Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Acode - Local Content
Acode - Local Content
Citation:
Magelah, P., G., (2014). Local Content in Oil and Gas Sector: An
Assessment of Uganda’s Legal and Policy Regimes. ACODE Policy Briefing
Paper Series, No.28, 2014. Kampala.
© ACODE 2014
Cover Photo:
List of Acronyms.....................................................................................v
Acknowledgement.................................................................................. vi
1. Introduction....................................................................................... 1
1.1 Study Objectives.................................................................................... 2
3.2 Uganda’s Capacity Needs for the Oil and Gas Sector.............................. 8
3.8 What Should be the Relationship Between the Local Supplier and Other
International Businesses Operating in the Country?............................ 16
Local Content in Oil and Gas: Legal and Policy Issues in Uganda
List of Acronyms
Local Content in Oil and Gas: Legal and Policy Issues in Uganda
v
Acknowledgements
The year 2014 marks 8 years since Uganda announced the existence of
commercially viable petroleum deposits. Since this announcement in
2006 a lot of efforts have gone in the making of laws and policies that will
govern the sector and see to it that the country maximises the benefits of
exploiting its oil and gas reserves. One major concern for government, the
citizens and all the actors has been how Ugandans will benefit from the
oil and gas sector. Concerns have been raised on whether the sector can
provide employment for citizens, use locally produced goods and services
as well as exploit local resources to transfer technology that can kickstart
other sectors of the economy. The debate has tended to be around local
content and how much local content will be utilised by the sector.
On the other hand the debate has been on whether there is enough local
capacity to deal with the employment, technology and service needs for
the oil and gas industry. Questions have also been raised on standards
of locally provided goods and services and whether they can meet the
demands of the industry. On overall there is an agreement that the oil and
gas industry should involve Ugandans and should in as much as possible
employ Ugandans and Ugandan goods and services. What seems to be a
disparity is whether Uganda has capacity to provide the goods, services
and skills necessary for the sector.
This policy brief assesses the legal and policy approaches so far adopted
in ensuring the participation of Ugandans in the oil and gas sector. The
brief assesses the standards set in the Oil and Gas Policy, 2008, the
Petroleum (Exploration, Development and Production) Act, 2013 and
Petroleum (Refining, Conversion, Transmission and Midstream Storage)
Act, 2013 which are the major instruments governing the petroleum
sector in Uganda. The brief also looks at standards and approaches
adopted by other countries in Africa and major commercial institutions.
The brief highlights the major gaps in the laws and policies and makes
key recommendations to address the gaps.
vi Local Content in Oil and Gas: Legal and Policy Issues in Uganda
1. Introduction
Many countries engaged in oil and gas production or mining are
introducing requirements for participation commonly referred
to as ‘local content’. This is increasingly so in the developing
world mainly in Africa, Asia and Latin America. Local content
requirements are mainly in form of policy and regulatory
measures that focus at increasing use of the locally available
labour, technology and other resources in the oil and gas sector.
The focus is on transfer of technology by companies engaged in
the extractive resource sector to the native people of a particular
nation with a hope of assuring them income, employment and
ultimately sustainable development. The development of local
content has basically been a result of recognition that after years
of oil and gas or mineral exploitation in many developing countries,
little seems to be transferred to the citizens of these resource-rich
countries in form of technology and employment1. Many citizens
of resource-rich countries especially in the developing world tend
to be mere spectators. This trend continues to exist in spite of the
fact that many mining and petroleum companies in the developing
world are given incentives such as tax holidays with a hope that
they will be able to exploit the resource, provide employment for
the natives and develop infrastructure which would enable the
economy to develop.
Local Content in Oil and Gas: Legal and Policy Issues in Uganda
1
producing countries in the developing world is of paramount
importance. It is necessary to have in place measures to avoid
the “Dutch disease”3 and the resource curse such as conflicts4.
Many scholars have argued that the ‘Dutch disease’ and resource
conflicts are basically a result of poor management of resources
in the country. The failure to exploit resources sustainably and
enable citizens take part in decision making and employment
greatly contributes to conflicts emanating from natural resource
endowments. Economic challenges such as the Dutch disease are
a result of failing to link natural resource exploitation with other
sectors of the economy like agriculture, tourism and industrial
development The lack of involvement of citizens in the exploitation
and use of the natural resources sector greatly hinders the
trickledown effect of a resource like oil consequently resulting in
negative effects to the economy.
Uganda government has in place the National Oil and Gas Policy
(NOGP). Secondly, the country has in place the upstream and
midstream laws to govern and regulate the oil and gas sectors
but the downstream bill is still being considered by parliament.
It is important for these laws and policies to provide for citizen
participation and safeguard citizens roles in the oil and gas sector.
3 The “Dutch Disease” is a term used to describe an economic situation faced by many resource
rich developing countries. The term is used to describe a situation where production and
export of natural resources such as Oil and Gas or Minerals results into economic situation
other exports from the country become less desirable which results in slowing down other
sectors of the economy and over dependency on the particular resource. This in the end
exposes the economy to negative forces of the sector (e.g. oil price fluctuation, “dying” of
other sectors like agriculture and industry) and later affects economic development.
4 Collier, P. 2010. The Political Economy of Natural Resources. Social Research, 77(4):1105-1132.
2 Local Content in Oil and Gas: Legal and Policy Issues in Uganda
c. To recommend key actions and reforms Uganda needs to
take up to have an effective local content policy, legal and
institutional regime.
Local Content in Oil and Gas: Legal and Policy Issues in Uganda
3
activities and systems that ensure views of an individual citizen
are included in decision making processes.
4 Local Content in Oil and Gas: Legal and Policy Issues in Uganda
up but rather the individual’s views were considered in the process
of arriving at a decision. Such a kind of participation can be direct
for instance, taking part in an election or being part of a meeting
that arrived at a decision or indirect through a representative.
This can range from national or regional representation such as
parliament to representation at a lower level such as village council
or family11.
Local Content in Oil and Gas: Legal and Policy Issues in Uganda
5
through exploitation of the existing opportunities. One of the ways
has been through government providing for Ugandans to take
part is the sector is through local content. Government is in the
process of making policies and laws that will ensure citizens take
part in the oil and gas sector. This policy briefing paper tackles
the present but is also futuristic and analyses the different policy
and legal provisions and how they will contribute to delineation of
local content in the oil and gas sector as well as identifying gaps
that need to be addressed.
6 Local Content in Oil and Gas: Legal and Policy Issues in Uganda
(d) Promotion of employment of Ugandans in the oil and gas
sector and
(e) Promotion of transfer of skills and technology to the country.
(f) Identifying training skills required for the sector and planning
for their development through both formal and industrial
training.
(g) Utilising oil and gas activities in the country to support
provision of the necessary training.
(h) Provide appropriate training to Government personnel in the
relevant fields as one of the ways to facilitate professional
dialogue with oil companies.
(i) Broaden the national education curricula to prepare the
necessary workforce for the growing oil and gas sector in the
country.
To give the above strategies the force of law, the Petroleum
(Exploration and Development) Act, 201312 (upstream law) and
the Petroleum (Refining, Conversion, Transmission and Midstream
Storage) Act13 (Midstream law) provide for training and employment
of Ugandans. The two laws make it a requirement for companies
to provide a plan for training and employment of Ugandans in the
sector during application for licences. Generally, it is presumed
that the plan to train Ugandans is one of the conditions for which
a licence can be granted. However there is no clear strategy to
ensure that the companies are followed-up to ensure they train
Ugandans as proposed in their applications.
12 Act 3 of 2013
13 Act 4 of 2013
Local Content in Oil and Gas: Legal and Policy Issues in Uganda
7
Whereas the foregoing programs and strategies for training
Ugandans are good for capacity building, there is need to
reform Uganda’s education sector to meet the demands for the
industry. For example, there are no systems to determine what
kind of capacity is needed for the sector and whether the training
programs submitted by oil companies will meet these capacity
needs at present. There is no link between the Petroleum Authority
which is the main regulatory agency and the Ministry of Education
and Sports and The National Curriculum Development Centre to
develop training content that will enable Ugandans take part in
the sector.
3.2 Uganda’s Capacity Needs for the Oil and Gas Sector
Government has not done Training Needs Assessment or other
forms of capacity needs assessment for the oil and gas sector and
the only existing data is the study conducted by the joint partners14
involved in the oil and gas sector. This means Uganda will have to
rely on data provided by industrial players. The challenge with this
data is it was gathered and analysed in the lenses of an industrial
player seeking to maximise profits and this may not necessarily
reflect the needs of the country.
The industrial survey data reveals that the Oil and Gas sector will
employ 13,000 people in the construction phase (within 3 to 5
years), this will drop to 3,000 people in the operational phase (20-
30 years). Out of this manpower required 15% will be engineers
and managers, 60% will be technicians and craftspersons and 25%
will be unskilled workers15 . The industrial survey recommends that
focus in education should be put on civil constriction, electrical
and mechanical fields.
14 These include Tullow Oil, CNOOC and Total Ltd who have active licenses in Uganda today
15 See CNOOC, Total and Tullow (2014) Planning for the future and promoting national content: A
survey to foster opportunities for Ugandans in the Oil and Gas sector
8 Local Content in Oil and Gas: Legal and Policy Issues in Uganda
The industrial survey indicates that existing capacity gaps in
the sector such as limited qualified civil craftspersons, drivers,
mechanical technicians among others. The survey expresses fear
that some areas such as welders and electrical technicians could
be “dried out” depriving them of other sectors.
On the other hand the capacity needs for the oil and gas training
institutions needs to be reviewed. At present government has not
10 Local Content in Oil and Gas: Legal and Policy Issues in Uganda
reviewed the capacity of technical institutions which will provide
training for oil and gas sector jobs. Whereas instructors at UPIK
and Nakawa Vocational Training Institute (NVTI) have had some
basic training for the oil and gas sector, the same cannot be said
of other technical colleges. This will greatly undermine the nature
of skills imparted by these institutions.
Local Content in Oil and Gas: Legal and Policy Issues in Uganda
11
a. What should constitute “local” business entity or a local
supplier?
b. What parameters should be used to determine a local
company/business entity?
c. What should be the relationship between the local supplier
and other international businesses operating in the country?
d. What level of control should citizens have over the foreign
suppliers/businesses operating in the country (for example is
employing citizens or having citizens as shareholders enough
to qualify someone)?
There is an attempt to answer the above questions in Uganda’s
petroleum policy and the laws. However, several gaps exist.
The law does not define what a “Ugandan” company is, thereby
leaving a gap for exploitation. The strict interpretation of the word
“Company” used in the section instead of “business entity” limits
the application of this section only to companies living out other
recognised business entities such as partnerships, cooperative
societies, and sole proprietorships among others. The Midstream
12 Local Content in Oil and Gas: Legal and Policy Issues in Uganda
Act, attempts to address this gap, (though not conclusively) by
providing that20
Local Content in Oil and Gas: Legal and Policy Issues in Uganda
13
the petroleum resources are found while others believe petroleum
being a resource for the nation, any citizen should take part.
22 S. 126(s) of upstream Act provides the programme submitted by licensee shall provide for the
training and recruitment of Ugandans in all phases of petroleum activities and shall take into
account gender, equity, persons with disabilities and host communities.
23 Act No. 1 of 2012
24 Uganda Investment Code Act, Cap 92 Laws of Uganda
14 Local Content in Oil and Gas: Legal and Policy Issues in Uganda
(b) a company, which more than 50 percent of the shares are
held by a person who is not a citizen of Uganda;
(c) a partnership in which the majority of partners are not
citizens of Uganda25.
The Investment Code Act goes ahead to provide that the definition
of a foreign company shall not inclide a company is registered
under the Companies Act in which government is a majority
shareholder directly or indirectly or a corporate body established
in Uganda by law, a cooperative society and an international
development agency.
A non-citizen means:
(a) a person who is not a citizen of Uganda as defined by the
Constitution and the Uganda Citizenship Act;
(b) in the case of a corporate body, a corporate body in which
the controlling interest lies with noncitizens;
(c) in the case of bodies where shares are not applicable, where
the body’s decision making lies with noncitizens;
(d) a company in which the shares are held in trust for noncitizens;
(e) a company incorporated in Uganda whose articles of
association do not contain a provision restricting transfer or
issue of shares to noncitizens26.
The Land Act describes “controlling interest” in a company to
include:
Local Content in Oil and Gas: Legal and Policy Issues in Uganda
15
From the above it is clear that when it comes to land matters,
the law looks at interests and benefits in determining a Ugandan
or foreign company. Unlike the other laws, the Land Act has a
more strict definition of a foreign company in as far as it limits
a Ugandan company to only that entity whose majority decisions
are made by Ugandans or where the company specifically limits
its ownership to Ugandans in the Articles and Memorandum of
Association.
Looking at the above laws on can say that the different laws in
Uganda have provided for different definitions of Ugandan or
foreign companies based on the objects that such laws intends
to achieve. For example the intention of the Investment Code is
to provide for favourable conditions for foreign investors investing
in Uganda, such interests maybe very different from the interests
set a law providing for local content where the interest would be
ensuring more Ugandans participate in the sector despite the fact
that the investment and capital might be by a foreign company.
16 Local Content in Oil and Gas: Legal and Policy Issues in Uganda
skill and capital to be able to run the JVs. Uganda’s businesses
are starting to get involved in the oil and gas sector and this may
hinder their ability to effectively exploit the JVs.
The two laws provide for joint venture agreements for Ugandans
to take part in the sector. However, the nature of joint ventures is
not clear. For example, the Upstream Act provides that:
Local Content in Oil and Gas: Legal and Policy Issues in Uganda
17
to have a mandatory joint venture company in which Ugandan
companies own a 48% stake, the midstream law is silent on this.
It provides
Where the goods and services are not available in Uganda, they
shall, where possible, be provided by a company which has entered
into a joint venture with a Ugandan company28.
18 Local Content in Oil and Gas: Legal and Policy Issues in Uganda
4. Determination of Local
Content, Experiences from the
Other Institutions and
Countries
A major challenge with the joint venture suggested under Uganda’s
petroleum laws is the requirement for the businesses entering into
joint venture to have same or similar capacities with the foreign
companies. The capacities needed here will basically be the need
to provide capital, skills and knowledge as well as technology. The
fact that most of the skills and technology will be provided by
foreign companies makes it easy to have joint venture companies
where Ugandan companies are merely fronted for the sake of
winning the tender and the actual work and control of business
is done by foreign companies with experience.
It is important to note that the trend across Africa and several other
developing countries has been developing specified policies, laws
and institutions for managing local content issues for oil and gas
or mining sector. Having such arrangements is aimed at ensuring
the local content requirements are properly implemented in the
extractives sector. A similar trend has been adopted by financial
institutions including the World Bank in determining the local
participation in oil, gas or mining sectors. Below is a summary
of how different institutions and countries have handled the issue
of local content
World Bank
The World Bank does not have specific provisions for local content.
However, it provides guidance for local procurement. Local
procurement here is determined based on three major pillars30
30 See World Bank (January 2012) Increasing Local Procurement By the Mining Industry in West
Africa. Report No. 66585-AFR
Local Content in Oil and Gas: Legal and Policy Issues in Uganda
19
its management (control of the company) and the number
of citizens employed in the company
ii. The level of value addition. This is based on amount of local
input in the product. This is based on use of local materials,
local technology or local human resource in the making of
the product. This test focuses on the real contribution of the
product to the economy in terms of use of local resources,
employment and technology.
iii. Whether a product is manufactured locally, or a service is
delivered locally. This focuses on the geographical location
of the company. Preference is given to companies located in
the country or in the region. Sometimes, this also deals with
the local location of the company. Companies located within
the local vicinity of the petroleum or mining establishment
are given priority.
Generally, the World Bank and AfDB standards have greatly shaped
the nature of local content laws and policies as seen in many
countries. Below are some of the recent laws and policies from
selected countries.
Nigeria
Nigeria passed the Oil and Gas Industry Content Act in 2010.
The law is meant to enforce the local content policy. It aims at
providing for the development of Nigeria Content in the Nigerian
Oil and Gas industry; for Nigerian Content Plan; for supervision,
31 African Development Bank (undated) Rules of procedure for procurement of goods and works
available at http://www.afdb.org/fileadmin/uploads/afdb/Documents/Project-related-
Procurement/Rules%20of%20procedure%20for%20procurement%20Goods%20and%20
Works.pdf accessed on 10/04/14
20 Local Content in Oil and Gas: Legal and Policy Issues in Uganda
coordination, monitoring and implementation of Nigerian content
and for matters incidental thereto32.
32 Preamble/long title to the Oil and Gas Local Content Act, 2010
Local Content in Oil and Gas: Legal and Policy Issues in Uganda
21
local content issues such as procurement information, company
requirements and involvement of citizens.
Ghana
Ghana made its local content policy in 2010. This was followed by
the Petroleum Commission Act, 201133 which gives the Minister
responsible for energy powers to make regulations for local content
and citizen participation in the oil and gas sector. The policy
provides for mandatory local content in oil and gas. The petroleum
law defines local content as:
The use of Ghanaian human and material resources, services
and businesses for the systematic development of national
capacity and capabilities for the enhancement of the Ghanaian
economy34
From the above it can be said that Ghanaian law provides for broad
areas for local content. According to the local content regulations,
at least 5% stake in the oil and gas sector must be reserved for
Ghanaian companies. An indigenous Ghanaian company is defined
as:
22 Local Content in Oil and Gas: Legal and Policy Issues in Uganda
From the above, it is clear that a local company has a strict
definition and includes such companies where citizens are the
driving engine of the company as well as are the main beneficiary
from the company. The regulations also create a Local Content
Committee whose role is to monitor compliance with the legal and
policy requirements for local content.
Liberia
Liberia passed its new petroleum law which provides for the
governance of the oil and gas sector in 2012. The law sets
conditions for involvement of local companies, training and
employment of citizens. The purchase of goods and services
from Liberian citizens is conditioned on their competitiveness.
Citizen companies and service providers must be able to effectively
compete.
Provisions like the ones above are good for the smooth running
of the industry and easily attract investment for being flexible,
however they may work against the interest of citizens since in
many African countries the local companies and citizens have not
developed much capacity to competitively compete with European,
American or Asian companies in the extractives sector. In the end
many citizens may be left out as being incompetent.
24 Local Content in Oil and Gas: Legal and Policy Issues in Uganda
Mainstream other sectors in the oil and gas and extractive business
At present, there are disjointed efforts for the oil and gas sector.
There is need to coordinate the work and activities leading to
local participation in the oil and gas sector including coordinating
sectors such as education, agriculture, fishing, tourism,
manufacturing,, transport, insurance, and other service providers.
Government should come up and mainstream the other sectors
and line them to provide goods and services or to benefit from
the oil and gas sector.
Local Content in Oil and Gas: Legal and Policy Issues in Uganda
25
References
CNOOC, Total and Tullow (2014) Planning for the future and promoting
national content: A survey to foster opportunities for Ugandans in the
Oil and Gas sector
Government of Ghana (2010) The Oil and Gas Local Content Act, 2010
26 Local Content in Oil and Gas: Legal and Policy Issues in Uganda
OECD (2001) Citizens as Partners: OECD Handbook on Information,
Consultation and Public Participation in Policy-Making. Paris: OECD.
Local Content in Oil and Gas: Legal and Policy Issues in Uganda
27
Publications in this Series
Mpeirwe, A., (2003), WTO Negotiations on Geographical Indicators: A Case
for Non-Discrimination of Products of Interest to Developing Countries.
ACODE Policy Briefing Paper, No.1, 2003. Kampala.
28 Local Content in Oil and Gas: Legal and Policy Issues in Uganda
Policy Briefing Paper, No.10, 2005. ACODE Policy Briefing Paper No. 21,
2010. Kampala.
Mugyenyi, O., Twesigye, B., and Muhereza, E., (2005), Balancing Nature
Conservation and Livelihoods: A Legal Analysis of the Forestry Evictions
by the National Forestry Authority. ACODE Policy Briefing Paper, No.13,
2005. Kampala.
Keizire, B., B., Muhwezi, W., W., Natuhwera, C., and Kayiso F., (2006),
Examining the Nexus between Nature, Wealth and Power in the Lake
George Fishery: The Case of Major Actors in the Fish Product Chain.
ACODE Policy Briefing Paper, No.15, 2006. Kampala.
Local Content in Oil and Gas: Legal and Policy Issues in Uganda
29
Naluwairo, R., and Tabaro, E., (2010), In Defense of Farmers’ and
Community Rights: Justifying their Inclusion in Uganda’s Plant Variety
Protection Legislation. ACODE Policy Briefing Paper, No.21, 2010.
Kampala.
Mugyenyi, O., and Kagarura, D., (2010), Step By Step Guidelines for
Making Ordinances and Bye Laws for Local Governments in Uganda.
ACODE Policy Briefing Paper Series No.22, 2010. Kampala.
Allen, E., P., (2011). Wil a New US Law Bring Oil Revenue Transparency
to Uganda? What the New US Dodd-Frank Act of 2010 Means for Oil and
Gas Governance. ACODE Policy Policy Briefing Paper Series, No.25, 2011.
Kampala.
Bogere, G., et.al., (2012). The Way Forward: Short- and Long-Term Policy
Responses to Uganda’s Economic Crisis. ACODE Policy Briefing Paper
Series No.26, 2012. Kampala.
30 Local Content in Oil and Gas: Legal and Policy Issues in Uganda
Local Content in Oil and Gas: Legal and Policy Issues in Uganda
31
ABOUT THE AUTHOR
32 Local Content in Oil and Gas: Legal and Policy Issues in Uganda