This document provides guidance on using theme analysis to teach English language learners critical thinking skills. It discusses selecting quotes at varying levels of difficulty and walking students through a process of paraphrasing, reviewing literary elements, and identifying themes. For lower-level students, quotes should be shorter and simpler, while higher-level students can handle longer quotes and a less structured approach. Examples of quotes used are provided, along with tips for finding suitable quotes from various sources. Teachers should choose quotes relevant to students and at an appropriate difficulty level to both challenge and engage them.
This document provides guidance on using theme analysis to teach English language learners critical thinking skills. It discusses selecting quotes at varying levels of difficulty and walking students through a process of paraphrasing, reviewing literary elements, and identifying themes. For lower-level students, quotes should be shorter and simpler, while higher-level students can handle longer quotes and a less structured approach. Examples of quotes used are provided, along with tips for finding suitable quotes from various sources. Teachers should choose quotes relevant to students and at an appropriate difficulty level to both challenge and engage them.
This document provides guidance on using theme analysis to teach English language learners critical thinking skills. It discusses selecting quotes at varying levels of difficulty and walking students through a process of paraphrasing, reviewing literary elements, and identifying themes. For lower-level students, quotes should be shorter and simpler, while higher-level students can handle longer quotes and a less structured approach. Examples of quotes used are provided, along with tips for finding suitable quotes from various sources. Teachers should choose quotes relevant to students and at an appropriate difficulty level to both challenge and engage them.
This document provides guidance on using theme analysis to teach English language learners critical thinking skills. It discusses selecting quotes at varying levels of difficulty and walking students through a process of paraphrasing, reviewing literary elements, and identifying themes. For lower-level students, quotes should be shorter and simpler, while higher-level students can handle longer quotes and a less structured approach. Examples of quotes used are provided, along with tips for finding suitable quotes from various sources. Teachers should choose quotes relevant to students and at an appropriate difficulty level to both challenge and engage them.
Theme analysis requires students to examine low-level students, quotes should be
information and isolate patterns—or shorter and/or simpler, and themes may be themes—to determine meaning. Analyzing limited. Here is a quote from John Muir, themes from written material helps English a conservationist, writer, and activist, that language learners practice and demonstrate may be suitable for students at the low or higher-level critical-thinking skills. I find intermediate level: that students crave participating in engaging group activities and want to discuss personally “When we try to pick out anything meaningful topics, like interpersonal by itself, we find it hitched to relationships, social and cultural issues, and everything else in the universe.” current events that affect them. Students need to understand the concept One of my goals is to provide memorable, of “universe” and vocabulary like hitched to relevant activities—like this theme-analysis analyze the quote effectively. As teachers, task—that motivate students and encourage we want to encourage students to learn new them to look at the world from new vantage words and stretch their English-language points. As an English Language Fellow at boundaries. Teachers should select quotes Hebron University in the West Bank, I have that build on the existing knowledge of used this activity with students who are students and challenge them with new generally 18 to 20 years old. Their English concepts. Themes that could emerge from proficiency level is low to midrange; however, an analysis of this quote include community, the activity can be used with students at all interconnectedness, and even faith. Again, levels. Websites that list quotes vary widely. SELECTING QUOTES Typical online searches can yield results Finding suitable quotes for students to for general and specific quotes. For analyze in this activity is an easy task for example, search “quotes from children’s both teachers and students, as there are literature” or “inspirational quotes” for a hundreds of websites dedicated to the variety of quotes to use for this activity; collection of quotations. Teachers can select you can also search for quotes from the quotes based on current or past class movies, quotes by a specific person, or objectives and topics; choose quotes from quotes about a topic that is relevant and various authors, personal heroes, religious of interest to your students. figures, philosophers, or politicians; and Textbooks, journal articles, videos, use quotes from English songs or movies. and other classroom materials are also Teachers can also involve the students in sources of quotes. From time to time, the quote-selection process. Figure 1 suggests popular magazines and online journals tips for finding quotes. provide top quotes. Additionally, social- media sites are sources of quotes to use In selecting quotes for the activity, teachers for theme analysis. must consider students’ vocabulary, comprehension level, and interest. For Figure 1. Tips for finding quotes
americanenglish.state.gov/english-teaching-forum 2019 ENGLISH TEACHING FORUM 35
With high-level students, a less-structured approach is favorable. Because student comprehension levels are higher, the step- by-step approach may not be needed. Using When we try to pick a simple “Who, What, When, Why, Where?” out anything by itself, approach may be enough. Students can use this approach to gain insight into the quote we find it hitched to and the intended meaning of the author by answering the Wh– questions. High-level everything else in the students can also articulate sophisticated universe. concepts by identifying, selecting, and defending their ideas and perspectives about the quotes, based on their own experience and ideas about the relevant themes.
I have used the following quote from Henry
David Thoreau in the theme-analysis activity: these ideas should not be too far outside the scope of the students’ language capacity. “I went to the woods because I wished to live deliberately, to front THEME-ANALYSIS PROCESS only the essential facts of life, and see if I could not learn what it had Although there are many ways to analyze a to teach, and not, when I came to quote, the “paraphrase, review, and evaluate” die, discover that I had not lived.” approach is useful. In low-level classrooms, students first try to understand the quote and I selected the quote because it focuses on paraphrase it in their own words. Paraphrasing objectives identified in the comparative allows the student to identify main ideas of literature course with which I was working. the quote and demonstrate understanding of Because students were puzzled by the meaning the context. Once a student has completed of front as used in this quote, they used their the paraphrasing step, the teacher can provide dictionaries to bring meaning to the word feedback and ask critical-thinking questions, in the context of the quote. Throughout which can guide the student toward deeper the activity, I provided feedback by asking understanding. students their ideas and gently guiding them. After the individual process was complete, I Next, students can review the quote and answered questions and helped student groups note the tone, mood, diction, and figurative through an analysis process, where all students language. By exploring the literary elements shared their ideas. Once the analysis was of the quote, students begin to understand complete, students determined that the theme the meaning of the quote from the author’s of the quote was “living life fully.” perspective. Again, the teacher can provide input to ensure that the student analysis is on Another quote I have used is the following, track. from Mark Victor Hansen, a motivational speaker and author: Finally, students evaluate the quote and identify the author’s intended message to the “Don’t wait until everything is reader. In this stage, students can provide a just right. It will never be perfect. written summary of the quote, identifying key There will always be challenges, messages. The teacher again plays a supporting obstacles and less than perfect role in the process, providing feedback and conditions. So what. Get started assisting students in the theme analysis. now. With each step you take,
36 ENGLISH TEACHING FORUM 2 01 9 americanenglish.state.gov/english-teaching-forum
you will grow stronger and INSTRUCTIONS stronger, more and more skilled, more and more self- 1. Find five or more quotes. Select them confident and more and more based on the English proficiency level successful.” of the students, course objectives, and topics of interest. Quotes should I found this quote through an Internet search include some vocabulary that students and selected it based on a teaching goal to are not familiar with. inspire students to overcome challenges. Students used the “paraphrase, review, and 2 . Write or type the quotes on slips of evaluate” approach to analyze the quote, first paper. Make enough copies so each individually and then collectively. They used student will have his or her own copy of their dictionaries to review the words obstacles the quote. For instance, if you have and self-confident. I provided feedback, and 25 students and you are using five after the group discussion, students decided quotes, make five copies of each quote. that the overarching theme for this quote was “[free] will.” 3 . Randomly hand out a quote to each student, distributing the quotes so that Other themes that emerged from the roughly an equal number of students are quote-analysis activity were freedom, assigned to each quote. love, friendship, and [positive] attitude. The activity was a fun way for students to 4 . Give students about five minutes use their conversation skills, in a group to read the quote, work through an setting, to discuss the thoughts of literary analysis process, and use the dictionary figures, religious leaders, and political to look up words with which they are leaders. Students also used reading, writing, unfamiliar. The initial review of the collaborative, and critical-thinking skills. quote should be an individual activity During the activity, they worked alone and for students. in groups. They reported that the activity provided them with a new outlet for 5 . Provide feedback to students about reviewing written material and literature, their understanding of the quotes and and they mentioned that the activity could guide them by asking critical-thinking be used in various academic and personal questions such as, “What message do contexts, such as song-lyric analysis. you think the person was trying to convey?”; “What did this quote make PREPARATION you think of when you first read it?”; and “When you read the quote, how do The activity requires minimal supplies you feel, and why do you feel that way?” and technology. Supplies include quotes, handwritten or typed on slips of paper, 6 . Ask students to individually write the on a range of topics aligned with class definitions of new vocabulary and the objectives. It is also helpful to have meaning of the quote in their own dictionaries, pens, paper, and, of course, words. interested students. The quotes should include both familiar and unfamiliar 7. Group students according to the quotes. vocabulary; including a range of vocabulary There should be five (or more) groups, words encourages students to use their and each student in the group should dictionaries and learn new vocabulary. have reviewed the same quote. A goal of the activity should be to increase student comprehension of the theme-analysis 8 . Give students about ten minutes to process and content of the quotes. discuss their personal understanding
americanenglish.state.gov/english-teaching-forum 2019 ENGLISH TEACHING FORUM 37
of the quote with group members. Students should also discuss the meaning of vocabulary that is new to them. There will always be 9 . Ask students to work as a group to challenges, obstacles write their understanding of the quote and determine a theme for and less than perfect the quote. conditions. So what. 1 0 . Ask each group to present its findings Get started now. to the class by reading the quote, identifying one new vocabulary word, and suggesting a theme for the quote.
1 1 . While each group is presenting, the
other students should summarize The activity can be repeated with additional the presentations by writing down quotes from different authors, genres, time a few brief sentences or ideas. This periods, or themes. It can be reflective, based helps all students stay focused during on content covered in previous lessons, or the activity and get the benefit of it can be forward-focused, introducing new the lesson. topics and objectives.
REFLECTION In addition to improving group skills,
this activity can strengthen conversation, Quote analysis is a worthwhile and enjoyable dictionary-use, reading, writing, and critical- stand-alone activity; it can also be a starting thinking skills, and it encourages students to point for other activities. For example, think and learn in an innovative way. after the initial quote analysis, the teacher can ask students to do any or all of the following: Cecilia Gregg earned her doctorate degree in Education from University of Phoenix. Cecilia has • Write a dialogue about a theme identified also studied business, psychology, and TEFL. She in the initial quotes. enjoys living in the West Bank, and prior to her work as an English Language Fellow, Cecilia served in the • Create skits using the themes identified in U.S. Peace Corps in Chongqing, China, and taught at the initial quotes. Arizona State University and University of Phoenix.
• Recall vocabulary from each presentation.
• Research the context or authors of the
quotes.
• Create a visual representation of a quote.
• Write a new, meaningful quote with a
theme of their choice.
• Analyze the group process, considering the
stages of working in a team setting.
38 ENGLISH TEACHING FORUM 2 01 9 americanenglish.state.gov/english-teaching-forum
Adrienne Gear - Powerful Understanding - Helping Students Explore, Question, and Transform Their Thinking About Themselves and The World Around Them-Pembroke Publishers, Limited (2018)