Overview of PON Technologies and System Architectures
Overview of PON Technologies and System Architectures
• Centralized Access Architecture for PON and Distributed Access Architecture for PON
• Overview of Purpose Built OLT Systems and SDN/NFV Systems for PON
Copyright 2015 – ARRIS Enterprises, Inc. All rights reserved. 29 September 2017 Overview of PON Technologies and System Architectures for SCTE 2
Overview of PON Standards
High-Level
EPON: IEEE 802.3ah 1310 nm ±50 is the standard however, MSOs often select the GPON 1310 nm ±10 Narrow wavelength
band optics (10G/1G upstream may use narrowband optics as well)
GPON Upstream Wavelength Evolution: G.984.2 1310 nm ±50 Regular wavelength band option, G.984.5 1310 nm ±20
Reduced wavelength band option, G.984.5 1310 nm ±10 Narrow wavelength band option
Copyright 2015 – ARRIS Enterprises, Inc. All rights reserved. 29 September 2017 Overview of PON Technologies and System Architectures for SCTE 5
Overview of EPON / 10G EPON
High-Level
Term Meaning
ODN Optical Distribution Network, referring to the out side plant OSP. Items include fiber and splitters. The
ODN is traditional all passive, thus no powered equipment in this network segment.
OLT Optical Line Terminal; located at the HE/CO. This network element controls the Downstream and
Upstream signals. The Downstream are broadcast to each premises sharing a fiber. Upstream
signals are combined using a multiple access protocol, invariably time division multiple access
(TDMA). The OLTs "range" the ONUs in order to provide time slot assignments for upstream
communication. Encryption is used to prevent eavesdropping.
The OLT manages traffic to ensure bandwidth amounts and priority for specified services. This is like
a CMTS in the cable network but terminates and manages optical connections end to end.
ONU Optical Network Units; located at the CPE (term associated with EPON or the IEEE version of PON).
This is like a Cable Modem or EMTA in the cable network but terminates an optical connections at the
home/business/MDU.
ONT Optical Network Terminals; located at the CPE (term associated with APON, BPON, GPON and is
based on the ITU-T version of PON)
Copyright 2015 – ARRIS Enterprises, Inc. All rights reserved. 29 September 2017 Overview of PON Technologies and System Architectures for SCTE 7
Definition of PON
• A passive optical network (PON) is a point-to-multipoint, fiber to the premises network architecture in which
unpowered optical splitters are used to enable a single optical fiber to serve multiple premises, typically 32-128.
• A PON consists of an Optical Line Terminal (OLT) at the service provider's central office or headend and Optical
Network Units (ONUs) are placed at end users locations.
• A PON configuration reduces the amount of fiber from the CO/HE to the end users compared with point-to-point
architectures.
• Upstream signals are combined using a multiple access protocol, invariably time division multiple access (TDMA).
• The OLTs "range" the ONUs in order to provide time slot assignments for upstream communication.
• Today PON point-to-multi-point fiber technology supports speeds from 1 Gbps to 10Gbps
• Distance from the facility to the end users where often up to 20 km, however today with PON extenders and
Remote OLTs distance from the facility to the end users are much further (80 km or even more is possible) this
mean active network elements are in the optical distribution network (ODN) making PON not exactly passive.
Source: Wikipedia and the Author of this presentation
Copyright 2015 – ARRIS Enterprises, Inc. All rights reserved. 29 September 2017 Overview of PON Technologies and System Architectures for SCTE 8
Attributes of EPON
• Subscribers sharing the same PON port could be up to 128 ONUs but often fewer
(the number of ONU per PON port is typcially optical budget limited)
Copyright 2015 – ARRIS Enterprises, Inc. All rights reserved. 29 September 2017 Overview of PON Technologies and System Architectures for SCTE 9
10G EPON OLT System
Downstream Dual-rate WDM
1G DS 1490nm ±10 “and” 10G DS 1577.5 ±2.5
1Gx1G “or”
Upstream Dual-rate TDMA 2G DS x 1G US ONUs
Existing Deployment?
1G US 1310nm ±50 (wideband) or
1G US 1310nm ±10 (narrowband)
and 10G US 1270nm ±10 single SERDES
1Gx1G “or”
Single Port 2G DS x 1G US ONUs
1310 nm Choice for New Install
1490 nm
1577 nm
1270 nm 10G / 1G EPON ONU
Customer upgrades
and/or New Installs
10G-EPON OLT
1 OLT Port Enabling 1G & 10G Downstream & Sharing 1G & 10G Upstream for 3 Types of ONUs
Source: “Comparing IEEE EPON & FSAN/ITU-T GPON Family of Technologies“, Michael J. Emmendorfer, SCTE-ISBE Workshop, September 2014
Copyright 2015 – ARRIS Enterprises, Inc. All rights reserved. 29 September 2017 Overview of PON Technologies and System Architectures for SCTE 10
EPON Downstream
Copyright 2015 – ARRIS Enterprises, Inc. All rights reserved. 29 September 2017 Overview of PON Technologies and System Architectures for SCTE 11
EPON Upstream
• The OLT makes sure ONUs do not transmit at the same time to avoid collisions at the OLT optical receiver
• To avoid collisions the OLT allocates Time Slots known as GATES or Grants to the ONU
• When the ONU would like to transmit data a request for bandwidth (time slots) are sent to the OLT this is
known as a REPORT
Copyright 2015 – ARRIS Enterprises, Inc. All rights reserved. 29 September 2017 Overview of PON Technologies and System Architectures for SCTE 12
EPON Terms
• Packet Classification:
– Classification is performed at each ingress point. Specific fields in the frames such as 802.1Q,
DiffServ(TOS), Layer 2/3 Address, or Layer 4 ports can be used to map traffic into Link Layer IDs and
Service Level Agreements.
Copyright 2015 – ARRIS Enterprises, Inc. All rights reserved. 29 September 2017 Overview of PON Technologies and System Architectures for SCTE 13
Bandwidth Allocation Modes
(Most EPON deployments worldwide use a DBA scheduler or dynamic solicited mode)
Copyright 2015 – ARRIS Enterprises, Inc. All rights reserved. 29 September 2017 Overview of PON Technologies and System Architectures for SCTE 14
DBA REPORT and GATE Messages
• DBA uses REPORT and GATE Messages to request and grant data for the ONU to transmit
upstream to avoid collisions and schedules bandwidth across the shared media
Copyright 2015 – ARRIS Enterprises, Inc. All rights reserved. 29 September 2017 Overview of PON Technologies and System Architectures for SCTE 15
EPON and DOCSIS Comparison
• EPON OLT Classifies Downstream and the the ONU Upstream are very
similar to DOCSIS (Port based as well as Layer 2 – Layer 4 traffic identifiers)
HFC +
DOCSIS
PHY Layer Rates after encoding and FEC (if used) however the copper solutions are estimate capacity
Copyright 2015 – ARRIS Enterprises, Inc. All rights reserved. 29/9/17 Overview of PON Technologies and System Architectures for SCTE 17
What’s Next? IEEE 100G-EPON Task Force (802.3ca)
• Work is underway defining beyond 10G EPON to include 25G, 50G and 100G
Copyright 2015 – ARRIS Enterprises, Inc. All rights reserved. 29/9/17 Overview of PON Technologies and System Architectures for SCTE 18
Overview of DOCSIS Provisioning of EPON
(DPoE)
• Purpose:
– Develop specifications for EPON devices to support DOCSIS provisioning and service concepts (Service
Flows and Per Services Type QoS)
– Develop specifications for support with DOCSIS Network Management Systems and IPDR
Copyright 2015 – ARRIS Enterprises, Inc. All rights reserved. 29 September 2017 Overview of PON Technologies and System Architectures for SCTE 20
DPoE Architectural Foundation
IP Management
DOCSIS OSS CM
IPv4 Host
Servers
IPv6 Host
DNS CMTS
HFC Network
DPoE System
IP Management eOAM
Source: “DOCSIS® Provisioning of EPON (DPoE™): A Next Generation Business Services Network”, Curtis Knittle, CableLabs SCTE EXPO 2011
Copyright 2015 – ARRIS Enterprises, Inc. All rights reserved. 29 September 2017 Overview of PON Technologies and System Architectures for SCTE 21
Provisioning Interoperability
OSSI Test
SNMP Get/Set
Source: “DOCSIS® Provisioning of EPON (DPoE™): A Next Generation Business Services Network”, Curtis Knittle, CableLabs SCTE EXPO 2011
Copyright 2015 – ARRIS Enterprises, Inc. All rights reserved. 29 September 2017 Overview of PON Technologies and System Architectures for SCTE 22
DPoE Network Elements
DPoE Standalone ONU (S-
ONU): a type of DPoE
ONU with multiple ports
L3
that provides both
Network
S-ONU
DEMARC Ethernet services and IP
services
B-ONU DEMARC
L2
Network
OLT PON Network
Source: “DOCSIS® Provisioning of EPON (DPoE™): A Next Generation Business Services Network”, Curtis Knittle, CableLabs SCTE EXPO 2011
Copyright 2015 – ARRIS Enterprises, Inc. All rights reserved. 29 September 2017 Overview of PON Technologies and System Architectures for SCTE 23
DPoE ONU Interfaces and Forwarding
D-ONU
Encapsulation
Fiber (to PON)
Source: “DOCSIS® Provisioning of EPON (DPoE™): A Next Generation Business Services Network”, Curtis Knittle, CableLabs SCTE EXPO 2011
Copyright 2015 – ARRIS Enterprises, Inc. All rights reserved. 29 September 2017 Overview of PON Technologies and System Architectures for SCTE 24
DPoE Benefits:
• Leverages existing DOCSIS back office systems (provisioning, NMS, IPDR) to support
EPON network elements
• Leverages back office systems enables smoother integration into operations and
processes
Copyright 2015 – ARRIS Enterprises, Inc. All rights reserved. 29 September 2017 Overview of PON Technologies and System Architectures for SCTE 25
Centralized Access Architecture for PON
and Distributed Access Architecture for PON
“A Comparison of Centralized vs. Distributed Access Architectures for PON“,
Mike Emmendorfer and Sebnem Zorlu Ozer, INTX 2016, Spring Tech Forum
Centralized Access Architecture for PON Distributed Access Architecture for PON
• OLT MAC and PHY are located at the • OLT MAC and PHY are located located in
Facility the ODN (node/cabinet)
Copyright 2015 – ARRIS Enterprises, Inc. All rights reserved. 29 September 2017 Overview of PON Technologies and System Architectures for SCTE 28
DPoE Subsystems
DOCSIS Back
Office / OSS DPoE Mediation Layer
vCM vCM
SNMP, IPDR, TFTP,
DHCP, etc.
RP R 802 OLT
VSI(1)
PE
VSI(N) Switch US UTM
IP VE DS TM
R PE PBB US LTM
Network
I-BEB EPON MAC
R/X
10G PHY
DPoE System
Copyright 2015 – ARRIS Enterprises, Inc. All rights reserved. 29 September 2017 Overview of PON Technologies and System Architectures for SCTE 29
DPoE System Functions
DPoE Mediation Layer Functions Multilayer Switch Router Ternary content- Control Plane Functions
• Mediation between OSS, NMS, and EPON Layers (Control & Data Plane) addressable memory • Centralized Control for all required configurations (e.g. port,
• Virtual Cable Modem (vCM) for registered D-ONU • Routing • MP-BGP (TCAM) channel and MC domain etc.)
• vCM handles all the OAMP functions for DOCSIS • ARP • MPLS table lookup and • Centralized Control for sending all the collected stats (e.g.
• vCM can proxy requests, signaling, and messages to the D- • NDP • VPLS classification of IPv4, IPv6 port, channel and mac domain etc.).
ONU using EPON OAM messages • IS-IS • .1ad / .1ah packets and L2 frames • EPON MAC for programming all required functionality (e.g.
• Communicate with D-ONU for provisioning all required • OSPF • L2 Switching port, channel, LLID and upstream QoS etc.).
services (e.g. IP HSD, MEF etc.) • DS TM for programming all required functionality (e.g. service
• vCM Interfaces with System Control Plane for flow, classifier, and downstream QoS etc.).
configuration (e.g. service flow, classifier, and downstream • Implement the control plane for multicast forwarding
QoS etc.) DPoE MLSR
TCAM Upstream Upper Traffic Management (US UTM)
• Platform Management Interfaces (CLI, SNMP, etc.) Mediation
• CALEA / LI (may not be part of TM)
Downstream Traffic Management (DS TM):
Layer R PE VSI(1) Timing • DSCP / ToS / TPID (MEF) Overwrite
• Subscriber Management Filtering (drop) vCM vCM VSI(N) • CoS Mapping
• Classification & Policing (to Service Flow (SF))
Control • Packet Counters and Statics (IPDR Raw Data)
• Multicast / Packet Replication 802 Plane • Subscriber Management Filtering (drop)
• Scheduling / Shaping Algorithms / QoS Priority of SF Switch • Cable Source Verify / MAC Learning /Protocol Throttling
(LLIDs)(DOCSIS QoS, MEF Metering / Color Marking) • Classification & Policing for forwarding toward the NNI or
• Packet Counters and Statics (IPDR Raw Data) backplane (aggregate rate limiting)
US UTM
• DSCP / ToS / TPID (MEF) Overwrite and Translation DS TM
• CoS Mapping US LTM Upstream Lower Traffic Management (US LTM)
• CALEA / Lawful Intercept (may not be part of TM) • Scheduling / Shaping Algorithms / QoS Priority of LLIDs
EPON MAC (Service Flows)
EPON MAC Layer 10G PHY • Dynamic Bandwidth Allocation (DBA) – solicited
• LLID to VLAN (tunnel ID) scheduling
• Operation, Administration, and Management (OAM) • Token Size per LLID
• Multipoint Control Protocol (MPCP) (Discovery & • Polling Interval per LLID
Registration, GATE Generation, REPORT Processing, Round EPON PHY Layer (Upstream) • Scheduling / Queuing Algorithm
Trip Time, LLID / Preamble (Frame Formation) • FEC • Unsolicited Scheduling
• Encryption AES 128 • PR-type PMD (PON Optics) • MPCP Processing
Copyright 2015 – ARRIS Enterprises, Inc. All rights reserved. 29 September 2017 Overview of PON Technologies and System Architectures for SCTE 30
Centralized Access Architecture (CAA) for PON Purpose Built
Service Provider Facility ODN Actives Passives CPE
Centralized Access Architecture – OLT with Standard Wavelengths
Integrated - DPoE System
PHY/XFP
Timing
DPoE
SFU
M L S R
W
PHY/XFP
Timing
SFU
M L S R
Ethernet
PHY/XFP
Timing
W
DPoE
Optics
Optics
O-E-O
PON
10G
D 10G Ethernet Optics D EPON Optics //
M
M Single Fiber and Lots of Wavelengths
ONU SMB ONU Enterprise
Note 1: OLT / DPoE System is shown in a single shelf. However, using a SDN architecture design the control and data plane processes may be separated, with the control plane processes placed on servers & control traffic
through spine switches. Additionally, using a Network Function Virtualization (NFV) architecture design both control and data plane processes may be placed on servers & traffic through spine switches.
Copyright 2015 – ARRIS Enterprises, Inc. All rights reserved. 06 December 2016 Internal Access BU and CCAP BU Mini Summit 31
Distributed Access Architecture (DAA) for PON Purpose Built
Service Provider Facility ODN Actives Passives CPE
PON Optics
Timing
PHY/XFP
MACsec
PHY/SFP+
US LTM
Timing
Layer 2
W
& MAC
DPoE
EMS MLSR
Distributed Access Architecture – Remote OLT
DPoE Remote OLT (R-OLT) SFU
M L S R
W
PHY/SPF+
DPoE Client
PON Optics
MACsec
MACsec
US LTM
PHY/SFP+
Timing
Layer 2
W
& MAC
D EPON Optics //
TM
10G Ethernet + MACsec D
M
M Single Fiber and Lots of Wavelengths
ONU SMB ONU Enterprise
EMS MLSR
Distributed Access Architecture – Remote DPoE System
Remote DPoE System (RDS) SFU
M L S R
PON Optics
PHY/SPF+
MACsec
PHY/SFP+
MACsec
L2 + L3
US LTM
W
Timing
DPoE
& MAC
D 10G Ethernet + MACsec EPON Optics //
TM
D
M
M Single Fiber and Lots of Wavelengths
ONU SMB ONU Enterprise
Note 1: M-OLT Packet Shelf is shown in a single shelf. However, using a SDN architecture design the control and data plane processes may be separated, with the control plane processes placed on servers & control traffic
through spine switches. Additionally, using a Network Function Virtualization (NFV) architecture design both control and data plane processes may be placed on servers & traffic through spine switches. Note 2: R-OLT is shown
using NFV for the DML only and SDN may used as well. Note 3: R-OLT and RDS may use SDN.
Copyright 2015 – ARRIS Enterprises, Inc. All rights reserved. 06 December 2016 Internal Access BU and CCAP BU Mini Summit 32
Leading OLTs System and Network Architectures
Copyright 2015 – ARRIS Enterprises, Inc. All rights reserved. 29/9/17 Overview of PON Technologies and System Architectures for SCTE 33
Centralized Access Architecture (CAA) for PON OLT
Traditional OLT with PON with All Passive Outside Plant
(PON MAC in the CO/HE with No Actives in the OSP)
20 km Distance at 1:32 Customers
//
Headend
ONU ONU
DPoE System (Basic)
DPoE Media4on (vCM)
ONU ONU
Standard PON Wavelengths
L2/L3
Traffic PON PON // //
Mgmt MAC Op4cs
ONU ONU
//
// Passive Optical splitter
ONU ONU
Copyright 2015 – ARRIS Enterprises, Inc. All rights reserved. 29 September 2017 Overview of PON Technologies and System Architectures for SCTE 34
Centralized Access Architecture (CAA) for PON OLT
Traditional OLT with PON Extender and No Software in the OSP
(Simple Layer 1 Optical-Electrical-Optical (O-E-O) conversion at the node/cabinet)
20 km at 1:32 Customers
10 km at 1:64 Customers
Optical DWDM or CWDM PON ~ 80 km 2 km at ~128 Customers
10G EPON Service Group 1
Extend PON Serving Area Reach and Expand the Number of Customers Served
ONU ONU
MDU
Distances of 5 km from the PON Extender to the ONUs have been observed to support 128 customers / ONUs
Copyright 2015 – ARRIS Enterprises, Inc. All rights reserved. 29 September 2017 Overview of PON Technologies and System Architectures for SCTE 35
Distributed Access Architecture (DAA) for PON OLT
Remote OLT in the OSP/Cabinet with Software in the OSP
(Routing/Switching, Traffic Management, PON MAC/PHY in the node/cabinet)
20 km at 1:32 Customers
10 km at 1:64 Customers
Optical DWDM or CWDM PON ~ 80 km 2 km at ~128 Customers
10G EPON Service Group 1
Extend PON Serving Area Reach and Expand the Number of Customers Served
ONU ONU
MDU
//
Remote OLT
Headend (PON MAC / PHY Functions in the Node) ONU ONU
W DWDM or CWDM W
Routers D D L2/ Traffic PON PON Standard PON Wavelengths
M L3 Mgmt MAC OpDcs
M 10G Ethernet Optics
10G EPON Service Group n
Switch /
Router
ONU ONU
MDU
Distances of 5 km from the Remote OLT to the ONUs have been observed to support 128 customers / ONUs
Copyright 2015 – ARRIS Enterprises, Inc. All rights reserved. 29 September 2017 Overview of PON Technologies and System Architectures for SCTE 36
Overview of Purpose Built OLT Systems
and SDN/NFV Systems for PON
“A Comparison of Purpose Built OLT Systems vs. SDN-NFV Systems for PON”,
Mike Emmendorfer and Sebnem Ozer, SCTE-ISBE Workshop, Sept. 2016
Copyright 2015 – ARRIS Enterprises, Inc. All rights reserved. 29 September 2017 Overview of PON Technologies and System Architectures for SCTE 38
What are the Drivers behind SDN/NFV? (1 of 2)
• Elasticity and Scalability Enable by System Modularity (Disaggregation of CCAP & OLT)
– Disaggregation: Separation of Hardware and Software Functional Blocks
• (PHY, MAC/PHY, Traffic Management/Service Gateway, Switch Fabric/Backplane, Control, WAN/NSI Link)
– Separation of Control and Data Planes
– Separating the network functions allows placement of capacity where and when needed
• (IO capacity for access layer like PON, P2P Ethernet, DOCSIS, etc. where and when needed)
Copyright 2015 – ARRIS Enterprises, Inc. All rights reserved. 29 September 2017 Overview of PON Technologies and System Architectures for SCTE 39
What are the Drivers behind SDN/NFV? (2 of 2)
• Reduce CAPEX
– COTS switches, servers, storage, compute elements
– Reduced headend estate, power and cooling
– Ability to scale per demand and integrate only needed functions
– New pricing options using licenses per subscriber, throughput, features enable (pay-as-you-grow)
– Open Software platforms from multiple vendors
• Reduce OPEX
– Reduced headend power and cooling
– Zero touch provisioning and programmable networks and services with reduced complexity
– End-to-end visibility, analytics and service assurance orchestration
– Dynamic and efficient resource management (self healing/optimizing networks)
– Standard APIs, control and management interfaces
Copyright 2015 – ARRIS Enterprises, Inc. All rights reserved. 29 September 2017 Overview of PON Technologies and System Architectures for SCTE 40
Traditional I-CCAP (e.g. I-CCAP DOCSIS or PON OLT System)
Operator IPDR TOD SYSLOG SNMP DHCP File
Purpose Built CCAP Based DPoE System (Aggregation) (CLI) Collector Server Server Server Server Server
CLI
Core Router Core Router IPDR FTP/
over NTP/ SYSLOG DHCP
Streaming SNMP SFTP/
SSHv2/ SNTP
Protocol TFTP
Telnet
100G WAN Ports
E6000 Management Interfaces
Data Plane
DS TM Mediation
MAC (DS) MAC (US) US LTM vCM vCM Line Cards
PHY (DS) PHY (US) x Client Slots
EPON MAC Control
DAC ADC 10G PHY Plane
10G Ethernet
using DWDM
DS RF US RF 10G EPON
Ports Ports Ports PON Extender
Node
10G EPON Ports
Copyright 2015 – ARRIS Enterprises, Inc. All rights reserved. 29 September 2017 Overview of PON Technologies and System Architectures for SCTE 41
Aggregation to Disaggregation (CAA to DAA + SDN + NFV)
Purpose Built I-CCAP DOCSIS Based System (Aggregation) DAA + SDN + NFV DOCSIS based System (Disaggregation)
Management Plane
Management Plane Traffic Elasticity and Scalability North South East West
Switch Fabric
Active-Active Control Plane (L3)
Control Plane (L3)
Switch Fabric & WAN
Leaf Switch Leaf Switch S-Leaf / DAAS Leaf Switch
Data Plane (L3)
Data Plane (L3)
40G Ethernet 10G Ethernet
Switch Fabric
Switch Fabric
Active-Active CCAP
Non-Blocking Manager WDM
Switch Fabric RPD
Switch Fabric Switch FabricSwitch Fabric Manager
Access Line Cards
Management Plane
Management Plane Traffic Elasticity and Scalability North South East West
Switch Fabric
Active-Active Control Plane (L3)
Control Plane (L3)
Switch Fabric & WAN
Leaf Switch Leaf Switch S-Leaf / DAAS Leaf Switch
Data Plane (L3)
Data Plane (L3)
40G Ethernet 10G Ethernet
Switch Fabric
Switch Fabric
Active-Active vOLT
Non-Blocking Manager WDM
Switch Fabric vCM
Switch Fabric Manager
Access Line Cards
DPoE vRouter
US UTM vRouter
Controller
Data Plane
SDN Controller
OLT Manager RAD vManager Video Switch Underlay
vOLT vCM Controller vCore vCore Server Router and Overlay
Manager Manager EMS VNFM Controllers Controllers Controller
10G Ethernet
using DWDM
using DWDM
I-DPoE System
High Speed WAN Ports
High Speed WAN Ports
Management DPoE Management
Switch Fabric & WAN
Management Plane
MLSR
VSI(1) Control
Plane Mediation Plane
R PE VSI(N)
Control Plane (L3) Plane Management Plane OLT Manager OLT Manager
802
Switch
Data Plane (L3) Control Plane (L3)
Switch Fabric
Switch Fabric
Data Plane (L3)
DPoE Mediation
Switch Fabric
US UTM DPoE DS TM US UTM
Data Plane
DS TM
US LTM
Media?on Aggregation Aggregation Aggregation
vCM vCM MACsec
EPON MAC Control MLSR with MLSR with MLSR with
10G PHY Plane PHY/XFP MACsec MACsec MACsec
10G Ethernet 10G Ethernet 10G Ethernet
10G Ethernet 10G Ethernet using DWDM using DWDM
using DWDM using DWDM
using DWDM with MACsec with MACsec with MACsec
with MACsec
PHY/SFP+
10G EPON PHY/SFP+ PHY/SFP+ MACsec
Ports MACsec MACsec Mgmt Plane
Crtl Plane Crtl Plane Crtl Plane
PHY/SFP+ Data Plane Data Plane Data Plane
MACsec DPoE Client DPoE Med DPoE Med
Data Plane TM TM TM
US LTM US LTM US LTM US LTM
OEO & MAC & MAC & MAC & MAC
PON Optics PON Optics PON Optics PON Optics PON Optics
PON Extender Remote PON MAC (RPM) Remote OLT (R-OLT) Remote OLT with DPoE Remote DPoE System
Copyright 2015 – ARRIS Enterprises, Inc. All rights reserved. 29 September 2017 Overview of PON Technologies and System Architectures for SCTE 45
Example of a Remote OLT with OLT Manager Interfaces
Overlay/
Underlay NETCONF
Operator Operator IPDR TOD SYSLOG SNMP DHCP File
Controller /Yang Kafka Fluentd
(RESTCONF) (CLI) Collector Server Server Server Server Server
Future Models Current
Interfaces RESTCONF CLI Interfaces
IPDR FTP/
Telemetry over NTP/
OpenFlow SYSLOG (CLI) API Streaming SYSLOG SNMP DHCP SFTP/
Data SSHv2/ SNTP
over HTTPS Protocol TFTP
Telnet
OLT Manager
vOLT Manager Interfaces vCM Manager Interfaces
- SNMP (CMTS and System MIBs) - SNMP (CM MIBs)
Mgmt Mgmt
- vOLT Manager System Logs
Plane Plane vCMs - vCM Logs
- vOLT Manager System Syslog (Legacy) - vCM Syslog
(Future)
- vOLT Manager IPDR - TFTP
- TFTP
vOLT Manager vCM Manager - DHCP-RA for vCM Mgr
- DHCP for vOLT Manager IP Address
Tunneled
DPoE-OAM
ONU
R-OLT
Spine/ ONU
vRouter leaf S-Leaf R-OLT
servers 10G Ethernet + MACsec
ONU
MACsec for connection to S-Leaf (DAAS)
R-OLT
and remote authentication server
Copyright 2015 – ARRIS Enterprises, Inc. All rights reserved. 29 September 2017 Overview of PON Technologies and System Architectures for SCTE 46
Initial Pros & Cons of Purpose Built DPoE Systems
• Pros
– Hardware and software integration create a highly reliable system
• Maturity of System enables low MTTD and MTTR
– Hardware and software are optimized for each function
• (example high packet processing in less space, power, and cost that commodity server NFV)
– Suppliers can rigorously test and troubleshoot known hardware and software
– Enable customers to go to a single supplier to resolve hardware and/or software issues
• Cons
– Accused of slow innovation of hardware and software features
– Closed purpose built systems have rigid scalability which binds access ports, fabric, WAN ports, type and
number of slots all together, if any one is exhausted another system is required to address capacity.
– Purpose built system vendor hardware and software may not be repurposed to run different software
– New access technologies (DOCSIS, PON, and Ethernet) on the CCAP require rewriting of similar functions
– Lack of programmability from a single controller (EMS) to all system components
Copyright 2015 – ARRIS Enterprises, Inc. All rights reserved. 29 September 2017 Overview of PON Technologies and System Architectures for SCTE 47
Initial Pros & Cons of SDN/NFV DPoE Systems
• Pros
– Disaggregation = Elasticity and Targeted Scalability where/when needed
– Ability to Pay-as-you-grow where capacity is needed (client cards, WAN, control, chassis independence)
– New pricing options using licenses per subscriber, throughput, features enable (pay-as-you-grow)
– Agility consistent services and features across vendors and access technologies (DOCSIS, PON, Ethernet, Wireless)
– Promises of open platform ecosystem (No Proprietary System Vendor hardware, software, interfaces)
– Readiness for control plane using commodity x86 exist
– New business relationships for SDN/NFV hosted web services for disaster recovery and capacity augmentation
– SDN / NFV enables the service provider to select hardware and software platforms and require system vendors to develop on
those systems. This enables consistent platforms, vendor hardware independence, and migration to different system
vendors.
• Cons
– Disaggregation = Complexity and Integration
– Many white-box switches use merchant silicon for accelerated and specialized packet processing (not open/off shelf)
– x86 for high packet processing data plane require more space, power, and cost
– Scalability of some server based network functions (vRouter) are not at all at the level of purpose built systems
– Lack of standards and certification
– Interoperability issues may be troublesome among various hardware, software, and interfaces
– Maturity of system may impact end-to-end MTTD and MTTR
– Open source does not mean the same implementation
Copyright 2015 – ARRIS Enterprises, Inc. All rights reserved. 29 September 2017 Overview of PON Technologies and System Architectures for SCTE 48
Questions?
Copyright 2015 – ARRIS Enterprises, Inc. All rights reserved. 29 September 2017 49
Thank you!
Copyright 2015 – ARRIS Enterprises, Inc. All rights reserved. 29 September 2017 50
References
• “DOCSIS® Provisioning of EPON (DPoE™): A Next Generation Business Services Network”, Curtis Knittle,
CableLabs SCTE EXPO 2011
• “Next Generation Networks for Multiple Dwelling Units (MDUs)”, Michael J. Emmendorfer, SCTE-ISBE
Workshop, September 2014
• “Comparing IEEE EPON & FSAN/ITU-T GPON Family of Technologies“, Michael J. Emmendorfer, SCTE-ISBE
Workshop, September 2014
• “A Comparison of Centralized vs. Distributed Access Architectures for PON“, Mike Emmendorfer and Sebnem
Zorlu Ozer, INTX 2016, Spring Tech Forum
• “A Comparison of Purpose Built OLT Systems vs. SDN-NFV Systems for PON”, Mike Emmendorfer and
Sebnem Ozer, SCTE-ISBE Workshop, Sept. 2016
• “End-to-end IP Video Services over 10G EPON Access Network Architectures“, Sebnem Zorlu Ozer and Mike
Emmendorfer, SCTE-ISBE Journal of Digital Video, Volume 1, Number 2, Sept. 2016
Copyright 2015 – ARRIS Enterprises, Inc. All rights reserved. 29 September 2017 Overview of PON Technologies and System Architectures for SCTE 51
PON Acronyms and Meaning
Term Meaning
APON ATM Passive Optical Network
BPON Broadband-Passive Optical Network
GPON Gigabit-Passive Optical Network
GEPON Gigabit Ethernet - Passive Optical Network (aka EPON)
EPON Ethernet Passive Optical Network (aka GE-PON)
10 EPON 10 Gigabit Ethernet PON
DPON Data Over Cable Service Interface Specification - PON uses EPON for MAC/PHY and DOCSIS defined
transactions and standards for OAM&P. (aka: DOCSIS over EPON or DPON)
RFoG Radio Frequency over Glass (aka: Radio Frequency PON (RF-PON) or Radio Frequency over Glass (RFOG) or
Hybrid-Fiber-Coax PON (HFC-PON) or Cable PON
Copyright 2015 – ARRIS Enterprises, Inc. All rights reserved. 29 September 2017 Overview of PON Technologies and System Architectures for SCTE 52
High-Level MSO SDN/NFV Architecture for 10G EPON
OSS/BSS
Network Inventory Subscriber/Service Database Policy
SDN Controller
OLT Manager RAD vManager Video Switch Underlay
vOLT vCM Controller vCore vCore Server Router and Overlay
Manager Manager EMS VNFM Controllers Controllers Controller
10G Ethernet
using DWDM
using DWDM
• Orchestration Layer
– Service and resource (networking, compute and storage) orchestration
• Service Orchestration (XOS) VM Orchestration on server and cloud (OpenStack, CloudStack, Hypervisor…)
– Service and network chaining, management of NFVIs
– Elastic resource management based on capacity, performance and power requirements and resource
optimization and load balancing
– Support for legacy EMS/NMS
– End-to-end service assurance and monitoring
– Underlay fabric and overlay network management
Copyright 2015 – ARRIS Enterprises, Inc. All rights reserved. 29 September 2017 Overview of PON Technologies and System Architectures for SCTE 54
System Architecture
• SDN Controllers
– NETCONF/YANG for configuration and management (FCAPS); OpenFlow for programming forwarding;
legacy SNMP/CLI ; Proprietary APIs
– Access network and service controllers
• vDPoE System and vCM controller
– Mediation between OSS, NMS and EPON layers
– Configuration and management of DPoE based OLT and ONU (DOCSIS OAMP functions)
• R-OLT controller
– Remote access device specific configuration and management
• vRouter/MLSR controller
– Configuration and management of OLT routing functionality
• Switch/router controller
– Configuration, management and control of fabric switches/routers
• Video controllers
– Configuration and management of video functions such as Multicast (M-ABR) , S-ABR, nDVR, vCDN etc…
– Network Controller (OpenDayLight, ONOS)
Copyright 2015 – ARRIS Enterprises, Inc. All rights reserved. 29 September 2017 Overview of PON Technologies and System Architectures for SCTE 55
System Architecture
• Network Functions
– Virtual (SW on COTS elements) and physical (embedded in HW) and purpose built network functions
• Data volume, control transaction rate, performance and security requirements
– Access network and service functions
• vRouter/MLSR: OLT Routing functionality
• vCPE: CPE/SG related functions such as parental control, firewall
• vVideo: Video service specific functions such as M-ABR, S-ABR servers, nDVR recorder, CDN/edge cache…
– Disaggregation of functions into common and specific features
– Support for control/management by controllers and orchestrators
– Support for analytics
– Implemented as VMs, containers
• Fabric Network
– Spine and leaf switches
• Controlled and managed by SDN controller/orchestrator
– Access specific S-leaf switch
Copyright 2015 – ARRIS Enterprises, Inc. All rights reserved. 29 September 2017 Overview of PON Technologies and System Architectures for SCTE 56