Impact of Overall Quality Management and Its Impact on

Care Homes
 Table of Contents
1. Introduction.........................................................................................................................................3
1.1 Background..................................................................................................................................3
1.2 Problem Statement.......................................................................................................................4
1.3 Significance of the research.........................................................................................................4
1.4 Aims of the Research...................................................................................................................4
1.5 Research Questions......................................................................................................................5
2. Literature Review....................................................................................................................................6
2.1 Quality Management....................................................................................................................6
2.2 Health Care..................................................................................................................................6
2.3 Role of Healthcare Leaders..........................................................................................................8
2.4 Quality Management and Healthcare...........................................................................................8
2.4.1 Shift in Medical Practices...........................................................................................................8
2.4.2 Value Setting..............................................................................................................................8
2.4.3 Engagement and Authorization...................................................................................................9
2.4.4 Data and Schooling for Care Labors and Administrators............................................................9
2.4.5 Constant Quality Enhancement Approaches.............................................................................10
2.4.6 Incentives on Performance Basis..............................................................................................10
2.4.7 Legislature and Guidelines........................................................................................................11
3. Methodology.........................................................................................................................................12
3.1 Target Population.......................................................................................................................12
3.2 Research Design........................................................................................................................12
3.3 Data Analysis.............................................................................................................................13
3.4 Ethical Issues.............................................................................................................................13
4. Conclusion.............................................................................................................................................15
5. Time Plan..............................................................................................................................................16
6. References.............................................................................................................................................17
 1. Introduction
1.1 Background

Various nations have experienced noteworthy upsurges in health-care quality complications in recent

decades. Health-care practitioners and administrators recognise the importance of successful and cost-

effective patient outcomes. According to the evidence, all tasks and procedures associated with providing

health care must be managed through a whole quality management system (Daqar et al., 2020). This

network is made up of a series of interrelated actions intended at measuring, evaluating, and improving

the quality of services, with the patient at the centre of it all (Tulloch et al., 2021). Patient self-

assuredness necessitates that all parties involved in the delivery of health care consider the patient's needs,

preferences, and expectations, as well as ensuring that patient values guide all clinical decisions.

Wellbeing administrators are in a unique position to incorporate patient values and goals into all functions

of leadership (Dawes et al., 2021). Several studies have demonstrated that the leadership's vision may

help enhance organisational commitment to improving the patient experience and creating the right

conditions for PCC to thrive. This implies a leadership style that promotes and enables employees to

adjust services locally and operate in a more patient-centered manner (Gozzoli et al., 2018). As per the

health care management literature, the quality paradigm has lately become one of the major components

on which healthcare system transformation and development is based. The effect of the paradigm has

moved to the field of social care, illustrating the critical interconnectedness between these two sectors

(Chadborn et al., 2020). However, as healthcare experts regularly highlight, the boundaries between

healthcare and social services are difficult to define and have long been a cause of conflict.

Total Quality Management (TQM) is a quality-centered management method for an organisation

based on the engagement of all of its members, with the goal of long-term success via customer

satisfaction and benefits to all members of the business and society. As a result, TQM is a methodology

for continually improving the quality of all organisations, processes, products, and services ( Atalıç et al.,

2021). Quality management involves numerous characteristics ranging from quality assurance to

continual improvement. For a long time, the most popular strategy in social care has been quality
assurance, with public authorities defining minimum requirements for the adequacy of care delivered, so

keeping the most deficient providers out of the sector (Hijazi et al., 2018). Quality management with

broader quality improvement objectives focuses on care processes, suggesting that intended results are

derived from the defined quality of 'care production' processes. Furthermore, quality management may

comprise defining and achieving desired outputs or outcomes of LTC operations, but paying little

attention to how they are achieved (Mozley et al., 2017). It may emphasise delivery efficiency as a proxy

for quality, or it may emphasise ideals of perfection or rely on professional norms of quality performance

based on evidence of excellent practise.

1.2 Problem Statement

The level of care provided to the patients is a critical problem. Assessment and evaluation of care in

nursing homes always is difficult (Mulhall et al., 2018). In past years, a rising number of nursing homes

throughout the world have begun to develop quality management systems that incorporate a variety of

quality assurance activities in order to enhance the quality of care offered to their clients (Dawes et al.,

2021). Systematic care planning, practise guidelines, and client councils are examples of QA activities.

1.3 Significance of the research

TQM is a system established by an organization's administration to guarantee customer/patient

fulfillment. In this age of globalisation, the relevance of TQM as a technique for improving organisational

performance has expanded (Bouranta et al., 2019). Numerous studies have proven the impact of TQM in

improving system quality and improving employee and organisational performance (Dawes et al., 2021).

TQM is regarded as an innovative method to organisational management. TQM incorporates quality

focus into all processes and procedures in health-care delivery in the medical industry (Chadborn et al.,

2020). It is currently widely used in many nations' medical sectors. This study examines the impact of

such actions on negative clinical consequences in care centres.

1.4 Aims of the Research

Following are the objectives that are to be addressed by this research:

 Exploring the relationship between quality management and care homes

 Discovering the practises linked with quality management in care homes

 Evaluating the impact of quality management on the care homes

1.5 Research Questions

 What is the relationship between quality management and care homes?

 What are the challenges faced by care homes in quality management?

 What are the practises linked with quality management in care homes?

 What is the impact of quality management on the care homes?

2.1 Quality Management

Quality management in health care discusses the administration of system design, policies, and

procedures that decrease, if not eliminate, damage while maximising patient care and consequences.

TQM is founded on a set of principles that aim to improve stakeholder fulfillment by making the greatest

use of organisational resources (Baguma et al., 2020). However, the influence of each quality

management concept on organisational success is currently being disputed. Several studies have been

conducted to explore the effects of TQM concepts on overall organisational effectiveness and

performance (Tulloch et al., 2021). Numerous studies have discovered a substantial and beneficial

association between stress and performance. There is widespread consensus that successful TQM

deployment improves organisational effectiveness (Daqar et al., 2020). The success of TQM adoption in

industry has prompted healthcare executives to investigate if it can be adopted in the healthcare sector.

According to studies, TQM operations improve patient happiness, productivity, profitability, and the

performance of health care organisations.

The objective of quality management is to ensure that a product, service, or organisation

accomplishes its primary purpose on a consistent basis. To accomplish this, information is continually

collected and procedures are modified in order to produce an optimal product or service that fulfils its

goal while delighting the consumer (Bouranta et al., 2019). After that, more data is collected to ensure

that no more modifications are necessary. Quality management systems (QMS) are tools for establishing

quality management as well as organising, coordinating, and optimising activities involving a consumer-

facing product or service (Gozzoli et al., 2018). Problems only within system are identified by examining

the outcomes and implications of several aspects through data collection, and evidence-based medicine

and resources are used to develop or change systems to improve treatment quality. The data on new

outcomes is then gathered to see if the improvements were effective or if further changes are required

(Mozley et al., 2017). The ultimate goal is to deliver consistent, high-quality care with minimal
morbidity, mortality, sickness, and pain, as well as high patient satisfaction, while meeting or exceeding

all six IOM criteria.

2.2 Health Care

Care homes are a type of long-term care facility that includes both residential and nursing facilities.

The worldwide definition of a nursing home is met by all care homes in the United Kingdom, including

residential homes. In both types of care facilities, people with advanced frailty are treated.  Nursing home

patients have a one-year life expectancy, whereas residential home residents have a two-year life

expectancy (Atalıç et al., 2021). In UK nursing homes, there are several variations in how care is

administered, resulting in a wide range of care quality. Clinical governance is complex and negotiated,

with care homes accountable for routine care and the NHS, notably general practitioners, liable for

medical treatment provided (Seelbach and Brannan, 2021). This may cause confusion and ambiguity

about who is in control of certain aspects of care. The link between the care home sector and the much

smaller acute hospital bed base is becoming more commonly acknowledged. These results, combined

with the federal government's increased focus on the integration of health and social care, have resulted in

a slew of new policies aimed at improving nursing home care quality (Smith et al., 2016). The volume

and rate of increase of quality improvement (QI) in care institutions, on the other hand, has received little

attention.

Nurses play an important role in the teams that deliver health care in health organisations. Effective

nursing cooperation is a critical component of providing high-quality care and ensuring patient safety

(Tulloch et al., 2021). Skilled physicians, nurses, and other health care professionals are required to

provide people, families, and communities with high-quality health care. A global shortage of 2.5 million

physicians, 9 million nurses and midwives, and 6 million allied health workers is currently anticipated. As

a result, basic care is frequently absent or inadequately administered (Wilkinson et al., 2019). The

situation is exacerbated in impoverished nations. Even in industrialised countries, health personnel are too

concentrated in cities, resulting in worse quality of treatment in rural and isolated locations. Even inside
cities, certain areas – such as slums – have a distinct shortage of health staff. Care homes are distinct from

hospitals in terms of construction, purpose, and client and personnel groups (Hijazi et al., 2018). As a

consequence, well-established quality improvement (QI) methodologies in hospitals will need to be

adapted to work within the framework of a care home. However, there should be enough overlap amongst

care facilities in many nations to imply that the QI ideas used in institutional long-term care homes are

global.

2.3 Role of Healthcare Leaders

Leaders in health care have a pivotal role in establishing excellent care (Smith et al., 2016). They may

empower others by encouraging team members to contribute and providing long-term growth

opportunities. Leaders can also skilfully and strategically persuade various parties to work together to

achieve common goals. They can also demonstrate a willingness to collaborate with both internal and

external parties (Bouranta et al., 2019). Fourth, they may define performance gaps and explain why

changes are required in a straightforward and logical manner (Mulhall et al., 2018). Leaders can also be

mindful of elements that influence their own conduct, such as personal sources of stress, emotions, and

biases. Finally, leaders may effectively lead by being cool in the face of adversity.

2.4 Quality Management and Healthcare

2.4.1 Shift in Medical Practices

The disparity between what is known to be effective treatment and what clinicians habitually offer

has been thoroughly documented all around the world. Health care personnel' abilities, expertise, and

attitudes are critical (Baguma et al., 2020). Clinical result support systems, which range from written

procedures to electronically backed assistance, are examples of measures to assist health care

practitioners in providing the best effective treatment (Wilkinson et al., 2019). One of the most important

goals is to keep patients safe. The model describes current approaches for healthcare provision in general,

as well as in respect to specific groups, including people with chronic diseases or mental health issues, or

those who have common characteristics (Dawes et al., 2021). New care models are typically community-
based, extending far beyond hospital walls and including contributions from primary, specialist, and

social care organisations.

2.4.2 Value Setting

Establishing guidelines based on proof procedures can assist to ensure that high-quality treatment is

delivered consistently across different health systems throughout the world (Wilkinson et al., 2019).

Although traditionally led by government agencies, standard setting is an area of quality improvement in

which professional organisations should play an important role, either independently or in conjunction

with authorities (Atalıç et al., 2021). Certain clinical guidelines are aimed at specific demographic groups,

whereas others are aimed at specific medical situations or treatment regimens (Smith et al., 2016). To

improve maternity and neonatal care in hospitals, for example, global clinical standards of care have been

developed. Patient care protocols and clinical pathways are widely used to embed clinical policy and

standards-based treatment (Gozzoli et al., 2018). Although clinical standards are typically adopted at an

early stage in national quality programmes, doing so without a comprehensive quality strategy may not

result in the desired advantages and progress.

2.4.3 Engagement and Authorization

Health systems must move beyond health literacy programmes to fully realise the potential of people-

centeredness as an entry point to higher-quality care (Hijazi et al., 2018). Across all nation contexts, there

is significant evidence that interventions that strive to involve and empower patients, caregivers, and

families can promote better care, including healthier behaviours, enhanced patient experience, more

effective health service utilisation, reduced costs, and improved outcomes. Individuals benefit from

information, therapy, and help in managing their healthcare and co-developing treatment and maintenance

programmes (Chadborn et al., 2020). Long-term community engagement approaches can also assist

programmes improve care quality. The need to secure or develop confidence in communities is also a

priority (Seelbach and Brannan, 2021). There would have been a fundamental barrier to receiving health

care even when it is essential if it did not exist.

One of several responsibilities of leadership is to keep a healthy level of investment in information

technology (Daqar et al., 2020). Clinical decision assistance, for example, can take the form of computer

prompts or as basic as paper forms with boxes to check off the necessary tasks associated with effective

child care.

2.4.5 Constant Quality Enhancement Approaches

Quality improvement is a dynamic concept rather than a static concept that is always growing

(Seelbach and Brannan, 2021). A variety of methods are used to endlessly ensure and advance the quality

of health care, as well as broad clinical governance instruments, peer evaluation and clinical review,

individual reaction, management and training, clinical decision backing tools founded on strategies, and

multidisciplinary knowledge collaboratives (Hijazi et al., 2018). A core assumption behind continuous

quality improvement is the activation of learning processes through repeated cycles of change.

Additionally, eliminating "blaming and shaming" is essential in order to avoid the risk of fostering fear

and opposition rather than enthusiastic involvement in a collaborative pursuit of improved performance

(Bouranta et al., 2019). There is no one-size-fits-all approach that works. Numerous treatments must be

employed in tandem and with a thorough awareness of the unique circumstances. The part of institutional

philosophy becomes a significant factor in determining the precise mixture of quality improvement

methodologies depending on the available volume and skills.

2.4.6 Incentives on Performance Basis

Financial incentives, such as remuneration, and non-financial incentives, such as recognition and

rewards, are both possible lever (Baguma et al., 2020). Performance-based finance is a wide phrase for

paying health-care providers founded on a set of presentation metrics, and it is gradually being utilised as

a superiority. Value-based buying, readmission fines, withholding expense for medical mistakes, and

presentation programmes aimed at boosting key care are examples of models (Dawes et al., 2021). Based

on a variety of financing options, the amount reliant on performance is a subcomponent of the total

expense. The evidence on the efficacy of pay-for-performance programmes to affect health outcomes on
their own remains equivocal. However, when employed as part of a solid quality improvement

programme, incentives – both financial and increasingly acknowledged nonfinancial measures – may play

a vital motivating and sustaining purpose (Wilkinson et al., 2019). At the same time, care must be taken

to eliminate disincentives to quality.

2.4.7 Legislature and Guidelines

Governments use in cooperation legislation and regulation to attain national health goals. Coverage and

benefits, the development of new national bodies, expense improvement, facility and individual provider

licensure, and community presentation reporting are all examples of legislation aiming at improving

health care quality (Gozzoli et al., 2018). Regulation means a set of factors outside of clinical practise or

health-care administration that influence behaviour in the distribution or utilisation of health-care

services. Regulation frequently seeks to regulate the conduct of official and separate clinicians, health

protection firms, medical and device constructers, and customers or patients (Mulhall et al., 2018).

Different regulatory initiatives regularly fail to accomplish their planned aims, in part since relevant

agencies absence enforcement capacity. Considering the enormous majority of total services provided,

regulation of private sector activities is becoming extremely relevant.

3.1 Target Population

Health care employees and managers in elderly residential care institutions were subjected to

extensive investigation. A massive dataset was compiled as a consequence of straight observations and in-

depth interviews with housing care facility managers, consultants, and workers. The resolution of our

travels was to know directly about the workers' working circumstances. The residents' limits were

explored during the visits. The physical qualities of residential care homes, the services and actions

supplied, aspects connected to the facilities' interior workings, and the numerous processes and internal

regulations utilised were all researched. Participants in the study comprised hospital managers, heads of

departments and units, pharmacists, staff nurses, nurses, nurse assistants, nutritionists, lab technicians,

radiology technicians, anaesthetic technicians, and sterilisation technicians.

3.2 Research Design

A standardised questionnaire with three elements was used: demographic data, overall quality

management, and hospital effectiveness. Medline, CINAHL, PsychInfo, and ResearchGate for official

academic articles were examined. Search phrases like "Quality Improvement," "Quality Indicators, Health

Care," and "Health Services Research" to find publications regarding quality improvement were also

utilized. Finally, to extract publications about nursing homes, we used a search strategy developed over a

current consensus workout.

From 2016 forward, records were sifted through. Articles were required to document job completed

in elderly care facilities and portray QI as alteration management, rather than providing a process for

gathering new knowledge about the resident-level intervention itself (Chadborn et al., 2020). The papers

highlighted particular feature improvement approaches, including such quality development

collaboratives or plan-do-study-act cycles. The articles discussed end-of-life care in nursing homes.

Articles concentrating on efforts for short-term residents of care facilities, such as respite and

intermediate care, were omitted since they are paid for and organised differently from long-term care
(Mozley et al., 2017). Projects aimed at improving hospital admission and discharge procedures,

children's care homes, persons with learning disabilities, or care centres were not evaluated.

3.3 Data Analysis

The analysis will be done by the thematic analysis method. This is a qualitative data analysis

technique that includes reading through a data set and recognizing patterns in sense across the data. It is a

flexible method to qualitative analysis that allows researchers to produce new understandings and ideas

derivative from data. One of many assistances of thematic analysis is that beginner researcher who are

just learning the analysis of qualitative data would find thematic analysis a manageable method. 

3.4 Ethical Issues

The ethical approval for the execution of this study was obtained from the participants of the

research in the form of signing the consent form and all the people that participated in the study were a

part of it by their own consent and free will.

Consent: Informed consent can be referred as an essential part of integrity of the research that has been

carried out. Qualitative researchers must make it clear in the beginning regarding the type of the data and

the usage of the data or information that has been gathered. Numerous individuals consider it essential to

contribute in the study that may be of benefit for their colleagues or the society therefore the participants

must be well-informed regarding the benefit of the study. There are a lot of ethical issues in relation with

the qualitative method of research that should be kept in mind while conducting the qualitative research.

Some of the issues are as follows:

Anonymity: Anonymity of the qualitative research refers to the unavailability of any means for any

individual to generally recognize any of the participants of the study. These studies cannot collect any

type of information that can personally recognize of identify the participants and the information is not

restricted to the names, addresses, etc.

independence of study participants by any way. Sometimes, some of the researches require the

clarification of the accessibility of the data and the usage of the data.
 4. Conclusion

Understanding the elements that promote cooperation in health care organisations allows for the

development and maintenance of teamwork qualities. It was discovered that leadership and

communication among nurses are important drivers of collaboration in their research of inpatients and

outpatients in an Australian tertiary-based hospital (Atalıç et al., 2021). Regardless matter how distant a

health system is from reaching universal health coverage, quality may be ingrained in its roots. A quality-

oriented approach to health care personnel, health care facilities, pharmaceuticals, equipment and other

technologies, information systems, and money is necessary at all stages of development (Seelbach and

Brannan, 2021). The foundation for high-quality healthcare institutions must be emphasized in thinking,

planning, and policy. The adoption of quality systems and models has benefited some health and social

sector experts in increasing the quality of care provided by residential care facility personnel. Other

academics, on the other hand, argue that the work expended in developing systems and models has not

been reflected in service quality. According to some authors, the premise that quality assurance standards

apply to all businesses is out of date. As a result, determining which quality assurance standards apply to

each industry is critical (Daqar et al., 2020). This type of research is useful to both researchers and

managers since TQM has become an essential management method for improving performance.
 5. Time Plan

Task Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sept Oct Nov Dec
Finding a Problem

Writing Aims and

Designing Methodology

Making a Proposal

Market and Environment

Survey Questionnaire

Selection of Participants

Conducting Surveys

Literature Review

Research Design and

Data Collection

Data Analysis

Discussion

Writing Draft

Proofreading

Writing final draft

Abu Daqar, M. and Constantinovits, M. (2020) "The role of total quality management in enhancing the

quality of private healthcare services", Problems and Perspectives in Management, 18(2), pp. 64-78.

doi: 10.21511/ppm.18(2).2020.07.

Atalıç, H. and Çiçek, H. (2021) "TOTAL QUALITY MANAGEMENT PRACTICES IN HEALTH

CARE ORGANIZATIONS: PERCEPTION OF HEALTH CARE PROVIDERS", European Journal

of Public Health Studies, 4(2), p. Available at:

https://oapub.org/hlt/index.php/EJPHS/article/view/100/100 (Accessed: 8 December 2021).

Baguma, J.C. and Uchejeso, O.M., 2020. Managing Quality in Health and Social Care Services; an

Exemplary Review of a Center in London. Journal of Quality in Health care & Economics

ISSN, 2642, p.6250.

Bouranta, N., Psomas, E., Suárez-Barraza, M.F. and Jaca, C., 2019. The key factors of total quality

management in the service sector: a cross-cultural study. Benchmarking: An International Journal.

Chadborn, N. et al. (2020) "Quality improvement in long-term care settings: a scoping review of effective

strategies used in care homes", European Geriatric Medicine, 12(1), pp. 17-26. doi: 10.1007/s41999-

020-00389-w.

Dawes, N. and Topp, S., 2021. Senior management characteristics that influence care quality in aged care

homes: A global scoping review. International Journal of Healthcare Management, 14(3), pp.731-

743.

Gozzoli, C., Gazzaroli, D. and D’Angelo, C., 2018. Who cares for those who take care? Risks and

resources of work in care homes. Frontiers in psychology, 9, p.314.

Hijazi, H. H. et al. (2018) ‘The Impact of Applying Quality Management Practices on Patient

Centeredness in Jordanian Public Hospitals: Results of Predictive Modeling’, INQUIRY: The Journal

of Health Care Organization, Provision, and Financing. doi: 10.1177/0046958018754739.

Mozley, C., Sutcliffe, C., Bagley, H., Cordingley, L., Challis, D., Huxley, P. and Burns, A.,

2017. Towards Quality Care: outcomes for older people in care homes. Routledge.
Mulhall, C.L., Lam, J.M., Rich, P.S., Dobell, L.G. and Greenberg, A., 2020. Enhancing quality care in

Ontario long-term care homes through audit and feedback for physicians. Journal of the American

Medical Directors Association, 21(3), pp.420-425.

Seelbach, C. and Brannan, G. (2021) "Quality Management", StatPearls, p. Available at:

https://www.statpearls.com/ArticleLibrary/viewarticle/28143 (Accessed: 8 December 2021).

Smith, T.O., Purdy, R., Latham, S.K., Kingsbury, S.R., Mulley, G. and Conaghan, P.G., 2016. The

prevalence, impact and management of musculoskeletal disorders in older people living in care

homes: a systematic review. Rheumatology international, 36(1), pp.55-64.

Tulloch, J.S.P., Green, R., Tunnah, C., Coffey, E., Ashton, M. and Ghebrehewet, S., 2021. COVID-19

outbreaks in care homes during the first wave: are Care Quality Commission ratings a good predictor

of at-risk homes?. Journal of Hospital Infection, 111, pp.96-101.

Wilkinson, A., Haroun, V., Wong, T., Cooper, N. and Chignell, M., 2019. Overall quality performance of

long-term care homes in Ontario. Healthc Q, 22(2), pp.55-62.