Research Prop. Asefa - Part 2
Research Prop. Asefa - Part 2
Research Prop. Asefa - Part 2
Assessment of internal control over cashes in Goba woreda finance and economic
development office. The study has attempted to address research question having attention in
the statement of the problem and objective of the study the main objective of the study is to
assess internal control over cash of Goba woreda finance and economic development office.
The researcher design descriptive types, more over primary and secondary data from Goba
Woreda finance and economic development office will be collected.
The respondent will be selected with probability sampling by using simple random sampling,
the respondents will be randomly selected who have background knowledge about and
graduate of accounting and finance department.
The data gained from Goba Woreda finance and economic development office can be
collected analyzed, interpreted using statistical techniques with the help of tables.
Based on analysis conclusions will be made, finally recommendation will be drawn that
assumed to be useful to solve existing problems of the internal control over cash in Goba
Woreda finance and economic development office.
1
CHAPTER ONE
1. INTRODUCTION
2
Mobilizing and support different investments in the woreda .
3
1.4. Objectives of the study
Readers of this research would be able to obtain almost all the relevant information
regarding the internal control system. It will provide accessory internal control,
system for safeguarding cash and establishing responsibility for it. It will provide a
basis for further investigation in the area of Goba Woreda finance and economic
development office to realize the benefits of internal control system over cash and
identity weakness and strength of internal control system.
4
of the study, significance of the study, scope of the study and organization of the
paper. The second chapter deal with review of literatures. The third chapter deals
about methodology. Discussion and analysis of the gathered data would be
including in the fourth chapter. The last chapter will comprises conclusion and
recommendation of the study.
5
CHAPTER TWO
2. LITERATURE REVIEW
Internal controls are the American institute of certified public Accountants (AICPA) has
defined internal control as « The plan of organization and all the coordinate methods and
measures adopted with in a business to safe guard its assets, check the accuracy and the
reliability of its accounting data, promote operational efficiency and encourage adherence to
prescribed managerial policies. A system of internal control extends beyond those matters
which relate directly to the function of the accounting and financial departments».
According to the institute of chartered accountants of England and Wales (ICAEW) internal
control means not only internal check or internal Audit, but the management in order to carry
on the business of the finance in an orderly manner , safeguard its assets, and secure as for as
possible accuracy and reliability of its records. Form the above two definitions it is clears that
inter control is a broad term with a wide area of operation. It includes a number of methods
and measures, which exercised by management to ensure smooth and economic functioning
of business entity. (Ravinder Kumar and Virender Sharma, 2005:81).
6
2.2. Components of Internal control
The effectiveness of an internal system is measured by the effectiveness of its component
which makes up the overall control system. Internal control has five components namely, the
control environment, risk assessment, control activities, information and communications,
and Monitoring (Rick hays and Arnold children with Roger Dassen and Philip wallage
1999:199).
A. Control Environment
The core of any business is its people their individual attributes, including integrity, ethical
values and competence and the environment in which they operate , the control environment
means the overall attitude , awareness and actions of directors and management regarding the
internal control system and its importance in the entity. It is internal control system the
foundation for all other components of inter control, providing discipline and structure (Rick
hays and Arnold children with Roger Dassen and Philip wallage 1999:199).
B. Risk Assessment
C. Control Activities
The third internal control component , are the policies and procedures must be established
and executed to help ensure that the actions identified by management as necessary to address
risks to achievement of the entity’s objectives are effectively carried out , sometimes referred
to as control activities and procedures which management has established to achieve the
entity’s specific objectives. They include arrange of activities including apparatus,
authorizations, verifications, reconciliations, reviews, checking arithmetical accuracy, and
controlling application and environment of computer information systems. There are
potentially many control activities but the generally fall in to five categories (Rick hays and
Arnold children with Roger Dassen and Philip wallage 1999:199).
7
1. Adequate separation of duties:-
2. Proper authorization of transactions and activities.
3. Adequate documents and records.
4. Physical control of over assess and records and
5. Independent checks on performance
D. INFORMATION AND COMMUNICATION
Communication takes such forms as policy manuals accounting manuals, and memoranda.
E. MONITORING
Monitoring, the fifth and final components internal control is a process must be monitored,
and modifications made as necessary. This is accomplished through ongoing monitoring
activities. Separate evolutions or combination of the two- on going monitoring occurs in the
course of operations. In this way, the system can react dynamically changing as conditions
warrant, the scope and frequency of evaluations will depend on an assessment and
effectiveness of ongoing monitoring procedures. These internal control components and their
linkages are depicted the model, developed by Coso, shows the dynamism of internal control
systems. Components of internal control performance over time. Organizational change and
the ways in which controls are applied in them evolve monitoring helps management
determine what modifications to the system are needed as conditions change (Rick hays and
Arnold children with Roger Dassen and Philip wallage 1999:199).
It involves assessing the design and operation. It involves assessing the design and operation
of controls and taking corrective action. (Rick hays and Arnold children with Roger Dassen
and Philip wallage 1999:227).
8
2.3. Principle of Good Internal control
A. A well designed accounting system should be in operation. Financial and accounting
operations must be separated, i.e. the handling of cash and the recording of movement
thereof should be done by different persons.
B. Responsibility for the performance of the job must be clearly stated so that there
remains no room for doubt or confusion subsequently. To achieve this clear cut and
well conceived organization structure should be established.
C. Too much confidence should not be pinned in one individual nearly all frauds are
committed by ‘trusted’ officials or employees. It’s interesting to note that trades have
occurred owing to their being trusted.
D. Rotation principle relating to transfer of an employee from one job to another should
be the inflexible guiding rule.
E. Mechanization of the work where ever feasible and practicable, should be resorted to
mechanical devices such as cash register, recording time clocks, calculation machines
should be introduced.
F. The work should be so arranged that work done by one employee could be promptly
checked by another independent employee such the errors and the trades can not to un
detect.
G. The arrangement of the work should be in such a manner that writ en record and of
the role played by each employee should be maintained.
H. Clear and well defined rules should be laid down and practically followed relating to
dealing of the cash, ordering, receiving and issuing goods.
I. Employees must be in bond so that the tempted employee will be deferred from
committing fraud and employer be protected.
J. Although not a substitute for protective financial internal control (Ravinder kumar
and Virden Sharma ,2005:82).
K. Internal controls may be characterized as two types administrative controls and
accounting controls. Administrative controls are primarily concerned with the
promotion of operational efficiency and the adherence to prescribed managerial
policies. Administrative controls are related to operational audits 6 and compliance
audits 7. Accounting controls are principally concerned with sate guarding assets and
providing assurance that the financial statements and the under lying accounting
records are reliable. Internal accounting controls relate to external and internal
financial audits. The independent auditor is primarily concerned with the accounting
9
controls, which generally bear directly and internal financial audits. The independent
auditor is primarily concerned with the accounting controls, which generally bear
directly and importantly on the reliability of financial records. Accounting controls
comprise the plan of organization and the procedure and records that are concerned
with the safeguarding of assets and the reliability of financial records. According to
Ravinder kumar and Virden Sharma (2005)they are designed to provide reasonable
assurance that :-
Transactions are executed in accordance with management’s general or specific
organization.
Transactions are recorded as necessary to permit preparation of financial statements
in conformity with international accounting standards (LAS) or other applicable
criteria and to maintain accountability of assets.
Access to assets is permitted only in accordance with management’s authorization.
The recorded accountability of assets is compared with the existing assets at
reasonable intervals and appropriate action is taken with respect to any differences
(Ravinder kumar and Virden Sharma, 2005).
10
goods of operations controls are accurate information for internal decision making
and lager guarding of assets. The physical assets (eg. cash), non physical assets (e.g.
Accounts receivable). Important documents and records (e.g. Journals) of a company
can be stolen, misused or accidentally destroyed unless they are protected by
adequate controls. Professional controls are importance because management has a
legal and professional responsibility to be sure that information is prepared fairly in
accordance with accounting standards (Rick Hayes and Arnold schilder with Roger
Dassen and Philip Wallage 1999:196).
11
In addition, money truncation either directly or indirectly affects the receipt or
payment of cash. It’s therefore necessary that cash can be effectively safe guarded by
special control.
A. The Bank Account As A Tool for Controlling cash
One of the major devices for maintaining control over is the bank account. To get the
most benefit from a bank account all cash received must be deposited in the bank and
all payment must be made by checks drawn on the bank or from special cash
funds(Warren, Fees, Reeve 20 twentieth edition accounting,1995).
B. Bank Statement
Although there are some defences in procedures banks usually maintain an original
and a copy of all checking account transactions. When this is done, the original
becomes the statements of account that is mailed to the depositor, usually once
month. Like any account with customer or act editor , the bank statement shows the
beginning balance, check and other debits (deduction by the bank), deposits and other
credits (Additions by the bank ), and the balance at the end of the period may a
company the bank statements, arranged in the order of payment. The paid or
concealed checks are perforated or stamped «paid» together with the date or
payment(Warren, Fees, Reeve 20 twentieth edition accounting,1995).
C. Bank Reconciliation
When all cash receipts are deposited in the bank all payments are made by check, the
cash accounts is often called cash in bank. This account with the depositor in the
bank ledger, cash in the bank in the depositor’s ledger is an asset with a debit
balance, and the account with a depositor in the bank’s ledger is a liability with a
credit balance. According to Warren, Fees, Reeve 20th edition accounting (1995)
indicated that it might seen that the two balances should be equal, but they are not
likely to be equal on any specific date because of either or both of the following
1. Delay by either in recording transactions and
2. Errors by either party in recording transactions , to determine the reasons for
any error that may have been made by the bank or depositor the depositors
own records should be reconciled with the bank statement.(Warren, fees,
Reeve 20 twentieth edition Accounting 1995: 289).
3. Delay by either party in recording transactions and
12
4. Errors by either party in recording transactions. To determine the reasons for
any error that may have been made by the bank or depositor the depositors
own records should be reconciled with the bank statement (Warren, Fees,
Reeve 18 eighteen Edition Accounting, 1995:250).
13
C. Collections from credit customers
In many manufacturing and wholesale companies, cash receipts consist principally
of checks received through the mail; this situation poses little threat of dislocation
unless one employee is permitted to receive and deposit these checks and also to
record the credits to the customer’s accounts. Atypical system of internal control
over cash received through the mail described below.
Incoming mail usually is opened in the mail room. Where an employee, prepare a
control listing of the incoming cash receipts. The listing shows the amount received
from each customer and identifies the customer by name or account number. A
copy of the control listing and the cash receipts are awarded to the cashier. The
remittance advices and copy of the control listing are for awarded to the employee
responsible for the customers’ accounts (Whittington Pany 17 seventeen edition,
2010:379).
14
authorization functions. Authorization function includes procedures as extending and fouling
the vender’s in voice, determining the agreement of the invoice purchase order and receiving
are recorded in avouched register, by an entry debiting the appropriate asset, liability, or
expense accounts and crediting vouchers payable (Warren, Fees, Reeve, 20-twenty edition,
2010).
On the payment date, the voucher and supporting documents are removed from the tickler
file. A check is prepared but not signed. The voucher supporting papers and the check
(complete except for signature) are for awarded to the finance department. The treasurer
reviews the voucher before signing the check the check is the mailed directly to the payee,
and the voucher and all supporting documents are perforated to prevent reuse. The cancelled
vouchers are returned to the accounting department, where an entry is made to record the
cash disbursement (a debit to vouchers payable and credit to cash). Paid vouchers usually are
filed by voucher number in a paid voucher file (Warren, Fees, Reeve, 20-twenty edition,
2010).
15
2.5.2 Change fund
Retail stores and other business that receive cash directly from customers must maintain a
fund of currency and coin in order to make change. The fund may be established by drawing
a check for make the required amount, debiting the account cash in hand and crediting cash in
bank. No additional charges or credits to the cash on hand account are necessary unless the
amount of the fund is to be increased or decreased. At the end of cash received during the day
is deposited and the original amount of the change fund is retained. The desired composition
of the fund is maintained by exchanging bills or coins for those of other dominations at the
bank (Warren, fees, Reeve 18 eighteen edition, 1995:252).
16
CHAPTER THREE
3. METHODOLOGY
the Bale Zone. It is bounded by West Arsi Zone in the West, Harena Buluk and Mena district in the South,
Sinana woreda in the East, and Dinsho Woreda in the North. It has a total area of 1674 km2 which ranked the
district 12th largest among the zonal district (Goba Woreda socio economic profile,2015).
The area of the district leads the district leads the district to have a share of 2.55 percent from the total area of
the zone. Goba woreda is one of the administrative territories of Bale Zone with an area of 1674 km2, which
ranked the woreda the 12th largesrt among the zonal district.The area of the district leads the the district to have
a share of 2.55 percent from the total area of the zone (69,661 km2).The woreda has a distance of 15 km from
Zonal capital called Robe and 445 km from country’s capital city and the region called Finfine(Goba Woreda
socio economic profile,2015).
The land use of Goba woreda highly comprised grazing of livestock. But small amount of land is moderately
cultivated which found in some part of woreda North.The present day Goba woreda land form, relief
configuration, rocks, mineral distribution and physical features are the result of past geological history of
Mesozoic and Cenozoic era.During Mesozoic era of Neogene period there was a formation of rock in the
Western and Southern part of the woreda. During Oligocene-Miocene period there is Arsi and Bale rock
formation at the tip of North Western part of the woreda. During the Cenozoic era (late-early of Quaternary
period) there was a formation of plateau and Basaltic rock at the Central and Eastern part of the woreda.
The highest elevation of the woreda is Tullu Dimtu Mountain and Batu Mountains. They have an elevation of
4,377m and 4,307m above sea levels which found along Northern part of the woreda, where as the lowest point
of the woreda is roughly below 1500m below sea level which found at Wacho Kebeles near Goba Woreda.
The mean annual temperature of the woreda is 11.50c. The lowest temperature is 50c and highest is 180c
respectively. The mean annual rainfall is 1000 mm where as the lowest and highest rainfall is 800mm and
1200mm respectively.
The woreda connected with others woreda and the Zonal capital through two main roads. These are Robe-Goba
road and Goba- Delo Mena roads.
17
3.2. RESEARCH DESIGN
The secondary data will be obtained from internal of the organization books, internet, annual
report, and other related materials.
Stage one: - first researcher will be select client with beneficiary of internal control over
Case and related with Goba Woreda finance and economic development office.
Stage two: - researcher will be used simple random sampling from clients select in stage
18
3.8. WORK PLAN AND BUDGET
Table 3.8.1. Work plan and time schedule
Activities Time Schedule Sep to June
May
Nov
Mar
Dec
Apr
Sep
Feb
Oct
Jun
Jan
Au
Jul
Identification of The Title
Gather Necessary Data for the
Proposal
Writing the Proposal
Proposal submission
Literature review
Data collection
Data analysis
Research writing
1st draft research submission
Final thesis submission and presentation
3.8.2 . BUDGET
Budget summary
Stationary=6,079, Contingency(20%)= 1216 Grand total=7295.00)
19
3.9 EXPECTED OUT COMES
The main purpose of the study is to assess Control over cash in Finance and economic
development Office of Goba Woreda. The expected outcomes of the study are to
Identify the policies and procedure of the internal control structure over cash
provides reasonable assurance that Goba woreda finance and economic
development office goals and objectives will be achieved.
Check internal control structure over cash will be period review by
independent auditors.
Determine whether the internal controls over cash procedure are being
effectively applied.
Verify Goba Woreda Administration finance and economic development
office cash are efficiently under operation.
To identify the factors that affect control over cash in Goba woreda finance
and economic development office
3.10. Disseminations
20
• Make research results accessible to various audiences through Print resources such as
Research Portfolio
3.10.2 Disseminate research progress and findings to study participants.
• Ask study participants how they would like to be informed of findings.
• Disseminate positive, negative and null results.
• Make dissemination accessible paying attention to language and literacy needs of audience
as was done during the outreach/recruitment study phase.
3.10.3 Disseminate research progress and findings to service providers.
• Prioritize dissemination of results for organization that assisted with recruitment and/or
serve the target population.
• Emphasize the practical implications of the study results and treatment interventions.
3.10 4. Disseminate research findings to community.
• Use dissemination venues appropriate to the targeted representatives.
• Present research results to Community
21
REFERENCE
Accounting principle 1984 fess warren 14 fourteen Edition, philipe , fess , CPD , PHD
professor. Accountancy.Univeristys of Illinois, champlaign urbans.
Goba District Socio Economic Profile (2015). Socio Economic Profile of Goba District
of Bale Zone,Goba District Finance and Economic Development Office,Goba,
Ethiopia(unpublished)
22
MADDAWALABU UNIVERSITY
This questionnaire is designed for the employees of Goba woreda finance and economic
development office. To collect information about internal control over cash, the aim of the
study is for the partial fulfilments of the course. So, you are kindly requested to contribute to
the study by providing your felling honestly.
I. Personal Information
1. Sex Male Female
2. Age 18-25 36-45
26-35 above 45
th
3. Level of education 10 grade Diploma holder
12th grade first degree 4 above
4. Is there a separate clerk for receiving cash?
Yes No Not applicable
According the above question number 4
5. If you say No, what is the reason, explain
15. Are payment vouchers and supporting documents properly authorized before
payment?
Yes No
16. If your answer ‘yes ‘what is the reason, explain?
Thank you!
24