Urbanization, Housing Quality and Environmental Degeneration in Nigeria
Urbanization, Housing Quality and Environmental Degeneration in Nigeria
Urbanization, Housing Quality and Environmental Degeneration in Nigeria
Review
This paper examines the housing quality in Nigeria cities and the impacts of urbanization on
environmental degeneration of urban built environment. The paper identifies the problems that have
aided the degeneration to: Inadequate basic infrastructural amenities, substandard housing,
overcrowding, poor ventilation in homes and work places, and noncompliance with building bye-laws
and regulations. In order to examine the above mentioned problems, the study included secondary
data. The secondary data involved available census data, official documents and other relevant
secondary data were obtained from existing literature, on books and journals. The paper finds that the
poor housing quality has serious adverse effects on environment and the health of city residents.
Strategies for improving the built environment for sustainable living are suggested. The paper
concluded that it is imperative to check and prevent further decay for harmonious living and
sustainable developments.
Key words: Urbanization, environmental, degeneration, substandard, housing, housing quality, overcrowding.
INTRODUCTION
Nigerians live in sub-standard and sub-human environ- mortality and migration. This population increase directly
ment, plagued by slum, squalor and grossly inadequate bears on urbanization, requiring a whole range of urban
social amenities. The result is manifested in growing services and infrastructure, together with job creation for
overcrowding in homes and increasing pressure on infra- the population able and willing to work.
structural facilities and rapid deteriorating environment.
In Europe, urbanization brought increased wealth and
economic earnings, higher education, lower fertility, Housing quality in Nigeria
better health, longer life and more amenities. But in
Africa, and indeed, in Nigeria, the opposite is the case. The definition of housing quality embraces many factors
The Executive Director of African Population and Health which include the physical condition of the building and
Research Centre, Nairobi, observes that in African other facilities and services that make living in a particular
States, research has shown that urbanization is attended area conducive. The quality of housing within any
by reduction in earnings, and other social indicators, neighbourhood should be such that satisfies minimum
adding that rural communities have better social and health standards and good living standard, but should
economic indicators than those in urban slums. also be affordable to all categories of households
(Okewole and Aribigbola, 2006).
facilities, burglary, spatial adequacy, noise level within infrastructures to keep pace with the rate of growth.
neighbourhood, sewage and waste disposal, air pollution Inadequate storm drains, dumping of refuse in drainage
and ease of movement among others, as relevant quality lines and construction of houses close to and even on the
determinants in housing. However, Hanmer et al. (2000) natural water channels have been shown to be
conclude that qualitative housing involves the provision of responsible in that order for the increasing cases of flood
infrastructural services which could bring about in the urban centres. Environment problems associated
sustainable growth and development through improved with the increasing growth of urban slums including
environmental conditions and improved livelihood. In overcrowding in squalid housing conditions, poor quality
determining the quality of residential development, or unavailability of basic infrastructures and social
Neilson (2004) stipulates five basic criteria which provide services, such as water and sewage facilities and even
that housing must be in compliance with tolerable lack of access routes (NEST, 1992).
standard, free from serious disrepair, energy efficient, ii. Overpopulation: Population is a major factor in all
provided with modern facilities and services, and that it environmental-related issues. Overpopulation causes
must be healthy, safe and secure. stress on the environment. There are evidences every-
These indicators consist of variables such as; access to where of rapid decline in environmental quality and
basic housing and community facilities, the quality of human living conditions occasioned by rapid increase in
infrastructural amenities, spatial adequacy and quality of human numbers.
design, fixtures and fittings, building layout and land- The Federal Government of Nigeria (1988) National
scaping, noise and pollution control as well as security. Policy on population for development also made the
There are however indications from these various studies observation that “the present high rate of our population
that a single variable may not be sufficient to assess the growth is already contributing substantially to the
qualitative nature of residential development; therefore, degradation of the ecology of the country.
housing acceptability and qualitative assessment should iii. Poverty: There is an inextricable link between poverty
also take into account type of constructions, materials and environmental degeneration. Poverty can be the
used, services, spatial arrangement and facilities within cause or the effect of environmental degeneration. Either
dwellings, function and aesthetics, among others (Olu- way, good quality environments cannot be achieved in
Sule and Gur, noted in Jiboye, 2004). the face of glaring poverty.
The unwise use of the natural environment due to igno- Ahianba et al. (2005) analyse the characteristics of
rance, poverty, overpopulation and urbanization amongst environmental degeneration as follows: Inadequate basic
others has led to the degeneration of the environment. infrastructural amenities, substandard housing, over-
The charges (degeneration) occur as Nigerians attempt crowding, poor ventilation in homes and work places, and
to adjust their seemingly endless wants and desires for non-compliance with building bye-laws and regulations.
food, shelter, recreation, infrastructural facilities, and so
on (NEST, 1992). These land use activities contribute to i) Inadequate basic infrastructural amenities: Most of our
the overall development of the country but they equally urban centres lack essential basic amenities such as pipe
produce negative impact on the environment. These borne water, electricity, and road network. Where they
negative impacts are referred to as environmental are provided, these facilities are insufficient or do not
degeneration which implies “abuse of the environment” function due to neglect by relevant authorities.
due to improper resources management. Waste disposal is also a major problem in our urban
centres, especially in most slum areas and squatter
settlements. There are no planned disposal sites for
Causes of environmental degeneration refuse with a resultant indiscriminate refuse disposal on
any available sites.
The causes of these impacts includes; urbanization, ii) Substandard housing: Shelter which connotes housing
overpopulation, poverty and all kinds of pollution. These has a fundamental purpose of protecting man, his
impacts have both negative and positive effects on the activities and his possessions from humans, animals and
natural environment. It is the negative impacts of man‟s other enemies and from the supernatural powers that
interaction with the environment that are discussed as plague man. Osuide (2004) suggests that: “Having a safe
follows. place to live in is one of the fundamental elements of
human dignity and this enhances human development”.
i. Urbanization: Environmental conditions in cities have Substandard housing in urban centres is a major problem
gradually deteriorated due to the rapid growth of the cities of our cities. The problems resulted from the fact that
and the attendance inability of social services and they were never planned by experts but sprang from
Lanrewaju 425
growth both spatially and in population. The esta- wellbeing of the individual, the community and the nation
blishment of a railway station is perhaps the most at large.
important single factor in the growth of Oshogbo. Apart
from the railway, postal and telecommunication, NEPA
regional station, road network and some small as well as CASE STUDY 2: AKURE
large-scale business exist. Oshogbo thus became a
major trading and distribution centre for people within and The study area
outside its immediate environment.
In recent times, the location of Oshogbo as a state Akure is a traditional Nigeria city and like other traditional
capital coupled with other factors mentioned earlier has Yoruba towns in the country, it existed long before the
led to the influx of people from other towns and villages. advent of British colonial rule. The city is located within
Oshogbo exhibits both traditional as well as modern Ondo State in the South Western part of Nigeria. It lies
characteristics (Adenaike, 1991; Egunjobi, 1995). Its approximately on latitude 70. 2 North of the Equator and
current population is estimated to about 845,000 longitude 50. 2 East of the Greenwich Meridian. Akure is
(Wikipedia, 2010). a medium-sized urban centre and became the provincial
headquarter of Ondo province in 1939. It also became
the capital city of Ondo State and a Local Government
Physical characteristics of Oshogbo headquarters in 1976.
Akure is located approximately 700 km South West of
Oshogbo has a considerable variation in its physical Abuja, the Federal Capital of Nigeria. The population of
pattern and growth. The Oba‟s palace and the traditional the city grew from 144,544 in 1987 to 148,880 in 1988
market (Oja Oba) acts as a central focus (Ojo, 1966). and 153,347 in 1989 to 157,947 in 1990 (Ondo State of
This is surrounded by residential districts which form the Nigeria, 1990). The 1991 national population census
core of the city. This area comprises of buildings and however, put the population of Akure at 239,124 and its
development dated back to the pre-colonial period. Most estimated population in 2006 was 353,211 (NPC, 2006).
of the buildings and infrastructure in the interior part of At present the city is estimated to have over 387,087
Oshogbo are already very old and in need of people (Wikipedia).
rehabilitation.
Next to the core area is the intermediate zone. This Characteristics of the buildings in Akure
zone is made up of buildings and development which
existed from between 1935 and 1960. Most of the There are three neighbourhoods in the core area of
dwellings here are of the contemporary types. This zone Akure, namely Erekesan-Erekefa (A), Idiagba-Ijemikin
is followed by the periphery and the newly developed (B), and Obanla (C). Most buildings in these neigh-
area. The houses here are of better quality than those of bourhoods are in very poor state, as less than 5% of
other zones. them are in sound conditions (Olotuah, 2000b). The
It is however noted that development in Oshogbo is buildings require one form of repairs or the other to make
noticed as one moves from the interior towards the them physically sound (Table 1).
outskirts while most of the business districts are inter- The placement and layout of the buildings in the
woven with residential districts (Egunjobi, 1995). neighbourhoods are amorphous and disorganized. The
dominant house type in the areas is the rooming house
built on one or two stories. In most of the buildings the
Effect of urbanization on housing quality in Oshogbo few bathrooms and toilets are located completely outside,
often times at the back of the buildings. The buildings are
Despite the provision and availability of some basic characterized by overcrowding, with high proportions of
infrastructures like water, electricity, telecommunication people living in single rooms. Olotuah (2005) notes that
and road networks in Oshogbo, the level and condition of the average number of rooms occupied by a household in
these facilities are still very inadequate as a result of the Akure, the capital city of Ondo state, Nigeria is 1.29 while
rapid rate of urbanization and population growth wit- the average room occupancy (number of persons per
nessed in the town in recent times. room) is 4.42. The United Nations Standard for Nigeria
The quality of housing amenities and infrastructures is for room occupancy is 2.20; the World Health Organi-
generally poor and falls below the expected standard. zation (WHO, 1990) stipulates between 1.8 and 3.1, while
the Nigerian Government prescribed standard is 2.0 per
room (Okoko, 2001).
Possible solution to poor housing quality in Oshogbo
Significantly, adequate housing contributes not only to Urbanisation and housing quality in Akure
national development but also determines the health,
security, sanitation and socio-cultural and physical The rate of urbanisation in Akure outpaces the rate of
Lanrewaju 427
economic development. Despite the enormous amount of The community participation approach
money proposed for urban investment in the National
Development Plan very limited investment is made in her Hamdi (1995) describes community participation as “the
infrastructure (Olotua, 2005). An increasing shortage of process by which professional, families, community
urban services and infrastructure characterize Akure groups, government officials and others get together to
town, and these are only accessible to a diminishing work something out, preferably in a formal or informal
share of the population. The existing urban services are partnership”
overstrained which often times lead to total collapse. A It is increasingly being recognized that the top-down
large proportion of the population does not have approach to planning which assumes that communities
reasonable access to safe and ample water supply, and do not know their infrastructural needs, has been the
neither do they have the means for hygienic waste reason for the failure of many initiatives. The community
disposal (Olotuah, 2000). As argued elsewhere (Olotuah, participation approach believes that communities know
2002), the demand for urban services in Akure has grown their need and should be consulted and carried along in
over the years but the overall quality and coverage of the decision-making process.
public services have deteriorated.
Thus housing that will be properly rooted in the cultural, beauty, backed by a lively appreciation of the visual world
climatic, socio-economic circumstances of the people can by the people.
only emanate from within the communities.
a welcome development. Also, the availability of incine- Annual Review, World Health Organization (2005). “Annual Review of
Environment and Health in Africa” July 2004 - June 2005 WHO
rators, septic tanks and soak away pits and the use of
Geneva. pp.22-32.
water closets as contained in the Environmental Sanita- Aribigbola A (2000). Conceptual Issues in Housing Provision in Nigeria.
tion Programme instituted by the Federal Government in In: Akinbamijo OB, Fawechinmi AB, Ogunsemi DR and Olotuah A
1984 are good measures taken which is helping (ed). Effective Housing in the 21st Century Nigeria: Environmental
Forum FUTA, Nigeria.
tremendously to improve housing quality.
Doumani FM (2005). Environmental Health in Sub-Saharan Africa:
The Waste to Wealth (Recycling) programme of the Effective Interruptions (Draft): World Bank, Washington D.C.
Lagos State Governments is very commendable. Other Draft National Housing Policy (2004).
state governments and especially Local Government Draft National Urban Development Policy (2004).
Ebong MO (1983). The Perception of Residential Quality: A case study
Authorities in the country must join in eradicating from our of Calabar, Nigeria. Third World Planning Review, 5(3):273-284.
markets heaps of refuse which litter the environment. Egunjobi L (1995). Osogbo: Aspects of Urbanization, Physical Planning
and Development.
Eldredge HW (1967). Housing and Community in Taning Megalopolis
Vol. I. Anchor\Books edition.
Standards for housing are strictly adhered to
Hanmer L, Booth D, Lovell E (2000). Poverty and Transport, A Report
prepared for the World Bank in collaboration with DFID, Overseas
Standards for housing, which prescribes minimum Development Institute.
conditions under which a building, or part of it, may be Jiboye A (2004). An Assessment of the influence of Socio-cultural
lawfully occupied as a dwelling are strictly adhered to. factors on Housing quality in Osogbo, Nigeria, Unpublished M.Sc.
Thesis, Department of Urban and RegionalPlanning, Obafemi
Therefore, the need to respect laws regulating zoning, Awolowo University, Ile-Ife, Nigeria
setbacks and adequate ventilation is very vital. Cross- Jiboye A (2009). The Significance of Households‟ Characteristics on
ventilation which is one of the design considerations for Housing Quality in Nigeria, J. Geogr. Plann. Sci. (2):1-10.
buildings helps to reduce the high interior temperature, Jagun A (1983). “Urban Housing Need Estimate in Nigeria:
Governmental Capability in its Provision” J. Bus. Social Stud. 4(2).
achieve thermal comfort in buildings, and achieve a state
Mabogunje AL (1980). The Development Process: A Spatial
of dryness in the rooms. Perspective 2nd Ed; London: Unwind Harman Ltd, pp.189-193, 217-
218.
Neilson M (2004): Scottish housing quality Standard (SHQS), Scottish
CONCLUSION AND RECOMMENDATION Executive Development Department.
NPC (2006). National Population Commission, Official Gazette. Abuja,
Nigeria.
This paper discusses the incidence of poor housing Ojo GJA (1966). The layout and morphology of Yoruba Town. p.131. In:
quality in Nigeria and the negative effects emanating from Yoruba Culture. University of Ife and London University Press.
it. It notes the occurrence of rapid rate of urbanisation Okoko E (2001). Residential Crowding and Privacy in High-Density
Neighborhoods in Akure, Nigeria. Ife Social Sci. Rev. 19(1):133-144
occurring in the country, the consequences of which have Olotuah AO (2000b). Housing Poverty in Three Inner-city
been severely degenerated urban environment. It reports Neighbourhoods, Akure; Paper Presented at Shelter Africa 2000-
the poor housing conditions in the urban cities of Nigeria Fourth International Conference on Housing, Nicon Hilton Hotel, and
especially at the core areas of Akure and Oshogbo the Abuja, Nigeria 2-6 October
Olotuah AO (2002). An Appraisal of the Impact of Urban Services on
capital city of Ondo and Osun state respectively. Housing in Akure Metropolis. J. Sci. Eng. Technol. 9(4)4570-4582
This paper also proffers recommendations to improve Olotuah AO (2005). Urbanization, Urban Poverty, and Housing
them and reduce environmental degeneration. It is my Inadequacy; Proceedings of Africa Union of Architects Congress, 23-
belief that if these recommendations are implemented 28 May, Abuja, Nigeria pp.185-199.
Olayiwola LM, Adeleye A, Jiboye AD (2006). “Effect of Socio-cultural
that our cities will grow in an environmentally harmonious
factors on Housing quality in Osogbo, Nigeria”. International
way. Further unplanned growth and decay would be Symposium on Construction in Developing Economies: New issues
checked and prevented. These measures would prevent and challenges. Santiago, Chile. January, 18-29.
poor housing quality, save our built environment and Onibokun AG (1972). Nigeria: Strategies for Urban Redevelopment. In:
Journal of the Royal Town Planning Institute 58(2).
improve the life expectancy of the average Nigerian.
Osuide SO, Dimuna KO (2005). Effects of Population Growth on
Urbanization and the Environment in Nigeria. pp. 27-33. In:
Proceeding of year 2000 National Seminar on Population, Growth,
REFRENCES Architecture and the Environment. Osuide SO (Ed.). Rasjel
Publishers.
Afon A (2000). Use of Residents Environment Quality Indicator (EQI) Osuide SO (2004). Strategies for Affordable Housing Stocks Delivery in
Data in a residential Housing improvement, In Effective Housing in Nigeria. 18th Inaugural Lecture ofAmbrose Alli University, Floreat
the 21st century, Nigeria. The Environmental Forum, F.U.T.A pp.115- System Benin-City pp.2-20
122. Wahab K, Adedokun LA, Onibokun AG (1990). “Urban Housing
Agbola T (1998). The Housing of Nigerians; A Review of policy Conditions” Urban Housing in Nigeria, Onibokun AG (Ed.), Ibadan:
Development and Implementation. Research Report 14, Nigerian Institute of Social and Economic Research.
Development Policy Centre, Ibadan, Nigeria. World Health Organization (1990). The Impact of Development Policies
Akinola SR (1998). “The Pattern of Housing Quality in Osogbo, Osun on Health. pp. 21-40. In: A Review of the Life Nature. Dianna A and
State”. Ife J. Environ. Design Manag. pp.109-120. Cooper D (Eds.). WHO, Geneva.
Anantharajan T (1983). Evaluation of Residential Development through
User‟s Rating and Ranking of Environmental Attributes. Proceedings
of the IAHS Congress on Housing NW 7–12 Miami Florida Ural ED.
(ed.) pp.73-84.