Disaster Waste Management in Malaysia: Significant Issues, Policies & Strategies
Disaster Waste Management in Malaysia: Significant Issues, Policies & Strategies
Disaster Waste Management in Malaysia: Significant Issues, Policies & Strategies
1051/ matecconf/20166600051
IBCC 2016
Abstract. Disaster Waste Management in Malaysia is still at the early stage of its research. Disaster can create large
volumes of debris and waste and mismanagement of disaster waste can affect both the response and long term
recovery of disaster affected area. The government of Malaysia is taking serious about this issue. This paper is aim to
explore the issues, policies and strategies regarding disaster waste management in Malaysia. The objectives were to
investigate the extent of disaster waste effects on the environment and to provide a basis from which the needs of
waste management could be evaluated in disaster management guidelines. Qualitative method of data collection has
been adopted in this study. The respondent are among the local authority and organization that involved in managing
wastes. The finding shows that many of the policies regarding waste management in Malaysia has not been well
implemented. The purpose of this paper is expected to improve the method of managing disaster waste in Malaysia.
© The Authors, published by EDP Sciences. This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution
License 4.0 (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/).
MATEC Web of Conferences 66, 00051 (2016) DOI: 10.1051/ matecconf/20166600051
IBCC 2016
2
MATEC Web of Conferences 66, 00051 (2016) DOI: 10.1051/ matecconf/20166600051
IBCC 2016
(interview and case study protocol and pilot exercise), disaster previous to the case study.
semi-structured interview questions and the effects of
Table 1. Previous studies on typical disaster waste management or issues and their impacts on the environment
Year Authors Title of Research Instruments Remarks
2008 [8] Estimation of waste Case study The research focuses on the
generation from floods flooded area and discusses the
parameters affecting floods waste
for the model development.
2010 [9] Waste management Semi- This research focuses on the post-
strategies during post structured disaster waste management
disaster phase: A Case of interview strategies adopted and on the
Sri Lanka issues and challenges encountered
at both national and local levels in
Sri Lanka during the post - Indian
Ocean tsunami period.
2011 [10] Environmental implications Case study The research focuses on the
for disaster preparedness: lessons learnt from the
Lessons Learnt from the environmental aspects of the
Indian Ocean Tsunami tsunami, strategies and its
implications for disaster
preparedness plans after disaster:
Indian Ocean Tsunami.
2011 [11] Disaster waste Case study This research focuses on
management: Semi- developing a systems
A systems approach structure understanding of disaster of waste
d management and in turn develops
interview context and disaster-transferrable
decision-making guidance for
emergency and waste managers.
2012 [12] Disaster waste management Survey Discusses waste management
challenges (questionn systems and challenges.
aire)
Semi-
structured
interview
Case study
2013 [13] Strategy for separation and Case study This research focuses on existing
treatment of disaster waste: guidelines in waste management
A manual for earthquake in several of countries due to
and tsunami disaster waste disaster.
management in Japan
2014 [14] Hazard and risk perception Semi- Concerns the socio-economic
at Turrialba volcano (Costa structured dimensions of hazards and how
Rica); interview these factors can be integrated
Implications for disaster Case study into disaster risk reduction at
risk management Turrialba volcano (Costa Rica)
2014 [15] Location and routing Case study This research concerns the debris
problems of debris collection operation hindered by
collection operation limited access,
after disasters with realistic Like blocked access by debris.
case study
The interview and case study protocol and qualitative target group will be identified before the actual data
instrument will be prepared to ensure reliability and collection takes place. Due to the nature of qualitative
validity of the qualitative data then piloted with a targeted research, the data will be collected until saturation point
group prior to the actual data collection process;, the is achieved. Based on the case study, observation,
purpose of this exercise is to maintain internal validity of parameters will be established to observe the current
the data and reliability of the instrument. Semi-structured status of disaster waste management in Malaysia. The
interview questions will be selected to be put to research will be focused on selected major post-disaster
professionals involved in disaster waste management. events such as floods in East Malaysia (Kuala Krai,
The selected samples of interviewee should consist of Kelantan; Temerloh, Pahang). For each case study,
policy makers from government related agencies relevant qualitative data will be gathered from post-disaster
to disaster waste management. The sampling frame of the literature (government reports, documents and legislation;
3
MATEC Web of Conferences 66, 00051 (2016) DOI: 10.1051/ matecconf/20166600051
IBCC 2016
practitioner, reports etc.).The third method of data promoting the use of products made from recycled
collection wills, draft proposed waste management materials and fuel made from disaster waste.
principles for adaption into disaster management
guidelines. The last method is to ensure validity of the
“ ...in our list of planning now, we’re planning to
findings and the proposed guidelines. Data from the
promote recycling materials by the next
literature review, semi-structured interviews and
generation; meaning more focus on children
document analysis will be juxtaposed and contextualised.
(primary and secondary school) and of course it is
This research is expected to emphasize the importance of
cheaper than branded things ” (Respondent 4)
the implementation of efficient disaster waste
management in order to sustain ecological systems and
enhance the social well-being of all Malaysian citizens 4.2 Improve the education and awareness of
and future generations. From the fundamental theoretical producers, the public and people involved
aspects, this research will proposed the adoption of in the disaster waste system/sector
disaster waste management into disaster management
guidelines. It is expected to encourage further research People affected by major disasters are badly traumatized,
and detailed investigation on disaster waste management but giving them a task to do helps them to recover. The
and sustainable development. Future collaboration with Environment Agency leads the way in cooperation
relevant government will be appreciated. This paper only between all the parties participating in education within
presents data from the interview sessions with the the waste sector such as private sector contractors and
selected respondents. sub-contractors:; Alam Flora Sdn. Bhd, Southern Waste
Management Sdn Bhd, E-Idaman Sdn Bhd, ın managing
the waste in our country, as stated by Respondent 2.
4 Results and discussion Strategies that can be considered include:
i. Promoting the advantages of recycling of waste
The researcher found that the authorities should play their
and practicing the 3Rs (Reduce, Reuse,
role towards sustainable waste management after
Recycle) programmes and make one day only
disasters such as floods. Four (4) respondents were
for collecting the waste.
selected, from the Department of Environment (DOE) in
Putrajaya, Department of National Solid Waste in the ii. Informing people of the waste management
Ministry of Urban Wellbeing, Housing and Local hierarchy: reduce,reuse,recycle,recovery and
Government and from the private sector; Alam Flora Sdn. dispose.
Bhd. The interview sessions were conducted in October iii. Promoting the use of less hazardous
2015.The working experience of the selected respondents alternatives such as chemicals during the
was 5 years and above in the waste management industry. production of goods
Climatic changes have made garbage disposal dumps the iv. Encouraging companies and institution to set
only method for efficient garbage disposal in Malaysia. up a certified environmental managements
To achieve sustainable and effective waste management, systems and follow a national environmental
development strategies must go beyond purely technical policy.
considerations to formulate specific objectives and
v. Appointing a ‘specialist officer of disaster
implement appropriate measures with regard to political,
waste management’ exclusively for Malaysia.
environmental, social, financial, economic and technical
aspects of disaster waste management. In addition, four “ ...even though we had to do a lot of campaigns,
(4) strategies for achieving good disaster waste promote everything, everywhere,publish the article,
management were identified: a lot of brochures about how to manage the waste,
and used 3R system (Reduce,Reuse, and Recycle),
our people nevertheless pretend to know nothing
4.1 Proper arrangement of the material by about waste,it is seen to be less efficient or still
recycling, recovery and disposal method lacking awareness and all this makes us more
Disasters such as floods can produce a large quantity of worried about our future generation. In this case,
waste, which will endanger people, block access roads, we should add some more strategies such as
block drainage channels, and conceal trapped people after campaigns in the schools, colleges or other
the disaster. Respondent 4 also recommended promoting institutions.” (Respondent 2)
the use of plastic recycling identification codes and labels
in order to sort and recycle plastic packaging more easily, 4.3 Control and decrease waste generation
for both municipalities and the private sector.Although
i. Promote the production of goods to minimize waste
this helps to separate the different types of waste to be
generation after disaster or as used by people.
recycled, reused or disposed of sorting the waste after a
ii. The Environment Agensy should set up a portal or
disaster, must consider the evironmental, political,
web site to inform the public about the ways of to
institutional, social, financial, economic and technical
re-use and control the waste and prevent waste
aspects. If possible, sort the rubble as it is being removed,
generation in households or after disasters.
and store reusable materials separately from the rest of
the waste. Another way to manage the waste is by
4
MATEC Web of Conferences 66, 00051 (2016) DOI: 10.1051/ matecconf/20166600051
IBCC 2016
iii. The roles and resposibilities of those involved in waste management, not just focusing on daily
disaster waste management system should be operation only ” (Respondent 1)
known such as the Environmental Department,
Solid Waste and Public Cleansing Management This study identified several authorities and law
Corporation (Act 672), local authorities and under their jurisdiction in handling solid waste areas as
contractors/sub-contractorts and agents. They shown in Table 2:
should know their purpose and main duties and
responsibilities when disaster occurs. According to Table 3. Authorities involve in Disaster Waste Management
the Respondent 3, the roles and responsibilities of
all the parties involved in a disaster area are very Authorities Laws/ Acts/ Scope/ Remarks
important because each has their ‘own style’ in Standard Policy
planning to solve these issues in short-terms National National Security Outlines a Policy on
actions. Security Council Disaster Management
Division Directive No. 20 and Relief according to
“ ...they have to understand their own roles
(Prime (The Policy And the level of disaster. The
and responsiilities, if not the coordination of Minister’s Mechanism On purpose is determining
the organizations will be disorganized in Department) National Disaster the roles and
terms of the operations planning due to their And Relief responsibilities of the
attitude” (Respondent 3) Management) various agencies
involved in handling
4.4 Improve and follow the existing policies and disaster.
legislation in the waste system/sector Ministry of Solid Waste and This act as guidelines for
Urban Public Cleansing the management and
Welbeing, Management Act regulation of controlled
İn general, disaster waste managemet is arranged
Housing and 2007 (Act 672) solid waste and public
and handled by several government agencies, from Local cleansing for the purpose
federal to state to local authorities. Due to lack of Government of maintaining proper
human and financial resources to manage solid of Malaysia sanitation. Normally, the
waste and public cleansing, an integrated system for act is focuses on
waste management and an interim privatisation household, municipal
period would take too long and make it more and hazardous industrial
difficult to secure loans; this is one of the reasons waste/areas.
the federal sector took over all the waste Ministry of Environmental The EQA was enacted in
Natural Quality Act 1974 1974 and applies to the
management systems, with two departments in
Resources (Act 127) whole of Malaysia. It is
2007;, National Solid Waste Management and –Part IV Section related to the prevention,
Department and Solid Waste and Public Cleansing Environment 24 (2b) abatement, control of
Management Corporation [16]. Therefore, several pollution and
strategies need to be improved, likes revising the enhancement of the
Waste Management Act of 2012 and their environment, and for
definitions of terms;, or defining the purpose connected
responsiblilities of each sector and improving the therewith.
databases regarding quantities and types of waste Department Malaysian This Malaysian Standard
of Standards Standard Landfill specifies requirements
that is treated. The system should be enforced, a
Malaysia/ Safe Closure- for landfill safe closure
deterrent to parties that do not abide by laws. SIRIM Requirements and it is to protect public
According to Respondent 2, the existing policies on BERHAD (MS 2547:2014) health and the
solid waste management focus on the household, environment by proper
municipal and ‘normal waste’ produced by our management of such.
community. Consequently, disaster waste is not
included in Act 672. Respondent 1 and 2 also stated Sources: National Security Council Directive No.20 [3], ACT 672
in reality, the existing policies it seem not to be [18], ACT 127 [19] and MS 2547:2014 by SIRIM [20].
implemented, as there is lack of enforcement.
“ ...of course every year,we’re faced with a flood Table 3. above shows the first authority is an
disaster related to existing policies of waste organization under the National Security Council (NSC)
management; Act 672 in Malaysia is for domestic of the Prime Minister’s Department Malaysia, which
waste and scheduled waste only and there is no introduced Directive No. 20 (Policy and Mechanism on
enforcement of this act...to date, we do not use any National Disaster and Relief Management). The scope of
policies, acts or guidelines on disaster waste this directive is according to the level of disaster:, Level
management ” (Respondent 2) 1:District; Level II: State; Level III: Central [3]. The
main purpose of this policy is to form a team and
“ ...in the EIA report there is nothing related to coordinate agencies involved in disaster management
disaster waste, but in my opinion other parties [17] and to determine the roles and responsibilities of the
involved in waste management after the recent agencies involved in handling the disaster. The second
floods must have planning, playing their role and authority is the Ministry of Urban Wellbeing, Housing
improving the existing policies related to disaster and Local Government of Malaysia with its Solid Waste
5
MATEC Web of Conferences 66, 00051 (2016) DOI: 10.1051/ matecconf/20166600051
IBCC 2016
7 Conclusions
The disaster waste management strategies is useful
approach to guide Malaysia for present and in the future.
The findings are expected to be the cornerstone for
disaster waste management in Malaysia. There is a gap in
terms of what has been planned and the actions actually
taken in particular disaster waste management events.
Generally, disaster waste management issues in Malaysia
have not been seriously addressed, thus more empirical
evidence and research is required to provide information
on the current scenario and the actions that should be
taken. This study revealed that they are four (4) elements
Figure 1. Cross-case study anaysis strategies of disaster to be considered in this research which are based on
social impact, economic impact, environmental impact
waste management
and technical impact (i.e.: insufficient equipment,
6
MATEC Web of Conferences 66, 00051 (2016) DOI: 10.1051/ matecconf/20166600051
IBCC 2016
transportation problems etc.). In order to have a better 6. Did, “Government Of Malaysia Department Of
disaster waste management in Malaysia, the factor could Irrigation Volume 1 – Flood Management,” vol. 1,
be highlighted for further study. These need more (2009).
investigation from the researcher to look into the 7. Hon Anna Bligh MP, “Disaster Management
suitability of the factors to be adopted in the disaster Strategic Policy Framework,” State Disaster
management guideline in Malaysia. Developing a Management. Gr., no. 1, pp. 1–20, (2010).
management strategy for Malaysia is the fundamental 8. H. Srinivas and Y. Nakagawa, “Environmental
task of an agency’s leader. Strategy indicates both where implications for disaster preparedness: Lessons
the agency wants to go (long-term objectives) and how it Learnt from the Indian Ocean Tsunami,” J. Environ.
plans to get there (on its planning on waste management). Manage, vol. 89, no. 1, pp. 4–13, (2008).
The agency management strategy must be realistic in 9. G. Karunasena, R. Amaratunga, and R. Haigh,
taking account both of limits and resources. That is, the “Waste management strategies during post disaster
strategy must be guided by the underlying reality of the phase: A case of Sri Lanka,” (2010).
setting in which objectives are pursued. In what follows, 10. M. Milke, “Disaster waste management research
we use management strategy and implementation strategy needs,” Waste Management, vol. 31, no. 1, p. 1,
as generally interchangeable. Furthermore, through the (2011).
exploratory interview, it provides clarify on actual events 11. C. Brown, M. Milke, and E. Seville, “Disaster waste
on disaster waste management in Malaysia. Thus, the management: A review article,” Waste Management,
additional knowledge about strategies on disaster waste vol. 31, no. 6, pp. 1085–1098, (2011).
management in this paper will benefit all the parties 12. Periathamby, a., Hamid, F. S. & Sakai, S. -i. Disaster
involved in waste management. From the above, it can be waste management challenges. Waste Manag. Res.
anticipated that this research will generate interests from 30, 113–114 (2012).
disaster waste researchers and disaster waste management 13. M. Asari, S. I. Sakai, T. Yoshioka, Y. Tojo, T.
policy makers, as it will provide fundamental elements Tasaki, H. Takigami, and K. Watanabe, “Strategy for
towards a more rigorous disaster waste management separation and treatment of disaster waste: A
policy. manual for earthquake and tsunami disaster waste
management in Japan,” J. Mater. Cycles Waste
Management, vol. 15, no. 3, pp. 290–299, (2013).
Acknowledgement 14. S. M. van Manen, “Hazard and risk perception at
The authors would like to express their gratitude for the Turrialba volcano (Costa Rica); implications for
financial support from MOHE (Ministry of Higher disaster risk management,” Appl. Geogr., vol. 50, pp.
Education) under the Fundamental Research Grant 63–73, (2014).
Scheme (FRGS), 600-RMI/FRGS DIS 5/3 (7/2015) and 15. A. Pramudita, E. Taniguchi, and A. Qureshi,
also LESTARI GRANT (600-RMI/DANA 5/3/LESTARI “Location and Routing Problems of Debris
(17/2015) which is internal grant of Universiti Teknologi Collection Operation after Disasters with Realistic
MARA (UiTM) for the management and support of this Case Study,” Procedia - Soc. Behav. Sci., vol. 125,
research. pp. 1–15, (2014).
16. T. J. Sin, G. K. Chen, K. S. Long, I. Goh, and H.
Hwang, “Current practice of waste management
References system in Malaysia : Towards sustainable waste
management Current Practices for Malaysia”, in 1st
1. P. Schübeler, J. Christen, and C.- Berne, “UNDP / FPTP Postgraduate Seminar Towards sustainable
UNCHS (Habitat)/ World Bank / SDC Collaborative waste management. (2013).
Programme on Municipal Solid Waste management 17. B. A. Rahman, “Issues of Disaster Management
in Low-Income Countries URBAN MANAGEMENT Preparedness: A Case Study of Directive 20 of
AND INFRASTRUCTURE Conceptual Framework National Security Council Malaysia,” Int. J. Bus.
for Municipal Solid Waste Management in Low- Soc. Sci., vol. 3, no. 5, (2012).
Income Countries,” (1996). 18. Ministry of Housing and Local Government, “Act
2. C. O. Ver and S. T. O. Ry, “Disaster Management in 672, Solid Waste and Public Cleansing Management
Malaysia : Evolution, Development and Future Act”, pp. 1-7, (2007).
Challenges,” no. February, (2007). 19. Ministry of Natural Resources and Environment,
3. National Security Council, “Disaster Management in “Act 127, Environmental Quality Act”, pp 1-17,
Malaysia: Landscape Review, Challenges and (1974).
Prospects,” (2011). 20. SIRIM, "MS 2547:2014- Malaysian Standard
4. G. Approach, “Cabarrus County, North Carolina,” Landfill Safe Closure- Requirements," Sirim Berhad,
no. April, (2012). Malaysia, (2014).
5. MSPs, “Draft National Policy for Disaster 21. Mustafa, M, “.Environmental law in Malaysia.
Management in Kenya,” no. February, pp. 1–50, Kluwer Law International BV, the Natherlands”, pp.
(2009). 98-99, (2011).