Thermal Stability of Bentonites in Foundry Molding Sand
Thermal Stability of Bentonites in Foundry Molding Sand
Thermal Stability of Bentonites in Foundry Molding Sand
ABSTRACT
T H E EFFECTS of heat on the behavior of sodium and calcium bentonite in bonding
foundry sands were studied.
Tests such as differential thermal analysis, viscosity, and melting or vitrification
temperatures do not indicate the suitability of a bentonite for foundry use.
The deterioration temperatures of sodium and calcium bentonite are 1180° and 600°F
respectively.
Reactivities of bentonites with cereal as affected by temperature and mulling were also
studied. Flowability of sands, defined as mold densiflcation in this paper, is better with
heated calcium than sodium bentonite.
Heating bentonites alone does not simulate the conditions encountered in heating
bentonite-sand mixtures in a mold.
INTRODUCTION
SYNTHETIC molding sands, used by the foundry industry to contain and shape
liquid metal, are essentially composed of a pure quartz sand, bentonite, and
an additive, such as pulverized coal or cereal, and water.
The molding sand is mixed in a sand muUer and is used to prepare a mold.
Molten metal is poured into the cavity. After the metal solidifies, the resulting
casting is removed from the mold for final cleaning.
Most iron foundries re-use the sand indefinitely, but steel foundries favor
the use of facing sand, prepared from all new materials, for the surface against
the casting, with the bulk of the mold made with the re-used sand.
The foundry literature (Zrimsek and Vingas, 1960, 1961a, b and c; 1962;
Vingas and Zrimsek, 1961; Heine et al., 1959; Ojala, 1962) contains consider-
able information on the properties of bentonite-bonded new sand mixtures.
Few data have been presented on the rate and nature of changes produced
by re-use.
The high temperature of the metal during casting heat-treats the molding
* The writers thank Magnet Barium Corporation for permission to conduct these
experiments and publish the results.
t P.O. Box 355, Arlington Heights, Illinois.
367
368 THIRTEENTH NATIONAL CONFERENCE ON CLAYS AND CLAY MINERALS
EXPERIMENTAL
Two bentonites were investigated: a sodium (western) and a calcium
(southern) bentonite, mined and processed in Greybull, Wyoming and
Kosciusko, Mississippi respectively. The bentonite was dried to 7 per cent
THERMAL STABILITY OF BENTONITES IN FOUNDRY MOLDING SAND 369
water content and ground so that 90 per cent was finer than a no. 200 sieve.
The behavior of the two bentonites after heat treatment was evaluated,
with the water content of the sand mixture, the mulUng response and ram-
ming as variables. Tests were performed to evaluate the effects of cereal
flour on heat-treated western bentonite and the effects of heat-inactivated
western bentonite on new western bentonite.
T A B L E 1.—SCREEN ANALYSIS OF B A S E
SAND U S E D
20 0.0
30 2.6
40 19.3
50 30.1
70 24.4
100 15.1
140 5.6
200 2.4
Pan 0.6
Mulling
In the first method of mulling, 1250-g sand and 100-g bentonite to be tested
were placed in a 12-in. Cincinnati muUer and mulled dry for 15 to 20 sec.
Water was added, and the mulling continued for 6 min more.
For the second method, 1250-g sand was placed in the muUer, the wheels of
which were removed, water was added, stirred with the plows only until
distributed (30-35 sec) and the 100 g of bentonite was then added and stirring
continued for an additional four minutes.
370 THIRTEENTH NATIONAL CONFERENCE ON CLAYS AND CLAY MINERALS
Tests
The sand mixtures were discharged into polyethylene bags and tested for
moisture content, green compression strength, green shear strength, dry
compression strength, and dry shear strength at 3 rams. The density of the
sand mixture was also checked at 1, 3, 5, 7 and 10 rams (Zrimsek and Vingas,
1961b). The sand mixtures were also riddled through a J-in. screen into a
250-cc volume and the density was calculated and reported as riddled density
in lb. per ft*.
Cereal Effects
The western bentonite, heat-treated to 1120°F., continued to act as a bond
in sand. To study the reactivity of this heat-treated bentonite to cereal and
compare it to the reactivity already established (Vingas and Zrimsek, 1963)
in new sand mixtures, some limited data were collected.
A mixture of 1250-g sand, 62.5-g (4.75 per cent) heat-treated and as-
received bentonite, and 12.5-g (1 per cent) cereal were mulled (with muUer
wheels on) as described above, at five moisture levels. The mechanical
properties of these systems were used for comparison and determination of
the effects of heat treatment on the reactivity of western bentonites to
cereal.
Viscosity Tests
Sodium (western) bentonite when mixed with water exhibits viscosity,
and it is common for some foundries to evaluate this property. The sodium
bentonite as received and all heat-treated samples were also checked for
viscosity. This was done by mixing 24-g (6 per cent) bentonite with 376 cm*
distilled water in a Hamilton Beach model 3D mixer for 6 min. The suspension
THERMAL STABILITY OF BENTONITES IN FOUNDRY MOLDING SAND 371
was then checked for viscosity with a Fann V.G. Viscosimeter at 600 rpm, and
calculated in centipoises.
RESULTS
Because of the volujne of data collected, all results are presented in graphic
form. Not all the data on cereal are presented since doing so would be repe-
titive.
DISCUSSION
We studied the deterioration of bentonites and the behavior of molding
sands containing heat-treated and deteriorated bentonites mixed with new,
unused materials.
Several investigations (Hofmann, 1958; Grim and Cuthbert, 1945) have
been conducted to establish the deterioration temperature of various ben-
tonites. In Europe, where sodium bentonites are scarce, the investigators
usually attempt to alter the calcium bentonite to sodium by treatment with
sodium salts. In most investigations, the major variables encountered in
regular foundry practice, such as water content, mulling response and
ramming energy, are maintained constant. As shown previously (Zrimsek and
Vingas, 1%0, 1961a, b, Vingas and Zrimsek, 1961, 1962; Heine, et al., 1959)
molding-sand data, unless collected on a system basis, are almost impossible
to analyze accurately.
This study shows the differences between sodium and calcium bentonites
when heated and mixed thoroughly with sand and water.
Figs. 1 and 2 show the data on sands bonded with the western and southern
bentonites before and after heat treatment, with the efficient mulling method
employed.
The curves obtained with the 7.45 per cent bentonite-sand-water mixture
before heat treatment are typical curves obtained with foundry molding sands
(Zrimsek and Vingas, 1960, 1961a, 1961b, Vingas and Zrimsek, 1961, 1962;
Heine, et ah, 1959).
Figs. 1 and 2 show that, as the heat-treating temperatures increase, the
peak green compression strength (Figures 1(a) and 2(a)), green shear strength
(Figures 1(b) and 2(b)), and the minimum density point (Figures 1(f) and 2-f))
shift to higher water levels.
When peak green compression strength (Fig. 3) is plotted versus tempera-
ture, the strength of the western bentonite bonded sand drops beyond
1150°F and that of the southern, beyond 600°F. The drop in strength beyond
these temperatures is drastic for the western and more gradual for the
southern.
Similar indications are reached if the other strength values are plotted as a
function of temperature and at other relatively equal water levels.
Figs. 4 and 5 show representative properties obtained at relatively low
372 T H I R T E E N T H NATIONAL CONFERENCE ON CLAYS AND CLAY MINERALS
^.2' /.'/'
S 22 -£. 200_ />'/"
-<% k 180 /•'•
•= 20
;\l\
- 18 S" 16(- / ''''
CO i 7
W
- 14t_ / '•'*
16 / '"'
Sl4 •a 6 12(1
B
5 - \ **^v\ .2 lot
S 12 £
K 4 - ^0^*\X •S. 80
/ 'i' /
1' //i / /
5 8 s 1 ^ ^ • v ^ ^ ^ . - ^ - *
E 60 ,//
" 6_ s 2 ' /-^-ti « 40 _ ^-^^
s 1 __ ST 20
o
/ "
*• 2 1,'... 1 - 1
0 0 1 - - i " ' 1
\ i \ I i i 5
3 4
% WAT E R % WAT E R i ?• W A T E R
(a) (b)
R.T. 10 rams,/'
230°F
510
870
1120
1210
c 70
B 1290
i
5?
60 1\\\
i
a
50 \^\
1
S
40
\v\
\\.\
\LX
i 40
30
?0 ,'>' :-'-'
c'
3e s 10 ' •
1 1 f VJ
0
3 4 S i 3 4 S 3 4 5
="
%.W A T E R * WAT E R ^0 W A T E R
F I G . 1. Water content effects on green compression strengths (a), green shear strength (b),
dry compression strength (c), riddled density (d), dry shear strength (e), and rammed
density (f) of 7.45% western (sodium) bentonite bonded sands; western bentonites
checked a t room temperature and a t the heat-treated temperature indicated; all proper-
ties shown a t 3 rams except rammed density, which was also checked at 1 and 10 rams.
Sands mulled for 6 min after water was added with wheels of muUer on.
THERMAL STABILITY OF B E N T O N I T E S IN F O U N D R Y MOLDING SAND 373
3 4 5
% W Jl T E R
- lOram /
1 X. ;•-'
1 /,• ,V
-—
J; 3 ram /
- -1.^
_-v
-^y
\ j . ~/
-\
-
1 '~'-"r' 1
3 4 5
•?. W A T E R
(f)
FIG. 2. Water content effects on green compression strength (a), green sliear strength (b),
dry compression strength (c), riddled density (d), dry shear strength (e), and rammed
density (f) of 7.45% southern (calcium) bentonite bonded sands; southern bentonites
checked a t room temperature and a t the heat-treated temperature indicated; all
properties shown at 3 rams except rammed density, which was also checked at 1 and
10 rams. Sands mulled for 6 min after water was added with wheels of muUer on.
374 THIRTEENTH NATIONAL CONFERENCE ON CLAYS AND CLAY MINERALS
R.T.
870 F
1120
CO
G3
''• 1 i i i
% WA T ER
(a)
FIG. 4. Water content effects on green compression strength (a), and riddled density (b),
of 7.45% western (sodium) bentonite bonded sands.
THERMAL STABILITY OF BENTONITES IN FOUNDRY MOLDING SAND 375
1 \V"'.
10 /
-X"^\.
/'"T-'-^'-^-^'-i^ ^
50
' \\"•••-.
\ \
8 / -' 40
«« 6 / /
Z^ ~" ,<--
3.
2 •''** ^ , , ,
I I
\ 4 5
Vo W A T E R %W A T E R
{b)
F I G . 5. Water content effects on green compression strength (a), and riddled density (b),
of 7.45% southern (calcium) bentonite bonded sands.
mulling response. The same data, however, show that with the low mulling
efficiency new as-received western bentonite responds to mulling more readily
than southern. This is contrary to what was previously reported (Vingas and
Zrimsek, 1961) when the low mulling efficiency was designed differently. In
that work, the low muUing efficiency was simulated by placing the sand and
bentonite in an 18-in. muUer and mixing for 30 sec. Water was added, and the
mulling was continued for 2 min more.
The direct relationship between 1- and 10-ram density differential (Zrimsek
and Vingas, 1961b, 1963; Vingas and Zrimsek, 1962) and the percentage of
bentonite present in a sand mixture, when checked at any water content
beyond the minimum density point, is substantiated by this experiment.
BD I B P MOO
Temperature — °F
F I G . 6. Density differential as a function of the temperature at which the
bentonites were heat-treated; mulled and stirred sands as indicated.
R I D D L E D SAND D E N S I T Y
It was shown previously (Zrimsek and Vingas, 1964), when molding sands
were investigated for their ability to reproduce a particular casting dimension
from that of the pattern, that the riddled density of the sand is the most signifi-
cant property. In addition, they showed that the main disadvantage of
bentonites in molding sands is the very narrow range of water after which a
major change in riddled density occurs. Modern high-production molding
machines do not consider this variable in their design. Riddled density is here
THERMAL STABILITY OF BENTONITES IN FOUNDRY MOLDING SAND 377
Water %
Bentonite Temp. °F From To Water range
Western
Mulled Room 2.45 2.90 0.50
510 2.55 3.05 0.50
870 2 50 3.15 0.60
1120 2.60 3.65 1.05
Southern
Mulled Room 1.35 3.20 0.85
510 2.55 3.65 1.10
738 3.00 4.40 1.40
Western
Stirred Room 2.70 3.60 0.90
870 3.15 4.15 1.00
1120 3.70 5.60 1.90
Southern
Stirred Room 3.20 4.20 1.00
230 3.40 4.90 1.50
510 3.60 Never reached
738 4.90 Never reached
Table 2 shows the range of water required to reduce the riddled density
from 65 lb/ft* to 40 lb/ft*. At all conditions, the southern bentonite shows a
larger water range than the western. This substantiates the statement made
by foundrymen that southern bentonites are more flowable than western.
Heat treatment of the southern bentonite not only reduced the sensitivity
of moisture to riddled density, but simultaneously increased the density
achieved at minimum. For example, the minimum riddled density of the
738°F heat-treated, southern bentonite-bonded sand (Figure 5(b)) reached is
63 lb per ft^ versus 33 lb per ft^ for the new, as-received bentonite.
It should be remembered that many additives put in molding sands affect
the fiowability of bentonites. For example, Vingas and Zrimsek (1963)
showed that cereal, when mixed with western bentonite, eliminates the narrow
water range at which these sands are workable.
Effects of Cereal
The western bentonite heated to 1120°F was used to prepare sand mixtures
378 THIRTEENTH NATIONAL CONFERENCE ON CLAYS AND CLAY MINERALS
with cereal flour in order to investigate the reactivity of cereal to the heat-
treated western bentonite.
Fig. 7 shows the influence of 1 per cent of cereal on green compression
strength for the 4.75 per cent bentonite system. Green strengths at low water
content were reduced, and the comprehensive tests showed that the minimum
density and comparable dry compression and dry shear strengths were
realized at about 0.5 per cent higher water contents.
The systems at lower heat-treating temperatures showed no major effects
on the reaction of cereal to the bentonites, and they are not included in this
report. The shifts in water requirement closely followed the systems con-
taining no cereal.
10
8
6 R.T.
CO
—II70°F
? 1 1 1
2 3
4 5
%W A T ER
F I G . 7. Water content effects on green compression strength of 4.75% west-
ern (sodium) bentonite and 1 % cereal flour bonded sands.
Room temp. 20
510 17.5
870 4.0
1120 1.5
SUMMARY
The difference between sodium (western) and calcium (southern) bentonites
and their reaction to heat have been shown. The evaluation made of their
behavior in bonding foundry molding sand was established by the physical
and mechanical properties they impart. Although both physical and mechani-
cal properties could help to establish the mold-making ability of the aggregate,
they cannot be used to predict the probability of making a defect-free casting.
The end product of a foundry is a casting, not a mold. Discretion is needed,
therefore, when applying the principles developed. It should not be taken for
granted that an adequately bonded sand that will produce a good mold will
necessarily produce a good casting.
Other tests developed to establish the mineralogy of bentonites, such as
differential thermal analysis, viscosity, and melting or vitrification tempera-
ture, cannot be used by the foundry industry to check the suitability of
bentonites, even from the bonding standpoint.
The conclusions reached are as follows:
1. The deterioration temperature of western and southern bentonite is
1180°F and 600°F respectively.
2. The drop in strength beyond the deterioration temperature is gradual
for southern and abrupt for western.
380 THIRTEENTH NATIONAL CONFERENCE ON CLAYS AND CLAY MINERALS
REFERENCES
BISHOP, H . F . , and PELLINI, W . S . (1951) Solidification of steel from and and chill
walls, U.S. Naval Res. Lab. NRL Rep. 3785.
Foundry Sand Handbook, 7tli ed. (1963) American Foundrymen's Society, Des Plaines,
Illinois.
GRIM, R . E . , and CUTHEKET, F . L . (1945) The bonding action of clays. Part I, Clays in
green molding sands, Illinois State Geol. Survey Rep. Invest. 102.
H E I N E , R . W . , PARKER, J. J., K I N G , E . H . , SCHUMACHER, J. S., and BOSWORTH, T . J.
(1959) Sand movement and compaction in green sand molding, Trans. Am. Foundry-
men's Soc. 67, 47.
HoFMANN, F . (1958) Investigations on the effect of heat on the bonding properties of
various bentonites, Trans. Am. Foundrymen's Soc. 66, 305.
MAREK, C. T . (1963) Transformation zones in green sand, Mod. Castings 4 3 , 185.
OjALA, T. (1962) The equilibrium of foundry system sands. Part I, Cast Iron Melts and
Methods, 5, 2.
PASCHKIS, V. (1945) Studies on solidification of castings, Trans. Am. Foundrymen's
Soc. 53, 90.
RUDDLE, R . W . (1957) The Solidification of Castings, Institute of Metals, London.
ViNGAS, G. J., and ZRIMSEK, A. H . (1961) Systematic approach to sand design and
control, Progress Report 3, The Mulling Effect, Trans. Am. Foundrymen's Soc.
69, 101.
ViNGAS, G. J., and ZRIMSEK, A. H. (1962) Systematic approach to sand design and
control. Progress Report 6, Trans. Am. Foundrymen's Soc. 70, 321.
ViNGAS, G. J., and ZRIMSEK, A. H. (1963) Steel foundry green facing sands. Mod.
Castings 4 3 , 50.
ZRIMSEK, A. H., and VINGAS, G . J. (1960) Systematic approach to sand design and
control. Trans. Am. Foundrymen's Soc. 68, 449.
ZRIMSEK, A. H., and VINGAS, G . J. (1961a) Systematic approach to sand design and
control. Progress Report 2, Clay bonded sand dry properties. Trans. Am. Foundry-
men's Soc. 69, 33.
ZRIMSEK, A. H., and VINGAS, G . J. (1961b) Systematic approach to sand design and
control, Progress Report 4, Wood flour: Trans. Am. Foundrymen's Soc. 69, 141.
ZRIMSEK, A. H., and VINGAS, G . J. (1961c) Systematic approach to sand design and
control. Progress Report 5, Interpretation of data. Trans. Am. Foundrymen's Soc.
69, 229.
ZRIMSEK, A. H., and VINGAS, G . J. (1963) Mechanics of rework sand, Mod. Castings 4 3 , 36.
ZRIMSEK, A. H., and VINGAS, G . J. (1964) Factors controlling casting dimension, Trans.
Am. Foundrymen's Soc. 72, To be published.