Review of Related Literature and Studies
Review of Related Literature and Studies
Review of Related Literature and Studies
This chapter includes the review of related literature and studies which the
RELATED LITERATURE
tend to rely on the actions and support from the government. Being a growing concern,
public safety has become the center of interest of the society because of the dangers
that currently pose to individuals. At every arena of public life, implementing agencies
ensures public security through programs and activities, so that health and normal life is
always maintained.
Thus, this study focuses its discussion in the related literature on the assessment
order to prevent violence against women. It will also discuss ordinances promoting self-
defense workshops and seminars for the public safety of women in Batangas City,
violence faced by women as well as crime rate and factors resulted by this assaults.
LEGAL FRAMEWORK
The Philippine Constitutions provides that “The States values the dignity of
each person and guarantees full respect for human rights” expressively in Article II,
Section 11. It additionally guarantees one and all the proper to life, security of person
and 12)
Section 3 of Republic Act 9710 otherwise known as the Magna Carta of Women
(MCW) provides that “All individuals are equal as human beings by virtue of the inherent
dignity of each human person. No one should therefore suffer discrimination on the
basis of ethnicity, gender, age, language, sexual orientation, race, color, religion,
birth, or other status as established by human rights standards. Magna Carta for
Women on "Protection from Violence" Section 9 states that the State shall ensure that
all women shall be protected from all forms of violence as provided for in existing laws.
As an act upholding a strong security for women against violence and abuses on
gender inequality, it prioritizes into the defense and protection of women against
recruitment and training of women in the police force forensics and medico-legal
services, and social work services availed of by women who were victims of gender-
related offenses until 50 percent (50%) of the personnel thereof shall be women. Also,
women shall have the right to protection and security in situations of armed conflict and
militarization. Towards this end, they shall be protected from all forms of gender-based
violence particularly rape and other forms of sexual abuse, and all forms of violence in
situations of armed conflicts. The state shall observe international standards for the
However, Rule IV of the Rules and Regulations Implementing the Magna Carta
barangay to ensure that violence against women cases are fully addressed in a gender-
sexual orientation and gender identity have been enacted in nineteen (19) LGUs,
namely: Barangays Bagbag, Lagro and Pansol in Quezon City, Angeles City in
Batangas, Candon City in Ilocos Sur, Cebu City, Dagupan City in Pangasinan, Davao
City, Mandaue City, Puerto Princesa, Quezon City, Vigan City in Ilocos Sur, Municipality
of San Julian in Eastern Samar, Province of Agusan del Norte, Province of Cavite. Sur,
Cebu City, Dagupan City in Pangasinan, Davao City, Mandaue City, Puerto Princesa,
Quezon City, Vigan City in Ilocos Sur, Municipality of San Julian in Eastern Samar,
Moreover, the punong barangay shall designate a VAW Desk person who is
or woman barangay tanod. Functions of the Barangay VAW desk is further explained
and shall perform the following tasks :( 1) respond to gender-based violence cases
brought to the barangay. (2) Record the number of gender-based violence handled by
the barangay and submits quarterly report on all cases of VAW to the DILG
City/Municipal Field Office and the City/ Municipal Social Welfare Development Office
(C/MSWDO). (3) keep VAW case records confidential and secured, and ensure that
only authorized personnel can access it.(4) assist victims of VAW in securing Barangay
Protection Order (BPO) and access necessary services.(5) develop the barangay
services, capacity building and referral system. (6) Coordinate with and refer cases to
service providers as necessary. (7) Address other forms of abuse committed against
women, especially senior citizens, women with disabilities, and other marginalized
groups. (8) Lead advocacies on the elimination of VAW in the community. (9) Perform
other related functions as may be assigned. All government personnel involved in the
The term violence against women describes a wide range of acts, including
murder, rape and sexual assault, physical assault, emotional abuse, beating, stalking,
prostitution, genital mutilation, sexual harassment and pornography. In the still evolving
field, there is little consensus on exactly how to define violence against women. The
main contention is whether the word ' violence' should be strictly defined or whether the
phrase ' violence against women' should be seen more generally as aggressive
define violence, definitions that can be implemented. For example, Gelles and Straus
(1979) defined violence as “any act carried out with a view to causing physical pain or
injury to another person or with a perceived intention.” Similarly, the National Research
Council (NRC) report Understanding and Preventing Violence (Reiss and Roth, 1993)
limited its definition to "behavior by persons against persons that intentionally threatens,
attempts, or actually inflicts physical harm." The 1993 NRC study deliberately excluded
behavior that inflicts harm unintentionally, while the Gelles and Straus definition
includes behaviors that may be unintentional but are perceived by the victim to be
intentional.
health, and social work frequently consider "violence" to cover a wider range of
behaviors. The Committee on Family Violence of the National Institute of Mental Health
(1992) included in its definition of violence "acts that are physically and emotionally
harmful or that carry the potential to cause physical harm … [and] may also include
normal activities or freedom, and denial of access to resources. The Task Force on
violence as ''physical, visual, verbal, or sexual acts that are experienced by a woman or
a girl as a threat, invasion, or assault and that have the effect of hurting her or
degrading her and/or taking away her ability to control contact (intimate or otherwise)
with another individual" (Koss et al., 1994). Those who argue for these broader
definitions suggest they more accurately represent the experiences of victims, who
often say they find verbal and psychological abuse more harmful than actual physical
abuse (Walker, 1979; Follingstad et al., 1990; Herman, 1995). In the field of intimate
violence, psychological abuse, sexual violence, and denial of resources. The concern is
about the multitude of behaviors used to dominate women. Physical violence does not
often need to be used to be effective: “In fact, abusers may regret resorting to violence,
but may feel ' driven' when their other methods of enforcing subordination are
insufficient “(Herman, 1995, p. 2). Fear is a key factor in the field of rape; it is a major
concern of many women (Warr, 1985; Gordon and Riger, 1989; Klodawsky and Lundy,
1994). Although women are the victims of violent crime less often than men, women are
more afraid of crime (Federal Office of Investigation, 1991) and this fear seems to be
largely based on their fear of fear of rape (Riger et al., 1981). Many feminist theorists
contend that this fear of rape serves to intimidate and control all women (Griffin, 1971;
acts and societal oppression. It covers all the ways in which our society aims and
pornography, stalking, battering and rape. It includes girls ' sexual and physical abuse
Every form of violence threatens all women and limits their ability to make
choices about their lives. Sexual violence is particularly insidious because sexual acts
are ordinarily and rightly a source of pleasure and communication. It is often unclear to
a victimized woman and to society as a whole whether sexual abuse was committed out
of sexual desire or through violent intent or whether these motivations can even be
males (Bachman, 1994). In one urban emergency room, violence was the most
common cause of injury to women between the ages of 15 and 44 and the second most
common cause of injury for all women (Grisso et al., 1991). Finally, women are far more
likely than men to be sexually assaulted. The National Crime Victimization Survey
(NCVS) found women were 10 times more likely to be raped or sexually assaulted than
were men (Bastian, 1995). The annual rate of rape is estimated to be 7.1 per 1,000
adult women, and 13 percent of all women will experience forcible rape sometime
In spite of the attention that has been paid to violence against women in recent
years, the research endeavor is relatively young, and much remains unknown. There
really is no one field focused on violence against women per se. Studies on rape and
sexual assault, for example, are separate from those on intimate partner violence, which
is different from the nascent stalking study. And all this research on violence in general
is different. Many of the studies on violence against women in this newly emerging field
and rape research have been extensively discussed in other papers (Rosenbaum,
1988; Gelles, 1990; Koss, 1992, 1993; Rosenfeld, 1992; Smith, 1994). Definitions differ
from study to study, comparisons and weak deeds to eliminate these types of misery.
SELF-DEFENSE
of assault; it is training to learn and use a small group of simple effective physical
particular physical and mental skills will strengthen woman’s physical capacities,
support woman’s independence, and increase women’s mobility and, ultimately, move
that day offer a more empowering perspective to women. According to Shibutani (1995),
The main features of a self - defense class that fosters group development and
cohesion include opportunities to share narratives and mutual perspectives. (Fraser and
hitting, punching, kicking, and screaming and yelling to attract help can reduce
victimization and increase self-efficiency among individuals (Anderson and
Dickenson (2008) suggest that while rape prevention and resistance can be a response
for individual women, they cannot be a solution for women as a group because males
diluted by such tactics target women who have not been trained in self - defense.
Furthermore, Women’s self-defense training aims to arm women with the skills to
avoid, interrupt, and resist assault. Early second-wave feminists, aware of the
it, took their safety literally into their own hands, adapting martial arts techniques to suit
women’s needs; adding verbal, psychological, and emotional skills; and integrating a
critical gender consciousness into their trainings (Telsey, 1981 cited by Hollander, 2016,
p. 207).
The self - defense course of a woman, which includes both physical technique
others in a way that protects and affirms their self - esteem, identity and emotions while
respecting the identity and emotions of the other with whom they interact.
In learning self – defense there are “changes in the interaction patterns of women
with strangers, even if they do not threaten violence”. In this way, self - defense training
literally trains women to defend themselves, not only physically and sexually, but also
2004, p. 217)
PUBLIC SAFETY
As defined by United State (US) Legal Dictionary, public safety, as a welfare and
states have public security departments with the primary objective of preventing
dangers and protecting the public from crimes and disasters. In different cases, the
Public Safety Division is made up of people from other organizations including police,
among peoples is high. It is a substitute term for social integration. It can be measured
indirectly, as in the case of suicide, murder, rates of accidental death or violent attacks,
but these are not social integration measures or the density of connections. This
According to Chris Cornell (2010), public security is a growing concern due to the
dangers that individuals and society currently face. He stressed that public safety is
important in the implementation of public safety measures to ensure that health and
normal life are always maintained. Every country has its own regulations and rules on
safety maintenance.
UN Women’s Global Flagship Initiative, “Safe Cities and Safe Public Spaces,”
builds on its “Safe Cities Free of Violence against Women and Girls” Global Program,
preventing and responding to sexual harassment and other forms of sexual violence
against women and girls throughout the world. It began with founding program in Quito,
Ecuador; Cairo, Egypt; New Delhi, India; Port Moresby, Papua New Guinea; and Kigali,
As the worldwide program demonstrates, the UN Women’s Safe Cities and Safe
through partnerships with mayors ' offices, national governments, women's groups and
In Cairo, the Ministry of Housing, Utilities and Urban Development of Egypt has
carried out women's security audits to guide urban planning, and more than 100 youth
change agents (50 percent young men and 50 percent young women) have been
involved and are leading transformative activities in schools and other settings in the
Mayors and local governments have played a major role in the evolution of
community security in Europe, North America, Africa and Australasia over the past
twenty years. The number of initiatives aimed at crime, victimization and social
victimization has shown that many agencies must work together to prevent crime.
Mayors and local governments have seen Community security as a fundamental human
right and an aspect of community quality of life. They were able to mobilize local
safe, secure and lively communities in large metropolitan areas and smaller towns and
rural areas: (a) the shift from a relatively narrow focus on crime prevention to a broader
public good community security and security issue (b) the development of consensus on
the need to work for community security by addressing the social and economic
conditions that promote crime and victimization (c) from the primary responsibility of the
police to the recognition that governments, communities and partnerships at all levels
must be actively involved (d) the recognition of the crucial role played by local municipal
leaders in this process through the organization and motivation of local partners '
coalitions to create a healthy and safe communities (e) Increasing evidence shows that
intervention targeting risk factors can be effective and cost effective in reducing crime
trained government workforce. For this reason, the CSC is committed to interventions
that will improve the knowledge, skills and expertise of government employees,
especially middle - level managers, and equip them with new ones in accordance with
the principle that “tomorrow’s jobs cannot be done with yesterday’s skills.” (Rosas,
2000)
Violence against women takes many forms. (a.) Domestic violence is where a
person attempts in an intimate relationship to control and assert power over his or her
partner. Any woman can be affected and in any house. Twenty - five per cent of all
reported violent crimes involve a man attacking his wife or partner. Domestic violence
involves physical, emotional, financial and sexual abuse. (b) Sexual assault and rape.
Rape is considered the most underreported violent crime and research at European
level shows that only 2 to 10% of rape is reported to the authorities. In 2011, there were
28, 615 helpline contacts to Rape Crisis services, a 10% increase on 2010. Statistics
for that year also show that 90 percent of perpetrators were known to the survivor when
sexual assaults occurred. (c) Prostitution and trafficking in which women suffered
terrifying and degrading treatment in this form of violence, and extreme levels of
violence, such as beatings, rape and sexual assault. The strong connection between
prostitution and sexually exploited trafficking has been well documented. On average,
1000 women can be sold every day and the vast majority is migrant women and girls.
(d) Female Genital Mutilation is considered an act of violence against women and
children because it can cause irreparable harm to female genitalia and reproductive
organs. It is common practice in at least 28 countries, in Africa, Middle East and Asia.
(e) Forced Marriage where women have found themselves deceived and subject to
sexual and other forms of abuse by agents and or prospective spouses. (f) Sexual
Harassment occurs when unwanted conduct has the purpose or effect of violating a
In The World Women’s 2015 Journal Issue, violence can lead to long - term
physical, mental and emotional problems; violence against women can lead to death in
the most extreme cases. Two thirds of the victims of inmate partner / family homicides
are women, while only 20% of the victims of all cases are women on cases of homicide.
direct consequences of abuse and/or sexual assault, such as traumatic injury, unwanted
consequences of the effect of traumatic stress, which can influence physical health by
emerging literature shows that many reflect physiological changes. Such effects are
especially common for women who suffer from repeated or long - term victimization.
Many of these repercussions last several years after violence. . Although the severity
and duration of violence are important determinants of the extent of the physical
woman to violence. Doctors and other healthcare professionals deal with the many
physical sequences of violence, even if they do not identify them. In fact, women who
have been subjected to violence are more likely to seek medical attention than to use
mental health, social services, clergy counseling, victim assistance or legal assistance.
Because of this increased utilization, health care providers have numerous opportunities
to help women who are experiencing of the effects of trauma (Tjaden and Thoennes,
2010).
primarily to address the VAW issue. These programs and facilities include temporary
care and shelter for women in particularly difficult circumstances, the Department of
Social Welfare and Development's Haven crisis intervention unit. The Department of
Health (DOH) institutionalizes the women and children protection on all its 39 hospitals
nationwide, now called the Women and Children Protection Unit, each WCPU is
In collaboration with the Unit for Child Protection and Women's Desk of the
Philippine General Hospital of the University of the Philippines, DOH has developed a
training program for WCPU doctors that meet the needs of women and children
survivors of violence. The training program also allows forensic doctors to work so that
rising programs of government on the issues on violence against women. This initiative
includes the following. (a) The Philippine Judicial Academy (PHILJA) conducts gender-
awareness seminars for prosecutors and judges as well as the five pillars of the justice
reflective of the youth’s visions and aspirations and supportive of their well-being.
(d)NGO community should be credited for not only raising violence against women as a
public issue and for providing services even before government systems were setup. (e)
Women’s Crisis Center (WCC), the first crisis center for victims/survivors of VAW-
launched its national family violence prevention program in 1997 with 18 cities and
family members to protect themselves against violence and manage peaceful resolution
of conflict within the context of family relations. (f) Other women NGOs that have been
KALAKASAN (women against Violence, an NGO providing shelter and counseling) and
Women’s’ legal bureau (legal group). (g) Several networks on violence against women
trafficking local and international. (A Deeper Look at Violence against Woman: The
Philippine case).
RELATED STUDIES
their safety against violence and crimes against women. It shows that around 120
million girls worldwide (slightly more than 1 in 10) at some point in their lives have
More than one in four women in Washington, DC, USA, experienced some form
make up 51% of all trafficked persons detected worldwide. Together, women and girls
account for 71%, with girls representing almost three out of four trafficked women and
girls being trafficked for sexual exploitation. Some national studies show, however, that
up to 70% of women have experienced physical and/or sexual abuse from an intimate
partner throughout their lives. It is estimated that in 2012, almost half of all women who
were victims of homicide worldwide were killed by intimate partners or family members,
compared with less than six per cent of men killed in the same year. With regard to
violence, the study shows that less than 40% of women who experience violence are
seeking help of any kind. Among women who look for family and friends, most look for
Women, " conducted in 1997, states that women have fewer advantages and privileges
than men built into the patriarchal system. Women are in a lower position and
There is also a new study from Canada involving 893 Canadian women who are
Acknowledge Act, which shows that college students who received 12 hours of training
This study is based on earlier research carried out by the self - defense training
company Model Mugging. They surveyed 60,000 of their female students and found that
98.3 percent of their students were able to prevent attacks after training (more intense
than Canadian training). Of those attacked, 97 percent were able to fight their
aggressor,
efficacy of a sexual assault risk reduction program including a physical self - defense
component for college women was evaluated in 2006 (N=500). Over the six - month
follow - up period, the women of the program group significantly increased their
protective behavior. However, during the follow - up periods there were no significant
differences between the two groups regarding sexual victimization rates, assertive
victimized during the 3-month follow - up period showed less self-defamation and
greater offender blame than control group women who were victimized following the
program. Given that women in the program were more aware of sexual assault at the
end of the study than women in the control group, the difficulties in addressing the
De Welde, K. (2003) in his study entitled " Getting Physical: Subverting Gender
stronger self that challenges dominant discourses. The process he used is to reframe
victimization, liberate him and allow the body to transform gender and self-narratives
studies (1992) entitled “Self - defense training for female college " examines the
effectiveness of self - defense training for female college. Advocates of self - defense
training believe that these courses will not only provide women with the physical survival
techniques necessary to effectively repel attacks, but also help prevent future violence
evidence that women with such features are less likely to be victims. Opponents argue
that self - defense training does not adequately prepare women for an attack, does not
address rape threats adequately and can give students a dangerous false sense of
security.
Assertiveness Training and Women's Response to Sexual Acts” studies explains that
self - defense classes aim to prevent violence against women by enhancing the ability
of women to defend themselves. Little research has, however, examined the effects of
self - defense training on attempts by women to combat back during actual attacks. This
and the physical and psychological responses of women to subsequent rape attacks
(N=1,623). Multi - disciplinary analyzes showed that victims with pre-assault training
were more likely to say that their resistance stopped or made the offender less
aggressive than victims without training. Women with training prior to their attacks were
angrier and less afraid than women without training, in line with self-teaching.
Preassault trainers rated their degree of non - consent or resistance as lower than non -
participants, perhaps because they were higher. Suggestions for future research on self
- defense and rape prevention for women are included in her recommendations.
academic class reveals additional important research support. This 4-credit Women's
Studies class was taught by the author of the Inside Out Self - Defense. Nadia Telsey is
a national non - violence and personal security expert and founder of the National
Women's Martial Arts Federation, which has been teaching at Oregon University for 17
years. During a 10-week academic quarter, her course included 45 hours in PSE. This
women's class included 3 hours of physical and verbal PSE training per week plus a
weekly discussion period of 1.5 hours. A qualitative longitudinal study revealed deep
and wide - ranging learning results for the students. Researchers identified five areas in
which the most striking changes were: “interactions with strangers, interactions with
about one’s body, perceived self-confidence, and beliefs about women, men, and
efficacy, risk avoidance, trust and self - esteem, and can also reduce anxiety and fear
(Brecklin, 2008; Hollander, 2004). It was important to note that low self - esteem and
In the Philippines, self - defense workshops are held (a) in Laoag City in
particular, Ilocos Norte teaches self - defense to its women, as well as providing
Gender and Development office, Ilocos Norte’s 2017 celebration of National Women’s
month kicks off with a woman’s trade fair and self-defense training for female students.
theme “ Be fit to Fight VAW”.(c) The Philippine Embassy in Athens, Greece conducted
“Basic Self-Defense Awareness and Skills Training” for the female members of the
Filipino community as part of its Gender and Development activities for 2014 and in time
for the month’s celebration of women’s month.(d) Two hundred women personnel of the
held.
In the Philippines, the rights of women against violence were protected by the
following laws:
1.1The 1987 Philippine Constitution - The protection of the human rights of all
is Article II, Section 14 which provides that “the state recognizes the role of
women in nation building and shall ensure the fundamental equality before the
1.2 Anti-Mail Order Bride Law (Republic Act 6955) – The law declares
created for matching Filipinas to foreign nationals and, through the use of the
postal service.
1.3 Anti-Sexual Harassment Act of 1995 (Republic Act 7877) – The law
sexual favors.
1.4 Anti-Rape Law of 1997 (Republic Act 8353) – The law reclassifies rape as
recognizes marital rape and questions the notion of sexual obligation in marriage.
It also notes that rape happens even without penetration and the use of objects
1.5 Rape Victims Assistance and Protection Act of 1998 (Republic Act 8505)
– The law provides assistance and protection to rape victims, establishes for the
purpose a rape crisis center in every province and city and authorizes the
appropriation of funds for the establishment and operation of the rape crisis
mandated for the law enforcement officers, public prosecutors, lawyers, medico-
legal officers, social workers and barangay officials on human rights and their
1.6 Anti-Trafficking in Persons Act of 2003 (Republic Act 9208) – The law
provided protection and support services by the State. Government agencies are
national and local levels for his/her early recovery and reintegration.
1.7 Anti-Violence Against Women and Their Children Act of 2004 (Republic
Act 9262) – The law defines violence against women and their children as a
public crime. It provides for the security of the woman-complainant and her
prosecutors, court personnel, social welfare and health care providers and the
The Anti-Violence Against Women and their Children Act of 2004 is in keeping
The forms of VAW addressed are physical, sexual, psychological and economic
abuse.
1.8 Article 245 of the Revised Penal Code (Republic Act 3815) – The law
provides that abuse against chastity is committed by any public officer who shall
report to or consult with a superior officer; or by any warden or other public officer
directly charged with the care and custody of prisoners or persons under arrest
The Philippines has adopted several National Plans to address VAW, beginning
with the Philippine Women's Development Plan (PDPW), 1989-1992, approved and
adopted by Executive Order 348 on 17 February 1989. Chapter 12 of the PDPW details
the programs and projects to be added and these were: domestic violence, rape, sexual
The PDPW was then followed by the Philippine Plan for Gender-
Executive Order 273 by then president Fidel V. Ramos. The PPGD has a long - term
vision of women's empowerment and gender equality and translates the Beijing
Platform for Action into Filipino women's policies and strategies and programs and
projects.
Framework Plan for Women (FPW) 2001-2004. The FPW is a time frame of the
PPGD and was developed in 2001 by the NCRFW in cooperation with partner
government agencies. The FPW sets out the government's priority goals for women's
advancement. The evolution of FPW was guided by the PPGD and the BPFA
framework. It adopts a gender and development approach that recognizes that the
unequal relationship between women and men in the Philippines hinders the pursuit of
VAW, reproductive health, and human rights and reflects this in its commitment to
addressing the “structural roots of gender gaps”. It also emphasizes human rights and
places VAW in its objective of promoting women's human rights committed to protecting
and advancing women's human rights through a strengthened service and justice
system for VAW survivors and information, women's rights education campaigns.
The FPW outlines its thrusts along three areas of concern: Women’s Human
Aside from the national efforts of the government to prevent violence against
women there were also local ordinances in the Philippines passed to protect women’s
right and safety: (a) an ordinance providing for a women’s development code of Davao
city, and for other purposes---This ordinance shall be known as the “Women
Development Code of Davao City. It shall be the policy of the Local Government Code
of Davao City to uphold the rights of women and the belief in their worth and dignity as
human beings. (b) Quezon City Council- an ordinance amending ordinance no. sp1401,
s-200, entitled” an ordinance providing for a city gender and development code, and for
other purposes” to harmonize with the provisions of republic act no. 9710, otherwise
known as “the Magna Carta of women” and to adopt the un women’s safe cities and
safe public spaces initiative. (c) An ordinance compelling every barangay of the city of
Batangas to establish violence against women (VAW) desk and launch protocol in