MGB Resource Validation Report - JDVC
MGB Resource Validation Report - JDVC
MGB Resource Validation Report - JDVC
July 2018
Resource Validation Report of JDVC’s Offshore Magnetite Proj. under MPSA No. 338-2010-II-OMR, Cagayan Province
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Page No.
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
LIST OF FIGURES
Page No.
Figure 7: Sea bottom topography and submarine features of Babuyan Channel …….. 16
Figure 8A: Tenement Map Showing Political Boundaries …….. 19
Figure 8b: Tenement Map Showing claim Boundaries …….. 20
Figure 9: Pre-determined Track lines Along the Eastern Segment of the JDVCRC …….. 24
Figure 10: Schematic Representation of Seismic Reflection and Bathymetric …….. 25
Surveys
Figure 11: Location of Actual Traverse lines Within the Eastern Segment of the …….. 26
JDVCRC Tenement
Figure 15: Color-filled Contour Map and 3-D Illustration of the Seabed of the …….. 30
JDVCRC Tenement Area
ii
Resource Validation Report of JDVC’s Offshore Magnetite Proj. under MPSA No. 338-2010-II-OMR, Cagayan Province
Figure 16: Color-filled Contour Map Showing the Various Thicknesses of …….. 33
Identified Sand-bearing Horizons Consisting of Seismo- stratigraphic
Units 1, 2 and 3.
LIST OF TABLES
Page No.
ANNEXES
iii
Resource Validation Report of JDVC’s Offshore Magnetite Proj. under MPSA No. 338-2010-II-OMR, Cagayan Province
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
The purpose of the request is to conduct field validation of the declared mineral resource
within the explored portion of the mineral property covered by Mineral Production Sharing
Agreement denominated as MPSA No. 338-2010-II-OMR, which is the subject of Declaration
of Mining Project Feasibility (DMPF) application of JDVCRC. As provided for in Chapter
XXVII, Section 252(f) of the Consolidated Department Administrative Order No. 9210356, the
verification fee was paid for by JDVCRC under Official Receipt No. 9086364 dated June 08,
2018 in the amount of Fifty Thousand Pesos Only (PhP 50,000.00).
The JDVCRC Final Exploration Report dated April, 2015 was prepared and signed by Mr.
Rafael R. Liwanag, a Philippine Mineral Reporting Code (PMRC) accredited Competent
Person (CP) for Reporting Exploration Results with PMRC Registration No. 08-03-02. The
JDVCRC Final Exploration Report is compliant with Philippine Mineral Reporting Code
(PMRC) of 2007 guidelines and Department of Environment and Natural Resources (DENR)
Administrative Order (DAO) No. 2010-09. The estimated mineral resources declared by
JDVCRC were computed based on the data obtained from the drilling exploration works
conducted at cut-off date July 31, 2015 exploration period.
The undersigned MGB personnel validated the acceptability of the declared mineral resources
of JDVCRC through: 1) Confirmation of deposit/mineralization type in the project site and
collection of check samples for variance and statistics study; 2) In-situ assessment and quality
acceptability of the mining contractor’s existing set up of analytical laboratory for sampling,
assaying, and handling of assay results; 3) confirmation of parameters used in the resource
estimation and resource models; and 4) gathering of basic exploration data and validating the
integrity of database.
The deposit type in the JDVCRC MPSA area is an Iron Ore that can be classified Titano-
Magnetite sand offshore deposit. The sand is being transported materials from the weathering
of volcanic rocks, intrusive rocks and sedimentary derivatives of the older rocks of Abuan and
Dibuluan Formations from the hinterlands. The sand and the contained titano-magnetite being
the most resistant materials transported by rivers and creeks to the seas and re-worked by long
shore current.
The mineral resource estimate conducted by MGB made use of the drillhole database of
JDVCRC; the integrity of the database was checked by MGB technical personnel as well as the
number of drillholes used for rendering and consequent computations. The mineral resource
estimation included geostatistical analysis, rendering of geological domains/solids and block
modelling using GEMS software v6.8.
A total of 10 drillholes and 28 sample intervals were used for the resource estimate at cut-off
grade of 5%MF (Magnetite Fraction). The histogram for the MF shows that the samples are
distributed along 5%MF. The procedure of the mineral resource estimation by MGB included
basic statistical analysis, geological modelling and volumetrics and tonnage calculations. The
construction of the polygons signifying the area of influence of each drillhole was done using
SURPAC v6.8.1. Statistical analysis, geological modelling and resource computations were
done using GEMS v6.8.1. A bulk density of 1.69 dmt/m3 was used in the tonnage calculation,
which was also the same density used by JDVCRC.
After MGB field validation and manipulation of the JDVCRC drillholes used in the resource
estimation, the undersigned estimated a grand total raw offshore magnetite sand resource of
512,971,918.94 DMT with weighted average grade of 26.51%MF. The cut-off grade of 5%MF
came out to be the most economical cut-off considering the trade-offs in the reduction in mining
and processing cost over the decrease in concentrates expected to be produced. Furthermore,
_____________________________________________________________________________________
Mines and Geosciences Bureau, North Ave., Diliman, Quezon City 2
Resource Validation Report of JDVC’s Offshore Magnetite Proj. under MPSA No. 338-2010-II-OMR, Cagayan Province
it can be observed in the histogram that a small size of the sample has a very low grade (MF <
5%). Thus, it was deemed necessary to set a cut-off grade of 5%
The overall resource estimate of MGB is lesser by 93,486,053.58 DMT than that of JDVCRC’s
declared total resource estimate of 606,457,972.52 DMT due to the different softwares used in
the construction of the polygons and determination of the area. The difference between the
estimates can also be accounted to different cut-off grades and % recovery used. While the
JDVC did not set any cut-off grades and % recovery, MGB used a 5%MF cut-off grade and
90% recovery. Overall, the Measured mineral resource estimates of MGB is lower by
93,486,053.58 MT with grade difference of 1.04 % MF.
Based on the Amended Feasibility Study (FS) of JDVCRC, the initial projected 10-year
production schedule is set at an annual extraction rate of 6.91 million DMT. In consideration of
the estimated grand total offshore raw magnetite sand resource of 512,971,918.94 DMT
classified as Measured category at cut-off grade of 5% MF with weighted average grade of
26.51%MF, the projected mine life is more than 25 years and stands sufficient to support
JDVCRC’s Offshore Magnetite Sand Project, with good potential for additional measured and/or
indicated resource that will be blocked by in-fill drilling program with inferred resource of 177.80
million DMT at 49.68%MF.
In view of the foregoing discussions, it is hereby concluded that the Declaration of Mineral
Resource Estimate of JDVC Resources Corporation's Offshore Magnetite Project under MPSA
No. 338-2010-II-OMR, Cagayan Province is acceptable and compliant to the Philippine Mineral
Reporting Code (PMRC) of 2007 and guidelines of the Department of Environment and Natural
Resources (DENR) Administrative Order (DAO) No. 2010-09.
_____________________________________________________________________________________
Mines and Geosciences Bureau, North Ave., Diliman, Quezon City 3
Resource Validation Report of JDVC’s Offshore Magnetite Proj. under MPSA No. 338-2010-II-OMR, Cagayan Province
1.0 INTRODUCTION
The purpose of the request is to conduct field validation of the declared mineral
resource within the explored portion of the mineral property covered by Mineral
Production Sharing Agreement denominated as MPSA No. 338-2010-II-OMR, which
is the subject of Declaration of Mining Project Feasibility (DMPF) application of
JDVCRC.
The JDVCRC Final Exploration Report dated April, 2015 was prepared and signed by
Mr. Rafael R. Liwanag, a Philippine Mineral Reporting Code (PMRC) accredited
Competent Person (CP) for Reporting Exploration Results with PMRC Registration
No. 08-03-02. The JDVCRC Final Exploration Report is compliant with the Philippine
Mineral Reporting Code (PMRC) of 2007 guidelines and Department of Environment
and Natural Resources (DENR) Administrative Order (DAO) No. 2010-09. The
estimated mineral resources declared by JDVCRC were computed based on the data
obtained from the drilling exploration works conducted in year 2015 exploration
period.
_____________________________________________________________________________________
Mines and Geosciences Bureau, North Ave., Diliman, Quezon City 4
Resource Validation Report of JDVC’s Offshore Magnetite Proj. under MPSA No. 338-2010-II-OMR, Cagayan Province
N Study Area
_____________________________________________________________________________________
Mines and Geosciences Bureau, North Ave., Diliman, Quezon City 5
Resource Validation Report of JDVC’s Offshore Magnetite Proj. under MPSA No. 338-2010-II-OMR, Cagayan Province
0
N 9km
Study Area
Source:Mapsof.net
Figure 1b. Regional Location Map showing the Study Area
_____________________________________________________________________________________
Mines and Geosciences Bureau, North Ave., Diliman, Quezon City 6
Resource Validation Report of JDVC’s Offshore Magnetite Proj. under MPSA No. 338-2010-II-OMR, Cagayan Province
The project site is easily accessible via domestic flights from Manila to
Tuguegarao City, the capital of Cagayan province, taking about one hour,
followed by a 3-hour drive north via Pan-Philippine Highway to Sta. Ana Port,
Cagayan. From Sta. Ana Port, the tenement area is located about 14 kilometers
off and parallel to the coast of the said coastal municipalities and can be
reached by 2-hour ride by pump boat.
The project area belongs to Type III climate under the Modified Coronas
Classification of the Philippine Climate System (Figure 2). This climate type has
no pronounced maximum rain period, with a short dry season lasting only from
one to three months, either during the period from December to February or from
March to May. This climate type resembles Type I since it has short fry season.
The average annual temperature is 29.0 °C while the average annual rainfall is
1196.6 mm. The least amount of rainfall occurs in March with an average of 25.2
mm. The greatest amount of precipitation occurs in October, with an average of
167 mm. The temperatures are highest on average in June, at around 30 °C.
The lowest average temperatures in the year occur in January, when it is around
23 °C.
_____________________________________________________________________________________
Mines and Geosciences Bureau, North Ave., Diliman, Quezon City 7
Resource Validation Report of JDVC’s Offshore Magnetite Proj. under MPSA No. 338-2010-II-OMR, Cagayan Province
The elevated areas in the locality are forested, given the high precipitation
over the region’s Type II Philippine’s tropical weather. The lower lands are
agricultural and are mainly planted with rice, corn and tobacco.
Study Area
Source: PAGASA-DOST
_____________________________________________________________________________________
Mines and Geosciences Bureau, North Ave., Diliman, Quezon City 8
Resource Validation Report of JDVC’s Offshore Magnetite Proj. under MPSA No. 338-2010-II-OMR, Cagayan Province
_____________________________________________________________________________________
Mines and Geosciences Bureau, North Ave., Diliman, Quezon City 10
Resource Validation Report of JDVC’s Offshore Magnetite Proj. under MPSA No. 338-2010-II-OMR, Cagayan Province
2.3.1 Topography
Of its total land area, 28.19% or 253,831 hectares are flat to nearly level
land. This consists of alluvial plains, river deltas, low wetlands,
mangroves, and beaches. Most of these are found contiguous to the
bodies of water, especially along the Cagayan, Pared, Dummun,
Pinacanauan, Abulug, and Chico Rivers (Figure 3). These areas are
planted to rice and corn, subjected to frequent floods during the wet
season.
The gentle and moderate slopes of the province, which constitute 6.08%
and 13.48%, respectively of the total land area of the province are mostly
contiguous to the level land, enclosing the plains of the meandering rivers
and creeks. This arrangement forms the various dales or valleys found in
between the hills of the province.
Majority of the rolling land to moderately steep areas which account for
17.07% of the province's total area are found at the foothills of the Sierra
Madre and Cordillera mountains, separating the valleys and the mighty
ranges.
Steep and very steep land which constitute 10.44% and 24.73%,
respectively, of the total land area, or 94,030 hectares and 222,595
hectares, respectively, are found along the Cordilleras, in some parts of
Sta. Praxedes, Claveria, Sanchez Mira, Pamplona, Lasam, Sto. Niño, and
Rizal; and in the eastern parts of Santa Ana, Gonzaga, Lal-lo, Gattaran,
Baggao and Peñablanca, as the northern mountains of the Sierra Madre
range.
215 meters above sea level, and Mount Pangasun in Babuyan Island,
which is about 840 meters above sea level and has two craters.
2.3.2 Drainage
The Cagayan River, also known as the Rio Grande de Cagayan, is the
longest river in the Philippines and the largest river by discharge volume
of water (followed by Rio Grande de Mindanao). It has a total length of
approximately 350 kilometers and a drainage basin covering 27,753
square kilometres. It is located in the Cagayan Valley region in
northeastern part of Luzon Island and traverses the provinces of Nueva
Vizcaya, Quirino, Isabela and Cagayan (Figure 4). The estimated annual
discharge is 53,943 million cubic meters with a groundwater reserve of
47,895 million cubic meters.
_____________________________________________________________________________________
Mines and Geosciences Bureau, North Ave., Diliman, Quezon City 12
Resource Validation Report of JDVC’s Offshore Magnetite Proj. under MPSA No. 338-2010-II-OMR, Cagayan Province
the Caraballo Mountains in the south. Iron sands are deposited offshore
of Sanchez Mira, Pamplona, Abulug, Ballesteros, Aparri, Buguey and
Gonzaga, all in the province of Cagayan.
The prominent sea bottom topographic features of the Babuyan Channel are
the westward trending trough that passes through the northernmost tip of
northern Luzon in Sta. Ana Cagayan and the Camiguin and Fuga Islands of
Babuyan Group of Islands. The peculiar delta built up is present northeast of
the mouth of Cagayan River in Aparri, Cagayan (Figure 5, JDVCRC).
_____________________________________________________________________________________
Mines and Geosciences Bureau, North Ave., Diliman, Quezon City 13
Resource Validation Report of JDVC’s Offshore Magnetite Proj. under MPSA No. 338-2010-II-OMR, Cagayan Province
The sediment built-up is influenced by the supply of sediments coming from the
Cagayan River and the Kuroshio Current (Figure 6, JDVCRC). The Kuroshio Current
is a northward flowing ocean current induced by West Pacific Current in the North
Pacific Ocean and intrudes into the West Philippine Sea and South China Sea
through the Luzon Strait. The Kuroshio Current flows from the east coast of Luzon
through Taiwan and thence to Japan as illustrated it Figure 6. The effects of the
northeast monsoon cause the deflection of the Kuroshio Current towards the deeper
portion of the Babuyan Channel. The Kuroshio Current contributes significantly to the
dispersal pattern and accumulation of sediments in the Babuyan Channel including
the delta built-up in northeast of Appari
There are indications that Cagayan River had meandered through time as suggested
by the relict lakes and marsh lands in the Buguey, Cagayan (Figure 7, JDVCRC).
The blue colored arrow in Figure 7 is presumed to be the former river path and
the submerged channel. The blue dotted line is inferred to be the relict river path
of Cagayan River; the white dash arrow represents the trajectory of the Kuroshio
Current deflected from its northward direction. As will be shown later, the
submarine channel has been identified and traced during the bathymetric survey in
the project area.
N N
The corners and area of the claim boundary are bounded by the following
geographical coordinates:
_____________________________________________________________________________________
Mines and Geosciences Bureau, North Ave., Diliman, Quezon City 18
Resource Validation Report of JDVC’s Offshore Magnetite Proj. under MPSA No. 338-2010-II-OMR, Cagayan Province
Site investigations previously undertaken by various workers in the area were noted
between 1969 and 1979. Table 2 presents a summary of relevant findings by
previous companies or organizations:
Occurrence,
Mines and Geosciences Mineral verification from
1971 character,
Bureau Sanchez Mira to
and thickness of
Ballesteros
the deposit
Occurrence,
Mines and Mineral verification in
1974 character,
Geosciences Gonzaga
and thickness of
Bureau
the deposit
Mineral verification of the
Mines and Geosciences Sediment profile
1974 magnetite sand deposits in
Bureau and thickness
Sanchez Mira
Delineation of
Mines and Beach and near-
1978-1979 potential
Geosciences shore sediment
magnetite sand
Bureau sampling
accumulations
Within this ore envelope, 11 vertical confirmation drillholes with an average of 90%
recovery, amounting to more than 140 meters, with the collection of 142 samples,
which were all analyzed by XRF for %Fe, %Al2O3, %CaO, %Cr2O3, %K2O,
%MgO, %P2O5, %SiO2,%V2O5, %As, %BaO, %Cl, %Co, %Cu, %MnO, %Na2O,
%Ni, %Pb, %SO3, %Sn, %Sr, %TiO2, %Zn,%Zr and Per cent loss-on-ignition (LOI)
and Sieve Test at Intertek Testing Services Philippines,Inc., and analyzed for
Magnetic Fraction (MF) using a Dings Davies Tube (DDT) which segregates the
magnetite through magnetism at the Petrochemical Laboratory of the Mines and
Geosciences Bureau. The geographic coordinates of the said 4,999.23- hectare
portion of the MPSA contract area are shown in Table 3.
Drill
From To
Hole %MF %Fe Latitude Longitude Water Depth
(m) (m)
ID
0 5 26.58 62.05
5 10 43.87 61.53 18° 26' 121° 53'
GN18 58 M
10 15 24.89 60.45 19.9572" 0.4992"
15 20 12.58 62.58
0 5 3.23 59.69
18° 25' 121° 53'
GN30 5 10 21.01 61.8 52 M
41.106" 44.8656"
10 15 20.71 61.38
0 5 22.56 62.53
5 10 41.89 61.52 18° 26' 121° 54'
GN33 37 M
10 15 23.63 61.23 17.0016" 11.0016"
15 20 11.65 62.03
0 5 24.87 60.58
5 10 46.55 62.12 18° 26' 121° 55'
GN48 35 M
10 15 25.41 62.35 34.0008" 14.9988"
15 20 12.66 60.09
0 5 24.94 60.5
5 10 47.29 61.49 18° 26' 121° 56'
GN58 56 M
10 15 27.89 60.37 48.0012" 12.0012"
15 20 10.24 61.78
0 5 26.98 60.38
5 10 43.15 62.58 18° 27' 121° 57'
GN68 64 M
10 15 23.89 61.06 5.0004" 7.9992"
15 20 13.56 61.74
_____________________________________________________________________________________
Mines and Geosciences Bureau, North Ave., Diliman, Quezon City 22
Resource Validation Report of JDVC’s Offshore Magnetite Proj. under MPSA No. 338-2010-II-OMR, Cagayan Province
20 22 18.86 60.53
18° 26' 121° 50'
GN01 0 5 59.3 48.4224" 38.49"
18° 27' 121° 48'
GN02 0 5 45.2 34.6716" 32.148"
18° 28' 121° 46'
GN03 0 5 46.7 20.9208" 22.4796"
18° 29' 121° 44'
GN04 0 5 45.4 6.1188" 56.0364"
A marine geophysical survey was carried out within Parcels A and B-1 of the MPSA
contract area in April 2015 located in Gonzaga, Buguey and Aparri (portion), Cagayan to
provide sub- surface information on the stratigraphy, character and structure of
unconsolidated sediments. The survey consisting of high-resolution seismic reflection
profiling and continuous bathymetric measurements was undertaken primarily to
precisely map water depths, characterize submarine topographic features, subsurface
stratigraphy of consolidated sediments and to identify, delineate and map areas with
potential economic occurrences of magnetite bearing sand bodies in the area.
almost perpendicular to the general trend of the shoreline and spaced at 500 to
1,000 meters interval. Figure 9 shows the proposed traverse lines within the eastern
segment of the mineral tenement of JDVCRC covering/adjoining the municipal waters
of Ballesteros, Aparri, Buguey and Gonzaga, Cagayan. The traverse lines running
NNE-SSW and NNW-SSE were spaced at 1 km interval with the option of using a
closer interval (i.e. 500-meter) in areas where on-site preliminary analysis of the data
indicates promising sites. The picture in Figure 10 shows a schematic representation of
the seismic reflection and bathymetric surveys.
_____________________________________________________________________________________
Mines and Geosciences Bureau, North Ave., Diliman, Quezon City 24
Resource Validation Report of JDVC’s Offshore Magnetite Proj. under MPSA No. 338-2010-II-OMR, Cagayan Province
The complete set of the seismic reflection survey equipment was sourced from
Hydronav Services (Singapore) Pte Ltd on contract rental basis including the
assignment of field technician during the course of the survey. The Delph Seismic
Analog Acquisition Unit was used as central control and signal processing module.
The bathymetric survey was carried out using a dual frequency Teledyne Echotrac MK-III
high precision echo sounder set at frequencies of 200 KHz and 33 KHz. A total of 452 line-
kilometers of bathymetric traverses were accomplished to produce a more detailed and
precise bathymetric map in the area. Figure 11 shows the actual traverse lines within the
eastern segment of the JDVCRC tenement area. The dotted gray lines represent the
additional bathymetric measurements. Surfer V.11 software was used in constructing
bathymetric contours and 3-D representation of the seabed.
_____________________________________________________________________________________
Mines and Geosciences Bureau, North Ave., Diliman, Quezon City 25
Resource Validation Report of JDVC’s Offshore Magnetite Proj. under MPSA No. 338-2010-II-OMR, Cagayan Province
Figure 11. Location of Actual Traverse lines Within the Eastern Segment of the JDVCRC
Tenement
_____________________________________________________________________________________
Mines and Geosciences Bureau, North Ave., Diliman, Quezon City 26
Resource Validation Report of JDVC’s Offshore Magnetite Proj. under MPSA No. 338-2010-II-OMR, Cagayan Province
The marine geophysical survey undertaken in the study area generated a total of 187.3 line-
kilometers of high-resolution seismic reflection data and a total of 377.3 line-kilometers of
bathymetric data. The additional echosounder measurements of about 190 kilometers were
accomplished in order to get a more precise seabottom topographic configuration of the
submarine delta within and adjacent to the municipal waters of Aparri, Buguey and
Gonzaga, Cagayan. Figure 12 shows the actual traverse lines within the study area.
Analysis of the bathymetric contours shown in the NAMRIA 1:250,000 topographic map
(Figure 13) indicates contrasting submarine topography of the seabed east and west of the
mouth of Cagayan River. A gentler slope of the seabed prevails on the eastern side of
offshore Cagayan from the mouth of Cagayan River towards the town of Santa Ana. In
contrast, the seabed west of Cagayan River shows a moderate slope of about -1.4% slope
from the shoreline of the town of Ballesteros to a distance of 3,600 meters (where the -50
meter contour is encountered) seaward. The slope of the seabed from the Town of Buguey to
a distance of 24,500 meters (up to -50 meter contour line) has a relatively gentler slope of
about -0.2%.
_____________________________________________________________________________________
Mines and Geosciences Bureau, North Ave., Diliman, Quezon City 27
Resource Validation Report of JDVC’s Offshore Magnetite Proj. under MPSA No. 338-2010-II-OMR, Cagayan Province
_____________________________________________________________________________________
Mines and Geosciences Bureau, North Ave., Diliman, Quezon City 28
Resource Validation Report of JDVC’s Offshore Magnetite Proj. under MPSA No. 338-2010-II-OMR, Cagayan Province
Figures 14 and 15 graphically present the color-filled contour maps and 3-D
presentations of the seabed of the eastern portion of MPSA-338-2010-II-OMR.
Figure 14. Color-filled Bathymetric Map of the Easternmost Segment of the JDVCRC
Tenement Area
_____________________________________________________________________________________
Mines and Geosciences Bureau, North Ave., Diliman, Quezon City 29
Resource Validation Report of JDVC’s Offshore Magnetite Proj. under MPSA No. 338-2010-II-OMR, Cagayan Province
_____________________________________________________________________________________
Mines and Geosciences Bureau, North Ave., Diliman, Quezon City 30
Resource Validation Report of JDVC’s Offshore Magnetite Proj. under MPSA No. 338-2010-II-OMR, Cagayan Province
Unit 1:
Unit 1 generally consists of recent sediments of beach deposits along the shore
grading into finer sediments offshore. It is characterized by parallel to divergent
reflection patterns. Due to the influence of the Kuroshio Current flowing from the
East Philippine Sea and deflected towards the Babuyan Channel, the finer
sediments particularly on the eastern part of the area are transported towards the
west. This unit generally consists of silt to fine grained sand with variable
amounts of magnetite sand.
Unit 2:
Unit 3:
Unit 4:
The oldest unconsolidated sediment sequence in the area is Unit 4 that generally
shows parallel to divergent and in some places hummocky reflection patterns. It is
_____________________________________________________________________________________
Mines and Geosciences Bureau, North Ave., Diliman, Quezon City 31
Resource Validation Report of JDVC’s Offshore Magnetite Proj. under MPSA No. 338-2010-II-OMR, Cagayan Province
Based on the analysis and interpretation of seismic reflection data gathered in the
area, the seismo-stratigraphic units that can be considered as the most
promising targets for magnetite sand exploration are Units 2 and 3. Table 5 shows
the tabulation of the individual thicknesses of Unit 1 and the combined Units 2 and
3. It will be observed in the tabulation and in the contour map in Figure 17 that the
sediments are thicker in the eastern portion of the tenement, which is identified
here as Parcel A. The area to the west is called Parcel B-1. The sediments are
observed to be thinning out going westward to Parcel B-1. These thicknesses
were determined from the meticulous interpretation of the seismic reflection
profiles of the seismic reflection survey lines shown in Annex 4. On the average,
the thicknesses of the sediments per Unit are as mathematically computed follows:
_____________________________________________________________________________________
Mines and Geosciences Bureau, North Ave., Diliman, Quezon City 32
Resource Validation Report of JDVC’s Offshore Magnetite Proj. under MPSA No. 338-2010-II-OMR, Cagayan Province
_____________________________________________________________________________________
Mines and Geosciences Bureau, North Ave., Diliman, Quezon City 33
Resource Validation Report of JDVC’s Offshore Magnetite Proj. under MPSA No. 338-2010-II-OMR, Cagayan Province
The N-S trending Cordillera Central, a 300 km-long and 90 km wide, is one
of the major tectonic unit of Northern Luzon (Figure 18). Acid plutonic rocks
form the core of the mountain chain, the outer shell of which consists of
shallow to deep sea sedimentary rock formations with intercalated volcanics.
The uplift of the Central Cordillera batholith started during the Miocene. The
Sierra Madre Range likewise consists of the acidic plutonic intrusive bodies.
The third morpho-tectonic unit is the Caraballo Mountains, which serve as the
connection of the southern segment of the Central Cordillera and the Sierra
Madre. These three morpho-tectonic units form the catchment basin of the N-
S oriented Cagayan River Valley. The fault-bounded Cagayan Valley, 200
km long and about 50 km wide, is surrounded by these mountains, except on
the northern side
5.3 Stratigraphy
The area of interest has a good potential for magnetite mineralization due to
the presence of rock units/lithology that are good source of heavy minerals
such as magnetite which are of products of continuous weathering and
erosion from the mountains particularly at the northern Sierra Madre. Below
are the geologic rock formations in the area and their position in the
stratigraphic column as shown in Figure 19.
• Abuan Formation
Dibuluan Formation
• Quaternary Alluvium
_____________________________________________________________________________________
Mines and Geosciences Bureau, North Ave., Diliman, Quezon City 35
Resource Validation Report of JDVC’s Offshore Magnetite Proj. under MPSA No. 338-2010-II-OMR, Cagayan Province
_____________________________________________________________________________________
Mines and Geosciences Bureau, North Ave., Diliman, Quezon City 37
Resource Validation Report of JDVC’s Offshore Magnetite Proj. under MPSA No. 338-2010-II-OMR, Cagayan Province
The Titano-Magnetite sand within JDVCRC MPSA area are offshore deposits found at
the seabed of Babuyan Channel. The rock formations that may have contributed as
source of magnetite and other associated placer minerals include the volcanic,
pyroclastics and sedimentary derivatives of the older rocks of Abuan and Dibuluan
Formations from the hinterlands. These volcanic flows intercalated with pyroclastic and
sedimentary rocks and intrusions of diorite, quartz diorite and andesitic to dacitic rocks
commonly have specks of magnetite that were disintegrated from the host rocks during
weathering process and eventually transported and concentrated through river systems
and through the winnowing actions of waves tides and currents.
The deposit type in the JDVCRC MPSA area is an Iron Ore that can be classified Titano-
Magnetite sand offshore deposit. The sand is being transported materials from the
weathering of volcanic rocks, intrusive rocks and sedimentary derivatives of the older
rocks of Abuan and Dibuluan Formations from the hinterlands. The sand and the
contained titano-magnetite being the most resistant materials transported by rivers and
creeks to the seas and re-worked by long shore current.
7.2 Mineralization
_____________________________________________________________________________________
Mines and Geosciences Bureau, North Ave., Diliman, Quezon City 39
Resource Validation Report of JDVC’s Offshore Magnetite Proj. under MPSA No. 338-2010-II-OMR, Cagayan Province
8.1 Methodology
The MGB-CO technical personnel inspected the JDVCRC's core house, sample
preparation facility located in Sta. Ana, Cagayan. A total of three (3)
representative check samples were taken and will be subjected to chemical
analysis upon return to MGB-CO for Quality Assurance/Quality Control (OA/QC)
study and to determine the overall reliability of field sample preparation
techniques, the accuracy of analytical data supplied by JDVCRC and finally to
ensure that analytical results were free of bias.
The JDVCRC resource geologists provided the latest compiled drillhole database
used during resource modelling and subsequent calculation of tonnages. MGB-
CO geologists will import the drillhole database of JDVCRC to GEMS v.6.8
software which will be recalculated and subjected to geostatistical analysis and
block modelling.
The field validation verified the deposit type and mineralization of JDVC
though their Siphon Vessel with 3-stage magnetic separator and
_____________________________________________________________________________________
Mines and Geosciences Bureau, North Ave., Diliman, Quezon City 40
Resource Validation Report of JDVC’s Offshore Magnetite Proj. under MPSA No. 338-2010-II-OMR, Cagayan Province
Photo 2. Twin engine motor boat used going to Siphon Vessel of JDVCRC located 15km-offshore of
Gonzaga, Cagayan, travel time of which is 2-hr though rough sea.
_____________________________________________________________________________________
Mines and Geosciences Bureau, North Ave., Diliman, Quezon City 41
Resource Validation Report of JDVC’s Offshore Magnetite Proj. under MPSA No. 338-2010-II-OMR, Cagayan Province
Photo 3. JDVCRC Siphon vessel with magnetic separator and processing apparatus on board located 15-km
offshore of Gonzaga, Cagayan.
Photo 4. Transfer from motorboat through vertical ladder going to the Siphon Vessel.
_____________________________________________________________________________________
Mines and Geosciences Bureau, North Ave., Diliman, Quezon City 42
Resource Validation Report of JDVC’s Offshore Magnetite Proj. under MPSA No. 338-2010-II-OMR, Cagayan Province
Photo 5. Introduction lecture, safety orientation explanation of production and processing of magnetite
sand.
Photo 6. Operation set-up for magnetite Photo 7. 3-stage magnetic separator system
extraction
_____________________________________________________________________________________
Mines and Geosciences Bureau, North Ave., Diliman, Quezon City 43
Resource Validation Report of JDVC’s Offshore Magnetite Proj. under MPSA No. 338-2010-II-OMR, Cagayan Province
_____________________________________________________________________________________
Mines and Geosciences Bureau, North Ave., Diliman, Quezon City 44
Resource Validation Report of JDVC’s Offshore Magnetite Proj. under MPSA No. 338-2010-II-OMR, Cagayan Province
Photo 11. MGB Validation Team with JDVC staff at roof top of Siphon Vessel.
Check samples for laboratory analysis were taken by the MGB validating
team from the core house facility of JDVCRC office in Times Street,
Quezon City (Photos 12 to 14, Figure 20). A total of three (3) drill core
samples comprised of magnetite sand materials were randomly collected
from the representative mineralized samples. The MGB used analytical
volumetric titration method using K-dichromate for Iron (Fe) ore determination.
_____________________________________________________________________________________
Mines and Geosciences Bureau, North Ave., Diliman, Quezon City 45
Resource Validation Report of JDVC’s Offshore Magnetite Proj. under MPSA No. 338-2010-II-OMR, Cagayan Province
% Fe = ( V x T) K2Cr2O7 where T = % Fe - g / ml
8.2.3 Results
% Fe2Oof Check Samples Fe2Analyses
3 = % Fe x O3 = % Fe x 1.4297
Check samples were collected during field validation and sent back to MGB
2 of
for metallurgical testing, the results Fewhich are subjected to computation
_____________________________________________________________________________________
( V North
Mines and Geosciences Bureau, x N) Ave., x Quezon
Diliman,
K2Cr2O7 55.85/
City 1000 46
% Fe = _________________________________ x 100
Resource Validation Report of JDVC’s Offshore Magnetite Proj. under MPSA No. 338-2010-II-OMR, Cagayan Province
to zero with minimal spread about this average value. Formula for
computation of RPE is:
The comparison of the analysis results conducted by MGB and JDVRC can
be summarized by the relative percentage errors (RPE) and the correlation
as shown in Figure 21 and Table 4. After computation of RPE for the 3
check samples concluded that the RPE outliers may have resulted from
different instrumentations and analysis methods used by MGB and JDVCRC.
Considering the number of samples used, the analysis results of the RPE
showed relatively good errors/ allowable error (<17%) and indicating good
repeatability and correlation (R^2).
% MF
No. of Pairs 3
Average RPE 16.93
Correlation 0.36
_____________________________________________________________________________________
Mines and Geosciences Bureau, North Ave., Diliman, Quezon City 47
Resource Validation Report of JDVC’s Offshore Magnetite Proj. under MPSA No. 338-2010-II-OMR, Cagayan Province
_____________________________________________________________________________________
Mines and Geosciences Bureau, North Ave., Diliman, Quezon City 48
Resource Validation Report of JDVC’s Offshore Magnetite Proj. under MPSA No. 338-2010-II-OMR, Cagayan Province
_____________________________________________________________________________________
Mines and Geosciences Bureau, North Ave., Diliman, Quezon City 49
Resource Validation Report of JDVC’s Offshore Magnetite Proj. under MPSA No. 338-2010-II-OMR, Cagayan Province
_____________________________________________________________________________________
Mines and Geosciences Bureau, North Ave., Diliman, Quezon City 50
Resource Validation Report of JDVC’s Offshore Magnetite Proj. under MPSA No. 338-2010-II-OMR, Cagayan Province
_____________________________________________________________________________________
Mines and Geosciences Bureau, North Ave., Diliman, Quezon City 51
Resource Validation Report of JDVC’s Offshore Magnetite Proj. under MPSA No. 338-2010-II-OMR, Cagayan Province
The mineral resource estimate conducted by MGB made use of the same
database used by the JDVC in its resource computations. The integrity of
the database, number of drillholes and sample intervals were checked by
MGB technical personnel before being utilized for geologic modelling and
resource calculation. The procedure of the mineral resource estimation by
MGB included basic statistical analysis, geological modelling and
volumetrics and tonnage calculations. The construction of the polygons
signifying the area of influence of each drillhole was done using SURPAC
v6.8.1. Statistical analysis, geological modelling and resource
computations were done using GEMS v6.8.1.
in order to mark the extent of the area of influences. These distances were
used to construct polygons representing the areas of influence for each
sample. These polygons were then used for the rendering of geological
models.
The average magnetic fraction contents used in the calculation are the
average of the sum of products of thickness of the horizon and average
magnetic fraction contents. The volume of raw sand is computed by
multiplying the area of sand with the average thickness of sand horizon.
The tonnage of the raw sand is computed by multiplying the volume with
specific gravity of raw sand (1.69 dmt/m3). The tonnage of the magnetite
sand was calculated by multiplying the tonnage of raw sand with the with
the average magnetic fraction
A total of 10 drillholes and 28 sample intervals were used for the resource
estimate. MGB set the cut-off grade to 5% MF and recovery at 90%. The
geological modelling was also done using the polygon method, which is similar to
that used by the JDVC in their resource estimates. Interpolation of grade values
_____________________________________________________________________________________
Mines and Geosciences Bureau, North Ave., Diliman, Quezon City 53
Resource Validation Report of JDVC’s Offshore Magnetite Proj. under MPSA No. 338-2010-II-OMR, Cagayan Province
Basic statistical analysis was done to determine data variance from the
sample analysis results that may arise from the geological interpretation of
the deposit, sampling practices, and laboratory analyses (Table 6). Basic
statistical analysis consisted of all 28 sample intervals from all 10 drillholes
used. After statistical analysis, it is imperative that dispersion of grades
especially in %MF Fe does not deviate much from the mean grades.
GEMS (Version 6.8) was used to perform the univariate statistical analysis
for %MF value subjecting each mineralized domain to this process. The
histogram for %MF is shown in Figure 28.
_____________________________________________________________________________________
Mines and Geosciences Bureau, North Ave., Diliman, Quezon City 54
Resource Validation Report of JDVC’s Offshore Magnetite Proj. under MPSA No. 338-2010-II-OMR, Cagayan Province
The extent of the deposit was based on the area of influence of the drillholes
which was determined by the conventional polygon method (Figure 29. In the
polygon method, the radius of the area of influence of a sample is equivalent to
half of the distance from one sample to another. The thicknesses were based on
the sample intervals used by the JDVC which is 5 meters. After constructing the
extents of the polygon of each sample, geological solids were constructed based
on these polygons and the thicknesses of the sample intervals. After the
geological model was constructed, it was clipped using the MPSA boundaries of
JDVC to ensure that the deposit calculated is within the bounds of the claim area.
_____________________________________________________________________________________
Mines and Geosciences Bureau, North Ave., Diliman, Quezon City 55
Resource Validation Report of JDVC’s Offshore Magnetite Proj. under MPSA No. 338-2010-II-OMR, Cagayan Province
Figure 29. Geological solid showing the magnetite sand with the tenement area of JDVC
_____________________________________________________________________________________
Mines and Geosciences Bureau, North Ave., Diliman, Quezon City 56
Resource Validation Report of JDVC’s Offshore Magnetite Proj. under MPSA No. 338-2010-II-OMR, Cagayan Province
After MGB field validation and manipulation of the JDVCRC drillholes used in the
resource estimation, the undersigned estimated a grand total raw offshore
magnetite sand resource of 512,971,918.94 DMT with weighted average grade of
26.51% MF(Table 7a, b and c, Figure 30 and 31). The cut-off grade of 5%MF
came out to be the most economical cut-off considering the trade-offs in the
reduction in mining and processing cost over the decrease in concentrates
expected to be produced. Furthermore, it can be observed in the histogram that a
small size of the sample has a very low grade (MF < 5%). Thus, it was deemed
necessary to set a cut-off grade of 5%
_____________________________________________________________________________________
Mines and Geosciences Bureau, North Ave., Diliman, Quezon City 57
Resource Validation Report of JDVC’s Offshore Magnetite Proj. under MPSA No. 338-2010-II-OMR, Cagayan Province
JDVC MGB
INFERRED RESOURCE
0-5 meters 63,179,310.69 47.71 177,800,022.17 49.68
Cut-off
Tonnage Grade
grade
0% 580551705.26 26.08
1% 580551705.26 26.08
2% 580551705.26 26.08
3% 580551705.26 26.08
4% 569968798.83 26.51
5% 569968798.83 26.51
_____________________________________________________________________________________
Mines and Geosciences Bureau, North Ave., Diliman, Quezon City 58
Resource Validation Report of JDVC’s Offshore Magnetite Proj. under MPSA No. 338-2010-II-OMR, Cagayan Province
Variations in the tonnage and grade estimates of MGB and JDVC can be
observed in Table 7. It should be noted that different softwares were used in the
construction of the polygons and determination of the area. This may result to
slight differences in the resource estimates. The total measured mineral resource
estimate by MGB of 512,971,918.94 MT is less than that of JDVC
(606,457,972.52 DMT) by 93,486,053.58 DMT with weighted average grade of
26.51 % MF compared to that of JDVC which is 25.47 %. The difference between
the estimates can be accounted to different cut-off grades and % recovery used.
While the JDVC did not set any cut-off grades and % recovery, MGB used a
5%MF cut-off grade and 90% recovery. Overall, the measured mineral resource
estimates of MGB is lower by 93,486,053.58 DMT with grade difference of 1.04
% MF.
_____________________________________________________________________________________
Mines and Geosciences Bureau, North Ave., Diliman, Quezon City 59
Resource Validation Report of JDVC’s Offshore Magnetite Proj. under MPSA No. 338-2010-II-OMR, Cagayan Province
Based on the Amended Feasibility Study (FS) of JDVCRC, the initial projected 10-year
production schedule is set at an annual extraction rate of 6.91 million DMT. In
consideration of the estimated grand total offshore raw magnetite sand resource of
512,971,918.94 DMT classified as Measured category at cut-off grade of 5% MF with
weighted average grade of 26.51%MF, the projected mine life is more than 25 years
and stands sufficient to support JDVCRC’s Offshore Magnetite Sand Project, with good
potential for additional measured and/or indicated resource that will be blocked by in-fill
drilling program with inferred resource of 177.80 million DMT at 49.68%MF
Prepared by:
Resty C. Gomez
Senior Science Research Specialist
_____________________________________________________________________________________
Mines and Geosciences Bureau, North Ave., Diliman, Quezon City 60
Resource Validation Report of JDVC’s Offshore Magnetite Proj. under MPSA No. 338-2010-II-OMR, Cagayan Province
11.0 REFERENCES
Mines and Geosciences Bureau, 2010. Geology of the Philippines, 2nd ed.
_____________________________________________________________________________________
Mines and Geosciences Bureau, North Ave., Diliman, Quezon City 61
Resource Validation Report of JDVC’s Offshore Magnetite Proj. under MPSA No. 338-2010-II-OMR, Cagayan Province
Table 7c. MGB’s Summary of Magnetite Sand Resource Estimate of JDVCRC at cut-off grade of 5% MF.
Mines and Geosciences Bureau, North Ave., Diliman, Quezon City Page 63
Resource Validation Report of JDVC’s Offshore Magnetite Proj. under MPSA No. 338-2010-II-OMR, Cagayan Province
Mines and Geosciences Bureau, North Ave., Diliman, Quezon City Page 64
REPRESENTATIVE SEISMIC PROFILES
I. NW – SE Lines
A. Line B3
Unit 1 is essentially characterized by reflection-free to parallel sub-parallel reflection patterns deduced to consist essentially of mud
to silty mud sediments. The thickness of this unit is relatively variable with an average of about 4 to 5 meters. Unit 2 is generally
characterized by relatively strong stratified divergent to sigmoidal to chaotic in some places internal reflection patterns and is inferred
to consist predominantly of fine to medium grained most possibly sand-sized deposits. It has an average thickness of about 8 to 10
meters. Unit 3 is characterized by irregular, discontinuous and faintly chaotic to hummocky reflection patterns and is deduced to
consist essentially of silty sand to muddy sand deposit. It has an average thickness of about 5 meters. Unit 4 – The “acoustic
basement” surface underlying the study area.
Unit 1 is essentially characterized by reflection-free to parallel sub-parallel reflection patterns deduced to consist essentially of mud
to silty mud sediments. The thickness of this unit is relatively variable with an average of about 4 to 5 meters. Unit 2 is generally
characterized by relatively strong stratified divergent to sigmoidal to chaotic in some places internal reflection patterns and is inferred
to consist predominantly of fine to medium grained most possibly sand-sized deposits. It has an average thickness of about 8 to 10
meters. Unit 3 is characterized by irregular, discontinuous and faintly chaotic to hummocky reflection patterns and is deduced to
consist essentially of silty sand to muddy sand deposit. It has an average thickness of about 5 meters. Unit 4 – The “acoustic
basement” surface underlying the study area.
II. N – S / S – N Lines
Unit 1 is essentially characterized by reflection-free to parallel sub-parallel reflection patterns deduced to consist essentially of mud
to silty mud sediments. The thickness of this unit is relatively variable with an average of about 4 to 5 meters. Unit 2 is generally
characterized by relatively strong stratified divergent to sigmoidal to chaotic in some places internal reflection patterns and is inferred
to consist predominantly of fine to medium grained most possibly sand-sized deposits. It has an average thickness of about 8 to 10
meters. Unit 3 is characterized by irregular, discontinuous and faintly chaotic to hummocky reflection patterns and is deduced to
consist essentially of silty sand to muddy sand deposit. It has an average thickness of about 5 meters. Unit 4 – The “acoustic
basement” surface underlying the study area.
Unit 1 is essentially characterized by reflection-free to parallel sub-parallel reflection patterns deduced to consist essentially of mud
to silty mud sediments. The thickness of this unit is relatively variable with an average of about 4 to 5 meters. Unit 2 is generally
characterized by relatively strong stratified divergent to sigmoidal to chaotic in some places internal reflection patterns and is inferred
to consist predominantly of fine to medium grained most possibly sand-sized deposits. It has an average thickness of about 8 to 10
meters. Unit 3 is characterized by irregular, discontinuous and faintly chaotic to hummocky reflection patterns and is deduced to
consist essentially of silty sand to muddy sand deposit. It has an average thickness of about 5 meters. Unit 4 – The “acoustic
basement” surface underlying the study area.
Unit 1 is essentially characterized by reflection-free to parallel sub-parallel reflection patterns deduced to consist essentially of mud
to silty mud sediments. The thickness of this unit is relatively variable with an average of about 4 to 5 meters. Unit 2 is generally
characterized by relatively strong stratified divergent to sigmoidal to chaotic in some places internal reflection patterns and is inferred
to consist predominantly of fine to medium grained most possibly sand-sized deposits. It has an average thickness of about 8 to 10
meters. Unit 3 is characterized by irregular, discontinuous and faintly chaotic to hummocky reflection patterns and is deduced to
consist essentially of silty sand to muddy sand deposit. It has an average thickness of about 5 meters. Unit 4 – The “acoustic
basement” surface underlying the study area.