Edinburgh EH14 4AS, United Kingdom Produced by Heriot-Watt University, 2018
Edinburgh EH14 4AS, United Kingdom Produced by Heriot-Watt University, 2018
Edinburgh EH14 4AS, United Kingdom Produced by Heriot-Watt University, 2018
Separation Processes B
Heriot-Watt University
Acknowledgements
Thanks are due to the members of Heriot-Watt, School of Engineering and Physical Science
who planned and generated this material.
We would like to acknowledge the assistance and contributions from colleagues across the
University and students in preparing this and support material.
Contents
TOPIC 1: EVAPORATION
TOPIC 2: DRYING
TOPIC 4: GLOSSARY
Topic 1
Evaporation
Contents
Evaporation ............................................................................................................ 1
1.1. Introduction to Evaporation ...............................................................................3
1.2 Indirect Heating .................................................................................................4
1.2.1 Natural Circulation .................................................................................4
1.2.2 Forced Circulation .................................................................................5
1.2.3 Film Type Units .....................................................................................6
1.3 Some Important Considerations ........................................................................9
1.3.1 Operating Under Vacuum ......................................................................9
1.3.2 Boiling Point Rise (BPR) ........................................................................9
1.3.3 Nomenclature and Basic Equations .....................................................10
1.4 Evaporator Configurations ...............................................................................13
1.4.1 Single Effect Evaporator ......................................................................13
1.4.2 Multi-Effect Evaporator ........................................................................13
1.5 Multi-Effect Arrangements ...............................................................................15
1.5.1 Forward Feed ......................................................................................15
1.5.2 Backward Feed ...................................................................................16
1.5.3 Parallel Feed .......................................................................................16
1.5.4 Economy of Multi-Effect Arrangements ...............................................17
1.5.5 Number of Effects................................................................................20
1.5.6 Condensation of Final Vapour .............................................................21
1.5.7 Vacuum Equipment .............................................................................23
1.5.8 Simplified Multi-Effect Evaporation Calculations ..................................24
1.6 Tutorial Questions Topic 1 ...............................................................................29
1.7 Bibliography ....................................................................................................33
Prerequisite knowledge
Learning objectives
After studying this topic 1 of “Separation Process A” you should be able to:
A wide variation of evaporator designs exists due to the use of evaporators used in
a variety of processes. Evaporators can be grouped into two types depending on the
way heat is supplied. Heating supply can be either direct or indirect. Direct heating
is represented either by solar evaporation or by submerged combustion of a fuel. In
indirect heating, the product is generally heated by the condensation of steam,
passing through the heat transfer surface of the evaporator.
The following list contains the names of the most common types of evaporators.
Direct Heating:
Solar heating
Submerged combustion
Indirect Heating:
Natural circulation
Forced circulation
Film-type units
Indirect heating evaporations will be explained in more detail in the next section.
On this basis indirect heating evaporators may be classified into three main types:
demister pad
1.2.1 Natural Circulation
VAPOUR
demister pad
CONCENTRATE
FEED
CONDENSATE
CONCENTRATE
VAPOUR
CONCENTRATE
STEAM
CONDENSATE
FEED
In both natural circulation and forced circulation evaporators the liquid remains in the
evaporator for some considerable time. Unlike those, film type units are designed to
have low residence time (seconds rather than up to 1 hr) and the operation is usually
once through flow. Film type units are especially good for heat sensitive products as
they are kept at high temperatures for very short periods. Three different types of
film units are shown below.
In climbing film evaporators, the feed enters the bottom and steam begins to form as
it heats. The steam produced causes the liquid and vapour to flow upwards. Vapour
production increases and the product is pressed as a thin film on the walls of the
tubes, resulting the liquid to rise upwards.
VAPOUR
STEAM
CONCENTRATE
CONDENSATE
FEED
Evaporator Cyclone
b) Falling film
In falling film evaporators, the liquid film moves downwards. The liquid flows
downwards flow under gravitational force and a thin film forms on the inside of heated
vertical tubes. Vapour too flows downwards parallel to the liquid in the centre of the
tubes. A complete unit consists of the evaporator, a separator to separate the
vapours from the residual liquid, and a condenser.
Falling film evaporators are the most commonly used type of evaporator. They are
suitable for higher viscosities, but film is thicker and heat transfer coefficient lower.
FEED
STEAM
CONDENSATE VAPOUR
CONCENTRATE
Evaporator Cyclone
In thin film evaporators the liquid entering the unit is picked up by the rotating blades
and thrown against the tube wall. This provides a thin film of liquid. The film flows
downwards by gravity and it becomes more concentrated as it flows down. The
concentrated liquid is removed at the bottom by a pump, and the vapour leaves at
the top of the unit.
Thin film evaporators are a development of falling film with higher heat transfer rates.
FEED VAPOUR
STEAM
CONDENSATE
CONCENTRATE
Also operation under a vacuum increases the temperature difference between the
steam and boiling liquid and therefore heat transfer rates are increased (provided ΔT
< ΔTcritical).
For example at 1 bar, 25% solution of NaOH in water boils at 381K, BPR = 8K.
The value of the BPR cannot be directly calculated from physical data therefore often
an empirical rule known as Duhring’s rule is used to find the change in the boiling
point with pressure.
If the boiling point of the solution is plotted against the boiling point of water at the
same pressure, a straight line is obtained.
Since the pressure is fixed, if the boiling point of water is found from steam tables,
and the boiling point of the solution can be found using Duhring plot.
VAPOUR: WV, T1
FEED: WF, TF
CONCENTRATE: WC, T1
Where,
TF = Temperature of the feed
TS = Temperature of the steam
T1 = Temperature inside the unit
WF = Flow rate of the feed
WV = Flow rate of the vapour
WS = Flow rate of the steam
WC = Flow rate of the concentrate
PS = Pressure of the steam
P1 = Pressure of evaporator
Assumptions:
Boiling liquid is well mixed at the evaporator temperature, T1, the concentrate
and the vapour will also be at T1
There are no heat losses
Steam gives up latent heat only (if the steam is saturated)
Condensate is a saturated liquid
The vapour is water vapour.
Q U A ΔT …………………………………………………………………...(1.1)
ΔT TS T1
Where,
Q = Heat transferred per unit time
U = Overall coefficient of heat transfer
A = Heat transfer surface
WS λS WV λ V WF Cp T1 TF ………………………………………...(1.2)
WF WV WC …………………………………………………………......(1.3)
Where,
Cp = Specific heat capacity of the feed
λS = Latent heat of condensation of steam
λV = Latent heat of vaporisation of water
The Economy of the evaporator is defined as the kilograms vaporised per kilogram
of steam fed to the unit.
Example 1.1:
Problem:
10,000 kg/hr of dilute NaOH (5 wt%) is to be concentrated by evaporation to 20 wt%.
The feed temperature is 20°C. The evaporator will operate at 1 bar, at which pressure
a 20 wt% solution boils at 105°C. (CpF = 4.2 kJ/kg-K, λV = 2240 kJ/kg).
Dry saturated steam is available at 2.5 bara. (TS = 127.4°C, λS = 2181 kJ/kg).
The evaporator should provide an overall heat transfer coefficient of 2300 W/m2-K.
Solution:
a) Heat balance:
WS = 20.37x106 / 2181
WS = 9340 kg/hr
b) Heat transfer
Q = U A (TS – T1)
A = Q / (U (TS – T1))
A = (20.37x106 x 1000) / (2300 x (127.4 – 105) x 3600)
A = 110 m2
c) Steam economy
The pressure difference between the steam and the condenser is spread across two
or more effects in the multiple-effect system. Pressure in the vapour space is highest
in the first effect. In the last effect vapour space pressure is minimum.
Where
T1, T2 = Temperatures of two effects (respectively)
P1, P2 = Pressures of two effects (respectively)
WF = Flow rate of the feed
WV1, W V2 = Flow rates of the vapour from the two effects (respectively)
WS1, W S2 = Flow rates of the steam from the two effects (respectively)
WC1, W C2 = Flow rates of the concentrate from the two effects (respectively)
Mass balance:
Economy
WV1 WV2 …………………………………………….....……(1.4)
WS1
n
Total vapour produced = W
i1
Vi
n
Economy = W
i1
Vi WS1 ……………………………………………………...….(1.5)
The most common method is using a pump for introducing the feed into the first
effect. Forward feed units require a single feed pump. There is no need of using
pumps between effects as the flow happens in the same direction as the pressure
drop between effects. This arrangement reduces economy and operating costs. If
the feed is cold then its temperature must be raised to the operating temperature.
Forward feed units tend to have most concentrated liquour (most viscous) in the
lowest temperature effects (difficulties in achieving good overall heat transfer
coefficient).
In backward feed units feed is fed to the last effect. It requires multiple pumps to work
against the pressure drop between effects. In this arrangement, the feed is gradually
heated (resulting in better economies). Reduces viscosity differences are observed
through the system, therefore backward-feed is better suited for viscous solutions.
In parallel feed units there is no transfer of liquid from effect to effect. This
arrangement is primarily used when feed is saturated and the product is solid. It is
most common in crystallising evaporators where the product is likely to be a slurry.
All effects may operate at the desired concentration or at different concentrations
and blended together later.
1st Effect:
WV1 WS2
0.8
WS1 WS1
2nd Effect:
WV2 WV2
0.9
WV1 0.8WS1
WV2 0.72WS1
(Otherwise there is no ∆T in 2nd or subsequent effects, TS1 > T1 > T2 > T3 > .... > TN)
The method of feeding has an effect on the economy as well. Economies of forward
feed and backward feeds at different temperatures is compared in the graph below
(figure 1.13).
In general, if the feed is cold, then the backward-feed system is more economical.
However, the forward-feed system is the more common, mostly because it is simpler
to operate as backward-feed requires the use of pumps between each effect.
The use of multi-effect evaporation provides increase in economy but at the cost of
reduced capacity.
Capacity: QT = Q1 + Q2 + Q3
Assuming:
A1 = A2 = A3 = A
U1 = U2 = U3 = U
3
QT U A ΔT
i1
i
QT U A TS1 T3
QT U A ΔTTotal ……………………………………………………………….(1.6)
A single effect evaporator carrying out the same duty between the same
temperatures would have approximately the same area as each effect of the multi
effect system.
Example 1.2:
Problem:
Solution:
1
U1
ΔT1 ΔTT
1 1 1
U1 U2 U3
1
ΔT1 2500 56
1 1
2500 2000 1000
1
ΔT1 11.8C
ΔT1 TS1 T1
T1 TS1 - ΔT1
ΔT1 108 - 11.8 96.2C
1This is a first approximation which makes it possible to solve the problem in an approximate
way. For a precise solution, the approximate values can be used to get the exact temperature.
Please see 1.5.8
There is economic balance between the steam cost and the capital cost so optimum
number of effects can be selected. Assuming there are no other costs, then the
capital cost and the steam costs together give the total cost.
When the two graphs (figure 1.14 and 1.15) are combined, they give the relationship
which links the total cost with number of effects:
Conventional heat exchangers provide sufficient heat transfer surface such as pipe
surface. Through the heat transfer surface, condensing vapour transfers latent heat
of vaporisation to cooling water flowing through the pipes.
In a jet condenser, cooling water is sprayed from the upper part of the unit to
condense the vapour; cooling water and vapour are drawn out of the condenser from
the base of the unit.
Example 1.3:
Problem:
Solution:
Enthalpy balance:
In = Steam + Water
Out = Water
M = 60.3 kg / kg steam
Evaporation
Cooling water (if using a jet condenser)
Inward leakage
The most convenient way of obtaining a vacuum is usually by using a steam jet
ejector.
Where:
a) Converging – diverging steam nozzle (high velocity steam jet)
b) Converging section – steam entrains gases
c) Diffuser section – part of kinetic energy is transformed to pressure energy
Steam is fed through the nozzle and some of its momentum is transferred to the gas
entering the ejector and the mixture is then compressed in the converging section.
Key design features of steam jet ejectors are the steam nozzle and the diffuser. If
they are well designed, ejector will have a good performance.
Typical “compression” ratios are 5-6: 1. Therefore, a single-stage ejector will remove
air from a system at a pressure of 17 kN/m2 to 102 kN/m2 and a two stage will from
3 kN/m2 to 108 kN/m2.
Example 1.4:
Problem:
4 kg/s (14.4 t/hr) of liquor containing 10% solids in water is fed at 21°C to the 1st
effect of a triple effect system (Cp constant at 4.18 kJ/kg-K). The produced
concentrate contains 50% solids from 3rd effect, operated at 0.13 bar.
Determine:
Assuming:
Intermediate temperatures
Iterate (T1 and T2 in this case) to find values that satisfy all conditions in our
specification. To get 1st estimates of these temperatures assume that sensible heat
terms in the energy balances for each effect are negligible.
Therefore:
U1∆T1 – U2∆T2 = 0
U2∆T2 – U3∆T3 = 0
U1∆T1 = U2∆T2 = U3∆T3
Also know:
∆T1 + ∆T2 + ∆T3 = TS1 – T3
Due to the cold feed, the 1st effect will have substantial sensible heat term in its heat
balance, so we increase ∆T1 at the expense of the others to give:
Heat supplied from steam = Sensible heat ‘gain’ of liquor + Latent heat of vapour
formed
Effect 1:
WS1λS1 = W FCp(T1-TF) + WV1λV1
Effect 2:
WV1λV1 = W C1Cp(T2-T1) + WV2λV2 WC1 = 4 – W V1
Effect 3:
WV2λV2 = W C2Cp(T3-T2) + WV3λV3 WC2 = 4 – W V1 – W V2
Areas
For effect 1:
Q1 = U1A1∆T1 = W S1λS1
A1 = W S1λS1 / U1∆T1 = (1.635 x 2200) / (3.1 x 18) = 64.5 m2
For effect 2:
Q2 = U2A2∆T2 = W V1λV1
A2 = W V1λV1 / U2∆T2 = (0.991 x 2249) / (2.0 x 17) = 65.6 m2
For effect 3:
Q3 = U3A3∆T3 = W V2λV2
A3 = W V2λV2 / U3∆T3 = (1.064 x 2294) / (1.1 x 35) = 63.4 m2
Since the calculated areas are so close, the assumed ∆Ts are approximately correct.
(Otherwise ∆Ts can be adjusted until the areas matched).
Feed V1 C1 V2 C2 V3 C3
Assumptions:
This time, since negligible sensible heat effects will be assumed throughout the
calculation, there is no need to make any adjustments to ∆T1 for the cold feed:
Effect 1:
WS1λS1 = W V1λV1
Effect 2:
WV1λV1 = W V2λV2
Effect 3:
WV2λV2 = W V3λV3
Areas
Qi = UiAi∆Ti = W ViλVi
Feed V1 C1 V2 C2 V3 C3
Single Effects:
What is the minimum feed temperature at which the above unit will operate
satisfactorily? How much steam is required?
Assume that the feed has the properties of water and that the steam used for
heating is at 1 bar absolute and 90% dry.
Find:
a) The overall heat transfer coefficient
b) The steam economy
a) 51.7 °C
b) 21.2 °C
c) 93.3 °C
Calculate:
i. Steam consumption
ii. Economy
iii. Heating surface required
Multiple Effects:
a) If the evaporator’s heat transfer area is 55m2, calculate its overall heat
transfer coefficient and its steam economy.
6. As question 2 but the plant is a 2 effect system. The feed enters Effect 1 at 20
°C; the boiling temperature in Effect 1 is recorded at 82 °C; the boiling
temperature in Effect 2 is 46 °C.
Latent heat of vapour at 82 °C: 2300 kJ/kg
Heat transfer area of each effect: 120m2
Find:
o The overall heat transfer coefficient for each effect
o The steam economy
a) Steam required
b) Economy
c) Heating surface per effect
Assuming negligible boiling point rise and neglecting sensible heat effects and
heat losses, determine the feed liquor rate with which the unit can cope.
1.7 Bibliography
Richardson, J.F. Harker, J.H. Backhurst, J.R.. (2013). Coulson and Richardson's
Chemical Engineering Volume 2 - Particle Technology and Separation Processes
(5th Edition). Elsevier
Topic 2
Drying
Contents
Drying..................................................................................................................... 1
2.1 Introduction to Drying of Solids ..........................................................................3
2.2 General Principles .............................................................................................4
2.2.1 Equilibrium Conditions ...........................................................................4
2.2.2 Bound and Free Moisture ......................................................................5
2.2.3 Hysteresis .............................................................................................6
2.2.4 Soluble Solids .......................................................................................6
2.2.5 Air Conditioning .....................................................................................7
2.2.6 Drying Operations ...............................................................................12
2.3 Batch Drying ....................................................................................................13
2.3.1 Rate Data ............................................................................................13
2.4 Rate of Drying in Batch Dryers ........................................................................15
2.4.1 Constant Rate from w to wc .................................................................16
2.4.2 Linear Falling Rate Zone from wc to we ................................................17
2.4.3 Non-Linear Falling Rate – Graphical Procedure ..................................18
2.4.4 Non-Linear Falling Rate – “Log Mean” Procedure ...............................18
2.5 Continuous Rotary Dryers ...............................................................................20
2.5.1 Indirect Heating Type ..........................................................................20
2.5.2 Direct Heating Dryers ..........................................................................22
2.5.3 Sizing Rotary Dryers ...........................................................................22
2.5.4 Temperature and Moisture Profiles in Continuous Direct Heating
Drying ......................................................................................................23
2.6 Rate of Drying In Continuous Direct Heating Dryers ........................................24
2.6.1 Zone II Drying Modes ..........................................................................24
2.6.2 High Temperature Zone II Drying ........................................................24
Prerequisite knowledge
Learning objectives
After studying this Topic 2 of “Separation Processes B” you should be able to:
1. Gas Flowrate - Increasing the gas flowrate reduces the resistance to mass
transfer
2. Gas Temperature - Driving force, which causes evaporation of moisture, will
be affected by the gas-solid temperature difference
3. Moisture Content - The amount of water in the solid
4. Transport Properties of the Solid - How effectively the moisture can be
transported to the solid surface for evaporation
5. Surface Area – The amount of solid effectively exposed to the drying agent
6. Required Product Form - A high drying rate may radically alter the
characteristics of dried solid
7. Value of the Evaporated Moisture - High solvent cost will necessitate
recovery and hence will influence the equipment design
8. Temperature Sensitivity - Some products can be damaged by heating, by
being exposed to high temperatures for long periods.
Drying is often a part of the manufacturing process. Uses of typical drying processes
include manufacture of soap, dried milk, timber, clay, ceramics, penicillin, food
concentrates, paper, textiles and pigments.
a) If the solid is exposed to a gas free from water, the moisture will
evaporate into the gas stream until equilibrium is established when the
vapour pressure exerts from the water within the solid equals the partial
pressure of water in the gas stream.
Equilibrium conditions depend on the type of solid and the gas humidity, the
particle size and the surface area if the solid can physically absorb moisture.
Moisture can exist in two forms, depending on the proximity to the equilibrium
conditions:
Bound Moisture - This is water contained within small capillaries and moisture
adsorbed onto the solids surface. Typically, this is water which exerts a vapour
pressure lower than pure water at the same temperature.
Un-Bound Moisture - Here the water exerts a vapour pressure equal to that of
pure water at the same temperature.
Free Moisture - This is any moisture present above the condition of equilibrium.
The extent at which the bound and free moisture occur therefore depends on the
relative humidity of the gas.
Note that the definition of moisture content (w) on a dry weight basis is :
And
f w w e …………………………………………………….(2.1)
Where,
w e Equilibrium moisture content(kg/kg dry solid)
f Free Moisturecontent
2.2.3 Hysteresis
Figure 2.4 Change of equilibrium moisture content in two directions, adsorption and
desorption
So far, the discussion applies to insoluble solids. Soluble solids usually have very
low, if not insignificant, equilibrium moisture content.
For dilute solutions, the water will evaporate until only the residual solid remains.
Crystal formation produces different equilibrium curves since different hydrate
forms can exist.
By far the commonest drying agent will be hot air, and it is useful, at this stage, to
review humidity and the use of psychrometric charts.
Humidity
The humidity H, is defined as the mass of water per unit mass of dry air.
18 Pw
H ……………………………………………………………..(2.2)
29 PT Pw
Where,
Pw = Partial pressure of water vapour
PT =Total pressure
Percentage Humidity
H
%H 100 ……………………………………………………….…….(2.3)
H0
Where
H = Humidity of air
H0 = Humidity of saturated air
%H = Percentage Humidity
Relative Humidity
The relative humidity, HR, is the humidity calculated in relation to the saturated
humidity.
H
HR ………………………………………………………………..…...(2.4)
H0
Enthalpy
The enthalpy (h) of the humid air is considered to be made up of the enthalpy of the
dry gas added to the heat required to vaporise the water from the base (reference)
temperature.
hdrygas Cp dt
T0
Tb Tg
h w aterin gas C
T0
p liquiddt λ C
T0
p vapourdt
Where
h = Enthalpy of the humid air
m =Humidity ratio
Cp= Specific heat capacity
λ = Latent heat of vaporisation
Tg = Dry bulb temperature
Tb =Boiling temperature
T0 = Initial temperature
Humid Heat
This is the heat required to raise the temperature of a unit mass of gas and its
associated water vapour by 1 degree at constant pressure.
Humid Heat is
Enthalpy is then
h Cs Tg T0 λY in kJ/kg dry gas
Where
Y = Absolute humidity in kg water / kg dry air.
Where
Cs = Humid heat
Here it is assumed that the gas and liquid heat capacities are constant over the
desired temperature range.
Humid Volume
This is the volume of a mass of dry gas and its associated water vapour.
The volume of an ideal gas or vapour at 273 K and 1 atm is 22.4 m3/kg mol.
Since molecular weight of air is 29 and water is 18 for air and water, assuming ideal
gas behaviour:
22.4 T 22.4 H T
Humid volume …………...……………………...(2.9)
29 273 18 273
Where
T is temperature (K)
Humid volume is in m3/kg
Dew Point
This is the temperature at which a vapour-gas mixture will become saturated, where
the liquid will condense out as the gas can no longer support the vapour. Note the
term gas is separated from the term vapour.
Used for determining the humidity, this thermometer gives lower values than a dry
bulb thermometer. It essentially measures the steady state temperature reached by
a small liquid drop evaporating into a large volume of unsaturated gas.
Tw
Temperature
Ps
Partial Pressure
Pw
Figure 2.6 Small liquid drop evaporating into a large volume of gas
Where
Tw = Wet bulb temperature
Tg = Dry bulb temperature
Ps = Vapour pressure of the liquid at the drop surface
Pw = Partial pressure of vapour in the gas stream
If the liquid is at a higher temperature than the gas dew point then:
a) The vapour pressure of the liquid at the drop surface will be higher than the
partial pressure of vapour in the gas stream
b) Liquid will evaporate so that vapour pressure = partial pressure
c) Drop temperature will fall as heat is removed to cause evaporation
d) Once the drop temperature falls below the dry bulb temperature, heat will
flow from the gas into the drop to continue the evaporation
e) Eventually steady state will be reached where the heat transfer from the gas
phase equals the heat required for evaporation
f) Temperature of the liquid drop will remain constant.
Wet bulb thermometers are essentially normal thermometers with their bulbs
covered with liquid supplied from a wick. If the dry gas stream is unsaturated, the
wet bulb temperature will be lower than the dry bulb temperature.
Rate of heat transfer from gas to drop hg A Tg Tw
Where
hg = Gas film heat transfer coefficient
A = Surface area of drop
Tg-Tw = Driving force
Tw = Wet bulb temperature
Tg = Dry bulb temperature
Rate of mass transfer of vapour from the surface kg A Yw Yg
Where
kg = Gas film mass transfer coefficient
Yw-Yg = Driving force
Yw = Saturation humidity, at the drop surface
Yg = Gas humidity
Thus:
kg A Yw Yg λ hg A Tg Tw
Where
λ = latent heat of vaporisation of unit mass of water
A = Surface area of drop
Hence:
Tg Y
Tw
w
hg
Yg λ
………………………………………………………(2.10)
kg
The ratio hg/kg is the psychrometric ratio and is constant for a particular liquid-gas
system.
Drying equipment and their associated design equations depend on the operating
mode, the heating source and the nature of the material to be dried.
Operating Mode
Either batch or semi-batch where a dryer is charged with stationary solid which
remains until the moisture content has fallen. Batches may then be passed into other
dryers operating at higher temperatures until the moisture content falls to the desired
level.
In continuous mode, the wet solid is passed through a heating source and can be
thought as formed of small batches passing into a series of units where the driving
force continually changes.
Heating Supply
a) Direct Heating: Where heat comes from a hot gas. Moisture is evaporated
from the solid into the flowing gas stream. Generally less costly that indirect
methods and easier to control, direct heating unfortunately has a low
efficiency due to the energy lost in the exhaust gas.
b) Indirect Heating: Where heat is supplied indirectly of the gas used to remove
the moisture. Microwave ovens are forms of indirect heating.
Moisture loss from some solids may cause structural changes. How these changes
affect the product may dictate the type of dryer used, e.g., cracking may lead to a
fine powder with handling difficulties or warping which occurs in large timber sheets.
Often the structural changes are influenced by the rate of drying.
Design data for batch dryers usually involves deciding on the length of time needed
to reach specified moisture content, given the surface area exposed to the gas. The
most important data for any dryer is the rate of drying, usually determined under
constant gas humidity conditions.
a) The ratio of the drying surface to the volume of solid is the same in the
experiment as in the full dryer
b) Support frame is of the same material and geometry
c) Conditions for radiant heat transfer are the same
d) Temperature, humidity and drying gas velocity are the same as the full scale
unit.
Drying rate data is usually of the form:
1 Please note that X and w are used interchangeably for moisture content.
Various drying zone can be observed and their characteristics are as flows:
A-B Initially, the solid surface is cooler than the gas so the drying rate will
increase as the solid heats up.
B-C This is the constant rate zone where drying takes place by
evaporation of the free moisture surrounding the solid grains. The
drying rate can be expressed by the mass transfer of moisture from
the solid into the vapour as : N kY Y *
Where
N = Rate of drying
k = Mass transfer coefficient
(Y-Y*)= Change in the humidity
Solid moisture content will continue to fall until dry spots appear on
the solid surface. At this point the solid will not be in equilibrium with
the gas stream- this is defined as the critical moisture content (Xc).
C-D Although the rate of drying per unit area of wet surface remains
constant, the overall drying rate falls as the number of dry spots
increases. This is the start of the falling rate zone. Solid surface can
change its structural properties at this stage.
D-E Moisture film surrounding the solid has been removed and further
drying depends on the rate at which moisture will move internally in
the solid phase. At point E, the drying rate falls to 0 as the equilibrium
is reached between the drying gas and the moist solid.
During the drying period, drying is assumed to take place from a saturated solid
surface and, for constant conditions, most materials exhibit similar drying rates:
Since drying is a mass transfer process, problem can be seen from either changes
in the gas or the solid moisture content.
N k g APs Pw ……………………………………………………….….(2.11)
Where
Ps = Vapour pressure of the water (i.e. on the solid)
Pw = Partial pressure of water vapour in the gas stream
N = Rate of drying expressed as a flux (kg moisture/s-m2)
h A T
k g A Ps Pw
dw
N
dt λ
………………………...…………..….(2.12)
Where
kg = Mass transfer coefficient
A = Interface area
h = Heat transfer coefficient
ΔT = Temperature difference between air and surface
λ = Latent heat of vaporisation per unit mass
w = Moisture content
The normal expression for drying time comes from looking at changes in solids
moisture content:
1 dw
N ………………………………………………………….……..(2.13)
A s dt
Where,
N = Drying rate, kg moisture/ s.m2
As = Surface area for drying,m2
t = time
The total time taken for drying from moisture content w1 to w2, is obtained by
integrating the expression:
t w2 w1
1 dw 1 dw ………………………………..(2.14)
0
dt
w
As N
→ t
As
w2
N
1
The exact for of this integral depends on the region in which the moisture changes.
During the drying from the initial moisture content w1 to the critical moisture content
wc, the drying rate is constant so the integral is simply:
1 w1 w c
t cr ……………………………………………….………….….(2.15)
As Nc
Where
tcr = Time of drying in the constant rate period
Nc = Rate of drying per unit area in the constant rate period
During this period the rate of drying is, approximately, proportional to the free
moisture content (w – we):
(w – we) = f
1 dw
m w we m f
A s dt
w
1 dw
t
m As w w - we f
c
1 wc - w e
In t
mA s w - we f
Then
1 fc
tf In ……………………………………………………..………(2.16)
mA s f
Where
fc = (w – we)
m = Ratio of rate of drying per unit area to moisture content
As = Surface area for drying
tf = Time of drying in falling rate period
The rate of drying, Nc, over the constant rate period, is equal to the initial rate of
drying in the falling rate period; therefore Nc = m fc.
1 f1 fc f
t In c …………………………………………………..(2.17)
mA s fc f
The area under the curve can then be used to estimate the time for drying.
X1
dX …………………………………………………………………....(2.18)
t
X2
N
Where t is time for drying and X is the moisture content.
For a slightly non-linear falling rate zone, a log mean approach can be adopted:
1 Nc Nc Ne
tf In m
mA s Ne
and
wc we
1 w c w e Nc
tf In
A s Nc Ne Ne
1 w c w e …………………………………………………………..(2.19)
tf
A s Nlogmean
Where
Nc = Rate of drying per unit area in the constant rate period
Ne = Rate of drying per unit area in the falling rate period
Example 2.1:
Problem:
A wet solid is dried from 25% to 10% moisture (dry weight basis) under constant
drying conditions in 4.17 hr. If the critical and equilibrium moisture contents are
15% and 5% respectively, how long will it take to dry the solid from 30% to 8%
moisture under the same conditions?
Solution:
mA s 0.406
Since the solid is the same and the same drying conditions are kept, then mAs
t 6.7 hr
There are many types of continuous dryers and the one adopted is selected
principally on the basis of its suitability in relation to the materials being dried, e.g.:
Continuous dryers fall into the two categories of direct and indirect heating.
a) Drum Dryers
In drum dryers the material to be dried is sprayed or poured over a rotating drum.
The drum is heated from inside usually by steam fed in via flexible couplings.
Condensate must be collected from the drum and removed.
The dry product, adhering to the outside surface, will be scrapped off by contact with
some knife edge. The moisture evaporated from the solids may be sucked away by
some kind of vent system. The moisture in this case might not be water and its
release into the general environment should be controlled.
The drying ability is controlled by the drum diameter and the dryability of the material.
Figure 2.12 applies to 7 barg steam and shows a wide variation in the evaporation
rate. (Lengths of drums can be anything from 0.5m to 6m.)
60
50
Evaporation kg/ hr m2
40
30
20
Easy to dry
Difficult to dry
10
0
0 250 500 750 1000 1250 1500
Drum Diameter mm
b) Tubular Dryers
Unlike the drum dryer, these dryers have wet solids poured over a tube bundle which
is heated, usually by steam, from the tube inside.
Brewing and Distilling – Drying spent grain from 65% moisture to 10%
moisture. (A pre de-watering screw press may be used to dry solids from
80% moisture to 65% moisture.)
Confectionery
Chemicals and Pharmaceuticals
Cereals
In these types of dryers, the air (or the hot gas providing the heating) is used to
remove the moisture. This is perhaps the more common form or drying. There is only
one main type of dryer in this category, namely– the rotary dryer. However several
forms of rotary dryers exist.
The drum is fitted with a series of spiral blades which break-up the solids and help
transport the material along the dryer. Usually the whole system is on an incline and
the solids slowly move to the other end of the equipment. Hot gas can be either co-
or counter-current. Co-current is the more common type of operation. Counter-
current operations are more efficient but expose the solids to quite high
temperatures. Typical drying temperatures are from just below 100°C to 700°C.
Exhaust gas from the dryer will contain particulate solids and might need cleaning
before disposal. Moisture can also be condensed out and recovered if desired. In
any event, some kind of waste heat recovery system can be installed without
affecting the product.
Diameters of this kind of dryers range from 1m to 3.5m, their length from 1m to 14m.
These dryers are used where very low moisture contents are required without high
air temperatures.
In this case, instead of passing down through the rotary section, hot air can be
passed through the sides of the drum and into past the solids via a series of louvre
shutters. The immediate contact between the air and solids increases the drying
efficiency.
There are two relevant parameters for the design/sizing of these dryers. One is the
diameter of the dryer, which is related to the velocity at which the hot gas is passed
through the unit. The second parameter is the length of the dryer, which is related to
the time required to assure the heat transfer from the drying air to the material being
processed. The length is also related to the time required for the mass transfer of the
water evaporated from the solids into the air. This combined heat and mass transfer
problem is very common in separation processes.
In continuous drying, the moisture content, the gas humidity and the temperature
vary throughout the dryer:
Zone I: The preheat zone where the solid is heated until evaporation
starts. Air temperature will fall since no additional heating is supplied
Zone III: Solid is in its falling rate zone when surface dry spots appear.
Drying rate will fall and the temperature will rise.
In continuous drying, it is possible changing the heating mode along the length of the
dryer, which influences the driving force.
Adiabatic Drying: Solids remain at the wet bulb temperature, since the layer of water
surrounding the solid is at the wet bulb temperature of the drying gas.
Heat Addition: Additional heat is added which increases the enthalpy of the gas
stream. Heat addition at constant moisture content is also possible by removing the
air through an external exchanger and hence raising the gas temperature.
Heat Loss: Heat is lost by poor insulation which causes the enthalpy of the gas to
fall; hence the saturation conditions change. The driving force for mass transfer and
heat transfer reduce.
Constant Temperature: Can only be achieved by heat addition to maintain the dry
bulb temperature. In this drying mode the wet bulb conditions of the gas increase,
increasing the driving force.
This method applies to the constant rate zone which constitutes the major part of any
dryer. (ΔT=40°C+)
Since the temperature controls this process, a heat balance over a small “slice” of
the dryer gives2:
Heat loss from the gas = heat gained by the solids + any heat losses
dq s aU Tg Ts dZ …………………………………………………….……(2.20)
Where
qs = Heat gained
a = Area of solid available for drying per unit length of dryer
U = Heat transfer coefficient
Tg = Temperature of gas
Ts = Temperature of solid
Where
qg = Heat loss
G = Gas flowrate
Cs = Humid heat
dTg = Change in gas temperature over the length dZ
aU Tg Ts dZ GmCs dTg
'
Integrating gives:
Tg1 '
Gm Cs dTg
Z
Tg2
aU Tg Ts
Where
'
Gm = Dry gas flowrate
Tg1, Tg2 = Gas inlet and outlet temperatures respectively
Ts1, Ts2 = Solid inlet and outlet temperatures respectively
2 Notice that the changes are assumed to happen along the length only, and consequently
the balance is done over a volume of length “dZ”.
As with absorption columns, this expression can be simplified into a number of drying
units:
' Tg1
Gm Cs dTg
Z
aU Tg2
T
g Ts
………………………………………………………(2.22)
Where
Z = (length of a drying unit) x (number of drying units) = LTU x NTU
The integral can be solved by methods such as the log mean method, the simplified
integral method, etc.
Similarly to the gas absorption process, the continuous drying process is a rate
determined process.
Provided that U and Cs are constant a further comparison can be made with the
absorption process by splitting the total length of the dryer into two parts:
Tg1
dTg
Number of Transfer Units (NTU):
T
Tg2 g Ts
…………………………...(2.23)
'
Gm Cs
Length of a Transfer Unit (LTU): …………………………..……...(2.24)
aU
To solve the integral representing NTU, Tg has to be related to Ts, (as humidity (Y)
is related to equilibrium moisture content (Xe) in absorption). Same simplifications,
as the ones attempted in absorption columns, can be made, depending on the
heating mode in the dryer.
Tg1
dTg
T
Tg2 g Ts
The simplest case is to assume adiabatic operation. So in Zone II, T s is always the
wet bulb temperature of the gas stream, i.e. the free moisture surrounding the solid
particles is at the wet bulb temperature and the heat supplied from the gas phase is
purely used to evaporate this free moisture. Consequently, Ts can be considered
independent of Tg.
Tg1
dTg Tg1 Tg 2
T
Tg2 g Ts T
=
g Ts LOGMEA N
T Ts
Tg1
Ts1 Tg 2 Ts 2
g LOGMEAN
Tg1 Ts1
Ln
Tg2 Ts2
Since it is assumed that the solid will always be at the wet bulb temperature:
Ts1=Twb = Ts2=Twb
The difficulty here is that Tg2, the gas exit temperature, is a function of the amount of
water evaporated from the solid, hence it depends on the gas flowrate.
In the actual design procedure, and in first approximation, a rule of thumb can be
used. Such procedure assumes that:
NTU=1.5
Consequently, the actual design procedure would follow the steps described below:
1) Assume NTU=1.5
Tg1 Tw b
2) Work out the gas exit temperature from : e1.5
Tg2 Tw b
3) Locate this temperature on the psychrometric chart and hence find the gas
exit humidity
4) Work out how much moisture is removed from the solid and hence
calculate the gas mass flowrate
5) Calculate the length and diameter of the unit
6) Check the exit temperature by a heat balance. The heat requirements
should balance implying that the heat load required needs to be calculated
by knowing how much water is removed: this will make it possible to
calculate heat lost by the dry gas. Such calculation will give the gas exit
temperature for the selected gas flowrate.
7) Reset the exit temperature (step 2) until the heat balance is satisfied.
Two forms are often quoted, either by correlating LTU directly with gas mass velocity,
or by expressing the overall heat transfer coefficient as a function of dry gas mass
velocity G’m, humid heat, Cs and diameter.
𝐺́𝑚 𝐶𝑠
𝐿𝑇𝑈 =
𝑎𝑈
Typically, the aU term will depend on the gas rate and is often expressed as:
Gb
aU k ………………………………………………………………….(2.26)
Dc
Where
The gas rate G is usually a maximum gas rate to prevent dust. A high gas velocity
will lift smaller dried particles into the gas stream which may then represent a hazard
for dust explosions. To reduce entrainment of the solid, a maximum velocity will
usually be specified.
For direct contact an empirical equation can also be used to find the total length:
Q
L …………………………………………………(2.27)
0.0625π D G'0.67 ΔTm
Where
L = Length of the dryer, m
Q = Rate of heat transfer, kJ/s
D = Diameter of the dryer, m
G’ = Mass velocity of the gas, kg/m2.s
ΔTm = log mean of the temperature difference, K
Note this equation is for METRIC units. For imperial units the constant (0.0625) will
change.
Where
Y1, Y2 = kg water / kg dry gas inlet and outlet respectively
X1, X2 = kg water / kg dry solids inlet and outlet respectively
Tg1, Tg2 = Gas inlet and outlet temperatures respectively
TS1, TS2 = Solid inlet and outlet temperatures respectively
The boundary between the two drying zones is given by the critical moisture content
which corresponds to a specific gas humidity. Since the drying rate will be constant
in Zone II and reduces in Zone III, there are two sets of relations which apply in each
zone.
Design information in this dryer requires an operating line and a residence time (a
hold up time for the solid in the dryer for a given gas flowrate).
A mass balance over the dryer gives operating lines for both zones:
a) Zone II :
b) Zone III :
Where
Gm' = Dry gas rate, kg/hr
Sm' = Dry solid rate, kg/hr
A hold up calculation yields a general expression for the residence time of the solids
in the dryer:
Where,
dm = Element of dry solid (kg)
dX = Change in moisture content of this solid element (kg/kg)
N = Drying rate (kg moisture/s-m2)
a = Area of drying per unit mass of dry solid (m2/kg)
Hence
X 2
a dX
MT
'
dm
0 Sm X1
N
2 X
a MT dX
'
Sm
X1
N
The residence time of solid in the dryer is given by:
MT
Θ ………………………………………………………………..………(2.32)
Sm'
Where
MT = Total mass of dry solid material in the dryer (kg)
Θ = Residence time (hr)
Giving:
X
1 1 dX
Θ
aX N
2
Breaking this down for the two regions gives the total residence time as:
X
1 1 dX dX
Xc
Θ
a X N X N ………………………………………………………(2.33)
c
II III
2
Zone II
The drying is not taking place under constant gas humidity conditions; therefore the
drying rate will change. The drying rate can be related to changes in gas humidity by
a mass transfer expression:
N=k(Ywb-Y)
It is assumed the solids will be at the wet bulb temperature of the air.
Where
N= Drying rate
k = Mass transfer coefficient
YWb =Humidity at this wet bulb temperature
Y = Humidity
Sm' dX Gm' dY
Then
Y '
1 1 Gm dY
Θ
a Y SmkYw b Y
'
c
Y1
G' dY
Θ m'
aSm kY
Yc w b Y
…………………………………………….…...….(2.34)
To progress this further, Ys must be found. This depends on the exact way of drying.
a) Adiabatic
Here, Ywb is constant and the integral can be solved fairly simply:
'
Gm Y Y
Θ In w b 1 ………………………………………………….….(2.35)
aSmk Yw b Yc
'
b) Constant Temperature
In this case, the gas temperature is held constant in the dryer and some form of
numerical integration is required:
Here, the drying rate will be falling. The drying rate can be related to the solids
moisture content as before:
N m(X Xe )
Where
Xe is the equilibrium moisture content at a particular stage in the dryer (gas
humidity is changing so Xe will change)
m is the ratio of rate of drying per unit area to moisture content
Y= m Xe
Where m is the gradient of the linear relationship of the equilibrium moisture content
and the gas humidity. Gradient m should be determined, experimentally in the first
instance.
At the end of zone II, the solids moisture content will come down to some
critical value, as would happen in batch drying where all the un-bound moisture is
removed. Hence a condition that gives critical drying rate (Nc) can be found:
NC=m(Xc-Xe)
It can also be said that: Nc=k(Ywb-Y), writing the critical rate as a function of the gas
humidity.
m(Xc-Xe) = k(Ywb-Y)
Where
Xc = Critical moisture content
YWb =Humidity at this wet bulb temperature
Y = Humidity
k = Mass transfer coefficient
Hence :
k(Yw b Y)
m , then
(Xc X e )
X X
1 c dX 1 c dX
Θ
a X N a X m(X Xe )
2 2
1
Xc (Xc X e )dX
Θ
a X k(Yw b Y)(X X e )
…………………………………………….….(2.36)
2
There is no other way to reduce this integral further and solution should rely
on numerical procedures.
Example 2.2:
Problem:
Design a co-current adiabatic tunnel dryer to handle 2000 kg/hr of wet sand from a
moisture content of 1 to 0.1 kg water/kg dry sand. The equilibrium moisture content
for the sand is negligible.
The air available for drying has wet and dry bulb temperatures of 34°C and 93°C
respectively. The air leaves the dryer at 38°C and the solid leaves at 34°C. A series
of preliminary tests under design conditions showed that the critical moisture
content of the sand was 0.5 kg water/kg dry sand and that the rate of drying above
this value was 1.0 kg water/m2.hr. Below the critical moisture content, the drying
rate fell linearly to zero at zero moisture content.
If the effective area of drying is 0.3 m2/kg dry solid and, neglecting shrinkage,
calculate the length of dryer required if 20 kg of dry material per m length is held.
Solution:
In
2000 kg/hr wet sand 1000 kg/hr dry sand 1000 kg/hr water X=1
Out
1000 kg/hr dry sand 100 kg/hr water 1100 kg wet sand X=0.1
Critical Point
1000 kg/hr dry sand 500 kg/hr water 1500 kg total X=0.5
Equilibrium Point
1000 kg/hr dry sand 0 kg/hr water 1000 kg/hr total X=0
GSY1 GSY2
Y
LPX1 LPX2
X
'
Gm Y Y
Θ In w b 1
aSmk Yw b Yc
'
GSY1 GSY2
Y
LPX1 LPX2
X
Rearranging gives:
Lp
Y Y2 X X2
Gs
1 c Xc X *
X
θ
a k X Ys YX - X *
dX
2
Xc X *
X Y X* YS Ys YX - X * Average of integral
(previous column)
0.1 0.0325 0 0.035 2000
0.2 0.0299 0 0.035 490.2 1245.1 124.5
Total 186.6
1 c
X
Xc X * dX 186.6 8.05hr
θ
a k X Ys YX - X * 0.3 77.28
2
1. A wet solid containing 35 wt% moisture on a wet basis (kg water / kg wet solid)
is dried in 6 hr to 10 wt%. The equilibrium and critical moisture contents were
determined as 4 wt% and 14% respectively, again on a wet basis. How long
would it take for the same solid to be dried to 6 wt%?
2. A porous solid is dried in a batch dryer under constant drying conditions. Seven
hours are required to reduce the moisture content from 35 to 10 percent. The
critical moisture content was found to be 20% and the equilibrium 4%. How
long should it take to dry a sample of the same solid from 35 to 5 percent under
the same drying conditions? All moisture contents given are dry weight basis.
3. Filter cake was found to have a negligible equilibrium moisture content and a
critical moisture content of 9 wt%. To dry from 20 wt% to 10 wt% took 2.64hr.
A second filter cake of the same material was found to have an initial moisture
content of 40 wt%. How long would it take to dry this second cake to the same
10 wt%? All moisture contents given are dry weight basis.
4. Wet chalk was found to dry from 35wt% to 0.6wt% in 10 hours. Critical moisture
content and equilibrium content were known to be 16wt% and 0.2wt%
respectively. If a maximum drying time of 15 hours is available determine the
wt% of the driest chalk possible from a 35wt% mixture.
5. A 100 kg batch of granular solids containing 30% moisture (wet weight basis)
is to be dried in a tray dryer to 15.5% moisture by passing a current of air at
350K tangentially across its surface at a velocity of 1.8m/s. If the constant rate
of drying under these conditions is 0.0007 kg/s.m2 and the critical moisture
content is 15% (wet weight basis), calculate the approximate drying time.
Assume the drying surface to be 0.03 m2/kg dry mass.
6. The following data was obtained when drying sand in superheated steam. The
sample was 50mm thick and weighted 16.02kg when dry. It was dried in steam
at 340kPa superheated by 11K, and following at 1.36 kg/s.m2. Drying was from
the top face only, and this face measured 203.2mm by 736.6mm.
Determine:
o The critical moisture content
o The drying rate during the constant rate period
Drying time (hr) Sample weight (kg) Drying time(hr) Sample weight (kg)
0.0 19.11 6.0 17.07
0.5 18.99 6.5 16.91
1.0 18.84 7.0 16.78
1.5 18.68 7.5 16.69
2.0 18.50 8.0 16.62
2.5 18.32 8.5 16.52
3.0 18.13 9.0 16.46
3.5 17.96 9.5 16.42
4.0 17.78 10.0 16.37
4.5 17.59 11.0 16.31
5.0 17.41 11.5 16.30
5.5 17.23 12.0 16.29
Continuous Drying:
8. 900 kg/h of wet slurry containing 5 wt% water (wet basis) is to be dried to 0.1
wt% (wet basis) in a rotary co-current dryer. The air available would be supplied
at a temperature of 90°C and a wet bulb temperature of 30°C. Assuming that
the dryer operates adiabatically, that the solids leave the dryer at the wet bulb
temperature and that the pre-heat zone can be neglected, calculate the
following:
The maximum mass velocity is 0.5 kg dry air/s.m2 and the humid heat of the
air can be taken as 1.5kJ/kg.K. The length of a transfer unit is given by: LTU =
6.12CsGv0.84, where Cs is the humid heat (kJ/kg.K), Gv is the gas mass velocity
(kg/s.m2).
9. Calculate the diameter and length of an adiabatic rotary dryer to dry 1270 kg/hr
of a heat sensitive solid from an initial moisture content of 15% to a final
moisture content of 0.5%, both dry basis. The solids have a specific heat of
2.18 kJ/kg,K they enter at 26.7°C and must not be heated to a temperature
above 51.7°C. Heating air is available at 126.7°C and a humidity of 0.01 kg/kg
dry air. The maximum allowable mass velocity of the air is 3420 kg/m2.h.
Questions 10 and 11 are optional questions for students who want to challenge their
knowledge:
10. The table below shows the time taken to dry a wet solid. Using the data,
calculate the critical and equilibrium moisture contents.
Take mA = 0.400.
11. A co-current adiabatic tunnel dryer is required to handle 2000kg/hr of wet sand
from a moisture content of 1 to 0.1 kg water / kg dry sand. The air available for
drying has wet and dry bulb temperatures of 25°C and 54°C, respectively. The
air leaves the dryer at 32°C and the solid leaves at 25°C.
A series of preliminary batch tests, under design conditions, showed that the
critical moisture content of the sand was 0.5 kg water / kg dry sand and the
rate of drying above this value was 1.0 kg water /m2.h. Below the critical
moisture content, the drying rate fell till the equilibrium moisture content of 0
was reached. The effective area for drying is 0.3 m2/kg dry solid and, neglecting
shrinkage, calculate the length of the dryer required if it holds 20 kg of dry
material per m length.
2.8 Bibliography
Richardson, J.F. Harker, J.H. Backhurst, J.R.. (2013). Coulson and Richardson's
Chemical Engineering Volume 2 - Particle Technology and Separation Processes
(5th Edition). Elsevier
Topic 3
Particle Technology
Contents
Particle Technology ................................................................................................ 1
3.1 Introduction to Particle Technology....................................................................3
3.2 Particle Fluid Interaction ....................................................................................4
3.2.1 Sphere Boundary Layer.........................................................................5
3.3 Terminal Velocity ...............................................................................................7
3.3.1 Particle Diameter from Terminal Velocity .............................................10
3.3.2 Wall Effects .........................................................................................10
3.4 Particle Size Analysis ......................................................................................11
3.4.1 Equivalent Sphere Diameter ................................................................13
3.5 Non-Spherical Particles ...................................................................................14
3.5.1 Drag Coefficient of Non –Spherical Particles .......................................14
3.5.2 Shape Factor.......................................................................................14
3.5.3 Terminal Velocity of Non-Spherical Particles .......................................15
3.5.4 Size of Non-Spheres from Terminal Velocity .......................................16
3.5.5 Slip Correction .....................................................................................16
3.6 Sedimentation .................................................................................................17
3.6.1 Sludge Line Settling ............................................................................17
3.6.2 Density, Concentration and Voidage ...................................................18
3.6.3 Apparent Velocity ................................................................................19
3.6.4 Suspension Viscosity ..........................................................................20
3.6.5 Settling of Coarse Suspensions ...........................................................20
3.6.6 Effect of Concentration on Suspension Flux ........................................21
3.7 Flow in Packed Beds .......................................................................................22
3.7.1 Finding the Bed Specific Surface Area ................................................23
3.7.2 High Reynolds Number in Packed Beds ..............................................23
Prerequisite knowledge
Learning objectives
After studying this Topic 3 of “Separation Processes B” you should be able to:
The term Particle Technology is used to refer to the science and technology related
to the handling and processing of particles and powders. It is also sometimes
referred to as powder technology, particle or powder science. Particles and powders
are usually referred to as particulate solids and bulk solids. Particle technology
includes the study of liquid drops, emulsions and bubbles, slurries, etc. Particles and
powders are commonly referred as bulk solids, particulate solids and granular solids.
Particle behaviour is not often as well predictable as it is the behaviour of gases and
liquids. A material in particulate form can have dramatically different properties and
behaviour depending on mean particle size, size distribution and surface topography.
For most materials, particle size and size distribution have a key role in determining
the bulk properties of the material. The size and the distribution of the particles can
be characterised if they were sphere shaped and had all the same size. However
real particles come in a range of sizes and shapes and it is not straight forward to
characterise them.
When fluid moves relative to a particle, the particle experiences a drag force, F, in
the direction of fluid motion. The fluid also experiences the same force acting in the
opposite direction.
Drag Coefficient
Where
= Fluid density
U = Fluid/Particle relative velocity
A = Particle projected area normal to U
F = Drag Force
CD = Drag coefficient
Ud
Re …………………………………………………………………….(3.2)
Where
d = Particle diameter (or other length)
µ = Fluid viscosity.
For steady, incompressible flow of an ideal fluid past an isolated rigid particle, CD
depends on Re only.
Experiments give the relationship between the drag coefficient and the particle
Reynolds number. This relationship can be presented in a standard drag curve
(Figure 3.2).
Varying the Reynolds number ranges, the drag coefficient correlations can be
summarised as:
104
103
102
CD
101
100
10-1 -3
10 10-2 10-1 100 101 102 103 104 105
Re
Figure 3.2 Standard drag curve
Stokes’ Law
F 3 Ud …………………………………………………………………….(3.3)
Hence
24
CD ……………………………………………………………………….(3.4)
Re
Laminar Flow
CD 0.44
For 0.2 < Re < 103, the empirical Schiller & Naumann expression can be used:
CD
24
Re
1 0.15Re0.687 ……………………………………………...…….(3.5)
Computer Formula
CD
24
Re
1 0.1806Re0.6459 0.4251
1 6880.95
…………………………………...(3.6)
Re
1. weight
2. buoyancy
3. drag
d3
g(ρp ρ) F 0 …………………………………………………….…….(3.7)
6
Where
p = Particle density
= Fluid density
F = Drag force.
d = Particle diameter
g = Acceleration due to gravity
Stokes’ Regime
F=3 U0 d
Where
U0 = Terminal falling velocity
Re0 = Terminal Re
µ = Fluid viscosity.
d3
g(p ) F 0
6 (Equation 3.7)
d3
g(p ) 3U0 d 0
6
d2 g(ρp ρ)
U0 ………………………………………………………..…….(3.8)
18μ
Laminar Flow
F=CD ½ ¼d2………………………………………………………………..(3.9)
So:
4dg p
U0 ………………………………………………………..…..(3.10)
3CD
The previous expression can be used also for turbulent flow, Re>2105, but with
CD=0.1
Transition Region
2
F U0 d
CD Re02
1 U2 1 d2 ……………………………………….......(3.11)
2 0 4
gp
d3
F
6
and
gp …………………………………………….…....(3.12)
4 d3
CD Re 02
3 2
All Regions
R’ is the force per unit projected area of particle in a plane perpendicular to the
direction of motion. For example for a sphere, the projected area would be of a
circle of the same diameter as the sphere.
R’/ρU2 is a form of the drag coefficient which can be denoted by C’D. The drag
1 R
coefficient CD is defined as the ratio of R’ to .
2 U2
Hence:
2 R
CD 2C'D
U2
CD Re02 can be calculated from particle and fluid properties without knowing in
which regions CDRe02 applies (flow properties).
A graph of CDRe02 against Re0 can be constructed to hence find Re0 by knowing
CDRe02.1
R CD Re02
Re0
2
……………………………………………………..…..(3.13)
U02 2
Computer Formula
d3 g p
Ar 3
CD Re02 …………………………………………..….(3.15)
4
2
Knowing the terminal velocity, the particle size can be easily found in the Stokes’
Regime or in the fully developed Laminar Flow.
In the Transition Region to determine the particle size from its terminal velocity is
more difficult, however a parameter which is independent of the diameter can be
constructed and then used to find Re0.
CD 4g p
…………………………………………………………(3.16)
Re 0 3 2U30
When a particle is within about 5d of solid boundaries or other particles, the flow
pattern is altered sufficiently to affect its terminal velocity.
For the Stokes’ Law region, the terminal velocity near a wall is given by:
U0
U0W …………………………………………………………….….(3.17)
1 2.4
Where
d
D
Where
d = Particle diameter (or other length)
U0W = Terminal velocity near a wall
β = Diameter ratio
D= Diameter of the equipment where the particle is flowing (e.g., diameter
of the pipe)
In many powder and processing operations, particle size and distribution play a key
role in determining the bulk properties of the powder. Describing the size distribution
of the particles making up a powder is central in characterising the powder.
Common diameters used in microscope analysis are statistical diameters, such as:
Equivalent circle diameter –circle with area equivalent to the projected area
of the particle.
Martin’s diameter –length of the line that equally divides the projected area.
The orientation of the particle on the microscope slide will affect the projected image;
this affects the measured equivalent sphere diameter.
If a sedimentation technique is used to measure the particle size, then the size is
defined as the diameter of a sphere having the same sedimentation velocity under
the same conditions.
Equal volume sphere diameter is the diameter of the sphere having the same
volume as that of the particle.
SA
Surface-volume diameter =
V
Where
SA = Surface area of the particle
V = Volume of the particle
Some particles, e.g. liquid drops and condensed fumes, are approximately spherical;
many are not, e.g. crystals and milled products. Orientation of the particle affects its
non-spherical properties.
At low Re, Stokes Law applies and CD=K/Re. Longest particle dimension
along the flow direction.
(K is the constant for given shape and orientation of particle.
Since the sphere behaviour is well understood and easily described, we approximate
the behaviour of non-spheres in terms of an equivalent spherical particle.
Volume dv V=dv³/6
Surface ds S=ds²
Heywood’s Method
1. Find dA, the particle’s projected area diameter when lying at its most stable
orientation and viewed from above
V
2. Calculate the Shape Factor k
d3A
Where
V = Particle’s volume
k = A constant whose value depends on the shape of the particle
3. Calculate the terminal velocity of the sphere (U0sph) from Re0 using
8k d3A
CD Re02 g p
2 …………………………………………………(3.18)
U0=U0sphCorrection
Computer Formula
1
18 2.3348 1.7439
U* 2 1
d* d* 2
1
4 Re0
1
3 2 3
U* U0
3CD g p
1
3
1
g p 3
dv
3
d* CD Re02
4 2
……………………………………(3.19)
d2v
And the Shape factor is:
S
Where
dv = Volume equivalent diameter
S = Particle’s surface area
= Shape factor
There is a similar method to find size of a non-sphere from terminal velocity (U0).
CD 8 k g p
1. Calculate ……………………………………….(3.20)
Re 0 2U30
CD
2. Find Re0 for a sphere from graph of against Re0
Re0
3. Apply the correction factor4
These techniques are approximations since they assume that the behaviour of a
particle of any shape can be described in terms of its shape factor and size only.
For very small particles, the fluid no longer appears like a continuum to the particle.
If the particle is similar in size to the mean free path () of the gas, it can slip between
the molecules and have a higher settling velocity than estimated.
Where
= Mean free path
d = Particle diameter
3.6 Sedimentation
For high concentration of suspensions there is significant interaction between the
particles. Therefore the frictional force exerted at a given velocity of the particles may
be greatly increased. This would lead to modifications of the flow pattern and cause
particles to settle slower; hindered settling takes place.
3. The fluid velocity field around a particle is altered by other nearby particles
Height
Time
Clear Liquid
Suspension
Sediment
Compressed
sediment
After a short time for acceleration, all the particles in the suspension will move at the
same speed, leaving behind a clear liquid layer and a depositing sediment. This is
referred as “sludge line settling”.
The sediment layer at the bottom becomes compressed. The sludge line separating
the clear liquid from the suspension descends at a constant rate for most of the
process.
Assuming that the Stokes’ law applies, the relative velocity between particles and
fluid is:
d2gp s
Ur
18s …………………………………………………………….(3.22)
Where
p = Particle density
= Fluid density
d = Particle diameter
g = Acceleration due to gravity
μ = Fluid viscosity
Fluid Volume
The voidage is defined as: =
Mixture Volume
So:
p s p ……………………………………………………….…..(3.23)
For an apparent settling velocity Ua, the volumetric flow rate of particles is:
Vp Ua 1 A ………………………………………………………..……..(3.24)
There must be an equal liquid volume flowing in the opposite direction in the voids
between particles, with area A.
Uf
Vp
Ua
1 ……….……………………………….……………….(3.25)
A
The relative velocity between the fluid and the particles is:
Ua
Ur Uf Ua
…………………………………………………...……….(3.26)
2d2gp
Ua …………………………………………………………...(3.27)
18s
Where
V p = Volumetric flow rate of particles
Ua = Apparent settling velocity
Uf = Upward fluid velocity
Ur = Relative velocity between fluid and particles
ε = Voidage
A = Vessel of cross section A
p = Particle density
= Fluid density
F = Drag force.
d = Particle diameter
g = Acceleration due to gravity
µ = Viscosity of suspension
s= (1+k(1-))………………………………………………………...……..(3.28)
Cautions
1. Flocculation. Suspensions form large, loose groups of particles (flocs) of
uncertain size and density.
Coarse particles have a much lower specific surface and interactions between
particles have a much less significance than in fine particle systems. Stokes’ Law
does not apply for large particles (>~100mm) and effective viscosity is inappropriate.
Ua U0 ε n ……………………………………………………………….……(3.30)
Where
n depends on the flow regime Re0, and on d/D, the particle/vessel diameter.
Re0 n
<0.2 d
4.6 + 20
D
0.2-1 d
4.4 + 18 Re 0.03
0
D
1-200 d
4.4 + 18 Re0.1
0
D
200-500 4.4 Re0.1
0
500-2x 2.4
Ua 1 ε ……………………………………………………..….(3.31)
Vp
A
ε n 1 ε
Vp
A U0 …………………………………………………..……(3.32)
Analytically, this indicates a maximum flux of sediment at ε ≈ 82% for fine particles
or ≈ 71% for coarse particles.
Darcy Law
U Lμ
P …………………………………………………………………....(3.33)
B
Where
µ = Viscosity
U = Superficial velocity
L = Bed thickness
B = Bed permeability (units m2)
Kozeny Equation
For laminar flow in a pipe or a pore of diameter dp, length Lp, velocity Up:
32 μ UpL p
P …………………………………………………......….…...(3.34)
dp2
Consider a cube of side X in the packed bed. The free volume in the cube is εX3.
U
Up
ε
And:
Void Volume ε
dp ………………………………………………....(3.35)
Wetted Surface Sb
WettedSurface
Sb
Bed Volume
Sb S (1 ) ………………………………………………………….…..(3.36)
Up dp U
Rep …………………………………………………(3.38)
S (1 )
P dp P 3
fp ……………………………………………...….(3.39)
L Up2 L S 1 U2
Unlike pipe flow, transition to turbulent flow does not occur suddenly. Each pore is
different so transition in each pore occurs independently.
Experimental data have been correlated using the parameters Rep and fp.
Carman Equation
5 0.4
fp 0.1 ………………………………………………………..…..(3.40)
Re p Re p
Sawistowski Equation
5 1
fp 0.1 …………………………………………………………….(3.41)
Re p Re p
Ergun Equation
For saddle type packing with high specific surface at low voidage:
4.17
fp 0.29 ……………………………………………………………..(3.42)
Rep
The voidage is higher near the wall. Overall, the flow resistance is reduced by the
wall correction factor:
2
S
f w 1 21 c ……………………………………………………………..(3.43)
S
Where:
Sc is the wetted surface area of the container per unit bed volume
fw is the wall correction factor.
P
P …………………………………………………………………....(3.44)
fw
3.7.4 Effect on K
K is a constant depending on the physical properties of the bed and fluid. These
properties that have an effect on K are:
Particle Size
For a narrow range of size, K=4.8±0.3. But if the range exceeds 5:1, voidage is
low and K is reduced.
Particle Shape
Provided 0.3<ε<0.8 then 4<K<5.5 except for thin plate shapes, for which 3<K<6.
High Voidage
Voidage is limited to ε<0.6 for approximately isometric shapes. But some ring
packings can achieve very high ε. Use the Sawistowski equation for 0.8<ε<0.9.
Health issues: Metallic and siliceous dusts with 0.5μm<d<3μm are most
damaging
Safety reasons: Fine powders can form explosive mixtures with air
Product Collection: e.g., Spray Dryers, Pneumatic Conveying
Cleaning: e.g., Removal of catalyst from FCC product
Various separation mechanisms can be used for gas-particle separation, these are:
Gravity
Inertia/Centrifugal force
Filtration
Electrostatics
Wet Scrubbing
Gas flows through long vessels at low speed U. Particles descend at U0. Small
particles settle at a lower rate therefore they are carried further forward before they
reach the bottom of the chamber. The very small particles are carried away in the
fluid overflow.
L
The residence time of the suspension in the vessel is t
U
U0L
Particle falls a distance h, given by: h U0 t in time t
U
Particles entering below h are collected; those above are not. Consequently, the
collection efficiency is given by:
h U0L
η ……………………………………………………………..…(3.45)
H UH
This separation process is suited for separation of large particles, i.e. d>100μm; a
very low pressure drop, ~50N/m2is usually involved. Velocity has to be less than
3m/s to prevent re-entrainment. The process requires dust hopper and e.g. rotary
valves to control discharge of particles.
In this type of separators, the centrifugal force is much greater than weight so small
particles (~10μm) can be separated using smaller equipment than settling
chambers. However the pressure loss is greater (250-1000 N/m2) than that needed
in settling chambers.
Gas spirals with high tangential velocity and lower radial and axial velocity
components inward and initially downward. Near the centre, the axial velocity
changes direction, toward the gas outlet. This is the Central Core.
Gas Velocity
1. Tangential Velocity
The tangential velocity is inversely proportional to the √radius outside the central
core:
D
UtD Ut …………………………………………………………………(3.46)
2r
Where
UtD = Inlet gas velocity
Ut = Tangential Velocity
D = Cyclone inside diameter.
2. Radial Velocity
The radial velocity is given by the volumetric flow rate divided by cylindrical surface
area at r:
G
Ur …………………………………………………………….....(3.47)
2 r Zρ
Where
G = Mass flow rate of gas of density ρ into the cyclone
Ur = Radial Velocity
Z = Depth of the separator
The tangential velocity causes a centrifugal force. The radial gas velocity causes a
drag force. For a given particle, these forces are in equilibrium at a particular
radius:
mU2t
3 μ Ur d
r
Then:
d2U2tDDZp
r
18 μ G
Provided that r is outside the central core of diameter x.D0 (x~0.4), particles are
retained within the cyclone at radius r, and gradually migrating to the particle exit
down the conical wall.
G
UtD for an inlet area of Ai
Ai
9 x D0 A i2
dcrit ……………………………………………………….(3.48)
GD Z p
There is not a sharp cut-off between collected and unseparated particle sizes.
There is a range of sizes over which removal is partial.
1. Using simple spherical particle drag theory, estimate the force required to
overcome air drag on:
3. Estimate the time taken for a 5 mm spherical water drop to fall 100m in still air.
Neglect mass transfer and internal circulation effects.
4. Square mica plates 0.08 cm thick by 0.065 cm2 area are falling through oil,
density 880 kg/m3 and viscosity 0.015 Ns/m2. What is the terminal velocity?
Specific gravity of mica is 3.0.
Mass % undersize 15 28 48 54 64 72 78 88
6. Estimate the time taken by air bubbles injected at a depth of 10 m to reach the
top of a water tank if the initial bubble diameter is 2mm.
3.10 Bibliography
Richardson, J.F. Harker, J.H. Backhurst, J.R.. (2002). Coulson and Richardson's
Chemical Engineering Volume 2 - Particle Technology and Separation Processes
(5th Edition). Elsevier
Topic 4
GLOSSARY
Adiabatic
Agglomeration
The process of gathering fine particles together into larger particles to form coarser
particles.
Buoyancy
Continuum assumption
The moisture content of a body at the time during drying when the constant rate
drying period changes to the falling rate drying period. It is also used to represent
the point between bound and unbound moisture content.
Condensate
When steam condenses to a liquid, then the liquid water is generally at high pressure
and temperature – liquid water formed in this way is often referred to as
“condensate”.
Correlation
Dispersion
It is a system where fine particles of one substance are scattered throughout another
substance.
Dühring’s Rule
Dühring's rule states that the ratio of the temperatures at which two solutions (one of
which can be pure water) exert the same vapour pressure is constant.
If the vapour pressure/temperature relation of a reference liquid is selected, and if
two points on the vapour pressure-temperature curve of the solution are known, the
boiling points of the solution to be evaporated at various pressures can be read off
from the diagram called a Duhring plot.
The Duhring plot will give the boiling point of solutions of various concentrations by
interpolation, and at various pressures by proceeding along a line of constant
composition.
Empirical
Entrainment
Entrainment is the liquid carried by vapour up to the tray above and is caused by
high vapour flow rates. It reduced the tray and could also contaminate the distillate.
Fouling
During operation with most liquids and some gases a dirt film gradually builds up on
the heat-transfer surface. The deposit is referred to as fouling.
Hydrate
Inviscid
Mach Number
The Mach Number is a dimensionless value used for analysing problems related to
fluid dynamics where compressibility is a significant factor.
Surface topography