Women Healing From Trauma
Women Healing From Trauma
Women Healing From Trauma
University of Regina
By
Regina, Saskatchewan
November 2016
Women who have complex trauma often experience problems in acquiring necessary
resources and supports needed to manage their symptoms. It is important that all women who are
experiencing complex trauma be given the opportunity to acquire information and build skills to
There is a lack of resources and community supports specifically developed for women
experiencing complex trauma. Consequently, I created a group curriculum for the Provincial
practices that can be utilized to help women with complex trauma. After completing a literature
facilitator’s guide entitled Women Healing from Trauma: A Facilitator’s Guide. It is intended to
be a user-friendly compilation of best practices in complex trauma. This guide contains clear and
concise lesson plans for facilitators for each session of a 10-week group program.
ii
Acknowledgements
I would like to acknowledge the support and direction given by Dr. Donalda Halabuza in her role
of academic supervisor. She provided support, direction, guidance, and encouragement, and this
project would not have been completed without her assistance and direction. Dr. Gabriela
Novotna was the academic committee member and offered guidance and supervision. Crystal
Giesbrecht (MSW) was the professional associate and provided significant aid, inspiration, and
(PATHS) provided support and opportunity to converse with other professionals in the field.
Lena Tanner, an elder in the First Nations community, offered me advice and information. I am
grateful for the opportunity to build my knowledge of First Nations culture and spirituality.
I would like to acknowledge my family, especially Theresa for her patience and computer
expertise and Becky for her artistic skill. I would like to recognize the YWCA for its support and
patience as I worked through the master’s program. Finally, I would like to thank the women of
YWCA My Aunt’s Place and Kikinaw Residence in Regina. Both staff and residents were
generous with their time and always open to share information, feelings, knowledge, and
experiences. Their resilience and strength were the inspiration for the guide.
iii
Table of Contents:
Introduction .......................................................................................................................... 1
Literature Review................................................................................................................. 4
Groups ............................................................................................................................ 13
Underlying Therapies..................................................................................................... 16
Outcomes ........................................................................................................................... 17
Considerations.................................................................................................................... 18
Design ................................................................................................................................ 23
References .......................................................................................................................... 27
iv
1
Introduction
group sessions for women with multifaceted problems and complex trauma. A traumatic response
occurs when the protective survival instinct of fight, flight, or freeze is unsuccessful, leaving a
person without the ability to resist or escape from the traumatic event (Courtois, 2004; Herman,
2015). The symptoms of post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) include re-experiencing, numbing
and avoiding, and hyperarousal (Lonegan, 2014). When traumatic events occur repeatedly and
over a long period of time, it is considered complex post-traumatic symptom disorder (CPTSD)
(Courtois, 2004; Lonegan, 2014). Complex trauma is a result of traumatic events that occurred
over a long period of time on a repeated basis and for women the effects are often compounded
by the fact that the traumatic events are committed by people with whom the women have a close
relationship. When the complex trauma is a result of domestic violence, sexual exploitation,
childhood sexual abuse, or when the perpetrator has a close relationship with the victim, the
trauma is considerably more complicated and requires a different therapeutic approach. Complex
trauma occurring in the domestic domain can significantly affect an individual’s worldview,
2004; Herman, 2015). Due to societal socialization patterns and deeply held belief systems,
women are more likely than men to be the victims of violence in the domestic sphere and are
more vulnerable to sexual exploitation (Brown, 1991; Russell & Radford, 1996). Therefore,
women tend to experience complex trauma differently and more often than men (Herman, 2015).
Therapeutic interventions that focus on complex trauma need to recognize the particular
CPTSD as a result of relational violence. Marginalized women are those who are excluded from
2
conventional social, economic, cultural, and political life. Marginalized women who use
homeless shelters have difficulty accessing services and supports because they are powerless and
voiceless in society: whereas the needs of these women are immense and their demands for
services great (Jenson, 2000). Unfortunately, this population often has access only to
organizations with limited resources and are therefore unable to find adequate supports (Tseris,
2013). In Regina, such organizations are YWCA, North Central Family Centre, Street Worker’s
Advocacy Project, and Alcohol and Drug Services through Qu’Appelle Health Region. Women
Healing from Trauma: A Facilitator’s Guide (The Guide) was written to serve as an aid for
professionals who work with women with CPTSD in the first phase of healing. This manual is a
separate document from the research practicum report. It gathers best practice materials to
Background
shelter, was to facilitate groups for women. During one group meeting, while the women were
discussing self-soothing techniques, a woman recognized that she could utilize some of the skills
taught when she experienced panic attacks. She proceeded to describe her experiences. Other
women participating in the group became excited because they identified with her and had had
similar experiences and symptoms of panic attacks. It became apparent from this discussion that
the women were unaware of trauma and techniques that could be used to minimize their
suffering. During the group sessions the women acknowledged that they felt alone and confused
by their experiences. In response, we discussed panic attacks and some techniques that could be
used to relieve symptoms, but more importantly, the women learned that they were not alone or
abnormal. As a result of this experience, I determined that my master’s research practicum would
Many of the women accessing support from the YWCA’s My Aunt’s Place have been
repeatedly victimized both as children and as adults. They have often been involved in a series of
abusive relationships, addicted to alcohol or drugs, lived on the street, and had a history of child
protection involvement both as children and as mothers. Many of the women have also o
experienced homelessness, poverty, and isolation from the community and others, which
increased their trauma reactions. As a result of social exclusion, they suffer complex trauma
alone, believing they are abnormal and less than other people.
This project is based on research completed on trauma and best practices in regards to
group sessions for women. The foundation of the project is that women’s experiences with
complex trauma are significantly different than the experiences of men; therefore, therapeutic
approaches need to reflect these differences. The foundation for this research practicum
framework is based on academic research by Herman (2015), Courtois (2004), Courtois and Ford
(2013), and Cloitre and Stolbach (2002). As already stated, the intent of my research practicum
was to create a group program for women that was based on research and could be utilized by
non-profit community organizations that work with abused and homeless women. Therefore, this
guide was developed for the Provincial Association of Transition Houses Society (PATHS) for
their distribution to shelters in the province (as requested) with the goal of supporting women
with complex trauma in healing. I used the experiences of women accessing the YWCA’s My
Aunt’s Place to inform aspects of the manual so that other women could gain strength and end
their isolation.
In this research practicum paper, I describe the methods I used to create The Guide. I
began with a literature review. Initially, my focus was a broad overview of trauma literature. I
then narrowed the focus to complex trauma and the experiences of women and Aboriginal
women in particular. I also reviewed the literature on existing programs and specific treatment
4
models. In this paper, I describe the outcomes of my literature review, as well as the structure of
the group program I developed and the content for each session. Finally, I examine the
methodology used to create group sessions that reflects the voices of participants. The intent of
this paper is to examine the intellectual process that influenced the creation of Women Healing
Literature Review
I began the research practicum with a literature review of trauma with the intention of
developing a curriculum for a group that incorporates both academic research and best practices.
Initially, I reviewed books and articles that focused on a universal understanding of trauma. This
included articles written by Lonegan (2004), Rothaum and Foa (1996), Courtois (2004),
Rothaum, Meadows, Resick, and Foy (2000), Turner, McFarlane, and Vander Kolk (1996). The
focus of this research was on symptoms and treatment strategies used with individuals
experiencing both trauma and complex trauma. During the initial examination of the literature on
trauma, it became apparent that research has been completed on the experiences of women and
complex trauma. I also ascertained that programs had been developed and implemented which
incorporated and reflected research completed on women with CPTSD. After completing
research, I concluded that all the programs incorporated the same essential themes in the healing
process: skill building, building women’s self-esteem and self-compassion, expanding their
There has been significant research completed on the experiences of women with
complex trauma. Scholars such as Herman (2015), Courtois and Ford (2013), Courtois (2004),
and Russell and Radford (1992) have explored the unique experiences of women. They have
5
written groundbreaking work in the field of complex trauma and the complications of healing
The feminist movement of the 1960s and 70s exposed and highlighted the extent of abuse
that was experienced by women in the domestic sphere (Herman, 2015; Russell & Radford,
1992). As a result of this scholarship, academics began to focus on how interpersonal violence
produces emotional damage and suffering that is unlike that of any other traumatic event
(Courtois, 2004; Herman, 2015). At the present time, feminist researchers and academics
recognize that women’s trauma due to interpersonal violence is substantially different than the
trauma experienced by men, specifically that of soldiers, whose PTSD has been researched
Research suggests that significant damage is caused when there is a close relationship
between the victim and the perpetrator (Courtois & Ford, 2013). The violence and abuse that
occurs in the domestic sphere substantially changes women’s worldviews, feelings about self,
and ability to trust (Courtois, 2004; Herman, 2015). Therefore, the needs of women experiencing
complex trauma demand treatment models that recognize their unique needs.
examining the works of Brown (1991), East and Roll (2015), Russell and Radford (1992), and
Tservis (2013). Tservis (2013) wrote that there are several therapeutic approaches for trauma that
should be adapted for marginalized women. Guided by feminist perspectives, the first belief that
a psychiatric diagnosis and assessment is needed before effective treatment of trauma can occur
in the therapeutic process has been reconsidered (Tservis, 2013). Psychiatric assessments are
rarely available for underprivileged women and therefore psychiatric assessments should not be a
the solution is in building skills and strengths. Any form of treatment should consider the whole
Third, Tservis (2013) argues that trauma resulting from physical and emotional violence
needs to be considered as a societal issue and not as an individual issue. As such, supports need
to reflect larger societal factors that lead to abuse in order to help women understand their
experiences of trauma in a broader context rather than as due to their individual failure.
Fourth, trauma treatment needs to examine themes of self-blame, power, shame, gender,
and the stigma of abuse (Courtois, 2004; Herman, 2015; Tservis, 2013). Finally, interventions
manner that does not model the hierarchal and patriarchal power structures prevalent in society
but facilitated in an egalitarian and empowering manner. In this environment, the facilitator is not
the expert but an equal partner in the healing journey (Cloitre & Stolbach, 2009; Tservis, 2013).
In conclusion, because women experience trauma differently than men, they need
different interventions than men. Therapeutic interventions need to take into account the role of
trauma occurring in domestic spheres and the resulting social isolation, poverty, and societal
power structures and inequalities (Courtois & Ford, 2013; Herman, 2015; Tservis, 2013). In
addition, it is important that interventions are sensitive to societal power structures. Therefore,
groups are most effective if the group structure is based on equality and a non-authoritarian
approach. It is important for facilitators to treat women as authorities about their own experiences
Stages of Healing
Academics such as Herman (2015), Ford and Courtois (2013), and Van de Hart (2012)
argue that healing can be broken down into three distinctive phases. Some women go through the
phases sequentially, completing all three phases in order (Courtois & Ford, 2013; Herman, 2015),
while others move in and out of each phase numerous times. Some women may choose to only
focus on the first phase of healing and not complete the other two phases (Herman, 2015; Van de
The Guide is intended to support women in the first phase of healing. There are four key
aspects of the first phase of healing. First, it is important for women to focus on their personal
safety as a means of curtailing retraumatization (Courtois & Ford, 2013; Herman, 2015). Women
who experience complex trauma often continue to put themselves in unsafe environments, thus
causing retraumatization. They also choose to act or make decisions in a manner that leads to
further victimization (Herman, 2015; Van de Hart, 2012). For example, individuals may decide to
use alcohol or drugs as a means of numbing emotions and suppressing thoughts, thereby placing
themselves in unsafe places and with unsafe people. Women may also, consciously or
unconsciously, endeavor to recreate the traumatic event with the hopes of changing the outcome
(Herman, 2015). An illustration of this is when a woman unconsciously and repeatedly seeks out
relationships with men who are abusive, with the unconscious intent of having a different
outcome to the relationship. Women may also believe that the world is unsafe and therefore
danger is inevitable (Courtois, 2004; Herman, 2015). Consequently, survivors may believe there
is no value in making decisions to create safety. Exploring the reasons women continue to place
safety plan that can be utilized to end retraumatization (Herman, 2015; Van de Hart, 2012).
8
A person struggling with complex trauma often experiences emotional dysregulation (Van
frustration, and depression. Survivors are unable to regulate or manage these intense emotional
reactions, causing problems in their personal lives and in their relationships with people
(Courtois, 2004). Learning how to manage emotional dysregulation will lead to an improvement
in their quality of life and in their ability to achieve personal goals (Courtois, 2004; Van de Hart,
2012). Building competency in emotional management includes specific skills such as self-
soothing and relaxation techniques (Courtois, 2004). Therefore, the second focus for women in
Women who have complex trauma often feel like they are abnormal or “crazy.” They tend
to perceive themselves as weak, failures, or social misfits (Courtois & Ford, 2013). Victims
internalize negative and destructive beliefs often acquired from their perpetrators, and as a result
they have low self-esteem, self-worth, and self-confidence (Courtois & Ford, 2013; Herman,
2015). Rather than perceiving these symptoms as normal reactions to abnormal situations, the
survivor views herself as a failure in being able to fit in or experience a normal life (Herman,
2015; Van de Hart, 2012). During this first phase of healing, it is important to promote self-
Women who have complex trauma are often isolated and alone. They have trouble
trusting, feeling close to, or communicating with others (Courtois & Ford, 2013). They have
needs and wants (Najavits, 2009). As a result of relational trauma, these women have a limited
ability to trust and develop lasting and fulfilling relationships with others (Courtois & Ford,
2013; Herman, 2015; Van de Hart, 2012). As a result, they do not have social supports that can
be used as a foundation for healing (Herman, 2015; Van de Hart, 2012). Developing the skills
9
and capacity to connect with others decreases isolation and helps women rebuild their lives
(Herman, 2015).
loss, altering perceptions and behaviors, and integrating skills (Courtois, 2004). In this phase of
healing, an individual focuses on building life stability. Attention is focused on telling their own
life story and recreating and reclaiming their narrative (Herman, 2015). The narrative may
include events, individuals, and particulars of their traumatization with the intention of
integrating this experience into their lives. The focus is also on disconnecting from the emotional
aspects of their experiences (Courtois, 2004). In the second phase, women continue to build on
their skills by participating in role plays, gaining more information, and integrating what has been
learned into their lives (Monson & Shnaider, 2014). During this phase of healing, it is beneficial
to utilize exposure and narrative therapies, to create meaning, and to detach from the traumatic
events (Courtois, 2004). This phase can also focus on mourning and accepting the long-term
aftereffects of the trauma (Courtois, 2004). Women may also increase their skills to regulate
The third phase of healing is a continuation of the first two phases, focusing on
developing a new, stronger self. This state centers on empowering the survivor and building
psychological and physiological mastery (Courtois & Ford, 2013; Herman, 2015). Survivors
concentrate on living the new narrative that was developed in earlier phases, strengthening skills,
and maintaining safety (Herman, 2015). The third phase centers on continuing the journey by
reconnecting with others, learning to trust, and seeking friendships (Courtois & Ford, 2013).
Aboriginal Perspectives
create programs that integrate Aboriginal cultures and perspectives. Aboriginal peoples continue
10
to struggle with the “destructive legacy of colonization” (Truth and Reconciliation Commission,
2015). Sexual and physical abuse, separation from families and communities, the loss of
parenting skills, and the destruction of a cultural identity occurred during colonization, residential
schools, and the 1960s scoop, causing significant damage to the Aboriginal population (Truth and
Reconciliation Commission, 2015). The lasting effect of residential schools has led to extensive
The Truth and Reconciliation Commission of Canada (2015) calls for programs and
organizations to recognize Aboriginal healing practices and to work in collaboration with First
Nations healers and elders. Therefore, it is important to recognize the needs of Aboriginal women
in all treatment services. Integrating traditional healing methods and western therapeutic models
is important to meet the needs of First Nation’s women (Heibron & Guttman, 2000). My
literature review included Aboriginal researchers’ and academics’ perspectives such as Ferrara
(2004), Heibron and Guttman (2000), and Isaak, Stewart, and Mota (2015).
women. Integrating traditional healing with western therapeutic models is important to meet their
needs (Heibron & Guttman, 2000). First, it is important to create an atmosphere and use a
leadership model that is comfortable for all participants in order for the group to be successful.
Leadership should not be hierarchical, rather, it should be a group of equal participants consistent
with feminist approaches (Heibron & Guttman, 2000). The facilitator should guide the
conversation but not control the group (Heibron & Guttman, 2000). Second, communication
styles vary within many Aboriginal groups and this needs to be respected when working in a
feelings (Ferrara, 2004). Therefore, it is important to ensure the women feel safe before asking
questions and to allow time for their response. Groups will benefit if women have control over
11
the pace and tone of the conversation (Ferrara, 2004). Finally, it is also important to note
positions of privilege. Group facilitators need to be aware of their positions of privilege and how
this may affect participants’ interpretation of the leaders’ behaviours in regards to power,
Culture and cultural identity is a source of healing, strength, and resilience and needs to
be integrated into the group format (Isaak, Stewart, & Mota, 2015). In communities involved in
healing, recovery may be a group process and not an individual endeavour. Therefore, services
should be offered with the support of the individual, family, and community (Ferrara, 2004).
Because healing is a community experience for many First Nations populations, group
interventions are often preferred rather than one-on-one counselling (Isaak et al., 2015).
There are three main subthemes in Aboriginal healing: turning points, connections and
reconnections, and moving forward (Isaak et al., 2015). It is important that these three subthemes
are recognized and integrated when designing interventions. A turning point is when the
participant wants to move on from the current situation and seek aid from others. In many cases,
this is the time when people reach out for support from groups or agencies. They are ready to
The second subtheme is connections and reconnections with culture, traditional teachings,
or spirituality. Connections to community and spiritual traditions are central to healing and need
The third theme is moving forward, which includes acceptance of the past, recognizing
strengths, and communicating dreams for the future. Interventions at this phase need to focus on
goal setting and supporting individuals who communicate hope, self-compassion, and self-
Traditional healing circles, led by an elder who can conduct a healing circle and a
purification ceremony, should be utilized for in-group programs whenever possible. A plant
(sage, sweet grass, cedar, or tobacco) is burnt at the beginning of the ceremony (Heibron &
Guttman, 2000). Each person participating in the circle removes jewellery and glasses and then
proceeds to place the smoke over their head, face, shoulder, and then entire body in prayer
(Heibron & Guttman, 2000; L. Tanner, personal communication, January 16, 2016). Members
come together to give thanks for the opportunity to speak honestly about their concerns and
feelings (Heibron & Guttman, 2000; L. Tanner, personal communication, January 16, 2016).
Women participating in the circle will then pass a scared object, often a stone, to another member
to start the talking circle when the group is having a check in. In Cree traditions, the circle should
progress in a clockwise fashion, representing the cycle of life (L. Tanner, personal
communication, January 16, 2016). When passing the sacred object around the circle, only the
person holding it is allowed to speak. After everyone has been given an opportunity to speak, the
scared object or stone is be placed in the middle of the circle. The talking circle can build an
environment of respectful dialogue, creating a bond of trust and a safe place for honest discussion
(Heibron & Guttman, 2000; L. Tanner, personal communication, January 16, 2016). The circle is
a unifying symbol in Aboriginal culture representing connectedness, equality, balance, and the
cycle of life (Heibron & Guttman, 2000). If it is not possible to include an elder in the group,
incorporating aspects of the talking circle is an important means of showing respect to both the
traditions and teachings of Aboriginal participants (L. Tanner, personal communication, January
16, 2016).
The concept of balance is important to First Nations culture; therefore, healing should
focus on including the spiritual, emotional, physical, and mental aspects of self in each session
(L. Tanner, personal communication, January 16, 2016). If only one facet is being focused on in
13
treatment while ignoring the others, services will not support healing and strength because there
will not be a balance (Heibron & Guttman, 2000). Therefore, in order to encourage balance in the
healing process group sessions need to include all four aspects of the individual (Heibron &
Guttman, 2000).
styles, the role of the leader, the importance of the circle, the three themes of healing, and the
show respect for Aboriginal culture and community in order to create a curriculum that benefits,
Groups
I next researched the structuring of groups for women with complex trauma. Some of the
information is found in the research conducted by Herman (2015), Courtois (2004), Courtois and
Ford (2013), and Ford and Russo (2006). I also examined articles written by Najavits, Weiss, and
Liese (1996), Van der Kolk, McFarlane, and Van der Kolk (1996), and Cloitre and Stolbach
(2009) These authors examined the specific needs of women with complex trauma and best
During the first phase of healing, it is important that women are safe, create community,
gain skills, and identify their strengths (Herman, 2015; Van de Hart, 2012). Groups can be
particularly successful at this stage of healing. Group work can focus on the psychoeducational
needs of survivors by making trauma information available to participants (Cloitre & Stolbach,
2009). Groups can also help women who have similar problems to learn social skills, which will
strengthen their ability to participate in healthy relationships (Herman, 2015; Van de Hart, 2012).
Finally, groups that emphasize individual women’s strength will empower and bolster
participants’ confidence (Cloitre, Koenen, & Cohen, 2002). Group work dynamics need to
14
encourage self-compassion and build self-esteem, which in turn will increase the women’s
In my literature review, I also came across information on how to develop and run groups
for women with complex trauma. Due to the complexity of trauma, it is essential to establish
structures and boundaries that will create and maintain emotional safety, including rules and the
Treatment Models
The next step in my research was to examine other programs that have been developed,
implemented, and researched. These included Skills and Training Affective and Interpersonal
Regulation (STAIR; Levitt & Cloitre, 2005), Trauma Recovery and Empowerment Model
(TREM; Fallot & Harris, 2002), Trauma Affect Regulation: Guide for Education and Therapy
(TARGET; Ford & Russo, 2006), and Seeking Safety (Najavits, Weiss & Liese, 1996). These
programs had similar structures, themes, and objectives, but subtle differences in the use and
emphases of particular therapies. I examined academic work that was used to create these
programs including Levitt and Cloitre (2005), Najavits, Weiss, and Liese (1996), Ford and Russo
(2006), and Fallot and Harris (2002), as well as research completed in regards to the outcome of
these programs.
therapy (DBT). This program addresses three core issues that are experienced by women with
complex trauma. These core problems are emotional regulation, PTSD and CPTSD symptoms,
and interpersonal problems. This program is based on providing emotional stabilization, building
relationship skills, and addressing everyday functioning (Levitt & Cloitre, 2005).
TREM is a group program that focuses on reducing the symptoms of PTSD and
increasing recovery skills. TREM is founded on four core beliefs: dysfunctional behaviours were
15
developed to cope with abnormal circumstances; long term abuse affects the development of
coping strategies; sexual and physical abuse fundamentally affects relationships with family,
community, and self; and women who have experienced complex trauma feel powerless (Fallot
& Harris, 2002). There are 11 areas of skill development: self-awareness, self-protection, self-
soothing, emotional modulation, building relationships, labeling of self and others, gaining a
sense of agency, problem solving, parenting, finding purpose and meaning, judgement, and
TARGET is founded on the participants’ desire for safety, hope, and community (Ford &
Focus through the use of the acronym SOS: (S)low down—pause and take a breath, clearing
brain and controlling impulses; (O)rient yourself—pay attention to the five senses,
feeling? what are your stress levels? your cognitive responses and reactions? (first phase);
Emotional regulation;
Options;
management.
The third phase of TARGET is founded on lifestyle choices, values, goals, and identifying
future plans to manage emotions (Ford & Russo, 2006). The aim is to create plans and learn
16
techniques that can be used to prevent dysfunctional reactions in harmless situations (Ford &
Russo, 2006).
Seeking Safety is a program designed for women who have experienced interpersonal
violence, complex trauma, and substance abuse (Najavits, Weiss, & Liese, 1996). This program
is designed to support women in their recovery from both the trauma and their addictions
(Najavits, 2009). It is based on CBT but also includes a psychoeducational component. The CBT
aspects of Seeking Safety include impulse control, grounding, problem solving, anger
coping strategies (Najavits, Weiss, & Liese, 1996). In this program, four spheres are explored:
cognitive, behavioural, interpersonal, and case management (Najavits, 2009). Topics covered in
the groups are honesty, asking for help, compassion, healthy relationships, self-care, creating
Underlying Therapies
different therapies in order to determine the strengths and weaknesses of each one. The intent was
to create a program that I believed would best meet the needs of women participating in a group.
Therefore, I examined narrative therapy, acceptance and commitment therapy (ACT), art therapy,
drama therapy, mindfulness, CBT, including stress innoculation training (SIT), progressive
exposure therapy (PE), cognitive processing (CP) and eye movement desensitization and
workbooks and self-help sheets that were utilized as homework or for group activities. I found
workbooks on specific topics such as anger (McKay & Rogers, 2000), panic attacks and
disassociation (Monson & Schaider, 2014), communication (Paterson, 2000), fighting fair
17
(Schmidt & Friedman, 1998), meditation (Metta Institute, 2015) and mindfulness (Flowers,
then allowed my research to progress to specific material. I noted a number of academics who
were widely deemed as experts in the field of women’s trauma and their research was extensively
used by others, this included Herman (2015), Courtois and Ford (2004), Cloitre and Stolbach
(2009), Najavits (2009), and Van der Kolk, McFarlane, and Van der Kolk (1996). Based on these
works, I set the direction for my research practicum, and by narrowing my review of the research,
I was able to develop a strong academic foundation for the therapies and activities in The Guide.
Outcomes
Women Healing from Trauma: A Facilitator’s Guide, which I developed and is based on both
academic literature and lived experiences of women who have been marginalized. This section
will outline the specifics of The Guide, including an overview of the intent and content of all ten
consultation with a Cree elder, and open dialogues with women who used the services at My
Aunt’s Place.
As previously stated, the aim of my research practicum was to design an easy to use, clear,
and concise facilitator’s guide. The Guide includes a section that explains complex trauma, its
symptoms, phases of healing, and the connection between the mind and body. It also examines
the particular needs of women experiencing complex trauma and the inclusion of Aboriginal
perspectives. The Guide consists of an outline for ten group sessions. Each of the ten sessions has
a clearly defined rationale, weekly objective, activity sheets, learning opportunities, and
homework. The sessions are not to be used in individual counselling sessions but rather in a
18
group that is focused on helping women gain the skills and information necessary during the first
phase of healing.
There are a number of objectives set out for each session of The Guide. The overall
relationships and social skills and sharing information about trauma and inclusion in a
community. Group activities include teaching specific skills such as assertiveness, safety
planning, breathing techniques, healthy communication, and mindfulness. The Guide also
Considerations
I am a white, middle-class, social worker and I have not been a victim of violence nor
have I been homeless, and I am not Aboriginal. Therefore, it was necessary for me to educate
myself on how to incorporate the voices of Aboriginal women participants in The Guide. I knew
from experience that it would be essential for the group process to reflect the perspectives of
academics on best practices and therapeutic approaches. In addition, I worked with a female Cree
elder for additional advice and aid. She was extremely supportive and open to discussing and
It is easy to become swamped with research and information found in books and scholarly
papers and in doing so to ignore the voices and needs of individuals who will utilize the program.
Therefore, The Guide focuses on hands-on techniques that can be easily used by a wide variety of
participants. The activities and topics were developed with the intent of supporting the particular
needs of marginalized women. I integrated the information acquired by speaking with women
who will eventually utilize the program. In this way, women with lived experience became a
19
fundamental instrument in building a guide that can be utilized by women struggling with
complex trauma.
I wanted to ensure that the voices of experience were included in the formation of
sessions for the group. To this end, I included my own experiences of working with women at
My Aunt’s Place and the knowledge I gained while working there. I also utilized the advice,
input, stories, and lived experiences of women who had been in the shelter to inform The Guide.
By including their voices and experiences of the group work, I was able to ensure that
participants and their experiences would give meaning and depth to The Guide. Finally, The
Guide includes ample opportunities for discussions so that group participants can share their
The first session sets the tone and intentions for the entire group program. In the first
meeting, group rules and expectations will be established. Predictability and clear guidelines are
especially important for people struggling with complex trauma and are important means of
establishing healthy boundaries and safety within the group (Courtois, 2004). Once the basic
structure of the group is determined, the discussion will center on goal setting and the importance
Session two examines the reasons safety is an issue for survivors, ways women re-create
the trauma, and how to regain a sense of safety. This session will also examine safety planning
because once a woman chooses to focus on safety, her feelings of powerlessness, vulnerability,
and isolation decrease. In this session, the group will discuss what women can do to regain a
thoughts, and finding and maintaining sobriety. The activity in this session is to create safety
plans that will assist the women as they consider situations, people, or behaviours that are risky.
20
Numbing, hyperarousal, hypervigilance and intrusive thoughts are constant symptoms for
women with complex trauma (Herman, 2015; Lonegan, 2014). Therefore, the intention of the
third session is to recognize emotional dysregulation and develop skills necessary to manage
emotions. Failure to manage intense emotions is the prime reason some women become
emotionally flat and disconnected, that is, avoiding their feelings (Herman, 2015; Van de Hart,
2012), and participants will be asked to consider this in terms of their own experiences. The
trauma), affective destabilization (emotional instability), and relationship difficulties (Courtois &
Ford, 2013). This session ends with a Safe Place Meditation, which connects the mind and body.
There are two benefits to meditation. First, the mind unwinds and centers on a safe place, the
breath slows down and deepens, and the body relaxes. (Birnie, Speca, & Carlson, 2010). Second,
participants gain control over their physical reactions, which is empowering and strengthens their
The objective of the fourth session is to help the participants become cognizant of their
personal triggers and to learn how to use skills that minimize negative reactions. The rationale of
these objectives is that women with complex trauma become overwhelmed when triggered,
feeling intense fight, flight, and freeze responses (Courtois & Ford, 2013; Herman, 2015).
Triggers, such as events, objects, smells, places, or sounds, elicit feelings of anxiety, fear, anger,
or frustration even when the triggers themselves are harmless (Boon, Steele, & Van der Hart,
2011; Ford & Russo, 2006). However, the individual’s response to the experience of being
triggered can be traumatizing (Courtois, 2004). In this session, helping women to recognize
triggers and how they affect thoughts, emotional responses, physical symptoms, and behavioural
reactions is the key to helping them learn how to manage inappropriate actions or feelings.
21
Emotional regulation becomes impaired when individuals experience trauma and respond
with anger, which is an adaptive reaction to dangerous environments (Chemtob, Novaco, &
Hamada, 1997), therefore, the fifth session will focus on helping participants monitor their
thoughts, recognize signs of arousal, and implement productive coping strategies. Anger is
activated when an individual feels threatened and once triggered, anger impairs their ability to
self-monitor and process complex information (Chemtob et al., 1997). Anger can impede a
woman’s ability to participate in healthy relationships, express emotions appropriately, and make
The sixth session will deal with how emotional regulation leads to a healthier lifestyle
and the attainment of personal goals. It focuses on how anxiety and panic attacks interfere with
ordinary life experiences. This session teaches techniques that can help women manage
symptoms rather than avoiding situations or circumstances that trigger anxiety and panic attacks.
As Courtois (2004) has shown, acceptance of their emotions and building skills tends to decrease
The seventh session will focus on building self-compassion, empathy, and self-esteem
and includes a number of activities that help with this. Women who have survived abuse and
neglect often experience profound low self-esteem, self-hatred, and a lack of confidence
(Herman, 2015). They also feel betrayed, rejected, and abandoned by others (Cloitre & Stolbach,
2009). Many women who have experienced complex trauma adopt feelings of shame, guilt, and
humiliation because of their experiences (Banks, Newman, & Saleem, 2015). These emotions
lead to harsh judgement on oneself and self-criticism. Women also internalize statements learned
from the abuser, including that they are responsible for the abuse and that they are worthlessness
Women who have experienced abuse and trauma often struggle with creating and
maintaining healthy relationships (Courtois, 2004; Herman, 2015; Levitt & Cloitre, 2005). The
ability to connect with others in a healthy manner is disrupted as a result of abuse, neglect, or
trauma. Therefore, survivors often struggle with the ability to trust others, becoming intimate,
and maintaining healthy emotional connections (Courtois, 2004; Herman, 2015). Given these
realities, the intention of session eight is to discuss abusive personalities and why individuals
stay with abusive partners. The session will focus on boundaries, what are healthy relationships,
who have experienced trauma often have unhealthy communication patterns in their relationships
and do not possess the confidence to successfully assert their needs and wants (Paterson, 2000).
Survivors can sometimes surrender to the demands of others but then become resentful or angry.
Developing the skills to communicate personal needs and wants in an assertive manner will
The final session will focus on creating a relapse management plan that can be utilized by
recovery (Courtois, 2004; Herman, 2015; Levitt & Cloitre, 2005; Najavits, 2009). Therefore,
when discussing relapse management plans these discussions often include specifics such as
substance abuse, depression, anger, isolation, returning to an abusive partner, and anxiety. An
effective relapse plan examines signs of a relapse such as altered sleep patterns, anger, and
craving for or use of substances (Najavits, 2009). Relapse management plans also include an
examination of actions, thoughts, and feelings that lead to setbacks. The intent of the final session
is to draw attention to the strengths of participants and the relationships that have been built.
23
Design
As stated earlier in the report, I facilitate an informal group for women who stay at My
Aunt’s Place. The women who utilize the shelter have often experienced considerable trauma,
the streets, and childhood abuse. They also manage problems that arise because of poverty,
and child protection. Most women do not reside at my My Aunt’s House for more than a month
and often return to dangerous and unstable situations. Therefore, for these women, I used selected
sections of the material that I developed for The Guide in-group session, including safety
planning, domestic violence and panic attacks. The group participants were encouraged to
critique the content and how the information was presented. They were also urged to share their
knowledge and skills in regards to these topics. Through the generosity and kindness of the
women at the shelter, I was able to deepen and strengthen The Guide based on their experiences
and thoughts.
At the beginning of the research practicum, I had a clear sense of the target population
and the subject matter. As a result of my experience, I determined that many women needed
information, skills, and group support in order to manage the symptoms of trauma. After I
completed the literature review, I completed an environmental scan, examining both the
programs available in Regina and gaps in available resources and programming for marginalized
women in non-profit agencies and government agencies in regards to trauma. The available
programs are Four Directions Community Health Centre, Street Worker’s Advocacy Project,
Addictions Services, North Central Family Centre, Regina Immigrant Women Centre, Family
Service Regina, Catholic Family Services, The Circle Project, and Prairie Spirits Connections.
These agencies all have group programs dealing with specific issues such as addictions, anger
24
organization offers group sessions or counselling that focus on trauma and its consequences.
I also worked with a female Cree elder to gather information on cultural aspects of
healing and how to support Aboriginal women through the therapeutic process in a culturally
sensitive manner. She was generous with her time, suggestions, and perspectives. We discussed
therapeutic approaches and cultural content. The elder then reviewed each session contained in
The Guide to ensure that it was accurate. Through her guidance, I was able to understand the
importance of the spiritual aspects of healing and balancing all aspects of self in the recovery
process. She also aided in my understanding of talking circles and how they could be utilized in
groups.
Once The Guide was completed, my professional associate agreed that it was to be
presented it at the PATHS 2016 conference in May 2016. At the conference, I met with other
professionals who worked with women with complex trauma who wanted to use The Guide to
develop group work in their organizations. I have agreed to facilitate a group for the Immigrant
Women Center on trauma, with the intent of incorporating the voices of immigrant women into
the sessions. I have also been given the opportunity through my current employer at YWCA to
facilitate a group using The Guide in its entirely. Through this experience, I am hoping to
Women who live with complex trauma experience a fundamental alteration to their
worldview, the capacity to trust, to connect to others, and to self-regulate (Courtois 2004;
Herman, 2015) Therefore, their ability to have the life that they dream of is substantially
damaged. Women Healing from Trauma: A Facilitator’s Guide is meant to be used in the first
phase of services. It is intended to end the isolation of women with complex trauma and to help
25
them develop the skills necessary to manage symptoms of complex trauma. With support,
understanding, and evidence-based services, women can escape the confines of domestic
violence, childhood abuse, sexual abuse, and exploitation. The intent of my research practicum
was to develop a curriculum that could be used for in-group work to support women through the
I hope that all 10 sessions of The Guide will be used and then modified or adjusted to
meet the particular needs of participants. As previously mentioned, I intend to use The Guide to
run a group with the objective of evaluating both the content and how to implement the group
sessions. The intent is to make improvements based on participant feedback. After an entire 10
sessions have been facilitated, I can make adjustments before sharing it with other agencies. It is
my intent not only to provide services based on The Guide, but in my role at the YWCA, to
support other agencies in the creation of programs for women that focus on trauma. These
services may include using The Guide in its entirety or in parts based on the particular needs of
the women using those services and the financial limitations of organizations.
The Guide is intended for the beginning of a healing journey. Unfortunately, due to the
lack of resources, its group sessions may be the only support some woman will ever receive.
There are few group or counselling services that can be used by marginalized women that are
free, easily accessible, culturally relevant, and comfortable for them. There are a number of
groups in the community that focus on addictions or anger management but nothing that
examines the complications of complex trauma in a holistic manner. Therefore, women may
complete these group sessions and have nowhere else to go for ongoing services. Ideally, there
need to be services for phases two and three of the healing process. Services in the second and
third phases would aid women through support groups, individual one-on-one counselling, and
alternative therapies, such as art or drama therapy. A group based on The Guide would be a good
26
beginning, but more resources need to be added to the spectrum of programs that provide
ongoing support for women with complex trauma. In conclusion, women need supports that can
aid in their healing from complex trauma. Without supports women will continue to have
References
Banks, K., Newman, E., & Saleem, J. (2015). An overview of the research on mindfulness-based
Birnie, K., Speca, M., & Carlson, L. (2010). Exploring self-compassion and empathy in the
context of mindfulness based on stress reduction (MBSR). Stress and Health, 26(5), 359–
371.
Boon, S., Steele, K., & Van der Hart, O. (2011). Coping with trauma-related dissociation: Skills
training for patients and therapists. New York: W. W. Morton & Company.
Brown, L. (1991). Not outside the range: One feminist perspective on psychic trauma. American
Chemtob, C., Novaco, R., & Hamada, R. (1997). Anger regulation deficits in combat-related
Cloitre, M., Koenen, K., & Cohen, L. (2002). Skills training in affective and interpersonal
Cloitre, M., & Stolbach, B. (2009). A developmental approach to complex PTSD: Childhood and
Courtois, C., & Ford, J. (2013). Treatment of complex trauma: A sequenced relationship-based
East, J. F., & Roll, S. (2015). Women, poverty and trauma: An empowerment practice approach.
Social Work: A Journal of the National Association of Social Work, 60(4), 279–286.
Fallot, R., McHugo, G., Harris, M., & Xie, H (2011). The trauma recovery and empowerment
89.
Ferrara, N. (2004). Healing through art: A ritualized space and Cree identity. Montreal: McGill-
Flowers, S., Kabat-Zinn, J. M., Santorelli, S., & Kornfield, J. (2016). Mindfulness-based stress
http://alumni.iupui.edu/associations/socialwork/2016handouts/Mindfulness%20-
%20Lauren%20Hall/MBSR-Workbook.pdf
approach to integrated treatment for PTSD and addiction: Trauma adaptive recovery
335–357.
Heibron, C., & Guttman, M. (2000). Traditional healing methods with First Nation women in-
Herman, J. (2015). Trauma and recovery: The aftermath of violence—from domestic abuse to
Isaak, C., Stewart, D., & Mota, P. (2015). Surviving, healing and moving forward: Journeys
toward resilience among Canadian Cree adults. The International Journal of Social
Jenson, J. (2000). Thinking about marginalization: What, who and why. Canadian Policy
Levitt, J., & Cloitre, M. (2005). A clinician’s guide to STAIR/MPE: Treatment for PTSD related
Lonegan, M. (2014). Cognitive behavioural therapy for PTSD: The role of complex PTSD on
McKay, M., & Rogers, P. (2000). The anger control workbook: Simple, innovative techniques for
managing anger and developing healthier ways of relating. New York: New Harbinger
Publications Inc.
Monson, C., & Shnaider, P. (2014). Treating PTSD with cognitive-behavioral therapies:
Najavits, L., Weiss, R., & Liese, B. (1996). Group cognitive-behavioral therapy for women and
Najavits, L. (2009). Psychotherapies for trauma and substance abuse in women: Review and
Newman, E., Riggs, D., & Roth, S. (1997). Thematic resolution, PTSD and complex PTSD: The
10(2), 197–213.
Paterson, R. (2000). The assertiveness workbook: How to express yourself at work and in
Rothaum, B., & Foa, E. (1996). Cognitive behavioural therapy. In B. Van der Kolk, A.
experience on mind, body and society (pp. 491-510). New York, NY: Guilford Press.
Rothaum, B., Meadows, E., Resick, P., & Foy, D. (2000). Cognitive-behavioural therapy. In E.
Foa, T. Keanne, & M. Friedman (Eds.), Effective treatment for PTSD: Practice guidelines
30
from the international society for traumatic stress studies (pp. 139–223). New York: The
Guilford Press.
Russell, D., & Radford, J. (1992). Femicide: Speaking the unspeakable. New York: Maxwell
Macmillan Inc.
Schmidt, F., & Friedman, A (1989). Fighting fair for families. New York: Peace Education
Foundation.
The Truth and Reconciliation Commission of Canada (2015). Truth and Reconciliation report:
http://nctr.ca/assets/reports/Final%20Reports/Executive_Summary_English_Web.pdf.
Turner, S., McFarlane, A., & Van der Kolk, B. (1996). The therapeutic environment and new
(Eds.), Traumatic stress: The effects of overwhelming experience on mind, body and
Van de Hart, O. (2012) The use of imagery in phase 1 treatment of clients with complex
Van der Kolk, B., McFarlane, A., & Van der Kolk, O. (1996) A general approach to treatment of
PTSD. In B. Van der Kolk, A. McFarlane, & L. Weisaebether (Eds.), Traumatic stress:
The effects of overwhelming experience on mind, body and society (pp. 417–441). New