This article was downloaded by: [FU Berlin]

On: 24 June 2015, At: 15:43

Publisher: Taylor & Francis
Informa Ltd Registered in England and Wales Registered Number: 1072954 Registered office: Mortimer House,
37-41 Mortimer Street, London W1T 3JH, UK

Journal of Environmental Science and Health, Part B:

Pesticides, Food Contaminants, and Agricultural Wastes
Publication details, including instructions for authors and subscription information:
http://www.tandfonline.com/loi/lesb20

Fungicide sensitivity of Trichoderma spp. from Agaricus

bisporus farms in Serbia
a b c c b
Dejana Kosanović , Ivana Potočnik , Jelena Vukojević , Mirjana Stajić , Emil Rekanović ,
b b
Miloš Stepanović & Biljana Todorović
a
Institute of Virology, Vaccines and Sera “Torlak,” Belgrade, Serbia
b
Institute of Pesticides and Environmental Protection, Belgrade-Zemun, Serbia
c
Institute of Botany, Faculty of Biology, University of Belgrade, Belgrade, Serbia
Published online: 11 Jun 2015.

Click for updates

To cite this article: Dejana Kosanović, Ivana Potočnik, Jelena Vukojević, Mirjana Stajić, Emil Rekanović, Miloš Stepanović
& Biljana Todorović (2015) Fungicide sensitivity of Trichoderma spp. from Agaricus bisporus farms in Serbia, Journal of
Environmental Science and Health, Part B: Pesticides, Food Contaminants, and Agricultural Wastes, 50:8, 607-613, DOI:
10.1080/03601234.2015.1028849

To link to this article: http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/03601234.2015.1028849

PLEASE SCROLL DOWN FOR ARTICLE

Taylor & Francis makes every effort to ensure the accuracy of all the information (the “Content”) contained
in the publications on our platform. However, Taylor & Francis, our agents, and our licensors make no
representations or warranties whatsoever as to the accuracy, completeness, or suitability for any purpose of the
Content. Any opinions and views expressed in this publication are the opinions and views of the authors, and
are not the views of or endorsed by Taylor & Francis. The accuracy of the Content should not be relied upon and
should be independently verified with primary sources of information. Taylor and Francis shall not be liable for
any losses, actions, claims, proceedings, demands, costs, expenses, damages, and other liabilities whatsoever
or howsoever caused arising directly or indirectly in connection with, in relation to or arising out of the use of
the Content.

This article may be used for research, teaching, and private study purposes. Any substantial or systematic
reproduction, redistribution, reselling, loan, sub-licensing, systematic supply, or distribution in any
form to anyone is expressly forbidden. Terms & Conditions of access and use can be found at http://
www.tandfonline.com/page/terms-and-conditions
 Journal of Environmental Science and Health, Part B (2015) 50, 607–613
Copyright © Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
ISSN: 0360-1234 (Print); 1532-4109 (Online)
DOI: 10.1080/03601234.2015.1028849

Fungicide sensitivity of Trichoderma spp. from Agaricus

bisporus farms in Serbia

DEJANA KOSANOVIC
1, IVANA POTOCNIK

 2
3, MIRJANA STAJIC
, JELENA VUKOJEVIC
3,

2 
2
EMIL REKANOVIC , MILOS STEPANOVIC and BILJANA TODOROVIC
2

1
Institute of Virology, Vaccines and Sera “Torlak,” Belgrade, Serbia
2
Institute of Pesticides and Environmental Protection, Belgrade-Zemun, Serbia
3
Institute of Botany, Faculty of Biology, University of Belgrade, Belgrade, Serbia
Downloaded by [FU Berlin] at 15:43 24 June 2015

Trichoderma species, the causal agents of green mould disease, induce great losses in Agaricus bisporus farms. Fungicides are widely
used to control mushroom diseases although green mould control is encumbered with difficulties. The aims of this study were,
therefore, to research in vitro toxicity of several commercial fungicides to Trichoderma isolates originating from Serbian and Bosnia-
Herzegovina farms, and to evaluate the effects of pH and light on their growth. The majority of isolates demonstrated optimal
growth at pH 5.0, and the rest at pH 6.0. A few isolates also grew well at pH 7. The weakest mycelial growth was noted at pH 8.0–
9.0. Generally, light had an inhibitory effect on the growth of tested isolates. The isolates showed the highest susceptibility to
chlorothalonil and carbendazim (ED50 less than 1 mg L¡1), and were less sensitive to iprodione (ED50 ranged 0.84–6.72 mg L¡1),
weakly resistant to thiophanate-methyl (ED50 D 3.75–24.13 mg L¡1), and resistant to trifloxystrobin (ED50 D 10.25–178.23 mg
L¡1). Considering the toxicity of fungicides to A. bisporus, carbendazim showed the best selective toxicity (0.02), iprodione and
chlorothalonil moderate (0.16), and thiophanate-methyl the lowest (1.24), while trifloxystrobin toxicity to A. bisporus was not tested
because of its inefficiency against Trichoderma isolates.
Keywords: Green mould disease, antifungal activity, cultivated mushroom.

Introduction T. aggressivum accounted for mushroom yield losses of

between 60% and 100%.[3,4] It first appeared in the British
World production of button mushrooms is over 3 million Isles (T. aggressivum f. europaeum) and North America
tons annually. European countries account for 50% of the (T. aggressivum f. aggressivum), and then spread into
overall world production, of which 87% belong to EU mushroom farms all over Western Europe over the next
countries and 13% to countries outside the EU.[1] The few years.[3,5–10] During the past decade, the pathogen has
most important fungal pathogens of edible mushrooms are dispersed into Central and South East Europe, Central
Trichoderma species, such as Trichoderma harzianum, Tri- America and Australia.[2,11–15] Green mould caused by
choderma atroviride, Trichoderma koningii, Trichoderma Trichoderma spp. is characterized by white mycelia of fast-
virens, etc., which are present in mushroom beds and have growing colonies on casing or substrate that change color
different abilities to cause disease.[2] In the 1990s, T. to green after profuse sporulation. Spots on fruiting bodies
aggressivum appeared and reached epidemic proportions. appear in the advanced stage of disease, while basidiocarps
Unlike other Trichoderma species whose mycelium formed fail to form during a serious outbreak.[3]
concentric rings after sporulation, the isolates of T. aggres- Disease control in mushroom farms worldwide includes
sivum f. europium formed white pustules, and had larger application of only a few fungicides. Prochloraz manga-
conidia and faster growth rate than T. harzianum. A phy- nese has been officially recommended in mushroom indus-
logenetic analysis showed that T. harzianum was most try in Europe, and chlorothalonil, thiabendazol and
closely related to the aggressive mushroom colonizer T. thiophanate-methyl in North America.[16,17] However,
aggressivum f. europaeum.[2] Green mould caused by there is still no solution for the green mould disease on
mushrooms. No fungicide has been registered for use on
mushrooms in Serbia, but Serbian growers nevertheless
Address correspondence to Ivana Potocnik, Institute of Pesti- frequently apply fungicides registered for other crops, such
cides and Environmental Protection, Banatska 31b, Belgrade as carbendazim, thiophanate-methyl and prochloraz man-
11080, Serbia; E-mail: ivana.potocnik@pesting.org.rs ganese.[18] In a previous study, prochloraz manganese and
Received January 2, 2015. Bacillus subtilis were found to be highly toxic to Serbian
 608 Kosanovi

c et al.

Trichoderma isolates, while tea tree oil did not exhibit a them considering their morphology and mycelium growth.
significant antifungal activity.[2] The survey continued on Also, they were different from all known Trichoderma spe-
five more fungicides: carbendazim, thiophanate-methyl, cies.[2] The isolates have been maintained on potato dex-
chlorothalonil, iprodione and trifloxystrobin, which have trose agar (PDA) at 5 C in the culture collection of the
already been used against other fungal pathogens on Institute of Pesticides and Environmental Protection,
mushrooms before: Mycogone perniciosa, Lecanicillium Belgrade.
(Verticillium) fungicola and Cladobotryum sp.[18–22] Thia-
bendazole, which is used in mushroom production world-
wide, was not included in the survey because it is not
available for use in Serbia.[18] It is very important to deter- Selected pH values and light intensity
mine optimum conditions for pathogen growth, such as
pH and light intensity, in order to improve disease control. Trichoderma isolates were grown at 20 C on PDA (agar,
The aim of this study was to examine in vitro toxicity of Torlak, Belgrade, Serbia; dextrose, Torlak, Belgrade, Ser-
several fungicides to Trichoderma isolates obtained from bia; peeled potato). The medium was inoculated with
A. bisporus farms in Serbia and Bosnia-Herzegovina, com- mycelium agar discs (Ø 10 mm) taken from the edge of
pared to prochloraz. The impacts of pH and light on the 4 day-old cultures of each tested isolate and incubated for
growth of Trichoderma isolates were also evaluated. 72 h. The effect of pH, adjusted by 0.1 M HCl or 0.1 M
NaOH before sterilization, was studied over a range from
5.0 to 9.0. To examine the effect of light effect, the isolates
Downloaded by [FU Berlin] at 15:43 24 June 2015

Materials and methods were grown under constant neon light (λ D 533–725 nm)
or in the dark. Six replicates were made per isolate and
Isolates and growth conditions treatment.

Twenty Trichoderma isolates were collected from 13 Ser-

bian A. bisporus farms and one in Bosnia-Herzegovina
during 2006–2010 and were identified to species level in a
Fungicides
previous study by standard mycological studies and ITS1/
ITS4 sequence analyses (Table 1).[2] There were three sepa- Five commercial fungicides: carbendazim, chlorothalonil,
rate groups that were not identified to species level. They iprodione, thiophanate-methyl and trifloxystrobin
were most similar to T. harzianum isolates as molecular (Table 2) were tested as potential antifungal agents against
analysis proved their relatedness, but distinguishable from the studied. Trichoderma isolates.

Table 1. Tested Trichoderma spp. isolates and their origin.

Year of
Species Code Origin Substrate collection
Trichoderma aggressivum f. T76 Lisovi
ci, Barajevo, Serbia Mushroom substrate 2010
europaeum Samuels and W. Gams T77 Lisovi
ci, Barajevo, Serbia Mushroom substrate 2010
T85 Lisovi
ci, Barajevo, Serbia Mushroom substrate 2010
Trichoderma atroviride P. Karst. T33 Zemun Polje, Serbia Fruiting body 2006
T60 Zemun Polje, Serbia Fruiting body 2008
Trichoderma harzianum Rifai T10 Pozarevac, Serbia Fruiting body 2006
T52 Institute of Pesticides, Belgrade, Serbia Fruiting body 2008
T54 Kula, Serbia Fruiting body 2008
T64 Institute Zemun, Serbia Fruiting body 2009
T91 Institute Zemun, Serbia Fruiting body 2010
Trichoderma koningii Oudem. T39 Veliko Gradiste, Serbia Fruiting body 2007
Trichoderma virens (J.H.Mill., T5 Komiri
c, Serbia Fruiting body 2006
Giddens & A.A.Foster) Arx
Trichoderma sp. group 1 T1 Komiri
c, Serbia Fruiting body 2006
Trichoderma sp. group 2 T63 Becej, Serbia Fruiting body 2009
Trichoderma sp. group 3 T37 Novi Slankamen, Serbia Fruiting body 2007
T69 Sarajevo, Bosnia and Herzegovina Fruiting body 2009
T71 Mol, Serbia Fruiting body 2010
T86 Skobalj, Serbia Fruiting body 2010
T88 Veliko Gradiste, Serbia Fruiting body 2010
T90 Zemun Polje, Serbia Fruiting body 2010
 Fungicides against Trichoderma spp. on mushrooms 609

Table 2. Characteristics of selected fungicides.

Active
ingredient (a.i.) Carbendazim Chlorothalonil Iprodione Thiophanate-methyl Trifloxystrobin
Trade name Galofungin WP Bravo 750 SC Kidan EC Funomil WP Zato50 WG
Formulation 500 g kg¡1 720 g L¡1 260 g L¡1 700 g kg¡1 500 g kg¡1
Supplier Galenika– Syngenta Bayer Crop Agromarket Bayer Crop
Fitofarmacija Science Science
Chemical Class Benzimidazole Chloronitril Dicarboximide Benzimidazole Strobilurin

Antifungal activity isolate were used to enable statistical analysis. Fungicide

concentrations inhibiting mycelial growth by 50% (ED50)
Activity of the selected fungicides against Trichoderma
were determined for each isolate. These values were defined
isolates were tested by macrodilution method on PDA
for each isolate by interpolation from computer-generated
(pH D 7) amended with each tested fungicide, ranging
log-probit plots of fungicide concentration and relative inhi-
from 0.01 to 1000.00 mg L¡1.[23] Based on earlier observa-
bition.[24] Fungicide effects were studied by analyzing the
tion, fungicide concentrations selected for the study
means and variance of ED50 by the multiple range test.[25]
included: iprodione 0.47, 0.94, 1.87 and 3.75 mg L¡1,
The isolates were considered resistant to a fungicide if its
chlorothalonil and carbendazim 0.19, 0.37, 0.75 and
ED50 exceeded 50.0 mg L¡1, weakly resistant if the ED50
1.50 mg L¡1, thiophanate-methyl 6.25, 12.50, 25.00 and
Downloaded by [FU Berlin] at 15:43 24 June 2015

was in the range between 5.0 and 50.0 mg L¡1, and sensi-
50.00 mg L¡1, and trifloxystrobin 0.10, 1.00, 10.00
tive if the value was less than 5.0 mg L¡1.[26] A selectivity
and 100.00 mg L¡1.[18] The selected fungicide volumes
index for each active ingredient was calculated as a ratio of
were added to molten sterile medium (50 C). The fungi-
the ED50 mean value for each tested isolate of the pathogen
cide-amended media and fungicide-free media, used as the
and a corresponding estimate for A. bisporus.[19]
control were inoculated with mycelium agar discs
(Ø 10 mm) taken from the edge of 4 day-old cultures of
Trichoderma isolates and incubated at 20 C. Colony diam-
eter was measured after 72 h. Mycelial growth on the Statistical analyses
fungicide-amended media was measured as percentage Data were examined by one-way analysis of variance,
against the control. Three replicates per treatment and including a comparison of means by F-test. The test was

Table 3. Effect of pH on mycelial growth of Trichoderma spp. isolates.

Colony diameter after 72-h-old cultivation (mm § SE)

Species Code pH 5.0 pH 6.0 pH 7.0 pH 8.0 pH 9.0

Trichoderma aggressivum f. europaeum T76 36.7 § 0.4 B
39.2 § 0.5 A
37.5 § 0.2 B
34.8 § 0.5 C
34.3 § 0.7C
T77 36.3 § 0.3A 32.8 § 0.7B 33.3 § 0.3B 31.0 § 0.6C 30.8 § 0.8C
T85 38.5 § 1.1A 36.5 § 0.7AB 37.0 § 0.4A 34.7 § 0.8B 34.3 § 0.6C
Trichoderma atroviride T33 41.2 § 1.0A 40.8 § 0.6A 38.3 § 2.0AB 38.0 § 0.9AB 33.1 § 1.1B
T60 35.0 § 0.4AB 37.0 § 0.0A 36.5 § 0.7A 33.3 § 1.3BC 32.2 § 1.0C
Trichoderma harzianum T10 42.0 § 0.9A 39.0 § 0.4B 39.3 § 0.4AB 36.0 § 1.4C 35.2 § 1.1C
T52 36.8 § 0.6A 33.7 § 0.2B 33.5 § 1.5B 32.8 § 1.4B 32.5 § 0.5B
T54 32.2 § 0.6A 29.2 § 0.7B 28.8 § 0.7BC 27.5 § 0.2C 24.8 § 0.4D
T64 38.5 § 0.8A 36.5 § 1.1B 36.8 § 0.4AB 35.2 § 0.4BC 33.7 § 0.5C
T91 32.3 § 0.3A 32.3 § 1.0A 32.2 § 1.4AB 29.8 § 0.6BC 27.7 § 0.2C
Trichoderma koningii T39 43.5 § 0.5AB 44.3 § 0.3A 43.2 § 0.3AB 42.3 § 0.6B 38.0 § 1.1C
Trichoderma virens T5 30.7 § 0.4A 29.5 § 0.6AB 28.0 § 1.0BC 27.5 § 0.2C 26.7 § 0.2C
Trichoderma sp. Group 1 T1 15.7 § 0.4A 14.5 § 0.3B 14.3 § 0.2B 14.7 § 0.2B 14.0 § 0.0B
Trichoderma sp. Group 2 T63 29.5 § 0.8BC 32.7 § 0.4A 30.2 § 0.8B 30.0 § 0.4B 28.3 § 0.2C
Trichoderma sp. Group 3 T37 37.7 § 0.3B 38.8 § 0.4A 36.5 § 0.4C 35.7 § 0.5C 34.5 § 0.2D
T69 34.3 § 1.6AB 34.7 § 0.2AB 35.5 § 0.3A 32.7 § 0.4BC 30.7 § 1.1C
T71 35.2 § 0.7C 37.5 § 0.6AB 38.5 § 1.0A 36.0 § 0.9BC 35.8 § 0.3BC
T86 35.8 § 1.0A 36.3 § 0.3A 37.0 § 0.7A 34.8 § 0.5A 31.5 § 1.3B
T88 42.3 § 0.6A 39.5 § 0.8B 38.3 § 0.3BC 37.5 § 0.3C 34.3 § 0.6D
T90 36.2 § 0.9A 35.7 § 0.3A 35.0 § 0.4AB 33.2 § 0.5BC 31.5 § 0.5C
Means in row followed by the same uppercase letter are not significantly different at P < 0.05.
 610 Kosanovi

c et al.

used to compare average colony diameters of each tested light (Table 4). Statistically significant (P < 0.05) increases
isolate under the influence of different pH values and in colony diameters were found for T. atroviride, T.
light. In all analyses, the level of significance was at least aggressivum f. europaeum, T. harzianum, and Trichoderma
P < 0.05.[27] Statistical data analysis was performed using sp. group 3 isolates. T. harzianum T10 showed the maxi-
the software Statistica for Windows 6.0 (Stat Soft Italia, mum growth both under neon light and in the dark (52.0
1997). and 54.0 mm, respectively). Trichoderma sp. group 1 T1
had only half of the colony diameter of the other isolates
after 72 h of cultivation both under illumination and in
the dark (17.3 and 18.0 mm, respectively).
Results

Effects of pH and light on isolate growth

Sensitivity of Trichoderma isolates to fungicides
Twelve tested isolates grew best under pH 5.0, five isolates
under pH 6.0 and three under pH 7.0. Medium pH 5.0, 6.0 The tested Trichoderma isolates showed different levels of
and 7.0 showed the same effect on the growth of T. harzia- sensitivity to the selected fungicides in vitro (Table 5).
num T91, while the lowest growth of all isolates was Chlorothalonil and carbendazim concentrations below
observed under pH 9.0 (Table 3). Declining growth rate 0.19 mg L¡1 failed to affect growth, while concentrations
with increasing pH value was noted in 12 isolates, while its of 0.75 mg L¡1 and higher inhibited the growth of most
maximum was reported at pH 6.0 or 7.0 in the remaining isolates severely. The respective ED50 values of chlorotha-
Downloaded by [FU Berlin] at 15:43 24 June 2015

8, which was particularly evident for the isolates of Tricho- lonil and carbendazim were 0.12–0.97 and 0.25–0.92 mg
derma sp. group 3. Growth exceeding 40.0 mm after 72 h L¡1. Most Trichoderma isolates were capable to grow at
was observed in T. atroviride T33, T. harzianum T10, Tri- 0.47 mg L¡1 iprodione concentration but growth was
choderma sp. group 3 T88 at pH 5.0, while a maximum inhibited by 3.75 mg L¡1 and higher concentrations. The
was reached by T. koningii T39 (44.3 mm) under pH 6.0. values of iprodione ED50 for Trichoderma isolates were in
Trichoderma sp. group 1 T1 was characterized by a signifi- a range of 0.84–6.72 mg L¡1. Growth of the isolates was
cantly lower colony diameter, regardless of pH value, good at thiophanate-methyl concentration 6.25 mg L¡1
ranging between 15.7 and 14.0 mm, which is the lowest and trifloxystrobin concentration lower than 10 mg L¡1.
growth observed (Table 3). Severely inhibited growth of Trichoderma isolates was
The data show faster growth of all tested Trichoderma observed at thiophanate-methyl concentration of 25 mg
isolates in the dark, compared to their growth under neon L¡1 and trifloxystrobin concentration of 100 mg L¡1.

Table 4. Effect of light intensity on mycelial growth of Trichoderma sp. isolates.

Colony diameter after 72 h incubation (mm § SE)

Species Code Light Dark

Trichoderma aggressivum f. europaeum T76 42.7 § 0.7 A
43.3 § 0.6A
T77 36.3 § 0.3A 37.8 § 0.2B
T85 43.2 § 0.7A 46.2 § 1.0B
Trichoderma atroviride T33 29.5 § 0.2A 40.3 § 1.4B
T60 44.8 § 1.0A 47.0 § 1.3A
Trichoderma harzianum T10 52.0 § 0.9A 54.0 § 0.0B
T52 43.3 § 0.2A 44.0 § 0.0B
T54 40.3 § 0.2A 42.0 § 0.0B
T64 38.0 § 0.0A 40.5 § 0.2B
T91 36.2 § 0.2A 37.0 § 0.2B
Trichoderma koningii T39 38.7 § 0.4A 39.0 § 0.4A
Trichoderma virens T5 33.0 § 0.8A 34.0 § 0.0A
Trichoderma sp. group 1 T1 17.3 § 0.7A 18.0 § 0.0A
Trichoderma sp. group 2 T63 41.0 § 1.3A 42.8 § 1.0A
Trichoderma sp. group 3 T37 39.0 § 0.0A 40.5 § 0.2B
T69 48.7 § 0.4A 50.5 § 0.3B
T71 34.0 § 0.0A 41.5 § 0.7B
T86 44.0 § 1.8A 49.7 § 0.2B
T88 42.3 § 0.5A 42.8 § 0.2A
T90 35.0 § 0.0A 43.5 § 0.2B
Means in row followed by the same uppercase letter are not significantly different at P < 0.05.
 Fungicides against Trichoderma spp. on mushrooms 611

Table 5. Effect of tested fungicides on the growth of Trichoderma spp. isolate.

ED50 (mg L¡1) mean and range

Species Code Carbendazim Chlorothalonil Iprodione Thiophanate-methyl Trifloxystrobin

Trichoderma T76 0.61 (0.54–0.68) 0.33 (0.27–0.41) 1.76 (1.29–2.56) 18.92 (16.71–21.11) 10.62 (5.56–22.48)
aggressivum f. T77 0.31 (0.28–0.34) 0.97 (0.80–1.26) 0.96 (0.76–1.26) 13.43 (12.05–15.11) 10.25 (4.10–65.69)
europaeum T85 0.60 (0.51–0.76) 0.45 (0.31–0.90) 3.04 (2.09–5.58) 13.75 (11.31–16.36) 84.55 (49.41–177.54)
Trichoderma T33 0.35 (0.28–0.42) 0.25 (0.19–1.30) 6.08 (3.21–22.63) 3.75 (2.49–4.88) 97.41 (21.90–4348.42)
atroviride T60 0.25 (0.22–0. 82) 0.14 (0.05–0.23) 1.29 (0.97–1.90) 5.28 (3.40–7.02) 17.57 (7.65–55.96)
Trichoderma T10 0.70 (0.62–0.78) 0.48 (0.38–0.61) 1.57 (1.29–1.98) 11.91 (9.84–16.00) 36.89 (16.86–113.50)
harzianum T52 0.35 (0.32–0.39) 0.22 (0.13–0.33) 2.10 (1.71–2.77) 7.24 (6.23–8.45) 151.02 (25.07–34070.19)
T54 0.30 (0.26–0.33) 0.12 (0.08–0.15) 1.36 (0.93–2.43) 24.13 (15.67–69.94) 34.78 (20.56–100.92)
T64 0.33 (0.27–0.39) 0.33 (0.29–0.38) 1.29 (1.01–1.78) 6.86 (5.83–7.92) 21.62 (5.15–465.45)
T91 0.37 (0.33–0.42) 0.21 (0.17–0.25) 1.16 (0.58–4.75) 9.29 (8.03–10.87) 34.28 (10.56–660.28)
Trichoderma koningii T39 0.92 (0.79–1.06) 0.97 (0.81–1.22) 2.98 (2.03–5.25) 8.74 (7.13–10.48) 21.07 (11.91–43.34)
Trichoderma virens T5 0.34 (0.31–0.39) 0.31 (0.26–0.36) 2.03 (1.54–2.99) 6.78 (6.02–7.69) 34.18 (8.97–1144.64)
Trichoderma sp. T1 0.28 (0.24–0.32) 0.50 (0.40–0.70) 1.27 (1.02–1.65) 5.67 (4.68–6.66) 178.23 (67.59–938.73)
group 1
Trichoderma sp. T63 0.41 (0.37–0.46) 0.36 (0.26–0.75) 6.72 (3.62–20.92) 19.02 (14.82–25.50) 52.87 (19.50–413.60)
Downloaded by [FU Berlin] at 15:43 24 June 2015

group 2
Trichoderma sp. T37 0.30 (0.26–0.34) 0.71 (0.56–0.92) 3.08 (1.67–12.18) 20.00 (15.88–27.40) 33.67 (8.93–1061.95)
group 3 T69 0.32 (0.28–0.36) 0.23 (0.19–0.28) 1.03 (0.81–1.34) 21.67 (17.77–25.07) 21.47 (9.36–68.14)
T71 0.27 (0.23–0.31) 0.31 (0.25–0.38) 2.20 (1.96–2.54) 11.06 (9.85–12.39) 65.80 (29.14–238.27)
T86 0.31 (0.28–0.35) 0.22 (0.17–0.27) 0.89 (0.71–1.12) 10.58 (9.43–11.84) 25.74 (9.31–203.87)
T88 0.44 (0.40–0.48) 0.32 (0.24–0.43) 1.14 (0.83–1.70) 17.43 (15.63–19.43) 22.69 (5.91–1091.50)
T90 0.40 (0.35–0.46) 0.40 (0.34–0.47) 0.84 (0.75–1.08) 12.90 (10.46–16.68) 51.67 (18.37–298.37)
95% confidence interval (P D 0.05).

Thiophanate-methyl ED50 values ranged 3.75–24.13 mg T. harzianum T54 was the most sensitive to chlorothalonil,
L¡1, and those of trifloxystrobin 10.25–178.23 mg L¡1. T. artroviride T60 to carbendazim and Trichoderma sp.
Based on the presented data, medial ED50 values were cal- group 3 T90 to iprodione. Toxicity of thiophanate-methyl
culated for all tested isolates per fungicide (carbendazim and trifloxystrobin was inferior to them. T. artroviride
0.41; chlorothalonil 0.39; iprodione 2.14; thiophanate- T33, T. aggresivum f. europaeum T85, T. harzianum T52
methyl 12.42) in order to define the selective toxicity of Trichoderma sp. group 1 T1, Trichoderma sp. group 2 T63,
fungicides to the pathogen and host (A. bisporus F56). and Trichoderma sp. group 3 T71 and T90 were resistant
to trifloxystrobin.
Previous ED50 quantification of fungicide toxicity to A.
Discussion bisporus F56 had enabled determination of a selective tox-
icity beteween the pathogen and A. bisporus.[18,22] In our
The results indicate that pH values higher than 7 decrease previous study, prochloraz manganese had demonstrated
Trichoderma spp. growth and that the tested isolates pre- high toxicity to all Trichoderma isolates as its ED50 values
ferred pH 5–7. The findings were consistent with our previ- were below 1 mg L¡1.[2] The medial ED50 value of pro-
ous study demonstrating that Trichoderma species on chloraz manganese for the Serbian Trichoderma isolates
oyster mushroom (Pleurotus sp.) grew better under acidic- was 0.16 mg L¡1, its toxicity to A. bisporus F56 was
to-neutral conditions.[28] Generally, neon light had an 2.97 mg L¡1, and the selective toxicity to the pathogen
inhibitory effect on the tested isolate growth, which agrees and the host 0.05.[2,18] Carbendazim toxicity to A. bisporus
with other reported data.[29] F56 was 16.58 mg L¡1 and it demonstrated the best selec-
According to criteria of Gea et al.,[30,31] the tested tive toxicity of 0.02 among the tested fungicides.[18] Chlor-
Trichoderma isolates from Serbia and Bosnia-Herzegovina othalonil showed a moderate selective toxicity of 0.16,
were sensitive to chlorothalonil, carbendazim and ipro- having ED50 to A. bisporus F56 2.39 mg L¡1. Iprodione
dione (except two isolates) since their ED50 values were and thiophanate-methyl, having the respective toxicity to
less than 5.0 mg L¡1, weakly resistant to thiophanate- A. bisporus F56 of 2.14 and 12.49 mg L¡1, had the worst
methyl (except one isolate) with ED50 higher than 5.0 mg selective toxicity of 1.24.[22] Trifloxystrobin toxicity to A.
L¡1, while as many as seven isolates were resistant to tri- bisporus was not tested because Trichoderma isolates
floxystrobin, its ED50 exceeding 50.0 mg L¡1. The isolate were weakly sensitive or resistant to that fungicide. The
 612 Kosanovi

c et al.

commercial A. bisporus strains cultivated across Europe optimum concentrations for control of green mould dis-
since the 1990s seem to be more tolerant to fungicides in ease, and excluding the least effective ones.
vitro than earlier ones.[32]
Chlorothalonil, iprodione and carbendazim have also
been highly effective against Serbian Cladobotryum den- Conclusions
droides, while Lecanicillium fungicola var. fungicola iso-
lates have shown weak resistance to iprodione.[18,20,22] After in vitro testing of five fungicides: iprodione, chloro-
However, thiophanate-methyl was characterized by low thalonil, carbendazim, trifloxystrobin, and thiophanate-
activity against Serbian C. dendroides isolates, and triflox- methyl, carbendazim was shown to be the most effective
ystrobin was not toxic at all.[18,22] against Serbian Trichoderma isolates. Carbendazim was
Trifloxystrobin belongs to strobilurins, the site-specific the least toxic fungicide to A. bisporus and, besides pro-
compounds carrying a high resistance risk. Their mode of chloraz manganese, had the best selectivity to the patho-
action, based on inhibition of mitochondrial respiration, is gen and the host. The strobilurin fungicide trifloxystrobin
assumed to be easily overcome by fungi as in the studies was ineffective as a growth inhibitor of the tested Tricho-
concerning Trichoderma and Cladobotryum.[19] It have derma isolates. As previous studies had reported, the fungi-
been found that carbendazim and prochloraz were effec- cide prochloraz manganese has the highest antifungal
tive against T. harzianum from Croatia.[15] Carbendazim effect on the causal agents of green mould. The Tricho-
toxicity against Trichoderma from Pakistan has been con- derma isolates tested in this study preferred acidic-to-neu-
firmed in in vitro studies.[33] Earlier studies have also tral conditions, pH 5–7, and growth in the dark.
Downloaded by [FU Berlin] at 15:43 24 June 2015

demonstrated that spawn treatment by benomyl and car-

bendazim, alone or in combination with prochloraz,
reduced substrate colonization by T. aggressivum f. aggres-
sivum, in North America.[34–38] Over time, the pathogen Funding
has developed resistance to benomyl and tiophanate-
methyl.[17] Benomyl and carbendazim have a limited appli- This study was funded by the Ministry of Education, Sci-
cability because they are susceptible to microbial degrada- ence and Technological Development of the Republic of
tion, which results in reduced pathogen control.[39,40] Two Serbia, projects TR 31043 and ON 173032.
chlorothalonil formulations have been found to signifi-
cantly inhibit the growth of T. harzianum in Poland.[41]
Likewise, some rarely used fungicides (ferulic acid, men- References
thol and thymol) have been reported as having fungistatic
effects on T. harzianum isolates from Croatian A. bisporus [1] Chang, S.-T. Global impact of edible and medicinal mushrooms on
human welfare in the 21st Century: Non-green revolution. Int. J.
and P. ostreatus farms, but they inhibited the host mush- Med. Mushrooms 1999, 1, 1–7.
rooms as well.[15] Prochloraz was found to inhibit the [2] Kosanovi
c, D.; Potocnik, I.; Duduk, B.; Vukojevi
c, J.; Staji
c, M.;
growth of aggressive Trichoderma isolates without having Rekanovi
c, E.; Milijasevi
c-Marci
c, S. Trichoderma species on
a significant negative effect on the cultivated mush- Agaricus bisporus farms in Serbia and their biocontrol. Ann. Appl.
rooms.[2,15] Also, prochloraz manganese showed higher Biol. 2013, 163, 218–230.
[3] Seaby, D.A. Investigation of the epidemiology of green mould of
selective fungitoxicity (0.01) to Cladobotryum dendroides mushroom (Agaricus bisporus) compost caused by Trichoderma
and A. bisporus than all other fungicides applied to mush- harzianum. Plant Pathol. 1996, 45, 913–923.
rooms.[18] The fungicide prochloraz manganese maintains [4] Kredics, L.; Jimenez, L.G.; Naeimi, S.; Czifra, D.; Urb
an, Man-
a balance between the benefit of disease control and poten- czinger, L.; V
agv€olgyi, Hatvani L. A chalenge to mushroom
tial for reducing the mushroom yield. growers: the green mould disease of cultivated champignons. Curr.
Res., Technol. Educ. Top. Appl. Microbiol. Microb. Biotechn.
Extended use of fungicides leads to development of 2010, 295–305.
pathogen resistance and there is a need for new fungicides [5] Rinker, D.L. Disease management strategies for Trichoderma
to be used in practice, while preference is given to biofungi- mould. Mushroom World 1993, 4, 3–5.
cides. Thus, the biofungicide based on Bacillus subtilis, has [6] Romaine, C.P.; Royse, D.J.; Wuest, P.J.; Beyer, D.M. Mushroom
been shown to have highly toxic effect on Trichoderma green mould: Cause, edaphic factors and control. Mushroom News
1996, 44, 20–23.
species from Serbia, including T. aggressivum, in contrast [7] Geels, F.P. Rondetafel – bijeenkomst over Trichoderma. Cham-
to that based on tea tree oil, which did not exhibit signifi- pignoncultuur 1997, 41, 13.
cant antifungal capacity.[2] Their effectiveness was also [8] Hermosa, M.R.; Grondona, I.; Monte, E. Isolation of Trichoderma
demonstrated in mushroom growing rooms, but it was sig- harzianum Th2 from commercial mushroom compost in Spain.
nificantly lower than that of prochloraz manganese.[2] Plant Dis. 1999, 83, 591.
[9] Mamoun, M.L.; Iapicco, R.; Savoie, J.M.; Olivier, J.M. Green
Commercial fungicides are still being used in mushroom mould disease in France: Trichoderma harzianum Th2 and other
farms and research studies have contributed by defining species causing damage on mushroom farms. Mushroom Sci. 2000,
and recommending the most efficient fungicides and their 15, 625–632.
 Fungicides against Trichoderma spp. on mushrooms 613

[10] Samuels, G.J.; Dodd, S.L.; Gams, W.; Castlebury, L.A.; Petrini, O. [24] Leroux, P.; Gredt, M. Etude de l’Action in–vitro des Fongicides; In
Trichoderma species associated with the green mould epidemic Methode de l’ Incorporation ou Milieu. Laboratorie de Phytophar-
of commercially grown Agaricus bisporus. Mycologia 2002, 94, macie – INRA: Versailles, France, 1972; 1–10.
146–170. [25] Finney, D.J. Probit Analysis; 3rd edition; University Press: Cam-
[11] Hatvani, L.; Antal, Z.; Manczinger, L.; Szekeres, A.; Druzhinina, bridge, UK, 1971; 1–383.
I.S.; Kubicek, C.P.; Nagy, A.; Nagy, E.; Vagvolgyi, C.; Kredics, L. [26] Gea, F.J.; Tello, J.C.; Honrubia, M. In vitro sensitivity of Verticil-
Green mould diseases of Agaricus and Pleurotus are caused by lium fungicola to selected fungicides. Mycopathologia 1996, 136,
related but phylogenetically different Trichoderma species. Phyto- 133–137.
pathology 2007, 97, 532–537. [27] Sokal, R.R.; Rohlf, F.J. Biometry: The Principles and Practice of
[12] Szczech, M.; Staniaszek, M.; Habdas, H.; Ulinski, Z.; Szymanski, Statistics in Biological Research; 3rd edition; W.H. Freeman and
J. Trichoderma spp. – the cause of green mould on Polish mush- Company: New York, NY, USA; 1995.
room farms. Vegetable Crops Res. B. 2008, 69, 105–114. [28] Woo, S.L.; Di Benedetto, P.; Senatore, M.; Abadi, K.; Gigante, S.;
[13] Romero-Arenas, O.; Lara, M.H.; Huato, M.A.D.; Hernandez, F. Soriente, I.; Ferraioli, S.; Scala, F.; Lorito, M. Identification and
D.; Victoria, D.A.A. The characteristics of Trichoderma harzianum characterization of Trichoderma species aggressive to Pleurotus in
as a limiting agent in edible mushrooms. Rev. Colomb. Biotecnol. Italy. J. Zhejiang Univ. Agric. Life Sci. 2004, 30, 469–470.
2009, 11, 143–151. [29] Chen, A.W.; Moy, M. Mushroom cultivation: building mould
[14] Clift, A.D.; Shamshad, A. Modeling mites, moulds and mushroom contamination. In Science and cultivation of edible fungi, Pro-
yields in the Australian Mushroom Industry; In Proceedings of the ceedings of the 16th International Congress on the Science and
18th World IMACS Congress and MODSIM09 International Con- Cultivation of Edible and Medicinal Fungi, Miami, USA;
gress on Modeling and Simulation. Cairns, Australia; Anderssen, R. Romaine, C.P., Ed.; Penn State University: Philadelphia, PA,
S.; Braddock, R.D.; Newham, L.T.H., Eds.; IMACS: Cairns, Aus- USA, 2004; 625–632.
tralia, 2009; 491–497. [30] Gea, F.J.; Tello, J.C.; Navarro, M.J. Occurrence of Verticillium
Downloaded by [FU Berlin] at 15:43 24 June 2015

[15] Hatvani, L.; Sabolic, P.; Koscube, S.; Kredics, L.; Vagvolgyi, C.; fungicola var. fungicola on Agaricus bitorquis mushroom crops in
Kaliterna, J.; Ivic, D.; Dermic, E.; Kosalec, I. The first report on Spain. J. Phytopathol. 2003, 151, 98–100.
mushroom green mould in Croatia. Arch. Ind. Hyg. Toxicol. 2012, [31] Gea, F.J.; Navarro, M.J.; Tello, J.C. Reduced sensitivity of the
63, 481–487. mushroom pathogen Verticillium fungicola to prochloraz-manga-
[16] Beyer, D.M.; Kremser, I.J. Evaluation of fungicide tolerance and nese in vitro. Mycol. Res. 2005, 109, 741–745.
control for three fungal diseases of mushrooms; In Scince and culti- [32] Challen, M.P.; Elliott, T.J. The in vitro responses to a range of fun-
vation of edible and medicinal fungi, Mushroom Science XVI, gicides of two strains of the mushroom Agaricus bisporus and
Romaine, C.P.; Keil, C.B.; Rinker, D.L.; Royse, D.J., Eds.; Penn the pathogen Verticillium fungicola. Mycopathologia 1985, 90,
State University: Philadelphia, PA, USA, 2004; 521–529. 161–164.
[17] Grogan, H.M. Challenges facing mushroom disease control in the [33] Khan, M.O.; Shahzad, S. Screening of Trichoderma species for tol-
21st century; In Proceeding of the Sixth International Conference erance to fungicides. Pakistan J. Bot. 2007, 39, 945–951.
on Mushroom Biology and Mushroom Products; Lelley, J.I.; Bus- [34] Abosriwil, S.O.; Clancy, K.J. A protocol for evaluation of the role
well, J.A., Eds.; WSMBMP: Bonn, Germany,:2008; 120–127. of disinfectants in limiting pathogens and weed moulds in commer-
[18] Potocnik, I.; Vukojevi
c, J.; Staji
c, M.; Rekanovi
c, E.; Milijasevi
c, cial mushroom production. Pest Manag. Sci. 2002, 58, 282–289.
S.; Todorovi
c, B.; Stepanovi
c, M. In vitro toxicity of selected fungi- [35] Abosriwil, S.O.; Clancy, K.J. A mini-bag technique for evaluation
cides from the group of benzimidazoles and demethylation inhibi- of fungicide effects on Trichoderma spp. in mushroom compost.
tors to Cladobotryum dendroides and Agaricus bisporus. J. Environ Pest Manag. Sci. 2003, 60, 350–358.
Sci. Heal. B 2009, 44, 365–370. [36] Grogan, H.M.; Noble, R.; Gaze, R.H. Control of Trichoderma
[19] Chrysayi-Tokousbalides, M.; Kastanias, M.A.; Filippoussis, A.; harzianum – a weed mould of mushroom cultivation; In Pests &
Diamantopoulou, P. Selective fungitoxicity of famaxadone, tebu- Diseases, Proceedings from the Crop Protection Conference, Brigh-
conazole and trifoxystrobin between Verticillium fungicola and ton, UK; British Crop Protection Council: Surrey, UK, 1996;
Agaricus bisporus. Crop Prot. 2007, 26, 469–475. 337–343.
[20] Potocnik, I.; Vukojevi
c, J.; Staji
c, M.; Tanovi
c, B.; Todorovi
c, B. [37] Rinker, D.L.; Alm, G. Efficacy and limitations of mushroom grain
Fungicide sensitivity of selected Verticillium fungicola isolates spawn treated with benomyl against green mould disease of the cul-
from Agaricus bisporus farms. Arch. Biol. Sci., Belgrade 2008, 60, tivated mushroom. Mushroom News: Sci. Technol. 1998, 11, 6–11.
151–157. [38] Rinker, D.L.; Alm, G. Management of casing Trichoderma using
[21] Potocnik, I.; Vukojevi
c, J.; Staji
c, M.; Tanovi
c, B.; Rekanovi
c, E. fungicides. Mushroom Sci. 2008, 17, 496–509.
Sensitivity of Mycogone perniciosa, Pathogen of Culinary-Medici- [39] Fletcher, J.T.; Connolly, G.; Mountfield, E.X.; Jacobs, L. The dis-
nal Button Mushroom Agaricus bisporus (J. Lge) Imbach (Agarico- appearance of benomyl from mushroom casing. Ann. Appl. Biol.
mycetideae), to Selected Fungicides and Essential Oils. Int. J. Med. 1980, 95, 73–82.
Mushrooms 2010, 12, 91–98. [40] Yarden, O.; Salomon, R.; Katan, J.; Aharonson, N. Involvement
[22] Potocnik, I.; Vukojevi
c, J.; Staji
c, M.; Rekanovi
c, E.; Milijasevi
c, of fungi and bacteria in enhanced and nonenhanhanced biodegra-
S.; Stepanovi
c, M.; Todorovi
c, B. Toxicity of fungicides with dif- dation of carbendazim and other benzimidazole compounds in soil.
ferent modes of action to Cladobotryum dendroides and Agaricus Canadian J. Microbiol. 1990, 36, 15–23.
bisporus. J. Environ. Sci. Heal. B 2009, 44, 823–827. [41] G
orski, R.; Fru_zy
nska-J
o
zwiak, D.; Andrzejak, R.; Sobieralski,
[23] Ishii, H. Monitoring of fungicide resistance in fungi: biological to K.; Siwulski, M. The Effect of selected preparations on in vitro
biochemical approaches; In Molecular Methods in Plant Pathology; growth of Trichoderma harzianum and Trichoderma atroviride
Singh, S.U.; Singh, P.R., Eds.; Lewis Publisher: Boca Ratton, FL, found in garden mushroom (Agaricus bisporus) crop. Phytopathol.
USA, 1995; 483–495. Pol. 2006, 42, 29–35.