or rotating parts and
facilitates factory reconfiguration to increase productivity. In case of IoT devices, two
endpoints of communications can even span countries such as a pipeline sensor in one
country and a pipeline valve in another country.

Rohde & Schwarz 5G Evolution: On the Path to 6G 9


2.2 Satellite Access
5G aims to support satellite access in addition to terrestrial access. Figure 2.3 summarizes
three main use case categories where a satellite network using 5G can be utilized.

The three use case categories are service ubiquity, service continuity, and service
scalability. These categories are not mutually exclusive; a given use case may belong to
more than one category.
ı Service Ubiquity. This category corresponds to the scenario where a terrestrial 5G
network is not providing coverage but a satellite network is. For example, some rural or
hard-to-reach areas may be unserved or underserved by a terrestrial network. Some
IoT use cases such as smart agriculture, remote area manufacturing, and off-shore
wind farms may not be economically viable for a terrestrial network but feasible in case
of a satellite access. If a terrestrial 5G Base Station (i.e., gNB) cannot connect to the
5GC using a typical fiber backhaul due to the lack of backhaul facilities, the satellite
access can come to the rescue. Since a satellite is helping with the implementation of
backhaul, such scenario is called a moving platform backhaul.
ı Service Continuity. In some cases, the UE initiates communications with a terrestrial
5G network but moves out of the terrestrial system’s coverage area. In such case,
service continuity can be ensured by using the satellite access. Example use cases
include asset tracking for IoT devices and people embarking on trains, planes, and
ships.

Rohde & Schwarz 5G Evolution: On the Path to 6G 10


ı Service Scalability. Since a satellite covers a large geographic area (e.g., the area
corresponding to hundreds or even thousands of terrestrial Base Stations), some
broadcast content such as Ultra High Definition content or 3-dimensional content can
be efficiently and economically transmitted to many users simultaneously. The
transmission of any non-time-sensitive data can be offloaded from a terrestrial network
to a satellite network as well.

2.3 Critical Medical Applications


5G can significantly influence the healthcare by enhancing preventive care, reducing time-
to-treatment and reducing overall costs [TR22.826].
In one category of critical medical applications, the patient and the medical specialists are
collocated. This category can be further classified into “static-local” or “moving-local”
depending upon whether the where the devices or people are moving while the care is
being delivered. For this category, since the care delivery occurs inside a facility, indoor
communication services occur in a private 5G network.
In another category of critical medical applications, the patient and the medical specialists
are located at different places. This category can be further classified into “static-remote”
or “moving-remote” depending upon whether the where the devices or people are moving
while the care is being delivered. For this category, since the care delivery occurs over a
large area, communication services are delivered using 5G PLMNs.
ı Private 5G Network Use Cases. In an Operating Room (OR), a teleoperation system
can be configured, where a surgeon is using a console and a robotic system is
operating on the patient under a surgeon’s guidance 4. URLLC and MEC can be
exploited, where the surgeon is working on the 3D model of the patient’s body and the
MEC application is processing the patient measurements superimposing from the
robotic system and the surgeon’s commands. In another use case of image-guided
surgery, real-time video is duplicated on multiple monitors in a wireless manner, where
an operator is controlling the imaging equipment using a video monitor in one part of
OR and the surgeon is observing the video on a separate monitor. In the Augmented
Reality Assisted Surgery, a surgeon uses a Head Mounted Display to carry out
surgery. Using the help of a MEC application, a combined real-time video stream and
reference medical imaging is displayed on the HMD to facilitate surgery.
ı 5G PLMN Use Cases. Distance is often a critical factor in emergency situations. 5G
helps overcome such distance limitations while providing critical care to a patient. In
one use case of emergency care, an ambulance nurse can carry out an ultrasound
examination at the incidence location and can perform suitable actions (e.g., applying

4 In certain cases of a robotic surgery, the robotic system can carry out more precise surgery though suitable
instrumentation (e.g., within very small areas) and tremors in a surgeon’s hand movements can be smoothed out by a
suitable Multi-access Edge Computing (MEC) application.

Rohde & Schwarz 5G Evolution: On the Path to 6G 11


pressure on specific body part to prevent bleeding or damage) under the guidance of a
remote medical specialist. A medical facility most suitable for the patient’s situation
(e.g., a heart hospital) can be selected. A variety of sensors can be placed on the
patient’s body and the Emergency Room (ER) can be prepared even before the
patient has been transported to the ER of a suitable facility. A remote surgery or
telesurgery is also possible, where a special surgeon does not need to be physically
present where the patient is, significantly expanding the reach of medical care to even
remote areas. In another use case, a connected ambulance can transmit important
patient data to the ER from the instant the ambulance has arrived at the incidence
scene to the point when the patient is brought to the operating table on the ER that has
been prepared to meet the patient’s needs in advance. In yet another use case, a
patient recently discharged from the hospital has sensors on the body that track
important measurements and keep the appropriate medical facility informed. Prompt
medical assistance is provided to the patient if a need arises.

2.4 5G V2X
While LTE can certainly address some Vehicle-to-Anything (V2X) use cases, 5G V2X
significantly expands the types of supportable use cases due to the high data rate, ultra-
low latency, and high reliability of 5G. Figure 2.4 summarizes the use case groups targeted
by 3GPP for 5G V2X [TR22.886].

Rohde & Schwarz 5G Evolution: On the Path to 6G 12


ı Platooning. Platooning is operating a group of vehicles in a tightly-coupled manner.
Such operation resembles a train with virtual strings between the vehicles. To maintain
distance between vehicles, the vehicles participating in platooning share their status
information such as speed, heading, and intentions (e.g., braking or acceleration).
Information about the platoon needs to be shared to vehicles that are not part of the
platoon so as not to disturb the platoon. Platooning enhances safety by maintaining a
safe distance, while reducing the required distances between vehicles. Platooning
reduces the overall fuel consumption and results in a smoother traffic flow. The
number of drivers needed to operate a given number of vehicles can be reduced as
well.
ı Advanced Driving. Vehicles can share a variety of information with one another to
enhance safety and avoid or prevent accidents. For example, cooperative collision
avoidance involves evaluation of the probability of an accident and coordinated
maneuvers using safety messages (Cooperative Awareness Message or CAM and
Decentralized Environmental Notification Message or DENM), sensor data, and
commands for braking and accelerating. In case of emergency trajectory alignment,
after a vehicle learns about road obstacles through on-board sensors, it calculates a
maneuver to avoid an accident and informs other vehicles in the proximity. Other
vehicles can then align their trajectories to perform the emergency reaction in a
cooperative manner. Similarly, at an intersection, an LDM (Local Dynamic Map) server
can monitor the road using a road radar and a traffic signal, generate LDM information
and deliver such information to the vehicle through a Roadside Unit (RSU).
ı Extended Sensors. A vehicle can share its raw or processed sensor data with other
vehicles and RSUs to create situational awareness. Such information sharing enables
a vehicle to make tactical or maneuver decisions. For example, sharing of sensor data
including high-resolution videos can be used to detect objects that are not directly
visible to the local sensors (e.g. behind other vehicles, on curves or behind the corners
of buildings).
ı Remote Driving. In remote driving, a vehicle is controlled remotely by a human
operator or a cloud server. For example, buses are driven on pre-determined routes. A
human operator can drive buses with the help of suitable data such as video feeds
containing outside bus views and inside bus views. A vehicle can be remotely driven to
a suitable destination such as home or a medical facility if the human driver is unable
to drive due to a personal situation (e.g., fatigue) or a health condition.

2.5 UAVs or Drones


An Unmanned Aerial Vehicle (UAV) or drone is a low-altitude (e.g., up to few hundred
meters) flying vehicle that can be used to provide communications for a short time and/or
in a limited geographic area. A UAV typically operates for up to 1 hour [TR22.829]. Hence,
after providing communications for a suitable time period, the UAV returns to its base for
charging. A UAV may be controlled by a controller in cloud and delay-sensitive
applications can be supported using Multi-access Edge Computing (MEC). Artificial

Rohde & Schwarz 5G Evolution: On the Path to 6G 13


Intelligence (AI) can also be used to control UAVs. Since traditional antennas in a cellular
network use down-tilting, the support for UAVs requires adjustment of existing antenna
systems or separate antenna systems. Here are example use cases where UAVs can be
utilized.
ı Live Video Broadcast. A 360˚ spherical camera can be mounted on a UAV. This UAV
can communicate with a gNB on the ground to send the 4k/8k video to a server in the
cloud. People with AR glasses can then enjoy live video broadcast as if they were
present at the venue.
ı Temporary Radio Access with Internet Connectivity. In disaster or emergency
situations, a UAV can act as a gNB (where it connects to a core network using
wireless backhaul) or a relay (where it connects to a ground gNB that provides
connectivity to the 5G core) to provide coverage quickly and cost-effectively.
ı Isolated Radio Access with Private Connectivity. In some situations such as
construction in an isolated area, there is no traditional cellular radio access coverage
or backhaul. A UAV can provide coverage quickly and cost-effectively compared to
ground-based solutions. The UEs in a private group can communicate with one
another using the UAV.
ı Swarm of UAVs for Logistics. A group of UAVs can be used in a coordinated fashion
to deliver packages. Even in disaster situations, medicine and food supplies can be
delivered when the ground infrastructure has been damaged and has become
unusable.

2.6 Audio-Visual Production


A 5G network can facilitate Audio-Visual (AV) production services by providing flexibility,
reducing costs, and reducing communications setup times. Media could be produced
within or outside the premises of a production company. Here are examples of the AV
production use cases where 3GPP can contribute [TR22.827].
ı Studio-based Production. Media could be produced in a studio using wireless
microphones connected to a variety of audio sources including singers and musical
instruments and audio mixers. A 5G system can replace costly and inflexible fixed
infrastructure.
ı Newsgathering. This use case represents unplanned ad-hoc production such as
covering of an important event. A 5G system can be set up quickly to produce relevant
AV media and supply such media to the central facility for further processing and
distribution.
ı Planned Outside Broadcasts. An elaborate AV infrastructure with numerous
cameras, microphones, and mixers can be installed for a planned event (e.g., for
elections or games). A 5G system can facilitate media transmission from such event
facilities to the central production base. Some media preprocessing could also be
carried out locally. Sometimes, a large coverage area is needed (e.g., a cycling event),

Rohde & Schwarz 5G Evolution: On the Path to 6G 14


and, an airborne 5G NG-RAN can be deployed. Examples of audio production use
cases include onsite live audio presentation (with mixing of the presenter talk and
audience questions) and audio streaming (with mixing of singer voice and audio
streams of instruments, amplification of the mixed signal, and distribution of combined
audio streams on loudspeakers in the hall). Suitable devices can communicate with a
5G system to facilitate production and distribution of media.
ı Live Immersive Media Service. Multiple cameras can be installed on various stadium
locations and players to create an immersive experience for the local audience and
global audience. For example, an event at the Olympics can be enjoyed through such
immersive experience.

2.7 Cyber-Physical Control Applications


Cyber-physical control applications are control applications that control physical processes
of cyber-physical systems, which consist of engineered and interacting networks of
physical components and computational components. Cyber-physical control applications
can be applied to verticals such as industry automation and energy automation. Here are
example use cases related to these verticals [TR22.104] [TR22.832].
ı Factories of the Future. The manufacturing industry is experiencing the 4th industrial
revolution or Industry 4.0, which aims for enhanced flexibility, versatility, resource
efficiency, cost efficiency, worker support, and quality of industrial production and
logistics [TR22.104]. A cyber-physical system is an enabling technology, where 5G
can be utilized. 5G can be applied to various aspects of automated factories such as
factory automation, process automation, Human-Machine Interfaces and production IT,
logistics and warehousing, and monitoring and maintenance. Factory automation
involves robotics and computer-aided manufacturing and is seeing the rising trends of
modular and mobile production systems. Process automation involves automation of
processes that control production and handling of substances such as chemicals,
foods, and beverages. 5G can help establish communications among sensors,
actuators, and controllers. Various HMI devices such as panels associated with a
production line and headsets exploiting AR/VR (e.g., step-by-step support from a
remote expert for a specific task) would benefit from 5G connectivity. Logistics and
warehousing involve control of the flow and storage of substances using mechanisms
such as automated guided vehicles (AGVs) and fork lifts. Monitoring and maintenance
involve processing of suitable sensor data to ensure long-term operations of the
factory and to perform predictive maintenance.
ı Electric-power Distribution. The emerging power distribution grid is called Smart
Grid, where insights are used to manage the distribution of power. In particular, the
rising focus on renewable energy (e.g., solar and wind energy), bi-directional electricity
flows, and increasingly dynamic power system require intelligent management of
suitable resources. 5G can help connect a large number of local power generators
such as solar power units and wind turbines to the Smart Grid. Fault detection and

Rohde & Schwarz 5G Evolution: On the Path to 6G 15


automatic restoration of electricity can be facilitated by 5G-based communications
among suitable measurement and control mechanisms.
ı Central Power Generation. Centralized power generation involves conversion of
chemical energy and other forms of energy into electric power. Large gas turbines,
steam turbines, combined-cycle power plants, and wind farms help create electric-
power outputs of 100 MW or more. 5G can facilitate operations, monitoring and
maintenance of such plants.
Time-Sensitive Networking (TSN) is an important aspect of cyber-physical systems. 5G is
expected to work with IEEE802.1-based TSN. Furthermore, Device-to-Device
communication may also be used along with UE-Network communications. Finally, since
Ethernet-based communication is quite common in factories today, 5G-LAN service would
play an important role in automated factories.

2.8 Positioning
While 4G LTE and 5G Phase 1 can certainly support location-based services, use cases
are being expanded significantly in Release 16 and beyond due to increased positioning
accuracy. Figure 2.5 summarizes example verticals that can benefit from positioning use
cases [10].

Rohde & Schwarz 5G Evolution: On the Path to 6G 16


ı Mission-Critical. In emergency situations, accurate positioning enables a user to get
help from first responders by contacting Public Safety Answering Point (PSAP) even in
challenging environments such as urban canyon and deep indoors.
ı Location Based Services. AR goggles and head-up displays (HUDs) can make use
of accurate positioning to superimpose contextual information on the real-world view of
the user to facilitate navigation, video recording, and identification of targets. A shared
bike service can benefit from accurate positioning where users can pick up and drop
off bikes at suitable locations. Outdoor sports and leisure activities such as
motorcycling, skiing and gaming can also make use of accurate positioning.
ı Industry and eHealth. Accurate positioning is critical in many factory automation
applications including assembly and container management. In a hospital setting,
people and medical equipment can be located accurately to facilitate prompt and high-
quality care.
ı Road. In the vehicular setting, 3D positioning facilitates traffic monitoring,
management, and control for smoother traffic flows to reduce commute times, save
fuel, and support emergency situations. Road User Charging (RUC) levies a charge on
a user based on the use of the road infrastructure.

Rohde & Schwarz 5G Evolution: On the Path to 6G 17


ı Railway and Maritime. Asset tracking in railway and maritime applications increases
transportation efficiency, reduces the possibility of lost or stolen containers, and
facilitates logistics.
ı Aerial. UAVs or drones can significantly benefit from accurate positioning for
automatic landing as well as personal or professional missions (e.g., delivery of
medical supplies). Images or sensor data (e.g., Infrared sensor data) can be merged
with positioning data to facilitate UAV operations.
ı E-911 and Regulatory. The UE location supports E-911 calls and helps meet (and
even exceed) regulatory requirements for Lawful Intercept.

2.9 Haptic Services


Haptic is a sense perceived by touching of an object. Haptic involves tactile sensing that
involves touching of surfaces and kinesthetic sensing that involves sensing of movement in
the body [TR22.987]. Recent advances in haptic feedback devices have been applied in
different field (e.g., haptic feedback from game controllers such as joysticks and steering
wheels to simulate the tactile sense and/or kina esthetic sense for a player in a VR game).
A 5G system could be used to deliver haptic feedback related to vibrations, temperature,
texture or electronic stimulus. Examples of haptic senses include vibrotactile sense, shear
sense, thermal sense, and pneumatic sense.
A haptic service is delivery of haptic information from one party to another. Such service
could be initiated by the UE or the network and could be delivered asynchronously or
synchronously. Here are example haptic services.
ı Haptic Emoticon Delivery. This service delivers the haptic information or haptic
emoticon for enhanced communications experience by conveying emotions or feelings
such as laughter and heartbeat. The haptic emoticon could be conveyed
synchronously in real-time along with voice and video. The haptic emoticon could also
be conveyed asynchronously in SMS, MMS, or IM.
ı Customized Alerting. This service replaces the default or customized alerting tones
by a multimodal tone that combines customized alerting haptic with sound, video and
other senses together. When the calling party tries to establish a call to the called
party, a Customized Alerting Haptic information along with the typical information
about the incoming call is sent to the called party’s UE. The called party’s UE
generates suitable Customized Alerting Haptic feedback for the user.
ı Call Waiting Alerting. A subscriber may be notified of an incoming call through haptic
feedback when engaged in an active call or holding a call. Such haptic feedback could
be customized for different callers. The haptic feedback results in more seamless
communications experience by avoiding the interruption.
ı Accident or Health Crisis. An elderly person may fall, triggering an alert to a suitable
server and enabling prompt assistance to the fallen person. Even if a person is
decapitated, help would be on the way due to automatic handling during the crisis.

Rohde & Schwarz 5G Evolution: On the Path to 6G 18


3 NR Enhancements Beyond Release 15
3GPP created a high-performance and ultra-flexible NR air interface in Release 15. The
NR air interface is expected to serve as a strong foundation for subsequent releases.
Figure 3.1 lists potential NR enhancements5 in R16 and beyond in support of various new
or enhanced services described in Section 2.0. These NR features are explained in
Sections 3.1 to 3.6.

53GPP extensively studied an adventurous multiple access scheme called Non Orthogonal Multiple Access (NOMA) but
decided not to pursue it further. Hence, OFDMA (and optionally SC-FDMA) would continue to be the multiple access
scheme of choice for the near-term future.

Rohde & Schwarz 5G Evolution: On the Path to 6G 19


3.1 Integrated Access and Backhaul (IAB)
Integrated Access and Backhaul (IAB) means that spectrum can be shared between (i)
wireless access to serve UEs and (ii) wireless backhaul to enable Base Station-Core
Network connectivity. IAB can be used for outdoor small cell deployments, indoors, or
even mobile relays (e.g. on buses or trains) in future. AIB can be viewed as a cost-
effective deployment solution that simplifies the radio-core connectivity and reduces the
complexity of the associated fiber-based transport network. Consider Figure 3.2, adapted
from [TR38.874], where example IAB deployments are illustrated.

In Figure 3.2, two Base Stations, IAB-node X and IAB-node Z, use the spectrum to provide
wireless access to their UEs and to communicate with the Base Station IAB-donor that
provides connectivity with the Core Network (CN). IAB-node does not have direct
connectivity with the CN, while IAB-donor has CN connectivity. Furthermore, IAB-donor
can provide wireless access to its own UEs. The 5G gNBs can be decomposed or
disaggregated into a Central Unit (CU) and a Distributed Unit (DU) as specified in Release

Rohde & Schwarz 5G Evolution: On the Path to 6G 20


15. IAB also supports a multi-hop link, where the Base Station IAB-node A connects to
IAB-donor through IAB-node Y. Network synchronization among Base Stations is
important for an effective IAB deployment. Furthermore, Cross Link Interference (CLI)
between the access link and the backhaul link should be managed effectively.
The IAB-node contains a DU and an MT6 (Mobile Termination). The IAB-node uses DU to
establish RLC-channels toward UEs and toward MTs of downstream IAB-nodes. The IAB-
node uses the MT to connect to an upstream IAB-node or the IAB-donor. The IAB-donor
contains a CU for its own DU as well as the DUs of all of its IAB-nodes and a DU to
support its own UEs and MTs of downstream IAB-nodes.
Here are potential characteristics or features of IAB.
ı In-Band and Out-of-Band Backhaul. In-Band backhauling implies that the access
link and the backhaul link at least partially overlap in frequency. Out-of-Band
backhauling does not have such frequency overlap. Both sub-6 GHz spectrum and
above-6 GHz spectrum are supported.
ı RAT and SA and NSA Modes. While NR-based backhaul is the primary focus, LTE-
based backhaul may be supported. Furthermore, the IAB-node may operate in
Standalone NR mode or Non-Standalone NR mode.
ı Topology Adaptation. This feature autonomously reconfigures the backhaul network
to mitigate the effects of blockage and loading variations. Blockage may occur due to
vehicles, foliage, or new construction. Loading variations and subsequent node
congestion could occur due to traffic variations.

3.2 NR-Unlicensed (NR-U)


LTE-based Licensed Assisted Access (LAA) utilizes licensed spectrum for an anchor
carrier frequency and unlicensed spectrum carriers on an opportunistic basis to improve
throughput. LAA uses Carrier Aggregation across licensed spectrum and unlicensed
spectrum to transmit data in parallel. Since unlicensed spectrum may have a large amount
of unlicensed spectrum available at an instant, LAA tries to make use of such spectrum
when interference is below a threshold. Release 16 reuses the concept of LAA with NR-
based air interface and supports additional deployment scenarios using unlicensed
spectrum [TR38.889]. Potential deployment scenarios for NR-U are summarized below.

6
Mobile Termination (MT) terminates the radio interface layers of the backhaul Uu interface toward the IAB-donor or the
IAB-node.

Rohde & Schwarz 5G Evolution: On the Path to 6G 21


Scenario A: CA between Licensed Spectrum NR (Primary Cell or PCell7) and
Unlicensed Spectrum NR (Secondary Cell or SCell). An NR SCell in the unlicensed
spectrum may have both DL and UL, or DL-only. A gNB serving a small cell can easily
implement such CA.
Scenario B: Dual Connectivity between Licensed Spectrum LTE (PCell) and
Unlicensed Spectrum NR (Primary SCell or PSCell). Dual connectivity implies two
independent schedulers at two Base Stations, which are an LTE eNB and an NR gNB in
this scenario.
Scenario C: Standalone NR in Unlicensed Spectrum. In this scenario, there is no need
for the anchor carrier frequency to be in licensed spectrum. NR is used solely in the
unlicensed spectrum. Such scenario is like MulteFire, where LTE is used in the unlicensed
spectrum with no dependence whatsoever on the licensed spectrum.
Scenario D: DL in Unlicensed Spectrum and UL in Licensed Spectrum. An NR-based
gNB uses unlicensed spectrum for the downlink but licensed spectrum for the uplink for a
given UE. This scenario targets DL-heavy traffic situations such as video streaming.
Scenario E: Dual Connectivity between Licensed Spectrum NR (PCell) and
Unlicensed Spectrum NR (PSCell). In this scenario, one gNB uses licensed spectrum to
provide PCell, while the second gNB uses unlicensed spectrum.
The initial focus of NR-U is on unlicensed spectrum below about 7 GHz, with the support
for higher unlicensed spectrum expected in future releases. Example frequency bands
being targeted for NR-U include widely used 5 GHz band (e.g., 5.150 GHz to 5.925 GHz)
and new 6 GHz band (e.g. US 5.925 GHz to 7.125 GHz in the U.S. and 5.925 GHz to
6.425 GHz in Europe).

3.3 URLLC Enhancements


R15 NR defines the frame structure that can be used as the baseline to support URLLC
applications., However, for enhanced AR/VR for the entertainment industry, factory
automation, transport Industry (e.g., ITS use cases and remote driving use case), and
electrical power distribution, additional NR enhancements are needed to increase reliability
(e.g., from 10-5 to 10-6 error rate), to reduce latency (e.g., on the order of 0.5 ms to 1 ms),
and to ensure tight synchronization (e.g., on the order of few microseconds). Figure 3.3
summarizes target enhancements to support more URLLC use cases.

7Primary Cell or PCell provides an RRC signaling connection (and quite often radio resources for user traffic) to the UE
on a specific carrier frequency. Secondary Cell or SCell typically provides additional radio resources for user traffic on a
separate carrier frequency.

Rohde & Schwarz 5G Evolution: On the Path to 6G 22


ı PHY/L1 and MAC Enhancements. Enhancements are being targeted for several
physical layer aspects such as PDCCH, PUSCH, UCI, and HARQ/scheduling.
PDDCHs may use compact DCI for faster processing and configurable field sizes.
More PDCCHs may be monitored within a slot. PUSCH may be repeated in a slot or in
consecutive slots. UCI may support more than one PUCCH for HARQ-ACK
transmission, and, at least two HARQ-ACK codebooks may be supported to cater to
different services for a given UE. Out-of-order HARQ-ACK is supported, where the
HARQ-ACK for the second PDSCH can be sent before the HARQ-ACK for the first
PDSCH. A second PUSCH may be scheduled before the first PUSCH is over.
ı UL Inter-UE Transmission Prioritization/Multiplexing. Example enhancements
include UL cancellation and enhanced UL power control. The UE may be sent an
indication about UL cancellation. The UE then cancels the UL transmission if the
transmission has already started. Otherwise, the UE does not start the transmission.
Potential power control enhancements include dynamic power boost for URLLC and
enhanced TPC parameters such as larger TPC range and finer granularity of transmit
power adjustments.
ı Enhanced UL Grant-free Transmissions. R15 supports configured grants to facilitate
grant-free transmissions in the uplink. Beyond R15, there can be multiple
simultaneously active configured Type 1 and Type 2 grants.

Rohde & Schwarz 5G Evolution: On the Path to 6G 23


3.4 Industrial IoT (IIoT) Enhancements
While Industrial IoT would certainly benefit from the URLLC enhancements summarized in
Section 3.3, Industrial IoT has specific requirements that need additional enhancements.
For example, wireless Ethernet and Time Sensitive Networking (TSN) need to be
supported. Here are IIoT-specific enhancements being targeted by 3GPP [TR38.825].
ı PDCP Duplication. R15 supports PDCP duplication for increased reliability. Beyond
R15, multiple RLC entities (e.g., up to a limit such as 4) may be configured to allow
multiple PDCP copies of data. The actual subset of RLC entities can be controlled
dynamically (e.g., using a MAC Control Element). Since duplication consumes more
resources, mechanisms to increase resource utilization efficiency become important
while PDCP duplication is active. Selective duplication, selective discard, and
activation/deactivation of PDP duplication enhancements are example of such
mechanisms.
ı Intra-UE Prioritization. To cater to higher-priority IIoT traffic, suitable prioritization
methods can be helpful. Examples include higher priority for a later dynamic grant
compared to an earlier dynamic grant, higher priority for a configured grant compared
to a dynamic grant, and resolution of the transmission conflict between the Scheduling
Request for a higher-priority traffic and lower-priority user traffic.
ı TSN Reference Timings. To facilitate precise timing synchronization, reference times
can be delivered from the gNB to the UE using broadcast and/or unicast RRC
signaling. The goal for the timing granularity is at least 50 ns.
ı Scheduling. To facilitate QoS-aware scheduling of TSN traffic, information about TSN
traffic patterns such as message periodicity, message size, DL message arrival time at
gNB, UL message arrival at the UE could be provisioned from Core Network to RAN.
Multiple simultaneously active Configured Grant (CG) and Semi Persistent Scheduling
(SPS) configurations for a given BWP of a UE would be supported. Additionally,
support for shorter SPS periodicities than the existing ones would further reduce
latency.
ı Wireless Ethernet. Ethernet header compression would be supported to reduce
overhead.

Rohde & Schwarz 5G Evolution: On the Path to 6G 24


3.5 New Frequency Bands
In R15, 3GPP initially defined Frequency Range 1 to cover 450 MHz to 6 GHz and
Frequency Range 2 (FR2) to cover 24.250 GHz to 52.6 GHz. FR1 was later enlarged in
R15 to cover 410 MHz to 7.125 GHz to include the 6 GHz unlicensed spectrum in the
higher frequencies and any available spectrum around 400 MHz (e.g., T-GSM 410 or GSM
Trunking System from about 410 MHz to about 430 MHz). 3GPP is exploring further
increase in frequency bands in the 7.125 GHz- 24.250 GHz and above 52.6 GHz. The
7.125-24.250 GHz frequency range may be divided into multiple frequency bands such as
7.125 GHz to about 10-13 GHz, 10-13 GHz to 16-18 GHz, and 16-18 GHz to 24.250 GHz.
The existing FR1/FR2 may be extended or new FRs may be defined.
Higher frequencies such as those greater than 52.6 GHz are characterized by challenges
of larger propagation path loss, higher phase noise, larger insertion losses in the RF front-
end, larger Low Noise Amplifier (LNA) noise and Analog-to-Digital Converter (ADC) noise,
and lower power amplifier efficiency compared to lower frequencies 8. However, these
higher frequencies offer the benefit of large channel bandwidths and subsequently high
throughput, low latency, and high capacity. Figure 3.4 depicts example use cases that
could be supported using above-52.6 GHz spectrum.

8
3GPP is studying several waveforms that are different from currently-used OFDM. These waveforms may be better
suited for higher frequencies.

Rohde & Schwarz 5G Evolution: On the Path to 6G 25


Network Densification. With the Ultra High definition displays, AR/VR Apps, and mobile
3D projects, data traffic demand is expected to soar further. To meet ever-increasing data
traffic demand, network densification is an effective mechanism. Higher frequency bands
are suitable for small cell deployments needed for network densification.
Backhaul and Fronthaul. Availability of large bandwidth at higher frequencies makes
them suitable for wireless backhaul. Decomposition or disaggregation of the gNB requires
two logical parts of the gNB to communicate with each other. In one possible scenario,
baseband and RF portions can communicate with each other using wireless fronthaul.
Indoor Hotspots and Stadiums. Heavy indoor or outdoor data traffic demand can be met
by deploying large-bandwidth high-frequency hotspots. Furthermore, higher frequency
reuse is possible due to small cells.
ITS. Vehicle-to-Vehicle and Vehicle-to-Infrastructure communications in an Intelligent
Transport System (ITS) are typically carried out over short distances. Large bandwidths
enable wireless transfer of High Definition videos and sensor data between the vehicles
and of High Definition maps from the infrastructure to the vehicles.
Industrial IoT. Factory automation can benefit from private 5G networks using high-
frequency spectrum in a local area with significant frequency reuse due to small cells.
Larger subcarrier spacing can reduce latency and wider channel bandwidths can achieve
high data rates and high reliability.

3.6 Miscellaneous NR Enhancements


ı UE Power Saving. The UE battery life is an important aspect of the user’s overall
service experience. Several mechanisms can be employed to reduce the UE battery
consumption can be reduced in the connected mode and non-connected mode
[TR38.840]. For example, monitoring of control channels such as PDCCHs, RRM
measurements, suitable transitions between the connected mode and power-efficient
mode, adaptation of MIMO layers, BWP switching, efficient paging, cross-slot
scheduling, and flexible DRX cycles can be used to influence the UE’s power
consumption. The UE may provide assistance information such as mobility history and
power preferences, which can be used by the network to minimize power consumption
while avoiding significant adverse impact on the service performance (e.g., latency).
ı MIMO Enhancements. R15 provides benefits such as enhanced codebooks,
Reference Signal design flexibility, and support for advanced antenna techniques for
both sub-6 GHz and above-6 GHz deployments. Beyond R15, MIMO can be further
enhanced to increase robustness, reduce overhead, and/or reduce latency. For
example, MU-MIMO can be enhanced by supporting more than two layers in CSI Type
II feedback, reducing PAPR for Reference Signals, control signaling for non-coherent
joint transmission, more antenna panels, enhanced beam failure recovery, and
enhanced DL/UL beam selection [24].

Rohde & Schwarz 5G Evolution: On the Path to 6G 26


ı Mobility Enhancements. R15 uses LTE-like handover, where the network controls
mobility based on measurements provided by the UE. However, meeting the 0 ms
interruption time target can be a challenge in the current break-before-make approach
when there is a change in the gNB or Secondary Cell Group (SCG). In particular, the
beamformed NR interface introduces complexities. Example mobility enhancements
include Random Access Channel (RACH)-less handover, fast handover failure
recovery, and handover or Secondary Cell Group (SCG) change with simultaneous
connectivity with source cell and target cell. Various R15-supported scenarios such as
intra-frequency handover, inter-frequency handover, Inter-CU handover, intra-CU/inter-
DU handover, and intra-DU handover would be supported in conjunction with mobility
enhancements.
ı NR Positioning. NR-based positioning techniques aim to achieve <3 m accuracy in
horizontal and vertical positioning for indoor deployments and <10 m accuracy in
horizontal positioning and < 3m accuracy in vertical positioning for outdoor
deployments [TR38.855]. New positioning reference signals would be used. Example
positioning techniques include DL Time Difference of Arrival (DL-TDOA), DL Angle of
Departure (DL-AoD), UL- Time Difference of Arrival (UL-TDOA), UL Angle of Arrival
(UL-AoA), Round Trip Time (RTT), and Enhanced Cell Identity (E-CID). The UE and
the gNB make measurements in support of these techniques. The UE observes
reference signals from serving and neighboring gNBs and makes DL measurements
such as Reference Signal Time Difference (RSTD), Reference Signal Received Power
(RSRP), and UE RX-TX time difference. In the radio network, these measurements are
made at serving and neighboring gNBs: Relative Time of Arrival (RTOA), Angle of
Arrival (AoA) measurements (including Azimuth and Zenith Angles), RSRP, and gNB
RX-TX time difference.
ı CLI and RIM. In a TDD system, when two gNBs use the same slot format on a given
carrier frequency, co-channel interference and adjacent channel interference are
minimized. However, if dynamic TDD is implemented and if gNBs independently
choose their slot formats, co-channel crosslink interference (CLI) occurs. 3GPP’s work
includes definition of reference signals and measurements to quantify CLI,
investigation of CLI mitigation mechanisms, and identification of coexistence
requirements [TR38.828]. Another interference of interest is remote interference,
where a remote gNB signal from a macro cell undergoes tropospheric bending and
causes interference to another macro gNB. 3GPP is exploring Remote Interference
Management (RIM) mechanisms (e.g., a reference signal to facilitate detection of
remote interference and adjustment of the Guard Period) to mitigate such remote
interference.
ı NR-Light. Smartphones and URLLC-based devices are high-end devices with
stringent performance requirements related to data rates, latency, and/or reliability.
Many IoT devices are low-end devices (e.g., smart water meters and smart sensors)
with relaxed latency and data rate requirements. However, devices such as smart
wearables are somewhere between these two extremes; they have mid-range cost
and performance requirements. NR-Light aims to reduce the complexity for such mid-
range devices.

Rohde & Schwarz 5G Evolution: On the Path to 6G 27


4 5G Network Architecture Enhancements
While the network architecture defined in Release 15 is quite flexible, 3GPP is making
enhancements to further expand the utility of the network. Examples of network
enhancements are related to V2X, network automation, Common API Framework (CAPIF),
and IP Multimedia Subsystem (IMS).
ı V2X Enhancements. The 5G System (5GS) undergoes several enhancements to
support NR-based V2X. For example, NR-based PC5 and Uu interfaces are supported
[TS23.287]. The UE provides V2X capabilities to the 5GC and receives V2X
configuration parameters (e.g., destination Layer 2 IDs for device-to-device
communications) over the N1 interface. The Policy Control Function (PCF) provides
V2X policy parameters to the UE. A V2X Application Server exchanges unicast V2X
data with the UE in the downlink and the uplink. The Unified Data Repository (UDR)
stores V2X service parameters, while the Unified Data Management (UDM) manages
V2X subscription.
ı Network Automation. A step toward network automation was taken when Network
Data Analytics Function (NWDAF) was defined in Release 15. 3GPP is working on
enhanced network automation by enhancing NWDAF interactions with other Network
Functions and Operations, Administration, and Management (OAM) [15]. In particular,
NFs and OAM provide raw data to NWDAF, and, NWDAF calculates network
analytics. These analytics can be used by NFs and OAM to modify parameters that
influence network operations (e.g., load balancing via cell selection and handover
parameters). While NWDAF would typically be a centralized entity, its local instance
may exist in a given geographic area in support of edge computing. Furthermore, NFs
may also calculate network analytics and convey those to NWDAF. Artificial
Intelligence (AI) techniques can be applied to NWDAF or any suitable NF. 3GPP would
continue to define NWDAF inputs and outputs for various functions. AI techniques
themselves would be implementation-specific with suitable measurement support from
3GPP NFs.
ı Enhanced CAPIF (eCAPIF). Release 15 defines CAPIF to enable third parties to
interface the 3GPP network (e.g., LTE or 5G) in support of various applications
including edge applications. 3GPP is enhancing the original CAPIF by adding features
such as support for multiple API providers, charging requirements, multiple
deployment models, and support for both EPS and 5GS network exposure.
ı IMS. 3GPP is enhancing the IMS network so that 5G capabilities such as Network
Slicing can be exploited [16]. IMS modifications to interface with SBA of the 5GC are
being investigated. Any IMS changes to support local traffic and associated service
continuity are being studied. Support for URLLC such as a local instance of IMS as
opposed to typical centralized IMS is also being explored.
ı Edge Computing. In Release 15, 3GPP defined the support for edge computing,
where a UPF close to the UE could be selected for user traffic to derive benefits such

Rohde & Schwarz 5G Evolution: On the Path to 6G 28


as reduced end-to-end latency and reduced transport bandwidth requirements. 3GPP
is exploring an architecture to enhance edge computing for a 3GPP network [14]. In
this architecture, the UE has an Application Client and an Edge Enabler Client. The
Edge Data Network, which would be close to the UE, has an Edge Application Server
and an Edge Enabler Server. The core network also has an Edge Data Network
Configuration Server. The Edge Enabler Server is responsible for the provisioning of
configuration information to enable the exchange of Application Data Traffic between
the Edge Application Client and the Edge Application Server. The Edge Enabler
Server also conveys information about the Edge Application Servers (e.g., availability
of servers) to the Edge Enabler Client. Edge Data Network Configuration Server
provisions the Edge Data Network configuration information in the Edge Enabler
Client. Such information includes service area information and information needed to
establish a connection with an Edge Enabler Server (e.g., Uniform Resource
Identifier). Deployment of edge computing Apps requires communications between the
3GPP management system (e.g., OAM) and non-3GPP management systems such as
ETSI Multi-access Edge Computing (MEC) and ETSI NFV MANagement and
Orchestration (MANO).

Rohde & Schwarz 5G Evolution: On the Path to 6G 29


5 Miscellaneous Enhancements
This section looks at auxiliary enhancements such as SEAL, SON, and security.

5.1 SEAL
Service Enabler Architecture Layer for Verticals (SEAL) defines an application-level
functional architecture to support a variety of verticals including V2X and mission-critical
services [13]. SEAL provides services such as group management, configuration
management, location management, identity management, key management, and network
resource management. SEAL defines functional models for both application layer support
aspects for verticals and signaling Control Plane 9. For the application layer support, there
are two functional models, on-network and off-network. The on-network model means that
the UE is connected to the radio network via the Uu interface, and, the off-network model
is applicable when a UE is using the PC5 interface. Figure 5.1 illustrates the on-network
model.

9The signaling Control Plane involves exchange of Session Initiation Protocol (SIP) signaling between the UE and the
SIP Core. The SIP Core could be IMS-based or non-IMS-based. Such SIP signaling helps with SIP session
management, subscriptions, and authentication.

Rohde & Schwarz 5G Evolution: On the Path to 6G 30


The UE has one or more Vertical Application Layer (VAL) clients and one or more SEAL
clients. Within the UE, VAL and SEAL clients communicate with each other using SEAL-C.
SEAL offers its services such as group management and configuration management to
VAL. The UE communicates with VAL and SEAL servers using an LTE-based or 5G-
based VAL-Uu and SEAL-Uu. The VAL-Uu interface supports unicast and multicast
delivery modes. VAL and SEAL servers communicate using SEAL-S. It is also possible for
two SEAL servers to communicate with each other using SEAL-X. The SEAL server uses
VAL-UDB with the VAL User Database (which could be part of Home Subscriber Server) to
store and retrieve user profiles. VAL clients and VAL servers are application-specific for a
given vertical, while SEAL provides a common framework to multiple VAL applications.
In the off-network mode, VAL clients on two UEs communicate with each other using VAL-
PC5 and SEAL clients on two UEs communicate with each other using SEAL-PC5. In such
mode, one UE can act as UE-to-Network Relay to enable suitable UEs to access VAL
servers over VAL-Uu.
VAL and SEAL services may be provided by PLMN operators or third parties.

5.2 5G SON
A Self Organizing Network (SON) was earlier defined for LTE. SON includes self-
configuration, self-optimization, and self-healing. Furthermore, a given SON algorithm's
deployment could be centralized, distributed, or hybrid (i.e., combination of centralized and
distributed). A SON process is an open loop process when some human intervention
exists. In the closed loop SON process, there is no human involvement except in case of
exceptions! Figure 5.2 shows example SON algorithms or use cases in 5G. 5G SON
algorithms can be categorized as LTE-like algorithms and new 5G algorithms [17].

ı LTE-like SON Algorithms. Since LTE and 5G shares several similarities, many SON
algorithms defined for LTE can be applied to 5G. Examples of LTE-like algorithms that
can be extended to 5G include Automatic Neighbor Relation (ANR), Physical Cell

Rohde & Schwarz 5G Evolution: On the Path to 6G 31


Identifier (PCI) Configuration, Random Access Channel (RACH) Optimization, Mobility
Robustness Optimization (MRO), Load Balancing Optimization (LBO), and Capacity
and Coverage Optimization (CCO). ANR enables automatic creation of a neighbor list
for a given cell to facilitate handover decision-making and UE measurement
configuration. PCI Configuration aims to address PCI related issues such as PCI
collision (two neighbors with the same PCI) and PCI confusion (a cell with two
neighbors using the same PCI). RACH Optimization, as the name suggests, optimizes
RACH parameters to improve the accessibility performance for RACH. MRO adjusts
handover parameters to address issues such as early handover, late handover, and
handover to an incorrect cell. LBO redistributes users among cells by adjusting cell
selection and handover parameters. CCO observes capacity and coverage metrics
and adjusts suitable network configuration and operational parameters to enhance
capacity and coverage.
ı New SON Algorithms. Network Slicing is a new concept defined in 5G. Hence,
several SON algorithms related to Network slicing are new algorithms in 5G. Examples
of new 5G SON algorithms include Automatic Network Slice Instance (NSI) Creation,
NSI Resource Allocation Optimization, Cross-Slice Network Resource Optimization,
and Service Quality Optimization. Automatic NSI Creation enables the network
operator to create a set of NSIs on demand based on customer requirements, which
involves instantiation and configuration of NFs and connectivity among the NFs. NSI
Resource Allocation Optimization observes NSI performance data such as numbers of
registered UEs and Protocol Data Unit (PDU) sessions and QoS measures to identify
traffic patterns, predict the demand for network resources, and optimize the allocation
of network resources. Cross-Slice Network Resource Optimization aims to optimize
allocation of virtual and physical resources for NG-RAN and NGC across NSIs.
Service Quality Optimization involves observation of performance data for a given
service (e.g., average latency for URLLC) and adjustment of relevant configuration and
operational parameters of NG-RAN and NGC NFs.

5.3 Security Enhancements


In developing 5G, security has been a top concern from the start. Release 15 set the
security framework [25] and Release 16 has followed up with many details and addressing
many identified weaknesses in the framework. Security for 5G is particularly challenging
because it is highly complex and extremely adaptable to support a wide variety of services
that have conflicting requirements [26]. For instance, for URLL applications low latency is
of ultimate performance concern, yet it takes processing time to do robust authentication
and encryption. Hence, security must be optimized and appropriate for the specific 5G
application. Optimization of the 5G system performance requires optimizing across
various layers of the system and hence the security must also be optimized across all the
layers. Security must be designed as a chain, it is only as good as its weakest link, hence
5G security design should allow for end-to-end assurance of security. This is particularly

Rohde & Schwarz 5G Evolution: On the Path to 6G 32


challenging since a 5G system may consist of equipment, software, transport links,
services, and systems from various entities.
Within 5G Release 16, numerous issues are being addressed including:
ı Security mechanism for prevent access to other network slices
ı Trusted non-3GPP access
ı Authentication of the user with security credentials
ı Security for small data mode
ı User plane DoS attacks
ı Broadcast/Multicast Security
ı Lawful intercept
ı Battery sensitive security
ı Location services security
ı Edge device security
ı Session management security
ı Base station security test cases
ı Security against false base stations
ı Mission-critical architecture security
In addition, Release 16 has numerous studies ongoing that if not integrated into Release
16, may be incorporated into future releases. These studies include:
ı Relay security
ı Security and connectivity from 5G to Local Area Networks (may be studied in Release
17)
ı Voice continuity
ı Convergence of wireless and wireline systems
ı Enhanced URLLC security
ı Restrictions on local operators
ı Enhanced virtualization security
One of the more attractive features of 5G is the ability to customize security and
authentication with network slicing. Yet, this feature does open up a number of different
attack surfaces with SDN and NFV. Still many vulnerabilities will need to be addressed in
future releases. Potential security vulnerabilities of 5G at various security layers have
been identified in [28]. There is no doubt that security issues will be continued to be
addressed with each release from 3GPP.

Rohde & Schwarz 5G Evolution: On the Path to 6G 33


6 6G: A Crystal Ball Perspective
"Prediction is very difficult, especially if it's about the future."

--Nils Bohr, Nobel laureate in Physics

If LTE is Long term Employment, 5G is Longer Term Employment. However, it is a good


idea to explore what wireless future may hold for 6G.

6.1 Predicting the 6G Future


Predicting the future can be a futile task, but we all do it – we must in order to get ready for
the future. Predicting what the next generation of wireless is a favorite pastime for
wireless engineers. Perhaps it is easier to do for the wireless field than for most fields
because one can look at the activities of standards bodies to gain insight on what vendors
and service providers are trying to accomplish (and what they need to fix from the last
standard!). Even before technology is debated in standards bodies, researchers are
developing new ideas that can clearly provide improvements in performance over current
systems.
History has shown lessons which comes from observing standards over the past five
generations. For example,
1. Not all features spelled out in a given release of the standard are implemented
immediately or simultaneously; rather, it could take some time for features to become
practical. Likely this will be even more true for 5G given the unprecedented large
scope of 5G technologies.
2. Weaknesses in the current standard become technology drivers for the next
generation standard. This has been especially true with privacy and security
weakness.
3. We may be able to predict technology trends, but we are less successful in predicting
business models that leverage those technology developments.
4. Sometimes new technologies may work great in simulations or prototypes used to
create the standard. However, scaling from the lab models to commercial production
and deployment doesn’t always work so well and may take much longer than
expected. Antenna arrays are a prime example.
5. New generations of wireless cellular standards tend to come in approximately 10-year
increments. For example, LTE deployments started around 2008 and 5G was
standardized in 2018.
6. The scope of the problems that wireless addresses increases with each generation.
For example, 1st generation started with voice; 2nd generation enabled rudimentary

Rohde & Schwarz 5G Evolution: On the Path to 6G 34


connections to machines, such as vending machines; 3rd generation enabled high-
speed Internet access including enhanced web browsing; and 4th generation made
video entertainment over wireless practical. A greatly expanding application scope of
5th generation standards is widely anticipated.
7. New technologies adopted in standards may have much more impact than expected
because of the development of synergistic technologies that together create a much
more powerful effect. The development of high-rate data transmission along with the

"The best qualification of a prophet is to have a good memory."

--Marquis of Halifax,

improvement of display technology drove data demand even higher because it


enabled mobile video entertainment.
8. In general, it takes longer to roll out all the capabilities of a standard than the initial
hype might imply, but in the end the standard exceeds overall expectations.
These have been fairly consistent trends across all five generation of standards; what is
new for the 6th generation of standard is that nations now recognize the importance of
wireless standards for national economic well-being and national security; hence, creating
the fundamental technologies behind 6G has become much more competitive [29].

6.2 Key Technologies as 6G Enablers


One of the ways to predict what 6G may provide is to examine the direction of current
fundamental and applied research. Three key enabling technologies are poised to drive
the development of 6G. They include Artificial Intelligence (AI), advanced RF and optical
technologies, and network technologies.

6.2.1 Artificial Intelligence

No one would doubt that AI has become one of the most studied areas across many
engineering disciplines. While 5G is known for a revolution in flexibility, 6G would likely be
known for using intelligence to capitalize on flexibility [30]. In the past, wireless research
activities have made use of AI in various areas such as design of handover algorithms
using neural networks and fuzzy logic [31]. However, practical implementations of AI-
based algorithms in wireless networks have been relatively rare. The situation is changing
now. Recent advances in learning techniques such as deep-learning and new computing
architectures that can make these complex algorithms practical have been key drivers
behind this trend. Wireless communications is no exception to this trend. Figure 6.1

Rohde & Schwarz 5G Evolution: On the Path to 6G 35


shows what a 6th generation 6G network may look like, with AI/cognition spread across all
levels and optimized jointly across the levels in the radio access network, the core
network, and applications. Such adaptability can improve the resilience of the network
and lower the operational and maintenance costs.

RF can benefit from cognitive tuning of components to optimize for environmental


impairments (such as interference) or the impact of aging or de-tuning of the circuitry. The
modem and protocols can be adaptive to facilitate better spectrum management and
demodulation, especially in cases of heterogeneous interference, something to be
expected with the emergence of spectrum sharing. Federated learning techniques can
leverage each mobile unit as a sensor to provide a holistic but detailed view of the
interference and coverage issues across a broad region [32]. Mechanisms for supporting
front haul or backhaul can be made more robust by using AI to find the appropriate
mechanism for routing information, including the use of satellite or terrestrial wireless
relaying. Studies are underway to examine the use of AI within the core network for

Rohde & Schwarz 5G Evolution: On the Path to 6G 36


system optimization, orchestration, and maintenance [33]. Security of this overall AI-RAN
can be continuously improved through the use of adversarial learning – competition
between an AI network attacker and an AI network defender to find vulnerabilities and their
solutions [34]. At the application level, AI can anticipate the context and need for
application information and preset the network parameters to accommodate the
anticipated information flow. (A form of “pre-cognition”, a term from the science fiction
movie Minority Report.)

6.2.2 RF and Optical Technologies

One of the key enablers of 5G has been the low-cost production of mmW devices. This
trend is expected to continue, with higher frequency devices and are becoming more
power efficient. Eventually, this technology trend may make terahertz (THz)
communications economically feasible 10. A complete phased array can be placed on a
chip [35]. Such a phased array chip would not need external power pins to communicate if
wireless power is utilized.
Another factor is flexibility in RF components. The DARPA HEDGEHOG program is an
example of such technology that is built on an RF-FPGA (Field Programmable Gate Array)
to create a very small radio that is highly configurable to cover a variety of bands from 10
MHz to 40 GHz- see Figure 6.2 [36].

10
The FCC has made THz spectrum in the 95 GHz- 3 THz range available for experimentation as part of Spectrum
Horizons order [37].

Rohde & Schwarz 5G Evolution: On the Path to 6G 37


Such flexibility will work synergistically with AI to adapt the radio for the users’ service
needs and the RF environment. Taking full advantage of such technology requires the
development of new communication protocols.
Single-frequency full-duplex has been demonstrated and is a testimony to ever-improving
RF technology [38]. In such a system, the transmitter and receiver operate at the same
time and on the same frequency, conceptually doubling the spectral efficiency of a system
by eliminating the need for frequency or time duplexing. Such systems work by
performing interference cancelation at the RF stage to remove the high-power transmit
signal. Such technology will provide an even more flexible spectrum management
technique for 6th generation wireless.
6G will no doubt extend beyond 95 GHz into the high mmW and terahertz range, including
optical spectrum. At such frequencies, communications tend to be short range, but the
devices can be very small to support technologies such as ultra-massive MIMO and
applications such as small swarms (insect size collaborating robots).
Optical 6G has promise as well with reduced interference, tremendous bandwidths, privacy
to line-of-sight, and an established technology base of devices that do transmission and
reception. Interestingly, ultra-violet light does NOT require line of sight, but rather scatters
in the atmosphere.11

11
In the late 1990s infrared version existed in the early 802.11 specification to provide up to 2 Mbps connectivity. It could
be found on selected laptop computers at that time.

Rohde & Schwarz 5G Evolution: On the Path to 6G 38


6.2.3 Network Technologies

Network technologies for 6G will continue as with 5G- the use of SDN, NFV, and network
slicing. However, 6G could take these concepts to the extreme, allowing for customized
network slices according to an individual’s needs and applications to create a truly
customized quality of experience for that individual. Such a system with personalized
network slices would inevitably leverage edge computing on a massive scale and creating
a very complex distribution of network responsibilities between the core network and edge
computing nodes.

6.3 Potential Performance Targets for 6G


New standards have a variety of metrics, with typical specifications of data rates, latency,
and availability among others. 6G will continue with the trend begun with 5G in defining
Quality of Experience over individual metrics. Certainly though, there will be higher data
rates, perhaps tera bits per second. Latencies may be as low as tens of microseconds,
and perhaps information will be freshness dated with the age-of-information to aid in the
prioritized processing of information. Power consumption reductions that are already
targeted for 10-year battery life for IoT devices in 5G could be further reduced to allow for
energy harvesting, including backscatter communications [39]. 6G might also include both
metrics and standards for energy harvesting or wireless power requirements. One might
expect to see metrics for security resilience in 6G standards, especially with the potential
of quantum computing to be able to break most encryption standards by the time 6G
appears.

6.4 Potential 6G Services

So, what sort of services might 6G and beyond wireless systems provide? 6G will build
on 5G to enhance existing services as well as introduce additional modes to handle
applications with widely different applications needs [40]. For example, while 5G will
introduce holograms, 6G would likely enable high-fidelity holograms on a massive scale.
One possible new application area is providing ultra-low-power communications through
energy harvesting or wireless power to very small devices. Such devices could be part of
the fabric of clothes, or embedded into plastic or glass. They could constitute the
communications between swarms of small UAVs or robots that can coordinate to do
complex tasks such as assembly or repairs. There eventually may be many thousands of
radios per individual. Accomplishing this would require a standard with protocols that

Rohde & Schwarz 5G Evolution: On the Path to 6G 39


facilitate energy transfer (wireless power) or energy harvesting configuration merged with
communication protocols.
We could see new applications that require a whole new level of latency management.
Yes, lower latency for sure than with latencies needed for precise power grid control with
distributed energy sources and sinks. Tactile sensing applications also push the limits for
low latency. This may be accomplished by freshness-dating information with an Age-of-
Information metric that can be used in prioritizing processing or it may be achieved by
using AI to anticipate communication or application needs or potential faults to provide
deep connectivity. Such capability will allow for imperceptible seamless coverage,
including a rapid transition between satellite communications and terrestrial
communications.
Services that require ultra-higher data rates are inevitable. One possible service may be
video wall paper that uses large display technology to form the walls of a room with
projected images. We are now seeing the emergence of 8k video and data speeds to
support 8k video are around 360 Mbps. Scaling this up to provide an immersive
experience on each wall means that one wall may need well over 10 Gbps of
communication speed for a real-time display. Hence, a terabit per second link is not an
unreasonable need.
Sensing as a service is a possible new category for 6G applications. Could 6G signals be
used to measure moisture or other particulates in the air to create a micro-climate profile?
Is it possible that the signal could be leveraged as a radar signal to get very precise
localization for indoor flying UAVs?
It is difficult to say at this point what 6G may bring. While an initial version of 6G might
come in the 2030 time-range, it will also undergo several years of revisions. Predicting
what the standard will evolve to in 2035 is a fascinating but very speculative endeavor!

Rohde & Schwarz 5G Evolution: On the Path to 6G 40


7 Summary
5G Phase 1 or Release 15 provides a strong foundation for enhancements in future
releases by defining a high-performance NR air interface and flexible network architecture.
Releases 16 and beyond focus on new verticals to significantly expand the applications of
wireless communications. Such trend of the support for verticals is expected to accelerate
in 6G.
Going beyond the eMBB-centric R15, R16 and later releases expand the supported
services. 5G LAN can replace or augment fixed or wireless LAN and provide flexibility and
enhanced performance. In Non Terrestrial Networks, satellites use 5G to provide service
ubiquity, service continuity, and service scalability. Critical Medical Applications benefit
from the 5G performance to improve healthcare and to reduce costs. 5G enables new V2X
use cases such as platooning, advanced driving, and remote driving. 5G-based UAVs can
support a variety of scenarios including the delivery of medical supplies in disaster
situations. 5G facilitates Audio-Visual Production Service inside and outside studios.
Cyber-Physical Control Applications can exploit 5G to make Industry 4.0 a reality on a
large scale. NR-based positioning supports numerous use cases including emergency
situations, UAV operations and AR/VR/XR, and factory automation. Haptic
communications takes the user experience to a new level by exploiting the haptic sense.
NR undergoes numerous enhancements beyond Release 16. NR-U utilizes NR in
unlicensed spectrum and supports a variety of scenarios including Carrier Aggregation and
Dual Connectivity. IAB enables the use of spectrum for backhaul in addition to traditional
access to reduce deployment costs and simplify radio-core connectivity. URLLC-centric
enhancements include increased reliability, faster processing, more flexible HARQ, uplink
cancellation, and enhanced uplink power control. Industrial IoT related NR enhancements
include support for TSN reference times and Ethernet and flexible grants and scheduling.
New frequency bands between 7 and 24 GHz and above 53 GHz open up more spectrum
for numerous use cases including densification, Industrial IoT, backhaul and fronthaul, and
ITS. NR also makes enhancements related to MIMO, mobility, positioning, and UE power
savings.
R15 defines virtualization-friendly Service Based Architecture. Such architecture is
enhanced for V2X, network automation, CLI/RIM, eCAPIF, and IMS. V2X related
enhancements include support for NR-based PC5 interface. NWDAF and its interactions
with other NFs are being expanded to increase the degree of automation and to facilitate
AI-based operations. The work on CLI/RIM aims to enable dynamic TDD while reducing
overall interference. eCAPIF supports multiple API providers and addresses charging
requirements. IMS is being enhanced to work with SBA and to support edge computing.
3GPP is also defining SEAL and SON for 5G and enhancing the security framework. At the
application layer, SEAL provides services such as group management and configuration
management to applications of various verticals by working with Vertical Application Layer
(VAL). 5G SON supports traditional LTE-like algorithms such as ANR and PCI

Rohde & Schwarz 5G Evolution: On the Path to 6G 41


configuration along with new algorithms related to Network Slicing. Security is being further
tightened, especially in the light of expansion into new verticals.
While Release 16 and beyond for 5G has immense untapped potential, 6G will take the
user experience to a whole new level and would revolutionize many industries. Data rates
on the order of Tera bits per second, latency on the order of few microseconds, and high
energy efficiencies for the devices and the network would be hallmarks of 6G. High-fidelity
holographic communications and multi-sensory communications could become part of our
daily lives. While industries such as healthcare, manufacturing, entertainment, and
transportation would begin to be influenced by 5G, they would be transformed on a larger
scale by 6G.
The world around us would be significantly shaped by the upcoming enhancements in
wireless communications; be prepared to be amazed!

Rohde & Schwarz 5G Evolution: On the Path to 6G 42


8 Literature
[1] Nishith D. Tripathi and Jeffrey H. Reed, “5G Cellular Communications- Journey and
Destination,” Multimedia eBook, https://thewirelessuniversity.com/ , May 2019.
[2] Rohde & Schwarz, “5G New Radio,” https://www.mobilewirelesstesting.com/5g-new-
radio-digital-book/ 2019.
[3] 3GPP, TS 22.104, “Service requirements for cyber-physical control applications in
vertical domains,”
Stage 1,”
https://portal.3gpp.org/desktopmodules/Specifications/SpecificationDetails.aspx?specificati
onId=3528 .
[4] 3GPP, TR 22.821, “Feasibility Study on LAN Support in 5G,”
https://portal.3gpp.org/desktopmodules/Specifications/SpecificationDetails.aspx?specificati
onId=3281 .
[5] 3GPP, TR 22.822, “Study on using satellite access in 5G,”
https://portal.3gpp.org/desktopmodules/Specifications/SpecificationDetails.aspx?specificati
onId=3372 .
[6] 3GPP, TR 22.826, “Study on communication services for critical medical applications,”
https://portal.3gpp.org/desktopmodules/Specifications/SpecificationDetails.aspx?specificati
onId=3546 .
[7] 3GPP, TR 22.827, “Study on Audio-Visual Service Production,”
https://portal.3gpp.org/desktopmodules/Specifications/SpecificationDetails.aspx?specificati
onId=3520 .
[8] 3GPP, TR 22.829, “Enhancement for Unmanned Aerial Vehicles (UAVs),”
https://portal.3gpp.org/desktopmodules/Specifications/SpecificationDetails.aspx?specificati
onId=3557 .
[9] 3GPP, TR 22.832, “Study on enhancements for cyber-physical control applications in
vertical domains,”
https://portal.3gpp.org/desktopmodules/Specifications/SpecificationDetails.aspx?specificati
onId=3629 .
[10] 3GPP, TR 22.872, “Study on positioning use cases,”
https://portal.3gpp.org/desktopmodules/Specifications/SpecificationDetails.aspx?specificati
onId=3280 .
[11] 3GPP, TR 22.886, “Study on enhancement of 3GPP support for 5G V2X services,”
https://portal.3gpp.org/desktopmodules/Specifications/SpecificationDetails.aspx?specificati
onId=3108 .
[12] 3GPP, TS 23.287, “Architecture enhancements for 5G System (5GS) to support
Vehicle-to-Everything (V2X) services,”

Rohde & Schwarz 5G Evolution: On the Path to 6G 43


https://portal.3gpp.org/desktopmodules/Specifications/SpecificationDetails.aspx?specificati
onId=3578 .
[13] 3GPP, TS 23.434, “Service Enabler Architecture Layer for Verticals (SEAL);
Functional architecture and information flows,”
https://portal.3gpp.org/desktopmodules/Specifications/SpecificationDetails.aspx?specificati
onId=3587 .
[14] 3GPP, TR 23.758, “Study on Application Architecture for enabling Edge Applications,”
https://portal.3gpp.org/desktopmodules/Specifications/SpecificationDetails.aspx?specificati
onId=3614 .
[15] 3GPP, TR 23.791, “Study of enablers for Network Automation for 5G,”
https://portal.3gpp.org/desktopmodules/Specifications/SpecificationDetails.aspx?specificati
onId=3252 .
[16] 3GPP, TR 23.794, “Study on Enhanced IMS to 5GC Integration,”
https://portal.3gpp.org/desktopmodules/Specifications/SpecificationDetails.aspx?specificati
onId=3421 .
[17] 3GPP, TR 28.861, “Telecommunication management; Study on the Self-Organizing
Networks (SON) for 5G networks,”
https://portal.3gpp.org/desktopmodules/Specifications/SpecificationDetails.aspx?specificati
onId=3556 .
[18] 3GPP, TR 38.824, “Study on physical layer enhancements for NR ultra-reliable and
low latency case (URLLC),”
https://portal.3gpp.org/desktopmodules/Specifications/SpecificationDetails.aspx?specificati
onId=3498 .
[19] 3GPP, TR 38.825, “Study on NR industrial Internet of Things (IoT),”
https://portal.3gpp.org/desktopmodules/Specifications/SpecificationDetails.aspx?specificati
onId=3492 .
[20] 3GPP, TR 38.840, “Study on User Equipment (UE) power saving in NR,”
https://portal.3gpp.org/desktopmodules/Specifications/SpecificationDetails.aspx?specificati
onId=3502 .
[21] 3GPP, TR 38.855, “Study on NR positioning support,”
https://portal.3gpp.org/desktopmodules/Specifications/SpecificationDetails.aspx?specificati
onId=3501 .
[22] 3GPP, TR 38.874, “Study on integrated access and backhaul,”
https://portal.3gpp.org/desktopmodules/Specifications/SpecificationDetails.aspx?specificati
onId=3232 .
[23] 3GPP, TR 38.889, “Study on NR-based access to unlicensed spectrum,”
https://portal.3gpp.org/desktopmodules/Specifications/SpecificationDetails.aspx?specificati
onId=3235 .

Rohde & Schwarz 5G Evolution: On the Path to 6G 44


[24] 3GPP, RP-182863, “Revised WID: Enhancements on MIMO for NR,”
https://portal.3gpp.org/ngppapp/CreateTdoc.aspx?mode=view&contributionUid=RP-
182863 .
[25] 3GPP TS 33.501, “Security architecture and procedures for 5G system (Release 15),”
https://portal.3gpp.org/desktopmodules/Specifications/SpecificationDetails.aspx?specificati
onId=3169 .
[26] 5G Americas, The Evolution of Security in 5G: A “Slice” of Mobile Threats, July 2019,
5G Americas white paper, https://www.5gamericas.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/08/5G-
Security-White-Paper_8.15.pdf .
[27] 3GPP, specification series for security issues, https://www.3gpp.org/DynaReport/33-
series.htm
[28] UK5G, “Technical Report on 5G Network Architecture and Security,” A collaborative
paper, DCMS Phase 1 5G Testbeds & Trials Programme, UK5G Report, December 2018,
https://uk5g.org/discover/research/technical-report-5g-network-architecture-and-secur/ .
[29] Martijn Rasser, “Setting the Stage for U.S. Leadership in 6G,” August 13, 2019,
LawFare, https://www.lawfareblog.com/setting-stage-us-leadership-6g .
[30] M. Yao, M. Sohul, V. Marojevic, J.H. Reed, “Artificial Intelligence0Defined 5G Radio
Access Networks,” IEEE Communications Magazine, Volume 57 Issue 3, March 2019,
pages 14-20. doi>10.1109/MCOM.2019.1800629
[31] Nishith D. Tripathi, Jeffrey H. Reed, and Hugh F. VanLandingham, “Radio Resource
Management in Cellular Systems,” Kluwer Academic Publishers, 2002.
[32] Solmaz Niknam, Harpreet S. Dhillon, Jeffery H. Reed, Federated Learning for
Wireless Communications: Motivation, Opportunities and Challenges,
https://arxiv.org/abs/1908.06847, (Submitted on 30 Jul 2019 (v1), last revised 24 Aug 2019
(this version, v2))
[33] Improved operator experience through Experiential Networked Intelligence (ENI)
Introduction - Benefits - Enablers - Challenges - Call for Action, ETSI White Paper No. 22,
1st Edition, October 2017, ISBN No. 979-10-92620-16-0.
https://www.etsi.org/images/files/ETSIWhitePapers/etsi_wp22_ENI_FINAL.pdf
[34] Y. Shi, Y. E. Sagduyu, T. Erpek, K. Davaslioglu, Z. Lu and J. H. Li, "Adversarial Deep
Learning for Cognitive Radio Security: Jamming Attack and Defense Strategies," 2018
IEEE International Conference on Communications Workshops (ICC Workshops), Kansas
City, MO, 2018, pp. 1-6. doi: 10.1109/ICCW.2018.8403655Satcomm
[35] M. M. Assefzadeh and A. Babakhani, "Broadband beamforming of terahertz pulses
with a single-chip 4×2 array in silicon," 2016 IEEE International Symposium on Antennas
and Propagation (APSURSI), Fajardo, 2016, pp. 589-590.
doi: 10.1109/APS.2016.7696003
[36] Tom Rondeau, “RF Convergence: From the Signals to the Computer,” IEEE
Workshop on 5G Technologies for Tactical and First Responder Networks Columbia, MD,
10/23/2018

Rohde & Schwarz 5G Evolution: On the Path to 6G 45


[37] FCC 19-19, “Spectrum Horizons- First Report and Order,” ET Docket No. 18-21,
https://www.fcc.gov/document/fcc-opens-spectrum-horizons-new-services-technologies-0 .
[38] C. D. Nwankwo, L. Zhang, A. Quddus, M. A. Imran and R. Tafazolli, "A Survey of Self-
Interference Management Techniques for Single Frequency Full Duplex Systems," in IEEE
Access, vol. 6, pp. 30242-30268, 2018. doi: 10.1109/ACCESS.2017.2774143.
[39] N. Van Huynh, D. T. Hoang, X. Lu, D. Niyato, P. Wang and D. I. Kim, "Ambient
Backscatter Communications: A Contemporary Survey," in IEEE Communications Surveys
& Tutorials, vol. 20, no. 4, pp. 2889-2922, Fourth quarter 2018. doi:
10.1109/COMST.2018.2841964.
[40] P. Yang, Y. Xiao, M. Xiao and S. Li, "6G Wireless Communications: Vision and
Potential Techniques," in IEEE Network, vol. 33, no. 4, pp. 70-75, July/August 2019. doi:
10.1109/MNET.2019.1800418.

Rohde & Schwarz 5G Evolution: On the Path to 6G 46


Rohde & Schwarz Regional contact
The Rohde & Schwarz electronics group offers Europe, Africa, Middle East
innovative solutions in the following business fields: +49 89 4129 12345
test and measurement, broadcast and media, secure customersupport@rohde-schwarz.com
communications, cybersecurity, radiomonitoring and
North America
radiolocation. Founded more than 80 years ago, this
1 888 TEST RSA (1 888 837 87 72)
independent company has an extensive sales and customer.support@rsa.rohde-schwarz.com
service network and is present in more than 70
countries. Latin America
+1 410 910 79 88
The electronics group is among the world market
customersupport.la@rohde-schwarz.com
leaders in its established business fields. The
company is headquartered in Munich, Germany. It Asia Pacific
also has regional headquarters in Singapore and +65 65 13 04 88
Columbia, Maryland, USA, to manage its operations customersupport.asia@rohde-schwarz.com
in these regions.
China
+86 800 810 82 28 |+86 400 650 58 96
customersupport.china@rohde-schwarz.com

Sustainable product design


ı Environmental compatibility and eco-footprint
ı Energy efficiency and low emissions
ı Longevity and optimized total cost of ownership

This white paper and the supplied programs may only


be used subject to the conditions of use set forth in
the download area of the Rohde & Schwarz website.
R&S® is a registered trademark of Rohde & Schwarz GmbH & Co.
KG; Trade names are trademarks of the owners.

Rohde & Schwarz GmbH & Co. KG


Mühldorfstraße 15 | 81671 Munich, Germany
Phone + 49 89 4129 - 0 | Fax + 49 89 4129 – 13777

www.rohde-schwarz.com
Rohde & Schwarz 5G Evolution: On the Path to 6G 47

You might also like