Design of Partially or Fully Composite Beams, With Ribbed Metal Deck, Using LRFD Specifications
Design of Partially or Fully Composite Beams, With Ribbed Metal Deck, Using LRFD Specifications
Design of Partially or Fully Composite Beams, With Ribbed Metal Deck, Using LRFD Specifications
A Hindu saying states, "One picture is worth a thousand The Load and Resistance Factor Design Specification
(LRFD) for Structural Steel Buildings1 adopted by AISC in
words (numbers)." With this optic in mind, the design aspects
September 1986 uses the ultimate strength of composite
of steel-concrete composite beams using the recently adopted
beams as the basis of their design. According to LRFD,
LRFD specifications1 are analyzed critically and the
composite beam designs are classified as fully composite and
significance of several parameters is brought out clearly.
partially composite designs.2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10 The present report on
Charts are then constructed to facilitate the design of
the design of partially composite beam design is a
partially or fully composite beams using rolled-steel, wide-
generalization of the work presented earlier in Ref. 11.
flange sections of A36 steel or A572 Gr. 50 steel. The slab
may be a composite metal deck slab with ribs perpendicular
to the beam, a haunched slab or, simply, a flat soffit concrete COMPOSITE METAL DECK SLABS
slab. The charts cover both adequate and inadequate slabs. Composite metal deck slabs consist of light-gage, ribbed
The charts provided are a valuable tool from the practical metal deck forms which interact with structural concrete
standpoint, and also familiarity with them should contribute topping as a composite unit to resist floor loads (Fig. 2).
to the student's and young engineer's overall feel of the Special embossments, dimples or lugs cold-rolled into the
composite beam design problem. The design charts given decking increase bond and act as shear connectors. Uplift is
here complement the composite beam design tables provided prevented either by the shape of the profile or by inclining
in the LRFD manual. the lugs to the vertical in opposite directions, on the two sides
of the rib. It is usual practice to design the slab as a one-way,
Introduction simply supported beam, for the ultimate limit state (with the
metal decking acting as reinforcement steel in the span
A typical bay floor framing of a high-rise building consists of direction), even though the slab and the decking may be
steel floor beams framing into steel girders along bay lines continuous over the floor beams. The slab is usually provided
(Fig. 1). The floor beams generally are designed for only with square mesh steel reinforcement at, or above, mid depth
gravity loads imposed by the floor as simply supported of the slab to minimize cracking due to shrinkage and
composite beams with the slab essentially in compression temperature effects and to help distribute concentrated loads.
over the full span of the beam. The beam normally is of a The variables for a composite deck slab include span
standard rolled, wide-flange shape designed to interact length, gage thickness, rib depth, slab thickness, unit weight
compositely with the concrete floor slab by means of shear of concrete and concrete strength.12,13,14 Thickness of metal
studs placed in metal decking troughs. In such a metal deck deck plate elements usually varies from 22 ga. (0.0336 in.) to
composite beam system, the ribs or corrugations generally 12 ga. (0.1084 in.), depending on configuration of the
run perpendicular to the supporting floor beams. section. For noncellular decks 1½ in., 2 in. and 3 in. deep
decks are generally used for spans up to 8 ft, 10 ft and 15 ft,
Sriramulu Vinnakota is a Professor of Civil Engineering, Marquette
respectively. The thickness of concrete above the metal deck
University, Milwaukee, Wisconsin. typically varies from a minimum of 2½ in. to 4 in., which
Christopher M. Foley is a Graduate Student, Marquette University, may be controlled by fire-rating requirements of the slab
Milwaukee, Wisconsin. instead of structural requirements. The choice of lightweight
Murthy R. Vinnakota is a Consulting Structural Engineer, Aurora, concrete or normal weight concrete, depends on economics
Colorado. and fire-rating considerations. For high-rise buildings, light-
© 2003 by American Institute of Steel Construction, Inc. All rights reserved. This publication or any part thereof must not be reproduced in any form without the written permission of the publisher.
further loading will be carried by the lightly loaded inner exploded diagrammatic elevation of the composite beam
connectors until eventually all the connectors are stressed to showing the longitudinal forces acting on the concrete slab,
the yield point. Thus the connector flexibility permits a between the mid-span and the end of the slab, as a free body
redistribution of forces so all the connectors between the separated from the steel beam. Let C equal the compressive
points of maximum and zero bending moments become force in the slab at mid-span, T equals the tensile force in the
loaded equally. Therefore, it follows the exact spacing of the steel beam and H equals the horizontal shear force to be
connectors is of little importance. In statically loaded transferred from the slab to the steel section over the length
structures, like the ones under consideration in the present L/2. From the longitudinal equilibrium of the slab,
paper, the connectors may therefore be spaced equally along
the length of the beam. H=C (4)
The minimum spacing of connectors along the length of
the beam in flat soffit concrete slabs is six diameters. When As natural bond and friction between the slab and the steel
the ribs of the metal deck are perpendicular to the beam, the section are not relied upon, the horizontal shear resistance is
longitudinal spacing of shear connectors must of course be to be provided by the shear strength of the connectors over
compatible with the pitch of the ribs. Also, since most test the length L/2.
data are based on the minimum transverse spacing of four Let C* represent the maximum compressive strength of
diameters, this transverse spacing was set as the minimum the concrete slab, T* the maximum tensile strength of the
permitted. To control uplift and to avoid too irregular a flow steel section and S the shear strength of the connectors
of shear into the concrete, limits are placed on the maximum between the point of maximum moment and the support point.
spacing of connectors along a beam. According to the LRFD Then,
Specification, the maximum longitudinal spacing of shear
connectors shall not exceed 32 in. or eight times the total C* = Fc Ac = 0.85 f c' btc (5a)
slab thickness. T* = Fy As (5b)
S = N Qnr (5c)
FULLY COMPOSITE AND PARTIALLY where
COMPOSITE BEAMS
Ac = area of slab based on the actual slab thickness tc,
Figure 3a shows a simple-span composite beam with in.2
uniformly distributed load. If the magnitude of these loads is As = area of steel section, in.2
increased monotanically, the ultimate bending moment of the b = effective width of the slab, in.
composite beam is reached at mid-span. Figure 3b is an Fc = equivalent yield stress of concrete in compression,
assumed to be equal to 0.85 f c' , ksi
Fy = yield stress of steel, ksi
f c' = compressive strength (28-day cylinder strength) of
concrete, ksi
N = number of connectors over half-span length
Qnr = shear capacity of one connector, kips
The slab is said to be adequate when C* ≥ T* and inadequate
when C* ≤ T*. According to the LRFD Manual, the
compressive force C in the concrete slab is the smallest of
C*, T* and S. That is,
C = min [C*, T*, S] (6)
Introduce the notations S*, N* so that
S* = min [C*, T*] (7)
N* = S*/Qnr (8)
Equation 6 can now be rewritten as
C = min [S*, S] (9)
If the strength of the shear connectors actually provided S is
less than S*, the beam is said to be a "partially composite
Fig. 3. Shear forces at ultimate moment beam." On the other hand, if the strength of the shear
SECONDQUARTER / 1988 63
© 2003 by American Institute of Steel Construction, Inc. All rights reserved. This publication or any part thereof must not be reproduced in any form without the written permission of the publisher.
connectors actually provided S is greater than or equal to S*, considered in this report, hc is a maximum when the concrete
the beam is said to be a "fully composite beam." Thus, is poured and the composite action is not yet effective. For
positive bending, rolled steel sections and simple beams
S < S* and N < N* for partially composite design
considered in this report, hc max is therefore equal to the web
S > S* and N > N* for fully composite design (10)
depth clear of fillets (= d – 2k). For steels with Fy = 36 ksi
A composite beam in which the concrete, steel and and 50 ksi, to which the present report is limited, all the
connectors are all of the same strength is said to be of a rolled sections tabulated in the LRFD Manual satisfy the
balanced design. Thus, for a balanced design, criteria given by Eq. 13. So the design of composite beams
C = C* = T* = S* = S (11) considered could be based on the plastic moment Mn. This
plastic moment is obtained by assuming the steel section is
The thickness of the slab and the size of the steel beam are fully yielded (in tension or compression) and the compressed
often determined, in practice, from factors other than their part of the concrete slab is everywhere stressed to 0.85 f c' ,
strength when acting together as a composite beam; and its
considered as an "equivalent yield stress for concrete." The
strength, when calculated by full interaction theory, is found
tensile part of the concrete slab, if any, is assumed
to be greater than required for actual loading. The most
ineffective.
economical design may then be one in which the number of
The equations for the plastic moment of a composite
shear connectors provided in a half-span N is such the degree
beam depend on the location of the plastic neutral axis
of interaction between the slab and the steel section is just
(PNA), which in turn is determined by the relative
sufficient to provide the required flexural strength, and is less
proportions of the steel concrete and connector areas.1,16,17
than the number N* required for a fully composite design.
There are three fully plastic stress distributions to be
Some such situations for use of partial composite action are:
considered:
1. An oversized steel beam must be selected from the
Case a: applies when the plastic neutral axis is in the slab
available rolled beam sizes for architectural reasons or
Case b: applies when the plastic neutral axis is in the flange
ease of fabrication (repeatability) or when deflection
of steel section
controls and strength requirements are adequately met by
Case c: applies when the plastic neutral axis is in the web of
less than fully composite action.
steel section
2. When the ribs of the metal deck are perpendicular to the
beam, the longitudinal spacing of shear connectors must The assumed stress distributions are shown in Figs. 4, 5
be compatible with the pitch of the ribs. Quite often it and 6, respectively. The compression force C in the concrete
may not be possible to fit in sufficient number of shear slab, in these figures, is defined by Eq. 6. The depth of the
connectors, for the beam to be designed as a fully compressive stress block in the slab is given by
composite beam. C C
a= = (14)
Decreasing the number of connectors for partial composite Fc b 085 f c' b
action reduces the effective stiffness of the composite beam
slightly, so deflections may increase. The LRFD Manual Let Yc be the distance from the top of the steel beam to top of
recommends a lower limit for the connector strength S from concrete and Y2 the distance from top of steel beam to the
practical considerations; namely compression force C in concrete. Then,
Smin = 0.25 T* = 0.25 As Fy (12) Yc = hr + tc for a metal deck slab
= hh + t for a haunched slab (15a)
=t for a flat soffit slab
NOMINAL PLASTIC MOMENT OF a
Y2 = Yc – (15b)
COMPOSITE SECTIONS 2
where
According to the LRFD Specification, the moment capacity is
approximated by the plastic moment of the composite section hr = height of rib, in.
Mn, provided web dimensions satisfy local buckling criteria: hh = height of haunch, in.
hc tw ≤ 640 Fy (13) t = thickness of a flat soffit slab, in.
tc = thickness of concrete slab above metal deck, in.
Here, tw is the thickness of the web and hc the web depth for
stability. From Sect. B5.1 of the LRFD, hc is twice the The dimension Y2 is used as a parameter in the
distance from the neutral axis to the inside face of the preparation of composite beam tables in the LRFD Manual
compression flange less the fillet. For simple beams and in the preparation of composite beam design charts
developed in this paper. The plastic moment of the composite section is obtained by
taking moments about the mid-depth of the steel section as
Plastic Neutral Axis in Slab-Case a
d
Mn = C e = T e = T * = Y2
When the PNA lies in the slab, the assumed stress 2
distribution at flexural failure is shown in Fig. 4. The = 05
. T* d + T* Y2 (19)
resultant compressive force in the slab is
where e is the moment arm, d is the depth of the steel section
C = Fc ba = 0.85 f c' ba (16) and Y2 is the parameter defined by Eq. 15b.
The PNA will be in the concrete, if
and it acts at a distance a/2 from the top of the slab. The
resultant tensile force in the section is a ≤ tc (20)
section, and the connectors have to develop the full strength while the modified compressive force in the steel section is
of the steel section. The beam is therefore a fully composite
Csm = 2 Fy Acs (23)
beam, and the slab is adequate.
where Acs is the area of steel section at yield in compression.
For longitudinal equilibrium,
Plastic Neutral Axis in Flange-Case b
Tm = C + Csm (24)
If the PNA is in the steel section, it yields in compression
above the PNA and fully yields in tension below the PNA, as which, using Eqs. 22 and 23, can be written as
in Figs. 5a and b. Here C is the compressive stress resultant
T* = C + 2 Fy Acs (25)
in concrete, Cs is the compressive stress resultant in the top
flange and T is the tensile stress resultant in the steel section. resulting in
Although only the steel section below the PNA is in Csm = [T* – C] (26)
tension at yield stress, a simpler expression for the plastic and
moment Mn results by assuming that (by adding a pair of 1
Acs = [T * − C] (27)
equal and opposite forces) the entire steel section is in 2Fy
tension and compensate for this by doubling the compressive
Then, denoting by y, the distance from the top of the steel
yield stress in steel section above the PNA, as in Fig. 5c. The
flange to the PNA,
modified tensile force in the steel beam is
(T* − C)
[T* − C] =
A 1
y = cs = tf (28)
Tm = FyAs = T* (22) bf 2 bf Fy 2 Pyf
© 2003 by American Institute of Steel Construction, Inc. All rights reserved. This publication or any part thereof must not be reproduced in any form without the written permission of the publisher.
where bf and tf are the width and thickness of the steel flange, yo
M n = C e + M p − Tsm
respectively, and Pyf is the flange yield force. Therefore, for 2
the moment arm, d C
= C + Y2 + M p − C (d − 2 t f )
d y 1 (T* − C) 2 4 Pyw
em = − = d − tf (29)
2 2 2 2 Pyf C2
= CY2 + M p + 05
. Cd − 2
M pw (34)
Pyw
Taking moments about the mid-depth of the steel section,
1
M n = Ce + Csm em where M pw = (d − 2t f ) 2 t w Fy is the web plastic moment.
4
1 (T* − C) The PNA will remain in the web for 0 ≤ yo < (d – 2 tf)/2.
= Ce + (T* − C) d − tf
2 2 Pyf Equation 33 shows this condition is equivalent to 0 ≤ C <
Pyw.
d 1 (T* − C) Again, if S < S*, the beam is a partially composite beam
= C + Y2 + (T* − C) d − tf (30)
2 2 2 Pyf and the depth of the concrete compressive stress block a is
less than the slab thickness tc. On the other hand, if S ≥ S*,
The PNA will remain in the flange if 0 ≤ y ≤ tf. From Eq. 28, the beam is a fully composite beam and the entire slab
these limits are seen to be C = T* and C = T* – 2 Pyf = Pyw thickness tc is in compression. The results of Sects. 5 and 6
where Pyw is the web yield force. Thus, when Pyw ≤ C ≤ T*, are summarized in Tables 1 and 2, and permit classification
the PNA will be in the top flange. In addition, if S < S*, the as a composite beam based on the relative strength of its
beam is a partially composite beam and the depth of the elements.
concrete compressive stress block a is less than the slab
thickness tc. On the other hand, if S ≥ S*, the beam is a fully DESIGN MOMENTS OF COMPOSITE BEAMS
composite beam and the entire slab is in compression. In the Load and Resistance Factor Design Approach, design
moments Md are obtained from nominal moments Mn by
multiplying them with a resistance factor φc, which is
Plastic Neutral Axis in Web-Case c specified as 0.85 for composite beams. Thus,
Md = φc Mn (35)
Figure 6b shows the plastic stress distribution where the
resulting in the following relations (however, note the order
PNA is in the web at a distance yo above the mid-depth of the
of the three cases is reversed for the convenience of
steel beam. This distribution can also be represented by three
construction of design charts):
equivalent parts, as in Figs. 6d, e and f. It can be seen that
the part in Fig. 6d represents the compressive force C in the Case c: Plastic Neutral Axis in Web (Fig. 6)
concrete, acting at a distance e from the mid-depth of the From Eqs. 34 and 35, write
steel section. The part in Fig. 6e represents the tension and
Mdl = (φcY2 ) C
compressive forces with zero stress resultant and a moment
resultant equal to the plastic moment Mp of the steel section. φc M pw
And the part in Fig. 6f represents a tensile force in the web,
( )
+ φc M p + (0.5φc d ) C − 2 C2
Pyw
Tsm = 2 Fy tw yo (31)
= AoC + [ A11 + A12 C − A13C 2 ] (36)
with its resultant at a distance yo/2 from the mid-depth of the
steel section. The longitudinal equilibrium of horizontal where Ao is a constant for an assumed value of the parameter
forces gives Y2, while A11, A12 and A13 are, for a given section and steel,
also constants. Eq. 36 is valid for 0 ≤ C < Pyw.
C = Tsm = 2 Fy tw yo (32)
Case b: Plastic Neutral Axis in Flange (Fig. 5)
The distance of the PNA from the mid-depth of the steel From Eqs. 30 and 35,
section is T*
M d 2 = (φc Y2 ) C + 05. φc T * d − t f
C C( d − 2t f ) C 2Pyf
yo = = = (d − 2 ty ) (33)
2 Fy tw 2tw ( d − 2t f )Fy 2 Pyw
2
φc t f
+ φc 2TP* t f C − C
where (d – 2 tf) is the height of the web and Pyw is the web yf 4 Pyf
yield force.
The plastic moment of the composite beam is next = Ao C + [ A21 + A22 C − A23C 2 ] (37)
obtained by taking moments about the mid-depth of the steel where A21, A22 and A23 are another set of constants for a
section as selected steel section and Ao is as defined in Eq. 36.
S > S* S = S* S < S*
1. Fully composite 1. Fully composite 1. Partially composite
I. C* < T* 2. Inadequate slab 2. Inadequate slab 2. Inadequate slab
3. PNA in steel 3. PNA in steel 3. PNA in steel
4. Use charts PFS, Ref. 11 4. Use charts PFS, Ref. 11 4. Use charts PFS or LRFD
or LRFD or LRFD
I C* < T*
C* < T* < S
C* < S < T* S = C* < T S < C* < T
II C* = T*
C* = T* < S S = C* = T* S < C* = T*
III C* > T*
T* < C*< S
S = T* < C* S < T* < C*
T* < S < C*
© 2003 by American Institute of Steel Construction, Inc. All rights reserved. This publication or any part thereof must not be reproduced in any form without the written permission of the publisher.
procedure is explained here with the help of Fig. 7, an minimum value Smin recommended by the LRFD
excerpt from the design chart PFS-4.) Plot the point A Manual and preferably should not be considered for
corresponding to the value Md = Mr on the Y axis. Also locate design as a composite beam.
the point B corresponding to the value C* on the abscissa. b. If a point of intersection Pi is to the right of the point
Next, estimate a value ao for the depth of the B , the corresponding section and sections below it
compressive stress block a (between 0 and tc/2) and, hence, are not candidates for design as they violate the
an estimate Y20 for the parameter Y2 = hr + tc – a/2. In the condition c = min (C*, T*, S).
bottom part of the chart (Fig. 7) locate the line c. If a point of intersection Pi coincides with the solid
circle on a curve and if, in addition, the abscissae of
corresponding to the particular value of Y2 = Y2o , by
Pi and B are same, then the corresponding design
interpolation if necessary. Through the point A draw a results in a balanced design as we have C = C* = T*
straight line parallel to the straight line . Let P1, P2, ... = S* = S.
Pi, ... be the points of intersection of line with different d. If the point of intersection Pi is at or to the left of the
curves shown in Fig. 7. We observe that the vertical intercept solid circle on a curve, then that section results in a
between any one of these points and the diagonal line is partially composite design. The corresponding beam
equal to MdY + Mdo = Md = Mr. So, all the points Pi are is heavier than the one corresponding to the balanced
possible candidates for the design, subjected to the following design, while the shear connectors required are
comments and restrictions: fewer.
e. If a point of intersection Pi is at or to the right of the
a. If the line intersects a curve to the left of the solid solid circle on a curve the corresponding design
square on that curve, the shear connector capacity C possibly results in a fully composite beam with the
= S using the corresponding section is less than the PNA
© 2003 by American Institute of Steel Construction, Inc. All rights reserved. This publication or any part thereof must not be reproduced in any form without the written permission of the publisher.
ions corresponding to the curves intersected by the line , included either in the above table. However, if the designer
provided the actual Y2 value equals the assumed value of Y20 intends to use one of these lighter sections, he should use
= 6.5, deliver the required moment of 1050 ft kips. The charts FC for fully composite beams (see next example).
abscissae corresponding to these points of intersection, give For the last two sections of Table 3, al = 1.99 ≈ ao
the value C for the compressive force in the concrete. indicating the value of Y2o = 6.5 in. used in constructing line
Note that as line intersects the curve for W27×84 to is correct. So they satisfy the strength design requirements.
the left of the solid square, that section is not included in Of these two, select the deeper and lighter W24×55 section
Table 3. Also, line intersects the curves for W21×57 and with C = 810 kips.
lighter sections to the right of the solid circle, so they are not If the designer intends to use even fewer shear connectors
(smaller C), the first three sections could be reconsidered
Table 3 with revised values for a and Y2 and repeat the procedure
al =
C followed earlier.
C 0.85 f c' b
T*
W24 × 76 317 0.78 1,120 Horizontal shear force to be transferred from the concrete
W24 × 68 472 1.16 1,005 slab to the metal beam is
W24 × 62 627 1.54 910
W21 × 62 810 1.99 914 S = H = C = 810 kips
W24 × 55 810 1.99 810 Select ¾-in. dia. headed studs.