Development of Affective Assessment Tools
Development of Affective Assessment Tools
Development of Affective Assessment Tools
Development
of Affective
Assessment
Tools
Overview-
The relevance of affective targets, attitude traits and
how :hese concepts are related to student learning were
discussed in :he preceding chapter. Assessment of the affective
domain is one :>f the requirements of the 21 st teaching-
learning proposition . . .\ holistic approach is required so as to
have a meaningful evaluation of student learning. Both the
traditional and authentic assessment tools are to be utilized to
come up with a good and quality results. There are various
instruments or tools :hat can be used but each has its own
focus and each instrument :s designed to cater to a specific
purpose. In this chapter are the ·,arious methods and
assessment tools that can be used to assess affective domain
of learners. Samples are provided to help you--craft your own
affective assessment tools.
11]1.NGAG}
Cognitive and affective domains are inseparable aspects of a learner. Each completes
one another with ;espect to learners' important domains. Proper, ongoing assessment of
the affective domain--students attitudes, values, dispositions, and ethical perspectives--is
essential in any efforts to improve academic achievement and the quality of the educational
experience provided. 'unfortunately, the practice of routinely asses-sing learners' affective
constructs are oftei1 left behind and focus is given m<2st of the time to aessing learners'
cognitive aspect. In addition, unlike cognitive domain, less assessment tools are available for
the affective construct. In this chapter, development of affective assessment tools will be
discussed and at the end of the chapter, you will be equipped to craft,proper affective
assessment tools. \
·,
Assessment of Learning 2
Below are the things that should be considered if teacher observation
method will be used to assess affect
0 Determine behaviors to be observed in advance
0 Record student's important data such as time, data, and place
0 _Jf unstructured, record brief descriptions of relvant behavior
0 Keep interpretations separate from description
0 Record both positive. and negative behaviors
0 Have as much observations of each student as necessary
0 Avoid personal bias
0 Record immediately the observations
0 Apply a simple and efficient procedur°e
socially-oriented affect.
\
2.2 If the information needed is from grouped or individual responses; and
If grouped response and tendencies are needed, selecte,;l response self-report method
is suited because it assures anonymity and is easily scored.
' .
2.3 The use of information
If the intention of the affective assessment is to utilize the results as supporting
input to grading, then multiple approaches is necessary and be mh1dful of the possibility
of· having fake rE:_stilts from self-report and even from pe.r judgment.
To sum it up, the choice of method or combining these methods: is dependent upon
the context, targets and the level of comfort in utilizing any particular method or · , .
combination of methods.
social skills, writing skills, speaking skills, athletic skills or whatever outcomes are likely to be
measured and monitored. Checklists can be used.for individual or group cases. The following
table shows an example of a checklist format.
OBSERVATION CHECKLIST
. .. '.
Student: Subject: Date:
Work Habits
• Gets work done on time I'
• Takes initiative
Study Habits
• Organizes work
.• Takes good notes
-• Uses time well
Social Skills
• Works well wJth others
,__ • Listens to others
• Helps others
Comments:
I.
Assssment of Learning 2
Score
1. - I am happy during Mathemtics class.
- 2. J get tired doing board work and drills.
3. I enjoy solving word ·problems.
Assessment of Learning 2
1 2 4
-Descriptive Graphic Rating Scales (
A'·better format for rating is this descriptive graphic rating scales that
replaces ambiguous single word with short behavioral descriptions of the
various points along the scale. Describing the points of the scale by behavior
descriptions leads to increased consistency of ratings across raters and ·
students.
Example:
Directions: Make your ratings on each of the following by placing X anywhere -
along the horizontal line under each item. In the space for comment(s), im;fu, de _
ari)!thing that helps clarify your rating.
1. To what extent does the student participate in team meetings and ..., --
Never participates;. Participates as · Participates
· quiet, much as other more than any
passive team other team
members member
discussions?
of Learning 2
Error I Description
Leniency Error Occurs when a teacher tends to 'make almost all ratings
toward the high end of the scale, avoiding the
low end of the scale.
Severity Error, A teacher tends to make almost all ratings
toward the low end of the scale. This is the
opposite of leniency error.
Central Tendency Error Occurs when a teacher hesitates to use
extremes and uses only the middle part of the
scale.
Halo Effect - Occurs when a teacher -lets his/her general
impression of the-student affecf how he/she
rates
the student on specific dimension. --
Personal bias. Occurs when a teacher has a general tendency
to use inappropriate or irrelevant ·stereotypes
favoring -boys over girls, from rich families over
fro_m middle-income families, etc.
. Logical Error Occurs when a teacher gives similar ratings to
two or more dimensions that the teacher
believes to be related whre in fact they are not
related at all.
Assessment
Rater Drift Occurs when the raters, whose ratings originally
agreed, begin to redefine thf rubrics for
themselves . '
Assessment of Learning 2
Directions: Put a check on the column for each of the statement that applies to yoZL
Legend: SA - Strongly Agree
A - Agree
U - Undecided
D Disagree
SD - Strongly Disagree
EXPLOR
A.
E
Given the following situations, based on what was discussed about methods of
assessing affecting target, discuss your insights relating it to the -ppropriate methods of
affective assessment that best fit the situation. - .
1. As an input' to the planning of the school, the president would like to know the
feelings of te students toward the teiching approach that the school employs
currently, which they call as Dynamic Learning Program (DLP), in particular to its
feature, that no homework is given to stude_nts.
.'
2.
Among several sections of the eighth grade, one section is noted when it comes to
misbehving. Thrs section is composed of varied types of students, above average,
average, and.below average. The challenge is that the...academic performance of
the class is affected due to misbehaving students. How can affective assessment
methods help to- improve the situation?
B. Based on the chosen method for the two scenarios cited, continue the process of
affective assessment by selecting the appropriate assessent tools in relation to the
chosen
methods for each scenario. Discuss why you have chosen the assessment tool(s) for that
particular approach.
of Learning 2
Intended Outcome: A comparative and contrasting analysis of the key characteristics of the
different forms of Teacher Qbservaion.
A. Use the template provided to compare and contrast the assessment method basedon
the specified aspects. ',
Teacher Observation
Unstructured Structured
Preparation/
Actual size
Advantage
Disadvantage
Assessment of Learning 2
Assessment
Intended Outcome: A comparative and contrasting analysis of the key characteristics of the
different assessment methods, othei;- than te·acher observation.
B.
Use the template provided to compare and contrast the assessment method based
on the specified aspects. You are given the free.cl om to choose what method
( except for teacher observation) as well as the point of comparison and contrast. _
Assessment of Learning 2
Intended Outcome: To develop an individual observation checklist for assffective learning. ,.,,._
r
. / ·,
C. Individul Observation Checklist
Customize•the template based on your own preference on what you need to
measure or assess. Use the template below and provide for the blank portion of the
template.
OBSERVATION CHECKLIST
Student: Subject: Date:
Type of Assignment:
Not Yet Sometimes Frequently
Work Habits
•
•
Study Habits
•
•
•
•
•
•
· Comments:
Assessment of Learning 2
D. Create your qwn observation checklist to measure three affective learning outcomes..
Use the template provjded below.
ALO#2
ALO#3
RATINGS:
F - Frequently Observed
S - Sometimes Observed N
- Never Observed
..
Assessment of Learning 2
Score
ng Subject.
1 I am happy during Assessment of Learni
. ·
. 3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
)
- Assessment of Learning 2
8. Likert Scale
Using the aetails you used in the previous activity. transform the simple rating scale
that you made into a Likert Scale.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
, 9.
10.
Assessment qi Learn il).g 2
Assessment of Learning
Relevant -- -- -- --
--
Insignificant
1. .
-- -- -- -- --
-- --
2. -- -- -- -- 3. -- -- -- -- --
- - --
4. -- --
5. -- -- - --
Assessment of Learning 2
❖ Selected-response formats, such as the Likert scale, are efficient to score and
can maintain anonymity when assessing groups.